๐ Lecture 40 โ Non Binding Evaluation II
๐ Overview: This lecture delves deeper into non-binding evaluation as an alternative dispute resolution (ADR) method, exploring its five main varieties in detail: non-binding arbitration, minitrial, summary jury trial, neutral evaluation, and dispute review boards. The lecture systematically compares non-binding evaluation with litigation, arbitration, and mediation, analyzing its advantages and disadvantages to help conflict diagnosticians determine when and how to use this approach effectively.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the five varieties of non-binding evaluation (non-binding arbitration, minitrial, summary jury trial, neutral evaluation, and dispute review boards), followed by a detailed comparison of non-binding evaluation with litigation, arbitration, and mediation. It concludes with a comprehensive table summarizing each process's typical neutral, presentation format, nature of outcome, and useful applications.
๐ Lecture Summary
Quotation and Introduction
"Excellence is to do a common thing in an uncommon way" โ Booker T. Washington. This lecture revisits four key points from the previous lecture: advantages and disadvantages of non-binding evaluation compared with other forms of ADR, appropriate uses, legal issues, and innovative processes including non-binding arbitration, summary jury trial, minitrial, neutral evaluation, and dispute review boards.
Non-binding evaluation is intended to give each disputant's legal team a preview of a litigation future. ๐ก Why this matters: The goal is to provide both sides with enough information that their positions will overlap, enabling settlement to take place.
Varieties of Non-binding Evaluation
1. Non-binding Arbitration
Non-binding arbitration is the most basic form of non-binding evaluation. It consists of an adjudication process in which the outcome is not binding. Sometimes it is chosen by private parties, but often it is a mandatory process ordered by the court.
๐ Definition โ Non-binding Arbitration: An adjudication process where parties present their case to an arbitrator, but the resulting decision is advisory only and not legally enforceable.
2. Minitrial
In minitrial, the time and expense of case presentation is minimized through the presentation of a summary version of the dispute. Minitrials are usually attended by representatives of the disputants who have the authority to settle the case. After case presentation, the neutral will either issue a non-binding decision or will discuss strengths and weaknesses with disputant representatives and their advocates.
๐ Definition โ Minitrial: An ADR process where parties present a condensed version of their case to representatives with settlement authority, followed by neutral evaluation or facilitated discussion to promote settlement.
3. Summary Jury Trial
Summary jury trial is a form of non-binding evaluation intended to promote settlement by demonstrating to the disputants and their legal teams what would be likely to happen if a jury decided the case.
๐ Definition โ Summary Jury Trial: An abbreviated trial process before an actual jury pool that produces a non-binding verdict, giving parties a realistic preview of jury decision-making.
4. Neutral Evaluation
Neutral evaluation is a process in which an expert in the subject matter of the dispute, or a legal expert, is hired to give an assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of each side's case. Neutral evaluation has many variations and is known by a variety of terms, used in often inconsistent fashion.
๐ Definition โ Neutral Evaluation: A process where a subject-matter or legal expert assesses each party's case and provides an advisory opinion on its merits.
5. Dispute Review Boards
Dispute review boards (also known as dispute resolution boards) are entities created by contract to resolve disputes as they arise during construction projects. Boards are generally made up of three members empanelled by the owner and contractor. As disputes arise during construction, they are submitted by informal hearing process to the review board, which issues an advisory decision in the matter. The dispute review board process is designed to facilitate the complex relationship among owners, contractors, and others involved in large construction projects.
๐ Definition โ Dispute Review Board: A panel of experts, typically three members appointed by both owner and contractor, that provides advisory decisions on disputes arising during construction projects to prevent costly delays and impasses.
Advantages and Disadvantages of Non-binding Evaluation
Non-binding evaluation represents an effort to obtain the benefits of both negotiation and adjudication.
1. Compared with Litigation
The most important advantage of non-binding evaluation is probably also its greatest disadvantage, i.e., its non-binding quality. Non-binding evaluation allows the disputants to retain a measure of their autonomy. A settlement reached after non-binding evaluation is more likely to be accompanied by psychological ownership than a judgment imposed by the court, because the disputants have freely chosen the outcome themselves.
