π Lecture 01 β The Challenge for Organizations
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental need for organizational change in today's rapidly evolving world, explaining why traditional management approaches are no longer sufficient. It establishes the foundation for Organization Development (OD) by examining the external forces driving change and defining what OD actually means as a discipline.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the chaotic and rapidly changing business environment, the external forces affecting organizations, the three major trends shaping organizational change (globalization, information technology, and managerial innovation), the growing relevance of Organization Development, and a detailed definition and analysis of what OD is and what it aims to achieve.
π Lecture Summary
The Challenge for Organizations
We live in a world that has been turned upside down. Companies are pouring money, technology, and management expertise into regions that were once off limits, acquiring new enterprises, forming joint ventures, and creating new global businesses from the ground up. Many major companies are going through significant changes, including outsourcing, downsizing, reengineering, self-managed work teams, flattening organizations, and doing routine jobs with automation and computers. Some experts contend that if you can describe a job precisely or write rules for doing it, the job will probably not survive.
Change is avalanching down upon our heads and most people are utterly unprepared to cope with it. Tomorrowβs world will be different from today's, calling for new organizational approaches. Organizations will need to be adapting to these changes in market conditions and at the same time coping with the need for a renewing rather than reactive workforce. Every day managers are confronting massive and accelerating change. As one writer comments, "Call it whatever you like β reengineering, restructuring, transformation, flattening, downsizing, rightsizing, a quest for global competitiveness β itβs real, itβs radical and itβs arriving every day at a company near you."
Global competition and economic downturns have exposed a glaring weakness in American organizations: the fact that many organizations have become overstaffed, cumbersome, slow and inefficient. To increase productivity, enhance competitiveness and contain costs, organizations are changing the way they are organized and managed. The successful twenty-first century manager must deal with a chaotic world of new competitors and constant innovation. In the future, the only winning companies will be the ones that respond quickly to change. Preparing managers to cope with today's accelerating role of change is the central theme and purpose of these lectures. The modern manager must not only be flexible and adaptive in a changing environment but must also be able to diagnose problems and implement change programs.
Tom Peters suggests that "the time for 10 percent staff cuts and 20 percent quality improvement is past."
Organizations are never completely static. They are in continuous interaction with external forces. Changing consumer lifestyles and technological breakthroughs all act on the organization to cause it to change. The degree of change may vary from one organization to another, but all face the need for adaptation to external forces. Many of these changes are forced upon the organization, whereas others are generated internally. Because change is occurring so rapidly, there is a need for new ways to manage it.
The Growth and Relevance of OD
Organizations must adapt to increasingly complex and uncertain technological, economic, political, and cultural changes. The rapidly changing conditions of the past few years have shown that organizations are in the midst of unprecedented uncertainty and chaos, and nothing short of a management revolution will save them. Three major trends are shaping change in organizations: globalization, information technology, and managerial innovation.
First: globalization is changing the markets and environments in which organizations operate, as well as the way they function. New governments, new leadership, new markets, and new countries are emerging and creating a new global economy. The toppling of the Berlin Wall symbolized and energized the reunification of Germany; entrepreneurs appeared in Russia, the Balkans, and Siberia as the former Soviet Union evolves into separate, market-oriented states; and China emerged as an open market, representing a powerful shift in global economic influence.
Second: information technology is redefining the traditional business model by changing how work is performed, how knowledge is used, and how the cost of doing business is calculated. The way an organization collects, stores, manipulates, uses, and transmits information can lower costs or increase the value and quality of products and services. Information technology is at the heart of emerging e-commerce strategies and organizations like Amazon.com and E-Trade. Electronic data interchange, a state-of-the-art technology application a few years ago, is now considered routine business practice. The ability to move information easily and inexpensively throughout and among organizations has fueled the downsizing, delayering, and restructuring of firms. The Internet and the World Wide Web have enabled telecommuting, where organization members can work from their homes or cars without ever going to the office. Information technology is also changing how knowledge is used; information that is widely shared reduces the concentration of power at the top of the organization.
