📘 Lecture 44 — Importance of Mass Media
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the critical role of mass media in democratic societies, where it serves as a bridge between the government and the public. It examines media's agenda-setting and agenda-following functions, provides historical examples of media influence, and discusses the global debate over a New World Information and Communication Order aimed at breaking Western media monopoly.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the importance of mass media as a bridge between government and masses in democratic societies. It explains media's two key policy functions: agenda setting and agenda following, illustrated through the US-Vietnam War and 1971 Pak-India War. The lecture then discusses transparency initiatives through government websites, historical issues of information access in Pakistan, and concludes with the UNESCO-led New World Information and Communication Order debate and the resulting Western backlash.
📝 Lecture Summary
Importance of Mass Media
In a democratic society, the government cannot make decisions without people's approval, and the majority holds authority. Mass media acts as a bridge between the government and the masses, informing leaders about public opinion and informing the public about governmental actions. Government departments regularly monitor radio, TV, and newspapers to gauge public opinion on policies. Mass media functions as both a mirror of society and a watchdog, keeping an eye on government officials' activities and informing the public about law violations, corruption, and betrayal.
Policy Making Functions
Mass media plays a role in policy making through two main approaches:
- Agenda setting function: Mass media informs policy makers about how a problem can be solved by setting the policy for them or with them.
- Agenda following function: Mass media does not provide solutions but is used to implement the government's existing policies.
Experts generally prefer and appreciate mass media's role more as an agenda setting body than an agenda following body.
🔑 Definition — Agenda setting: Mass media's ability to influence policy makers by proposing how problems should be solved and shaping the policy agenda. 📐 Formula: Agenda Setting = Media proposes solutions → Government adopts/considers those solutions
📌 Example: The US-Vietnam War is a key example of mass media's agenda setting role. Live media coverage of the war turned Americans against their own government, forcing the government to change policies and call back troops from Vietnam on people's demand.
📌 Example: In the 1971 Pak-India war, media played an agenda following role and was used as a tool to implement government's policies. The government did not transfer power to the party that got majority votes after the 1971 election, resulting in the loss of half the land. Mass media did not work as a watchdog and did not inform the public of the truth.
💡 Why this matters: These contrasting examples show that when media functions as an agenda setter, it can hold government accountable and reflect public will. When it functions merely as an agenda follower, it can enable government failures to go unchecked.
Government Transparency Initiatives
The government has decided to create websites for all its ministries and departments, displaying policies and details of actions. This will reduce the distance between government and masses and help achieve transparency. People will be able to submit applications and complaints regarding different issues on these websites.
Issues of Information Access
Due to the non-acceptance of people's right to know and access to information at the governmental level, many issues remain unsolved in Pakistan's history:
- Liaqat Ali Khan's assassination is still a mystery.
- After the Dhaka Fall, the Hamood-ur-Rehman Commission was formed to investigate the causes of the tragedy, but its report was not opened. Even when partially revealed, the full facts remain hidden from the people.
🔑 Definition — Right to know: The principle that citizens have a fundamental right to access information held by their government.
Media and War Coverage
After the United States' defeat in the Vietnam War, an investigation found that mass media turned Americans against the government, contributing to the loss against a smaller nation. Following the investigation, US armed forces commanders stated that no TV channel or reporter would be permitted to do live coverage of war without prior approval from commanders.
People filed cases in courts against this order, arguing: "Since our armed forces are paid from our tax money, and huge sums are spent on the purchase of arms and ammunition, therefore, public who is the financer of armed forces and war machinery, has a right to know what their armed forces are doing when they are outside of the country and fighting somewhere."
New World Information and Communication Order
An unfortunate fact about mass media is that a few developed countries enjoy monopoly over global mass media. Their news agencies, broadcasting houses, TV channels, and films dominate the world. To break this monopoly and give third world countries their share, the 21st General Conference of UNESCO in Belgrade (October 1980) received a report and issued a declaration on communication.
Key events and reactions:
- The New York Times editorial titled "UNESCO as Censor"
- Time magazine issued "The Global First Amendment War"
- Hundreds of newspapers carried stories like "Press Groups Denounce UNESCO Plan on Media"
MacBride Commission Report
In 1976, UNESCO's Director General Amadou-Mahtar M'Bow authorized the appointment of an International Commission for the Study of Communication Problems under Sean MacBride (former foreign minister of Ireland and recipient of both Nobel and Lenin Peace Prizes).
The report, "Many Voices, One World" (Unipub, 1980), supported principles of free reporting of news but also encouraged state regulation of the media and suggested UNESCO give priority to "the elaboration of international norms" in its communication program.
