π Lecture 33 β Pricing and Estimation (Contd.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on pricing and estimation in project management, focusing on the detailed processes for determining materials/support costs, pricing out work through a logical sequence, and system pricing approaches. It also covers developing backup costs, the complexities of the low-bidder dilemma, special problems in pricing, and common estimating pitfalls. Understanding these elements is crucial for creating accurate, credible cost proposals that support effective project control and organizational strategy.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers materials and support costs, including their determination and flow; a thirteen-step logical sequence for pricing out work; the systems approach to pricing for resource control; development of supporting/backup costs with considerations for different contract types; challenges of the low-bidder dilemma; special problems related to cost billing methods; and a detailed list of estimating pitfalls that can undermine pricing accuracy.
π Lecture Summary
33.1 MATERIALS/SUPPORT COSTS
Three of four major pricing input requirements are fulfilled by the salary structure, overhead structure, and labor hours. The fourth major input is the cost for materials and support, which includes six subtopics: materials, purchased parts, subcontracts, freight, travel, and other. For small-dollar-volume programs, travel and freight are estimated directly. For large dollar-volume programs, travel is normally expressed as between 3 and 5 percent of the direct labor costs, and freight as between 3 and 5 percent of all costs for material, purchased parts, and subcontracts. The "other support costs" category may include computer hours or special consultants.
Determination of material costs is very time-consuming, more so than for labor hours. Material costs are submitted via a bill of materials that includes all vendors, projected costs throughout the program, scrap factors, and shelf lifetime for perishable products. Upon release of the work statement, work breakdown structure, and subdivided work description, the end-item bill of materials and manufacturing plans are prepared. End item materials are those identified as an integral part of the production end-item. Support materials are those required by engineering and operations to support the manufacture of end-items, identified on the manufacturing plan.
Furthermore, a procurement plan/purchase requisition is prepared as soon as possible after contract negotiations. This plan is used to monitor material acquisitions, forecast inventory levels, and identify material price variances. Manufacturing plans are used to prepare tool lists for manufacturing, quality assurance, and engineering. From these plans, a special tooling breakdown is prepared by tool engineering, defining tools to be procured and material requirements for in-house fabrication.
The materials/support costs are submitted by month for each program month. If long-lead funding of materials is anticipated, it must be applied to all materials/support costs. Some vendors may provide fixed prices over time periods in excess of twelve months. For example, Vendor Z may quote a firm-fixed price of $130.50 per unit for 650 units delivered over 18 months if the order is placed within 60 days.
π Definition β Bill of Materials: A document that lists all materials, including vendors, projected costs, scrap factors, and shelf life required for a project. π Example: Vendor Z offers a firm-fixed price of $130.50/unit for 650 units over 18 months if the order is placed within 60 days.
33.2 PRICING OUT THE WORK
Logical pricing techniques are available to obtain detailed estimates. The following thirteen steps provide a logical sequence to better control the company's limited resources:
Step 1: Provide a complete definition of the work. Step 2: Establish a logic network with checkpoints. Step 3: Develop the work breakdown structure. Step 4: Price out the work breakdown structure. Step 5: Review WBS costs with each functional manager. Step 6: Decide on the basic course of action. Step 7: Establish reasonable costs for each WBS element. Step 8: Review the base case costs with upper-level management. Step 9: Negotiate with functional managers for qualified personnel. Step 10: Develop the linear responsibility chart. Step 11: Develop the final detailed and PERT/CPM schedules. Step 12: Establish pricing cost summary reports. Step 13: Document the result in a program plan.
Although pricing is an iterative process, the project manager must develop cost summary reports at each iteration to enable key project decisions. Detailed pricing summaries are needed at least twice: in preparation for the pricing review meeting with management and at pricing termination. At other times, "simple cosmetic surgery" on previous cost summaries may suffice, such as adjustments to escalation factors and procurement costs.
Typical pricing reports include:
- A detailed cost breakdown for each WBS element, with cost summary sheets for each task and rollup sheets for each project and the total program.
- A total program manpower curve for each department, showing how each department has contracted to supply resources. "Peaks and valleys" may require schedule alterations for manpower smoothing.
- A monthly equivalent manpower cost summary, showing the fully burdened cost for the average departmental employee over the project period.
- A yearly cost distribution table, broken down by WBS element, showing yearly or quarterly costs; essentially a project cash-flow summary per activity.
