📘 Lecture 35 — Network-Based Structures: Restructuring Organizations
📖 Overview: This lecture explores how organizations restructure through network-based structures, downsizing, and reengineering. It explains the different types of networks, their advantages and disadvantages, and provides detailed application stages for both downsizing and reengineering interventions. Understanding these restructuring approaches is critical for managing organizational change in complex and dynamic environments.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining and categorizing four types of network structures: internal market, vertical market, inter-market, and opportunity networks. It then details the characteristics of network structures including vertical desegregation, brokers, and coordinating mechanisms, followed by their advantages and disadvantages. The second major section covers downsizing interventions, including conditions leading to downsizing, application stages, and research results. The final section addresses reengineering as a radical redesign approach, its application stages, and its relationship to downsizing and process-based structures.
📝 Lecture Summary
Network-Based Structures
A network-based structure manages the diverse, complex, and dynamic relationships among multiple organizations or units, each specializing in a particular business function or task. Four basic types of networks exist:
🔑 Definition — Internal market network: Exists when a single organization establishes each subunit as an independent profit center allowed to buy and sell services and resources from each other and from the external market. Example: ABB’s fifty worldwide businesses consist of twelve hundred companies organized into forty-five hundred profit centers.
🔑 Definition — Vertical market network: Composed of multiple organizations linked to a focal organization that coordinates resource movement from raw materials to end consumer. Example: Nike manufactures shoes in different plants and organizes distribution through retail outlets.
🔑 Definition — Inter-market network: Represents alliances among organizations in different markets, exemplified by the Japanese keiretsu and Korean chaebol.
🔑 Definition — Opportunity network: The most advanced form; a temporary constellation of organizations brought together to pursue a single purpose. Once accomplished, the network disbands.
These types are distinguished by whether they are single or multiple organizations, single or multiple industry, and stable or temporary. An internal market network is stable, single-organization, single-industry; an opportunity network is temporary, multiple-organization, spanning several industries.
Network structures redraw organizational boundaries and link separate business units to facilitate task interaction. Network organizations use strategic alliances, joint ventures, research and development consortia, licensing agreements, and wholly owned subsidiaries. They are known as shamrock organizations, virtual, modular, or cellular corporations.
Characteristics of Network Structures
Vertical desegregation: Breaking up business functions into separate organizations performing specialized work. In the film industry, separate organizations for transportation, cinematography, special effects, set design, music, actors, and catering work together under a broker organization (the studio). Disintermediation — replacement of whole steps in the value chain by information technology, especially the Internet — has fueled network structure development.
Brokers: Networks are often managed by broker organizations that locate and assemble member organizations. The broker may play a central role and subcontract, or specialize in linking equal partners. In construction, the general contractor assembles and manages drywall, mechanical, electrical, plumbing, and other specialties.
Coordinating mechanisms: Network organizations are not controlled by hierarchical arrangements or plans. Coordination falls into three categories:
- Informal relationships: Depend on interpersonal relationships; conflicts resolved through reciprocity; trust is built over time.
- Contracts: Formal contracts such as ownership control, licensing arrangements, or purchase agreements.
- Market mechanisms: Spot payments, performance accountability, and information systems.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Network Structures
Advantages: Highly flexible and adaptable to changing conditions; enables "best-of-the-best" company to exploit global opportunities; allows each member to exploit distinctive competence; can accumulate resources for large, complex tasks; can produce synergistic effects where the whole exceeds the sum of its parts.
Disadvantages: Managing lateral relations across autonomous organizations is difficult; motivating members to relinquish autonomy is troublesome; sustaining membership and benefits is problematic; may expose proprietary knowledge/technology to partners.
Contingencies: Best suited to highly complex and uncertain environments; applies to organizations of all sizes; fits goals emphasizing specialization and innovation; appropriate for highly uncertain technologies and worldwide operations.
💡 Why this matters: Network structures require matrix skills of managing lateral relations across organizational boundaries, but lack the ability to appeal to a higher authority to resolve conflicts — making administration particularly challenging for hierarchically managed organizations.
Downsizing
Downsizing refers to interventions aimed at reducing the size of the organization, typically by decreasing the number of employees through layoffs, attrition, redeployment, or early retirement, or by reducing organizational units or managerial levels through divestiture, outsourcing, reorganization, or delayering.
