📘 Lecture 39 — Coaching Relationships
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the role of coaching in employee development, detailing the functions of a coach, the dynamics of effective coaching relationships, and the systematic development planning process. It emphasizes how coaching can motivate employees, develop skills, and address performance gaps, while outlining the responsibilities of both employees and managers in creating a successful development plan.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the three roles a coach can play: providing one-on-one feedback, helping employees learn independently by connecting them with experts, and providing resources like mentors or job experiences. It also discusses the characteristics of effective coaching relationships, including the duration (7–12 months), reasons for using coaches, and factors for success, such as a strong manager-coach relationship and employee motivation. The second major topic is the development planning process, which involves identifying needs, setting goals, determining actions, measuring progress, and establishing a timetable, with clear responsibilities for both the employee and the company.
📝 Lecture Summary
Employee Development (Continued)
A coach is a peer or manager who works with employees to motivate them, help them develop skills, and provide reinforcement and feedback. There are three roles a coach can play. The first role involves one-on-one interaction with an employee, providing feedback based on psychological tests, 360-degree assessment, or interviews with bosses, peers, and subordinates. The second role is to help employees learn for themselves by putting them in touch with experts who can help with their concerns and by teaching them how to obtain feedback from others. The third role is to provide the employee with resources such as mentors, courses, or job experiences that the employee may not otherwise have access to.
🔑 Definition — Coach: A peer or manager who works with employees to motivate them, help them develop skills, and provide reinforcement and feedback.
Coaching Relationships
Research provides insight into coaching relationships. Coaching typically occurs during a 7- to 12-month period. The main reasons why coaches are used include: to develop high-potential managers, to act as a sounding board for managers, or to specifically try to change behaviors that are making managers ineffective. The most important factors in a successful coaching relationship include a good manager-coach relationship, a high motivation (on the manager’s part) to change, and strong commitment by top company management to develop the manager. The most important qualifications to look for when hiring a coach are experience, the use of a clearly defined coaching method (such as in-depth psychological interviews or use of 360-degree feedback), and the quality of the coach’s client list.
The best coaches are empathetic, supportive, practical, and self-confident but do not appear to know all the answers or want to tell others what to do. Employees who are going to be coached need to be open-minded and interested, not defensive, close-minded, or concerned with their reputation. Both coaches and employees to be coached take risks in the relationship. Coaches offer their expertise and experience to help an employee. Employees are vulnerable because they must speak honestly about their weaknesses. Coaches need to be able to suggest effective improvement actions and must respect employee confidentiality. If assessment instruments are part of the coaching process, the coach must be familiar with them. Some companies use coaching specifically to help groom current and future executives.
🔑 Definition — Successful Coaching Relationship Factors: A good manager-coach relationship, high motivation to change on the manager’s part, and strong commitment by top company management to develop the manager.
📌 Example: A company uses coaching to develop high-potential managers. The coach uses 360-degree feedback and in-depth psychological interviews. The key to success is the manager’s openness to change and the company’s commitment to the process.
Training Programs for Coaching Skills
Training programs that develop coaching skills need to focus on four issues related to managers’ reluctance to provide coaching. First, managers may be reluctant to discuss performance issues even with a competent employee because they want to avoid confrontation, especially if the manager is less of an expert than the employee. Second, managers may be better able to identify performance problems than to help employees solve them. Third, managers may feel that the employee might interpret coaching as criticism. Fourth, as companies downsize and operate with fewer employees, managers may feel that there is not enough time for coaching.
💡 Why this matters: Understanding these barriers is crucial for designing effective coach training programs that overcome manager resistance and ensure coaching is seen as supportive, not punitive.
The Development Planning Process
The development planning process involves identifying development needs, choosing a development goal, identifying the actions that need to be taken by the employee and the company to achieve the goal, determining how progress toward goal attainment will be measured, investing time and energy to achieve the goal, and establishing a timetable for development. An emerging trend is that the employee must initiate the development planning process. The development approach is dependent on the needs and developmental goal. To identify development needs, employees must consider what they want to do, what they are interested in doing, what they can do, and what others expect of them.