- A functional cost and hour summary, providing top management with an overall description of hours and dollars per major functional unit, including indirect costs.
- A monthly labor hour and dollar expenditure forecast, including manpower termination liability information for premature project cancellation.
- A raw material and expenditure forecast, showing cash flow for raw materials based on vendor lead times, payment schedules, commitments, and termination liability.
- A total program termination liability per month table, showing the customer's monthly costs including termination liability for labor and raw materials.
These tables are used by project managers for cost control and by top-level management for selecting, approving, and prioritizing projects.
33.3 SYSTEMS PRICING
The basis of successful program management is establishing an accurate cost package from which all organization members can project and track costs. The cost data must be represented to achieve maximum allocation of corporate resources (people, money, and facilities).
The systems approach to pricing out activity schedules and the work breakdown structure provides unity within the company. The flow of information allows participation of all organization members, even part-time. Functional managers obtain a better understanding of how their labor fits into the total program and how their activities interface with other departments. For the first time, functional managers can accurately foresee how their activity leads to corporate profits.
The project pricing model (sometimes called a strategic project planning model) acts as a management information system, forming the basis for the systems approach to resource control. The summary sheets from the computer output provide management with data to select possible programs for maximum resource utilization. The strategic pricing model also allows management to perform perturbation analysis on base case costs, providing opportunity for design and evaluation of contingency plans.
π Definition β Perturbation Analysis: An analysis performed on base case costs to evaluate the impact of changes and design contingency plans. π‘ Why this matters: Systems pricing ensures all parts of the organization are aligned and resources are allocated optimally.
33.4 DEVELOPING THE SUPPORTING/BACKUP COSTS
Not all cost proposals require backup support. For those that do, backup support should be developed along with pricing. Extreme caution must ensure that itemized prices are compatible with supporting data. Government pricing requirements are a special case.
Most supporting data come from external (subcontractor or outside vendor) quotes. Internal data must be based on historical data, which must be updated continually as each new project is completed. Supporting data should be traceable by itemized charge numbers. Customers may wish to audit the cost proposal, starting with supporting data. On sole-source proposals, it is not uncommon for supporting data to be audited before the final cost proposal is submitted.
The determining factor for requiring supporting data is usually the type of contract. On a fixed-price effort, the customer may not have the right to audit your books. For a cost-reimbursable package, your costs are an open book, and the customer usually compares your exact costs to the backup support.
Companies often have a choice of more than one estimate for backup support. In deciding which estimate to use, consider the possibility of follow-on work:
- If actual costs grossly exceed backup support estimates, you may lose credibility for follow-on work.
- If actual costs are less than backup costs, you must use the new actual costs on follow-on efforts.
The moral is that backup support costs provide future credibility. Well-documented, "livable" cost estimates may be included in the cost proposal even if not required.
Since both direct and indirect costs may be negotiated separately as part of a contract, supporting data (such as in Tables 33.1-33.4 and Figure 33.4) may be necessary to justify costs that differ from company or customer-approved standards. These tables include details on staff turnover data, staff experience profile, and total reimbursable manpower.
33.5 THE LOW-BIDDER DILEMMA
The price tag is critical to the proposal, but the question is what price will win the job. The decision process leading to the final price is highly complex with many uncertainties. While proposal managers may think a very low price helps, winning is only the beginning. Companies have short- and long-range objectives on profit, market penetration, and new product development that may be incompatible with a low-price strategy.
Considerations against a low-price strategy include:
- A suspiciously low price on cost-plus proposals might be perceived as unrealistic, affecting cost credibility or technical ability.
- The bid price may be unnecessarily low, eroding profits.
- The price may be irrelevant to the bid objective, such as entering a new market.
- Low pricing without market information is meaningless; price level is relative to competitive prices, customer budget, and the bidder's cost estimate.
- The bid proposal may cover only part of the total program; winning phase II depends on phase I performance and phase II price.
- Customer financial objectives may include total system life-cycle cost (LCC), design to unit production cost (DTUPC), or specific logistic support items.
Despite customer pressures toward low cost and fixed price, the lowest bidder is not an automatic winner. Both commercial and governmental customers are increasingly concerned about cost realism and the ability to perform under contract. A compliant, sound technical and management proposal based on past experience with realistic, well-documented cost figures is often chosen over the lowest bidder, who may project a risky image.
π Definition β Cost Realism: The credibility and accuracy of a cost proposal, reflecting the bidder's ability to perform the work at the stated price.