An important consequence is the rise of the contingent workforce — less expensive temporary or permanent part-time workers. The American Management Association found nearly a third of 720 firms rehired recently terminated employees as independent contractors because downsizings had not been matched by appropriate workload reduction.
Four major conditions leading to downsizing:
- Mergers and acquisitions: One in nine job cuts during 1998 resulted from integration of two organizations.
- Organization decline: Caused by loss of revenues, market share, technological and industrial change. In southern California, over 100,000 defense industry jobs were lost.
- Implementation of new organizational structures: Network-based structures involve outsourcing non-essential work.
- Beliefs that smaller is better: The conviction that organizations should be leaner and more flexible. Hamel and Prahalad warned against "corporate anorexia" — downsizing for its own sake, losing key employees and leaving a legacy of mistrust.
Application Stages of Downsizing
Stage 1: Clarify the organization's strategy. Leaders specify corporate strategy and communicate how downsizing relates to it, making clear that downsizing is not a goal itself but a restructuring process for achieving strategic objectives. Leaders provide visible support and opportunities for members to voice concerns.
Stage 2: Assess downsizing options and make relevant choices. Table 17 describes three primary downsizing methods:
🔑 Definition — Workforce reduction: Aimed at headcount reduction, short-term implementation. Includes attrition, retirement incentives, outplacement services, and layoffs.
🔑 Definition — Organization redesign: Aimed at organization change, moderate-term implementation. Includes merging units, eliminating layers, eliminating products, redesigning tasks.
🔑 Definition — Systemic change: Aimed at culture change, long-term implementation. Involves changing responsibilities and work behaviors of everyone, fostering continuous improvement as a way of life.
Case (manufacturer of heavy construction equipment) used multiple methods: eliminating money-losing product lines, narrowing product breadth, bringing customers for design input, shifting production to outside vendors, restructuring debt, spinning off stores, closing five plants, and reducing payroll by almost 35%.
Stage 3: Implement the changes. Best controlled from top down; identify and target specific areas of inefficiency and high cost; link specific actions to strategy; communicate frequently using multiple media.
Stage 4: Address needs of survivors and those who leave. When layoffs occur, remaining employees take on additional responsibilities, often without compensation increases, leading to "survivor syndrome" — self-absorbed, risk-averse behaviors that threaten organizational survival. Survivors are preoccupied with whether additional layoffs will occur, guilt over receiving pay while coworkers struggle, and career advancement uncertainty.
Organizations can address survivor concerns through communication that shifts from explaining who left to clarifying visions, strategies, and goals; training and development for new work; and promoting involvement in decision making.
For laid-off employees: outplacement counseling, personal and family counseling, severance packages, office support for job searches, relocation services, and job retraining.
Stage 5: Follow through with growth plans. Implementing an organization renewal and growth process. A study of 1,020 HR directors found only 44% shared details of growth plans with employees; only 34% told employees how they would fit into the new strategy.
Results of Downsizing
Empirical research on downsizing is mostly negative. The National Research Council concluded: "From the research produced thus far, downsizing as a strategy for improvement has proven to be, by and large, a failure."
Key findings:
- Fewer than half of firms met cost targets
- Only 22% achieved expected productivity gains
- About 80% needed to rehire some previously terminated people
- Fewer than 33% reported profits increased as expected
- Only 21% achieved satisfactory shareholder return on investment
- Individual problems: increased stress and illness, loss of self-esteem, reduced trust and loyalty, marriage and family disruptions
Financial performance studies: One study of 210 companies found that layoff announcements produced initial improvements, but gains were temporary and not sustained at even pre-layoff levels. Another study of sixteen firms found stock prices declined below market by 17% to 48% two years after layoff announcements.
Cautions in interpreting results:
- Survey responses from HR specialists may view downsizing negatively
- Financial performance studies may include biased samples of poorly managed firms
- Disappointing results may reflect poor implementation rather than downsizing itself
Companies like Florida Power and Light, General Electric, Motorola, Texas Instruments, Boeing, Chrysler, and Hewlett-Packard posted solid returns following downsizing. A study of thirty automobile firms showed that those implementing the process effectively scored significantly higher on performance measures.