Third: managerial innovation has responded to the globalization and information technology trends and has accelerated their impact on organizations. New organizational forms, such as networks, strategic alliances, and virtual corporations, provide organizations with new ways of thinking about how to manufacture goods and deliver services. The strategic alliance has emerged as one of the indispensable tools in strategy implementation. No single organization, not even IBM, Mitsubishi, or General Electric, can control the environmental and market uncertainty it faces. New methods of change, such as downsizing and reengineering, have radically reduced the size of organizations and increased their flexibility. New large-group interventions, such as the search conference and open space, have increased the speed with which organizational change can take place.
π‘ Why this matters: These three forces (globalization, information technology, and managerial innovation) are not only powerful individually but are interrelated. Their interaction creates a highly uncertain and chaotic environment for all kinds of organizations, making OD increasingly relevant.
Fortunately, a growing number of organizations are undertaking the kinds of organizational changes needed to survive and prosper. They are making themselves more streamlined, nimble, and more responsive to external demands. They are involving employees in key decisions and paying for performance rather than for time. Organization Development is playing an increasingly key role in helping organizations change themselves. It is helping organizations assess themselves and their environments, and revitalize and rebuild their strategies, structures, and processes. OD is helping organization members go beyond surface changes to transform the underlying assumptions and values governing their behaviors. Perhaps at no other time has OD been more responsive and practically relevant to organizations' needs to operate effectively in a highly complex and changing world.
What is Organization Development (OD)?
What makes one organization a winner, whereas another fails to make use of the same opportunities? The key to survival and success lies not in the rational, quantitative approaches, but rather in a commitment to irrational, difficult-to-measure things like people, quality, customer service, and more importantly, developing the flexibility to meet changing conditions. For example, in a study that examined the "high tech-high touch" phenomenon at Citicorp, the crucial component in adapting to technological change was the human factor. Employee involvement and commitment is the true key to successful change.
Defining Organization Development (OD)
The words "organization development" refer to something about organizations and developing them. An organization is "the planned coordination of the activities of a number of people for the achievement of some common explicit purpose or goal, through division of labor and functions, and through a hierarchy of authority and responsibility." Organizations are social systems, and OD efforts are directed toward organizations or major subparts of them.
Development is the act, process, result, or state of being developed β which in turn means to advance, to promote the growth of, to evolve the possibilities of, to further, to improve, or to enhance something. Two elements of this definition seem important: first, development may be an act, process, or end state; second, development refers to "bettering" something.
Combining these words suggests that organization development is the act, process, or result of furthering, advancing, or promoting the growth of an organization. According to this definition, organization development is anything done to "better" an organization. However, this definition is too broad and all-inclusive, as it can refer to almost anything done in an organizational context that enhances the organization β hiring a person with needed skills, firing an incompetent, merging with another organization, installing a computer, and so on.
π Definition β Organization Development (OD) (Richard Beckhard): "OD is an effort (1) planned, (2) organization-wide, and (3) managed from the top, to (4) increase organization effectiveness and health through (5) planned interventions in the organization's 'processes,' using behavioral science knowledge."
Analysis of this definition suggests that OD is not just "anything done to better an organization"; it is a particular kind of change process designed to bring about a particular kind of end result. OD thus represents a unique strategy for system change, a strategy largely based in the theory and research of the behavioral sciences, and a strategy having a substantial prescriptive character. OD is thus a normative discipline; it prescribes how planned change in organizations should be approached and carried out if organization improvement is to be obtained.
In summary, OD is a process of planned system change that attempts to make organizations (viewed as social-technical systems) better able to attain their short- and long-term objectives. This is achieved by teaching the organization members to manage their organization processes and culture more effectively. Facts, concepts, and theory from the behavioral sciences are utilized to fashion both the process and the content of the interventions. A basic belief of OD theorists and practitioners is that for effective, lasting change to take place, the system members must grow in the competence to master their own fates.
Finally, it is important to note that OD has two broad goals: organization development and individual development. Although it is not stated explicitly in the above definitions, improving the quality of life for individuals in organizations is a primary goal of organization development. Enhancing individual development is a key value of OD practitioners and a key outcome of most OD programs.
