π Lecture 26 β Team Dynamics
π Overview: This lecture focuses on understanding teams, their dynamics, and the stages of group development. It explains the advantages and disadvantages of teams, how to measure their effectiveness, and why organizations increasingly rely on them. The lecture also categorizes different types of teams and highlights the characteristics of high-performance teams.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by defining team and teamwork, then explores the advantages and disadvantages of teams. It explains why organizations rely on teams and how team effectiveness is measured. The stages of group development (Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, Adjourning) are described in detail, including member concerns and behaviors at each stage. Different types of teams are covered, including project teams, problem-solving teams, self-managed work teams, cross-functional teams, and virtual teams, along with their characteristics and challenges. Finally, the benefits of teams and characteristics of high-performance teams are summarized.
π Lecture Summary
Team: A team is a formal work group in which there is a high level of interaction and interdependence among group members who work intensely together to achieve a common goal.
Teamwork is the process of people actively working together to accomplish common goals.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Having a Team: Advantages include: a wider range of knowledge, expertise and ideas; an effective way to build consensus; and an effective way to communicate complex information. Disadvantages include: blocking (members holding back the group's progress), dominant people who overshadow others, status differential (unequal power dynamics), and groupthink (the tendency for members to agree without critical thinking).
Why Rely on Teams: Compared with individuals working alone, teams tend to make better decisions and produce better products and services due to more knowledge and expertise. Organizations have turned to teams to better utilize employee talents. Management is looking for that positive synergy that will allow their organizations to increase performance. The extensive use of teams creates the potential for an organization to generate greater outputs with no increase in inputs. However, merely calling a group a team does not automatically increase its performance; we need to convert those groups into teams.
How Do We Measure Team Effectiveness?
Effective teams have confidence in themselves and believe they can succeedβthis is team efficacy. Success breeds success. Management can increase team efficacy by helping the team achieve small successes and through skill training. Small successes build team confidence. The greater the abilities of team members, the more likely the team will develop confidence and the capability to deliver that confidence.
Team effectiveness can be measured by: o Productivity o Cohesion o Learning/ growth & development o Integration with the rest of the organization.
Stages of Group Development
The classic model of group development describes five stages:
Forming β group members gather and try to get to know each other and establish a common understanding as they struggle to clarify group goals and determine appropriate behavior within the group. This is the initial entry of members to a group/team. Member concerns include: getting to know each other, discovering what is considered acceptable behavior, determining the groupβs real task, defining group rules, questions about purpose, approach-avoidance behavior, high drop-out possibility, and members seeking leadership. Relations are non-intimate.
Storming β characterized by considerable conflict. Group members resist being controlled by the group and disagree about who should lead, how to achieve objectives, or how much power the leader should have. This is the startup stage after the group is formed. Everybody gives their suggestion. It is a period of high emotionality and tension among group members. Member concerns include: dealing with outside demands, clarifying membership expectations, dealing with obstacles to group goals, understanding membersβ interpersonal styles, members testing others' strength, authority in the group being tested, a fluid status structure, and possible member ejection.
Norming β group members really start to feel that they belong to the group. They develop close ties with one another and start coming to points where most members agree. They feel a willingness to move forward. This is the point at which the group really begins to come together as a coordinated unit. Member concerns include: holding the group together, dealing with divergent views and criticisms, dealing with a premature sense of accomplishment, intensified interpersonal involvement, desire for group attention, member interdependence, dependence on the leader, increased trust, well-established norms, and rules, roles, and standards. There is a growing capacity to plan.
Performing β the group is ready to tackle group tasks and work toward achieving group goals. They actually start performingβthe real work gets accomplished in this stage. This marks the emergence of a mature, organized, and well-functioning team. Members deal with complex tasks and handle internal disagreements in creative ways. The primary challenge is to continue to improve relationships and performance. Key characteristics include: a sense that "our" group is special, acceptance of individual differences, people can be themselves, disagreement/conflict is OK, structure, roles, and norms are established and accepted, and teamwork utilizes the diverse strengths of members.
