π Lecture 44 β Project Risk Management
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of project risk management, including definitions, components, and the systematic process for dealing with uncertainty in projects. It emphasizes the importance of proactive risk management to anticipate and mitigate potential issues before they adversely impact project goals.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers what risk is and its primary components, including probability and impact, as well as tolerance of risk profiles. It then explores risk management processes, categories of risk, risk planning, risk identification, risk assessment, and risk handling methods. The discussion also includes decision-making under certainty, risk, and uncertainty, along with the risk management process cycle.
π Lecture Summary
44.1 What are the Risks?
Risk is a measure of the probability and consequence of not achieving a defined project goal. It involves the notion of uncertainty; for example, "Can the computer be produced within budgeted cost?" A probability measure can be used, such as a 0.15 probability of not meeting a launch date. However, the consequences or damage associated with occurrence must also be considered. A goal with a probability of occurrence of only 0.05 may present a much more serious risky situation than a goal with a probability of 0.20, if the consequences of not meeting the first goal are more than four times more severe. Risk is not always easy to assess since probability and consequence are usually not directly measurable and must be estimated by statistical or other procedures. π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that risk is a combination of both probability and impact allows project managers to prioritize risks that have low probability but catastrophic consequences over high-probability, low-impact risks.
π Definition β Risk: A measure of the probability and consequence of not achieving a defined project goal.
44.2 Components of Risk
Risk has two primary components for a given event:
- Probability of occurrence of that event
- Impact of the event occurring (amount at stake)
Conceptually, risk for each event can be defined as a function of likelihood and impact: Risk = f(likelihood, impact). As either the likelihood or impact increases, so does the risk.
Another element is the cause of risk β the hazard. Risk can also be represented as: Risk = f(hazard, safeguard). Risk increases with hazard but decreases with safeguard. The implication is that good project management should be structured to identify hazards and allow the development of safeguards to overcome them.
44.3 Tolerance of Risk
The three commonly used classifications of tolerance for risk are: the risk averter (or avoider), the neutral risk taker, and the risk seeker (or lover). Utility is the amount of satisfaction or pleasure an individual receives from a payoff.
With the risk averter, utility rises at a decreasing rate, meaning when more money is at stake, satisfaction or tolerance diminishes. A risk averter prefers a more certain outcome and will demand a premium to accept risk.
With the risk lover, satisfaction increases when more money is at stake (increasing slope). A risk lover prefers the more uncertain outcome and may be willing to pay a penalty to take a risk.
π Example: A risk averter would prefer a guaranteed $50,000 profit over a 50% chance of earning $100,000. A risk lover would choose the 50% chance.
44.4 Risk Management
Risk management is the act or practice of dealing with risk. It includes planning for risk, assessing (identifying and analyzing) risk issues, developing risk handling options, and monitoring risks to determine how they have changed. Proper risk management is proactive rather than reactive.
π Example: An activity in a network requires new technology development. The schedule indicates six months, but engineers think nine months. A proactive manager develops a Risk Handling Plan now. A reactive manager does nothing until the problem occurs, losing valuable time.
44.5 Categories of Risk
The Project Management Institute categorizes risks as follows:
- Externalβunpredictable: Government regulations, natural hazards, acts of God (outside PM's control)
- Externalβpredictable: Cost of money, borrowing rates, raw material availability (outside PM's control)
- Internal (nontechnical): Labor stoppages, cash flow problems, safety issues (may be within PM's control)
- Technical: Changes in technology, design issues, operations/maintenance issues (relates to utilization of technology)
- Legal: Licenses, patent rights, lawsuits, subcontractor performance, contractual failure
Decision-making falls into three categories:
- Decision-Making under Certainty: All necessary information is available, and outcomes can be predicted with high confidence. A payoff matrix will have one dominant strategy with no probabilities assigned.
- Decision-Making under Risk: No single dominant strategy exists; probabilities must be assigned to each state of nature. Outcomes can be described within established confidence limits from well-defined experimental distributions.
- Decision-Making under Uncertainty: Meaningful assignments of probabilities are not possible. The decision-maker has four basic criteria from which to make a management decision, depending on the project type and the PM's risk tolerance.
The Risk Management Process includes several related actions:
- Risk planning: Developing and documenting an organized, comprehensive strategy for identifying and tracking risk issues, developing handling plans, and assigning adequate resources.