β Key Takeaways
Students must understand that modern organizations face unprecedented change driven by globalization, information technology, and managerial innovation, and the only winning companies will be those that respond quickly. OD is not just any effort to improve an organization; it is specifically a planned, organization-wide change managed from the top, using behavioral science knowledge to increase effectiveness and health through interventions in processes. The successful manager must not only be flexible and adaptive but must also be able to diagnose problems and implement change programs, with employee involvement and commitment being the true key to successful change. Finally, OD has two inseparable goals: improving organizational effectiveness and enhancing individual development, and lasting change requires system members to grow in their competence to master their own fates.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three major trends shaping change in organizations, as discussed in this lecture?
- According to Richard Beckhard's definition, what are the five key characteristics of Organization Development?
- Why is the simple definition of OD as "anything done to better an organization" considered too broad and all-inclusive?
- What does it mean that OD is a "normative discipline"?
- What are the two broad goals of Organization Development?
π Lecture 2 β OD: A Unique Change Strategy
π Overview: This lecture explores what makes Organization Development (OD) a distinct and unique approach to consulting and organizational change, differentiating it from traditional expert consulting models. It examines the core characteristics of OD, the unique role of the OD consultant, the nature of OD interventions, and how the targets and desired outcomes of OD set it apart from other improvement strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by contrasting OD with three traditional consulting models: purchase of expertise, doctor-patient, and process consultation. It then details six primary distinguishing characteristics of OD: change, collaboration, performance, humanistic values, systems thinking, and scientific approach. The lecture explains that an OD program is long-range, planned, and sustained, unfolding according to a strategy. It then explores the unique collaborative and relatively equal relationship between the OD consultant and the client system, the reflective and self-analytical nature of OD interventions, and the targets of change which include role sets, intergroup configurations, and organizational culture and processes. Finally, it outlines the distinctive desired outcomes of OD, such as enhanced self-renewing capacity.
π Lecture Summary
Consulting to organizations can take many forms
Edgar Schein describes three consulting models that are common in organizations. In the purchase of expertise model, a leader identifies a need for information and hires a consultant to make a report with recommendations, such as surveying consumers. In the doctor-patient model, a leader detects symptoms of ill health and calls in a consultant to diagnose the problem and prescribe a cure, for example, examining low morale. In the process consultation model, which is typical in OD, the consultant works collaboratively with the group to diagnose strengths and weaknesses and develop action plans, helping the organization become more effective at improving its own processes.
π Definition β Process Consultation Model: A consulting model where the consultant assists the client organization in becoming more effective at examining and improving its own processes of problem solving, decision-making, and action taking.
π Example: For problems like low morale or over-budget projects, a process consultant would use a collaborative, participative approach, helping the clients generate valid data and learn from it, rather than providing the answers themselves.
π‘ Why this matters: OD differs fundamentally from traditional "expert" models by focusing on process, not content, and by placing the responsibility for solving problems with the client.
Primary distinguishing characteristics of organization development
OD is a planned strategy to bring about organizational change, focusing on the human and social side. It involves a collaborative approach, where participation and involvement in problem solving by all levels are hallmarks. OD programs emphasize improving and enhancing performance and quality. They rely on a set of humanistic values about people and organizations, aiming to increase the use of human potential. OD represents a systems approach, concerned with the interrelationship of divisions, departments, groups, and individuals. Finally, OD is based upon scientific approaches to increase organization effectiveness.
An OD Program is a long-range, planned, and sustained effort that unfolds according to a strategy
An OD program is conceptualized in long-range terms because changing a system's culture is a difficult and complicated matter that takes time, and organizational problems are multifaceted and complex, not solvable by one-shot interventions. It is a planned and sustained effort, as opposed to a system "drift," and involves creating a subsystem within the organization, like a Department of OD, charged with planning, managing, and evaluating the continuous process of organizational self-renewal. The evidence suggests that in large organizations, two to three years of OD effort is typical before self-sustaining change occurs. Finally, OD programs unfold according to a strategy, which involves developing overall goals and paths to goals, usually based on the diagnosed problems of the client system.
π Definition β Organization Development Program: A long-range, planned, and sustained effort that unfolds according to a strategy to bring about organizational change.
π Example: An OD effort to improve inter-departmental communication might be a two-year program involving initial diagnosis, team-building workshops, and follow-up activities, rather than a single training session.