Non-binding evaluation is also chosen by disputants because it is potentially cheaper and faster than litigation. However, it is sometimes touted as an efficiency measure without due regard for whether, in fact, the presumed cost and time savings will be realized.
Finally, like other forms of ADR, non-binding evaluation is typically a private process. Privacy can have both advantages and disadvantages. Some disputants may benefit from the privacy, whereas others prefer that the public be informed of the process and outcome.
2. Compared with Arbitration
In many ways, non-binding evaluation is similar to arbitration: it can seem indistinguishable from arbitration until the moment when one disputant decides not to accept the decision of the neutral. It should not be surprising, then, that non-binding evaluation has many of the same advantages and disadvantages of arbitration. Like arbitration, it has a tendency to promote an adversarial, competitive perspective on the conflict and to promote positional bargaining.
3. Compared with Mediation
The comparison of non-binding evaluation with facilitative varieties of mediation raises the most interesting questions for conflict diagnosticians. Non-binding evaluation is considered effective in dealing with extreme differences of fact or law, and it is useful for BATNA clarification: it functions as a dry run at litigation, enabling attorneys and their clients to get a reasonable estimate of what would happen if the case went to trial.
๐ก Why this matters: Non-binding evaluation serves as a "reality check" for parties who have vastly different views of their legal positions, providing objective information that facilitates realistic settlement negotiations.
Varieties of Nonbinding Evaluation โ Comparative Table
| Process | Who is typically the neutral? | What is typically presented? | Nature of outcome | What is the process useful for? |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nonbinding arbitration | Arbitrator, who may be an attorney, a retired judge or an ADR neutral | Oral arguments; occasionally exhibits and informal testimony (as in arbitration) | Arbitration award, advisory only; may be oral, written, or both | General BATNA clarification |
| Minitrial | Corporate executives with authority to settle; may also be a neutral moderator | Typically, oral arguments; may also be some evidentiary showing | Typically, no outcome per se; observations of hearing provide BATNA clarification to those with authority to negotiate settlement; advisory award may be issued by neutral if no settlement reached | BATNA clarification for those in a position to settle |
| Summary jury trial | Members of the jury pool as adjudicators; judge or retired judge as moderator | Abbreviated version of litigated case | Nonbinding verdict | Teasing out of complicated factual issues (as in class actions/products liability); BATNA if jury trial expected; "day in court" for litigants |
| Neutral evaluation | Experts in technical area of dispute, or lawyers with expertise in the sort of dispute being litigated | Typically, oral arguments | Assessment of the strengths and weaknesses of each side's case; may include advisory award | BATNA clarification; expert empowerment |
| Dispute review board (example: M2 Motorway construction by Turkish firm) | A panel of leaders or other experts in the field involved, empanelled by the owner and contractor in a construction project | A summary of disputes that threatens to delay or derail a complex construction project | An advisory decision | Overcoming of costly impasses and delays created by disputes that occur during complex construction projects |
โญ Key Takeaways
Non-binding evaluation is fundamentally a "preview of litigation" that provides parties with BATNA clarification through an advisory process, helping their positions overlap to enable settlement. Its five main varietiesโnon-binding arbitration, minitrial, summary jury trial, neutral evaluation, and dispute review boardsโeach serve different diagnostic functions, from general BATNA clarification to resolving complex factual issues or managing ongoing construction disputes. The most critical advantage (and disadvantage) is its non-binding quality, which preserves party autonomy and psychological ownership but may also be ignored. Compared to litigation, it offers potential cost, time, and privacy benefits; compared to arbitration, it shares the risk of promoting adversarial positioning; and compared to facilitative mediation, it excels at addressing extreme differences of fact or law. The choice of process depends on the specific conflict diagnosis: whether parties need expert assessment, jury simulation, executive-level settlement authority, or ongoing dispute management in complex projects.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary purpose of non-binding evaluation, and how does it achieve this goal?
- List the five varieties of non-binding evaluation discussed in this lecture.