- Risk assessment: Identifying and analyzing program areas and critical technical process risks to increase the likelihood of meeting cost, performance, and schedule objectives. Risk identification examines program areas to identify documented risk; risk analysis examines each identified issue to refine the description, isolate the cause, and determine effects.
- Risk handling: Identifies, evaluates, selects, and implements options to set risk at acceptable levels. Options include assumption, avoidance, control (mitigation), and transfer.
- Risk monitoring: Systematically tracks and evaluates the performance of risk handling actions against established metrics and provides inputs for updating strategies.
π Definition β Risk management: The act or practice of dealing with risk, including planning, assessment, handling, and monitoring.
44.6 Risk Planning
Risk planning is the detailed formulation of a program of action for the management of risk. It is the process to:
- Develop and document an organized, comprehensive, and interactive risk management strategy
- Determine methods to execute the program's risk management strategy
- Plan for adequate resources
The result is often the Risk Management Plan (RMP). The RMP is the roadmap that tells the project team how to get from where the program is today to where the program manager wants it to be. The key to writing a good RMP is to provide necessary information so the program team knows the objectives, goals, and risk management process.
44.7 Risk Assessment
Risk assessment is the problem definition stage of risk management that identifies, analyzes, and quantifies program issues in terms of probability and consequences. The componentsβidentification and analysisβare performed sequentially with identification being the first step.
Risk identification begins by compiling the program's risk issues. Risk analysis is a technical and systematic process to examine identified risks, isolate causes, determine relationships to other risks, and express the impact in terms of probability and consequence.
44.8 Risk Identification
The second step in risk management is to identify all potential risk issues. Methods for identifying risk are numerous. Most sources are either objective or subjective.
- Objective sources: Recorded experience (lessons learned files, program documentation evaluations, current performance data)
- Subjective sources: Experiences based upon knowledgeable experts (interviews, subject matter experts)
Expert judgment techniques include:
- Delphi method: A panel of experts is selected without face-to-face interaction. Each expert makes anonymous predictions, receives composite feedback, and then makes new predictions. The process repeats as necessary.
- Nominal group technique: Allows face-to-face contact. A panel generates ideas in writing, lists them, discusses each, and then prioritizes them mathematically.
Risks can also be classified as:
- Business risk: Provides opportunities of profit and loss (competitor activities, inflation, customer response)
- Insurable risk: Provides only a chance for loss (direct property damage, indirect consequential loss, legal liability, personnel)
44.9 Risk Handling
Risk handling includes specific methods and techniques to deal with known risks, identifies who is responsible, and provides cost and schedule estimates for reducing the risk. Options fall into four categories:
- Risk assumption (retention): "I know the risk exists and am aware of the possible consequences. I accept the risk and its impact should it occur."
- Risk avoidance: "I will not accept this option because of potentially unfavorable results."
- Risk control (mitigation): "I will take necessary measures to control this risk by continuously reevaluating it and developing contingency plans."
- Risk transfer: "I will share this risk with others through insurance or warranty, or transfer the entire risk to them."
β Key Takeaways
Risk is a function of both the probability of an event occurring and its impact, and it decreases as safeguards are implemented against identified hazards. Project managers have different tolerances for risk (averse, neutral, or seeking), which influences their decision-making. The risk management process is a continuous, proactive cycle of planning, assessment, identification, analysis, handling, and monitoring, not a reactive problem-solving activity. Risks can be categorized by source (external, internal, technical, legal) and by decision-making environment (certainty, risk, or uncertainty), which determines the analytical approach. Expert judgment techniques like the Delphi method and nominal group technique are valuable but require awareness of potential biases.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two primary components of risk for a given event, and how do they relate conceptually to the overall risk?
- What are the three classifications of tolerance for risk, and how does utility change with money at stake for a risk averter versus a risk lover?
- What are the four main options for handling risk, and what does each option represent from the project manager's perspective?
- What is the difference between decision-making under risk and decision-making under uncertainty?
- What are the key differences between the Delphi method and the nominal group technique for expert judgment in risk identification?
