π Lecture 23 β Assessing the Negotiating Style
π Overview: This lecture explores the Dual Concern Model of negotiation, examining five distinct negotiation styles based on concern for self and concern for others. It uses the classic "parable of the two sisters and the orange" to illustrate how each style leads to different outcomes, and discusses when integrating (collaborative) negotiation is possible or impossible, along with specific tactics used by expert integrators.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with quotations about negotiation, then introduces the Dual Concern Model and its limitations, including masochistic and sadistic orientations. It presents the parable of two sisters and an orange to illustrate five negotiation styles: avoiding, dominating, obliging, compromising, and integrating. It discusses considerations for using each style, situations where integration is not possible, and five specific tactics used in integrating negotiation: expanding the pie, cutting costs, nonspecific compensation, logrolling, and bridging.
π Lecture Summary
Assessing the Negotiating Style
The lecture opens with quotations emphasizing that anger can be an effective tool, but that negotiators should not try to take all the money in a deal. It then lists the topics to be covered: best styles for preserving cooperation, for self-protection, skills of best negotiators, assessing your own style and others', and tactics for win-win solutions.
Dual Concern Model
The Dual Concern Model maps negotiation styles based on two dimensions: concern for self (horizontal axis, from low to high) and concern for other (vertical axis, from low to high). This creates four quadrants representing five styles:
- Avoiding (low concern for self, low concern for other)
- Dominating (high concern for self, low concern for other) β also called competing
- Obliging (low concern for self, high concern for other) β also called accommodating
- Integrating (high concern for self, high concern for other) β also called collaborating or problem-solving
- Compromising (moderate concern for both self and other), located in the center
π Definition β Dual Concern Model: A framework for understanding negotiation styles based on the negotiator's degree of concern for their own outcomes and concern for the other party's outcomes.
Limitations of Dual Concern Model
Research in negotiation is highly complex, and situations vary significantly. The Dual Concern Model assumes that no disputant has a negative orientation, which is not always true. Sometimes a disputant may be a sadist and get pleasure from harming others. The model was expanded to include negative orientations: masochistic (very negative concern for self, very positive concern for other β inviting abuse or misery) and sadistic (very positive concern for self, very negative concern for other). Negotiation style is an overall strategy, not just a tactic.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that some disputants may have negative orientations (sadism or masochism) helps negotiators recognize when cooperative models will fail and when self-protection becomes paramount.
The Parable of the two sisters and the orange
This parable demonstrates how each negotiation style produces different outcomes in the same simple situation: two sisters find only one orange in the fridge and must decide who gets it.
Avoiding (Low concern for self and other): The sisters do nothing since they can't decide. Two weeks later, there are two dissatisfied sisters and the orange has gone stale in the fridge. The orange is wasted, and there is a cost of disposing it.
Dominating, or competing (High concern for self, low concern for other): The sisters agree to an arm-wrestling contest, with the winner taking the orange. Naila wins and juices the orange; Ayesha loses and is unhappy. The skin is wasted, with disposal costs for taxpayers.
Obliging, or accommodating (Low concern for self, high concern for other): Naila says "You take it," and Ayesha replies "No, you take it." Unless one recovers from "terminal etiquette," the result is the same as avoiding. If one relents, the outcome is similar to dominating, though with less animosity.
Compromising (Moderate concern for both self and other): The sisters divide the orange in half. Naila juices her half for a tiny glass. Ayesha grates the skin from her half for a cake (but doesn't have enough). Result: two half-satisfied sisters and a half-wasted orange.
Integrating, Collaborating, or Problem-solving (High concern for both self and other): Naila asks Ayesha what she needs the orange for. Ayesha needs the skin for her cake. Naila wants juice. The result is two fully satisfied sisters and a fully utilized orange, with less waste for taxpayers.