A development need can result from gaps between current capabilities and/or interests and the type of work or position that the employee wants in the future. Some ways that employees can identify opportunities for development include looking at the strengths and weaknesses listed on their most recent performance appraisal and looking at their progress on skills needed to achieve personal goals or their mastery of competencies that the company may have identified. Also, asking peers and friends and using 360-degree feedback data can be useful for identifying development opportunities.
The company responsibility is primarily taken by the employee’s manager. The role of the manager in development planning is to provide coaching, communicate information about development opportunities (e.g., job experiences, courses), help eliminate barriers to development, and refer the employee to other people (human resources) and resources (assessment tools). Managers must also help employees set realistic development goals, establish checkpoints for evaluating progress toward meeting those goals, and ensure that the time requirements for completing the plan are realistic given the employee’s job demands.
🔑 Definition — Development Planning Process: A systematic process involving identifying development needs, choosing a goal, identifying actions, measuring progress, investing time/energy, and establishing a timetable.
💡 Why this matters: The development planning process shifts initiative to the employee, making it a collaborative effort where the manager provides support and resources, rather than dictating the plan.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical things a student MUST remember from this lecture are: (1) a coach plays three roles: providing feedback, connecting employees with experts, and offering resources, with successful relationships hinging on a strong manager-coach bond, high motivation to change, and top management commitment. (2) Coaching typically lasts 7–12 months, and coaches should be empathetic, supportive, and practical, while employees must be open-minded and honest about their weaknesses. (3) Four common barriers to coaching include fear of confrontation, inability to solve performance problems, fear of being seen as critical, and lack of time due to downsizing. (4) The development planning process is employee-initiated and involves identifying gaps between current capabilities and future goals, using tools like performance appraisals and 360-degree feedback. (5) The manager’s role in development is to coach, provide resources, help set realistic goals, and establish checkpoints for progress, always considering the employee’s job demands.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three roles a coach can play in employee development?
- List the three most important factors for a successful coaching relationship.
- What are the four reasons why managers may be reluctant to provide coaching?
- What is the first step in the development planning process, and who initiates it?
- What resources and tools can employees use to identify their development needs?
📘 Lecture 40 — SPECIAL ISSUES IN TRAINING AND EMPLOYEE DEVELOPMENT
📖 Overview: This lecture explores critical external and internal issues that affect training and employee development programs. It focuses on legal vulnerabilities arising from training activities, the imperative of cross-cultural preparation for global business, and the specific challenges of preparing expatriates and their families for international assignments. Understanding these issues is vital for designing compliant, effective, and globally-minded training initiatives.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture first details a range of legal issues stemming from the external environment, including failing to provide adequate training, workplace injuries, breach of confidentiality, copyright infringement, and discrimination. It then shifts to the topic of cross-cultural preparation for a global workforce, explaining the different types of global employees and the critical dimensions of national culture. Finally, the lecture outlines the necessary competencies and support systems required for successful expatriate assignments.
📝 Lecture Summary
TRAINING ISSUES RESULTING FROM THE EXTERNAL ENVIRONMENT
Legal Issues
Companies face significant legal exposure from various training-related activities. These issues can harm a company’s reputation and lead to legal actions. Managers must proactively manage these risks across several areas.
🔑 Definition — Expatriates: Employees who work in a country other than their country of origin.
🔑 Definition — Host-country nationals: Employees with citizenship in the country where the company is located.
Failing to Provide Training or Providing Inadequate Training: Companies are legally required to show that employees have not only completed training but are also applying their new knowledge on the job to comply with laws and regulations.
Incurring Employee Injury during a Training Activity: On-the-job training and simulations using tools and equipment can cause injury. Workers’ compensation laws often make employers responsible for salary and financial settlements for injuries from employment-related activities like training. Managers must ensure employees are warned of dangers and safety equipment is used.
Incurring Injuries to Employees or Others Outside a Training Session: Managers must ensure trainees have the necessary competence before operating equipment or interacting with customers. A company remains liable for damages from poorly trained employees, even if training was conducted by a vendor. To mitigate risk, companies should ensure vendors have liability insurance, confirm trainer competence, and check for previous litigation. Trainers should keep copies of notes and manuals showing correct procedures.
Incurring Breach of Confidentiality or Defamation: Information placed in employee files about training performance must be accurate. Managers must inform employees if training performance will be used for promotion or salary decisions and should not discuss it with other employees without prior notice.