π Lecture 45 β Project Procurement, Contract Management, and Ethics in Project Management
π Overview: This lecture explores the strategic and operational aspects of project procurement, including procurement cycles, contract types, and contract administration. It also addresses the critical role of ethics in project management, providing a framework for ethical decision-making and professional conduct. Understanding these concepts is essential for managing project resources, mitigating risks, and ensuring project success.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture is organized into four main sections: Procurement, which defines procurement and outlines its strategies and environments; Procurement Cycles, which details the requirement, requisition, solicitation, and award cycles; Types of Contracts, which explains various contract types like Fixed-Price, Cost-Plus, and Incentive contracts; and Ethics in Project Management, which discusses ethical origins, a code of ethics for project managers, and ways to improve ethical performance.
π Lecture Summary
45.1. Procurement
Procurement is defined as the acquisition of goods or services. It is a process involving two parties with different objectives interacting in a given market segment. Good procurement practices increase corporate profitability by leveraging quantity discounts, minimizing cash flow problems, and seeking quality suppliers. Procurement is often centralized to standardize practices and lower paperwork costs.
There are two basic procurement strategies: a corporate procurement strategy, which relates specific procurement actions to the corporate strategy, and a project procurement strategy, which relates actions to the project's operating environment. Project strategies can differ from corporate strategies due to constraints, resource availability, or customer requirements. For example, corporate strategies might favor multiple vendors, while project strategies may dictate sole-source procurement.
Procurement planning involves selecting one of four primary objectives: procure all goods/services from a single source, procure from multiple sources, procure only a small portion, or procure none.
A critical factor is the procurement environment. The macro environment includes general external variables like recessions, inflation, and unemployment that influence how and when procurement occurs. For example, a foreign corporation in a country with high unemployment might use only domestic suppliers.
The microenvironment is the internal environment of the firm, including policies and procedures that govern procurement. This environment involves a procurement/contracting system with five cycles:
- Requirement cycle: definition of the project's boundaries.
- Requisition cycle: analysis of sources.
- Solicitation cycle: the bidding process.
- Award cycle: contractor selection and contract award.
- Contract administration cycle: managing the subcontractor until completion.
These cycles can be conducted in parallel, especially requisition and solicitation.
45.2. Procurement Cycles
The first step, the requirement cycle, includes defining the project need, developing the Statement of Work (SOW), specifications, and Work Breakdown Structure (WBS), performing a make or buy analysis, laying out milestones and schedule, cost estimating including life-cycle costing, and obtaining authorization to proceed.
The SOW is a narrative description of the work to be accomplished and/or the resources to be supplied. To prevent companies from subcontracting almost all work, SOWs now often require identification of the talented internal resources committed to the project.
Specifications are written, pictorial, or graphic information that describe, define, or specify the services or items to be procured. There are three types:
- Design specifications: Detail what is to be done in terms of physical characteristics. The risk of performance is on the buyer.
- Performance specifications: Specify measurable capabilities the end product must achieve. The risk of performance is on the contractor.
- Functional specifications: The seller describes the end use of the item to stimulate competition among commercial items at a lower cost. This is a subset of performance specifications, and the risk is on the contractor.
Feasible procurement alternatives include make or buy, lease or buy, buy or rent, and lease or rent.
π Definition β Make or buy analysis: A decision-making process that compares the costs and benefits of producing an item internally versus purchasing it from an external supplier.
Factors for a make decision include: less costly (but not always), easy integration of operations, utilize idle capacity, maintain direct control, maintain design/production secrecy, avoid unreliable suppliers, and stabilize the workforce. Factors for a buy decision include: less costly (but not always), utilize skills of suppliers, small volume requirements, limited capacity or capability, augment the labor force, maintain multiple sources, and indirect control.
π Formula: Breakeven Point for Lease vs. Rent β The point in time where the total cost of leasing equals the total cost of renting.
Lease Cost = Fixed Cost + (Variable Cost per Day * Days)
Rent Cost = Variable Cost per Day * Days
Breakeven Point = Fixed Cost / (Rent Cost per Day - Lease Variable Cost per Day)
π Example: A company can rent equipment for $100 per day or lease it for $60 per day plus a one-time cost of $5000. The breakeven point in days is: $5000 / ($100 - $60) = $5000 / $40 = 125 days. If the firm needs the equipment for more than 125 days, leasing is more cost-effective.
Requisition Cycle: Once requirements are identified, a requisition form is sent to procurement. This cycle includes evaluating/confirming specifications, confirming sources, reviewing past performance of sources, and producing a solicitation package.
