π Lecture 43 β Electronic Transactions Ordinance, 2002 (ETO) (Continuedβ¦)
π Overview: This lecture continues the detailed discussion of the Electronic Transactions Ordinance, 2002 (ETO), focusing on the accreditation of certification service providers, the requirements for a Certification Practice Statement (CPS), and the types of documents exempted from the ordinance. It also covers the jurisdiction of Pakistani courts over relevant matters and outlines the specific offences and their punishments under the ETO.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Section 24 (accreditation of certification service providers), Section 25 (Certification Practice Statement requirements), the five types of documents exempt from the ETO under Section 31 (including negotiable instruments, wills, and property contracts), the overriding jurisdiction of Pakistani courts under Sections 32 and 33, and finally, the four categories of offences under Sections 34-37, including false information by subscribers, dishonest issuance of certificates, unauthorized access, and unauthorized data alteration.
π Lecture Summary
Accreditation of Certification Service Providers (Section 24)
Section 24 of the ETO empowers the Certification Council to grant accreditation to certification service providers. The Council specifies the criteria and procedure for granting these certificates through regulations. The accreditation process covers the provider's cryptography services, electronic or advanced electronic signatures, and security procedures. The terms and conditions, including duration, renewal, suspension, or revocation, are also specified by regulations, which include a prescribed fee. A fundamental principle of law, the principle of natural justice, is observed, meaning every applicant has a proper right of hearing before a decision on their application is made.
π Definition β Accreditation: The formal recognition granted by the Certification Council to a certification service provider, confirming they meet specified criteria for providing services like cryptography and electronic signatures. π Formula: Accreditation = (Compliance with Council's Regulations & Fee Payment) β Authorization to Operate π Example: A company wants to be a certification service provider. It must apply to the Certification Council, demonstrate that it meets the security and procedural criteria laid out in the regulations, and pay the prescribed fee. The Council will then consider the application and, adhering to the principle of right of hearing, either grant or deny the accreditation.
Certification Practice Statement (CPS) (Section 25)
Under Section 25, every certification service provider seeking accreditation must prepare a Certification Practice Statement (CPS). This is a policy document filed with the application for accreditation. The CPS must be accessible at all times and must include specific details as per the Certification Council's regulations. A copy of the CPS is maintained at the Council's office and is open to public inspection. The CPS typically covers information for persons affected by a wrong certificate, liability extent, and policies on suspension or revocation. During its validity, the certification service provider is deemed to warrant that they have complied with the law and that the information in the certificate is accurate.
π Definition β Certification Practice Statement (CPS): A policy document prepared by a certification service provider that details their practices and procedures, including liability, suspension/revocation policies, and subscriber identification, and is filed for accreditation. π Formula: CPS = Compliance + Public Access + Warranties β Accreditation Approval π Example: A certification service provider, when applying for accreditation, drafts a CPS. This document includes its policy for suspending a certificate if a subscriber's key is compromised, and the limits of its liability if a false certificate is issued. The provider then submits this CPS to the Certification Council for approval alongside its application.
Exempted Documents & Section 31
Section 31 of the ETO specifies that the ordinance does not apply to five types of documents, meaning these must still be in paper form. These are:
- A negotiable instrument (e.g., a promissory note, bill of exchange, check).
- A power of attorney (authorizing one person to act for another).
- A trust (excluding constructive, implied, and resulting trusts).
- A will (testamentary disposition of property after death).
- A contract for sale or conveyance of immovable property.
π‘ Why this matters: This section defines the boundary of the ETO. Traditional paper-based legal documents for these critical transactions remain essential in Pakistan, though the Federal Government can extend the ETO's application to them via a gazette notification.
π Definition β Negotiable Instrument: A document (like a check or promissory note) containing an unconditional promise to pay a specific sum to a specific person, which can be transferred. π Definition β Power of Attorney: A legal document granting authority to one person to act on behalf of another in specified matters. π Definition β Will: A legal document through which a person declares who will inherit their property after their death.