- What is the most important advantage AND greatest disadvantage of non-binding evaluation when compared with litigation? Explain why.
- How does non-binding evaluation compare with facilitative mediation in terms of when each is most appropriately used?
- For what specific type of project are dispute review boards typically created, and what is the composition of a standard board?
๐ Lecture 41 โ Mixed and Multimodal Dispute Resolution
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the design of effective dispute resolution systems, distinguishing between healthy and distressed systems based on how disputes are resolved. It introduces six key design principles for building systems that prioritize interest-based negotiation, and extends the discussion to online dispute resolution (ODR), covering its varieties, advantages, disadvantages, and legal issues. The lecture concludes with extensions and refinements proposed by various scholars for more effective systems.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by contrasting healthy and distressed dispute management systems using a heuristic of three approaches: interests, rights, and power. It then details six system design principles for creating effective systems, followed by the typical steps in dispute resolution system design. The discussion moves to ADR and the Internet, covering ODR varieties, advantages, disadvantages, and legal issues. Finally, the lecture presents extensions of dispute systems design from authors like Rowe, Lynch, and Slaikeu and Hasson.
๐ Lecture Summary
Designing New Dispute Resolution Systems
The first heuristic involves the relationship between three ways of resolving disputes: by negotiating interests, by adjudicating rights, or by pursuing power options (such as strikes or lockouts). A distressed conflict management system resolves most disputes at the power level, whereas a healthy system resolves most at the interest level, fewer at the rights level, and the fewest through power options. This is healthier because negotiating interests is less expensive, results in mutually satisfactory solutions, and is usually less time-consuming than the other two win-lose approaches. When power-based approaches are used, the losing side often becomes angry and may seek retaliation.
Six System Design Principles
1. Put the focus on interests. This means any dispute resolution should start with a process (either direct negotiation or mediation) where parties try to solve the problem using interest-based bargaining. This is the best way to find a solution that satisfies everyone. Only when this fails should parties move to rights-based processes (such as arbitration) or power-based processes (such as elections).
2. Provide low-cost rights and power backups. Arbitration, voting, and protests are low-cost alternatives to rights and power contests. Although they are higher in cost than negotiation, they are less costly than adjudication or violent force.
3. Build in "loop-backs" to negotiation. Rights-based and power-based strategies seldom need to be played out to the end. As soon as it becomes clear who will "win," parties can "loop-back" to negotiation to develop a solution that best meets their needs and rights. A common example is when parties settle a lawsuit out of court โ once it is clear who is likely to win, both sides can avoid the costs and uncertainty of further litigation by negotiating a solution.
4. Build in consultation before, feedback after. Increasing shared information is a basic strategy in ameliorating all conflicts. Consultation and feedback mechanisms between parties provide a consistent and reliable method of sharing information.
5. Arrange procedures in a low-to-high-cost sequence. By arranging dispute-resolution procedures in a low-to-high-cost sequence, one can reduce the probability of rapid escalation. For example, first try to solve a conflict on your own, then seek the help of a lawyer. Minimizing rapid escalation has the added benefit of reducing enmity and increasing faith in the system's ability to resolve basic disputes.
6. Provide the necessary motivation, skills, and resources. An alternative system functions only if people buy into it. People are creatures of habit, which is the greatest limit to broad-based systemic change. While there may be active resistance, the greater problem is spreading the skills, knowledge, and habits that reinforce the new system. It is incumbent on elites and third-party interveners to provide the resources and time necessary to generate cooperation.
Dispute Resolution System Design
While every situation is unique, the typical steps involved in dispute resolution systems are the following:
- Establish a process for making decisions about new or enhanced dispute resolution processes.
- Identify and diagnose the causes of recurring organizational conflicts and the effectiveness of existing dispute handling procedures.
- Examine the range of options for additional procedures or revisions of existing procedures.
- Select or revise conflict resolution procedures, considering the corporate culture and the kinds of disputes that arise.
- Organize the selected procedures in a comprehensive conflict management system.
- Seek support from key organizational constituencies and secure approval for the proposed new system.