Considerations involved in using five negotiation styles
When deciding which style to use, consider:
- Usefulness in inducing cooperation (motivate cooperation)
- Self-protectiveness (high degree of motivation to protect one's own interests)
- Integrating is good especially when there is power imbalance
- Effective interests analysis is a must for using integrative style
- Creative problem solving for meeting the underlying needs of all disputants
- Mutual and unilateral styles: Integrating and compromising require mutuality β both parties must participate
Integration style not possible in some situations
Integrating style cannot be adopted when:
- A relatively powerful disputant does not want to cooperate
- A disputant is disempowered due to lack of information
- One disputant is forced to litigation
- There is a constraint of time or limited mental energy
- Integrating is difficult for those with limited cognitive capacities
Tactics Used In Integrating
Expert integrators use five common tactics (Rubin, Pruitt, & Kim 1994, 173-79):
π Definition β Expanding the pie: Making the resource pool larger so both parties can get more of what they want. π Example: If both sisters wanted juice, they could buy more oranges rather than fight over one.
π Definition β Cutting costs: The converse of expanding the pie; relies on cost reduction to increase the net revenues available for distribution. π Example: One sister agrees to give up the orange if the other covers an expense she would normally pay.
π Definition β Nonspecific compensation: Giving the other disputant "unrelated" compensation for giving up something of value. π Example: One sister takes the orange while the other gets something else she values, like a candy bar.
π Definition β Logrolling: The exchange of items that have values personal to the disputants. π Example: Each sister gives up something she values less in exchange for something she values more.
π Definition β Bridging: Responding to underlying interests rather than to positions. In essence, every effective integrating negotiation is a bridging process. π Example: In the orange parable, instead of fighting over who gets the orange (positions), the sisters discover one needs the peel and the other needs the juice (underlying interests).
Integrating style is the best style but it has its own limitations
Integrating assumes that all disputants are rational, but in reality some disputants may be irrational and masochistic. These limitations of individual disputants can influence the choice of negotiation style.
π‘ Why this matters: Even though integrating is ideal, negotiators must be prepared to switch to more self-protective styles when dealing with irrational, sadistic, or uncooperative opponents.
β Key Takeaways
The Dual Concern Model maps five negotiation styles based on concern for self and others: avoiding, dominating, obliging, compromising, and integrating. The parable of the two sisters and the orange demonstrates that only integrating (collaboration) fully satisfies both parties by addressing underlying interests rather than positions. Integrating requires mutuality, effective interest analysis, and creative problem-solving, but it fails when disputants are irrational, powerful and uncooperative, disempowered, or when time and cognitive resources are limited. Expert integrators use five tactics: expanding the pie, cutting costs, nonspecific compensation, logrolling, and bridging, with bridging being the essence of all integrative negotiation. Students must remember that while integrating is the best style, negotiators must assess the situation and the other party's orientation before choosing a strategy.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to the Dual Concern Model, which negotiation style involves high concern for self and low concern for other?
- In the parable of the two sisters and the orange, what outcome does the integrating style produce, and why is it superior?
- List the five tactics used by expert integrators (Rubin, Pruitt, & Kim, 1994).
- In what five situations is the integrating style NOT possible?
- What are the two negative orientations that the Dual Concern Model fails to account for, and how do they affect negotiation?
π Lecture 24 β Assessing Power among Disputants
π Overview: This lecture examines the concept of power in interpersonal conflict, moving beyond simplistic notions of force to understand power as a multifaceted tool for influence. It explores how power operates in personal, environmental, and relationship domains, detailing specific types of relationship power like coercive, reward, referent, and normative power. Understanding these distinctions is crucial for diagnosing conflicts and developing effective resolution strategies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining power as deliberate or purposive influence, then distinguishes between formal power (tied to hierarchy) and informal power (based on personal resources). It explores the complex relationship between conflict and power, provides everyday examples of power usage, and outlines three domains of power: environmental, relationship, and personal. The core of the lecture details five types of relationship powerβcoercive, reward/exchange, referent, normative, and expertβwith particular focus on the first four.
π Lecture Summary
Power
Power may be defined as a deliberate or purposive influence. It is a kind of force to modify the behavior of people, change the environment, or change physical or social conditions. Understanding power is essential to the study of interpersonal conflict. Peacekeeping and feminist theorists coined the term equal power relationship to describe a situation in which neither partner had clear power over the other. Peacemaking is a form of conflict resolution focusing on establishing equal power robust enough to forestall future conflict.
π Definition β Power: a deliberate or purposive influence; a force to modify behavior, change the environment, or change physical/social conditions.
