π Lecture 39 β Project Effectiveness Through Enhanced Productivity
π Overview: This lecture examines the critical relationship between competitiveness and productivity in project management. It defines productivity, distinguishes it from production, explores different professional perspectives, and identifies barriers to productivity. The lecture also provides comprehensive strategies for productivity improvement through both hard and soft factors, including human resource management techniques.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers competitiveness and its indicators, definitions of productivity in project management context, differences between production and productivity, various professional perspectives on productivity, definitions of effectiveness and efficiency, types of productivity including partial and total factor productivity, white-collar productivity challenges, critical barriers to productivity, causes of productivity decline, productivity improvement strategies, categories of productivity factors (external and internal), and soft factors including motivation, incentives, job design, worker participation, training, time management, and quality of work life.
π Lecture Summary
39.1 Competitiveness
Competitiveness emerged strongly in the new era of globalization and describes the "economic strength" of any organization or position of a company with respect to its competitors in the marketplace. Competitiveness is the process by which one entity strives to outperform another. In organizations, competitiveness is the ability to get customers to choose your product or service over competing alternatives on a sustainable basis. Competitiveness is continually "sustained incorporated in productivity," resulting in high wages and living standards. It is demonstrated by the "ability to meet the rest of free international markets" while "expanding real income."
39.1.1 Indicators of Competitiveness
Macro-level competitiveness of nations reflects the standard of living of their citizens. National competitiveness is a consolidation of micro-level performances of companies and individuals, who are the true "Agents of Economic Growth." The Competitiveness Pyramid shows that company and industry competitiveness at the micro level feeds into national competitiveness at the macro level.
Competitiveness depends on productivity: "Standard of living is determined by productivity of a nation's economy which is measured by the value of goods and services (products) produced per unit of the nation's human, capital and natural resources."
Indicators of competitiveness include Productivity: the efficiency with which goods and services are produced and provided, determined by previous investments, quality and performance of workforce, technology innovation, quality of plant and equipment, and the efficiency with which these factors of production are utilized.
Productivity of "local" industries is of fundamental importance to competitiveness. It depends on:
- Sophistication with which companies compete
- Quality of the microeconomic business environment
When productivity and quality are considered together, competitiveness can be enhanced. The definition of productivity in a successful project management organization is to create surplus through productive output. Productivity = Outputs (Time/Quality) Inputs.
π Definition β Competitiveness: The ability of an entity to outperform another and get customers to choose your product or service over competing alternatives on a sustainable basis.
π Definition β Productivity (in PM context): Outputs divided by Inputs, with consideration of both quality and time.
π Formula: Productivity = Outputs / Inputs β The ratio of goods/services produced to resources used, considering time and quality factors.
39.2 Productivity in the Context of Project Management
39.2.1 Definition of Productivity
- Ratio of output to input by a large number of professionals.
- ILO Definition: "Ratio between output of wealth produced and input resources used up in process of production."
- Comparative tool for managers, industrial engineers, economists, and politicians.
The Project Management System diagram (Figure 39.2) shows inputs (men, machines, materials, money, methods, management) being transformed through a conversion process into outputs.
39.2.2 Difference between Production and Productivity
Production: Concerned with the activity of "producing goods and/or services." Productivity: "Efficient utilization of resources (input) in producing goods/services (output)."
The basic differences:
- Production is the quantity of output produced.
- Productivity is the "ratio of output produced to input(s) used."
- Higher productivity means accomplishing more with the same "amount of resources" or achieving higher output in terms of volume/quality for the same input.
39.2.3 Messages of Productivity
Taylor's Message of Productivity:
- Various pay plans based on output for surplus increase: labor productivity is not possible without work order that: a. Provided ample reward b. Adequate targets c. Managerial help
- Careful advance planning by manager
- Managers to design work system for workers to do their best.
Frederick concluded: Low productivity is a matter of ignorance on the part of labor and management ignorance. "Fair day's work" and "fair day's pay" β productivity enhancement is the answer to high wages/profits.
Peter Drucker says: The problem faced in developing countries is not a problem of "underdevelopment but rather of under management." Actually, productivity is the most serious challenge confronting management.
39.2.4 Perspectives on Productivity
Productivity β Manager's Perspective: Use "accounting ratios" for management. Usually interested in productivity measures that enable easy assessment of the present profitability of the company.