33.6 SPECIAL PROBLEMS
Pricing must include an understanding of cost control, specifically how costs are billed back to the project. There are three possible billing situations:
- Work priced at department average, charged at department average: This is the easiest method but encourages project managers to fight for the highest salary resources, since only average wages are billed.
- Work priced at department average, billed at actual salary: This can create problems if only the best (highest-paid) employees are used, leading to cost overruns unless they work faster. Some companies are forced to use this by government agencies and may "inflate" direct labor hours to compensate.
- Work priced at actual salary, billed at actual salary: This is the ideal situation, as long as the people can be identified during pricing.
Some companies use a combination of all three methods. The project office is often priced using the third method (because these people are identified early), while functional employees are priced using the first or second method.
33.7 ESTIMATING PITFALLS
Several pitfalls can impede the pricing function. The most serious is the "buy-in" decision, which is based on the assumption that there will be "bail-out" changes or follow-on contracts later. These may include spares, spare parts, maintenance, manuals, equipment surveillance, optional equipment, optional services, and scrap factors.
Other estimating pitfalls include:
- Misinterpretation of the statement of work
- Omissions or improperly defined scope
- Poorly defined or overly optimistic schedule
- Inaccurate work breakdown structure
- Applying improper skill levels to tasks
- Failure to account for risks
- Failure to understand or account for cost escalation and inflation
- Failure to use the correct estimating technique
- Failure to use forward pricing rates for overhead, general and administrative, and indirect costs
Unfortunately, many of these pitfalls do not become evident until detected by the cost control system, well into the project.
π Definition β Buy-in Decision: A strategy of submitting a low price to win a contract, based on the assumption that future changes or follow-on contracts will cover the losses. π‘ Why this matters: Buy-in promises higher profits later but carries extreme risk if changes or follow-on work do not materialize.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are the structure and determination of materials/support costs, the logical thirteen-step sequence for pricing out work, and the importance of systems pricing for resource control. Students must understand the different billing methods for costs (department average vs. actual salary) and their impact on project budgets. The low-bidder dilemma highlights that credibility and cost realism are often more important than the lowest price. Finally, the extensive list of estimating pitfalls, especially the buy-in strategy, represents serious risks that can compromise project success and must be recognized and avoided.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four major pricing input requirements, and which is the fourth one discussed in this lecture?
- List the thirteen steps for logically pricing out the work.
- What is the project pricing model also called, and what type of analysis does it allow management to perform on base case costs?
- For what type of contract are costs considered an "open book" and subject to customer audit of backup support?
- Name at least five of the nine estimating pitfalls that can impede the pricing function.
π Lecture 34 β Quality in Project Management
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of quality as a critical factor in project management and business success. It explores how quality is defined from multiple perspectives, examines its various dimensions, discusses its role in creating competitive advantage, and traces the evolution of quality management philosophies culminating in Total Quality Management (TQM). Understanding quality is essential because high quality reduces costs, increases productivity, generates customer satisfaction, and provides a sustainable competitive edge.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by examining the subjective and multifaceted nature of quality, presenting definitions from a historical business perspective. It then details six distinct perspectives on quality: judgmental, product-based, user-based, value-based, manufacturing-based, and an integrating customer-driven view. Following this, the eight principal quality dimensions are outlined. The concept of competitive advantage is explored through Porter's cost and differentiation frameworks. Finally, the lecture traces the evolution of quality in Japan and explains Total Quality Management (TQM) as a comprehensive management philosophy based on customer focus, participation, and continuous improvement.
π Lecture Summary
WHAT IS QUALITY?
Quality is not a new concept; in 1887, William Cooper Procter linked quality to productivity, cost, and profitability. Of these three determinants of profitability, quality is the most significant factor in determining the long-run success or failure of any organization. High quality goods and services provide a competitive edge, reduce costs from returns and rework, increase productivity and profits, and generate satisfied customers who provide continued patronage and word-of-mouth advertising.
Quality is a confusing and subjective concept because people view it from differing criteria based on their roles in the production-marketing value chain. A study of 86 firms produced several dozen different definitions, including perfection, consistency, eliminating waste, speed of delivery, compliance with policies, providing a usable product, doing it right the first time, delighting customers, and total customer satisfaction.