Jurisdiction and Overriding Effect (Sections 32 & 33)
Section 32 declares that Pakistani courts have jurisdiction over matters covered by the ETO, even if they occur outside Pakistan, as long as they are connected to or affect persons, information systems, or events within Pakistan. Section 33 gives the ETO an overriding effect over any other law that is inconsistent with its terms.
π Example: An individual in England hacks into a Pakistani information system and deletes data. Under Section 32, the act is considered to have an effect in Pakistan, so Pakistani courts have jurisdiction to try this case, regardless of where the person is located. Furthermore, under Section 33, the ETO's provisions would prevail over any other inconsistent law.
Offences under the ETO (Sections 34-37)
Sections 34 to 37 define four main categories of offences, each punishable with imprisonment (up to seven years) or a fine (up to ten million or one million rupees), or both.
- Subscriber's Offence (Section 34): A subscriber is guilty if they provide false information to get a certificate, fail to update the certification service provider about a change in circumstances that makes a certificate misleading, or use a certificate or electronic signatures fraudulently. Punishment: up to 7 years imprisonment or fine up to ten million rupees.
- Certification Service Provider's Offence (Section 35): Directors or officers commit an offence if they issue a false certificate, fail to revoke or suspend a false certificate, or issue a certificate while their accreditation is suspended. They are also liable for compensation for any foreseeable damage. Punishment: up to 7 years imprisonment or fine up to ten million rupees.
- Unauthorized Access (Section 36): A person is guilty if they access or attempt to access an information system without authorization, regardless of whether they intend to acquire the information. Punishment: up to 7 years imprisonment or fine up to one million rupees.
- Unauthorized Alteration/Hindering (Section 37): A person is guilty if they alter, delete, or remove information in an information system without authorization, or if they hinder or impede access to an information system. Punishment: up to 7 years imprisonment or fine up to one million rupees.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture details the operational framework of the ETO, starting with the Certification Councilβs role in accrediting providers and approving their Certification Practice Statements. A critical exception is the Section 31 list of five paper-only documents (like negotiable instruments and wills). The ETO asserts broad jurisdiction over cyber acts affecting Pakistan and has an overriding legal effect. Finally, the ordinance creates four distinct criminal offencesβfor subscribers, providers, unauthorized access, and unauthorized tamperingβwith severe penalties, reinforcing the law's authority.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to Section 24, what is the fundamental legal principle that must be observed when the Certification Council decides on an application for accreditation?
- What is a Certification Practice Statement (CPS) and where must a copy be kept?
- Name three of the five types of documents that are exempted from the application of the ETO under Section 31.
- Under which section does the ETO claim jurisdiction over a cybercrime committed from outside Pakistan that affects a person in Pakistan?
- What are the maximum penalties for the offence of unauthorized access to an information system under Section 36?
π Lecture 44 β Global Legal Issues of E-Commerce
π Overview: This lecture examines major global legal challenges facing e-commerce, beginning with Pakistan's court hierarchy and the Electronic Transactions Ordinance (ETO) deficiencies. It then explores critical issues including territorial jurisdiction in cyberspace, online contract formation, copyright protection on the internet, and conflicts between domain names and trademarks.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Pakistan's judicial hierarchy and ETO deficiencies, then examines eight major global e-commerce legal issues: territorial jurisdiction problems in cyberspace leading to forum shopping, online contract formation including offer, acceptance, and click-wrap agreements, copyright challenges in cyberspace with fair use defenses, domain name and trademark conflicts, online defamation, online privacy, internet taxation issues, and cyber crimes.
π Lecture Summary
District/Session Courts and Court Hierarchy
Pakistan's court system is hierarchical, starting with civil courts (for civil wrongs) and magistrates' courts (for criminal wrongs). Appeals from these go to District Courts (civil) and Session Courts (criminal), then to High Courts. The Supreme Court of Pakistan is the apex court. High Courts have extraordinary writ jurisdiction under Article 199 of the Constitution, allowing direct filing against government bodies that breach law. Under the ETO (Electronic Transactions Ordinance), session courts have jurisdiction to try e-commerce offences.
