๐ Lecture 23 โ STATE OF MEDIA IN DIFFERENT SOCIETIES
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how mass media functions differently across various societal systems, examining the four major press theories that define media-state relationships. It is essential for understanding why media operates with varying degrees of freedom and responsibility globally, and how these frameworks impact democracy and governance.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing the importance of accountability and free mass media for democracy. It then introduces the Four Theories of the Press (1956) by Siebert, Peterson & Schramm, detailing each: Authoritarian Theory (16th-17th century origins, government control), Libertarian Theory (post-1688 England, individual freedom), Social Responsibility Theory (1947 Hutchins Commission, ethical obligations), and Soviet Communist Theory (USSR, state instrument). Each theory is examined in terms of development, philosophy, purpose, ownership, control mechanisms, and assumptions.
๐ Lecture Summary
STATE OF MEDIA IN DIFFERENT SOCIETIES
For good democracy, accountability and free mass media are essential. Mass media acts as a watchdog and a mirror of society. Accountability requires transparency, which mass media provides. However, due to its power to influence society, mass media must operate within ethical boundaries. Journalists are now asked to be as objective as possible (not at every cost as before). Pakistan has not yet succeeded in creating a code of ethics for journalists.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these theories explains why media in different countries reports the same event so differentlyโit's not just bias but fundamentally different philosophical systems.
AUTHORITARIAN THEORY
The Authoritarian doctrine determined mass communication patterns for more people over a longer period than any other theory.
Development: Evolved in 16th & 17th century Europe; still practiced in many places. Fred S. Siebert stated that for almost 200 years after printing spread, authoritarianism was the exclusive basis for press function and relationship to society.
Who owns the media? Printing remains mostly in private hands, but broadcasting and cinema remain in government hands.
Main Purpose: To support and advance the policies of the government in power and to serve the state.
How are the media controlled? Through government patents, guilds, licensing, and sometimes censorship.
Authoritarian Assumptions:
- Press should do nothing to undermine vested powers
- Press should be subordinated to vested power and authority
- Press should avoid contravening prevailing moral and political values
- Censorship justified in applying these principles
- Criminalization of editorial attacks on vested power, deviations from official policy, moral code violations
- Media as instrument/mouthpiece to publicize and propagandize government ideology
- Absolute state power versus subservience of the individualโpress "freedom" is a right vested in the state
๐ Example: Germany under Hitler and Italy under Mussolini are historical examples of authoritarian media control.
LIBERTARIAN THEORY
Development: Adopted in England after 1688. The best early expression is Areopagitica, an essay by John Milton (1644) arguing for intellectual freedom without government control. Milton wrote: "let her (truth) and falsehood grapple; who ever knew truth put to the worse, in a free and open encounter?"
In America, Thomas Jefferson was the best example of libertarian thought. In 1787 he wrote preferring "newspapers without a government" over "government without newspapers." He also said: "Eternal vigilance is the price of liberty."
The best spokesman was John Stuart Mill (1806-1873), who wrote On Liberty (1859) arguing that human errors are corrigible.
Philosophy: Writings of Milton, Mill, rationalism, and natural rights. This theory views man as rational and able to discern truth from falsehood. Man can determine his own destiny and, given all facts, will make the right choice.
Main purpose: To inform, entertain, sellโbut chiefly to help discover truth and to keep check on the government.
Who has the right to use the media? Anyone with economic means to do so.
How are the media controlled? By the 'self-right process of truth' in the 'free market place of ideas' and by courts.
Ownership: Chiefly private.
Classical liberal perspective:
- Free market as foundation of free media
- Freedom to publish without prior restrictionโindependence from government
- Public has access to wide diversity of opinion (only limitation is public willingness to pay)
- Market-based diversity promotes rationalityโfree marketplace of ideas as self-righting mechanism
Another strand in liberal tradition:
- Media as "Fourth pillar of the state" (alongside executive, legislative, judicial) or as watchdog
- Watchdog reveals abuses of state authorityโthis role overrides all other functions
- "The best stories are those that afflict the comfortable and comfort the afflicted" (Peter Beaumont & John Sweeney, The Observer)
- Objectivity: As newspapers lost party affiliations, journalists sought "objective truth"
- Independence from government is essential
Libertarian Assumptions:
- Press should be free from any external censorship
- Publication/distribution accessible to any individual/group with permit or license
- Attacks on governments/parties should not be punishable
- No coercion to publish anything
- Freedom of access to information
๐ Definition โ Libertarian Theory: A press theory emphasizing individual freedom, rationality, and minimal government control, where truth emerges from the free marketplace of ideas.
SOCIAL RESPONSIBILITY THEORY
Development: Hutchins Commission, 1947 reaffirmed freedom/independence but added social responsibility. Practiced in the US in the 20th century.
Purpose: To inform, entertain, sell, but also to raise conflict to the plane of discussion.