Reengineering
Reengineering is the fundamental rethinking and radical redesign of business processes to achieve dramatic improvements in performance. It transforms how organizations traditionally produce and deliver goods and services.
Reengineering addresses problems created by the Industrial Revolution's fragmentation of work into specialized units. It breaks down specialized work units into more integrated, cross-functional work processes, streamlining work and making it more responsive to changes in competitive conditions, customer demands, product life cycles, and technologies.
Reengineering requires revolutionary change, questioning unexamined assumptions about how organizations perform work. This differs from continuous improvement and total quality management, which emphasize incremental changes. Reengineering seeks dramatic increases in performance.
Modern information technology enables reengineering. At IBM Credit, an integrated information system with expert systems technology enables one employee to handle all stages of credit delivery. SAP is the most popular software system for supporting process-based work, integrating information flow among different business parts.
Reengineering overlaps with downsizing, shift from functional to process-based structures, and work design. It can result in fewer people and management layers, and helps break down the vertical orientation of functional organizations.
Application Stages of Reengineering
Stage 1: Prepare the organization. Clarify and assess competitive environment, strategy, and objectives. At GTE Telephone Operations, executives determined deregulation would spread to local networks, presenting an enormous competitive challenge.
Stage 2: Specify organization strategy and objectives. Business strategy determines focus of reengineering. GTE set dramatic goals: doubling revenues while halving costs and reducing product development time by 75%. Communications program lasted a year and a half.
Stage 3: Fundamentally rethink the way work gets done. Three activities:
a. Identify and analyze core business processes. Core processes are essential for strategic success. Develop a process map listing different activities required to deliver products/services. GTE characterized core processes as "choose, use, and pay."
Analysis can include assigning costs to each phase of work flow. At Dana Corporation, traditional accounting showed salaries and fringe benefits accounted for 82% of costs. Process-based accounting showed 44% of costs involved expediting, resolving, and reissuing orders — half their costs were associated with reworking deficient orders.
Processes can be assessed in terms of value-added activities. Corky's Pest Control provides customers with a self-addressed, stamped envelope — adding cost but paying for itself in customer loyalty and reduced accounts receivables. Conversely, a Denver hospital had an employee checking a pump that no longer required physical inspection, wasting resources.
📐 Value-added analysis: Process activities that contribute value to product/service → decisions about which activities to keep or eliminate.
b. Define performance objectives. Set challenging goals for speed, quality, cost. Andersen Windows set targets for ease of ordering, manufacturing, and delivery. By 1995, sales tripled at some locations, products increased to 188,000, and fewer than 1 in 200 shipments had discrepancies.
c. Design new processes. Start with a clean sheet addressing: "If we were starting this company today, what processes would we need for sustainable competitive advantage?" Guidelines include:
- Begin and end with customer needs
- Simplify by combining and eliminating steps
- Use "best of what is"
- Attend to technical and social aspects
- Do not be constrained by past practice
- Identify critical information at each step
- Perform activities in natural order
- Assume work gets done right first time
- Listen to people who do the work
"Early wins" or "quick hits" — implementing obvious redundancies and inefficiencies immediately — help generate momentum.
Stage 4: Restructure the organization around the new business processes. Implement new information and measurement systems that shift from measuring behaviors (absenteeism, grievances) to assessing outcomes (productivity, customer satisfaction, cost savings). Information technology is a key driver because it drastically reduces cost and time for integrating business processes.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Network structures represent a fundamental shift from traditional hierarchies to relationship-based coordination across organizational boundaries. Four distinct types exist — internal market, vertical market, inter-market, and opportunity networks — each suited to different organizational arrangements. Downsizing interventions, while aimed at reducing costs and improving efficiency, have largely negative empirical results unless implemented carefully following the five-stage process with attention to strategy, options assessment, implementation, survivor support, and growth follow-through. Reengineering provides the most radical restructuring approach by fundamentally rethinking business processes from the ground up, often enabled by information technology, with its own four-stage application process. The success of all restructuring interventions depends more on how effectively they are applied than on the scale of layoffs or structural changes.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the four types of network structures, and how can they be distinguished from one another?