π Definition β Writ Jurisdiction: The extraordinary power of High Courts under Article 199 of the Constitution to entertain cases directly against government bodies that have breached any law.
ETO Deficiencies and Global Legal Issues
Pakistan's ETO has several deficiencies: unclear distinction between electronic signature and advanced electronic signature, broadly worded sections on privacy violations and damage to information systems, missing international aspects like recognition of foreign certificates and electronic signatures, illogical difference between accredited and non-accredited certification service providers, and missing rules/regulations despite years since enforcement.
The lecture identifies eight major global legal issues: territorial jurisdiction, online contracts, copyright in cyberspace, domain name and trademark conflicts, online defamation, online privacy, internet taxation issues, and cyber crimes.
Territorial Jurisdiction
Territorial jurisdiction refers to a court's competence based on geographical area. Jurisdiction lies where the defendant resides, carries on business, the cause of action wholly/partly arose, or immovable property is situated. The plaintiff files the lawsuit; the defendant is sued.
In cyberspace, territorial jurisdiction becomes complicated because the internet transcends geographical boundaries. Example: An Australian firm with English-language website hosted in Canada, maintained by English residents, sells goods to a Pakistani buyer who becomes unhappy. The Pakistani plaintiff can choose among Australia, Canada, England, or Pakistan. Similarly, a defamatory message from England defaming a Canadian, hosted in Sweden, via a Brazilian ISP implicates four countries.
The plaintiff has the option to choose the forum with the most favorable laws. This is called forum shopping. Courts determine cyberspace jurisdiction by examining the level of interactivity, commercial nature, and effects of information exchange.
π Definition β Forum Shopping: The relative ease with which a plaintiff in cyberspace can drag the defendant to a forum of the plaintiff's choice, selecting a jurisdiction whose laws are more favorable.
π Example: An Australian firm sells goods to a Pakistani buyer. The website is in English, hosted in Canada, maintained by English residents. The unhappy Pakistani buyer can file suit in Australia, Canada, England, or Pakistan β whichever has laws most favorable to the plaintiff.
Online Contracts
A valid contract requires three elements: offer, acceptance, and consideration. An offer is a commitment with specific terms. Consideration is the agreed exchange of something valuable (money, property, services). A click wrap agreement is formed when you click "I accept" or "I agree" on a web page.
Contracts need not be written β they can be made orally, by conduct, or through correspondence. Offers and acceptances occur in cyberspace via email, EDI, web forms, or downloaded web pages. An offer can be revoked as long as no payment, delivery, or consideration has been accepted. A seller's website advertisement is an invitation to offer, not an offer. The buyer's order is an offer that the seller can accept, reject, or counter.
When an imposter without authority issues acceptance, digital signatures help establish identity. If a company fails to protect passwords enabling an imposter to accept an offer, the company may be held responsible for breach of contract and directed to fulfill terms or pay compensation.
π Definition β Click Wrap Agreement: A lawfully binding contract formed when a user clicks "I accept" or "I agree" button on a web page, indicating acceptance of the offer's terms.
π Formula: Offer + Acceptance + Consideration = Valid Contract
π Example: Mr. 'A' offers to buy a basket of apples for Rs. 200. Mr. 'B' accepts. This is a lawful contract. Consideration for Mr. 'A' is the basket of apples; for Mr. 'B', it's Rs. 200.
Copyright in Cyberspace
Copyright is an exclusive right granted to the author/creator of literary or artistic work to reproduce, print, publish, or make copies. Copyrightable works include books, music, artwork, recordings, software, architectural drawings, and packaging. Ideas cannot be copyrighted β only their particular expression.
Each HTTP request creates a copy of HTML on the client machine; ISPs caching creates extra copies in cache memory. Some argued copyright couldn't be enforced on the internet, but fair use or fair dealing provides legitimate exceptions. Fair use includes copying for criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. Authors who provide hyperlinks to their work may be giving implied license to download.