Who owns the media? Private ownership.
Philosophy: An outgrowth of libertarian theory, but goes beyond "objective" reporting to "interpretive" reporting. The Commission on Freedom of the Press noted: "It is no longer enough to report the fact truthfully. It is now necessary to report the truth about the fact."
The Commission (1940) viewed man as not so much irrational as lethargicโcapable of using reason but loath to do so. The more alert elements of the community must goad him into exercising his reason.
Responsibility of Press: The press must be the "more alert element" and keep the public informed, as an informed populace is the cornerstone of democracy. Large media conglomerates may not function naturally as a public forum.
Siebert, Peterson & Schramm warned that the power and near-monopoly position of media imposes an obligation to be socially responsible, ensuring all sides are fairly presented. If media fails, some other agency may enforce it. Freedom of expression is not an absolute rightโit must be balanced against private rights and vital social interests.
Solutions to reconciling freedom with responsibility:
- Regulation: Promotion of political/cultural pluralism, independent public institutions for broadcasting control, balance of public and private ownership
- Professionalism: Codes of conduct, training and development for balanced/impartial news
More principles (Denis McQuail):
- Media should accept responsibilities towards society
- Media should set professional standards for truth, accuracy, objectivity, balance
- Media should apply self-regulation
- Media should avoid publicizing information leading to crime, violence, social disruption, or offending ethnic/religious minorities
- Media should represent all social groups and reflect diversity
- Society entitled to high standards; intervention justifiable if media fails
๐ Definition โ Social Responsibility Theory: A press theory holding that media has obligations to society, must balance freedom with responsibility, and should provide interpretive reporting beyond mere facts.
๐ Example: It would not be socially responsible to report how a terrorist evaded security to smuggle a bomb onto an airline, as this could enable future attacks.
SOVIET COMMUNIST THEORY
Development: Developed in the Soviet Union (some similar practices by Nazis).
Purpose: To contribute to the success and continuance of the Soviet socialist system, especially the dictatorship of the party.
Who owns the media? Public ownership.
Assumptions:
- Media should act in the interests of and be controlled by the working class
- Media should not be under private control
- Media should perform positive functions: socialization (making people conform), education, information supply, motivation, mobilization of the masses
- Media should respond to desires/needs of recipients
More assumptions:
- Society has right to use censorship and legal measures to prevent/ punish antisocial publication
- Media should reflect complete and objective view using Marxist-Leninist principles
- Media should support communist movements everywhere
๐ Definition โ Soviet Communist Theory: A press theory where media is publicly owned and serves as an instrument of the state to support the socialist system and party dictatorship.
๐ก Why this matters: While the Soviet Union no longer exists, elements of this theory persist in various authoritarian and socialist states today, influencing how they control information.
โญ Key Takeaways
The Four Theories of the Press provide a foundational framework for understanding media systems globally. Authoritarian theory subjugates media to state control, prioritizing government policy over public information. Libertarian theory champions individual rationality and a free marketplace of ideas, viewing media as a watchdog against government abuse. Social Responsibility theory modifies libertarianism by requiring media to be socially responsible, interpretative, and self-regulating, balancing freedom with ethical obligations. Soviet Communist theory treats media as a state instrument for socialization, education, and mobilization under Marxist-Leninist principles. For exam purposes, remember the key authors (Siebert, Peterson, Schramm), dates (1956, 1644, 1787, 1859, 1947), and the specific assumptions and control mechanisms for each theory.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to the lecture, what are the two most important requirements for good democracy?
- What is the fundamental difference between how libertarian and social responsibility theories view human rationality?
- Who wrote Areopagitica in 1644, and what was its main argument?
- Under which theory would a journalist be required to "report the truth about the fact" rather than just "report the fact truthfully"?
- What is the role of the "self-righting process of truth" in the libertarian theory of press control?
๐ Lecture 24 โ RADIO BROADCASTING โ A BIG DEVELOPMENT IN MASS COMMUNICATION
๐ Overview: This lecture traces the historical development of radio broadcasting from its early experimental days through the First World War to modern digital transmissions. It examines how radio evolved from a novelty into a powerful tool for propaganda, politics, and mass communication, with special focus on its development in the subcontinent and Pakistan. Understanding this evolution is crucial because radio remains one of the most effective communication media in developing countries with low literacy rates.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the early history of audio broadcasting from 1915 to the 1950s, including key milestones like the first regular broadcasts, the invention of AM and FM radio, and the role of patent wars among companies like Westinghouse, GE, and RCA. It then discusses later 20th century developments including transistor radios, satellite communication, and digital broadcasting. The political use of radio is examined from the 1924 US Presidential elections onward. Finally, the lecture provides a detailed chronology of radio broadcasting in the subcontinent from 1926 to 1947, followed by the complete history of Radio Pakistan from independence through 1996, concluding with an analysis of radio's effectiveness as a communication medium in Pakistan.