-
What three categories of coordinating mechanisms are used in network organizations, and how do they differ from hierarchical control?
-
What is "survivor syndrome" in the context of downsizing, and what practices can organizations use to address it?
-
What are the three primary downsizing tactics (workforce reduction, organization redesign, systemic change) and how do they differ in implementation timeframe and focus?
-
How does reengineering differ from continuous improvement and total quality management, and what role does information technology play in enabling it?
📘 Lecture 36 — Employee Involvement
📖 Overview: This lecture examines employee involvement (EI) as a critical OD intervention for enhancing participation, commitment, and productivity. It explores how organizations empower employees by moving decision-making authority downward, and details major EI applications including parallel structures, cooperative union-management projects, and quality circles. The lecture uses the case of Michael Dell to illustrate why even successful companies must address employee engagement.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture opens with the Michael Dell case study showing the consequences of neglecting employee involvement. It then defines employee involvement through four key elements: power, information, knowledge and skills, and rewards. The relationship between EI and productivity is explained through communication, motivation, and capability improvements. Finally, the lecture covers parallel structures including their application stages, cooperative union-management projects, and presents case examples from GE Medical Systems and GTE California.
📝 Lecture Summary
Changing Michael Dell’s DNA
Dell Inc. is one of the world’s largest PC manufacturers and topped the Fortune 500 list in 10-year total return to investors. CEO Michael Dell still manages with urgency and determination from his college dorm days. However, a recent employee survey revealed that half of Dell’s employees would leave if they got the chance. Internal interviews showed that subordinates felt Michael Dell was impersonal and emotionally detached, while president Kevin Rollins was autocratic and antagonistic.
Michael Dell believes the status quo is never good enough—once a problem is uncovered, it should be dealt with quickly. In the 1990s, seasoned managers recruited from IBM and Intel quickly bailed out because they were unwilling to work in Dell’s demanding culture. An executive coach who worked with Dell since 1995 said, “They need to work a lot on appreciating people.” Fearing an exodus of talent, Dell went before his management team and offered an honest self-critique. He acknowledged his shyness made him appear removed and uncaring, and promised to build tighter relationships with his team. A videotape of the meeting was shown to every manager in the company.
Like Dell, a growing number of companies recognize that empowered employees are the difference between success and failure in the long run. Faced with competitive demands for lower costs, higher performance, and greater flexibility, organizations increasingly turn to employee involvement (EI) to enhance participation, commitment, and productivity.
🔑 Definition — Employee Involvement (EI): A broad term that has been variously referred to as “empowerment,” “participative management,” “work design,” “industrial democracy,” and “quality of work life.” It seeks to increase members’ input into decisions that affect organization performance and employee well-being.
🔑 Definition — Empowerment: Giving employees power to make decisions about work.
Firms that have transformed their culture claim increased productivity, more clients, a sense of ownership in each employee, and increased profits. OD interventions in this area aim at moving decision-making downward in the organization, closer to where actual work takes place—i.e., delegation of power. Major EI applications discussed include: parallel structures (including cooperative union-management projects and quality circles), high-involvement organizations, and total quality management. Work design and reward system interventions are discussed in later chapters.
💡 Why this matters: The Dell case demonstrates that even highly successful companies can face a talent crisis if employees feel undervalued. Employee involvement is presented not as optional but as essential for long-term organizational survival and competitiveness.
Employee Involvement: What is it?
Employee involvement is the current label for practices and philosophies that started with the quality-of-work-life (QWL) movement in the late 1950s. The phrase “quality of work life” was used to stress the prevailing poor quality of life at the workplace. Both the term QWL and its meaning have undergone considerable change and development.
A Working Definition of Employee Involvement
Employee involvement seeks to increase members’ input into decisions that affect organization performance and employee well-being. It is described in terms of four key elements that promote worker involvement:
-
Power: Providing people with enough authority to make work-related decisions covering work methods, task assignments, performance outcomes, customer service, and employee selection. The amount of power can vary enormously—from simply asking for input, to joint manager-worker decisions, to employees making decisions themselves.