Fair use protection depends on: (1) Nature of use β educational/non-profit; (2) Nature of work β factual information gets better protection than creative works; (3) Extent copied β insignificantly small amounts favor the accused; (4) Effect on market value β no negative impact on actual work's value helps the defense.
Fair use requires citation to avoid plagiarism β copying another's expression to obtain credit. Academic institutions take serious action against plagiarism.
The Napster case: Napster provided software enabling millions to exchange MP3 music files. Music companies sued for copyright infringement. Napster argued it only provided machinery. US courts found Napster guilty of vicarious/contributory copyright infringement because it could supervise infringing activity and obtained financial benefit. Napster was shut down, agreed to pay $26 million in damages, and agreed to pay future copyright holders.
WIPO (World Intellectual Property Organization), a UN body, proposed two international copyright treaties in 1996, signed by many countries agreeing to adopt/amend laws protecting copyrighted work in signatory countries regarding digital information exchange.
π Definition β Fair Use: Legitimate exceptions to copyright violation allowing copying for criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research, subject to specific criteria.
π Definition β Vicarious/Contributory Copyright Infringement: Liability for copyright violation when a party is capable of supervising infringing activity and obtains financial benefit from such activity.
π‘ Why this matters: The Napster case established that simply providing technology that enables copyright infringement can still result in legal liability, setting a precedent for all digital platforms.
Domain Name and Trademark Conflicts
This topic is covered in the lecture outline but the document does not provide detailed content on domain name and trademark conflicts. The syllabus indicates it is a major global legal issue of e-commerce.
Online Defamation
This topic is covered in the lecture outline but the document does not provide detailed content on online defamation. The syllabus indicates it is a major global legal issue of e-commerce.
Online Privacy
This topic is covered in the lecture outline but the document does not provide detailed content on online privacy. The syllabus indicates it is a major global legal issue of e-commerce.
Issues of Taxation on Internet
This topic is covered in the lecture outline but the document does not provide detailed content on internet taxation issues. The syllabus indicates it is a major global legal issue of e-commerce.
Cyber Crimes
This topic is covered in the lecture outline but the document does not provide detailed content on cyber crimes. The syllabus indicates it is a major global legal issue of e-commerce.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts are: territorial jurisdiction in cyberspace is determined by interactivity and commercial effects, leading to forum shopping where plaintiffs choose favorable jurisdictions; valid online contracts require offer, acceptance, and consideration, with website ads being invitations to offer while user orders constitute offers; copyright protects expressions not ideas, with fair use providing defenses based on use purpose, work nature, extent copied, and market impact; the Napster case established that companies facilitating infringement can be vicariously liable if they supervise and profit from it; WIPO treaties require signatory countries to protect copyrights in digital environments.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is forum shopping and how does it relate to territorial jurisdiction in cyberspace?
- What three elements are required for a valid online contract, and why is a website advertisement considered an invitation to offer rather than an offer?
- How does the fair use defense protect against copyright infringement claims, and what four factors determine its applicability?
- What was the significance of the Napster case in establishing liability for copyright infringement on the internet?
- What is the difference between copyright protection for ideas versus expressions, and why is this distinction important for mathematical calculations?
π Lecture 45 β GLOBAL LEGAL ISSUES OF E-COMMERCE
π Overview: This lecture examines the major legal challenges facing e-commerce across international borders. It covers intellectual property disputes like patent and trademark conflicts, online defamation, privacy regulations, internet taxation, and cyber crimes, explaining how different legal systems and jurisdictions interact with the global nature of the internet.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers patent infringement and business process patents; trademark and domain name conflicts including cyber squatting, concurrent use, parasites, and top-level domain variations; online defamation and ISP liability; online privacy laws and cultural differences in the EU, Canada, and USA; internet taxation including nexus and double taxation; and cyber crimes and jurisdictional issues.