๐ Lecture Summary
Audio broadcasting (1915 to 1950s)
The lecture begins by explaining that before the First World War, newspapers were the major communication medium. After the communist revolution in Russia, Russian Radio began using radio to propagate communist ideology worldwide, as radio has no physical boundaries. This made European and American leaders angry, realizing the power of electronic media to cross borders and achieve political goals.
The chronological development begins with 1916: First regular broadcasts on 9XM (now WHA) delivering Wisconsin state weather in Morse Code. In 1919, the first clear transmission of human speech occurred on 9XM after experiments with voice (1918) and music (1917). 1920 saw regular wireless broadcasts for entertainment begin in Argentina, pioneered by Enrique Telรฉmaco Susini's group, and spark-gap telegraphy stopped.
๐ Definition โ Commercial broadcasting license: On 20 August 1920, E.W. Scripps's WWJ in Detroit received its commercial broadcasting license and started broadcasting with a regular schedule continuing to the present. Initially broadcasting was not supported by advertising; stations owned by manufacturers and department stores were established to sell radios, while newspaper-owned stations sold papers and expressed owners' opinions.
๐ Example: On 31 August 1920, the first known radio news program was broadcast by station 8MK, the unlicensed predecessor of WWJ (AM) in Detroit, Michigan.
In October 1920, Westinghouse in Pittsburgh became the first US commercial broadcasting station to be licensed with call letters KDKA. Their engineer Frank Conrad had been broadcasting from his own station since 1916. In 1922, regular wireless broadcasts for entertainment began in the UK from the Marconi Research Centre at Writtle near Chelmsford, England.
๐ Formula: Early radios ran the entire power of the transmitter through a carbon microphone โ This meant the microphone had to handle all transmission power directly.
In the mid-1920s, amplifying vacuum tubes revolutionized radio receivers and transmitters; Westinghouse engineers improved them. Before this, the commonest receiver was the crystal set, though some early radios used electric current or battery amplification. Inventions of the triode amplifier, generator, and detector enabled audio radio. Fessenden and Lee de Forest pioneered amplitude-modulated radio (AM radio) , allowing more than one station to send signals, unlike spark-gap radio where one transmitter covered the entire bandwidth.
๐ก Why this matters: AM radio's ability to allow multiple stations on different frequencies was a fundamental breakthrough that enabled the broadcast industry as we know it today.
Westinghouse joined the patent allies group comprising General Electric, American Telephone and Telegraph, and Radio Corporation of America (RCA), becoming a part owner of RCA. All radios made by GE and Westinghouse were sold under the RCA label (60% GE, 40% Westinghouse). ATT's Western Electric built radio transmitters. The patent allies attempted to set up a monopoly but failed due to successful competition. Several contracts for inventor's patents held clauses protecting "amateurs" and allowing them to use the patents.
Early 1930s: Single sideband (SSB) and frequency modulation (FM) were invented by amateur radio operators, becoming established commercial modes by 1940.
Key features that arose during this period included: commercial (United States) or governmental (Europe) station networks, the Federal Radio Commission, the Federal Communications Commission, birth of the soap opera, and the race towards shorter waves and FM.
๐ Formula: FM radio (Frequency Modulation) uses frequency modulation of the radio wave to minimize static and interference from electrical equipment and the atmosphere in the audio program โ This made FM superior to AM for sound quality.
๐ Definition: FM radio was patented in 1933 by Edwin H. Armstrong. In 1937, the first experimental FM radio station was granted a construction permit by the FCC. In the 1940s, standard analog television transmissions started in North America and Europe.
๐ Example: In 1943, Tesla's patent (number 645576) was reinstated by the U.S. Supreme Court shortly after Tesla's death, because prior art existed before Marconi's patent was established. This decision may have let the U.S. government avoid paying damages that the Marconi Company claimed for using its patents during World War I.
After World War II, FM radio broadcast was introduced in Germany. In 1948, a new wavelength plan was set up for Europe at a meeting in Copenhagen. Germany was not invited and was only given a few medium-wave frequencies (not good for broadcasting), so Germany began broadcasting on USW ("ultra short wave," now called VHF). After amplitude modulation experience with VHF, it was realized that FM radio was a much better alternative for VHF radio than AM.
Later 20th century developments
Early 1960s: VOR systems finally became widespread; before that, aircraft used commercial AM radio stations for navigation. (AM stations are still marked on U.S. aviation charts.)
1954: Regency introduced a pocket transistor radio, the TR-1, powered by a "standard 22.5V Battery." 1960: Sony introduced their first transistorized radio, small enough to fit in a vest pocket and able to be powered by a small battery. It was durable because there were no tubes to burn out. Over the next twenty years, transistors displaced tubes almost completely except for very high power or very high frequency uses.