Adjourning β for temporary committees, teams, task forces, and similar groups that have a limited task to perform. After completing the task, they reach the adjourning stage. In this stage, the group prepares for its disbandment. Attention is directed toward wrapping up activities. Responses of group members vary: some are upbeat, basking in the groupβs accomplishments, while others may be depressed over the loss of camaraderie and friendships. This stage is particularly important for temporary groups/teams. A well-integrated group/team is able to disband when its work is finished, willing to work together in the future, and celebrates individual and collective accomplishments.
Other classifications describe these stages similarly: o Orientation (Forming) o Dissatisfaction (Storming) o Resolution (Norming) o Production (Performing) o Termination (in the case of temporary groups)
Types of Teams
Project Team: Is convened for a specific purpose and disbands after completing its task.
Problem-Solving Teams: Twenty years ago, teams were just beginning to grow in popularity and most took similar form. They are typically composed of 5β12 hourly employees from the same department who meet for a few hours each week to discuss ways of improving quality, efficiency, and the work environment. Members share ideas or offer suggestions on how work processes and methods can be improved. Rarely are they given the authority to unilaterally implement their suggested actions. One of the most widely practiced applications during the 1980s was quality circles.
Self-Managed Work Teams: Problem-solving teams did not go far enough in getting employees involved in work-related decisions and processes. This led to experimentation with truly autonomous teams. These groups of employees (typically 10β15 in number) perform highly related or interdependent jobs and take on many of the responsibilities of their former supervisors. This includes planning and scheduling of work, assigning tasks to members, collective control over the pace of work, making operating decisions, and taking action on problems. Fully self-managed work teams even select their own members and have the members evaluate each otherβs performance. As a result, supervisory roles become less important.
π‘ Why this matters: While business periodicals have documented successful applications of self-managed teams, caution is needed. Some organizations have been disappointed with results. Teams do not seem to work well during organizational downsizing. Overall research on the effectiveness of self-managed work teams has not been uniformly positive. While individuals on teams do tend to report higher levels of job satisfaction, they also sometimes have higher absenteeism and turnover rates. The effectiveness of self-managed teams is situationally dependent, and care needs to be taken when introducing them globally.
Cross-Functional Teams: These are teams made up of employees from about the same hierarchical level, but from different work areas, who come together to accomplish a task. Many organizations have used horizontal, boundary-spanning groups for years. For example, IBM created a large task force in the 1960sβmade up of employees from across departmentsβto develop the highly successful System 360. A task force is really nothing other than a temporary cross-functional team. The popularity of cross-discipline work teams exploded in the late 1980s. Cross-functional teams are challenging to manage.
Virtual Teams: The previous types of teams do their work face to face. Virtual teams use computer technology to tie together physically dispersed members in order to achieve a common goal. They allow people to collaborate online. Virtual teams can do all the things that other teams do. They can include members from the same organization or link an organizationβs members with employees from other organizations. They can convene for a few days to solve a problem, a few months to complete a project, or exist permanently.
The three primary factors that differentiate virtual teams are:
- The absence of verbal and nonverbal cues, which help clarify communication by providing increased meaning but arenβt available in online interactions.
- Limited social context; virtual teams often suffer from less social rapport and less direct interaction among members.
- The ability to overcome time and space constraints, allowing people who might otherwise never be able to collaborate to work together.
Summary of Team Types:
- Project Team: Convened for a specific purpose and disbands after completing its task.
- Cross-functional Team: Operates with members who come from different functional units of an organization.
- Quality Circle Team: Employees who meet periodically to discuss ways of improving work quality. A group of workers from the same functional area who meet regularly to uncover and solve work-related problems and seek work improvement opportunities.
- Self-Managing Teams: Work team having the authority to make decisions about how they share and complete their work.
- Virtual Teams: Work together and solve problems through computer-based interactions.
Teams can also be divided into Permanent or Temporary Teams. Permanent teams: Team-based departments, team-based organizations, quality circles. Temporary teams: A task force is a collection of people who come together to accomplish a specific goal. Once the goal has been accomplished, the task force is usually disbanded. Temporary teams are to solve problems. A standing committee or task groups are task forces that may be enduring (though members may change) or permanent in nature.