Productivity β Engineer's Perspective: Seek measures of physical assets and other resources. Examples: Production/hour, Man hours/unit, Material required/unit, material consumption, utilization, Space utilization. May fail to relate to overall productivity.
Productivity β Behaviorist's Perspective: View productivity of people in organization in terms of time they spend at work versus total time available β a misleading measure.
Productivity β Accountant's Perspective: "Costing and budgeting" approach to productivity. When budget figures, rather than optimum achievable values, are used as standards, this can create a false impression of high productivity.
Productivity β Economist's Perspective: Partial measures, such as "labor productivity," are employed by economists, along with total factor and total productivity, but again definitions do not agree.
39.3 Definition of Effectiveness and Efficiency
Productivity implies both effectiveness and efficiency in individual and organization performance.
- Effectiveness is the "achievement of objectives." It entails promptly achieving stated objectives.
- Efficiency is the "achievement of ends with the least amount of resources." Resources used to achieve objectives are weighted against what is actually accomplished.
π Definition β Effectiveness: The achievement of stated objectives promptly.
π Definition β Efficiency: The achievement of ends with the least amount of resources.
39.3 Types of Productivity
- Partial Productivity
- Total Factor Productivity
- Total Productivity
Total-Factor Productivity: Ratio of "net output to sum of associated labor and capital (factor) inputs." Net output equals total output minus intermediate goods and services purchased.
Findings of Survey in Different Industries:
- Average: only 4.4 hours per day used productively
- 1.2 hours lost due to personal and other unavoidable delays
- Hours are simply wasted because of management's inability to effectively "plan and control" the worker's tasks.
Productivity Loss:
- Percent due to poor: "Planning and scheduling" of work.
- 25% due to: "Unclear and untimely instructions."
- Percent due to: "Inability to adjust staff size" and duties during "peak and valley workload periods."
- 25% due to: "Poor co-ordination" of material flow, unavailability of needed tools, excess travel time.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the types of productivity and sources of productivity loss helps project managers identify specific areas for improvement and allocate resources effectively.
39.5 White-Collar Productivity
Productivity of white-collar workers is no less important than that of direct labor or manufacturing employees. It is usually the least known, least analyzed, and least managed of all factors of productivity. White-collar employees are productive only 50% of the time. The remainder is non-productive time and can be traced to personal delays (15%) and improper management (35%).
Examples of White Collar Waste:
- Poor staffing
- Inadequate communication
- Unproductive meetings and telephone conversations
- Poor scheduling
- Slack start and quiet times
- Lack of communication between functions
- Information overload
39.6 Critical Barriers/Problems to Productivity
- Family-controlled industry
- Earning easy money
- Monopolistic market, in some segments, some highly competitive
- Erratic inflow of orders
- Lack of productivity and quality culture
- Shortage of funds, low level of codification
- Automation not encouraged
- Low priority of market and commercial activities
- Poor after-service
- Complicated government policy, rules and regulations
- Poor infrastructure support/road transport
- Energy shortage
- Poor working conditions: light, ventilation, safety, housekeeping
- Non-availability of basic material components (to be imported)
- Unreliable suppliers
39.7 Causes of Productivity Decline in Organizations
- Inability to measure, evaluate, and manage productivity of white-collar employees β causes shocking waste of resources.
- Rewards and benefits given without requiring equivalent in productivity and accountability.
- Diffused authority and inefficiency in complex organizations, thereby causing delays and time lags.
- Organization expansion lowers productivity growth, resulting in soaring costs.
- Low motivation among rising numbers of affluent workers with new attitudes.
- Late deliveries caused by schedules disrupted by limited materials.
- Unresolved human conflicts and difficulties in teamwork, resulting in project inefficiencies.
- Legislative intrusions and antiquated laws, resulting in constrained "management options and prerogatives."
- Specialization in work processes resulting in monotony and boredom.
- Rapid technology changes and high costs, resulting in decline in new opportunities and innovation.
- Demand for leisure time causing disruption in operations.
- Project manager's inability to keep pace with the latest information and knowledge.
39.8 Productivity Improvement (PI)
How can projects improve their productivity?
Productivity is composed of:
- People
- Operations variables
To improve productivity, management needs to focus on two points:
- Productivity does not just happen by "trying harder." It must be planned.
- How do you plan for productivity, and what factors are involved?
Improvement means "increase the ratio of output of goods and services produced divided by input used to produce." The ratio can be increased by either increasing output, reducing input, or both.