Reproducing and Using Copyrighted Material in Training Classes without Permission: Copyrights protect the expression of an idea and prohibit copying, broadcasting, or publishing without permission. Using videotapes, manuals, and other copyrighted materials without permission is illegal. Material on the Internet is not necessarily free from copyright; while the fair use doctrine allows limited use of small amounts without permission or fee, it must meet four standards: (1) the purpose of use, (2) the nature of the copyrighted work, (3) the proportion used, and (4) the potential financial loss to the copyright owner. Republishing or repackaging Internet material under one’s own name can violate copyright law.
Excluding Women, Minorities, and Older Employees from Training Programs: Illegal exclusion can occur by not informing employees of opportunities or by purposeful exclusion from enrollment. Denial of training opportunities can support claims of age, race, or gender discrimination. For example, courts will investigate whether older workers were denied training provided to younger workers. Managers must ensure an age-neutral culture and policies, make decisions based on job-relevant factors like performance, and ensure all employees have development plans.
Not Ensuring Equal Treatment of All Employees While in Training: Equal treatment means all trainees, regardless of background, have equal access to practice, feedback, and role-playing opportunities. Trainers must avoid jokes, stories, or props that create a hostile learning environment.
Requiring Employees to Attend Programs That Might Be Offensive: Cultural and religious values must be considered when designing programs to avoid causing offense.
Revealing Discriminatory Information during a Training Session: Disclosing personal or negative information about a participant as an example for others can cause issues.
Not Accommodating Trainees with Disabilities: Reasonable accommodation involves making training facilities accessible and usable by individuals with disabilities. This may include modifying instructional media or providing readers or interpreters. Employers are not required to provide accommodation if the person does not request it or if the person is not qualified (e.g., lacks prerequisite certification).
Incorrectly Reporting Training as an Expense or Failing to Report Training Reimbursement as Income: For training expenses to be deductible, they must maintain or improve skills required for the job, serve a business purpose, and be required by the company or law for employees to keep their current salary, status, or job.
💡 Why this matters: Ignoring these legal issues can expose a company to costly lawsuits, fines, and reputational damage, undermining the value of any training program.
Cross-Cultural Preparation
With increased global operations, employees often work outside their home country or with colleagues from other nations. Top managers with international experience contribute to a global company’s success. The lecture distinguishes between two types of global employees: expatriates, who work in a country other than their own, and host-country nationals, who are citizens of the country where the company is located. A key reason for using more host-country nationals is their easier understanding of local workforce values and customs. Cross-cultural preparation involves educating expatriates and their families before they are sent to a foreign country to help them understand different business practices and cultural norms.
Dimensions of Cultural Differences
National culture, the set of shared assumptions and ideals, significantly influences employee behavior and the effectiveness of management styles. Research by G. Hofstede identified five key dimensions of national culture.
🔑 Definition — Culture: The set of assumptions that group members share about the world and how it works and the ideals worth striving for.
🔑 Definition — Individualism-collectivism: The degree to which people act as individuals rather than as members of a group. In an individualistic culture (e.g., USA), employees are hired and rewarded based on personal skills. In a collectivist culture, employees are more likely to have a voice in decisions.
🔑 Definition — Uncertainty avoidance: The degree to which people prefer structured rather than unstructured situations. Cultures with strong uncertainty avoidance (e.g., Japan, Russia) favor clear rules, while those with weak uncertainty avoidance (e.g., Jamaica) cope by not worrying about the future.
🔑 Definition — Masculinity-femininity: The extent to which a culture values traditionally masculine traits (competitiveness, assertiveness) versus feminine traits (helpfulness, quality of life). Examples of masculine cultures include Japan, Germany, and the USA.
🔑 Definition — Power distance: Expectations for the unequal distribution of power in a hierarchy. High power distance cultures (e.g., India, Mexico) maintain clear hierarchical differences in communication and behavior, such as using titles.
🔑 Definition — Time orientation: The degree to which a culture focuses on the future rather than the past and present. Short-term orientation (e.g., USA, Russia) emphasizes tradition and social obligations. Long-term orientation (e.g., Japan, China) values thrift and persistence for future payoffs.