QUALITY FROM DIFFERENT PERSPECTIVES
Judgmental Perspective This view, first defined by Walter Shewhart in 1931, equates quality with superiority or excellence, known as the transcendent definition of quality. Under this view, quality is "both absolute and universally recognizable, a mark of uncompromising standards and high achievement." It cannot be defined preciselyβ"you just know it when you see it." This perspective is often linked to marketing efforts aimed at developing quality as an image variable.
π Definition β Transcendent Quality: Quality as the "goodness of a product" which is synonymous with superiority or excellence, rising above ordinary limits. π Example: Rolex watches and BMW and Lexus automobiles are attributed with this quality image.
Product-Based Perspective This definition views quality as a function of a specific, measurable variable, where differences in quality reflect differences in the quantity of some product attribute. This assessment implies that higher levels or amounts of product characteristics are equivalent to higher quality.
π Definition β Product-Based Quality: Quality determined by the quantity of a measurable product attribute. π Example: The number of stitches per inch on a shirt or the number of cylinders in an engine are measurable attributes that influence perceived quality.
User-Based Perspective This definition is based on the presumption that quality is determined by what a customer wants. Individuals have different wants and needs, leading to different quality standards.
π Definition β User-Based Quality: Quality defined as fitness for intended use, or how well the product performs its intended function. π Example: A Cadillac sedan and a Jeep Cherokee are both fit for use, but they serve different customer needsβa Cadillac for highway touring with luxury amenities, a Jeep for camping and skiing trips.
Value-Based Perspective This approach defines quality based on the relationship of usefulness or satisfaction to price.
π Definition β Value-Based Quality: A quality product is one that is as useful as competing products and sold at a lower price, or one that offers greater usefulness at a comparable price. π Example: Japanese brands like Toyota and Honda have better reputations for long-term durability than the Big Three (General Motors, Ford, Chrysler), allowing them to offer fewer incentives and rebates, which are essentially payments to compensate for lower quality.
Manufacturing-Based Perspective This view defines quality as the desirable outcome of engineering and manufacturing practice, or conformance to specifications. Specifications are targets and tolerances determined by designers. Targets are the ideal values for which production strives, and tolerances are the allowable variations because it is impossible to meet targets all the time.
π Definition β Manufacturing-Based Quality: Quality as conformance to specifications. π Formula: For a part dimension specified as "0.236 Β± 0.003 cm" β the target is 0.236 centimeters, the tolerance is 0.006 centimeters (0.003 above and below), and any dimension in the range of 0.233 to 0.239 centimeters is deemed acceptable and conforms to specifications. π Example: "On-time arrival" for an airplane might be specified as within 15 minutes of the scheduled arrival time. The target is the scheduled time, and the tolerance is 15 minutes.
Integrating Perspectives on Quality How quality is viewed depends on one's position in the value chain (designer, manufacturer, distributor, or customer). The customer is the driving force, and customers generally view quality from the transcendent or product-based perspective. The manufacturer must translate customer requirements into detailed product and process specifications. Product designers must balance performance and cost.
Customer-Driven Quality The American National Standards Institute (ANSI) and the American Society for Quality (ASQ) defined quality as "the totality of features and characteristics of a product or service that bears on its ability to satisfy given needs." By the end of the 1980s, a simpler, more powerful customer-driven definition emerged.
π Definition β Customer-Driven Quality: "Quality is meeting or exceeding customer expectations."
QUALITY DIMENSIONS
The following are the "principal quality dimensions":
- Performance β a product's primary operating characteristics. Example: A car's acceleration, braking distance, steering, and handling.
- Features β the "bells and whistles" of a product. Example: A car may have power options, a tape or CD player, antilock brakes, reclining seats.
- Reliability β the probability of a product's surviving over a specified period of time under stated "conditions of use." Example: A car's ability to start on cold days and frequency of failures.
- Conformance β the degree to which physical and performance characteristics of a product match the pre-established standards. Example: Car's fit/finish and freedom from noises reflect this.
- Durability β the amount of use one gets from a product before it physically deteriorates or until replacement is preferable. Example: Car's corrosion resistance and long wear of upholstery fabric.
- Serviceability β the speed, courtesy, and competence of repair work. Example: Auto owner access to spare parts also comes under serviceability.
- Aesthetics β how a product looks, feels, sounds, tastes, or smells. Example: Car's color, instrument panel design, and "feel of the road" make it aesthetically pleasing.
- Perceived Quality β the "subjective assessment of quality" resulting from image. Example: Advertising, brand names shaped by magazine reviews, and manufacturers' brochures.