Power may be divided into two types:
- Formal Power β associated with hierarchy, a social shared structure where decision power distribution is graded and unequal. Formal power relationships are intrinsically asymmetrical (not reciprocal). It is exercised in a top-down manner by superiors on subordinates.
- Informal Power β based on personal resources whose distribution is not necessarily related to hierarchical structure. It requires the target to accept the influence of the agent and allows the target to develop a feeling of control and empowerment.
Conflict and Power
Power and conflict have complex relationships. Analyzing the differences between formal and informal power can help unravel some complexities. For most people, the concepts of conflict and power are interconnectedβeach party seeks to use powerful means to gain advantage. However, our understanding of power is distorted and taken as "narrow" due to the invisible veil or complexity of human systems.
Uses of Power
Everyday examples of power use include: a mother soothing her infant, a family rebuilding after an earthquake, a superstar athlete endorsing a product, a good teacher explaining a difficult concept, a person quitting smoking, a political party publishing its manifesto, and a lawyer filing a lawsuit that prompts settlement negotiations.
Domains of Power
When we talk about power, we may ask over what domain this deliberate or purposive influence is exercised. There are three major domains:
- Environmental domain β a person's surroundings
- Relationship domain β a person's relationship to another person
- Personal domain β a person's own interests
Personal and environmental power become more important when a disputant considers his or her alternatives to a negotiated agreement.
Kinds of power in the Relationship Domain
Many types of relationship power are available to disputants and their teams. An effective conflict diagnostician must think "outside the box" regarding power's impact in conflict.
- Coercive Power
- Reward/Exchange Power
- Referent Power
- Normative Power
- Expert Power
- Ecological Power
1. Coercive Power
Coercive power is the power to impose negative, damaging, or unpleasant consequences on someone else. It includes the power to kill or injure, damage property, irritate someone, or create expensive outcomes. Coercive power often carries the greatest potential for immediate influence, particularly when the threat of harm is severe. However, it also damages the ability of the disputant wielding the power to use other, more positive sources of influence later.
π‘ Why this matters: An over-reliance on coercive power actually disempowers the user by denying them the ability to exercise any other types of power. This phenomenon has occurred in the Middle East, where the peace process between Israel and Palestinians has been seriously compromised by both sides using coercive power.
π Definition β Coercive Power: the power to impose negative, damaging, or unpleasant consequences on someone else.
2. Reward / Exchange Power
Reward/exchange power is the flip side of coercive powerβthe ability to influence people by offering them something they value. A father offering his daughter money for a good grade exercises reward/exchange power, as does a disputant who offers to dismiss a lawsuit in exchange for a favorable settlement.
Coercive and reward/exchange power go hand in hand. Often, disputants engineer situations carrying the threat of coercion, only to offer to withdraw the threat as a reward for a favorable outcome. When reward/exchange power is wielded as threat withdrawal, it often creates the same problems that coercive power doesβtypically requiring more and more reward to produce the same behavior.
Reward/exchange power is very effective when there is a rational basis for concluding that the amount and type of reward is a just and fair exchange for items given up by the person being rewarded.
π Definition β Reward/Exchange Power: the ability to influence people by offering them something they value.
3. Referent Power
Referent power is the power held by attractive, charismatic people to persuade and influence others. It drives the giant industry of celebrity product endorsementβhundreds of millions of dollars paid to sports stars and rock stars to appear with products are a testament to the immense power of personal attraction.
Not everyone possesses referent power, and those who do have appeal that is not universal. Referent power must be used with judiciousness, as using it in an illegitimate manner not only fails to persuade but can undermine the power of the referent.
π Definition β Referent Power: the power held by attractive, charismatic people to persuade and influence others.
4. Normative Power
Normative power is the power of moral rectitudeβbeing on the "right" side of a moral issue gives the user the ability to convince others to serve the norm. For example, a supervisor committed to gender equity is likely to increase the salary of an employee who demonstrates pay inequity based on gender.
Normatively powerful people tend to acquire a certain degree of referent power by virtue of their noble or heroic positions. There are two sources of normative power: individual norms and group norms. If you try to convince someone based on that person's individual moral stance, you use an individual-norm source. However, to wield normative power, the other disputant need not share the normβonly a large and influential group must do so.