📌 Example: An attempt to expand decision-making authority for production workers in a Mexican plant (a culture with high power distance) failed because workers rebelled at doing what they saw as the manager’s work. Managers then narrowed the scope of worker authority. This contrasts with Mexico's high collectivism, which supported team-related information sharing for the benefit of the entire team.
Implications for Expatriates and Their Families: Cross-Cultural Training
To prepare employees for overseas assignments, companies must provide cross-cultural training. For success, expatriates need to be:
- Competent in their area of expertise.
- Able to communicate verbally and nonverbally in the host country.
- Flexible, tolerant of ambiguity, emotionally stable, outgoing, agreeable, and sensitive to cultural differences.
- Motivated to succeed, enjoy the challenge, and willing to learn about the host country’s culture, language, and customs.
- Supported by their families.
📌 Example: Studies found that expatriates who were extroverted (outgoing), agreeable (cooperative, tolerant), and conscientious (dependable, achievement-oriented) were more likely to want to stay on assignment and perform well. This suggests cross-cultural training may be most effective when an expatriate’s personality predisposes them to success.
A key reason for the high failure rate of U.S. expatriates is that companies over-emphasize technical skills and under-prepare employees for working in other cultures. Research indicates that the comfort of the expatriate’s spouse and family is the single most important determinant of whether the employee will complete the assignment.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A student must remember that training activities create significant legal liabilities, including for employee injuries, copyright infringement, and various forms of discrimination, requiring managers to be vigilant in design, delivery, and record-keeping. Cross-cultural preparation is not optional but essential for global business success, as cultural dimensions like power distance, individualism, and uncertainty avoidance profoundly affect management and communication styles. The Hofstede dimensions provide a foundational framework for understanding and predicting these cross-cultural differences. When preparing expatriates, technical competence is insufficient; personality traits like extroversion and agreeableness, along with strong family support, are critical predictors of assignment success. Finally, companies must legally ensure equal access and treatment in all training programs to avoid costly and reputation-damaging lawsuits.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four standards an organization must meet to legally use copyrighted material under the "fair use doctrine" in a training class?
- List at least three specific legal issues described in the lecture that can arise from training activities.
- What are the five dimensions of national culture identified by G. Hofstede, and how might "power distance" affect a training program's design?
- Besides technical competence, what five key characteristics must an expatriate possess for a successful overseas assignment?
- What is cited as the single most important determinant of whether an expatriate will complete a foreign assignment?
📘 Lecture 41 — Special Issues in Training and Employee Development (continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the critical phases of foreign assignments—pre-departure, on-site, and repatriation—and the necessary training for expatriates and their families. It also examines cultural differences that impact training design and delivery, and introduces the importance of managing workforce diversity to create an inclusive organizational environment.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by detailing the three phases of foreign assignments (pre-departure, on-site, and repatriation) and the specific training needs in each phase, including language training, cross-cultural orientation, and repatriation support. It then discusses the implications of cultural dimensions (e.g., power distance, individualism) for conducting training in different countries, using examples from China, Brazil, and Russia. Finally, the lecture defines workforce diversity, explains its importance, and outlines the goals of diversity training and managing diversity.
📝 Lecture Summary
Pre-departure Phase
In the pre-departure phase, employees need language training and an orientation to the new country’s culture and customs. It is critical that the family be included in these orientation programs. They need information about housing, schools, recreation, shopping, and health care facilities. Expatriates must also discuss with their managers how the foreign assignment fits into their career plan and what type of position they can expect upon return. Failing to speak the native language may keep the expatriate from informal conversations and increase the risk of being misinterpreted.
🔑 Definition — Rigor: The degree to which the training program emphasizes knowledge about the culture as well as behavior and skills needed to effectively live in the culture. Less rigorous methods (e.g., lectures) focus on factual material, while more rigorous methods help develop communication skills and behavior for interacting in another country.
📐 Formula: Training Rigor vs. Training Focus → As the level of cultural and job novelty increases, and as the need for interpersonal interaction with host nationals increases, more rigorous, experiential training methods are most effective and most needed.
📌 Example: Figure 41 shows the relationship between training rigor and training focus: presentational techniques (low rigor, low focus on interpersonal skills) at one end, and actual experiences in culturally diverse communities (high rigor, high focus) at the other.
💡 Why this matters: Including the family in pre-departure training is essential because the spouse’s adjustment is a major predictor of expatriate success or failure.
