📘 Lecture 40 — Implementation: Radical or Transformative Change (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the discussion of radical or transformative change by examining the causation typology for revolutionary change developed by Dunphy. It then delves deeply into the managerial implications of managing radical organizational transformation, presenting a framework by Francis and Bessant that identifies five key organizational and managerial competencies required for successful transformation. The lecture provides a detailed breakdown of the first two stages of this framework, including the critical "pre-action barriers" and four generic transformational strategies.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by presenting Dunphy's typology for the causation of revolutionary change, which includes environmental creep, organizational creep, diversification/acquisition/merger/shutdowns, industry re-organization, and major technological breakthroughs. The focus then shifts to the managerial implications of transformation, emphasizing the need for profound, fundamental changes across multiple dimensions. The core of the lecture is dedicated to explaining the Francis and Bessant analytical framework of five key competencies, with a deep dive into the first two stages: "Recognize the challenge" (including the five pre-action barriers of avoidance, indecision, poverty, insularity, and inability) and "Determine a transformational strategy" (covering four generic strategies: reconfiguring the value stream, redefining the driving force, reconstructing competencies, and redefining the value proposition).
📝 Lecture Summary
Causation for Revolutionary Change (Dunphy's Typology)
Dunphy developed a typology to explain what causes revolutionary change. The first cause is Environmental Creep, where the environment changes incrementally in ways that become imperceptible to managers. Over time, the degree of change becomes large and requires major re-adjustment. The second cause is Organizational Creep, where the organization itself moves out of strategic alignment with a relatively stable environment.
Diversification, Acquisition, Merger, Shut downs can also cause revolutionary change. For example, diversification often involves a major structural shift from a functional to a divisional structure. Because these structures are radically different, incremental change is often not a realistic possibility. The same applies to acquisition, merger, and shut down, as large-scale additions or subtractions preclude an incrementalist approach.
Industry Re-organization occurs when an organization may be adjusting appropriately to an industrial structure, but that structure itself is altered dramatically. Examples include deregulation, nationalization, opening of borders, and signing trade liberalization treaties like those of the WTO, which introduce discontinuity in the industry environment. Finally, Major Technological Breakthroughs can cause revolutionary change. Organizations might have invested too much in current technology, but a major new technology breakthrough occurs that dramatically changes production costs. This creates problems for old organizations with older technology while creating potential for new investors, such as mini-mills in the steel industry.
Managerial Implications (Managing Radical Organization Transformation by Francis & Bessant)
Transformation means profound, fundamental changes in thought and action, which creates an irreversible discontinuity in the experience of a system in multiple dimensions of an organization’s strategy, structure, culture, and work processes. The three key variables are: 1) thought and actions, 2) irreversible discontinuity, and 3) multiple dimensions. Several factors create a transformational imperative, of which the most ubiquitous is technical change. Firms founded to exploit specific technologies are especially vulnerable when there are discontinuous changes in the prevailing scientific paradigm or dominant technologies. The principal reason for this vulnerability is that the prevailing core values, routines, strategies, cultural imperatives, and asset endowment were built on a business model that has become competitively inferior. When this happens, a firm’s traditional competitive advantage ebbs away. A radical transition is required, but firms can fail to recognize the urgency, lack understanding of the scale of destruction and reconstruction required, or not possess the skills to handle the “jump”. Hence, a transformational imperative presents particular problems for strategic managers. Radical organizational transformation requires multiple changes: strategies must be rewritten, organizational culture realigned, processes re-worked, and value chains re-designed. The study by Francis and Bessant shows that firms need to acquire a set of different, distinctive, and possibly temporary new capabilities, generally from outside the firm, to make a radical transformation. They proposed an analytical framework that identified five key organizational and managerial competencies: 1) Recognize the challenge, 2) Determine a transformational strategy, 3) Require extensive innovation, 4) Manage systemic change, and 5) Upgrade leadership process.
🔑 Definition — Transformation: Profound, fundamental changes in thought and action, which creates an irreversible discontinuity in the experience of a system in multiple dimensions of an organization's strategy, structure, culture, and work processes.
Stage I: Recognize the Challenge
Most organizations face strategic dilemmas as they are not in a state of readiness or mood to go for change. These dilemmas are identified by managers as "we are in a wrong place". The author has defined that organizations face pre-action barriers, which are five specific obstacles that prevent them from initiating change.