The Belgrade Assembly referred the report to member governments without endorsing its conclusions. However, the Group of 77 (a bloc of over 100 developing countries) proposed a detailed "New World Information Order." After negotiations, sections most offensive to the West were removed, including:
- "The right of peoples... to comprehensive and true information"
- "The right of each nation" to inform the world about its affairs
- "The right of each nation to protect its cultural and social identity against false or distorted information"
All participating nations accepted the document for the first time, though the United Kingdom stated it would have opposed the resolution had it come to a vote. The U.K. objected to the very idea of defining the new order.
Guidelines for the New Information Order
The assembly agreed on several guidelines:
- Elimination of imbalances and inequalities in the present solution
- Elimination of negative effects of certain monopolies and excessive concentrations
- Removal of obstacles to free flow and better balanced dissemination of information
- Plurality of sources and channels of information
- Freedom of the press and information
- Freedom of journalists – inseparable from responsibility
- Capacity of developing countries to improve their situations through own equipment, training personnel, improving infrastructure
- Sincere will of developed countries to help developing countries
- Respect for each people's cultural identity and right to inform the world about their interests, aspirations, and values
Western Backlash and Fallout
In May 1981, representatives from the U.S. and 20 other nations adopted the "Declaration of Talloires" in the French Alps, calling on UNESCO to "abandon attempts to regulate news content and formulate rules for the press."
In June, Elliott Abrams, assistant secretary of state for international organization affairs, charged that UNESCO had "lent itself to a massive assault on the free flow of information" and warned that if Director General M'Bow did not remain "neutral," he faced a battle with the U.S.
In 1984, the United States withheld contributions and withdrew from UNESCO in protest, followed by the United Kingdom in 1985 and Singapore in 1986. After a change in government, the UK rejoined in 1997, and the United States rejoined in 2003. As of 2007, Singapore had still not rejoined.
The attitude of media giants towards the New World Information and Communications Order and the MacBride Commission's report ultimately failed the idea, and it could not be implemented practically.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Mass media serves a critical watchdog function in democratic societies, acting as a bridge between government and citizens by reflecting public opinion and holding officials accountable. The lecture distinguishes between two media policy roles: agenda setting, where media helps shape policy by proposing solutions (as seen in the US-Vietnam War), and agenda following, where media merely implements government decisions (as seen in the 1971 Pak-India War, which had disastrous consequences). Historical failures of information access in Pakistan, such as the secret Hamood-ur-Rehman Commission report, highlight the importance of citizens' right to know. The UNESCO-led New World Information and Communication Order attempted to break Western media monopoly and give developing countries a voice, but faced intense opposition from Western nations and media giants, leading to US and UK withdrawal from UNESCO and the eventual failure of the initiative.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two ways mass media plays a part in policy making, and how do they differ?
- How did mass media's agenda setting function influence the outcome of the US-Vietnam War?
- What was the outcome of mass media playing an agenda following role during the 1971 Pak-India War?
- What were the key provisions of the New World Information and Communication Order proposed by the Group of 77 at UNESCO's Belgrade conference?
- Why did the United States and United Kingdom withdraw from UNESCO in the 1980s, and what was the result for the New World Information Order?
📘 Lecture 45 — Effect of Other Organizations on Mass Media and Its Performance
📖 Overview: This lecture explores how various organizations and institutions influence mass media’s working and performance in Pakistan. It covers the government’s relationship with media, key journalist and newspaper bodies (PFUJ, CPNE, APNS, APNEC), film and television associations, and the legal frameworks surrounding freedom of expression, including constitutional provisions and the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the government’s influence on mass media, then details five main Pakistani organizations that affect media: PFUJ (Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists), CPNE (Council of Pakistan Newspaper’s Editors), APNS (All Pakistan Newspapers Society), APNEC (All Pakistan Newspapers Employees Configuration), and film/television associations. It concludes with an examination of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948), Article 19, and the Constitution of Pakistan 1973’s Article 19 regarding freedom of expression.
📝 Lecture Summary
Effect of Other Organizations on Mass Media and Its Performance
Mass media both influences society and is influenced by societal organizations. The government is the primary institution that influences media. In totalitarian societies, governments seek to control media due to a lack of belief in press freedom and people’s right to know. Mass media has two major responsibilities: as a mirror of society and as a watchdog. Conflict between government and media typically arises over the watchdog role, as governments dislike criticism of their policies. The intensity of this clash varies across societies.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding government-media tension is fundamental to analyzing press freedom in any country.
PFUJ
Pakistan Federal Union of Journalists (PFUJ), located in Islamabad, is arguably South Asia’s first national journalists’ association. It was established in 1950 and has consistently stood for freedom of speech and democratic values. It was set up primarily to improve working conditions for Pakistani journalists and has been at the forefront of civil society struggles.
In 1959, the government appointed the Press Commission of Pakistan to examine journalists’ financial conditions. Based on its report, the first Wage Board for journalists was formed in 1963. This board directed newspapers on minimum wages, dividing newspapers into three categories by circulation, with corresponding wage categories for journalists, and recommended wage revisions every three years. PFUJ drove this creation, and by 2005 was working to implement the 7th Wage Board.