Financial and social benefits of a "productivity improvement strategy" in a project should be greater than the "implementation cost" in the long run.
The task of the project manager is to evaluate those factors that have a bearing on productivity and take appropriate measures to use them effectively. To raise productivity and reduce cost, we must eliminate bad features in design and specifications that cause excessive work content.
39.8.1 Productivity Improvement Factors
Productivity improvement (PI) is not just "doing things better," but more importantly, it is "doing the right things better." Inter-relationships between labor, capital, and socio-organizational environment are important in a way that they are balanced and coordinated into an integrated whole.
Three Main Productivity Factor Groups:
- Job-related
- Resource-related
- Environment-related
39.9 Categories of Productivity Factors
There are two major categories of productivity factors:
- External (not controllable): Beyond the control of individual enterprise. Understanding of them can motivate certain actions that may change the enterprise's or project's behavior and its productivity in the long run.
- Internal (controllable): Within its control. The first step towards productivity improvement is to identify problem areas within these factor groups.
The Integrated Model of Project Productivity Factors (Figure 39.4) shows external factors (technology, economy, demographics, government/legal, social, ecological, customer/client, supplier/contractor) influencing internal factors (human resources, materials/equipment, systems/procedures, work methods/technology), which together affect project outputs.
39.10 Soft Factors
People: The principal resource and central factor in productivity improvement. All people in the organization have a role to play as workers, engineers, managers, entrepreneurs, and trade union members.
Each role has two aspects:
- Application
- Effectiveness
Application: The degree to which people apply themselves to their work. People differ not only in their ability but also in their will to work.
Law of Behavior: Motivation decreases if it is either satisfied or blocked from satisfaction. Workers may do their jobs working hard (no motivation), but even if they work to their full capacity, they would not be satisfied (motivation is blocked from satisfaction).
Motivation is basic to all human behavior and to efforts in productivity improvement. Material needs are predominant, but this does not mean that non-financial incentives are not effective or have no place.
The project manager should see what stimulates and maintains motivation to bring about changes in the attitude of managers, engineers, and workers, and develop a set of values conducive to higher productivity.
Workers' success in increasing productivity through:
- Rewards
- Improving recognition
- Involvement
- Learning opportunities
- Elimination of negative rewards
Execute effective incentive schemes for significant improvement in productivity. Wage incentives are related to the amount of change accomplished.
The project manager should work to encourage workers to apply their creative talents by taking special interest in their problems and promoting a favorable social climate.
2. Effectiveness: Effectiveness is the extent to which application of human effort brings desired results in output and quality. It is the ability to do a productive job, improved through:
- Training and development
- Job rotation and placements, systematic job progression (promotion)
- Career planning
Key approaches, methods and techniques to improve labor productivity:
- Wages and salaries
- Training and education
- Social security β pensions and health plans
- Rewards
- Incentive plans
- Participation or co-determination
- Contract negotiations
- Attitudes to work, to supervision and to change
- Motivation to higher productivity
- Co-operation
- Organization development
- Improved communications
- Suggestion systems
- Career planning
- Attendance
- Turnover
- Job security
Financial Incentives (Individual and Group): Individual plan is made to give financial incentives on the basis of individual performance.
Types of Individual Plan:
- Piece work plan
- Standard hour plan
- Measured day work plan
- Emerson plan
Group plan is made to give financial incentives on the basis of group performance.
Types of Group Plan:
- Scanlon plan
- Ruker plan
- Kaiser plan
- Tonnage plan
- Dollar sales plan
- Profit sharing
- Improshare
Fringe Benefits: Some intangible means of rewarding and encouraging management employees. These are referred to as "fringes" and include:
- Free Medical
- Insurance
- Free Air
- Fares
- Entertainment
- Company Car
- Telephone
- Subsidized education, etc.
Employee Promotion: Both financial and non-financial form of motivation. Upgradation of employee status is a natural way to recognize skill, knowledge, proficiency, and effort on the job.
Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs: Only dissatisfied needs can motivate workers to high productivity β physiological, safety/security, belongingness, self-esteem, self-actualization (realization of one's potential).
- Japanese: promotion based on seniority
- USA: promotion based on extraordinary performance
- Debatable issue
Job Enrichment: A non-financial motivation technique that provides:
- Variety in assigned tasks
- Employee autonomy and discretion in performing tasks
- Feedback on performance
- Herzberg's two-factor theory applied
Two Factors Theory: "Motivators" β factors leading to job satisfaction: achievement, recognition, nature of work, responsibility, growth, etc. Factors leading to dissatisfaction/avoidance are "Hygiene" factors: company policy, administration, supervision, pay, status.