The first pre-action barrier is Avoidance. People in organizations, especially top managers, cannot move away from their tested ways of doing business because they do not believe the world has changed. This is a kind of success trap for individuals who are unable to differentiate environments and situations and believe that with the same set of knowledge and skills, they can counter every situation. The second barrier is Indecision. Even when the need for change is understood, no one may know what the best strategic direction to follow is. This is the problem of too many options and alternatives on one hand, and the problem of leadership and decision-making amongst competing and splintered leadership.
The third pre-action barrier is Poverty. Firms may find themselves needing to undertake radical change at the same time as their financial results are poor. The cost of investment is very high, especially when going for technology-driven solutions, licensing, maintenance, up-gradation, and training. The fourth barrier is Insularity. The individuals in power in the organization are those whose life experience has been in creating that which now has to be destroyed. High-powered leadership, which is isolated from people, is least equipped to be the leaders of transformation. The fifth and final barrier is Inability. The management of major change programs or organizational transformation is a demanding task, and relatively few leaders have the necessary prowess. It is unlikely that managers who have spent years managing steady-state organizations will have the appropriate skills and values to lead transformational change.
💡 Why this matters: Recognizing these five pre-action barriers is critical for leaders. It forces them to diagnose why their organization is stuck—whether it's denial (avoidance), confusion (indecision), lack of resources (poverty), being too close to the old system (insularity), or lacking the right skills (inability)—before they can even begin to plan for transformation.
🔑 Definition — Pre-action Barriers: Obstacles that prevent an organization from being in a state of readiness or mood to go for change, including avoidance, indecision, poverty, insularity, and inability.
Stage II: Determine a Transformational Strategy (TS)
Once the challenge is recognized, the next stage is to determine a transformational strategy. There are several generic transformational strategies, of which four are identified here. The first generic TS is TS 1. Reconfigure the value stream. This involves making major changes in the positioning of the firm within a web of suppliers, partners, and/or downstream agents. Firms may be able to change, upgrade, or develop their suppliers and do the same with downstream agents. They may find new ways to meet supply needs or reposition themselves within the value stream with advantage. For example, Sun Microsystems developed an extensive partnering network for service support that extended their reach and enabled them to provide locally adapted services. Three key advantages are associated with this strategy: it enables activities to be undertaken at rock-bottom costs, a value stream can be constructed so it is inherently agile, and visibility of the value stream provides an opportunity to detect inefficient linkages and improve them.
The second generic TS is TS 2. Redefine the driving force of the business. Over time, organizations need to change their strategic orientation, must revise their strategic driving force, and innovate their mission. The risks of adopting a new strategic driving force are high as the organization must abandon, at least in part, what it knows and enter a domain of ignorance, uncertainty, and discovery. For example, a company in a Scandinavian country, back in 1865, was concerned with the pulp and paper industry. After 100 years or so, it entered telecommunications and, since the late 1990s, has been an industry leader.
The third generic TS is TS 3. Reconstruct the competencies of the business. Competencies are underlying attributes that enable difficult things to be done reliably and economically. The way you do things that nobody else can do is known as strategic competence. Critical Success Factors (CSF) is an equivalent concept. For instance, oil companies have a competence in finding oil by interpreting complex geological data to reduce the risk of drilling in the wrong place. In the pharmaceutical industrial sector, spending on research and development (R&D) is a norm to discover new compounds. One computer firm transformed itself from a memory company to a processor company. Hence, the development of new competence is essential given the perceived change in environment.
The fourth generic TS is TS 4. Redefine the value proposition to the existing and/or new customers. Competitive strategies are about meeting sufficient numbers of customers' needs better than others, managing costs, and innovating. Firms that understand their existing customers well, and importantly, their potential customers, have an advantage. Intimacy with the customer provides a form of learning that can be applied to the design of the product/service offer. However, a focus on existing customers can blinkers a firm's decision-makers since existing customers may not be lead users. A commitment to study potential and/or lead-user customers is needed. This theme is central to Christensen's (1997) analysis of the "innovator's dilemma" , where the weak signals indicating the emergence of new market opportunities are unlikely to be picked up by concentrating on existing core customers. The challenges of an uncertain or turbulent environment are such that unless organizations change what they offer (product/service innovation) and the ways in which they create and deliver that offering (process innovation), their survival will be in doubt.
