π Lecture 45 β REVISION
π Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive revision of major communication theories, focusing on the shift from limited effects paradigms to cultural and critical perspectives. It examines how media can produce profound changes in social life, and systematically reviews key theoretical frameworks including Marxism, Neo-Marxism, the Frankfurt School, and contemporary theories such as Agenda Setting and the Spiral of Silence.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main approaches used by cultural theorists (microscopic and macroscopic), the concept of mediation of social relations, dominant versus pluralist media models, centripetal and centrifugal tendencies, Marxism including materialism, economic determination, base/superstructure, false consciousness and alienation, Neo-Marxism and hegemony, the Frankfurt School and critical theory with false needs, political economy theory with internationalization, integration and diversification, and several contemporary theories including Agenda Setting, Spiral of Silence, McLuhan's medium theory, Knowledge Gap theory, and Uses and Gratifications theory.
π Lecture Summary
Challenge to limited effects paradigm
The challenge to the limited effects paradigm came from ideas beyond social cognitive learning and systems theories. Instead of focusing on specific effects on individuals, cultural theorists focus on changes in culture, shared understandings, and social norms. Rather than trying to locate hundreds of small effects and add them up, we can ask whether the development of mass media has profound implications for the way we create, share, learn, and apply culture.
These new perspectives argue that media might have the power to intrude into and alter how we make sense of ourselves and our social world. In all these theories, the concept of culture is central.
Two Ways Used By Cultural Theorists
Cultural theorists use two widely used ways to differentiate the various theories of media.
Microscopic Theories are interpretive theories that focus on how individuals and social groups use media to create and foster forms of culture that structure everyday life.
Macroscopic, Structural Theories focus on how social elites use their economic power to gain control over and exploit to propagate hegemonic culture as a means of maintaining their dominant position in social order. These are called political economy theories because they place priority on understanding how economic power provides a basis for ideological and political power.
Differences between Microscopic and Macroscopic Theories: Microscopic cultural studies researchers prefer to understand what is going on in the world immediately around them. They are intrigued by the mundane, the seemingly trivial, and the routine. Macroscopic researchers are troubled by the narrow focus of microscopic theory and demand answers to larger questions about how media affect politics, national economy, or delivery of vital social services.
Critical Theories
Some cultural theories and political economy theories are also referred to as critical theories because they openly espouse certain values and use these values to evaluate and criticize the status quo. However, political economy theories are inherently critical but some cultural studies theories are not. Those who develop critical theories seek to initiate social change that will implement their values.
For example, some critical theorists argue that media in general sustain the status quo. Mass media are criticized for aggravating or preventing problems from being identified, addressed, and solved. A common theme is that content production is so constrained that it inevitably reinforces the status quo and undermines useful efforts for constructive social change.
Mediation of Social Relations
Mediation involves several different processes. It refers to the relying of second-hand or third party version of events and conditions which we cannot directly observe for ourselves.
The media have been variously perceived as:
- A window on events and experience, extending our vision
- A mirror of events, implying faithful reflection
- A filter or gatekeeper, selecting parts of experience
- A signpost, guide or interpreter, making sense of the puzzling
- A forum or platform for presentation of information
- A screen or barrier, cutting us off from reality
These propositions give rise to sub-questions about who controls the media, whose version of reality is presented, how effective media are, and whether media promote more or less equality.
Model of Dominant Media: This model sees media subservient to other institutions, owned or controlled by a small number of powerful interests. They disseminate a limited and undifferentiated view of the world shaped by ruling interests. Audiences are constrained to accept this view with little critical response.
Pluralist Model: This holds that there is no dominant elite, and change and democratic control are both possible. Differentiated audiences initiate demand and are able to resist persuasion and react to what media offer.
Centrifugal tendencies include notions of change, freedom, diversity, and fragmentation. Centripetal tendencies include notions of order, control, unity, and cohesion.