1963: Color television was commercially transmitted, and the first (radio) communication satellite, TELSTAR, was launched. In the late 1960s, the U.S. long-distance telephone network began converting to a digital network, employing digital radios for many links.
1970s: LORAN became the premier radio navigation system. Soon, the U.S. Navy experimented with satellite navigation. 1987: The GPS constellation of satellites was launched.
Early 1990s: Amateur radio experimenters began using personal computers with audio cards to process radio signals. 1994: The U.S. Army and DARPA launched an aggressive successful project to construct a software radio that could become a different radio on the fly by changing software. Late 1990s: Digital transmissions began to be applied to broadcasting.
Radio for political purposes
When radio first started, no one thought about politics because radio was viewed as just another novelty. Getting politics on the air was a slow process. For political purposes, it was first used in USA in the US Presidential Elections 1924.
Through mid-1924, shortwave was still seen as an inconsistent novelty even by engineers, and few believed it could ever be used reliably for daytime long-distance broadcasting.
๐ Example: On October 11, the H.J. Heinz Company of Pittsburgh celebrated its 55th anniversary. Ten thousand employees sat down in 65 banquet halls across the US and Great Britain. President Coolidge was the featured speaker from Washington D.C. The president's speech was carried by landline to KDKA then broadcast over shortwave. This was the first time such a broadcast had been attempted, and millions in the Americas and Europe are believed to have heard it.
When the 1924 campaign began, no one knew radio's value as a weapon in the campaign war chest. For millions, hearing the voices of the candidates was uniqueโit couldn't be duplicated in silent movies or newspapers. Many questioned how they could know if there was an audience listening and if their message was reaching them. By the end of the campaign, these questions were answered. It was clear that radio had improved politics and furthermore politics had improved radio.
Radio Broadcast in sub-continent
March 1926: Indian Broadcasting Company (IBC) , a private company, was formed in Bombay. 23rd July 1927: IBC launched its transmission. 1928: A small transmitting station was set up at Lahore. April 1930: Broadcasting went under direct control of Government and IBC was changed to Indian State Broadcasting Service. Jan. 1934: The Indian Wireless Telegraphy Act 1933 came into force.
Jan. 1935: Peshawar Radio Station was set up by NWFP Government with a 250 watts transmitter. Jan. 1936: Delhi Radio Station was opened, with A.S. Bukhari appointed as its 1st Station Director. Jun 1936: Indian State Broadcasting Service was changed into All India Radio. Dec 1937: Lahore station went on air. 1939: Dhaka Radio station was opened.
Radio Broadcast in Pakistan
Aug 14, 1947: Pakistan comes into being and the announcement of its creation is made by the new organization, the Pakistan Broadcasting Service, which comes into existence at the same time and is later designated as Radio Pakistan.
When Pakistan came into being, it had three radio stations: Lahore, Peshawar, and Dhaka. Setting up of further radio stations continued:
| Year | Station | Details |
|---|---|---|
| 1948 | Rawalpindi-3 Radio Station | 500 watts shortwave transmitter |
| 1948 | Karachi Radio station | 100 watts shortwave transmitter |
| 1949 | Rawalpindi station | 100 watts Medium wave transmitter |
| 1950 | Karachi Radio Station | (details not specified) |
| 1951 | Hyderabad Radio Station | 1 KW/ SW transmitter |
| Oct 1956 | Quetta Radio Station | 1 KW/ SW Transmitter |
| Oct 1960 | Rawalpindi-2 Radio Station | 1KW/ SW Transmitter |
| 1970 | Staff training and technical training school | At Islamabad |
| 1970 | Multan Radio Station | 120 KW/ MW |
| 20 Dec.1972 | Pakistan Broadcasting Corporation (PBC) | Radio Pakistan converted into PBC |
| April 1973 | World service | For overseas Pakistanis |
| 1974 | Khairpur Radio station | 100 KW |
| August 1975 | Bhawalpur Radio Station | 10 KW/ MW |
| 1977 | Islamabad Radio Station | In new national Broadcasting house, 1000 KW/ MW transmitter |
| 1977 | Skardu Radio Station | 250 W/MW |
| 1981 | Turbat Radio Station | 250 W/MW |
| 1981 | D.I. Khan Radio Station | 10 KW/MW |
| 1981 | Khuzdar Radio Station | 250 W/MW |
| Sept 1982 | Faislabad Radio Station | 250 W/MW |
| May 1986 | New BH at Khairpur | (new Broadcasting House) |
| 1989 | Sibi Relay Station | 250 W Trans |
| 1989 | Abbotabad Relay Station | 250 W/Trans |
| Aug 1993 | Chittral Radio Station | 1 KW/FM Trans |
| 1996 | Loralai Radio Station | 10 KW/MW |
| 1996 | Zhob Radio Station | 10 KW/MW |
Radio as an effective medium of communication
As the 2nd World War began, radio showed its effectiveness in a much better way, making its place in the mechanical world as an important invention. Radio performed two important jobs in this war: First, it was the best medium to transmit and provide latest information regarding different warfronts. Secondly, it was used as a tool to conduct psychological warโboosting the morale of your own people and demoralizing the enemy.