π‘ Why this matters: "Good management" practiced without an OD program is not considered OD. OD practitioners aim to inculcate good practices, but the term OD is not synonymous with good management; it refers to a specific, structured, and ongoing process.
The OD consultant establishes a unique relationship with client system members
The most fundamental difference in OD is the role of the consultant. The OD consultant seeks a collaborative relationship of relative equality with the organization members, meaning consultant and client "co-labor." The relationship is one of relative equality, with each party possessing different but needed knowledge and skills. The consultant's role is generally that of a facilitator, not a content expert, acting primarily as a question-asker. This nondirective posture rests on three beliefs: (1) division of labor (consultant focuses on process, client on content), (2) the best solution is in the heads of client members, and (3) the responsibility for change rests ultimately with the client system, who must "own" the problem and solution.
π Definition β Collaborative Relationship (in OD): A relationship where the consultant and client system co-labor, with the consultant acting as a facilitator and the client owning the problem and solution.
π Example: Instead of a consultant prescribing a new reward system, an OD consultant would facilitate a series of meetings where employees and managers identify issues with the current system and collaboratively design a new one.
The nature of the intervention differentiates OD from other improvement strategies
OD consultants create interventions, which are structured sets of activities designed to achieve certain outcomes. These interventions are reflective, self-analytical, and action-oriented, focusing on the organization's culture and human processes. The overriding goal of an OD intervention is to teach the client system members to diagnose and solve problems by themselves, a concept known as "learning how to learn." The emphasis is on system improvement, rather than just individual change, targeting the organization's ability to cope and its relationships with subsystems and the environment.
π Definition β OD Interventions: Structured sets of activities and events in the life of the organization designed to achieve certain outcomes, focusing on making the client system self-analytical and proficient in solving its own problems.
π Example: An intervention might involve collecting survey data about communication breakdowns, then having the relevant team members analyze the data, discuss the causes, and develop their own action plan for improvement.
π‘ Why this matters: The rationale is captured by the proverb: "Give a man a fish, and you have given him a meal; teach a man to fish, and you have given him a livelihood." OD teaches the organization to "fish."
The targets of OD interventions differentiate OD from other improvement strategies
OD interventions target specific configurations of people. The first target is intact work groups and role sets, as immediate work groups and supervisors have immense power to determine individual behavior and are the source of many organizational problems. The second target is intergroup configurations, focusing on enhancing key interdependences across units and levels by addressing issues like dysfunctional competition. The third target is the organizationβs processes and culture, which are seen as important strategic leverage points for bringing about organizational improvement and change.
OD consultants utilize a behavioral science base
OD is an applied field that draws on theories, concepts, and practices from sociology, psychology, social psychology, education, economics, psychiatry, and management. This behavioral science knowledge base is brought to bear on real organizational problems and is a contributing factor to OD's distinctive approach.
The desired outcomes of OD are distinctive in nature
While OD shares the common goal of improving organizational effectiveness, it has additional distinctive outcomes. These include a changed organizational culture, changed processes (especially renewal and adaptation), and the establishment of norms for continual self-study and pro-action. Michael Beer lists the aims of OD as: (1) enhancing congruence between structure, processes, strategy, people, and culture; (2) developing new and creative organizational solutions; and (3) developing the organizationβs self-renewing capacity. It is this focus on self-renewal that is particularly unique to OD.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that OD is fundamentally a collaborative, process-oriented approach to change, distinct from the expert-driven "purchase of expertise" and "doctor-patient" models. The core of OD lies in its long-range, planned, and sustained nature, aimed at making the client system self-sufficient in diagnosing and solving its own problems. The OD consultant acts as a facilitator, not a prescriber, focusing on the organization's culture, processes, and human systems. The primary targets for change are intact work groups, intergroup relationships, and the overall culture, rather than just individuals. The ultimate desired outcome is not just a one-time fix, but the development of the organization's ongoing capacity for self-renewal and adaptation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are Edgar Schein's three consulting models, and which one is typical of Organization Development?
- List and briefly explain the six primary distinguishing characteristics of Organization Development.
- Why is an OD program considered "long-range," and what does "planned and sustained effort" mean in this context?