Limits of Normative Power
There are two important limitations:
- An appeal to prevailing norms taken to an individual disputant who does not hold them will fail if the other disputant can rationalize that the norm is inapplicable (e.g., Affirmative Action).
- The use of normative power will not be effective against an individual who holds a contrary norm with significant support group. In such circumstances, normative power will only consolidate and harden the contrary group.
π Definition β Normative Power: the power of moral rectitude; being on the "right" side of a moral issue gives the ability to convince others to serve the norm.
β Key Takeaways
Power in conflict is far more nuanced than simple force or dominanceβit operates across environmental, relationship, and personal domains, with relationship power being central to conflict resolution. The five types of relationship power (coercive, reward/exchange, referent, normative, and expert) each have distinct characteristics, uses, and limitations. Crucially, over-reliance on coercive power can disempower the user by blocking access to more positive forms of influence. Reward/exchange power works best when perceived as fair and just, while referent power depends on personal charisma and must be used legitimately. Normative power relies on moral rectitude but fails when the target rejects the norm or holds a contrary position supported by others. Understanding these power types helps diagnosticians think "outside the box" about conflict dynamics.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three domains of power, and which one is most relevant to conflict resolution?
- How does formal power differ from informal power in organizational settings?
- What is the main limitation of relying too heavily on coercive power, and what real-world example illustrates this?
- Under what conditions is reward/exchange power most effective, and when does it create problems similar to coercive power?
- What are the two limitations of normative power, and why might using it against a contrary norm group backfire?
π Lecture 25 β Assessing Power Among Disputants II
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of power types in conflict management, focusing on expert and ecological power. It examines how each type of power is context-dependent and associated with predictable side effects, particularly the creation of alienation. The lecture also explains how understanding your alternatives to a negotiated agreement, including the BATNA, can help maximize your use of power.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the varieties of relationship power and how their effectiveness depends on context. It examines expert power as the power of knowledge and ecological power as the power to manipulate the environment. The lecture details the concept of alienationβthe mistrust and hatred created by power useβand how each power type has different tendencies to cause it. Finally, it explores the sources of relationship power (resources, personal attributes, roles) and emphasizes that power is context-dependent.
π Lecture Summary
Quotation
The lecture opens with a quote from Albert Einstein: "I don't know with what weapons World War III will be fought, but World War IV will be fought with sticks and stones." This sets the stage for discussing the nature and consequences of power.
Expert Power
Expert power is the power of knowledge. It is effective when the wielder has considerable knowledge and the person they are trying to influence accepts this degree of knowledge. It is critical for legal professionals and other dispute resolvers to be familiar with this type of power. Expert power, used honestly to persuade others, is considered the least likely form of power to (1) disempower the person exercising it and (2) result in conflict escalation.
However, expert power can be used illegitimately, creating a sense of alienation in the person against whom it is used. For example, a daughter whose father requires her to engage in some action "for her own good," when it obviously serves the father's interest, will cease to believe the father's honest views of expert power. The illegitimate or dishonest use of expert power disempowers the wielder by creating the belief that the claimed superior knowledge is a lie.
π Definition β Expert Power: The power of knowledge. π Formula: Knowledge + Acceptance by the other = Expert Power π Example: The United States gained a lot of expert power throughout the twentieth century by acting as a mediator in international conflicts and contributing to public health and agricultural science.
Ecological Power
Ecological power is the power to manipulate the environment. For example, imagine a dispute between two neighbors. Although some social scientists list ecological power as a separate type of power, it functions in the environmental domain as a means of exercising various other types of powers. Ecological power tends to be as harmful as the type of power it is used to impose. Disputants often use ecological means to exercise coercive power. Ecological power used to coerce, or perceived as illegitimately used, tends to create conflict escalation and eliminate the wielding disputant's ability to use broader power sources.
π Definition β Ecological Power: The power to manipulate the environment.
Power and Alienation
The term alienation refers to the extent to which a person becomes mistrustful of, hateful toward, and unwilling to assist another. It has been recognized that the six types of power have different intrinsic tendencies to create alienation in the person toward whom the power is exercised. Of the six types, coercive power is considered the most alienating; expert power the least alienating. Any exercise of power that is perceived as illegitimate by the recipient also produces alienation.