🔑 Definition — Strategic Competence: Underlying attributes that enable difficult things to be done reliably and economically, in a way that nobody else can do.
🔑 Definition — Innovator's Dilemma: A concept by Christensen where weak signals indicating the emergence of new market opportunities, generally based on new technological capabilities, are unlikely to be picked up by concentrating on existing core customers.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The key takeaways from this lecture are that revolutionary change can be caused by gradual environmental or organizational creep as well as by discrete events like mergers, industry deregulation, or technological breakthroughs. Managing radical transformation requires a specific set of five competencies, starting with recognizing the challenge by overcoming five critical pre-action barriers. Once the challenge is recognized, a leader must select one of four generic transformational strategies, each with a distinct focus: reconfiguring the value stream, redefining the business's driving force, reconstructing its core competencies, or redefining its value proposition to customers. The concept of the "innovator's dilemma" is a crucial reminder that focusing too heavily on existing customers can blind a company to emerging opportunities, making it harder to define a new value proposition.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five types of causation for revolutionary change in Dunphy's typology? (Hint: Think about environmental, organizational, structural, industry, and technological sources of change.)
- Name and explain the three key variables that define "transformation" according to Francis and Bessant.
- What are the five "pre-action barriers" that prevent an organization from recognizing the need for transformative change?
- Describe one of the four generic transformational strategies. For example, what does it mean to "reconfigure the value stream"?
- According to Christensen's "innovator's dilemma," why can a focus on existing customers be a problem when a company needs to redefine its value proposition?
📘 Lecture 41 — Implementation: Radical or Transformative Change (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the Francis & Bessant model of managing radical change, focusing on the competencies required for extensive innovation, systematic change, and leadership processes. It explores how firms can move beyond "doing what we do better" to achieve transformational "do different" innovation, and highlights the paradoxes and challenges leaders must navigate during major transitions.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Stages III through V of the Francis & Bessant model: competency required for extensive innovation (distinguishing incremental vs. discontinuous innovation), competency to manage systematic change (proactive vs. unresponsive approaches to discontinuities), and competency to install leadership processes (managing paradoxes, avoiding wrong leadership choices). It concludes with research questions on organizational age, radical change, and survival.
📝 Lecture Summary
Stage III: Competency required for extensive innovation
Most innovation takes place within an established envelope of possibilities, usually following a "technological trajectory." When this occurs, change is possible in small or large increments but the overall boundary conditions remain relatively stable. For example, in studies of the bicycle, Roy and colleagues showed how the dominant design emerged in the mid-nineteenth century and remained the framework for innovation for the next century. Countless innovations have occurred in product modifications and process developments—today's bicycle is smoother, safer, cheaper, and available in different configurations. But all of this innovation has essentially been "doing what we do better" —the fundamental framework remains constant.
By contrast, the emergence of float glass represented a radical shift in how flat glass was made. For centuries, the basic envelope for product and process innovation was bounded by the principles of grinding and polishing. Pilkington's breakthrough innovation transformed the industry—and the company's fortunes with it. This exemplifies "do different" innovation that establishes a new dominant design—a new trajectory for development and a new envelope for exploring product and process innovations.
The journey to become more successfully innovative is not easy, especially in firms facing major discontinuities. Among the case companies studied, difficulties included:
• Failure of perception — Not recognizing the need to innovate. This can arise through isolation from key environmental signals (typically a small firm problem) or from insulation caused by a corporate "mindset" associated with particular historical strengths—core competencies can become what Leonard Barton (1995) calls "core rigidities".
• Inappropriate innovation — Recognizing the need to change but responding in ways that have poor strategic fit with the business or divert from more important ends. Firms may take changes but cannot support them—for example, the failure of the EMI Body scanner is attributed partly to a lack of suitable experience or competence in manufacturing and marketing complex high-tech products. Another common problem is adopting innovation as a result of following fashion rather than for clear strategic purposes.
• Episodic innovation — Recognizing the need but on an occasional basis, so intensive innovation effort is followed by a period of inactivity. The problem is maintaining continuity and ensuring a steady stream of innovation rather than pursuing a blockbuster approach.
• Emphasizing steady state innovation — Recognizing the need for and deploying innovation continuously, but where product and process innovations are essentially "doing what we do better" rather than transformational in intent.