- Describe the role of the OD consultant in terms of collaboration, expertise, and the reason for a "nondirective" posture.
- What are the three main "targets" of OD interventions, and why are these targets chosen over a focus on individuals?
π Lecture 3 β What an βidealβ effective, healthy organization would look like?
π Overview: This lecture defines the characteristics of an ideal, effective, and healthy organization based on consensus among practitioners. It then explores the critical importance of adapting to constant change in the modern environment and outlines the organizational traits required for future success, illustrated by the case of Trilogy Software.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by listing ten specific characteristics of an effective, healthy organization, covering goal management, structure, decision-making, rewards, communication, conflict, and system thinking. It then discusses why change is the only constant in today's environment, using 3M's 15 percent rule as an example. Finally, it describes the organization of the future, emphasizing flexibility, speed, and innovation, and presents the Trilogy Software case study as a practical example of a new kind of company.
π Lecture Summary
What an βidealβ effective, healthy organization would look like?
An effective organization is defined by ten key characteristics. First, the total organization, its subparts, and individuals manage work against goals and plans. Second, form follows function, meaning the task determines how human resources are organized. Third, decisions are made by and near the sources of information, regardless of their location on the organization chart. Fourth, the reward system punishes and rewards managers comparably for short-term profit, subordinate development, and creating a viable working group. Fifth, communication is open and confronting, sharing all relevant facts, including feelings, with minimal distortion.
The remaining characteristics include: a minimum of win/lose activities, with conflict treated as a problem-solving opportunity; high conflict about ideas but low interpersonal conflict; the organization functioning as an open system interacting with a larger environment; a shared value of helping each person maintain integrity and uniqueness; and operating in an action-research way with built-in feedback mechanisms for learning from experience.
π Definition β Effective Organization: An organization where total organization, subparts, and individuals manage work against goals; form follows function; decisions are made near information sources; and communication is open and undistorted. π‘ Why this matters: These 10 characteristics provide a comprehensive benchmark for diagnosing organizational health and identifying areas for improvement through OD interventions.
The only constant is Change
While many firms adapt to information technology, few adapt to changing social and cultural conditions. Change is unavoidable in a dynamic environment, and its pace makes it a moving target. For survival, organizations must effectively respond to technological, social, and economic changes. In the twenty-first century, productivity increases of 100% will be needed to compete. Past failures to address the changing environment create problems for many executives. In contrast, 3M Corporation excels at innovation through its 15 percent rule, allowing employees to spend 15% of their work week on product-related ideas, which led to the Post-it note.
π Definition β 15 percent rule: 3M's policy allowing employees to spend up to 15% of their work week on any product-related activity, fostering innovation.
The Organization of the Future
The nature of managerial success is changing fundamentally. Past advantages like economies of scale and large advertising budgets are no longer effective. The traditional managerial approach cannot lead to economic leadership. Managers need a new mindset valuing flexibility, speed, innovation, and challenge. Virtual organizations can form overnight as networks of free agents. Successful future organizations will share common traits: being faster and more responsive to innovation; quality conscious with total commitment; having employee involvement that adds value; being customer oriented to create niche markets; and being smaller, made up of more autonomous units.
π Formula: Future Organization Success = Flexibility + Speed + Innovation + Quality + Employee Involvement + Customer Orientation + Smaller Autonomous Units
OD in Practice: Trilogy Software β A New Kind of Company
Joe Liemandt founded Trilogy Software Inc. in Austin, Texas in 1989. It grew from 400 to 1000 employees in four years and is now one of the world's largest privately held software companies. All employees are shareholders, managers, and partners. The founder's biggest worry is holding onto talented people in competition with Microsoft. The CEO personally teaches much of the employee development program. Unusual practices include perks like a company speedboat, stocked kitchens, weekly parties, spontaneous awards (sports cars, Las Vegas trips), all-expense-paid company trips to Hawaii, and bonuses equal to 50-100% of salary. These new organizations offer the advantages of free agency (flexibility, compensation linked to contribution) while also providing the continuity of mutual commitment.
π Definition β Trilogy Model: A new kind of company where all employees are shareholders, managers, and partners; extraordinary perks and bonuses are used to retain talent; and the CEO personally leads employee development.