- Affordability, Variety, Simplicity etc. are also the principal quality dimensions.
COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE
When a firm sustains profits that exceed the average for its industry, it possesses a competitive advantage over its rivals. Michael Porter identified two basic types of competitive advantage:
- Cost advantage: delivering the same benefits as competitors but at a lower cost.
- Differentiation advantage: delivering benefits that exceed those of competing products.
A competitive advantage enables the firm to create superior value for its customers and superior profits for itself. Cost and differentiation advantages are known as positional advantages since they describe the firm's position as a leader in either cost or differentiation. A resource-based view emphasizes that a firm utilizes its resources and capabilities to create a competitive advantage that results in superior value creation.
QUALITY EVOLUTION AND QUALITY STAGES IN JAPAN
The lecture includes Figure 34.2, which illustrates the quality evolution and quality stages in Japan, showing the progression of quality thinking from inspection-based approaches to more comprehensive management frameworks.
TOTAL QUALITY MANAGEMENT (TQM) AND ITS PHILOSOPHY
Quality as a Management Framework A 1970s General Electric (GE) task force found that product lines with poor quality reputations deemphasized the customer's viewpoint, regarded quality as synonymous with conformance to specifications, and used formal quality control systems only in manufacturing. In contrast, product lines that received customer praise emphasized satisfying customer expectations, determined needs through market research, and had formalized quality control systems for all business functions. The task force concluded that quality must be viewed as a management discipline, not solely as a technical discipline.
This led to the concept of Total Quality (TQ) . A 1992 definition endorsed by nine major U.S. corporations states:
π Definition β Total Quality (TQ) : A people-focused management system that aims at continual increase in customer satisfaction at continually lower real cost. TQ is a total system approach, an integral part of high-level strategy that works horizontally across functions and departments, involves all employees top to bottom, and extends backward and forward to include the supply chain and customer chain. TQ stresses learning and adaptation to continual change as keys to organizational success.
The foundation of total quality is philosophical: the scientific method. TQ includes systems, methods, and tools. TQ is anchored in values that stress the dignity of the individual and the power of community action. Procter and Gamble's concise definition is: "Total quality is the unyielding and continually improving effort by everyone in an organization to understand, meet, and exceed the expectations of customers."
A. V. Feigenbaum coined the term Total Quality Control in the 1950s, observing that quality is directly influenced by the 9 Ms: markets, money, management, men and women, motivation, materials, machines and mechanization, modern information methods, and mounting product requirements. The Japanese adopted this concept as companywide quality control, with five aspects:
- Quality emphasis extends through market analysis, design, and customer service.
- Quality emphasis is directed toward operations in every department.
- Quality is the responsibility of the individual and the work group, not inspection.
- The two types of quality characteristics are those that satisfy and those that motivate.
- The first customer for a part or piece of information is usually the next department.
The term Total Quality Management (TQM) was developed by the Naval Air Systems Command to describe its Japanese-style approach to quality improvement and became popular in the United States during the 1980s.
Principles of Total Quality Total quality is based on three fundamental principles:
- A focus on customers and stakeholders.
- Participation and teamwork by everyone in the organization.
- A process focus supported by continuous improvement and learning.
These principles differ significantly from traditional management practices. With total quality, an organization actively seeks to identify customer needs and expectations, build quality into work processes by tapping workforce knowledge, and continually improve every facet of the organization.
Customer and Stakeholder Focus: The customer is the principal judge of quality. A company's efforts must include designing new products that delight the customer and responding rapidly to changing demands. Internal customers (employees who view themselves as both customers of and suppliers to other employees) are as important as external customers. Employees and society also represent important stakeholders. A TQ organization must demonstrate commitment to employees and view society as a stakeholder through business ethics, public health and safety, the environment, and community support.
Participation and Teamwork: Joseph Juran credited Japanese managers' full use of the knowledge and creativity of the entire workforce as a reason for Japan's rapid quality achievements. When managers give employees tools to make good decisions and the freedom and encouragement to make contributions, better quality products and processes result. Employees allowed to participateβindividually and in teamsβin decisions affecting their jobs can make substantial contributions to quality. This represents a profound shift from the traditional view that the workforce should be "managed" and leave their brains at the door.
π‘ Why this matters: The three principles of TQ represent a complete paradigm shift from traditional command-and-control management. Success depends on management formulating systems and procedures to embed participation into the organizational culture.