Discontinuous innovation is qualitatively different from improvement-oriented approaches. These forms of innovation provide transformational change opportunities. The differences between incremental and discontinuous innovations are:
• Both the positive and/or negative impact of discontinuous innovation is greater. • Generally, discontinuous innovation requires destruction of mind-sets and other assets. • Discontinuous innovation requires entering into a psychological space with unknowns and uncertainties. • The risk element is high. • There are likely to be many trials and tribulations. • Distinctive skills are needed.
💡 Why this matters: Recognizing whether an innovation is incremental or discontinuous affects resource allocation, risk management, and the entire change approach a firm must adopt.
Stage IV: Competency to manage systematic change
Firms can be proactive with regard to discontinuities—they can actively seek to create them and thereby "re-write the rules of the competitive game." Alternatively, they can be unresponsive, being surprised by emerging developments and not maintaining their position within the new strategic opportunity space. Research indicates that firms need to develop strategic orientations and routines to help them cope not only with "steady state" innovation but also with discontinuity. Frequently, this requires change in multiple parts of the organization—i.e., systematic change.
One key requirement is a massive upgrading of an organization's capacity to be open to signals from the outside and be prepared to learn from "outside of the box." Consequently, there is often tension between groups tasked with radical change. The solution may require separation of the radical and steady state groups. New divisions and companies may need to be established, or frustrated staff with entrepreneurial skills may leave to set up their own organizations to pursue their radical vision. Key routines are required for activities like scanning the environment for signals to trigger innovation, managing the implementation of projects, and coordinating different knowledge sets. The solution sought for this problem is either in the form of Strategic Business Unit (SBU) or concepts like corporate entrepreneurship.
Stage V: Competency to install leadership process
Research suggests that a key to managing a successful transition is having the capacity to manage paradoxes. This requires a strength and subtlety of leadership that is comparatively rare. Leadership processes need to be capable of contextual adaptability and handling paradox.
The ten paradoxes outlined encapsulate "competing values" and can be characterized into "hard" and "soft," reawakening debates about the merits of androgyny as a guiding management philosophy. In brief, an organization's leaders need to be able to be both hard and soft, and most importantly, to know when each stance is best at a moment in time. In periods of transformational change, there is a need for attention, agility of mind, and wise judgment.
As Slatter (1984) showed, a common cause of corporate collapse is that the firm is led by a strong personality who does not listen to others. Research suggests a major risk in managing transitions is that "wrong people are chosen to lead".
The capacity to pursue apparently paradoxical principles, sometimes at the same time, appears especially important when sea-change is contemplated. Managers need to develop themselves, their processes, and adopt values that promote prudent, radical change. Without the capacity to manage paradoxes, a company in transition is in peril.
🔑 Definition — Paradoxes: Competing values that require leaders to be both hard and soft, knowing when each stance is appropriate. 📌 Example: A strong personality who does not listen to others (Slatter, 1984) is a common cause of corporate collapse during transitions—the wrong person chosen to lead during radical change.
Research Questions for Further Work
• Are older organizations less likely to undergo radical change? • Do they respond less quickly? • Does the occurrence of fundamental change decrease the probability of organizational survival? • Do slower responses to environmental shift increase the likelihood of survival?
💡 Why this matters: These questions invite critical, analytical thinking applied to Pakistani organizations, industry, and society, rather than mere description.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that the Francis & Bessant model's Stages III-V distinguish "doing what we do better" (incremental) from "do different" (discontinuous) innovation, with the latter requiring destruction of mind-sets and higher risk. The four common innovation failures are failure of perception, inappropriate innovation, episodic innovation, and overemphasis on steady-state innovation. To manage systematic change, firms must be proactive about discontinuities, separate radical from steady-state groups, and build routines for environmental scanning. Leadership during transformational change requires managing paradoxes—being both hard and soft—and avoiding strong personalities who don't listen, as this often causes corporate collapse. The research questions provided invite critical analysis of how organizational age, response speed, and fundamental change affect survival, specifically in the Pakistani context.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between "doing what we do better" innovation and "do different" innovation, and give an example of each from the lecture?
- List and briefly explain the four difficulties firms face when managing the journey to become more successfully innovative.
- What are the six characteristics that distinguish discontinuous innovation from incremental innovation?
- Why is the capacity to manage paradoxes considered a key competency for leadership during transformational change, and what risk arises when "wrong people are chosen to lead"?
- According to the lecture, what are two structural solutions (organizational forms) for managing the tension between radical and steady-state innovation groups?