Four different theoretical positions relating to social integration: The positive version of the centripetal effect stresses media as integrative and unifying (functionalist view). The negative version represents homogenization and manipulative control (critical theory). The positive version of centrifugalism stresses modernization, freedom, and mobility (individualism). The negative version points to isolation, alienation, loss of values, and vulnerability (dysfunctional view).
Marxism
Karl Marx developed his theory in the latter part of the 19th century. Social change was explained by the struggle between competing and antagonistic forces in society through the dialectic process. This struggle was between the 'haves' and 'have nots' differentiated by possession of economic power. The power of the bourgeoisie is exercised through material exploitation of the working classes by extracting their surplus value and making excess profit.
π Definition β Materialism: A conception of history and the way society organizes itself, suggesting everything is shaped ultimately by the economic system of a society, which affects the ideas individuals have and the institutions they establish.
π Definition β Economic Determination: The idea that everything in life is determined by capital. The flow of money affects our relations with other persons, with nature and with the world. Every cultural activity is reduced to an expression of some preceding and controlling economic content.
The base and the superstructure: Marx's deterministic economic conception divides society into two layers: Base: Composed of material production, money, objects, relations of production, and the stage of development of productive forces. Superstructure: The overt and tangible world, plus the economic relations that capital generates. Superstructures include the legal system, philosophy, religion, ideas (educational), arts (media), and culture.
π Definition β False Consciousness and Ideology: The ruling class propagates an ideology that justifies its status and makes it difficult for ordinary people to recognize. The mass media and popular culture are centrally important in the spread of false consciousness, leading people to believe that 'whatever is, is right'.
π Definition β Alienation: Separation and distance; according to Marx, capitalism necessarily generates alienation, and all classes suffer from it. People become separated or estranged from their work, from friends, from themselves, and from life.
Role of mass media in alienation: Mass media provide momentary gratifications for the alienated spirit, distract the alienated individual from misery, and with advertising, stimulate desire leading people to work harder. Advertising acts as the chief means of motivating people to work hard.
Consumer Society: Advertising is an essential institution in advanced capitalist societies because it motivates people to work hard to accumulate money to buy things. People must be driven to consume, as consumption maintains the economic system. Advertising diverts people's attention from social and political concerns toward selfish and private concerns.
π‘ Why this matters: Marx's analysis of false consciousness and alienation provides a foundational critique of how media and advertising function within capitalist systems to maintain social control while giving people the illusion of free choice.
Neo Marxism
Contemporary incarnation of Marxist theory focusing attention on superstructure. Most British cultural studies theories can be labeled Neo-Marxist. They deviate from classic Marxist theory by focusing concern on superstructure issues of ideology and culture rather than the base.
π Definition β Hegemony: A loosely interrelated set of ruling ideas permeating a society in such a way as to make the established order of power and values appear natural, taken-for-granted, and commonsensical. A ruling ideology is not imposed but appears to exist by virtue of an unquestioned consensus.
Dominant groups maintain their dominance by securing the 'spontaneous consent' of subordinate groups through the negotiated construction of a political and ideological consensus that incorporates both dominant and dominated groups.
Gramscianism on Communications Matters: From a Gramscian perspective, the mass media have to be interpreted as an instrument to spread and reinforce the dominant hegemony, although they could be used to spread counter-hegemonic ideas too. The media, as unwitting instruments of hegemonic domination, shape people's very ideas of themselves and the world.
Frankfurt School and Critical Theory
The term critical theory serves to a long and diverse tradition owing its origin to a group of post-1933 scholars from the Marxist school of Applied social research in Frankfurt. The most important members were Max Horkheimer and Theodor Adorno, along with Herbert Marcuse and Walter Benjamin.
The school engaged in a critique of the enlightenment, arguing that the promise of scientific and rational progress and the extension of human freedom had turned into a nightmareβthe use of science and rationality to stamp out human freedom.
The universal and commercialized mass culture was seen as one important means by which success for monopoly capital had been achieved. The affluence and consumerism generated by capitalist societies, and the levels of ideological control possessed by their culture industries, ensured the working class was thoroughly incorporated into the system.