Job Enlargement: Enlargement of responsibilities associated with the job. Enhanced scope and responsibility. Proponents say jobs get boring and monotonous, causing high absenteeism, high turnover, and low morale, with consequent low productivity. Example: Volvo Sweden β worker could stamp name on engine.
Job Rotation: Involves rotation of workers in different jobs for short periods of time to provide an "all-rounder" in the company's operations for which they were not originally hired:
- Relieves boredom through flexibility in job assignments.
- Not retraining conscious β an ongoing basis effort to provide opportunity to exercise freedom in staying on a job for a fixed period.
Workers Participation and Empowerment: Overcoming resistance to change through employee involvement in planning and implementing change. Mental and emotional involvement in groups encourages workers to contribute to group goals and share responsibility.
Workers Participation Approaches:
- Quality control circles
- Productivity quality teams
- Productivity action teams
- Productivity circles
- Productivity maintenance group
- Employee participation group
Skill Enhancement: Formalized techniques to increase skills needed to perform the job. Skill training is needed for employees when the employee's attitude is positive but abilities are low.
- In the information age, there is a great need for skill at all levels.
Management by Objectives (MBO): A managerial motivation technique that aids motivation through participation by having superior and subordinate managers jointly identify common goals, carefully define them, and together monitor progress towards achieving results for both employer and employee.
- In setting up goals, care must be taken:
- Set simplistic goals
- Set goals without adequate resources
- Not set harsh goals that cause resentment
- If properly administered, MBO can create joint goals and help in team building
- MBO goals provide fairness to both employee and employer
Working Condition Improvement β Quality of Work Life (QWL): An often-emphasized but rarely applied technique that involves a detailed audit of working conditions, designing improved conditions of working, installing and maintaining improvements in working conditions.
Designing Improved Factors include:
- Temperature, light and humidity
- Noise
- Colors of surroundings
- Extent of handling hazardous material, parts or product
- Extent of manual handling of heavy items
Training: Seeks to achieve improved human productivity by increasing ability levels of the workforce. Seeks to meet demands of growth and change. Training may actually decrease total productivity initially.
Types of training:
- On-the-job training
- Apprenticeship
- Internship
- Outside courses
- Visitation training
Role Perception: Refers to the manner in which an individual defines his or her job. The type of effort an employee believes is essential for effective job performance. If workers see high or low productivity as a path to attainment of one or more of their personal goals in work situations, they will tend to be high or low producers.
Quality of Supervision: Concerned with the work of creating and maintaining environments in which people can accomplish goals efficiently and effectively. To improve supervision quality, supervisors must be trained in:
- Interpersonal skills
- Human management
- Group dynamics
- Other behavioral tools
Recognition: Management shows acknowledgment of an employee's outstanding performance in terms of improved productivity, ideas, or any act of good workmanship. They include:
- Pay raise
- Bonus
- Awards
- Certificate of appreciation
- Special highlights in company newsletter
- Special parking provision
- Engraving on plaque in cafeteria
Punishment: Punishment contingency attempts to decrease the likelihood of a particular behavior occurring by making punishment contingent on that behavior. Common punishment contingencies used in work organizations include:
- Disciplinary layoffs
- Transfer to undesirable jobs
- Withholding salary increases
Quality Circles: A group of employees who voluntarily cooperate to solve problems related to production, quality, work environment, maintenance scheduling, or anything that affects these areas.
Productivity and Quality Teams: Small groups of people doing similar tasks meet regularly to select, investigate, and solve problems related to workplace, products, and services. An effective means of improving employee morale, quality, and productivity in organizations. Team spirit, positive thinking, and philosophy of achieving excellence are three important characteristics of productivity and quality teams.
Zero Defects: Zero defects program attempts to improve quality by changing workers' attitudes. Their theme, "do it right first time," stresses error-free performance. It relies on workers to identify error-prone situations with the assumption that the people best prepared to eliminate errors are those who create them.