Alienation is disempowering to the person exercising power. If Disputant A influences Disputant B and alienates B in the process, the alienation directly impairs Disputant A's referent power (by causing B to dislike A) and undermines A's normative and expert power (by creating distrust). In a relationship already marked by high alienation, the use of coercive power may be appropriate only if the relationship is likely to be short-term, such that one coercive move is sufficient.
π Definition β Alienation: The extent to which a person becomes mistrustful of, hateful toward, and unwilling to assist another. π‘ Why this matters: Alienation is a key side effect of power use that can damage the wielder's own power. Understanding which power types cause the least alienation (expert) and most (coercive) helps in strategic power selection.
Sources of Relationship Power
Where do the six types of power come from? Resources, including tangible assets like money, are important sources of power that operate in all domains. Money and other forms of wealth can be converted to other types of power. Personal attributes also influence power: characteristics such as physical appearance, mode of dress, articulateness, educational level, likeability, and emotional stability are important sources of normative, referent, and expert power. Power also comes from roles that people play in society and interpersonal relations. Social role expectations often create a script-like interaction between role participants.
The lecture provides a table summarizing the six power types:
| Type of Power | Definition | Example | Sources of Power: Examples | Likelihood of Alienation from use |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Coercive | Ability to influence by coercing, threatening, harming, irritating | Threatening litigation | Physical strength, weaponry, ability to file a lawsuit | Very high |
| Reward/Exchange | Ability to influence by rewarding or withdrawing threats | Offering to dismiss a lawsuit if the other agrees to terms | Wealth, possession of something the other wants | High |
| Referent | Ability to influence based on charisma and attractiveness | A father's influence based on his son looking up to him | Improvement of physical appearance, "charm school" | Moderate |
| Normative | Ability to influence based on high moral standing | A minister influencing a penitent's important life choice | Association with a "good cause," influential spokespersons | Moderate |
| Expert | Ability to influence based on availability of knowledge | A parent convincing a child to behave based on experience | Research, investigation, formal learning, experts | Low |
| Ecological | Ability to influence by manipulating the environment | Cleaning the kitchen to make a used refrigerator seem well cared for | Wealth, research into options, "elbow grease" | Dependent on what power is exercised for |
Context and Power
Power is context-dependent. Each of the six types of power exists to varying degrees depending on the specific other person toward whom the power is directed and the specific situation where power is exercised. Powerful people and entities often have a lot to lose because they come to rely on their power and are comfortable with the choices and advantages it brings. Paradoxically, a less powerful person may be in a better position because they have little to lose.
Summary
Power and its use are context-dependent. Power is not all joy; it brings a lot of pressure and anxiety. At times, the powerless is more at peace and comfort than a person who has power.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical things a student must remember from this lecture are the definitions and alienation profiles of expert power (power of knowledge, least alienating) and ecological power (power to manipulate the environment). Alienationβthe mistrust and hatred created by power useβis a key side effect that can disempower the power wielder, especially by damaging referent, normative, and expert power. The six types of power have different intrinsic tendencies to cause alienation, from coercive (most) to expert (least). Power is context-dependent and stems from resources, personal attributes, and roles; understanding this helps in strategic use. Finally, the powerless may paradoxically have an advantage over the powerful because they have less to lose.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is expert power and why is it considered the least alienating form of power?
- Define ecological power and give an example of how it can be used to exercise coercive power.
- What is alienation and how does it, in turn, disempower the person who exercised the power?
- Name three sources of relationship power discussed in the lecture.
- Explain the paradox mentioned in the lecture regarding powerful vs. less powerful people.
π Lecture 26 β Power, Conflict, and BATNA III
π Overview: This lecture explores the relationship between power, conflict, and BATNA (Best Alternative to a Negotiated Agreement) in negotiation settings. It covers how to assess and strengthen BATNA, the role of third parties, power imbalances between disputants, and strategies for empowerment. Understanding these concepts is critical for effective conflict resolution and negotiation success.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture examines the definition and importance of BATNA as coined by Fisher and Ury, a six-step process for BATNA assessment, litigation as a BATNA through case valuation, three drawbacks of BATNA analysis, power imbalance between individual and group disputants, strategies for becoming empowered particularly through expert power, dealing with power imbalance through legal or less competitive processes, and implications for conflict diagnosis including the context-specific nature of power.