β Key Takeaways
A healthy organization must have goals, structure that follows function, decentralized decision-making, balanced rewards, open communication, problem-solving approaches to conflict, and operate as an open system. Change is the only constant, requiring organizations to adapt continuously to technological, social, and economic shifts for survival. Future successful organizations will prioritize flexibility, speed, quality, employee involvement, customer orientation, and smaller autonomous units. The Trilogy Software case demonstrates a radical new model where employees are owners, extraordinary perks retain talent, and CEO involvement in development creates strong commitment. The 10 characteristics of an effective organization serve as a diagnostic framework for OD practitioners to assess and improve organizational health.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the ten characteristics of an effective, healthy organization according to the lecture?
- Why is "form follows function" important in an effective organization, and how does it relate to decision-making?
- Explain how 3M's 15 percent rule exemplifies the principle that "the only constant is change."
- What five common traits will successful organizations of the future share?
- How does Trilogy Software's model differ from traditional organizations in terms of employee roles, rewards, and retention strategies?
π Lecture 4 β The Evolution of OD
π Overview: This lecture traces the historical development of Organization Development, explaining its emergence from five major stems. Understanding this evolution is crucial because it reveals the intellectual foundations and practical methods that continue to shape how organizations manage change today.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the five major stems that led to the evolution of OD, beginning with Laboratory Training (T-Groups) and Kurt Lewin's pioneering work at NTL. It then examines Action Research and Survey Feedback, including the classic studies by Coch and French, and Likert's development of the Likert Scale. The lecture concludes with the three remaining stems: participative management, quality of work life, and strategic change, though these are outlined briefly.
π Lecture Summary
The Evolution of OD
A brief history of OD helps clarify the evolution of the term and surrounding confusion. As currently practiced, OD emerged from five major stems. The first was the growth of the National Training Laboratories (NTL) and the development of training groups (sensitivity training or T-groups). The second stem was classic work on action research by social scientists, featuring a technique known as survey feedback. Kurt Lewin was instrumental in developing T-groups, survey feedback, and action research. The third stem represents participative management applied to organization structure. The fourth stem focuses on productivity and quality of work life. The fifth and most recent stem involves strategic change and organization transformation.
π‘ Why this matters: Recognizing these five stems helps students see OD not as a single invention but as a convergence of different fieldsβsocial psychology, group dynamics, industrial relations, and strategic management.
1. Laboratory Training (The T-Group)
This stem pioneered laboratory training, or the T-groupβa small, unstructured group where participants learn from their own interactions about interpersonal relations, personal growth, leadership, and group dynamics. Laboratory training began in 1946 when Kurt Lewin (1898β1947) and his staff at MIT's Research Centre for Group Dynamics were asked by the Connecticut Interracial Commission to train community leaders. A workshop was developed, and community leaders met to discuss problems. Researchers privately discussed observed behaviors; the leaders requested to sit in on these feedback sessions. Thus, the first T-group was formed where people reacted to data about their own behavior. Two conclusions emerged: feedback about group interaction was a rich learning experience, and "group building" had transferable learning potential.
The Office of Naval Research and the National Education Association backed the formation of NTL at Gould Academy in Bethel, Maine. The first Basic Skill Training Groups (later T-groups) were offered in 1947. In the 1950s, three trends emerged: regional laboratories, year-round T-group sessions, and T-group expansion into business and industry.
As trainers worked with more permanent and complex social systems, they faced frustration in transferring behavioral skills from T-groups to organizations. However, training "teams" from the same organization emerged, linking to the organizational focus of Douglas McGregor, Herbert Shepard, and Robert Blake, and later Richard Beckhard, Chris Argyris, Jack Gibb, and Warren Bennis. Applying T-group techniques to organizations became known as team buildingβa process for helping work groups become more effective in tasks and member needs.
π Definition β T-group: A small, unstructured group where participants learn from their own interactions and evolving dynamics about interpersonal relations, personal growth, leadership, and group dynamics. π Example: In 1946, community leaders sat in on researcher feedback sessions about their own behavior, forming the first T-group.