Time Management: A powerful technique, particularly for white-collar, supervisory, and management personnel. Time management involves minimization of wasteful elements of a person's administrative work, including:
- Interruptions by drop-in visitors (without appointment)
- Attending lengthy and unnecessary meetings that accomplish very little
- Inability to say "no" for some tasks
- Procrastination and lack of decisiveness
- Inability to delegate work
- Taking on much more than can be handled
- Lack of responsibility and authority to do certain jobs
- Delayed, inaccurate or inadequate information
- Taking orders from too many people
- Handling too many "crisis" situations
- Lack of organization of tasks by priority or target dates
- Lack of determination to complete tasks assigned
- Lack of organization on and around desk
- Unnecessary socialization
- Poor filing system
- Making unnecessary trips to people, departments, copy machines, etc.
- Excessive conversation time
- Too many rescheduling of meetings, personal engagements, etc.
To minimize these "time-wasters," time management applies simple, common-sensical but very effective programming rules to every item of work, one of which is: "never handle the same paper twice." Time management always improves human productivity. It is too often ignored, particularly by management people who preach productivity to their subordinates.
Flex Time: Employees are given freedom in determining their hours of work.
- Core time (hours when all employees must be at work)
- Flexible time (hours when employees can vary their time of arrival and departure)
Compressed Work Week: Working for the same number of hours but for fewer days per week (e.g., 8 hours for 5 days vs. 10 hours for 4 days).
Harmonization: Integration of the interests of stockholders, the board of directors, management at all levels, and all employees in a consistent manner both within and outside the physical boundaries of the organization.
π Definition β Motivation: The basic force behind all human behavior and efforts in productivity improvement; it decreases if either satisfied or blocked from satisfaction.
π Definition β Job Enrichment: A non-financial motivation technique that provides variety, autonomy, discretion, and feedback in assigned tasks.
π Definition β Management by Objectives (MBO): A managerial motivation technique where superior and subordinate managers jointly identify, define, and monitor progress towards common goals.
π Definition β Zero Defects: A program that attempts to improve quality by changing workers' attitudes, with the theme "do it right first time."
β Key Takeaways
Competitiveness depends fundamentally on productivity, which is defined as the ratio of outputs to inputs with consideration of both quality and time. Productivity must be distinguished from production β production is the quantity of output, while productivity measures efficient resource utilization. There are three types of productivity: partial, total factor, and total productivity, and different professionals (managers, engineers, behaviorists, accountants, economists) view productivity from different perspectives. White-collar productivity is often the least managed factor, with employees being productive only 50% of the time. Productivity improvement requires planned intervention through both external (uncontrollable) and internal (controllable) factors, with people being the central resource. Key soft factors for improvement include motivation, financial and non-financial incentives, job enrichment, workers' participation, training, quality of work life, time management, and MBO. The project manager's task is to evaluate these factors and take appropriate measures for productivity enhancement.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between production and productivity, and why is this distinction important in project management?
- What are the three types of productivity, and how is total-factor productivity calculated?
- What are the main causes of white-collar productivity loss, and what percentage of time do white-collar workers spend productively?
- What are the two major categories of productivity factors, and how do they differ in terms of managerial control?
- According to Herzberg's two-factor theory, what are "motivators" and "hygiene factors," and how do they relate to job enrichment and productivity improvement?
π Lecture 40 β Cost Management and Control in Projects
π Overview: This lecture explores the critical processes of cost management and cost control in project management. It introduces the Management Cost and Control System (MCCS) as a comprehensive framework encompassing both a planning cycle and an operating cycle. The lecture explains how to control costs through work authorization, cost account codes, budgets, and variance analysis, emphasizing the need to integrate time, cost, and performance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers cost management and cost control, the Management Cost and Control System (MCCS) as a two-cycle process (planning and operating), understanding control as verification and decision-making, the four phases of the operating cycle, the structure and function of cost account codes and work authorization forms, and the creation and management of budgets including management reserve and variance analysis using BCWS, BCWP, and ACWP.
π Lecture Summary
40.1 Cost Management
Cost management is the process whereby companies use cost accounting to report or control various costs of doing business. It describes the approach and activities of managers in short-range and long-range planning and cost decisions that incorporate value for the customer and lower costs of products and services. Managers make decisions on the amount and kind of material used, changes of plant processes, and changes in product designs, with information from the accounting system helping them make such decisions. In the context of a project, cost management involves the overall planning, co-ordination, control, and reporting of all cost-related aspects from βproject initiationβ to βoperation and maintenanceβ. It is a process of identifying all costs associated with an investment, making informed choices about options that will deliver the best βvalue for moneyβ, and managing those costs throughout the life of the project. Techniques like value management help improve value and reduce costs.