Before independence, there was no concept of private ownership in broadcasting as the British government was sensitive towards electronic media and could not afford to risk allowing people to own radio stations. This is also why newspapers played an active part in the Pakistan Movement while no radio station's contribution is recorded.
Before partition, radio was used more as a medium of entertainment, and even in the early years of independence it did more in the entertainment section. Radio Pakistan's contribution in promoting music in all its forms and singers is really acknowledging. In the news section, being a state-owned organization, it has always followed government's policies and worked as a government's mouthpiece.
๐ Example: As Pakistan is a developing country with low literacy rate, radio has been a very effective medium of communication (information and education). In remote and rural areas where newspapers could not reach or where electricity is not available and people cannot watch television, radio is still the best medium. Radio is very cheap and in the form of a transistor can be taken anywhere, making it possible for a person to be aware of world events even from a warfront.
However, radio has one disadvantage: it makes it difficult for broadcasters to address complex issues or use difficult language. Radio, like telephone, is a time-consuming channel of communication, so the speed of comprehension is always in the performer's hand, making it impossible to send complex messages. This is why among broadcasting standards, one standard is the use of simple language and precise messages.
Till the 1960s when TV was not introduced, radio was a very popular medium in both rural and urban areas of the country. Now it is more listened to in rural areas, with the exception of FM radio channels that are equally appreciated and listened to in cities.
โญ Key Takeaways
Radio broadcasting evolved from experimental Morse code transmissions in 1916 to become a powerful mass medium that transcended national boundaries, as demonstrated when Russia used radio to spread communist ideology. The key technological developments include the transition from spark-gap to AM radio (allowing multiple stations), the invention of FM radio by Edwin Armstrong in 1933 (offering superior sound quality), and the transistor revolution starting in 1954 that made radios portable and affordable. For Pakistan specifically, radio began with just three stations at independence in 1947 (Lahore, Peshawar, Dhaka) and expanded into a nationwide network under the Pakistan Broadcasting Corporation (established 1972). Radio remains most effective in developing countries with low literacy rates because it is cheap, portable, and does not require electricity or reading ability, though it is limited by requiring simple language and being unsuitable for complex messages.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
-
What were the two major jobs radio performed during World War II?
-
How many radio stations did Pakistan inherit at the time of independence in 1947, and what were their names?
-
What was the significance of Edwin H. Armstrong's 1933 invention, and how does it differ technically from AM?
-
Why did Germany begin broadcasting on USW (VHF) after the 1948 Copenhagen wavelength plan?
-
What was the name of the organization that replaced Radio Pakistan on 20 December 1972?
๐ Lecture 25 โ Radio in Pakistan I
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the pivotal role of Radio Pakistan from the country's independence through the 1960s, focusing on its contributions during national crises and wars. It explores how radio served as a vital communication tool for national unity, emotional support for refugees, and psychological warfare during the 1965 war with India, while also addressing the medium's unique characteristics and programming formats.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with Radio Pakistan's immediate post-independence role in rehabilitating refugees and reuniting separated families, followed by its crucial psychological operations during the 1965 Pak-India war. It then examines the medium's decline in credibility during Ayub Khan's era when it became a government mouthpiece, before discussing popular programming formats including radio dramas and children's programs, and concludes with an analysis of radio's unique characteristics as a sound-only medium requiring broadcast-quality voices and parallel messages.
๐ Lecture Summary
Radio's Role After Independence
Immediately after Pakistan's independence, the nation faced numerous challenges that required immediate communication solutions. Newspapers were impractical as they took 24 hours to produce, but radio stepped forward and played a devoted role in addressing these challenges. A major challenge was rehabilitating migrating people from India who needed both physical shelter and emotional consolation. Children, women, and elderly people arrived in devastating conditions. Radio Pakistan broadcast special programmes for them and made special announcements to help reunite separated family members, which would have been impossible for the administration of the newborn state to accomplish otherwise.
๐ก Why this matters: This demonstrates how radio, as an instantaneous mass medium, was uniquely positioned to serve emergency communication needs that print media could not fulfill.
Radio's Role in the 1965 War
Radio Pakistan is saluted for its role in the 1965 Pak-India war, where it produced two different types of programs. The first type aimed to keep the morale of the nation and military forces high, while the second type was designed to demoralize the enemy country, its public, and military forces who relied on Radio Pakistan for news and updates.