π Lecture Summary
KEY POINTS
Power is defined as the force to modify behavior of individuals, groups, societies, or nations. Conflict is the clash of interests among individuals, groups, societies, or nations. BATNA stands for Best Alternative to the Negotiated Agreement.
BATNA
BATNA is a term coined by Roger Fisher and William Ury in 1981. It stands for "best alternative to a negotiated agreement." It is always useful to increase one's BATNA, as it increases negotiating power. Good negotiators use it for better results of negotiation. If a negotiator is well aware of how desperately the other party wants to come to a settlement, the negotiator may use the opportunity according to their terms and conditions. Therefore, making your BATNA as strong as possible before negotiating, and then making that BATNA known to your opponent, strengthens your negotiating position.
In an interpersonal conflict, the exercise of power in the other two power domains (personal and environmental) has relevance. Sometimes, a disputant finds that using negotiation to meet their interests and needs is not as useful as getting those goals attained some other way.
π Definition β BATNA: The best of all available alternatives to a negotiated agreement (ATNAs) for any given disputant.
Knowing the BATNA protects a disputant and the team from irrational action. Trying to resolve a conflict without knowing the BATNA puts the team in the untenable position of not knowing whether to negotiate or to stop negotiating. Many disputants deal with this pressure by developing a bottom line β if the negotiation leads to a deal as good as the bottom line, they will settle; otherwise they won't.
Knowing the BATNA also helps a disputant and team to act with efficiency. The team chooses to negotiate only if there appear to be potential benefits, stays in negotiation only as long as it appears potentially beneficial, and gains a clear idea of what to do if negotiation does not lead to settlement. This reduces wasted time, money, effort, and trauma.
Role of Third Party in BATNA
Third parties can help disputants accurately assess their BATNAs through reality testing and costing. In reality testing, the third party helps clarify and ground each disputing party's alternatives to agreement.
Assessing the BATNA
BATNA assessment follows a six-step process:
- Conduct an Interest Analysis
- Brainstorm the Alternatives to a Negotiated Agreement
- Fine-tune the Alternatives
- Assess Each Alternative Realistically
- Choose the Best Alternative
- Regularly Reassess the BATNA
Conduct an Interest Analysis
BATNA assessment begins with an interest analysis. There is no way to determine which alternative to negotiation is best without a clear picture of the disputant's interests, needs, and goals.
Brainstorm the Alternatives to a Negotiated Agreement
Consider whether the disputant can meet their goal by exercising personal power, spending money, or considering litigation.
Fine-tune the Alternatives
Develop a list of alternatives to a negotiated agreement. Personal power and environmental power are highly relevant to this stage of BATNA analysis.
Assess Each Alternative Realistically
In assessing both costs and benefits, it is important to avoid limiting the analysis to monetary aspects. Non-monetary factors such as impact on relationships, potential for conflict escalation, grief, and wasted time are equally important to consider.
Choose the Best Alternative
Compare the estimated costs and benefits of each alternative to the disputant's goals to determine the "best" alternative β this is the disputant's BATNA.
When developing a BATNA, a negotiator should:
- Brainstorm a list of alternatives if negotiation fails to deliver a favorable agreement
- Select the most promising alternatives and develop them into practical, attainable alternatives
- Identify the most beneficial alternative to keep in reserve as a fall-back during negotiation
Regularly Reassess the BATNA
Situations change, new information becomes available, and disputant interests can evolve. Some alternatives that were formerly available may disappear, and others may develop.
Knowing the Other Disputant's BATNA
It is useful to know the other disputant's BATNA as well as your own. The better the other disputant's BATNA, the lower your team's chances of an excellent outcome in negotiation (unless the other disputant's team is unaware of their BATNA).
Litigation and the BATNA: Performing Case Valuation
In most legal disputes, the choices are either to settle with the disputant or go to court. If assessing the BATNA of a potential claimant, the options are often to negotiate a settlement, walk away without compensation, or file a lawsuit.
