π Lecture 45 β Seven Practices of Successful Organizations
π Overview: This lecture explores the seven key practices that characterize successful organizations, providing a comprehensive framework for building high-performance management systems. Understanding these practices is essential for organization development professionals because they represent proven approaches that create competitive advantage through people. The lecture emphasizes that these practices work as an integrated system rather than isolated initiatives.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers seven essential practices of successful organizations: employment security, selective hiring, self-managed teams and decentralization, high compensation contingent on performance, extensive training, reduction of status differences, and sharing information. Each practice is examined through real-world examples from companies like Southwest Airlines, Lincoln Electric, Whole Foods Markets, and AES Corporation, with detailed explanations of how these practices create organizational effectiveness.
π Lecture Summary
1. Employment Security
Employment security is a critical element of high-performance management systems, as innovations in work practices are unlikely to be sustained when workers fear job loss. This principle has been demonstrated by Lincoln Electric, which has offered guaranteed employment to workers after three years on the job and has not had a layoff since 1948. During a recession in the early 1980s when domestic sales fell 40 percent, the company redeployed factory workers to sell products in the field rather than resorting to layoffs.
π Definition β Employment security: A policy ensuring that employees are not laid off due to economic downturns or strategic mistakes of senior management, while still allowing termination for poor performance or lack of cultural fit.
π‘ Why this matters: Employment security creates multiple organizational benefits. It prevents firms from laying off trained workers too quickly during downturns, which would put strategic assets into competitors' hands. It leads to leaner, more careful hiring. It builds trust between people and their employer, encouraging cooperation and better spirit. The Vice President for People at Southwest Airlines explained, "Why would we want to put our best assets, our people, in the arms of the competition?"
However, employment security does not mean retaining poor performers. Lincoln Electric has high turnover in the first few months for those who don't fit the culture. The policy focuses on maintaining total employment, not protecting individuals from consequences of their individual behavior.
Employment security is fundamental to implementing other high-performance practices like selective hiring, extensive training, information sharing, and delegation, as companies will not invest in these if people are not expected to stay long enough to recoup investments.
2. Selective Hiring
Successful organizations ensure they recruit the right people through several key approaches:
First, the organization needs a large applicant pool. In 1993, Southwest Airlines received about 98,000 applications, interviewed 16,000, and hired only 2,700. Singapore Airlines is extremely selective: from an initial pool, about 10% are shortlisted and only 2% (one out of 50) are selected for flight attendant positions.
Second, the organization must be clear about the most critical skills and attributes needed. Southwest evaluates flight attendant applicants on initiative, judgment, adaptability, and ability to learn using behavioral interview questions like "Give an example of working with a difficult coworker."
Third, skills hired should be consistent with job requirements and market approach. Enterprise Rent-A-Car, now the largest car rental company in the US, hires college graduates primarily for sales skills and personality rather than academic performance.
Fourth, organizations should screen primarily on attributes difficult to change through training. Japanese organizations have long practiced hiring based on "proper character" and social background rather than specific technical skills. Southwest rejected a top pilot who was rude to a receptionist because technical skills are easier to acquire than teamwork and service attitude.
Evidence shows cultural fit and value congruence between applicants and organizations significantly predicts subsequent turnover and job performance. Rigorous selection processes, sometimes taking six months, ensure careful scrutiny, develop commitment, and create a feeling among selected individuals that they are part of an elite group.
π Definition β Selective hiring: A recruiting approach emphasizing a large applicant pool, clear identification of critical attributes, screening for qualities difficult to change through training, and rigorous multi-stage selection processes.
3. Self-Managed Teams and Decentralization as Basic Elements of Organizational Design
Organizing people into self-managed teams is a critical component of virtually all high-performance management systems, giving workers greater autonomy and discretion.
Teams offer several advantages: First, teams substitute peer-based for hierarchical control of work. Peer control is frequently more effective than hierarchical supervision because individuals are less likely to let down their teammates. Team-based organizations succeed in making all people feel accountable for the enterprise's success.
Whole Foods Market operates with a team-oriented philosophy: each store has about ten self-managed teams with team leaders and clear performance targets. Teams must approve new full-time hires by two-thirds vote after a thirty-day trial period.
Second, teams permit employees to pool ideas for more creative solutions to problems, similar to brainstorming where each participant builds on others' ideas.