40.2 Cost Control
Cost control is equally important to all companies, regardless of size. Small companies generally have tighter monetary controls, mainly because of the risk with the failure of as little as one project, but with less sophisticated control techniques. Large companies may have the luxury to spread project losses over several projects, whereas the small company may have few projects. Cost control is not only the "monitoring" of costs and recording massive quantities of data, but also analyzing the data in order to take corrective action before it is too late. Cost control should be performed by all personnel who incur costs, not merely the project office. Cost control implies good cost management, which must include: cost estimating, cost accounting, project cash flow, company cash flow, direct labor costing, overhead rate costing, and others such as incentives, penalties, and profit-sharing.
40.3 Management Cost and Control System (MCCS)
Cost control is actually a subsystem of the Management Cost and Control System (MCCS) rather than a complete system per se. The MCCS is represented as a two-cycle process: a planning cycle and an operating cycle. The operating cycle is what is commonly referred to as the cost control system. Any cost control system is only as good as the original plan against which performance will be measured. It is more common for the plan to be at fault than the control system. The purpose of any MCCS is to establish policies, procedures, and techniques that can be used in the day-to-day management and control of projects and programs. The planning and control system must provide information that: gives a picture of true work progress; relates cost and schedule performance; identifies potential problems with respect to their sources; provides information to project managers with a practical level of summarization; and demonstrates that the milestones are valid, timely, and auditable.
As a tool for planning, the system must be able to: plan and schedule work; identify those indicators that will be used for measurement; establish direct labor budgets; establish overhead budgets; and identify management reserve. The project budget must be reasonable, attainable, and based on contractually negotiated costs and the statement of work. There are two categories of standards: Performance results standards are quantitative measurements (quality, quantity, cost, time-to-complete); Process standards are qualitative (personnel, functional, and physical factors relationships).
Management Cost and Control System (MCCS) planning activities include: contract receipt, work authorization for project planning, work breakdown structure (WBS), subdivided work description, schedules, planning charts, and budgets. MCCS planning is accomplished in one of these ways: one level below the lowest level of the WBS; at the lowest management level; or by cost element or cost account. A well-disciplined MCCS will produce results like: policies and procedures that minimize the ability to distort reporting; strong management emphasis on meeting commitments; and weekly team meetings with a formalized agenda. For MCCS to be effective, both the scheduling and budgeting systems must be disciplined and formal to prevent inadvertent or arbitrary budget or schedule changes. This does not mean the baseline budget and schedule are static, but that changes must be controlled and result only from deliberate management actions. Two new programs used with MCCS are zero-base budgeting (for better estimating) and design-to-cost (for a decision-making framework).
40.4 Understanding Control
Effective management during the operating cycle requires a well-organized cost and control system for immediate feedback. The requirements for an effective control system (for both cost and schedule/performance) include: thorough planning of the work; good estimating; clear communication; a disciplined budget and authorization; timely accounting; periodic re-estimation; and frequent comparison of actual progress to schedules and budgets. It is essential that management must compare the time, cost, and performance of the program to the budgeted time, cost, and performance, not independently but in an integrated manner. Being within one's budget serves no purpose if performance is only 75 percent. All three resource parameters must be analyzed as a group.
The first purpose of control is a verification process accomplished by comparing actual performance to date with predetermined plans and standards. This verifies that objectives have been translated into standards, standards are reliable, and meaningful budgets have been established. The second purpose of control is decision making. Three useful reports required by management are: the project plan, schedule, and budget; a detailed comparison between resources expended and those predetermined (including an estimate of work remaining); and a projection of resources to be expended through program completion.
π Definition β Variance: Any schedule, technical performance, or cost deviation from a specific plan.
π‘ Why this matters: The "iceberg syndrome" shows that problems become evident too late in the project to be solved easily, resulting in a very high cost to correct them. Possible cost reductions are usually available more readily in the early project phases but are reduced as we go further into the project life-cycle. Downstream, the cost for changes could easily exceed the original cost of the project.
