📘 Lecture 45 — Seven Practices of Successful Organizations
📖 Overview: This lecture identifies seven key practices that characterize successful organizations. It explains why these practices are essential for building high-performance work systems and how they contribute to long-term organizational success. The lecture provides concrete examples from companies like Southwest Airlines, Lincoln Electric, and Whole Foods to illustrate each practice in action.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers seven dimensions of successful organizations: employment security, selective hiring, self-managed teams and decentralization, high compensation contingent on organizational performance, extensive training, reduction of status differences, and sharing information. Each practice is explained with its benefits, implementation strategies, and real-world examples from successful companies.
📝 Lecture Summary
1. Employment Security
Employment security is a critical element of high-performance management systems. Research shows that innovations in work practices or worker-management cooperation are not likely to be sustained when workers fear job loss. Lincoln Electric, a successful arc welding manufacturer, began offering guaranteed employment to workers after three years on the job and has not had a layoff since 1948. During a recession in the early 1980s when domestic sales fell 40%, the company redeployed factory workers to sales roles instead of laying them off, which increased market share and penetration.
Employment security provides numerous benefits beyond encouraging workers to contribute knowledge and effort to enhance productivity. It decreases the likelihood of firms laying off employees too quickly during downturns, which protects strategic assets from being picked up by competitors. The Vice President for People at Southwest Airlines viewed people as strategic assets rather than costs, stating, “Why would we want to put our best assets, our people, in the arms of the competition?”
Employment security policies lead to more careful and leaner hiring because firms know they cannot simply let people go if they overestimated labor demand. This makes the workforce more productive, with fewer people doing more work. Furthermore, employment security maintained over time helps build trust between people and their employer, leading to more cooperation, forbearance in pressing for wage increases, and better company spirit.
Employment security also encourages people to take a longer-term perspective on their jobs and organization performance. A study of 192 banks found that “The greater the employment security given to a loan officer, the greater the returns to banks.” With employment security, loan officers worry about repayment prospects and building customer relationships rather than just booking loans.
It is important to note that employment security does not mean retaining people who don’t perform or work effectively with others. Lincoln Electric has high turnover for employees in their first few months, as those who don’t fit the company culture leave. Southwest will fire people who don’t provide the customer service the firm is known for. Employment security means employees are not put on the streets for things over which they have no control, such as economic downturns or senior management’s strategic mistakes.
🔑 Definition — Employment Security: A policy where organizations commit to maintaining total employment levels, protecting workers from layoffs due to economic downturns or management mistakes, while still holding individuals accountable for their own performance and behavior. 📐 Formula: Employment Security = Long-term Job Commitment + Performance Accountability 📌 Example: Lincoln Electric guaranteed employment after three years, and during the 1980s recession with 40% sales decline, they redeployed factory workers to sales roles instead of laying them off. This maintained market share and productivity gains.
2. Selective Hiring
Successful organizations ensure they recruit the right people in the first place. This requires several things:
First, the organization needs to have a large applicant pool from which to select. In 1993, Southwest Airlines received about 98,000 applications, interviewed 16,000, and hired 2,700. Singapore Airlines is extremely careful and selective; from an initial pool of candidates, about 10% are short-listed and only 2% (one out of 50) are selected.
Second, the organization needs to be clear about what are the most critical skills and attributes needed in its applicant pool. The notion of trying to find “good employees” is not helpful; organizations need to be as specific as possible about the precise attributes they are seeking. At Southwest Airlines, applicants for flight attendants are evaluated on initiative, judgment, adaptability, and their ability to learn.
Third, the skills and abilities hired need to be carefully considered and consistent with the particular job requirements and the organization’s approach to its market. Simply hiring “the best and the brightest” may not make sense in all circumstances. Enterprise Rent-A-Car hires college graduates primarily for their sales skills and personality, not their academic performance.
Fourth, organizations should screen primarily on important attributes that are difficult to change through training and should emphasize qualities that actually differentiate among those in the applicant pool. Japanese organizations have long hired more on the basis of basic ability and attitudes than on specific technical skills, which are much more easily acquired. At Southwest Airlines, a top pilot from another airline was rejected because he was rude to a receptionist, as Southwest believes technical skills are easier to acquire than a teamwork and service attitude.
Firms serious about selection put applicants through several rounds of interviews and a rigorous selection procedure. A manufacturing company in the US could take as long as six months or more. This ensures careful scrutiny, develops commitment in those hired, and promotes a feeling of being part of an elite group, causing them to enter the organization with high motivation and spirit.
Rigorous selection requires a method refined and developed over time through feedback and learning. At Southwest Airlines, the company tracks who has interviewed job applicants and assesses what interviewers saw or missed. Sources of applicants, scores on tests, and interview ratings must be validated against subsequent performance to improve the effectiveness of the process over time.