π Definition β False Needs: Identified particularly with the work of Marcuse, based on the assumption that people have true or real needs to be creative, independent, and autonomous. The cultivation of false needs is bound up with the role of the culture industry, and is so effective that the working class no longer poses a threat to capitalism.
Political Economy Theory
Directs research attention to the empirical analysis of the structure of ownership and control of media and to the way media market forces operate.
Three economic processes that have increased the reach of media corporations:
- Internationalization: Corporations are ceasing to be simply national and are becoming global.
- Integration: Fewer and fewer large companies increasingly own what we see, hear, and read. Takes two forms: Vertical integration (one owner acquires all aspects of production and distribution of a single type of media product) and Horizontal integration (one company buys different kinds of media, concentrating ownership across different kinds of media).
- Diversification: Cross-media ownership control by non-media companies has widened and deepened media concentration.
Two approaches analyzing the relationship between ownership and control: Instrumental (direct intervention): Sometimes the impact of views and prejudices of owners is immediate and direct through constant everyday interventions. Structural (economic structures shape activities): Analysis is centered on constraints and limitations placed on owners, managers, and workers by the nature of the capitalist economy.
Agenda Setting Theory
π Definition β Agenda Setting: As laid out by Maxwell McCombs and Donald Shaw, it is "the process whereby the news media lead the public in assigning relative importance to various public issues."
Spiral of Silence
Its originator is Elizabeth Noelle-Neumann. Because of people's fear of isolation or separation from those around them, they tend to keep their attitudes to themselves when they think they are in the minority.
Three characteristics of news media that produce this scarcity of perspective:
- Ubiquity: The media are virtually everywhere as sources of information
- Cumulation: Various news media tend to repeat stories and perspectives across programs, editions, and time
- Consonance: The congruence or similarity of values held by news people influences the content they produce
Marshall McLuhan: the medium is the message and massage
McLuhan argued that technology inevitably causes specific changes in how people think, how society is structured, and the forms of culture created. He coined the term Global village to refer to the new form of social organization emerging from instantaneous electronic media.
He proclaimed media to be the extensions of man, arguing that media extend sight, hearing, and touch through time and space.
McLuhan's conception of hot and cool media: Television is cool because it presents vague, shadowy images requiring people to participate in creating fully formed images. Print is hot because it supplies all information needed, offering predigested descriptions of the social world.
Knowledge Gap Theory
The news media systematically inform some segments of the population (persons in higher socioeconomic groups) better than others. Over time, the differences between the better informed and less informed segments tend to growβthe knowledge gap between them gets larger and larger.
Uses and Gratifications Theory
This perspective takes the view of the media consumer. It examines how people use the media and the gratification (satisfaction, pleasure) they seek and receive from their media behaviors. Researchers assume that audience members are aware of and can articulate their reasons for consuming various media content.
β Key Takeaways
Students must understand the fundamental shift from limited effects paradigms to cultural theories that examine how media change collective understandings and social norms. The distinction between microscopic (individual/group level) and macroscopic (structural/elite power) approaches is essential, as is the difference between dominant media models (where elites control) and pluralist models (where audiences have agency). Marx's concepts of base/superstructure, false consciousness, alienation, and economic determination remain foundational for critical media analysis, while Neo-Marxist concepts like hegemony explain how ruling ideas appear natural and commonsensical. Contemporary theories including Agenda Setting, Spiral of Silence, Knowledge Gap, and Uses and Gratifications each offer distinct but complementary explanations of media's role in society, with McLuhan's medium theory providing a technological determinist alternative.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two ways used by cultural theorists to differentiate theories of media, and what does each focus on?
- According to Marx, what is the relationship between the base and superstructure in society?
- What is hegemony according to Gramscian theory, and how do mass media function within it?
- What three characteristics of news media does Noelle-Neumann identify as producing the spiral of silence?
- What is the difference between vertical integration and horizontal integration in media ownership?