Benefits of Teams
Synergy (a type of process gain) occurs when members of a group/team working/acting together are able to produce more or better output than would have been produced by the combined efforts of each person acting alone.
Why Teams Are Good for Organizations: o More resources for problem solving o Improved creativity and innovation o Improved quality of decision making o Greater commitments to tasks o Increased motivation of members o Better control and work discipline o More individual need satisfaction
Characteristics of High Performance Teams:
o Clear goals o Results-driven structure o Competent team members o Unified commitments o Collaborative climate o Standards of excellence o Leadership
β Key Takeaways
Teams are formal work groups with high interaction and interdependence, and they offer advantages like broader knowledge and better decision-making, but also face disadvantages like groupthink and dominant personalities. The five key stages of group development are Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, and Adjourning, each with specific member concerns and behaviors that managers must recognize and address. Different types of teamsβproject, problem-solving, self-managed, cross-functional, and virtualβserve distinct organizational purposes and have unique characteristics, benefits, and challenges. Effective teams demonstrate team efficacy, and their performance is measured through productivity, cohesion, learning, and integration. High-performance teams are characterized by clear goals, competent members, a collaborative climate, and strong leadership.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five stages of group development, and what is the primary characteristic of each?
- What is the difference between a problem-solving team and a self-managed work team in terms of authority?
- What are the three primary factors that differentiate virtual teams from face-to-face teams?
- Define groupthink and explain why it is considered a disadvantage of teams.
- List at least four characteristics of high-performance teams.
π Lecture 27 β Building the Team
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the critical process of converting individuals into a high-performing team. It covers the responsibilities of team leaders and organizations, strategies for building team cohesion, and the key factors like work design, team composition, context, and process that affect team effectiveness. Understanding these elements is essential for leadership success in fostering collaborative and productive teams.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by emphasizing the need for leaders to turn individuals into team players through selection, training, and reward systems. It then covers team building as a leader's and organization's responsibility, including specific strategies for building teams. The main content details the four key factors affecting teams: work design (autonomy, task, feedback), team composition (ability, personality, roles, size, flexibility), context (resources, leadership, evaluation/rewards), and process (common purpose, goals, team worth, conflict management, avoiding social loafing). It concludes with practical steps for building a team and addressing weak links.
π Lecture Summary
Turning Individuals into Team Players
It starts with the selection of the right type of people, training them, and linking the performance with a proper reward system. βNONE OF US IS AS SMART AS ALL OF USβ is a key principle: when teams operate effectively, they can solve more problems, make better decisions and be more creative. Leadership success requires an understanding of group behavior and the ability to tap the constructive power of teams. Teams are described as "unique, dynamic, complex and ever changing" by Ken Blanchard.
Team Building
Team building involves several key steps: getting the right people, determining the challenge, preparing the team leader, training, adding value, and seeing the big picture. It also requires building and supporting the team through leadership skills, team building strategies, and team logistics.
Team Building: The Team Leaderβs Responsibility
A good team leader fosters communication among team members and seeks to build bonds among them (work together, meet together, get to know each other). They create a positive environment for collective problem solving and support, where differing opinions are valued but clear decisions can be reached. The leader is alert to cliques and bickering and acts to address them, maintaining an atmosphere where harassment is not acceptable. They also monitor individual staff members for signs of stress, provide basic support, model good stress management, and seek to base interactions on mutual respect, transparency, and partnership.
Team Building: The Organizational Responsibility
The organization plays a crucial role by identifying team-building skills as an essential qualification for prospective managers. It also trains staff and managers in teamwork skills (e.g., conflict management) and helps build team cohesion through common experiences like safety and security training. Finally, the organization regularly reviews team functioning and has policies to address the problems of dysfunctional teams and staff members who have difficulty functioning in their team.
Strategies for Team Building
Key strategies include: establishing common goals, understanding each other's roles in the team, finding occasions to celebrate, recognizing effort, and improving communication.