- Develop a plan for implementing and promoting the new system, and train personnel to administer it and provide specific services, such as mediation.
- Create a process for quality control, feedback, and refinement of the system.
Guiding a Disputant
The lecture illustrates a possible intake system for a dispute resolution center, directing disputants to various rooms: Screening clerk (Room 1), Mediation (Room 2), Arbitration (Room 3), Fact finding (Room 4), Malpractice screening panel (Room 5), Superior court (Room 6), and Ombudsman (Room 7).
ADR and the Internet
Two key concepts are introduced:
- ADR of cyber disputes: the use of ADR to resolve disputes occurring in the online environment.
- Online dispute resolution (ODR): the use of online platforms to resolve conflicts of all origins.
ODR Varieties
Following are some ODR varieties:
- ADR by email
- ADR with web-based conferencing
- ADR using technologically sophisticated, multimodal platforms
- Analytical tools added to multimodal platforms
- Blind bidding sites
- Online summary jury trial
Advantages of ADR Conducted Online
The advantages include: transcending geographic and time-zone differences; being more immediate than letter writing; providing time to diagnose conflict, think, and respond appropriately; protecting intimidated disputants; separating enraged disputants; handling disabilities that prevent attending sessions; and allowing technologies that enable better conflict diagnosis.
Disadvantages of ADR Conducted Online
The disadvantages include: disempowering computer-illiterate people and those who write poorly; disempowering people with impaired access to the Internet; lack of body language and technology problems that may produce meta-disputes; ADR neutrals losing non-verbal information; and disputants potentially abandoning the process.
Legal Issues in ODR
Some legal issues involved in ODR include:
- Where did the dispute arise? (cyberspace dispute choice of law problem)
- Where is ADR taking place? (ADR choice of law problem)
- How can settlements be enforced?
Extensions of Dispute Systems Design
Several authors advocate refinements to make dispute systems design more effective.
Rowe suggests an effective system should incorporate:
- Commitment to the values of fairness and freedom from reprisal
- Interest- and rights-based options
- Multiple access points
- An organizational ombudsperson
- Wide scope
- Continuous improvement via an oversight committee
Lynch argues an effective system should incorporate:
- Responding to stakeholder interest
- Reflecting important values
- Promoting the mission of the new agency
- Providing visible support by the organization's leadership
- Loop-backs forward and back between interest- and rights-based options
- A system that is fair, flexible, friendly, and fast
- The goal of resolution at a low level
- Mechanisms by which the organization can shift from conflict resolution to management
Slaikeu and Hasson outline four principles for an effective system:
- It should acknowledge four means of resolution (power, rights, interest, and avoidance)
- It should include prevention and early-intervention options
- It should seek to build collaborative strength through seven checkpoints
- It should utilize the mediation model to build consensus among those involved
โญ Key Takeaways
This lecture's core message is that effective dispute resolution systems are designed to channel most conflicts toward interest-based negotiation, which is cheaper, faster, and produces more satisfying outcomes than rights or power contests. The six design principlesโfocus on interests, provide low-cost backups, build in loop-backs, use consultation and feedback, arrange low-to-high-cost sequences, and provide motivation and skillsโform the blueprint for such a system. Online Dispute Resolution (ODR) extends ADR into the digital domain, offering advantages like transcending geography but also presenting challenges such as loss of non-verbal cues and access inequality. Finally, scholars like Rowe, Lynch, and Slaikeu & Hasson offer complementary extensions, emphasizing fairness, multiple options, leadership support, and continuous improvement as hallmarks of a robust system.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three ways of resolving disputes according to the heuristic presented in the lecture, and which one is considered the most healthy for an organization?
- List and briefly explain the six system design principles for creating an effective dispute resolution system.
- What does the principle "build in loop-backs to negotiation" mean? Provide a common example.
- What is the difference between "ADR of cyber disputes" and "Online Dispute Resolution (ODR)"?
- Name three advantages and three disadvantages of conducting ADR online.