On-Site Phase
On-site training involves continued orientation to the host country through formal programs or a mentoring relationship. Expatriates and their families may be paired with a mentor from the host country to help them understand the new work environment and community. Companies also use the Web and knowledge management software to answer questions and allow employees to organize and access knowledge specific to their assignment.
A major reason employees refuse expatriate assignments is the concern about their spouse’s career being derailed by being out of the workforce, or the inability of the spouse to obtain a work permit. “Trailing” spouses may pursue educational activities. Research suggests companies should offer career counseling for expatriates to reduce stress. Support from the foreign facility and high-quality relationships with supervisors are important for work and interaction adjustment.
Repatriation Phase
Repatriation prepares expatriates for return to the parent company and country. Employees and their families often experience high stress due to changes that have occurred since their departure, and may need to readjust to a lower standard of living. Salary and compensation arrangements should be worked out before return. Experts suggest companies can minimize turnover by offering recognition, career support, choice in the return assignment, and opportunities to use their international experience. Employees should self-manage the repatriation process by considering skills they want to develop and maintaining contact with key company people while abroad.
Due to difficulty in getting employees to accept foreign assignments and low success rates, companies are creating virtual expatriate positions. These employees manage an operation abroad without being permanently located there, traveling periodically and using videoconferencing. Virtual expatriates eliminate family culture shock and are less expensive (traditional expatriates cost over three times that of a host-country national). A major disadvantage is that sporadic visits may lengthen the time needed to build a local management team.
📌 Example: Because of family issues, poor economic times, and security issues, many companies are reducing the number of expatriates and relying more on short-time assignments, frequent business travel, and international commutes.
Implications of Cultural Differences for Training
Table 83 presents the implications of cultural dimensions for training. In the United States, interaction between trainer and trainees is viewed positively, but in other cultures this may violate expected norms. In China, trainers are highly respected, education is valued, power distance is high, and harmony (low individualism) is valued. Therefore, lecture is the preferred method, trainers should not be questioned, and group performance (not individual) should be highlighted. In Brazil, trainers need to build a personal relationship, power distance is accepted, and popular methods include lecture and small group work. Group discussion may seem argumentative but is acceptable communication behavior. In Russia, on-the-job training may be viewed skeptically because workers expect formal training at an institute. Because Russian culture is more “feminine,” training materials should use examples from employees’ work and life situations. Trainers must also consider language differences: if an interpreter is used, a practice session is needed, and training materials must be translated well in advance.
💡 Why this matters: The key to success in foreign training is preparation—the needs assessment must include an evaluation of cultural dimensions and audience characteristics (language ability, company, and cultural status).
What Is Diversity? Why Is It Important?
Diversity can be considered any dimension that differentiates one person from another (e.g., age, ethnicity, education, work style, race, gender). The goals of diversity training are (1) to eliminate values, stereotypes, and managerial practices that inhibit personal development, and (2) to allow all employees to contribute to organizational goals regardless of race, age, physical condition, sexual orientation, gender, family status, religious orientation, or cultural background. Because of equal opportunity laws, companies focus on ensuring equal access to jobs. Cultural factors increasing the need for diversity training include the terrorist attacks of 9/11; fear of discussing cultural differences; diverse teams; diverse customer markets; and hiring highly trained employees from overseas who need training to understand American culture (e.g., obsession with time, individualistic attitudes).
Managing Work Force Diversity
Managing diversity involves creating an environment that allows all employees to contribute to organizational goals and experience personal growth. This includes fair and positive treatment of all employees. The company must develop employees comfortable working with people from diverse backgrounds. Managing diversity may require changing the company culture, including standards and norms about treatment, competitiveness, results orientation, innovation, and risk taking.
⭐ Key Takeaways
A successful foreign assignment requires training across three phases: pre-departure (language and cultural orientation for the employee and family), on-site (mentoring and continued support), and repatriation (career planning and readjustment). The rigor of cross-cultural training should match the novelty of the culture and job, with experiential methods being most effective for high-interaction assignments. Cultural dimensions like power distance and individualism significantly affect training methods and trainee expectations, requiring trainers to adapt their style (e.g., lecture in China vs. personal relationship building in Brazil). Diversity training aims to eliminate stereotypes and create an inclusive environment where all employees can contribute, while managing diversity involves changing company culture to ensure fair treatment.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three phases of a foreign assignment, and what type of training is required in each phase?