Factors Affecting Teams
There are four main categories of factors: Work Design, Team Composition, Context, and Process.
π Definition β Work Design: The structure of a job or task that influences a team's performance. Its essential ingredients are autonomy, the task itself, and the feedback system in the organization.
π Definition β Team Composition: The mix of individuals that make up a team. Its essential components include the members' abilities, personalities matching the task, clear role identification, the size of the team, and the flexibility within their working relationships.
π Definition β Context: The broader organizational environment that supports the team. This includes available resources, effective leadership, and a performance evaluation and rewards system.
π Definition β Process: The internal dynamics and interactions of the team that affect its performance. This includes having a common purpose, specific goals, a sense of team worth, effective conflict management, and avoiding social loafing (the tendency of individuals to exert less effort when working in a group).
Building the Team (Practical Steps)
- Get them together.
- Keep them informed β vacuums tend to fill with negativity.
- Keep them involved β make it their project too.
- Ensure everyone sees themselves and understands their role in the βnew worldβ.
- Donβt focus on differences, focus on similarities.
- Add value to individuals and you multiply team effectiveness.
- Impart spiritual life on a daily basis.
- Value added to cohesion stimulates synergism.
- Remove ineffective members.
- Define purpose and timeline.
- Have regular review against goals.
- Begin with smaller assignments and test at higher levels.
Addressing a Weak Link
A weak link can destroy a team. The process involves:
- Stronger members identify the link.
- Stronger members have to help.
- Stronger members begin to resent.
- Stronger members become less effective.
- Stronger members begin to question the leaderβs ability.
Facts a leader must accept: not everyone will or can take the journey; some will not work on personal weaknesses, will not work with the rest of the team, or cannot fulfill the expectations of their area. As a leader, you are a catalyst within the team to:
- Increase the value of every member.
- Increase individual commitment to shared values.
- Remind them of the Big Picture.
- Uplift other team members.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding how weak links erode team morale and effectiveness is critical. The leader's role is to proactively address these issues by being a catalyst, not just a manager.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical learning is that building a team requires a deliberate, multi-faceted effort from both the leader and the organization, starting with selecting the right people and providing proper training and rewards. A leader must foster communication, build bonds, and create a positive environment for problem-solving, while the organization must train staff, build cohesion, and review team functioning. The four key factorsβwork design, team composition, context, and processβall significantly impact team effectiveness, and leaders must actively manage each. Finally, a leader must accept the reality of weak links, address them decisively, and act as a catalyst to increase value, commitment, and unity within the team.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three critical components of work design that affect team performance?
- Explain the five essential components of team composition.
- What is "social loafing," and why is it important to avoid it as part of the team process?
- According to the lecture, what is the primary negative impact of a "weak link" on the stronger members of a team?
- What are the three main ways the organization is responsible for supporting team building?
π Lecture 28 β A Team-Based Organization
π Overview: This lecture explores the transition from traditional hierarchical structures to team-based organizations. It covers the fundamentals of organizational structure, including departmentalization, span of control, formalization, and centralization, and contrasts mechanistic and organic models. The lecture emphasizes the significant benefits of teams, provides a checklist for implementation, and outlines the leader's crucial role in fostering a team-based environment.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining a team-based organization and contrasting its characteristics with traditional structures. It then delves into the basics of organizational structure, including key design elements like departmentalization, span of control, formalization, and centralization. The discussion moves to a comparison of mechanistic and organic organizational models, followed by an extensive list of the benefits of teams in organizations. Finally, the lecture provides a practical checklist for implementing team-based working, identifies potential pitfalls, and defines the critical roles a leader must play in a team-based organization.
π Lecture Summary
Team Based Organization
Implementing a team-based approach to organizational structure can empower employees and increase cooperation among different skills and disciplines. This approach is based on the belief that organizational goals will be achieved by groups of people who share responsibility for outcomes and who work efficiently and effectively in teams. These processes require highly developed communication competencies from all team members. Team skills are usually divided into two categories: task roles and maintenance roles.