Another key PFUJ issue is Freedom of Press, essential for democracy, transparency, and free access to information (people’s right to know). PFUJ continues to fight against restrictive press and publication laws inherited from the British Raj. The current media freedom is largely attributed to PFUJ’s efforts and sacrifices.
CPNE
The Council of Pakistan Newspaper’s Editors (CPNE) was established in 1955 as a representative body of newspaper editors.
Initially, editors were professional journalists, not owners. However, after the RPPO (Registration of Printing Presses and Publications Ordinance) was enforced, a trend emerged where newspaper owners became editors or appointed close relatives. This has negatively affected newspaper policies and overall quality journalism in Pakistan. Owner-editors may avoid publishing news that could offend political parties, advertisers, or the government to protect business interests, whereas a professional editor prioritizes truth over business concerns. This dual role has compromised the gatekeeper’s responsibility of editors, who now sometimes suppress true, important news to avoid business damage. This trend has damaged quality journalism.
APNS
All Pakistan Newspapers Society (APNS) is a proprietors’ association founded in 1953 by major editors and publishers to facilitate exchange of views and protect newspapers’ rights. Elections are held annually, with three major groups as key players: Jang Group, Dawn Group, and Nawa-i-Waqt Group.
Today, APNS serves as a clearing house safeguarding commercial interests of members, including tax payment matters. For example, if an advertiser refuses to pay, APNS issues an ultimatum: pay or get blacklisted. Since many owners are also editors, they are often members of both CPNE and APNS, causing a clash of objectives that affects newspapers and journalism.
APNEC
All Pakistan Newspapers Employees Configuration (APNEC) is an active organization similar to PFUJ. Newspapers employ not only working journalists but also workers in printing press, computer lab, advertising, marketing, circulation, accounts, and other departments. These employees cannot join PFUJ, so they formed separate unions. APNEC is a configuration of all these unions, formed in 1970s to preserve employees’ rights and demands. Journalists are also part of this organization.
Film
Film producers formed an association to preserve their rights, but it is quite inactive due to lack of unity. Despite many problems, such as the Censor Board issue where serious topics cannot be addressed due to censorship, the association has not taken serious united action, causing the film industry to face its worst period.
Television
While Pakistan now has many private channels alongside state-owned PTV, there is no collective union for TV channels or their employees, especially in the private sector. PTV, being a state channel, permits employee unions. Private sector employees have formed associations to preserve rights and fight for freedom of expression. Many important subjects are banned on state channels, and producers/writers cannot address them despite their importance. Freedom of Expression and People’s Right to Know remain the biggest problems for Pakistani mass media.
Universal Declaration of Human Rights (1948)
On December 10, 1948, the UN General Assembly adopted the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, calling on member countries to publicize and disseminate the text, especially in schools.
Article 19: “Everyone has the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.”
Till 2002, this basic right was not accepted in Pakistan.
Constitution of Pakistan 1973 – Article 19
“Every citizen shall have the right of freedom of speech and expression, and there shall be freedom of the press, subject to any reasonable restrictions imposed by law in the interest of the glory of Islam or the integrity, security, or defense of Pakistan or any part thereof, friendly relations with foreign states, public order, decency or morality or in relation to the contempt of court, defamation or incitement to an office.”
Note: Conditions are vague and can be exploited by the government against journalists or media.
During the caretaker government of Malik Mairaj Khalid (Nov. 1996 – Feb. 1997), Information Minister Javed Jabbar introduced a “Right to know” ordinance, but the next government did not forward it to the assembly, so it died.
In October 2002, under pressure from international donors, General Musharaf’s government hurriedly promulgated the Freedom of Information Ordinance, bypassing parliament—indicating a negative government attitude toward the issue. While the law has serious flaws, it has been appreciated as a first step toward ensuring complete press freedom.
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture emphasizes that mass media in Pakistan is deeply influenced by multiple organizations: government (which often conflicts with media’s watchdog role), journalist unions (PFUJ), editor bodies (CPNE), proprietor associations (APNS), and employee unions (APNEC). A major concern is the shift from professional editors to owner-editors, which compromises gatekeeping and journalism quality. Additionally, the film and television sectors lack effective unions, hindering freedom of expression. The lecture underscores that Pakistan’s constitutional protection of press freedom (Article 19) is conditional and vague, and the 2002 Freedom of Information Ordinance, though flawed, represents an initial step. The core problem remains the incomplete realization of people’s right to know and freedom of expression.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two major responsibilities of mass media in any society?
- What was the purpose of the first Wage Board for journalists in 1963, and which organization’s efforts led to its creation?
- How has the trend of owner-editors negatively affected quality journalism in Pakistan?
- What is APNS, and what role does it play for member publications?
- According to the lecture, what are the main flaws in Pakistan’s constitutional protection of freedom of the press (Article 19)?