📘 Lecture 42 — Implementation: Punctuated Equilibrium Model
📖 Overview: This lecture synthesizes the incremental and radical approaches to change implementation into an integrated Punctuated Equilibrium (PE) model. It explains how organizations progress through long periods of stable, incremental change punctuated by short, intense bursts of radical transformation, and presents key hypotheses about when and how such revolutionary change occurs.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture compares features of incremental versus radical change, introduces the Punctuated Equilibrium model as a synthesis developed by Tushman and Romanelli, defines momentum in organizational context, outlines four types of organizational change (fine tunings, incremental adjustment, modular transformation, corporate transformation), explains the theory and key attributes of the PE model, and presents five formal hypotheses that predict when revolutionary transformation will occur, including triggers like performance decline, environmental shifts, and new CEO installation.
📝 Lecture Summary
Implementation: Punctuated Equilibrium Model
The Punctuated Equilibrium (PE) model presents a synthesized version of the two approaches to implementation of change—incrementalism and radicalism. Scholars like Greiner, Miller & Freisen, and Tushman believe both approaches are complementary rather than conflicting, arguing the issue is not whether but when to adopt each type. They propose a lifecycle approach with dual features of stability and turbulence, drawing on Organization Life Cycle Theory, Greiner’s model, and Organizational Learning.
Features of incremental change include: unidirectional, continuous, constant learning, relevant at multiple levels, converging, and short-term based. Features of radical change include: multi-directional, discontinuous, periodic learning, relevant at upper echelon (top-level), frame-breaking, and long-term based.
The Punctuated Equilibrium Model (Tushman & Romanelli)
The PE model was developed by Tushman and Romanelli, who argued that organizations progress through convergent periods punctuated by re-orientations that demark and set bearings for the next convergent period. Convergent periods are relatively long spans of incremental change and adaptation, whereas re-orientations are relatively short periods of radical, discontinuous change.
🔑 Definition — Strategic Orientation: The configuration of five domains of organizational activity that together constitute the organization's strategic direction.
Change is theorized on five domains of organizational activity: culture, strategy, structure, power structure, and control system.
Momentum
Momentum refers to long periods of relatively stable, slow, and predictable organizational activity interspersed with short and intense periods of massive changes in momentum within the organization. According to Miller and Freisen, momentum involves long periods of maintenance of a given configuration, punctuated by brief periods of multi-faceted and concerted transition.
Four Types of Organizational Change (P-E Model)
- Fine tunings — ongoing process of finding fit or matches between strategies, structure, people, and processes.
- Incremental adjustment — based on Quinn's model of logical incrementalism.
- Modular transformation — major re-alignment of one or more departments or divisions.
- Corporate transformation — radical shift in strategy and revolutionary changes in the whole organization.
📌 Example: A company that annually adjusts its marketing strategy (fine tuning) but later completely restructures its entire organization after a major market disruption (corporate transformation) demonstrates both change types within the PE model.
💡 Why this matters: The purpose of organizational change is to move from one state to the desired state in different ways—either incremental or radical—and the PE model provides a framework for when each is appropriate.
Theory of P-E Model
The PE model has the following attributes:
- Enables predictions about patterns of fundamental organizational transformation
- Accounts for tension between the forces of stability and change
- Organizations establish an initial pattern of activity based on environmental conditions prevailing and managerial decisions made during their time of founding
- As a result of inertia and institutionalization, organizations develop coherent systems of shared understandings that support continuation of established patterns
- Therefore, radical and discontinuous change is necessary to break the inertia
Hypothesis 1: Organizational transformation will most frequently occur in short, discontinuous bursts of change involving most or all key domains of organizational activity.
PE theorists suggest the interdependence of organizational sub-units, arguing that organizations must be constructed to ensure complementary alignment among structural variables (buyers, suppliers, financial backers, pattern of culture, norms & ideology), as opposed to the incremental view that emphasizes relative independence of subunits dealing incrementally and disjointedly with one problem at a time.
Hypothesis 2: Small changes in individual domains of organizational activity will not accumulate incrementally to yield a fundamental transformation.
Triggers of Organizational Change
PE theorists believe resistance to change or organizational inertia can be broken through revolutionary transformation means and conditions.
Hypothesis 3: Major declines in short-term performance or sustained decline over several years will substantially increase the likelihood of revolutionary transformation.