Characteristics of Traditional Vs Team-based Organizations
The lecture provides a comparison between traditional and team-based organizations across several dimensions. Traditional organizations have individual command structures where the manager controls, whereas team-based organizations have collective structures where the team monitors. Traditional structures are characterized by vertical hierarchy, stability, uniformity, and a 'one best way' philosophy, while team-based structures feature horizontal integration, change, flexibility, and organization-specific approaches. In traditional structures, managers manage; in team-based structures, self-managing teams are prevalent.
Traditional vs. Best Place to Work Changes
To understand this shift, we need to understand the basic concept of organizational structure.
The Basics of Organizational Structure:
- Organizational structure defines how job tasks are formally divided, grouped, and coordinated.
- The organization chart is a visual representation of this division, grouping, and coordination.
- Organizational Structure: This is the formal setup of task and authority relationships. Structure controls the coordination of activities and employee motivation to attain goals. Structure must be continually evaluated. The formal structure shows the intended configuration of positions, job duties, and the lines of authority among different parts of the enterprise.
Designing an Organization Structure:
Organization design is the process by which leaders/managers select and manage aspects of organizational structure so that an organization can achieve its goals.
Basic Steps:
- Leaders/Managers must decide how to divide the overall tasks of the organization into successively smaller jobs.
- Leaders/Managers must decide the basis by which to group the individual jobs.
- Leaders/Managers must decide the appropriate size of the group reporting to each supervisor.
- Leaders/Managers must distribute authority among the jobs.
Departmentalization:
Departmentalization is the bedrock of horizontal differentiation. It begins when one person assumes a functional task. As others assume specialized roles, a functional structure emerges, with people placed in groups based on common skills or common use of resources.
Span of Control
To avoid becoming too tall, an organization can increase the span of control, which is the number of subordinates a manager directly oversees. Different companies have different spans of control. A managerβs span of control is limited to the number of subordinates that can be adequately supervised. An increase in subordinates exponentially increases the subordinate relationships to be managed. A manager with two subordinates manages three relationships, but a manager with three subordinates manages six. If the span of control becomes too wide, a manager loses control over subordinates. π Formula: [Number of relationships = n(2^n-1 + n - 1) or similar geometric progression] β As the number of direct reports (n) increases, the number of potential relationships to manage grows much faster, increasing managerial complexity. π Example: A manager with 2 subordinates manages 3 relationships. With 3 subordinates, this jumps to 6 relationships.
Formalization:
The use of written rules and procedures to standardize operations is known as formalization. If formalization and standardization are extensive, there is no room for mutual adjustment. Employees are held accountable for following rules.
Centralization:
When top managers make decisions, authority is centralized. When lower-level managers make decisions, authority is decentralized.
Organizational Design Decisions:
The lecture contrasts two primary types of organizations:
Mechanistic Organization: A rigid and tightly controlled structure characterized by high specialization, rigid departmentalization, narrow spans of control, high formalization, and a limited information network (downward).
Organic Organization: A highly flexible and adaptable structure characterized by non-standardized jobs, a fluid team-based structure, little direct supervision, minimal formal rules, and an open communication network.
Mechanistic vs. Organic Models Mechanistic structures influence people to behave in a predictable manner. Decision making is highly centralized and roles are clearly defined. Organic structures encourage flexibility and decentralize decision making. Roles are loosely defined. Employees perform many tasks and work with people from various functions. Strategic planning assumes that the old structure may not work in the new realities. It demands the organization think in terms of new approaches to solving existing and potential issues.
Benefits of Teams in Organizations:
- Enhanced Performance: Teams may take many forms, including improved productivity, quality, and customer service. These enhancements result from pooling individual efforts in new ways and continuously striving to improve for the benefit of the team.
- Employee Benefits: Teams provide the sense of self-control, human dignity, identification with work, and sense of self-worth and self-fulfillment for which current workers seem to strive.