The solicitation package is prepared in the requisition cycle but used in the solicitation cycle. It should be identical for all suppliers to ensure a level playing field. A typical package includes: bid documents, a listing of qualified vendors, proposal evaluation criteria, bidder conferences, and change request management.
Solicitation Cycle: The critical element is selecting the acquisition method. The three common methods are:
- Advertising: Sealed bids are used with no negotiations; the award goes to the lowest bidder.
- Negotiation: Price is determined through bargaining. This can involve a Request for Information (RFI), Request for Quotation (RFQ), or Request for Proposal (RFP). The RFP is the most costly for the vendor. The process can be competitive or noncompetitive (sole-source procurement).
- Small purchases: For items like office supplies.
The three major factors of negotiations are: compromise ability, adaptability, and good faith. Negotiations should be planned for, including developing objectives (min-max positions), evaluating your opponent, defining strategy and tactics, gathering facts, performing a price/cost analysis, and arranging "hygiene" factors (e.g., location, timing).
There should be a postnegotiation critique, both internally and with losing bidders, to explain why they did not win. This can help prevent bid protests, which are most common on government contracts.
Award Cycle: This cycle results in a signed contract. Basic elements of most contracts include:
- Mutual agreement: There must be an offer and acceptance.
- Consideration: There must be a down payment.
- Contract capability: The contract is binding only if the contractor has the capability to perform.
- Legal purpose: The contract must be for a legal purpose.
- Form provided by law: The contract must reflect the contractor's legal obligation.
The objective of the award cycle is to negotiate a contract type and price that results in reasonable contractor risk and provides the greatest incentive for efficient performance.
The two most common contract forms are:
- Completion contract: The contractor must deliver a definitive end product. The contract is complete upon delivery and acceptance.
- Term contract: The contractor must deliver a specific "level of effort" (e.g., man-days) over a specific period. The contractor is under no further obligation once the effort is performed, irrespective of technical accomplishments.
A definitive contract follows normal contracting procedures. However, if work must begin immediately, a letter contract (or letter of intent) can be used. This is a preliminary written instrument authorizing the contractor to begin work, with a "not to exceed" face value.
45.3. Types of Contracts
Before analyzing contract types, key terminology must be understood:
- Target cost or estimated cost: The cost level the contractor will most likely obtain under normal conditions.
- Target or expected profit: The profit value negotiated and set forth in the contract.
- Profit ceiling and profit floor: The maximum and minimum values of total profit.
- Price ceiling or ceiling price: The amount of money for which the customer is responsible, usually greater than the target cost.
- Sharing arrangement or formula: The cost responsibility split between customer and contractor for each dollar spent, typically applying to overruns or under-runs.
- Point of total assumption: The point where the contractor assumes all liability for additional costs.
Contracts range from cost-plus types, where the contractor's profit is fixed and risk is minimal, to lump sum or turnkey types, where the contractor assumes full responsibility for all costs and profits.
There are five general types of contracts to consider:
1. Fixed-Price (FP) or Lump-Sum:
- The contractor must carefully estimate the target cost and perform the work for the negotiated value.
- Risk: High for the contractor. If costs are underestimated, profit is reduced or eliminated.
- Advantage: Maximum protection for the owner on ultimate cost.
- Disadvantage: Requires a long period for bid preparation. Owner must know exact requirements at the time of bidding.
2. Cost-Plus-Fixed-Fee (CPFF) or Cost-Plus-Percentage-Fee (CPPF):
- The cost may vary but the fee (profit) is fixed (CPFF) or a percentage of cost (CPPF).
- Risk: Low for the contractor, who only agrees to use "best efforts". Good and poor performance are rewarded equally.
- Advantage: Quick preparation of bids, encourages quick completion. Provides maximum flexibility for the owner.
- Disadvantage: No financial assurance of ultimate cost; higher costs may result due to lack of financial incentive.
3. Guaranteed Maximum-Shared Savings (GMSS):
- The contractor is paid a fixed fee and reimbursed for actual costs, but only up to a ceiling figure (the "guaranteed maximum"). Savings below the ceiling are shared between owner and contractor.
- Risk: Shared between owner and contractor.
- Advantage: Combines the advantages of lump sum and cost-plus contracts. Establishes a maximum price early and protects the owner from being overcharged. Both parties have a real incentive to complete the project at the lowest possible cost.