Hypothesis 4: Major changes in environmental conditions will significantly increase the likelihood of revolutionary transformation.
Hypothesis 5: Installation of a new chief executive officer will significantly increase the likelihood of revolutionary transformation.
Indicators of Transformational Change
Fundamental organizational transformation occurs whenever substantial changes are observed in strategy, structure, and power distribution domains of organizational activity. Power distribution means appointment, key positions and placements, hiring-firing, and transfers.
📌 Example: When a struggling Pakistani public sector enterprise experiences three years of declining profits (triggering Hypothesis 3), a new CEO is appointed (Hypothesis 5), who then restructures the entire organization's strategy, hierarchy, and replaces senior leadership (demonstrating transformation in power distribution, strategy, and structure).
💡 Why this matters: To what extent these variables (strategy, structure, power distribution) are valid for change management in public or corporate sector organizations in Pakistan is a critical practical question.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The Punctuated Equilibrium model is the most comprehensive view of change implementation because it integrates both incremental and radical approaches, recognizing that organizations experience long convergent periods of stability punctuated by brief revolutionary re-orientations. The five key domains of organizational activity—culture, strategy, structure, power structure, and control system—form the strategic orientation that changes during transformation. Four types of change exist on a spectrum: fine tunings, incremental adjustment, modular transformation, and corporate transformation. The five hypotheses crucial for exam understanding are that transformation occurs in short discontinuous bursts (H1), small changes don't accumulate to fundamental transformation (H2), and triggers include performance decline (H3), environmental shifts (H4), and new CEO installation (H5). Fundamentally, PE theorists argue that inertia can only be broken through revolutionary, not incremental, means.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five domains of organizational activity in Tushman and Romanelli's Punctuated Equilibrium model?
- Explain the difference between a "convergent period" and a "re-orientation" in the PE model.
- What is "momentum" in organizational context according to Miller and Freisen?
- List and briefly describe the four types of organizational change in the PE model.
- According to Hypotheses 3, 4, and 5, what three conditions substantially increase the likelihood of revolutionary transformation?
📘 Lecture 43 — Change Implementation: OD Models
📖 Overview: This lecture examines two major models for implementing organizational change: the Organization Development (OD) model and the Burke-Litwin Model of Organizational Change. It distinguishes OD from Change Management (CM), traces the historical evolution of OD, and explains how transformational and transactional factors interact to drive organizational performance and change.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by reviewing three previously discussed implementation approaches (Logical Incrementalism, Transformational Change, and Punctuated Equilibrium Model), then defines and provides historical context for Organization Development, listing its common attributes. It subsequently introduces the Burke-Litwin Model, explaining its transformational and transactional factors, distinguishing between organizational climate and culture, and describing the model's twelve key variables and their causal relationships.
📝 Lecture Summary
Organization Development Model
The lecture first differentiates between Organization Development (OD) and Change Management (CM) . Though apparently parallel, OD primarily deals with internal organizational dynamics (sometimes called "Orgonomics"), while CM emerged as more comprehensive, handling both internal and external environments due to challenges like oil crises and regional wars starting in the early 1980s.
🔑 Definition — Organization Development (OD) : "A planned and sustained effort to apply behavioral science for system improvement, using reflexive and self-analytic methods." (Schmuck and Miles, 1971)
🔑 Definition — OD (alternative) : "A process of planned change, change of an organization's culture from one which avoids examination of social processes—especially decision making, planning, and communication—to one which institutionalizes and legitimizes this examination." (Burke and Herrnstein, 1972)
💡 Why this matters: Both definitions emphasize that change is deliberate, requires scientific techniques, and careful interplay among variables such as strategy, structure, technology, and leadership to achieve sustainability, productivity, and innovation.
Historical Context of Organization Development
The OD model achieved global success from post-World War II until the late 1970s, but had limitations: it worked effectively for organizations in the growth phase of business cycles but stagnated at late maturity. This led to the evolution of Change Management, which incorporated both internal and external environments.
This evolution caused a revolutionary shift from a scientific approach to a cultural approach in management. While Frederick W. Taylor believed in "one best way" and universal management principles, the new assumptions of empowerment, delegation, decentralization, and participative decision making nullify universalist claims. Concepts such as multiple-rationality, equi-finality, and multiculturalism show that management principles are culturally based—there are multiple ways of doing things.