-
Information: Timely access to relevant information is vital for making effective decisions. Organizations can promote EI by ensuring necessary information flows freely to those with decision authority, including data about operating results, business plans, competitive conditions, new technologies, work methods, and ideas for improvement.
-
Knowledge and skills: Employee involvement contributes to organizational effectiveness only to the extent that employees have the requisite skills and knowledge to make good decisions. Organizations can facilitate EI by providing training and development programs covering performing tasks, making decisions, solving problems, and understanding how the business operates.
-
Rewards: Because people generally do things for which they are recognized, rewards powerfully affect getting people involved. Meaningful involvement opportunities can provide internal rewards like feelings of self-worth and accomplishment. External rewards like pay and promotions can reinforce EI when linked directly to performance outcomes resulting from participation in decision-making.
These four elements are interdependent and must be changed together to obtain positive results. For example, giving members more power without information or knowledge/skills makes involvement negligible. Increasing power, information, and knowledge/skills without linking rewards to performance gives members little incentive to improve.
The farther that all four elements are moved downward throughout the organization, the greater the employee involvement. Parallel structures (union-management cooperative efforts and quality circles) are limited in moving these elements downward; high-involvement organizations and total quality management provide far greater opportunities.
💡 Why this matters: The four elements form a system—changing only one or two elements will likely fail. This explains why many EI initiatives fail: organizations give power but not training, or provide information but no rewards.
How Employee Involvement Affects Productivity
An assumption underlying much EI literature is that such interventions will lead to higher productivity. Studies have found a consistent relationship between EI practices and productivity measures such as financial performance, customer satisfaction, labor hours, and waste rates.
The traditional explanation—that involvement raises job satisfaction which then raises productivity—is now considered too simplistic and sometimes wrong. A more realistic explanation shows three ways EI interventions improve productivity:
-
Communication and coordination: EI improves communication and coordination among employees and departments, helping integrate different jobs or departments that contribute to an overall task.
-
Employee motivation: EI improves employee motivation, particularly when it satisfies important individual needs. Motivation translates into improved performance when people have necessary skills and knowledge and when technology and work situations allow people to affect productivity. Some jobs are so rigidly controlled that individual motivation has little impact.
-
Employee capabilities: EI improves employee capabilities, enabling them to perform better. For example, participation in decision-making generally includes skill training in group problem-solving and communication.
Secondary effects include increased employee well-being and satisfaction by providing a better work environment and more fulfilling job. Improved productivity also increases satisfaction, particularly when it leads to greater rewards. Increased satisfaction ultimately attracts good employees to join and remain with the organization.
In sum, EI interventions increase productivity by improving communication and coordination, employee motivation, and individual capabilities, plus secondary effects of increased employee well-being and satisfaction. Recent data support the conclusion that relatively modest levels of EI produce moderate improvements, while higher levels of EI produce correspondingly higher levels of performance.
Employee Involvement Applications
This section describes three major EI applications varying in how much power, information, knowledge/skills, and rewards are moved downward: parallel structures (including cooperative projects and quality circles), high-involvement organizations, and total quality management.
Parallel Structures
Parallel structures involve members in resolving ill-defined, complex problems and build adaptability into bureaucratic organizations. Also known as “collateral structures,” “dualistic structures,” or “shadow structures,” they operate in conjunction with the formal organization. They provide an alternative setting where members can address problems and propose innovative solutions free from formal structure and culture. For example, members may attend periodic off-site meetings to improve quality, or be temporarily assigned to special projects to devise new products or solutions.
Parallel structures facilitate problem-solving and change by providing time and resources for members to think, talk, and act in completely new ways. Norms and procedures in parallel structures are entirely different from the formal organization.
OD in Practice: A Work-Out Meeting at General Electric Medical Systems Business
As part of large-scale change, CEO Jack Welch and managers at General Electric devised Work-Out—a process for gathering relevant people to discuss important issues and develop a clear action plan. The program has four goals: use employees’ knowledge and energy to improve work, eliminate unnecessary work, build trust by allowing employees to speak without fear, and engage in constructing an organization ready for the future.
At GE Medical Systems (GEMS), internal consultants conducted extensive interviews revealing dissatisfaction with performance management (too many measurements, not enough customer focus, unfair rewards, unrealistic goals), career development, and organizational climate. Managers reported feeling their hands were tied and needing help delegating.