The lecture explains that in the modern world, a country cannot win a war merely through military force, arms, or ammunition. The morale of the enemy country and its people is equally important. Modern wars are fought with military and media on parallel scales.
๐ Example โ America-Vietnam War: Americans, although a super power, lost the war because their strategists failed to break the commitment and resistance of Vietnamese who had such high morale they refused to give up. Meanwhile, American people were not supporting their government and were protesting against their government's and military's actions and decisions.
Psychological Operations in 1965 War
In the 1965 war, Radio Pakistan worked on psychological grounds and through its music and special programs for people and soldiers, kept providing strong moral support to the nation. It also broadcast propaganda programs for Indian people, particularly for Eastern Punjab of India.
๐ Definition โ Propaganda: Information, especially of a biased or misleading nature, used to promote a political cause or point of view, aimed at influencing the psychology of the target audience.
๐ Example: On September 9, 1965, the Indian government had to announce that under the Defense Act of India, anyone found listening to Radio Pakistan would be given three years imprisonment. This shows that Radio Pakistan's propaganda programs were very successful and had more credibility than All India Radio, which had already lost its credibility by giving false news of Lahore's occupation at the early stages of the war.
๐ก Why this matters: This illustrates how credibility is a strategic asset in wartime communication, and how one erroneous broadcast can destroy a media organization's trustworthiness.
Radio Under Ayub Khan's Era
In Ayub Khan's era, Radio Pakistan, being a state-controlled medium of communication, worked as a government's mouthpiece and started losing its credibility in the eyes of the public. Particularly in 1968, when Radio Pakistan celebrated 10 Years of Progress with the government, it was very difficult for people to absorb these celebrations as reality because what they were seeing with their own eyes contradicted what was being broadcast.
๐ก Why this matters: This demonstrates the fundamental problem of state-controlled mediaโwhen propaganda diverges from observable reality, the medium loses public trust and becomes ineffective.
Popular Radio Programming Formats
Till the 1960s and even before partition, the most popular format of radio was Radio Drama. Radio Pakistan performed very well in producing dramas and was fortunate to have big names like Rafi Peer, Imtiaz Ali Taj, etc., in its very early days. The artists who worked in that golden era of Radio Pakistan are still as famous as they used to be at that time.
Children's Programs of Radio Pakistan were also very popular. Moni Hameed, who worked as host of children's programs on Radio Pakistan and even in Undivided India's radio, is still remembered for her beautiful and perfect voice.
Radio as a Medium of Sound
Radio, being a medium of sound, has always given importance to the perfect voice of broadcast quality. The reason is that unlike other mediums of communication, the message delivered through radio has no parallel messages (body gestures, expressions, etc.) with it. Therefore, a perfect voice for broadcast is preferred and appreciated because it helps fill the space left by parallel messages.
๐ Definition โ Parallel Messages: Additional communication cues such as body language, facial expressions, and gestures that accompany verbal messages in face-to-face or visual communication.
๐ Example: Background music and sound effects, which are improving with time, are now used as parallel messages in radio broadcast to compensate for the lack of visual cues.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that Radio Pakistan played an irreplaceable role immediately after independence by providing emotional support and family reunification services for refugees when newspapers were too slow. In the 1965 war, radio proved that media is as crucial as military force in modern warfare, as demonstrated by India's decision to ban Radio Pakistan under penalty of imprisonment due to its effective psychological operations. The lecture clearly shows how state control during Ayub Khan's era destroyed radio's credibility, teaching that media must maintain independence to retain public trust. Radio drama was the dominant format before and after partition, with legendary artists like Rafi Peer and Imtiaz Ali Taj. Finally, radio's unique characteristic as a purely auditory medium means broadcast-quality voice and parallel messages (sound effects, background music) are essential for effective communication.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Why was radio more suitable than newspapers for addressing Pakistan's immediate post-independence challenges?
- What two types of programs did Radio Pakistan produce during the 1965 war, and what was each designed to achieve?
- What action did the Indian government take on September 9, 1965 regarding Radio Pakistan, and why does this demonstrate the effectiveness of Pakistan's propaganda?
- How did Radio Pakistan's role as a state-controlled mouthpiece during Ayub Khan's era affect its credibility, and what specific event in 1968 highlighted this problem?
- Why is a "perfect voice of broadcast quality" particularly important for radio compared to other communication mediums, and what are "parallel messages" in this context?
๐ Lecture 26 โ Radio in Pakistan II
๐ Overview: This lecture examines Radio Pakistanโs role during the Ayub Khan era, its failure in fostering national integration between East and West Pakistan, and the potential of radio for development communication. It highlights how state-controlled media failed to unite the nation and how radio could be leveraged for agricultural and educational development.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the political context of General Ayub Khanโs regime and the anti-Ayub movement of 1968. It then critically analyzes Radio Pakistanโs failure in promoting national integration between East and West Pakistan. Finally, it discusses UNESCOโs recommendations for using radio in development communication and Radio Pakistanโs current capabilities in terms of languages and broadcast hours.