- Reduced Costs: Through empowered teams, an organization can reduce scrap, make fewer errors, file fewer worker compensation claims, and reduce absenteeism and turnover, resulting in significant cost reductions.
- Organizational Enhancements: Improvements in team results move from a hierarchically based, directive culture to a team-based culture, including increased innovation, creativity, and flexibility in the organization.
Research indicates team-based organizations generally outperform more hierarchically organized structures in terms of product and service output, less absenteeism, fewer industrial accidents, more worker flexibility, quality improvements, and overall employee job satisfaction.
Benefits of Team-based Organization:
Profitability and long-term viability of an organization is increased due to its working as a team-based organization. Other benefits include:
- Efficient Process
- Flexible Response to change
- Improve Effectiveness
- Reduce Cost
- Increase Innovation
- Customer Involvement
- Employee commitment
- Skill utilization
Checklist for Team Based Working/ Organization Implementation Plan:
- To what extent does the senior management team agree with the team-based working philosophy?
- To what extent does the organization need team-based working to achieve its goals?
- Are team-based working practices already in place in some parts of the organization? If so, where?
- Where should we start? (Whole organization, one area, with well functioning teams?)
- How do we move on from where we are now?
- What major changes need to take place?
- What resources do we need?
Possible Pitfalls in the Introduction of Team Based Organization (TBO)
- Introducing teams regardless of need
- Introducing teams without changing systems
- Failing to train for TBO
- Not providing expert support
- Failure of communication within, with and between teams
- Failure to establish and support TBO objectives
Roles of a Leader in the Team-Based Organization
- Defining the teamβs mission
- Building trust and inspiring teamwork
- Coaching team members and group members toward higher levels of performance
- Serving as a model of teamwork, including power sharing
- Facilitating and supporting teamβs decisions
- Expanding the teamβs capabilities
- Creating a team identity
- Emphasizing pride in being outstanding
- Anticipating and influencing change
- Inspiring the team toward higher levels of performance
- Enabling and empowering group members to accomplish their work
- Selecting team-oriented members
- Using technology that facilitates teamwork
Fostering Teamwork Through Organization Structure or Policy:
- Designing physical structures that facilitate communication
- Emphasizing Team recognition and rewards
- Initiating ritual and ceremony
β Key Takeaways
This lecture presents a fundamental shift from traditional, mechanistic organizational structures to more flexible, team-based, organic structures. Key design elements to understand are departmentalization, span of control (and its geometric impact on relationships), formalization, and centralization. The core premise is that team-based organizations offer significant benefits in performance, employee satisfaction, cost reduction, and innovation. However, successful implementation requires a deliberate process, avoiding common pitfalls like introducing teams without changing support systems. Finally, the leader's role in a team-based organization is not to command but to coach, empower, build trust, and foster a team identity.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key differences between a mechanistic and an organic organization in terms of structure, decision-making, and formalization?
- Explain the concept of 'span of control' and why an increase in the number of subordinates can be challenging for a manager.
- List four major benefits that a team-based organization can offer compared to a traditional hierarchical structure.
- What is the distinction between a 'task role' and a 'maintenance role' within a team?
- Describe at least three specific roles a leader must perform in a team-based organization that differ from a traditional manager's role.
π Lecture 29 β Decision Making
π Overview: This lecture explores the nature of decision making in leadership and management, distinguishing it from problem solving. It covers the categories and types of decisions, the conditions under which decisions are made, the structured eight-step decision-making process, and various approaches and roadblocks to effective decision making. Understanding this process is critical for managers because every action they take involves some form of decision.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining decision making and the decision-making process, then contrasts problem solving with decision making. It categorizes decisions (technical, emotional, communication, etc.) and distinguishes between programmed, non-programmed, and intuitive decisions. Decision-making conditions (certainty, risk, uncertainty) are examined, followed by a detailed breakdown of the eight-step decision-making process. The lecture also covers quantitative and qualitative factors, the classical model, decision-making behavior, approaches (withdrawing, smoothing, compromising, confronting, forcing), and workplace decision types. It concludes with how to make better decisions, helpful hints, roadblocks (cognition, perception, bias), and the role of technology.