๐ Lecture 42 โ Power Tools and Magic Keys I
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how conflict diagnosis can be applied in legal contexts to improve the delivery of legal services. It examines ethical obligations of lawyers regarding ADR options, introduces client-centered and collaborative lawyering approaches, and compares major dispute resolution forms across multiple dimensions to guide process selection.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the necessity and practical applications of conflict diagnosis in legal practice, including strategy and tactic selection, process and provider selection, ethical obligations of lawyers regarding ADR, client-centered and collaborative lawyering approaches, and a detailed comparison of major dispute resolution forms (facilitative mediation, nonbinding evaluation and evaluative mediation, informal arbitration, formal arbitration, and litigation) across dimensions like cost, time, finality, psychological ownership, outcome creativity, conflict containment, invisible-veil thinking, procedural justice, dealing with prejudice, power disparities, disputant transformation, and more.
๐ Lecture Summary
Introduction
You have been introduced until now with conflict diagnosis, a theory-based set of skills. As a stand-alone technique, conflict diagnosis is a practical method of understanding and analyzing interpersonal conflict, particularly legal disputes. After reading this course you must have recognized that you are now able to use less destructive and useful approaches to resolving conflicts.
Necessity of conflict diagnosis
Conflict diagnosis is mentally challenging and time consuming. That is why most lawyers would say that conflict diagnosis is not necessary, and that the efforts to develop an understanding of underlying interests, sources of conflict, personal power, and the need to preserve relationships and trust are in the domain of the client alone. However some will say yes it is necessary. The reason is that the invisible veil will always hide many important aspects of interpersonal conflict from those involved in it. Most of the time one enters a conflict aware of the resource disputes, preferences and nuisances problems, and perhaps the disputes over facts or law, but little else. The hidden information will be critical to assessing the hidden conflict, the participantsโ most interests, the opportunities presented by the other disputantโs interests. Emotional issues and hidden interests may complicate or impede resolution. Once adversarial negotiation or litigation starts, it is extremely hard to find out about them.
๐ก Why this matters: The invisible veil means that critical interests, emotions, and opportunities remain hidden until it is too late if conflict diagnosis is not applied early.
Using conflict diagnosis
The practice of conflict diagnosis has two major uses in dealing with legal disputes and transactions. It assists the disputant or conflict professional in:
- Choosing strategies and tactics for handling conflict
- Choosing a dispute resolution process and provider
Choosing strategies and tactics for handling conflict
In real-world interpersonal conflict, the practice of conflict diagnosis can reap benefits if applied early, before ADR is even a consideration. A disputant or conflict professional who regularly engages in conflict diagnosis can maximize gain for clients, prevent conflict escalation and dispute recurrence, ensure optimal resource use, and for disputes that involve ongoing relationships, protect the viability of these relationships. Legal professionals and other advocates can enhance their advocacy role by applying conflict diagnosis as early as possible.
Choosing a dispute resolution process and provider
The use of conflict diagnosis for selecting ADR processes is a field still in its earliest infancy. This lack of maturity makes conflict diagnosis very exciting to study and practice.
Comparing the major dispute resolution forms
The lecture provides a comparative table of five major dispute resolution forms across multiple dimensions. The forms compared are:
- Facilitative mediation
- Nonbinding evaluation & evaluative mediation
- Informal arbitration
- Formal arbitration
- Litigation
The dimensions compared include:
Cost: The cost associated with each process, from lowest (facilitative mediation) to highest (litigation).
Time: The duration of each process, from shortest (facilitative mediation) to longest (litigation).
Finality: The degree to which the outcome is binding and final, from lowest (facilitative mediation โ nonbinding) to highest (litigation and formal arbitration โ binding).
Psychological ownership and quality of consent: The extent to which disputants feel they own the outcome and have given genuine consent, from highest (facilitative mediation) to lowest (litigation).
Outcome creativity and pareto optimality: The ability to craft creative, mutually beneficial outcomes, from highest (facilitative mediation) to lowest (litigation).
Conflict containment and escalation: The degree to which the process contains conflict versus allows escalation, from highest containment (facilitative mediation) to lowest (litigation).