- Explain the concept of training “rigor” and how it relates to the “training focus” shown in Figure 41.
- How do high power distance and low individualism in Chinese culture affect the preferred training methods and trainer-trainee interaction?
- What is a “virtual expatriate,” and what are its main advantages and disadvantages compared to a traditional expatriate?
- Define “managing diversity” and state its two primary goals as they relate to training.
📘 Lecture 42 — Special Issues in Training and Employee Development (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the challenges of managing workforce diversity and the role of training in addressing them. It explains why affirmative action alone is insufficient and explores two main types of diversity training programs—attitude awareness and behavior-based—along with characteristics of successful diversity efforts. Understanding these concepts is critical for HR professionals who must create inclusive environments that capitalize on diversity for competitive advantage.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the barriers women and minorities face in the workplace, how managing diversity can provide competitive advantage, the cycle of disillusionment resulting from solely relying on employment law adherence, two types of diversity training programs (attitude awareness and change programs versus behavior-based programs), cultural immersion as a training approach, and the characteristics of successful long-term diversity efforts including evaluation metrics and the importance of tying diversity initiatives to business objectives.
📝 Lecture Summary
Managing Work Force Diversity
Despite company efforts, women and minorities continue to report barriers to career advancement. A Society for Human Resource Management survey revealed barriers including stereotyping and preconceptions, corporate culture, exclusion from informal networks, and lack of mentors and role models. Anyone perceived as "different" struggles to contribute to company goals and experience personal growth.
Managing diversity helps companies gain a competitive advantage because diverse customer groups prefer doing business with employees like themselves, and diverse employees provide insights into customers and product markets. Diversity goes beyond race and ethnicity to include differences in communication and problem-solving style and professional and functional expertise (e.g., marketing versus engineering). When teams get caught up in identifying differences rather than capitalizing on them, distrust and unproductive teams result. Team mission statements should reflect both what the team accomplishes and how interpersonal conflict is handled. Some companies require rotation of responsibilities so each person can demonstrate abilities and disprove stereotypes.
The link between diversity and company performance is both direct and indirect and requires a long-term commitment. Successful diversity requires viewing it as an opportunity for employees to (1) learn from each other how to better accomplish work, (2) be provided with a supportive and cooperative organizational culture, and (3) be taught leadership and process skills for effective team functioning. Diversity is a reality in labor and customer markets and is a social expectation and value.
💡 Why this matters: Diversity is not just about fairness—it directly impacts team performance, customer relationships, and competitive advantage in the marketplace.
Managing Diversity through Adherence to Legislation
One approach to managing diversity is through affirmative action policies and human resource practices meeting equal employment opportunity laws. However, this approach rarely changes employees' values, stereotypes, and behaviors, which can inhibit productivity and personal development.
📐 Cycle of Disillusionment: The cycle begins when the company realizes it must change policies regarding women and minorities due to legal pressure or a discrepancy between workforce numbers and labor market availability. More women and minorities are hired, and managers see little need for additional action. As women and minorities gain experience, they become frustrated because managers and co-workers avoid providing coaching or performance feedback, being uncomfortable interacting with different backgrounds. Co-workers may express beliefs that women and minorities received special treatment (e.g., lowered hiring standards). Women and minorities form support groups to voice concerns, but due to the work atmosphere, they may fail to fully utilize skills and leave the company.
🔑 Definition — Cycle of Disillusionment: A process where reliance solely on legal compliance for diversity leads to hiring without cultural change, causing frustration among minority employees and ultimately their departure.
Managing Diversity through Diversity Training Programs
Affirmative action without additional supporting strategies does not address assimilating women and minorities into the workforce. To successfully manage a diverse workforce, companies must ensure:
- Employees understand how their values and stereotypes influence behavior toward people of different gender, ethnicity, race, or religion
- Employees gain appreciation of cultural differences
- Behaviors that isolate or intimidate minority group members improve
These goals can be accomplished through diversity training programs.
🔑 Definition — Diversity training: Training designed to change employee attitudes about diversity and/or help employees develop skills needed to work with a diverse workforce.