π Lecture Summary
Decision Making and Decision Making Process
A decision is a choice made from two or more alternatives. The decision-making process is recognizing and defining the nature of a decision situation, identifying alternatives, choosing the "best" alternative, and putting it into practice. An effective decision is one that optimizes some set of factors such as profits, sales, employee welfare, and market share. Managers make decisions about both problems and opportunities.
π Definition β Decision: a choice made from two or more alternatives. π Definition β Effective Decision: a decision that optimizes a set of factors (e.g., profits, sales, employee welfare, market share).
Problem Solving Vs Decision Making
Problem solving involves finding the root cause of a deviation (cause analysis), while decision making involves choosing from alternative courses of action (choice analysis). The sequence flows from problem solving to decision making.
π Definition β Problem Solving: finding the root cause of a deviation (cause analysis). π Definition β Decision Making (choosing): choosing from alternative courses of action (choice analysis).
Categories of Decisions
Decisions can be categorized by their nature: Technical, Emotional, Communication, Budget, Ethical, Personnel, and Career. Each category carries a different level of relative importance depending on the context.
Types of Decisions
Programmed Decisions are fairly structured decisions or recur with some frequency. Example: Starting your car in the morning. Non-programmed decisions are relatively unstructured and occur much less often. Example: Choosing a vacation destination. Intuitive decision making is a subconscious process of making decisions on the basis of experience and accumulated judgment. Making decisions on the basis of gut feeling doesn't necessarily happen independently of rational analysis; the two complement each other. Although intuitive decision making will not replace the rational decision-making process, it does play an important role in managerial decision making.
π Definition β Programmed Decision: a fairly structured decision or one that recurs with some frequency. π Definition β Non-programmed Decision: a relatively unstructured decision that occurs much less often. π Definition β Intuitive Decision Making: a subconscious process of making decisions on the basis of experience and accumulated judgment.
Decision-Making Conditions
There are three primary conditions: Decision Making Under Certainty is a condition where the decision maker knows with reasonable certainty what the alternatives are and what conditions are associated with each alternative. Few managerial decisions are made under certainty. Decision Making Under Risk is a condition where the availability of each alternative and its potential payoffs and costs are all associated with risks. Decision Making Under Uncertainty is a condition where the decision maker does not know all the alternatives, the risks associated with each, or the consequences of each alternative. The choice of alternative is influenced by the limited amount of information and the psychological orientation of the decision maker.
π Definition β Decision Making Under Certainty: a condition where the decision maker knows with reasonable certainty the alternatives and their associated conditions; outcomes are known. π Definition β Decision Making Under Risk: a condition where each alternative and its potential payoffs and costs are associated with risks. π Definition β Decision Making Under Uncertainty: a condition where the decision maker does not know all alternatives, risks, or consequences and cannot make reasonable probability estimates.
The Decision-Making Process
This is an eight-step process: Step 1: Identifying a problem. A problem is a discrepancy between an existing and a desired state of affairs. Three characteristics must be recognized: (1) The manager must be aware of the problem, identifying the actual problem rather than a symptom; (2) the manager must be under pressure to act; (3) the manager must have the authority or resources to act. Step 2: Identifying decision criteria. Decision criteria define what is relevant in a decision. Step 3: Allocating weights to the criteria. Not all criteria have equal importance, so the decision maker must assign a weight to each to give accurate priority. Step 4: Developing alternatives. The decision maker identifies viable alternatives that could resolve the problem. Step 5: Analyzing alternatives. Each alternative is critically evaluated against the criteria established in Steps 2 and 3. Step 6: Selecting an alternative. The decision maker selects the best alternative, often the one that received the highest score in Step 5. Step 7: Implementing the alternative. The chosen alternative is implemented by communicating the decision effectively and winning commitment from those affected. Step 8: Evaluating results. The final step assesses whether the problem has been resolved.
π Definition β Problem: a discrepancy between an existing and a desired state of affairs. π Definition β Decision Criteria: criteria that define what is relevant in a decision.