4. Fixed-Price-Incentive-Fee (FPIF):
- A fixed-price contract with a provision for adjusting total profit by a formula, agreed upon in advance, that depends on the final total cost.
- Risk: Shared between owner and contractor. Provides an incentive for the contractor to reduce costs and increase profit.
- Use: When project requirements are firmly established.
5. Cost-Plus-Incentive-Fee (CPIF):
- A cost-plus contract with a provision for adjusting the fee by a formula that compares total project costs to the target cost.
- Risk: More risk is placed on the contractor compared to CPFF, forcing them to plan ahead and keep costs down.
- Use: For long-duration or R&D type projects.
π‘ Why this matters: The choice of contract type is a critical strategic decision that allocates risk between the buyer and seller. It directly impacts the contractor's behavior, incentive for cost control, and the final project cost.
45.4. Ethics
Ethical Origins: Ethics in project management has several origins.
- Societal Ethics: Standards of behavior based on a society's values, legal rules, norms, and mores. These vary from one society to another.
- Professional Ethics: Values and standards used by a group of managers in the workplace, applied when decisions are not clear-cut ethically (e.g., practices of physicians or lawyers).
- Individual Ethics: The values of an individual, resulting from their family and upbringing. Values are basic convictions of what is "right and wrong."
Ethics codes and policies reflect top management's desires in a project-based organizational culture. Project managers should behave ethically to avoid harming others. Managers are responsible for "protecting and nurturing resources" in their charge. Leadership, culture, and incentive compensation plans help shape individual ethical behavior. There is strong evidence that ethical managers benefit in the longer run.
Ethical decisions involve a normative judgment, implying something is "good or bad, right or wrong." For example, should you buy goods from overseas firms that hire children?
Code of Ethics for Project Managers: The Project Management Institute has developed a code of ethics. Its key articles state that Project Managers shall:
Article I (Personal Conduct):
- Maintain high standards of personal and professional conduct.
- Accept responsibility for their actions.
- Undertake projects only if qualified by training or experience.
- Maintain professional skills at the state-of-the-art.
- Advance the integrity of the profession.
- Support the code and professional society.
Article II (In Their Work):
- Provide project leadership to maximize productivity and minimize costs.
- Apply state-of-the-art management tools.
- Treat all team members fairly.
- Protect project team members from harm.
- Provide suitable working conditions.
Article III (Relations with Employers and Clients):
- Act as faithful agents or trustees.
- Keep confidential information.
- Disclose any circumstances that could lead to a conflict of interest.
- Not give or accept gifts of more than nominal value.
- Be honest and realistic in reporting project cost, schedule, and performance.
Article IV (Responsibilities to the Community):
- Protect the safety, health, and welfare of the public.
- Seek to extend public knowledge of the project management profession.
How Firms Can Improve Their Social Responsiveness (Ethical Performance):
- Establish and publish their own Code of Ethics.
- Appoint Ombudsmen to review corporate past behavior.
- Protect whistle-blowing (when an employee discloses an illegal, immoral, or unethical action).
- Implement training programs for ethical sensitivity.
- Control compliance through a corporate social audit.
- Demonstrate commitment through leadership.
- Involve personnel at all levels.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical lessons from this lecture are that project procurement is a strategic process involving five cycles, and the selection of a contract type is the primary mechanism for allocating risk between the buyer and the seller. Understanding the differences between Fixed-Price, Cost-Plus, and Incentive contracts is essential, as each type creates different incentives for the contractor regarding cost control and performance. Furthermore, a project manager must adhere to a strict code of ethics, which governs their conduct with team members, clients, and the public. Finally, factors like make-or-buy analysis, the use of different specification types, and the negotiation process are all integral to successful procurement management.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five cycles of the procurement/contracting system, and what is the primary activity of each?
- What is the formula for calculating the breakeven point between leasing and renting equipment, and why is it important?
- A project requires a new software module. The buyer is unsure of the exact technical specifications but knows the operational results needed. What type of specification should be used, and who bears the performance risk?
- What are the five main types of contracts, and how does the allocation of risk differ between a Fixed-Price contract and a Cost-Plus-Fixed-Fee contract?
- According to the Code of Ethics for Project Managers, what are a project manager's primary ethical responsibilities regarding information from an employer or client?