β Key Takeaways
Quality is the most significant factor in determining long-term organizational success, reducing costs while increasing customer satisfaction and competitive advantage. Quality must be understood from multiple perspectives (judgmental, product-based, user-based, value-based, and manufacturing-based), but the most powerful modern definition is "meeting or exceeding customer expectations." The eight principal quality dimensionsβperformance, features, reliability, conformance, durability, serviceability, aesthetics, and perceived qualityβprovide a framework for evaluating any product or service. Competitive advantage is achieved through either cost leadership or differentiation, both of which quality supports. Total Quality Management (TQM) transformed quality from a technical discipline into a comprehensive management framework based on customer and stakeholder focus, participation and teamwork by everyone, and continuous improvement and learning across all functions of the organization.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five different perspectives from which quality can be viewed, and how does the customer-driven definition integrate them?
- List and briefly explain each of the eight principal quality dimensions, providing an example for each.
- According to Michael Porter, what are the two basic types of competitive advantage, and how does quality contribute to each?
- What were the key findings of the General Electric task force regarding how successful and unsuccessful product lines approached quality?
- What are the three fundamental principles of Total Quality (TQ), and how do they differ from traditional management practices?
π Lecture 35 β Quality in Project Management (Contd.)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of quality in project management by examining the historical evolution of quality from simple inspection to Total Quality Management (TQM). It introduces the key stages of quality development, explains the purpose and components of a quality audit, and presents Deming's influential philosophy on management's role in achieving quality. Understanding this evolution is critical for project managers to implement effective quality systems.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the historical "Quality Movement" from pre-WWI inspection to modern TQM, detailing the "five level model" of quality development stages: Inspection, Quality Control, Quality Assurance, Quality Management, and Total Quality Management. It then defines the "Quality Audit" and its objectives, and concludes with an examination of "Deming's Philosophy," including his "Dreadful Diseases" and the "Deming Cycle for Improvement."
π Lecture Summary
35.1 THE QUALITY MOVEMENT:
This section traces the evolution of quality views over the past 100 years. Before World War I, quality was seen as inspectionβsorting good items from bad, with an emphasis on problem identification. After WWI and into the early 1950s, this sorting focus remained, but principles of quality control emerged using statistical and mathematical techniques, sampling tables, and process control charts. From the early 1950s to the late 1960s, quality control evolved into quality assurance, shifting the emphasis from problem detection to problem avoidance. New principles like the cost of quality, zero-defect programs, reliability engineering, and total quality control were developed.
35.2 DEVELOPMENT OF QUALITY STAGES:
This section details the "five level model" of quality development, which represents the progression from basic inspection to an organization-wide focus on quality.
1. Inspection: Inspection is defined as an activity of measuring, examining, testing, or gauging characteristics and comparing results with specified requirements to determine conformity.
π Definition β Inspection (ISO 8402): "Activity such as measuring, examining, testing, or gauging one or more characteristics of an entity and comparing the results with specified requirements in order to establish whether conformity is achieved for each characteristic."
2. Quality Control: Quality control is a collective term for activities and techniques within a process that create specific quality characteristics. This includes monitoring processes, identifying and eliminating problem causes, and using statistical process control to reduce variability and increase efficiency. It certifies that quality objectives are being met and is also referred to as the technical aspect of quality management. A good quality control system will select what to control, set standards, establish measurement methods, compare results to standards, act to correct nonconformance, monitor and calibrate measuring devices, and include detailed documentation.
π‘ Why this matters: Quality control is the hands-on, technical process that ensures each step of the project produces a quality output.
3. Quality Assurance: Quality assurance is the collective term for formal activities and managerial processes planned to ensure delivered products and services are at the required quality level. It includes efforts to improve internal processes and attempts to integrate project scope, cost, and time functions. The PMBOK refers to quality assurance as the management section of quality management, where the project manager can have the greatest impact. A good quality assurance system will identify objectives and standards, be multifunctional and prevention-oriented, plan for data collection and continuous improvement, establish performance measures, and include quality audits.
π‘ Why this matters: This is where the project manager establishes administrative processes to ensure and prove that deliverables meet customer requirements.