π Lecture Summary
Patent infringement
A patent is an exclusive right granted by law to make, use and sell an invention. To be patentable, the invention must be unique, genuine, and useful according to prevalent technological standards. Patenting software programs is not considered a popular option these days because obtaining a software patent is expensive and time consuming. Therefore, copyright registration of software programs is considered a more feasible option. However, business process patents have value for e-commerce companies β these are granted on 'methods of doing business' and protect a specific set of procedures for a certain business activity. Examples include a famous online business's unique 1-click purchasing method, another e-business's peculiar price tendering system ('name your own price' system), and an online business's approach of aggregating information from different web sites. Some experts argue that granting such business process patents can cause unfair monopoly for recipients, and courts have yet to decide complicated issues involving them.
Trade mark and domain name conflicts
A trade mark is a sign/symbol that associates the manufacturer or service provider with manufactured goods or services. A trade name is the name or brand under which a business carries on its activity to become recognizable, often used as part of a trade mark. A domain name is the user friendly name used to access a web site, such as 'vu.edu'. Domain names are unique and global β there cannot be two similar domain names. Trade marks/trade names can be multiple and localized; the same trade mark/trade name can be used in different countries or geographical areas, or for different products/services within the same area. Based on this distinction, experts have identified four areas of conflict:
Cyber squatting is the act of intentionally registering domain names containing trademarks/trade names of prominent companies to later blackmail or demand ransom from those companies. It is regarded as an offence in most countries.
π Definition β Cyber squatting: Intentionally registering a domain name containing a trademark/trade name of a prominent company with the intent to blackmail or demand ransom.
π Example: A firm 'Glory Enterprise' wants a domain name containing the word 'glory' because it is recognized by this word. However, Mr. 'A' β who has nothing to do with the firm or the word 'glory' β has already registered this domain name. When the firm requests Mr. 'A' to transfer the domain name, Mr. 'A' blackmails or claims ransom. This is cyber squatting.
Concurrent use arises when two organizations have apparently legitimate claims to use the same domain name but cannot due to uniqueness. For example, a company manufacturing electronic goods and another selling French fries β both can have the same trade mark/trade name such as 'frys' under traditional trade mark law. But when both apply for a domain name containing 'frys', only one can be assigned the desired domain name.
Parasites are domain names that are variants on famous domain names, confusingly similar to them to gain business advantage. For instance, a software company may intentionally register 'macrosoft.com' (a variant of 'Microsoft') to take advantage of Microsoft's reputation. Someone intending to reach Microsoft may mistype and reach the parasite site.
xyz.com vs. xyz.org arises because second level domain names can be assigned to multiple top-level domains. For example, 'whitehouse.org' and 'whitehouse.com' are both valid. The former may contain information about the American President's residence, while the latter may be deliberately registered to gain business advantage, potentially leading a user to irrelevant or pornographic content.
International Corporation for Assigned Names and Numbers (ICAAN) supervises domain name registration worldwide and has implemented the Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP) for deciding domain name disputes. UDRP enables trademark holders to claim/retrieve domain names by invoking mandatory arbitration proceedings at different arbitration forums. Arbitration is a legal concept where parties appoint a person or panel to act as judge instead of referring the dispute to ordinary courts. The arbitrator's decision is final and binding. World Intellectual Property Organization (WIPO) based in Switzerland is one such arbitration service provider nominated under UDRP.
Online Defamation
A defamatory statement is a false statement that injures the reputation of another person or company. If a statement injures the reputation of a product or service instead of a person, it is called product disparagement.
π Definition β Online defamation: Defamation committed using the internet.
π Example: Someone circulates a news item about a doctor, alleging professional incompetence and negligence. The doctor may file a lawsuit claiming reputation injury. Often, the defendant pleads that the statement is not false but a 'fair comment'.
It is difficult to draw a clear line between justifiable criticism and defamation. Commercial web sites should avoid negative or critical statements about other persons or products. Web site designers should avoid defamation liability when modifying pictures or images β they should not depict a person in a derogatory or negative sense. Any online statement about competitors must be carefully reviewed before posting.
Closely connected is the issue of liability of internet service providers (ISPs). ISPs provide the channel for communication. An ISP may be accused of aiding online defamation by hosting a web site containing defamatory material. Courts have prescribed a test: where the ISP has editing control and can review and remove defamatory material, it is treated as a publisher and can be held liable. Where the ISP has no editing control over offensive material, it is merely acting as a distributor and can escape liability.