Case valuation is a very inexact science. Attorneys use the following information to value a case:
- Their experiences with similar cases
- Their knowledge of, or research into, the applicable law
- Their knowledge of the presiding judge
- Their assessment of the believability and likeability of witnesses
- Their assessment of the evidence
- Their assessment of opposing counsel
- Their institution
Drawbacks of BATNA Analysis
Understanding BATNA has many advantages β having a well-conceived BATNA can lead to better decisions about whether to (1) accept a settlement, (2) "hang in" with a negotiation, or (3) end a negotiation. The other disputant's BATNA can help gain leverage and make more realistic assessments.
BATNA analysis has three drawbacks:
-
Difficulty of accurate analysis β It's often difficult to perform BATNA analysis accurately. A common mistake is omitting non-monetary implications of ATNAs (e.g., bad relations). When you misconstrue a BATNA, the effects can be unwanted.
-
Time, money, and resources β BATNA analysis often takes a great deal of time, money, and resources, particularly when litigation is involved.
-
Irrelevance in certain circumstances β In some circumstances, BATNA is not relevant. These circumstances usually relate to conflict involving long-term, close, intimate, family relationships.
Power Imbalance
In a technical sense, no two disputants have the same degree of power. Each interpersonal conflict brings together persons or entities with complex patterns of power. It is frequently true that disputants have obviously unequal powers (e.g., gender power).
Power affects the choices that individual disputants can make and the degree of influence one disputant can have on another.
Group Power Imbalance
A high-power group is highly likely to wield or threaten coercive, brutal, and sadistic power. Group power imbalance sets in motion processes that reinforce and increase the existing power imbalance. Once group power imbalance is in place, it can be very difficult to dislodge. These considerations can set the stage for explosive and violent clashes if the lower-power group does not accept its status.
The identity of lower-power group members is transformed from "helpless victim" to "rights struggle," and the higher-power group correctly views this new attitude as a direct threat to its entrenched privileges. The identities of struggling groups tend to perpetuate a protracted, competitive, and destructive conflict cycle.
Becoming Empowered
Power means choice. The more power you have, the better your range of choices and potential outcomes.
People often wield power in the relationship domain to get outcomes they want (e.g., threatening one another or taking a legal dispute to court). But another important use of relationship power is to influence the other disputant to engage in the most desirable conflict resolution process.
Power exercised in the personal and environmental domains can produce better alternatives to a negotiated agreement β hence, better BATNAs. Changes wrought by uses of power in personal and environmental domains can also improve a disputant's ability to wield power in relationship.
π‘ Why this matters: Empowerment can be produced two ways: either the amount of power can be increased, or the person's ability to use existing powers can be strengthened. Overall, expert power is more alterable than any other type of power. Expert power is the least likely form of power to create alienation, so conflict participants who seek to empower themselves are smart to begin by increasing this form of power.
Dealing with Power Imbalance
Legal scholars differ on whether power imbalance is best dealt with through zealous and adversarial advocacy or whether less competitive processes can be used effectively. Some legal experts argue that the only effective means for dealing with power imbalance is to resort to the legal system or to extra-legal processes such as violent or revolutionary struggle.
Implications for Conflict Diagnosis
The concept of power, applied to interpersonal conflict, goes far beyond the commonly held idea of physical force. A conflict diagnostician must understand how power operates in each of three major domains (relationship, environmental, and personal) and identify the types of power available to conflict participants in each domain.
Power is a context-specific attribute. A characteristic of an individual disputant, their resources and environment, or their team may spell considerable power in one circumstance but helplessness in another.
There are no "magic bullets" that can fix power imbalances. A conflict diagnostician needs to examine each situation and carefully consider the interests of the disputants.
β Key Takeaways
BATNA is a critical negotiation concept that represents the best alternative if negotiation fails β strengthening and knowing your BATNA increases negotiating power and protects against irrational decisions. The six-step BATNA assessment process (interest analysis, brainstorming alternatives, fine-tuning, realistic assessment, choosing the best, and regular reassessment) provides a structured approach for negotiators. Power exists in three domains (relationship, personal, and environmental), and expert power is the most alterable and least alienating form of power for self-empowerment. Power imbalances, especially in group contexts, can create destructive conflict cycles and require careful diagnosis rather than "magic bullet" solutions. Finally, while BATNA analysis is valuable, it has significant limitations including difficulty of accurate assessment, high costs, and irrelevance in intimate or long-term relationships.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six steps in the BATNA assessment process, and why is the first step (interest analysis) essential?