4. Quality Management: This section notes that a revolution toward improved quality has occurred, often driven by economic recessions. The push for higher quality is now customer driven, with customers demanding higher performance, faster development, higher technology, and fewer defects. Market expectations are affected by variables including:
- Salability: the balance between quality and cost
- Produceability: the ability to produce the product with available technology and workers at an acceptable cost
- Social acceptability: the degree of conflict between the product and society's values (safety, environment)
- Operability: the degree to which a product can be operated safely
- Availability: the probability the product will perform satisfactorily when used
- Reliability: the probability of the product performing without failure under given conditions for a set time
- Maintainability: the ability of the product to be retained in or restored to a performance level
Customer demands are now handled using Total Quality Management (TQM), which is an ever-improving system for integrating organizational elements to provide cost-effective products fully acceptable to the customer.
5. Total Quality Management (TQM): Total Quality encompasses the quality of work, service, information, process, organization, people, company, and objectives. Because quality is defined by the customer, mature organizations admit they cannot accurately define it. The Kodak definition is products and services that meet or exceed customer needs at a cost representing outstanding value. The ISO 9000 definition is "the totality of feature and characteristics of a product or service that bears on its ability to satisfy stated or implied needs."
Total Quality Management (TQM) is a management strategy aimed at embedding awareness of quality in all organizational processes. It provides an umbrella under which everyone can strive for customer satisfaction at continually lower costs. TQM is the management of total quality, which consists of three qualities:
- Quality of return to satisfy shareholders
- Quality of products and services to satisfy the consumer (end user)
- Quality of life at work and outside work to satisfy the people in the organization
This is achieved with upstream and downstream partners, plus corporate citizenshipβthe social, technological, economical, political, and ecological (STEPE) responsibility of the enterprise.
π Example: In a Supply Chain Management approach, TQM means not just satisfying your immediate customer's needs, but the needs of your customers' customers, all the way to the end consumer.
35.3 QUALITY AUDIT:
A quality audit is an independent evaluation performed by qualified personnel to ensure the project conforms to quality requirements and follows established procedures and policies. A good quality audit will ensure that:
- The planned quality for the project will be met
- The products are safe and fit for use
- All pertinent laws and regulations are followed
- Data collection and distribution systems are accurate and adequate
- Proper corrective action is taken when required
- Improvement opportunities are identified
π Definition β Quality Audit: An independent evaluation performed by qualified personnel that ensures that the project is conforming to the project's quality requirements and is following the established quality procedures and policies.
35.4 DEMING'S PHILOSOPHY:
Deming postulated that 85 percent of all quality problems required management to take the initiative and change the process, while only 15 percent could be controlled by workers. For example, workers were not at fault for poor raw materials resulting from management's decision to seek lowest-cost suppliers; management had to change purchasing policies and develop long-term vendor relationships.
Dr. Deming's Dreadful Diseases:
- Looking elsewhere for examples, or concluding that "our problems are different"
- "Creative accounting" rather than "commitment"
- Purchasing to an "acceptable level of quality"
- Management's failure to delegate responsibility
- That employees cause all the problems
- Quality can be "assured by inspection"
- False starts: no organization-wide commitment
Deming pioneered the use of statistics and applied Dr. Shewhart's Plan/Do/Check/Act cycle to clerical tasks. He contended that workers must be shown what constitutes acceptable quality and that continuous improvement is possible and necessary. To achieve this, workers need training in statistical process control charts.
π Definition β Deming Cycle (Plan/Do/Check/Act): A continuous improvement cycle where you Plan a change, Do it on a small scale, Check the results, and Act to standardize the improvement or begin the cycle again.
π Example: If a project team finds that 85% of defects come from poor raw materials, Deming's philosophy says management must change the purchasing process (e.g., develop long-term relationships with quality vendors), not blame the workers on the floor.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point is the historical evolution of quality from simple inspection to a comprehensive, organization-wide TQM strategy, culminating in the five-level model. A project manager must understand that quality assurance focuses on prevention through managerial processes, while quality control is the technical, monitoring aspect. Deming's philosophy is foundational: 85% of quality problems are management's fault and require process changes, not worker blame. A quality audit is an independent check for conformance to procedures and requirements. Finally, TQM is a total system covering shareholder returns, customer satisfaction, people's quality of life, and corporate citizenship.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key difference between Quality Control (QC) and Quality Assurance (QA)?
- According to Deming, what percentage of quality problems require management to change the process, and what are two of his "Dreadful Diseases"?
- List the five stages of quality development in order, from least to most comprehensive.
- What is the primary purpose of a quality audit?
- According to the lecture, what are the three specific "qualities" that make up "Total Quality" in TQM?