Invisible-veil thinking: The ability to uncover hidden interests, emotions, and information, from highest (facilitative mediation) to lowest (litigation).
Sense of procedural justice: The perceived fairness of the process, from highest (facilitative mediation and nonbinding evaluation) to lowest (litigation).
Bigoted or prejudiced behavior: dangers: The risk of bias or prejudice affecting the process, from lower risk (litigation with formal rules) to higher risk (facilitative mediation if not managed).
Dealing with disparities in bargaining power: The ability to address power imbalances, from higher (litigation and formal arbitration with legal representation) to lower (facilitative mediation without safeguards).
Disputant transformation: The potential for personal growth, learning, and relationship improvement, from highest (facilitative mediation) to lowest (litigation).
Where it is often found: The typical settings for each process:
- Facilitative mediation: Family Court, private sector
- Nonbinding evaluation & evaluative mediation: Private sector
- Informal arbitration: Private sector
- Formal arbitration: Private sector
- Litigation: The default dispute resolution process in civil and criminal courts
Usefulness in conjunction with other processes: The ease of combining each process with other ADR or legal processes, from highest (facilitative mediation โ can be combined with many processes) to lowest (litigation โ adversarial and less flexible).
Misconduct by neutral: The risk of misconduct by the third-party neutral, from lower risk (litigation with judicial oversight) to higher risk (informal arbitration with less oversight).
Special qualities: Unique strengths of each process, such as facilitative mediationโs focus on interests and relationships, litigationโs establishment of legal precedent, etc.
Summary
We learnt the comparative nature of different forms of conflict resolution against various dimensions related with the needs of disputants. We also learnt about the complexity of social and economic environment and also about the nature of invisible veil.
โญ Key Takeaways
Conflict diagnosis is a mentally challenging but essential tool for uncovering the invisible veil of hidden interests, emotions, and opportunities that can make or break a legal dispute. Lawyers have an ethical and practical obligation to apply conflict diagnosis early, before adversarial processes lock parties into positions, to maximize client gain, prevent escalation, and protect ongoing relationships. The two primary uses of conflict diagnosis are selecting strategies/tactics and choosing a dispute resolution process/provider. The comparative framework of five major dispute resolution forms (facilitative mediation, nonbinding evaluation, informal arbitration, formal arbitration, litigation) across multiple dimensions provides a systematic way to "fit the forum to the fuss" and select the optimal process for each unique dispute. No single process is universally best; each excels on different dimensions (e.g., facilitative mediation for psychological ownership and creativity, litigation for finality and power-balancing), requiring careful diagnosis to align process choice with disputant needs.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "invisible veil" in conflict diagnosis, and why is it critical to apply diagnosis before adversarial negotiation or litigation begins?
- List the two major uses of conflict diagnosis for legal professionals dealing with disputes and transactions.
- Compare facilitative mediation and litigation on at least three dimensions from the comparative table (e.g., cost, finality, psychological ownership).
- Why might a lawyer choose facilitative mediation over litigation for a dispute involving an ongoing business relationship?
- What are the ethical obligations of lawyers regarding advising clients of ADR options, and how does conflict diagnosis support meeting these obligations?
๐ Lecture 43 โ Power Tools and Magic Keys II
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the hidden factors that impede effective conflict diagnosis, introduces a structured client interview framework for conflict analysis, and presents the "Fitting the Forum to the Fuss" methodology for matching dispute resolution processes to client objectives. It emphasizes the importance of understanding invisible veilsโsuch as anger and power imbalancesโthat obscure rational conflict resolution and compromise the quality of consent.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the concept of the invisible veil and reasons for needing conflict diagnosis, followed by a table of factors impeding facilitative mediation. It then presents the proposed contents of a client interview, introduces collaborative law, and details the "Fitting the Forum to the Fuss" approach with client objectives and a grid-filling methodology. Finally, it covers the conflict diagnosis approach, impediments to facilitative mediation, and a diagram showing how different processes reduce invisible-veil thinking.