๐ Lecture Summary
General Ayub Khan's Regime and Public Resentment
General Ayub Khan concentrated political power in his own hands, controlled the press and media, imposed a state of emergency, and interfered in religion. These policies infuriated the public. In 1968, he celebrated a decade of his rule using state-owned newspapers and radio, making exaggerated claims about the countryโs development. By the end of 1968, public resentment reached a boiling point. An anti-Ayub movement was launched by the urban-middle class, including students, teachers, lawyers, doctors, and engineers. The Joint Labor Council called for a labor strike. Demonstrations and agitation swept the country, leading to a breakdown of law and order, forcing Ayub to step down.
National Integration
Pakistan, as a newborn state, had a strange territorial shape comprising two wings separated by 1400-1500 km of hostile territory. The two parts had different languages, cultures, and traditions; the only thing they shared was the Ideology of Pakistan. It was the responsibility of the countryโs leaders and mass media to bring the people of East and West Pakistan closer by introducing them to each otherโs cultures, traditions, and languages. Unfortunately, the stateโs media and leadership failed in this task. Radio Pakistan, instead of dividing its transmission into reasonable categories, divided its stations and responsibilities. Radio Pakistanโs Dhaka station transmitted programmes in Bengali, while stations in West Pakistan transmitted most programmes in Urdu, which most people in East Pakistan did not understand. Only a very small part of the transmission was in English, the common language of understanding between the two ends.
๐ Definition โ National Integration: The process of bringing people from different regions, cultures, and languages within a country together to build a harmonious relationship and a shared national identity. ๐ Example: Radio Pakistanโs Dhaka station broadcast in Bengali, while West Pakistani stations broadcast in Urdu. This linguistic divide meant East Pakistanis could not understand most West Pakistani broadcasts, and vice versa, failing to foster mutual understanding.
๐ก Why this matters: National integration is a major responsibility of mass media. Radio Pakistanโs failure to bridge the cultural and linguistic gap between the two wings contributed to the political tensions that eventually led to the separation of East Pakistan.
For a successful federation, people must be aware of each otherโs culture, background, and traditions. While newspapers were available, the lack of transportation and the distance between the two wings made them insufficient for this task. Radio was the only medium capable of achieving national integration, but it failed.
Radio and Development Communication
UNESCO suggested using mass media for development purposes, particularly in underdeveloped or developing countries. The best medium for this purpose was Radio. UNESCO invited all nations to join in this venture for the unshackling of menโs minds and the liberation of new technological, civic, and moral potential. The idea of a mass literacy campaign aroused interest worldwide. Two U.N. regional bodies โ the Economic Commissions for Africa and for Asia and the Far East โ met in Addis Ababa (February 1964) and Tehran (March 1964), adopting resolutions recommending that governments include adult literacy programmes in their national education plans as part of overall development.
Pakistan is an agricultural country. Radio can provide people in remote areas with information regarding modern farming, which can help in the countryโs overall development in the agriculture sector. In 1950, Japan invented transistor radios, which are now available in very small sizes, often requiring only one dry cell. After this invention, it became much easier to use radio for development purposes. People are conveyed messages through different programmes in their native languages and by favorite artists.
๐ Key Data: Radio Pakistan broadcasts programmes in 31 different languages (23 local and 8 international). Total broadcast hours of Radio Pakistan are 400 hours. Worldโs biggest broadcasters, Voice of America and BBC, have 1000 hours of broadcast on a daily basis in 70 different languages, which includes propaganda programmes.
โญ Key Takeaways
Radio Pakistan failed in its critical duty of national integration by broadcasting primarily in Urdu in West Pakistan and Bengali in East Pakistan, neglecting a common language like English for mutual understanding. This failure exacerbated cultural and political divides between the two wings. The lecture highlights that radio is uniquely suited for development communication in developing countries like Pakistan, especially for agricultural modernization. The invention of transistor radios made it highly accessible for reaching remote populations in their native languages. Currently, Radio Pakistan broadcasts 400 hours daily in 31 languages, a capacity that can be leveraged more effectively for national development.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What specific policies of General Ayub Khan led to public resentment and the anti-Ayub movement of 1968?
- How did Radio Pakistanโs broadcasting strategy fail to promote national integration between East and West Pakistan?
- Why was radio considered the best medium by UNESCO for development communication in underdeveloped countries?
- What technological innovation in 1950 made radio more accessible for development purposes?
- How many languages and total broadcast hours does Radio Pakistan currently operate with?