Based on compiled information, about fifty GEMS employees and managers gathered for a five-day Work-Out session. Participants included the group executive, his staff, employee relations managers, and informal leaders from key functional areas thought to be risk-takers who would challenge the status quo. Teams engaged in “bureaucracy busting” by identifying CRAP (Critical Review Appraisals) in the organization—needless approvals, policies, meetings, and reports that stifled productivity. Senior managers were not part of these discussions to encourage free thinking.
At week’s end, senior management listened to concerns, proposals, and action plans. According to traditional Work-Out methods, managers must make instant, on-the-spot decisions about each idea: approve, reject with clear reasons, or request more data with a decision within one month. The session ended with individuals and functional teams signing nearly one hundred written contracts to implement new processes or drop unnecessary work. One important outcome was involving suppliers in internal email networks, leading to joint new-product prototypes, cost reductions, improved design quality, and decreased cycle times.
Since 1988, hundreds of Work-Outs have been held, evolving into best-practice investigations, process mapping, and change-acceleration programs. The process is based on the confrontation meeting model where a large group gathers to identify issues and plan actions.
Application Stages
Parallel structures fall at the lower end of the EI scale. Member participation is typically restricted to making proposals and suggestions because management reserves decisions about implementation. Membership tends to be limited to volunteers and numbers for which there are adequate resources. Management heavily influences authority, information sharing, training, and monetary rewards.
Parallel structures are most appropriate for organizations with little or no history of employee participation, top-down management styles, and bureaucratic cultures. They are implemented in the following steps:
-
Define the purpose and scope: Define the purpose and initial expectations. Organizational diagnosis clarifies which problems to address (productivity, absenteeism, service quality). Management training includes discussions about commitment, resources, openness, and willingness to experiment and learn.
-
Form a steering committee: Composed of acknowledged leaders from various functions and constituencies. Tasks include refining scope and purpose, developing a vision, guiding creation and implementation, establishing linkage mechanisms between parallel and formal structures, creating problem-solving groups, and ensuring senior management support. OD practitioners help develop norms of learning and innovation, create vision statements, and specify objectives, strategies, expectations, resources, and rewards.
-
Communicate with organization members: Communicating purpose, procedures, and rewards promotes involvement. Employee participation in developing vision and purpose increases ownership and visibly demonstrates the “new way” of working. Continued communication ensures member awareness.
-
Form employee problem-solving groups: These are the primary means of accomplishing the parallel structure’s purpose. Formation involves selecting and training group members, identifying problems, and providing facilitation. Members need to represent appropriate hierarchical levels, expertise, functions, and constituencies relevant to the problems at hand. Training may include the vision, specific problems, and problem-solving methods. Group norms promoting openness, creativity, and integration must be established. Facilitation, though expensive, yields benefits in problem-solving efficiency and quality by helping disparate groups cooperate.
-
Address the problems and issues: Groups use an action research process—diagnosing problems, planning solutions, implementing and evaluating them. Effective relationships between groups and the steering committee permit appropriate direction, resource acquisition, support, and approval of action plans, ensuring solutions are appropriately linked to the formal organization.
-
Implement and evaluate the changes: Implement appropriate organizational changes and assess results. Change proposals need steering committee and formal authority structure support. Feedback on changes helps the organization learn to adapt and innovate.
Cooperative Union-Management Projects
Cooperative union-management projects are one of the oldest EI applications of parallel structures. They are associated with the original QWL movement and its focus on workplace change, though recent approaches have broadened to include productivity improvement. Such dual involvement has a long history in Scandinavian countries. These interventions have the following structural characteristics:
-
Steering committee: A top-level labor-management committee serving as the basic center for planning, created during project start-up. It comprises key representatives from management (president or COO) and each union/employee group (local union presidents). The mandate is to begin activities improving both quality of working life and organizational effectiveness. Members are encouraged to be open about the need for productivity improvements. Unionists are told that because projects are jointly controlled, they need not fear productivity motives.
-
Multiple-level committees: Because the steering committee cannot oversee all aspects, additional labor-management committees are established at selected levels (plant, department, shop-floor) to reflect differing interests and knowledge. Lower-level committees deal with day-to-day activities.