๐ Lecture Summary
Invisible Veil Consideration
Reasons for needing conflict diagnosis are often hidden. Conflict escalation obscures important information and disempowers participants. Anger is part of the invisible veilโit hampers rationality, curtails your ability to see hidden interests, and impairs your capability to understand conflict.
๐ก Why this matters: Without piercing the invisible veil, mediators and clients cannot identify true underlying interests, leading to poor-quality settlements or escalation.
Factors thought to impede the usefulness of facilitative mediation
| FACTOR | EFFECT |
|---|---|
| Other disputant/team refusing to participate | May not be possible to use facilitative mediation. Even if other team's participation can be coerced, quality of consent may be impaired. |
| Unfamiliar format disturbing to other disputant/team | Quality of consent may be impaired. |
| One or both disputants or their teams unsure of their BATNAs | Quality of consent may be impaired. |
| Large differences in perceptions of fact or law | Impasse may result unless BATNAs are clarified. |
| Immediate enforcement needed | Irreparable harm may result from failure to act decisively. |
| Untrustworthy disputant | Irreparable harm may result from failure to act decisively. |
| Underlying interest in legal reform | Consensual processes may not address underlying interests. |
| Disempowered disputant | Exploitation of disempowered disputant may occur. Decisions will reflect poor quality of consent unless disputant acquires more power. |
| Time and/or money very limited | Facilitative mediation can take longer than more evaluative, informal processes. |
Proposed Contents of a Clientsโ Interview
- A summary of the clientโs interview
- A description of the clientโs presenting problems and goals
- A description of the likely sources of the conflict
- A sociogram showing the participants and their roles
- An exploration of the clientโs underlying interests and goals, as well as the other disputantโs likely goals and interests (use interest trees)
- Analysis of how the other participants' interests may play into exacerbating or resolving the conflict
- A sense of how escalated the conflict has become and the state of trust between the parties
- An initial list of the apparent impediments to cooperative resolution
- An assessment of the various sources of power held by the client and the other disputant
- An analysis of the clientโs BATNA, including a case evaluation, and the same for the other disputant
- A list of the information needed to prepare the case, including any analysis of the legal and factual issues
- An analysis of what strategy would best help the client meet his or her underlying goals, interests, and needs, with discussion of tactics
- A section discussing โnext stepsโโfurther interviews, investigation, legal research, referrals, and so forth
๐ Definition โ Sociogram: A diagram that maps the participants in a conflict and their relationships/roles. ๐ Definition โ Interest tree: A visual tool used to break down a disputant's surface positions into deeper underlying interests, needs, and goals.
Collaborative Law
A form of lawyering currently seen primarily in family law and based on a contractual relationship between a lawyer and a client is called collaborative law. This contract generally specifies the lawyerโs duty to seek collaborative and interest-based resolution with the other disputant. If litigation commences, the lawyer is required to withdraw from representing the client.
Fitting the Forum to the Fuss (Brainchild of Frank Sander and Stephen Goldberg)
Basic Idea: Different dispute resolution processes are better at different things, and different things are important to different people.
Client Objectives (Sander/Goldberg List) :
- Minimize costs
- Speed
- Privacy
- Maintain/improve relationships
- Obtain vindication
- Obtain neutral opinion
- Obtain precedent
- Maximize or minimize recovery
How to Use Fitting the Forum to the Fuss โ Grid Methodology
Step 1: Assign Client Objective Values The client rates each objective on a scale (e.g., 1-5) based on importance. In the example, the client assigned:
- Minimize costs = 5
- Speed = 5
- Privacy = 1
- Maintain/improve relationships = 5
- Obtain vindication = 2
- Obtain neutral opinion = 2
- Obtain precedent = 1
- Maximize/minimize recovery = 4
Step 2: Rate Each Process on Each Objective Each dispute resolution process is rated (1x, 2x, 3x) for how well it fulfills each objective. 3x = best, 1x = poor, 0 = not at all.
Step 3: Calculate Weighted Scores Multiply the value (I) by the process rating to get a weighted score for each cell. Sum all weighted scores per process.