๐ Lecture 27 โ RADIO PAKISTAN โ SERVICES AND FORMATS
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the evolution of Radio Pakistan from an entertainment-focused medium to a comprehensive broadcasting service. It covers the various program formats and services offered by Radio Pakistan, including news, current affairs, entertainment programs, international broadcasts, and the role of its archives. Understanding these formats is crucial for grasping the diverse functions of state-controlled radio in Pakistan.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture details the different services and formats of Radio Pakistan, starting with the News department and its procedures for gathering and broadcasting bulletins. It then covers Current Affairs programming, which includes discussions and talk shows on national and international issues. The Entertainment section focuses on Radio Drama and Sports commentaries. Finally, the lecture explains International Broadcasts (World Service, External Service, and Propaganda) and the importance of the Radio Library/Archives.
๐ Lecture Summary
News
The News department is headed by the Director General News, who ensures that all news bulletins adhere to the channel's policy. As a state-controlled body, Radio Pakistan's news policy aligns with the government, making it a source for understanding the government's stance on issues. Initially broadcasting only a few bulletins daily, it now broadcasts a news bulletin every hour. The procedure involves reporters collecting news, which is sub-edited and selected for the bulletin. News is also received from international and national news agencies. For the central news bulletin from the Central Newsroom in Islamabad, news is re-edited and chosen for broadcast, featuring only the most important national and international stories. Radio news typically lacks the detail of newspapers, so insertions like a police officerโs statement or a foreign office spokespersonโs briefing are added.
๐ Definition โ State-controlled body: A media organization whose operations and policies are directly or indirectly managed and guided by the government. ๐ Example: When the public wants to know the government's official policy on an economic issue, they listen to Radio Pakistan's news bulletins.
Current Affairs
This format includes programmes like discussions, talk shows, interviews, seminars, and conferences. These programmes involve debate on hot or important international and national issues. The basic purpose is to keep people aware of the issues they face and to keep them updated. In these programmes, both sides of a picture are presented regarding a topic, and the decision is left to the public.
๐ Definition โ Current Affairs: Programmes that focus on discussing and analyzing recent or ongoing events of national and international importance. ๐ก Why this matters: Current affairs programmes fulfill radio's role as a public service by informing citizens and encouraging critical thinking on societal issues.
Entertainment Programs
1. Drama Radio drama is very different from TV drama. In radio drama, there are no parallel messages along with the main message; a voice artist must be very expert in dialogue delivery to convey the true sense of the message. Radio Pakistan benefitted from having excellent dramatists and performers from its early days.
๐ Definition โ Radio drama: A play performed exclusively with sound (dialogue, music, sound effects) without visual elements, requiring exceptional voice acting to convey conflict and emotion.
2. Sports Sports have always been part of Radio Broadcast. Vibrant running commentaries of the nation's favorite games added to radioโs popularity, especially before the arrival of TV. Even today, in many parts of the world without electricity or where people cannot afford TVs, they listen to radio commentaries of Cricket or Hockey matches.
๐ Definition โ Running commentary: A live, continuous description of an event (e.g., a sports match) as it happens, intended to create a vivid mental picture for the listener.
International Broadcasts
International broadcasts are divided into three categories:
- World Service for Overseas Pakistanis: Programmes designed to keep expatriates informed about their homeland, discussing local and national issues along with some entertainment-based programmes.
- External Service: Broadcast in almost all important international languages. These aim at building and improving Pakistanโs image internationally and building better relations with foreign nations.
- Propaganda Broadcast: These broadcasts are aimed at demoralizing or provoking rival nations and their people against their own governments.
๐ Definition โ External Service: Radio broadcasts targeted at foreign audiences in their own languages, designed to foster a positive image of the broadcasting country.
Radio Library/ Archives
The Library is the richest place in Radio Pakistan. Its archives contain everything: Quaid-e-Azamโs speeches, addresses from political leaders, interviews of important personalities, and musical archives and dramas, kept in the form of audio cassettes and CDs. Radio Pakistan became commercial in the 1970s by involving itself in advertising and sponsorships. Today, a program's popularity is linked to commercial success, as ratings determine which programs get more ads.
๐ Definition โ Archives: A collection of historical documents, records, or (in this case) audio recordings that are preserved for their long-term value and historical significance.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are the distinct formats of Radio Pakistan. News is state-controlled and aims to present the government's official stance. Current Affairs programming offers balanced debate on key issues, leaving judgment to the audience. Radio drama is a unique art form that relies entirely on sound and voice acting. International broadcasts serve multiple diplomatic functions, from connecting with overseas Pakistanis to propaganda. Finally, the radio archives are an invaluable historical resource, and commercialism (advertising) now drives program popularity through ratings.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary role of the Director General News at Radio Pakistan?
- How does radio drama fundamentally differ from television drama?
- What are the three main categories of International Broadcasts by Radio Pakistan?
- Besides entertainment, what is the core purpose of current affairs programmes on Radio Pakistan?
- In what decade did Radio Pakistan become a commercial medium by involving itself in advertising and sponsorships?