Third, by substituting peer for hierarchical control, teams permit removal of layers of hierarchy, avoiding enormous costs of management overhead. AES Corporation, a global power plant developer, has never formed corporate departments for finance, operations, or human resources. Front-line people develop expertise in these areas and receive responsibility for carrying them out. The company developed a $400 million plant with a team of just ten people.
4. High Compensation Contingent on Organizational Performance
The level of salaries sends a message about whether employees are truly valued. When John Whitney assumed leadership of Pathmark grocery chain with 90 days to live, he found 120 store managers were paid terribly. He gave them a substantial raise of 40-50%, enabling them to focus on improving performance instead of worrying about pay.
Contingent compensation can take various forms including gainsharing, stock ownership, pay for skill, and team incentives. When employees are owners, they act and think like owners. Paying for skill acquisition encourages people to learn different jobs and become more flexible.
Gainsharing differs from profit sharing as it is based on incremental improvements in a specific unit's performance, even if overall firm profits are down. At Whole Foods, gainsharing ties bonuses directly to team performance measured by sales per hour.
π‘ Why this matters: Coupling employment security with group-based incentives like profit sharing or gainsharing prevents civil service mentality by aligning team economic interests with higher performance levels.
5. Training
Training is an essential component of high-performance work systems because these systems rely on front-line employee skill and initiative. The amount of training reflects different views of people held by firms. Japanese companies train extensively because they rely on flexible production and intend to keep people longer, making investment in development worthwhile.
Training can be a source of competitive advantage. Taco Inc., a pump and valve manufacturer, offers over six dozen courses in an on-site learning center costing $250,000 to build with annual expenses of $300,000. When asked about monetary return, the CEO said, "It comes back in the form of attitude."
6. Reduction of Status Differences
High-performance systems require tapping ideas from all people, which requires reducing status distinctions. This is accomplished symbolically through language, physical space, and dress, and substantively through reducing wage inequality across levels.
At Subaru-Isuzu, everyone from the president down was called an Associate. At Kingston Technology, the two co-founders sit in open cubicles with no private secretaries. The CEO of Southwest Airlines, who earned about $500,000 per year, agreed to fix his salary at $395,000 for four years when the company negotiated a wage freeze with pilots.
Reducing status differences encourages open communication and develops a sense of common fate. Contingent rewards applied at group or organizational level are at least as effective as individual incentives and avoid many problems inherent in individual merit pay.
7. Sharing Information
Information sharing is essential for two reasons: First, sharing financial, strategic, and operational information conveys trust. The CEO of Whole Foods Markets stated, "If you are trying to create a high trust organization... you can't have secrets."
Second, even motivated and trained people cannot contribute without information on performance dimensions and training on how to interpret that information.
The concept of open book management emerged from a CEO who purchased a harvester plant with $100,000 and $8.9 million debt. The philosophy states: "Don't use information to control or manipulate people. Use it to teach people how to work together to achieve common goals." Implementation involved: generating daily numbers reflecting work performance and production costs, sharing this information with all employees, and providing extensive training on understanding balance sheets, cash flow, and income statements.
β Key Takeaways
The seven practices of successful organizations form an integrated system where employment security provides the foundation for other practices. Selective hiring ensures the right people enter the organization with attitudes and values that are difficult to train. Self-managed teams and decentralization substitute peer control for hierarchical supervision, creating accountability and reducing overhead. High compensation contingent on organizational performance, through gainsharing or stock ownership, aligns employee interests with organizational success. Extensive training develops the skills needed for front-line initiative and problem-solving. Reducing status differences through symbolic and substantive means encourages open communication and a sense of common fate. Finally, sharing information transparently through open book management builds trust and enables trained employees to make informed decisions that enhance performance. These practices work together β implementing one without the others diminishes overall effectiveness.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the seven practices of successful organizations, and how does employment security serve as the foundation for implementing the other practices?
-
How did Lincoln Electric avoid layoffs during the 1980s recession when domestic sales fell 40 percent, and what benefits resulted from this policy?
-
What four key approaches do successful organizations use for selective hiring, and why does Southwest Airlines reject applicants with excellent technical skills but poor attitudes?
-
What three advantages do self-managed teams offer over traditional hierarchical structures, and how does Whole Foods Market implement team-based decision-making?
-
What is the difference between gainsharing and profit sharing, and why does open book management require both information transparency and financial training for all employees?