🔑 Definition — Selective Hiring: A recruitment approach that emphasizes finding applicants with the right attitudes, values, and cultural fit rather than just specific technical skills, using rigorous multiple-round selection processes from a large applicant pool. 📐 Formula: Selective Hiring = Large Applicant Pool + Clear Attribute Requirements + Rigorous Screening + Feedback Validation 📌 Example: Southwest Airlines received 98,000 applications, interviewed 16,000, and hired only 2,700. They rejected a top pilot who was rude to a receptionist because they value teamwork and service attitude over technical skills.
3. Self-Managed Teams and Decentralization as Basic Elements of Organizational Design
Organizing people into self-managed teams is a critical component of virtually all high-performance management systems. Workers in self-managed teams enjoy greater autonomy and discretion, which translates into intrinsic rewards and job satisfaction.
Teams offer several advantages:
First, teams substitute peer-based for hierarchical control of work. Instead of management devoting time and energy to controlling the workforce directly, workers control themselves. Peer control is frequently more effective than hierarchical supervision. Someone may disappoint their supervisor, but they are much less likely to let down their mates. This creates enormous peer pressure against absenteeism.
World Food Markets has a team-oriented philosophy where each store is a profit center with about ten self-managed teams. Team leaders in each store are a team, store leaders in each region are a team, and the company’s six regional presidents are a team. Teams must approve hires for full-time jobs by a two-thirds vote, normally after a thirty-day trial period. Pressure for performance comes from peers rather than from headquarters.
Second, teams permit employees to pool their ideas to come up with better and more creative solutions to problems. This involves pooling ideas and expertise to increase the likelihood that at least one member will come up with a way of addressing the problem. In the group setting, each participant can build on others’ ideas.
Third, by substituting peer for hierarchical control, teams permit removal of layers of hierarchy and absorption of administrative tasks previously performed by specialists. This avoids the enormous costs of having people whose sole job is to watch people who watch other people do the work. The AES Corporation has never formed corporate departments or assigned officers to oversee project finance, operations, purchasing, human resources, or public relations. These functions are handled at the plant level where plant managers assign them to volunteer teams. The organization has only five levels, and the company developed a $400 million plant with a team of just ten people.
🔑 Definition — Self-Managed Teams: Work groups that operate with autonomy and discretion, using peer-based control instead of hierarchical supervision to manage work, solve problems, and make decisions. 📐 Formula: Self-Managed Teams = Autonomy + Peer Control + Hierarchy Reduction + Creative Problem-Solving 📌 Example: AES Corporation developed a $400 million plant with just ten people, using self-managed teams that handle finance, operations, and other functions typically managed by corporate departments.
4. High Compensation Contingent on Organizational Performance
While labor markets are not perfectly efficient, some relationship exists between what a firm pays and the quality of the workforce it attracts. The level of salaries sends a message to the firm’s workforce – they are truly valued or they are not.
When John Whitney assumed leadership of Pathmark, a large grocery store chain in the US, the company was in desperate financial shape. He found that 120 store managers were paid terribly, so he gave them a substantial raise of about 40 to 50%. The subsequent success of the chain was because store managers could now focus on improving performance instead of worrying about their pay.
Contingent compensation figures importantly in most high-performance work systems. Such compensation can take several forms: gainsharing, stock ownership, pay for skill, or various forms of individual or team incentives. Many successful companies encourage share ownership because when employees are owners, they act and think like owners.
Pay for skill acquisition encourages people to learn different jobs and become more flexible. Gainsharing differs from profit sharing in that it is based on incremental improvements in the performance of a specific unit. If a plant becomes more efficient, the people share in the economic gains even if profits in the firm as a whole are down.
Contingent compensation helps motivate effort because people know they will share in the results of their work. At Whole Foods, a gainsharing program ties bonuses directly to team performance, specifically sales per hour.
💡 Why this matters: Coupling employment security with group-based incentives like profit or gainsharing prevents employment security from becoming like civil service where people just mark time. The organization unleashes the power of the team whose economic interests align with higher levels of economic performance.
🔑 Definition — Contingent Compensation: A pay system that ties employee rewards to organizational or team performance through mechanisms such as gainsharing, stock ownership, and pay for skill. 📐 Formula: Contingent Compensation = Performance-Based Pay + Group Incentives + Employee Ownership 📌 Example: Pathmark gave store managers a 40-50% raise when the company was in financial trouble, allowing them to focus on improving performance instead of worrying about pay.
5. Training
Virtually all descriptions of high-performance management practices emphasize training, and the amount of training provided by commitment-oriented management systems is substantial. Training is essential because these systems rely on front-line employee skill and initiative to identify and resolve problems, initiate changes in work methods, and take responsibility for quality.
The difference in training reflects different views of people held by different firms. Japanese firms train a lot because they rely heavily on flexible production and intend to keep their people longer, making it sensible to invest more in developing them. US-owned plants train very little because they follow traditional mass production practices.
Studies of firms in the US and the UK consistently provide evidence of inadequate levels of training focused on the wrong things: special skills rather than generalist competence and organizational culture.
Successful firms that emphasize training do so almost as a matter of faith and because of their belief in the connection between people and profits. Taco Inc. , a privately owned manufacturer of pumps and valves with annual sales under $100 million, offers employees more than six dozen courses in an on-site learning center. It cost $250,000 to build the center and annual direct expenses and lost production cost about $300,000. When asked to put a monetary value on the return, the CEO said, “It comes back in the form of attitude.”