-
Ad hoc committees: Labor-management committees may initiate particular projects involving workers and managers in specific parts of the organization. Employees themselves frequently initiate action toward particular goals. Ad hoc committees are established with specific tasks and limited lifetimes.
-
External consultants: External change agents act as third-party facilitators, offering guidance and assistance to labor-management committees and providing problem-solving and teamwork training. The steering committee typically selects the consultants.
-
External researchers: In some projects, researchers assess overall results. Separate roles for change agents and evaluation researchers allow consultants to focus on client needs and researchers to provide objective assessments.
Almost every major union and corporation has become involved in these efforts, including UAW, Communications Workers of America, Ford, General Motors, and AT&T.
Application 7: Union-Management Cooperation at GTE California
GTE of California (GTEC) and the Communications Workers of America began a cooperative union-management project in fall 1984 in response to the court-ordered breakup of AT&T. Deregulation removed guaranteed returns, monopoly territories, and “cradle-to-grave” employment. Traditional management was characterized by centralized decision-making, lackadaisical service orientation, and little cross-functional teamwork.
Under the new conditions, GTEC management and union leadership believed the usual way of operating needed to change. Working with OD consultants from the University of Southern California’s Center for Effective Organizations, senior managers and union leaders began discussing how to increase worker participation and decentralize decision-making without treading on traditional collective bargaining issues. The result was a cooperative union-management partnership called Employee Involvement, aimed at improving employees’ quality of working life and productivity.
The steering committee established a parallel structure with twenty-six thousand employees at GTEC, comprising three area coordinating committees responsible for implementing EI in respective geographic regions. Each created support committees for functional areas, which in turn established EI teams to identify and solve work-related problems. All organization members attended a two-hour orientation conducted by both GTEC management and local union presidents. A three-day union-management training program was conducted for all supervisors and union officials—managers and union leaders trained separately for the first two days, then together on the third day. Support committee and EI team members attended a five-day training program on meeting-management skills, problem-solving techniques, and group dynamics, with internal facilitators available.
Initially, EI teams focused on quality-of-work-life issues like bottled drinking water rather than productivity-related changes. Responsible committees modified the process to align more closely with productivity objectives—problem-solving training emphasized performance issues, committee compositions were revised to increase senior management and union leadership involvement and accountability, a new incentive compensation system rewarded cross-functional teamwork, and facilitators were permanently assigned to functional areas to focus on operating problems.
The EI process produced many successes. One team worked for over two years to simplify how field employees reported their time, producing savings of more than $3 million by increasing productive time and consolidating offices. Between 1987 and 1988, evaluation concluded the program had produced net savings of more than $1 million after costs. By 1991, GTEC surpassed competitors in customer satisfaction measures for large and medium-sized businesses, becoming the benchmark. Several cost measures also decreased significantly. The EI program survived two union contract negotiations and massive corporate changes that reduced workforce size.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The critical message is that employee involvement is not a single practice but a system of four interdependent elements—power, information, knowledge/skills, and rewards—that must all be moved downward together for success. The Dell case demonstrates that even the most successful companies face a talent crisis when employees feel undervalued, and that meaningful change requires authentic self-critique from top leadership. The lecture establishes that EI improves productivity not simply through satisfaction but through three proven mechanisms: better communication and coordination, enhanced motivation, and improved employee capabilities. Parallel structures offer a low-risk entry point for bureaucratic organizations by creating alternative settings for problem-solving, with the six application stages providing a clear roadmap for implementation. Finally, the GTE California case shows that cooperative union-management projects can succeed even in deregulated, rapidly changing environments—but require persistent attention to aligning goals, training, and reward systems with productivity objectives rather than just quality-of-work-life concerns.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four key elements of employee involvement, and why must they be changed together rather than independently?
- How does employee involvement affect productivity through the three mechanisms described in the lecture?
- What are the six application stages for implementing parallel structures, and why are they considered appropriate for bureaucratic organizations?
- What structural characteristics distinguish cooperative union-management projects from other parallel structures?
- How did the GTE California case demonstrate the importance of aligning EI goals with productivity objectives rather than focusing solely on quality-of-work-life issues?