Attributes of Organization Development Model
Common attributes found in almost every recognized OD model include:
- Assumptions of planned change
- A framework to diagnose problems
- A cause and effect linkage for visualizing problem domains
- Supremacy of the process for rectification or feedback loop
- Predictability or causality
Burke Litwin Model of Organizational Change
This model is based on organizational performance and change by exploring the interplay between organizational functioning and organizational change. Change is depicted in terms of both process and content, with particular emphasis on transformational versus transactional factors.
Transformational change occurs as a response to the external environment and directly affects organizational mission and strategy, leadership, and culture. Transactional factors are affected by structure, systems, management practices, and climate. Together, these factors affect motivation, which in turn affects performance. The model applies to both individual and organizational performance.
Transformational and Transactional Dynamics
The model shows how to create first-order change (transactional) and second-order change (transformational). The transformational variables (upper half of the model) are areas where alteration is caused by interaction with environmental forces and requires entirely new behavior sets. For most organizations, change is initiated by forces from the external environment, such as changes in competitive environment, government regulations, and technological breakthroughs.
The transactional variables (lower half of the model) involve alteration via relatively short-term reciprocity among people and groups—"You do this for me and I'll do that for you."
Organizational Climate and Organizational Culture
The model distinguishes between these two concepts:
🔑 Definition — Organizational Climate: People's perception and attitude strongly affected by organizational conditions (systems, structure, manager behavior). These perceptions are relatively easier to change because they are built on employees' reaction to current practices. The resultant psychological state can be good or bad, friendly or unfriendly, hard-working or easy going.
🔑 Definition — Organizational Culture: The relatively enduring set of values and norms that underlie a social system—a "meaning system" that allows members to attribute meanings to events. Changing culture is much more difficult than changing climate. Culture provides the framework (gauge) by which members perceive their work climate.
Day-to-day climate results from transactions around:
- Sense of direction: effect of mission's clarity or lack thereof
- Role and responsibility: effect of structure reinforced by manager practice
- Standards and commitment: effect of manager practice, reinforced by culture
- Fairness of rewards: effect of systems, reinforced by manager practice
- Focus on customer vs. internal pressures, standards of excellence: effect of culture, reinforced by other variables
The Model
The total of 12 boxes represents the most important organizational variables at three levels:
- Total system level: mission, strategy, culture
- Group/local work unit level: climate
- Individual level: motivation, individual needs and values, job-person match
A change in one box will eventually impact others. Though a causal model, reality is more circular (hologram idea). For example, culture has a stronger influence on systems than vice versa. Kerr and Slocum (1987) showed that corporate culture determines the type of reward system, but the reward system can also be used to help change culture.
For major organizational change to occur, the top transformational boxes represent the primary and significant levers. Examples include:
- (a) An acquisition where culture, leadership, and business strategy were dramatically different
- (b) A federal agency where mission, structure, and leadership changed but culture remained from the 1960s
- (c) A high-tech firm where leadership changed negatively, strategy was unclear, and internal politics became predominant
📐 Model Premise: Interventions directed toward structure, management practices, and systems (policies and procedures) result in first-order change (transactional).
📐 Model Premise: Interventions directed toward mission and strategy, leadership, and organizational culture result in second-order change (transformational).
🔑 Definition — Transformational Leaders: Those who inspire followers to transcend their self-interest for the good of the organization and who are capable of having a profound and extraordinary effect on their followers.
🔑 Definition — Transactional Leaders: Those who guide their followers in the direction of established goals by clarifying role and task requirements.
⭐ Key Takeaways
OD focuses on planned, behavioral science-based internal change but evolved into Change Management when external environmental challenges (oil crises, regional wars) made internal-only approaches insufficient. The Burke-Litwin Model distinguishes between transformational change (affecting mission, strategy, leadership, and culture—second-order change) and transactional change (affecting structure, systems, management practices, and climate—first-order change). Organizational climate (perceptions, easier to change) must be distinguished from organizational culture (enduring values and norms, harder to change). The model's 12 variables operate causally across system, group, and individual levels.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five common attributes of Organization Development models?
- Distinguish between organizational climate and organizational culture as defined in the Burke-Litwin Model.
- What type of change results from interventions directed toward structure, management practices, and systems?
- What type of change results from interventions directed toward mission, strategy, leadership, and culture?
- How do transformational leaders differ from transactional leaders according to the Burke-Litwin Model?