π Definition β Team building: A process for helping work groups become more effective in accomplishing tasks and satisfying member needs, derived from applying T-group techniques to organizations.
2. Action Research/Survey Feedback
Kurt Lewin was also involved in the second movementβaction research and survey feedback. The action research contribution began in the 1940s with studies by John Collier, Kurt Lewin, and William Whyte. They discovered research needed to be closely linked to action for managing change. A collaborative effort between organization members and social scientists was initiated to collect data, analyze problems, devise solutions, implement them, then collect further dataβcreating a continuous cycle. Results were twofold: members used research on themselves to guide change, and social scientists derived new knowledge for other settings.
Pioneering studies included Lewin's work at Harwood Manufacturing Company and the classic research by Lester Coch and John French on overcoming resistance to change, which led to participative management. Other notable studies included Whyte and Edith Hamilton's study of Chicago's Tremont Hotel and Collier's work on race relations. Today, action research is the backbone of most OD applications.
A key component was systematic collection of survey data fed back to the client organization. After Lewin's death in 1947, his Research Center moved to Michigan, joining the Survey Research Center as part of the Institute for Social Research, headed by Rensis Likert. Likert's doctoral dissertation developed the widely used five-point "Likert Scale."
In an early study at Detroit Edison (beginning 1948), Likert and Floyd Mann administered a company-wide survey of management and employee attitudes. Three data sets were developed: (1) viewpoints of 8,000 non-supervisory employees about supervisors, promotion, and satisfaction; (2) similar reactions from first- and second-line supervisors; (3) higher management information. The feedback process evolved into an "interlocking chain of conferences." Findings were reported to top management and transmitted downward through task groups. In 1950, eight accounting departments requested a repeat survey; feedback approaches varied across departments. A third follow-up indicated more significant positive changes in departments receiving feedback than those without it.
π Definition β Action research: A collaborative effort between organization members and social scientists to collect research data, analyze it for causes of problems, devise and implement solutions, and then collect further data to assess results in a continuous cycle. π Formula: Data Collection β Data Feedback β Action Planning β Implementation β Follow-up Data Collection β (repeat cycle) π Example: At Detroit Edison, a company-wide survey was administered; findings were reported to top management and transmitted downward through interlocking conferences; follow-up studies showed departments practicing feedback had more positive changes.
π Definition β Likert Scale: A widely used scale in survey research where respondents specify their level of agreement to a statement, traditionally using a five-point scale (Strongly Disagree, Disagree, Neither agree nor disagree, Agree, Strongly Agree).
Results of Action Research/Survey Feedback
Likert and colleagues found that when managers failed to discuss survey results with subordinates and plan improvements, little change occurred. Conversely, when managers discussed results with subordinates and planned together, substantial favorable changes occurred. Another finding: feeding back data from attitude surveys to participating departments produced more positive change than traditional training courses. The effectiveness lies in dealing with the system of human relationships as a whole (supervisors and subordinates change together) and treating each person in the context of their own job and work relationships.
(Remaining Stems β Briefly Mentioned)
The lecture briefly notes the third stem (participative management and organization structure/design), fourth stem (productivity and quality of work life), and fifth stem (strategic change and organization transformation), but does not elaborate on these in detail.
β Key Takeaways
OD evolved from five distinct stems: Laboratory Training (T-groups), Action Research/Survey Feedback, Participative Management, Quality of Work Life, and Strategic Change. Kurt Lewin is the founding father of OD, instrumental in T-groups, action research, and survey feedback. The T-group was the first method to use real-time feedback about participants' own behavior to drive learning, but transferring these skills to complex organizations proved difficult, leading to team building. Action research created a collaborative cycle of data collection, feedback, action planning, and follow-upβnow the backbone of most OD. Survey feedback using the Likert Scale demonstrated that actively discussing results with subordinates produces far more positive change than simply reporting data or relying on traditional training.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What were the five major stems from which OD emerged?
- How did the first T-group form in 1946, and what two conclusions did researchers draw from it?
- What is the difference between a T-group and team building?
- Describe the cycle of action research as taught in this lecture.
- What key finding did Likert and Mann derive from the Detroit Edison study about the importance of discussing survey results with subordinates?