Online Privacy
The issue of online privacy constantly evolves as the internet grows. Web sites can collect information about page viewing habits, product selection, and demographic information (age, sex) of customers, potentially threatening informational privacy rights. Cultural differences cause different levels of privacy expectations worldwide.
Many countries have privacy laws β Canada has Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act, 2000 (PIPEDA). In 1998, the EU adopted a directive on the protection of personal data, applying to all internet activities. The directive prevents businesses from exporting personal data outside the EU unless this data is protected in the exporting country according to the directive's provisions. In the United States, the government has avoided firm privacy regulations β companies make their own policies using two approaches:
In the opt-out approach (more common), the company assumes the customer does not object to a specific use of information unless the customer specifically denies permission. The company may use collected information for its own purpose, and sell or rent it to other firms.
In the opt-in approach (less common), the company assumes it cannot use information for any other purpose except the one for which it was collected. It cannot sell, market, or rent information unless the customer specifically chooses to allow such use.
Four guiding principles for privacy legislation:
- Collected data may be used for improved customer service.
- Sharing personal data with outside firms/persons should not be allowed unless the customer consents.
- Customers should have the right to know what type of data has been collected and how it has been used.
- Customers should have the right to ask for deletion of any data collected by the company.
Internet Taxation
Companies doing business on the web are subject to the same taxes as any other business. Traditional businesses at one location are subject to one set of tax laws, but e-businesses may have to comply with multiple tax laws enforced in different countries.
An online business is subject to various taxes:
- Income tax: levied by national, state, or local government (where the business is located) on net income from business activities.
- Transaction taxes (sales tax and custom duties): levied on products or services sold. Sales tax is levied on goods sold to customers; businesses file returns and remit collected tax. Custom duties are taxes imposed by countries on import of goods.
- Property tax: imposed on personal property and real estate used in the business.
π Definition β Nexus: The connection between a tax payer and a government that gives the government the power to tax that business.
The general principle is that if a company undertakes sufficient business activities in a particular country, it establishes nexus with that country and becomes liable for filing returns and complying with its tax laws. An e-business may need to file returns and pay taxes in different countries. For example, a US company must pay income tax to the American government on income generated inside and/or outside the USA. To avoid double taxation, US tax law allows credit/refund for taxes paid to foreign countries on foreign earnings. An online seller must know where the customer is located and the sales tax law in that jurisdiction to determine whether an item is subject to sales tax.
Cyber Crimes
Cyber crimes include online fraud, online hate (spreading hatred against a community through internet), cyber-stalking (sending threatening messages using internet), online terrorism, distribution of pornography, and using a computer to launch attacks on other computers. Many countries are drafting new laws or amending existing criminal codes to deal with cyber crimes. The issue of territorial jurisdiction is critical. For instance, if a Pakistani resident commits a cyber crime against a Canadian resident, a question arises whether the Canadian court can take action against this Pakistani, particularly if the act is not considered criminal under Pakistani law.
β Key Takeaways
The lecture emphasizes that e-commerce faces complex global legal issues due to the internet's borderless nature. Students must understand the four types of domain name conflicts β cyber squatting, concurrent use, parasites, and top-level domain variations β along with the UDRP arbitration process through WIPO. Online defamation requires distinguishing between publisher and distributor liability for ISPs, while privacy laws differ significantly between the EU's strict directive and the US's self-regulatory opt-out/opt-in approaches. Internet taxation revolves around the concept of nexus, and cyber crimes raise critical jurisdictional questions when offenses cross national boundaries.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are business process patents, and provide two examples mentioned in the lecture?
- What is the difference between a publisher and a distributor when determining ISP liability for online defamation?
- Explain the opt-out approach versus the opt-in approach to online privacy in the United States.
- What is nexus in the context of internet taxation, and why is it important for e-businesses?
- What is the Uniform Dispute Resolution Policy (UDRP), and which organization serves as an arbitration service provider under it?