Evaluating Alternatives in the Decision-Making Process
Quantitative Factors include tools like investment appraisal, break-even analysis, market research, sales forecasting, critical path analysis, and decision trees. Qualitative Factors include stakeholder analysis, HRM, and SWOT analysis.
The Classical Model of Decision Making
The Classical model is based on economic conditions and considered normative. It relates to accomplishing goals that are known and agreed upon. It strives for certainty by gathering complete information, and this information is also used as criteria for evaluating alternatives that are known.
π Definition β Classical Model: a normative model of decision making based on economic conditions, striving for certainty with complete information.
Decision Making Behavior
Behavior varies from person to person. People adopt a particular approach based on factors such as: their own personality, their current mood, the organisational culture, the personality of others involved, the nature of their relationship with others, and time pressure/perceived stress. Being aware of these influences can result in better decision making.
Decision Making Approaches
The five main approaches are: Withdrawing (holding off making the decision), Smoothing (focusing on areas of agreement and ignoring differences), Compromising (trying to find a decision that provides some degree of satisfaction for all parties), Confronting/problem solving (working through the issues), and Forcing (executing a particular decision knowing agreement has not been reached).
π Definition β Withdrawing: holding off making the decision. π Definition β Smoothing: focusing on areas of agreement and ignoring areas of difference. π Definition β Compromising: trying to come up with a decision that provides some degree of satisfaction for all parties. π Definition β Confronting/Problem Solving: working through the issues. π Definition β Forcing: executing a particular decision knowing agreement has not been reached.
What Kinds Of Decisions Do People Make In The Workplace?
Decisions in the workplace include: handling complex problems individually, handling complex problems as a team, focusing effort, and judging people.
How to Make Better Decisions
Four key strategies: Increase Your Knowledge by asking questions, gaining experience, using consultants, doing research, and forcing yourself to recognize facts with objectivity. Use Your Intuition, a cognitive process whereby a person instinctively makes a decision based on accumulated knowledge and experience. Weigh the Pros and Cons by quantifying realities and considering the relative importance of each objective. Don't Overstress the Finality of Your Decision, as few decisions are forever. Make Sure the Timing Is Right, as decisions always depend on the time.
Helpful Hints
The "Don't Do" list includes: making assumptions, delaying, jumping to conclusions, making uninformed decisions, favoring one decision prior to gathering facts, allowing only technical people to decide, attempting to decide in isolation, and letting emotion override objectivity. The "Do" list includes: clearly identifying the decision, involving qualified people, identifying the context (bigger picture), identifying all alternatives, assessing each alternative, assessing risks, considering your "gut feel", and making the decision and sticking to it.
Roadblocks to Good Decision Making
Key roadblocks are: Human Cognition (our mental ability to comprehend and understand), Human Perception (difficulty isolating problems, tendency to think of a narrow range of solutions), and Human Bias (tendency to shape responses based on stereotypes, memory, and current position).
π Definition β Human Cognition: our mental ability to comprehend and understand something. π Definition β Human Perception: difficulty isolating problems; tendency to think of only a narrow range of possible solutions. π Definition β Human Bias: tendency to shape responses based on stereotypes, memory, and current position.
Decision-Making and Technology
Information technology can support decision making. Different decision-making tools are available for managers and leaders to use in practical life. π‘ Why this matters: Technology can process large amounts of data, run simulations, and provide analytical support that humans alone cannot, thereby improving decision quality.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that decision making is a structured eight-step process, not a haphazard act, and managers must distinguish between programmed and non-programmed decisions, and between certainty, risk, and uncertainty conditions. Intuition complements rational analysis and should not be dismissed. Key roadblocks to avoid are biases, narrow perception, and cognitive limitations. Finally, incorporating both quantitative and qualitative factors, along with technology, leads to more robust decisions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between problem solving and decision making?
- List the eight steps in the decision-making process.
- What are the three conditions under which decisions are made, and what distinguishes each?
- Name and briefly describe the five decision-making approaches.
- What are the three main roadblocks to good decision making?