- What are the three drawbacks of BATNA analysis, and in what circumstances is BATNA considered irrelevant?
- How does knowing the other disputant's BATNA affect your negotiation position, and what exception to this exists?
- What are the three power domains, and why is expert power recommended as the starting point for empowerment?
- According to the lecture, what happens when group power imbalance is in place, and why are there "no magic bullets" for fixing power imbalances?
π Lecture 27 β Stereotypes, Diversity, and Conflict I
π Overview: This lecture examines how stereotyping, culture, and social-group power influence interpersonal conflict. It explores why humans stereotype, why stereotypes resist change, and how cultural and sub-cultural differences affect conflict handling. The lecture also provides strategies to offset stereotyping and minimize the negative impact of cultural diversity.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the influence of stereotyping, culture, and social-group power on interpersonal conflict; reasons for stereotyping others and why stereotypes resist change; 'Red Flags' that may mislead you; tactics to offset stereotyping; how cultural and sub-cultural differences affect conflict; ways to minimize negative impact of cultural differences; and the effect of caste, baradarism, religious sect, and gender on handling conflict.
π Lecture Summary
Stereotype
Stereotypes are oversimplified generalizations about people who belong to a different group. Prejudice is an unsubstantiated judgment or opinion about an individual or a group, either favorable or unfavorable. The term is usually used to show hostile attitudes toward others based on their membership in another group. The distinguishing characteristic of prejudice is that it relies on stereotypes. The result of prejudice and stereotyping is discrimination and integration.
π Definition β Stereotype: oversimplified generalizations about a person who belongs to a different group. π Definition β Prejudice: an unsubstantiated judgment or opinion about an individual or a group, either favorable or unfavorable, that relies on stereotypes.
Categories of Diversity Issues
Diversity issues fall into three main categories:
- Stereotyping: The attribution of thoughts, qualities, behaviors, and attitudes to others based on their categorization into a social group.
- Culture: Includes language, cultural values, perspectives, and cultural attitudes toward conflict, negotiation, and conflict resolution.
- Power: Power problems in diversity conflict include the disempowerment of particular social groups and the existence of bigotry and prejudice based on social group membership.
These categories frequently influence one another.
Stereotyping
βFirst impressions are importantβ β stereotypes are similar to first impressions; many first impressions come from stereotypes. All human beings stereotype. The propensity to judge people based on stereotype is general practice because it is part of the human cognitive system.
Effect of Stereotypes
Two major problems exist with stereotyping:
- The attribution made as a result of stereotyping may be totally wrong.
- It is shameful to be stereotyped.
Stereotyping in Interpersonal Conflict
Stereotypes are often wrong, leading to bad strategy. People are embarrassed when they are stereotyped, making conflict escalation likely.
π‘ Why this matters: When someone feels unfairly categorized, they are more likely to react emotionally and defensively, escalating rather than resolving the conflict.
Why People Stereotype
People use systematic processing to understand other people only if: a) They have plenty of time and resources to devote to the task. b) They are highly motivated to understand the situation accurately.
In the absence of these two requirements, people will use categories, such as stereotypes, to draw inferences about people.
Summary
Stereotypes are used to determine ready behaviors towards individuals belonging to different social categories. If we try to process information about every individual in all situations, it becomes highly inefficient. Stereotypes are part of human cognition and are an important component of human relations and interpersonal conflict. Understanding stereotyping can help avoid conflict and also help in resolving interpersonal conflict.
β Key Takeaways
Stereotypes are oversimplified generalizations that are part of human cognition and are used when we lack time or motivation for systematic processing. They often lead to wrong attributions and shame, which escalates interpersonal conflict. Diversity issues fall into three interrelated categories: stereotyping, culture, and power. Prejudice relies on stereotypes and results in discrimination. Since stereotypes are unavoidable cognitive shortcuts, understanding how they work is essential for managing and resolving conflicts effectively.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main categories of diversity issues discussed in this lecture?
- Why do people stereotype others according to this lecture?
- What is the distinguishing characteristic of prejudice as defined here?
- What are the two major problems with stereotyping in interpersonal conflict?
- Under what two conditions will people use systematic processing instead of stereotypes to understand others?