Completed Grid Scores:
| Objective (Value) | Mediation | Minitrial | Summary Jury Trial | Early Neutral Evaluation | Arbitration | Litigation |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Costs (5) | 15 | 10 | 10 | 15 | 5 | 0 |
| Speed (5) | 15 | 10 | 10 | 15 | 5 | 0 |
| Privacy (1) | 3 | 3 | 6 | 6 | 9 | 0 |
| Maintain/Improve Relationships (5) | 15 | 10 | 10 | 5 | 5 | 0 |
| Obtain Vindication (2) | 0 | 2 | 2 | 2 | 4 | 6 |
| Obtain Neutral Opinion (2) | 0 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 | 6 |
| Obtain Precedent (1) | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 2 | 3 |
| Maximize/Minimize Recovery (4) | 0 | 4 | 4 | 4 | 8 | 12 |
| TOTAL | 48 | 45 | 48 | 53 | 44 | 27 |
๐ Example: For a client who values minimizing costs (value=5) and maintaining relationships (value=5) highly, but cares little about precedent (value=1), Early Neutral Evaluation scores highest (53), while Mediation and Summary Jury Trial tie at 48. Litigation scores lowest (27), confirming it is a poor fit for collaborative objectives.
Conflict Diagnosis Approach
- Facilitative mediation is the default choice.
- If there are reasons not to use facilitative mediation:
- Try to work around them.
- If not possible, use fallback choices (e.g., evaluative mediation, arbitration, litigation).
Impediments to Use of Facilitative Mediation
- The other team wonโt play
- Worry about signaling weakness
- Unknown or uncertain BATNA
- Wildly divergent BATNA assessments
- Limited time, money
- Need for immediate enforcement
- Other disputant a nasty fellow
- Underlying interest in legal reform
- Facilitative process already tried, settlement did not result
Dispute Resolution, Invisible-Veil Thinking, & Quality of Consent
The lecture presents a diagram showing how different processes reduce invisible-veil thinking and affect quality of consent:
- Pure and Transformative Mediation: Most effective at reducing invisible-veil thinking; produces highest quality of consent.
- Facilitative Mediation: Highly effective.
- Compromising: Moderately effective.
- Evaluative Mediation: Less effective.
- Nonbinding Evaluation: Even less effective.
- Med-Arb: Low effectiveness.
- Arbitration: Very low effectiveness.
- Litigation: Least effective; produces lowest quality of consent.
Theories of conflict, cooperation, competition, and negotiation style suggest that the best processes for promoting constructive, equitable, and efficacious dispute resolution are those in which participants are consistently guided away from invisible-veil, zero-sum thinking and toward collaborative, integrative problem solving. These processes include (1) pure mediation geared directly toward promoting collaborative problem solving and (2) transformative mediation.
๐ก Why this matters: The choice of process directly impacts whether parties will reach a truly consensual, durable agreement or simply a coerced, low-quality outcome.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that the invisible veilโanger, power imbalances, and hidden interestsโoften obscures true conflict dynamics, making diagnosis essential. The conflict diagnosis approach begins with facilitative mediation as the default and only uses fallback processes when specific impediments cannot be worked around. The "Fitting the Forum to the Fuss" grid is a quantitative tool that matches client objectives (cost, speed, relationship, etc.) to the most suitable dispute resolution process by calculating weighted scores. Crucially, processes like pure mediation and transformative mediation best reduce invisible-veil thinking and produce the highest quality of consent, while litigation and arbitration tend to produce the lowest. Collaborative law offers an alternative in family law where lawyers contractually commit to non-litigation approaches.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- List four factors that impede the usefulness of facilitative mediation and explain their specific effects.
- What are the thirteen proposed contents of a client interview for conflict diagnosis?
- Describe the basic idea behind "Fitting the Forum to the Fuss" and name the eight client objectives.
- Using the completed grid example, which dispute resolution process scored highest and why? Which scored lowest?
- According to the lecture, which two dispute resolution processes are most effective at reducing invisible-veil thinking, and what kind of mediation serves as the default choice?