40.5 Operating Cycle
The operating cycle of the MCCS is composed of four phases:
- Work authorization and release (phase II)
- Cost data collection and reporting (phase III)
- Cost analysis (phase IV)
- Reporting: customer and management (phase V)
These four phases, when combined with the planning cycle (phase I), constitute a closed system network. Phase II is considered as work release. Work is authorized via a work description or project work authorization form, which is a contract containing the narrative description, organization, and time frame for each WBS level. This multipurpose form releases the contract, authorizes planning, records detail description of the work, and releases work to the functional departments. Program management may issue a subdivided work description form to the functional units, which generally is not used for efforts longer than ninety days and must be "tracked" as if a project in itself. The work control center assigns a work order number to the subdivided work description form. A work order number is required for all in-house direct and indirect charging and serves as a cross-reference number for automatic assignment of the indentured work breakdown structure number.
40.6 Cost Account Codes
Since project managers control resources through line managers rather than directly, they control direct labor costs by opening and closing work orders. Work orders define the charge numbers for each cost account.
π Definition β Cost Account: An identified level at a natural intersection point of the work breakdown structure and the Organizational Breakdown Structure (OBS) at which functional responsibility for the work is assigned, and actual direct labor, material, and other direct costs are compared with actual work performed for management control purposes.
Cost accounts are the focal point of the MCCS and may comprise several work packages, which are detailed short-span jobs or material items. The work authorization form specifically identifies the cost centers that are "open" for the charge number, the man-hours available for each cost center, and the operational time period. If a charge number is opened up at the department level, then the department manager has the right to subdivide the assigned man-hours among sections. If a cost center needs additional time or man-hours, a cost account change notice form must be initiated.
Cost data collection and reporting (phase III) accumulates actual cost for work performed (ACWP) and budgeted cost for work performed (BCWP) for each contract in detailed cost accounts. These are usually printed out monthly for all levels of the WBS. Weekly supplemental direct labor reports can also be printed. The weekly labor report lists all cost centers authorized to charge to the WBS element. Four categories of cost data are normally accumulated: labor, material, other direct charges, and overhead. Project managers can maintain reasonable control over labor, material, and other direct charges, while overhead costs are calculated yearly or monthly and applied retroactively.
40.7 Budgets
The project budget must be reasonable, attainable, and based on contractually negotiated costs and the statement of work. The basis for the budget is historical cost, best estimates, or industrial engineering standards. The budget must identify planned manpower requirements, contract allocated funds, and management reserve.
π Definition β Management Reserve: The dollar amount established by the project office to budget for all categories of unforeseen problems and contingencies resulting in out-of-scope work to the performers.
Management reserve should not be used to cover up bad planning estimates or budget overruns. An undistributed budget is associated with contract changes where time constraints prevent necessary planning. An unallocated budget represents contract tasks not yet identified or authorized.
To calculate variances, three basic variables are defined: π Formula:
- BCWS (Budgeted Cost for Work Scheduled): Budgeted amount for work scheduled to be accomplished in a given time period.
- BCWP (Budgeted Cost for Work Performed): Budgeted amount for completed work within a given time period (also called "earned value").
- ACWP (Actual Cost for Work Performed): Amount actually expended in completing the work accomplished within a given time period.
There are two primary methods of measurement:
- Measurable efforts: Discrete increments of work with a definable schedule for accomplishment, whose completion produces tangible results.
- Level of effort: Work that does not lend itself to subdivision into discrete scheduled increments, such as project support and project control.
Variances are used on both types of measurement. The cost variance compares deviations from the budget, while the scheduling variance provides a comparison between planned and actual performance. All budgets must be traceable through the budget "log," which includes: distributed budget, management reserve, undistributed budget, and contract changes.
β Key Takeaways
Cost management and control are not just about monitoring expenses but involve analyzing data for timely corrective action. The Management Cost and Control System (MCCS) is a comprehensive framework that integrates a planning cycle with an operating cycle, where cost control is a subsystem. Effective control requires the integrated analysis of time, cost, and performance, not in isolation. Cost accounts are the focal point of MCCS, using work orders and cost account codes to track resources at the intersection of WBS and OBS. Finally, variances between BCWS, BCWP, and ACWP are essential for verifying budgets and schedules, with management reserve designated for unforeseen problems, not to cover poor planning.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary difference between cost management and cost control in a project context?
- What are the two main cycles of the Management Cost and Control System (MCCS), and what is the primary purpose of each?
- Why is it important to analyze time, cost, and performance together rather than independently?
- What is a cost account, and what two organizational structures define its intersection point?
- Define BCWS, BCWP, and ACWP. What is the purpose of comparing these three variables?