🔑 Definition — Training: Investment in employee skill development that focuses on generalist competence and organizational culture rather than just specific technical skills, essential for high-performance work systems. 📐 Formula: Training Investment = Employee Skill Development + Long-term Commitment + Competitive Advantage 📌 Example: Taco Inc. spent $250,000 to build a learning center and $300,000 annually for courses, with returns coming in the form of improved employee attitude and organizational performance.
6. Reduction of Status Differences
High-performance management systems can perform only when they tap the ideas, skills, and efforts of all their people. One way to do this is to organize people in teams. But neither individuals nor teams will feel comfortable or encouraged to contribute if they feel undervalued.
Reduction of status differences is accomplished in two principal ways: symbolically, through language, labels, physical space, and dress; and substantively, through reduction of wage inequality across levels.
At Subaru-Isuzu, everyone from the company president down was called an Associate. At Kingston Technology, with 1994 sales of $2.7 million per employee (higher than Exxon, Intel, or Microsoft), the two co-founders sit in open cubicles and have no private secretaries.
The reduction of status differences encourages open communication, which is necessary in an organization where learning and adaptation are encouraged. Status differences are reduced and a sense of common fate is developed by limiting the difference between senior management and other employees.
The CEO of Southwest Airlines, who had been on the cover of Fortune, earned about $500,000 per year. When the company negotiated a five-year wage freeze with its pilots, he agreed to fix his basic salary at $395,000 a year for four years.
Practices that reduce status differences are consistent with rewards contingent on performance, as long as these contingent rewards are applied on a group or organizational level so that the benefits of performance are not awarded to the few. Reducing wage inequality does limit the organization’s ability to use individual incentives, but this is not necessarily a bad thing. Contingent rewards provided at the group or organizational level are at least as effective as individual incentives and avoid many problems inherent in individual merit or incentive pay.
🔑 Definition — Reduction of Status Differences: Practices that minimize hierarchical distinctions through symbolic measures (language, dress, physical space) and substantive measures (reduced wage inequality) to encourage open communication and a sense of common purpose. 📐 Formula: Status Reduction = Symbolic Equality + Wage Compression + Open Communication + Common Fate 📌 Example: Kingston Technology co-founders sit in open cubicles with no private secretaries, despite the company having higher revenue per employee than Exxon, Intel, or Microsoft.
7. Sharing Information
Information sharing is an essential component of high-performance work systems for two reasons:
First, sharing information on financial performance, strategy, and operational measures conveys to the organization’s people that they are trusted. The CEO of Whole Foods Markets stated, “If you are trying to create a high trust organization ... an organization where people are all-for-one and one-for-all, you can’t have secrets.” The company shares detailed financial and performance information with every employee.
Second, even motivated and trained people cannot contribute to enhancing organizational performance if they don’t have information on important dimensions of performance and training on how to use and interpret that information.
The famous case of a CEO who purchased an old harvester plant worth $100,000 with a debt of $8.9 million led to a system called “open book management.” The philosophy states: “Don’t use information to control or manipulate people. Use it to teach people how to work together to achieve common goals and thereby gain control over their lives. Cost control happens at the individual level.”
Implementing this system involved:
- First, making sure all people generated daily numbers reflecting their work performance and production costs.
- Second, sharing this information with all people of the company.
- Third, extensive training on how to use and interpret the numbers – how to understand balance sheets, cash flow, and income statements.
🔑 Definition — Information Sharing: The practice of openly communicating financial, strategic, and operational information to all employees, combined with training on how to interpret this data, to build trust and enable performance improvement. 📐 Formula: Open Book Management = Information Transparency + Employee Training + Trust Building + Empowered Decision-Making 📌 Example: A CEO purchased a plant for $100,000 with $8.9 million debt and implemented open book management, sharing daily performance numbers and training all employees to understand financial statements.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The seven practices of successful organizations form an integrated system where each practice reinforces the others. Employment security provides the foundation for trust and long-term perspective, while selective hiring ensures the right people enter the organization. Self-managed teams replace hierarchical control with peer-based accountability, and high contingent compensation aligns employee interests with organizational performance. Extensive training develops the skills needed for autonomous work, reduction of status differences enables open communication, and information sharing empowers all employees to contribute to organizational success. These practices are not isolated policies but an interconnected system that creates a high-performance work environment where people are treated as strategic assets rather than costs.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- How does employment security benefit organizations beyond encouraging worker productivity, and what example from Lincoln Electric illustrates this?
- What four key elements are required for effective selective hiring, and why did Southwest Airlines reject a top pilot from another airline?
- What are the three main advantages of self-managed teams, and how did AES Corporation demonstrate the cost savings from this approach?
- Why should employment security be coupled with contingent compensation like gainsharing or profit sharing?
- What are the two methods for reducing status differences in organizations, and how did the CEO of Southwest Airlines demonstrate this principle during wage negotiations?