Attitude Awareness and Change Programs
Attitude awareness and change programs focus on increasing employees' awareness of differences in cultural and ethnic backgrounds, physical characteristics (e.g., disabilities), and personal characteristics that influence behavior. Awareness training covers questions like "What is diversity?", "Who am I?", and stereotypes, assumptions, and biases regarding different ethnic groups. The underlying assumption is that by increasing awareness of stereotypes and beliefs, employees will avoid negative stereotypes when interacting with employees of different backgrounds. Programs use videotapes and experiential exercises to increase awareness of negative emotional and performance effects of stereotypes.
Criticisms of attitude awareness approach:
- By focusing on group differences, the program may communicate that certain stereotypes and attitudes are valid
- Encouraging employees to share attitudes and stereotypes may cause feelings of discrimination, guilt, anger, and reduce seeing similarities among groups
- If training only covers race, gender, ethnicity, or sexual orientation, some employees may feel their interests are not represented
Behavior-Based Programs
Behavior-based programs focus on changing organizational policies and individual behaviors that inhibit employees' personal growth and productivity.
Three approaches:
-
Identify incidents that discourage employees from working to their potential. Groups identify specific promotion opportunities, sponsorships, training opportunities, or performance management practices they believe were handled unfairly. Specific training programs address issues from focus groups.
-
Teach basic rules of behavior in the workplace, including behavior toward peers, managers, and customers. Employees learn that it is inappropriate to use statements or engage in behaviors with negative racial, sexual, or cultural content. Companies using this approach find employees react less negatively than to other diversity training approaches.
-
Cultural immersion refers to sending employees directly into communities where they interact with persons from different cultures, races, and/or nationalities.
🔑 Definition — Cultural immersion: The process of sending employees directly into communities where they have to interact with persons from different cultures, races, and/or nationalities, involving activities like talking with community members, working in community organizations, or learning about religious, cultural, or historically significant events.
📌 Example: UPS Community Internship Program — A management development program designed to help UPS senior managers understand diverse customer and workforce needs through exposure to poverty and inequality. Since 1968, over 1,200 senior managers have completed this four-week internship. Managers may serve meals to the homeless, help migrant farm workers, build temporary housing and schools, or manage children in a Head Start program. Three out of four UPS managers are white, while 35% of employees are minorities. The company invests $10,000 per intern, totaling over $13.5 billion since 1968. One manager who worked at a halfway house realized she had failed to capitalize on the creativity of supervised employees, and upon returning, began brainstorming with her entire staff, not just senior managers. Other managers report the experience helped them empathize with employees facing home crises.
Characteristics of Successful Diversity Efforts
Increasing evidence shows that attitude awareness programs are ineffective and one-time diversity training programs are unlikely to succeed. Effective diversity training programs are part of a broader company strategy where capitalizing on diversity is a business goal.
Surveys of diversity training efforts found:
- The most common area addressed is the pervasiveness of stereotypes, assumptions, and biases
- Less than one-third of companies do any kind of long-term evaluation or follow-up
- Most programs last only one day or less
- Three-fourths of respondents believe employees leave with positive attitudes; however, over 50% report no long-term effect
- 29% report no tools provided to reinforce training; 22% report no development or advancement issues addressed
Most common indicators of success: reduced number of grievances and lawsuits, increased diversity in promotions and hiring, increased self-awareness of biases, and increased consultation of HR specialists on diversity issues.
Critical characteristic: Diversity programs must be tied to business objectives. For example, cultural differences affect consumer preferences for skin cream or fragrance. Understanding cultural differences is part of understanding the consumer. Top management support can be demonstrated by creating a structure to support the initiative. Another important characteristic is that managers are rewarded for progress toward meeting diversity goals.
💡 Why this matters: Successful diversity training is not a one-day event but a long-term, integrated strategy tied to business goals with management accountability.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The cycle of disillusionment demonstrates that affirmative action alone, without cultural change, leads to frustration and turnover among minority employees. There are two main types of diversity training: attitude awareness programs (which have significant criticisms) and behavior-based programs (which focus on changing actual policies and behaviors). Cultural immersion, like the UPS program, is a powerful behavior-based approach that exposes managers to the real-life challenges of diverse populations. Successful diversity efforts must be tied to business objectives, have top management support, reward managers for meeting diversity goals, and include long-term evaluation—one-time training programs lasting a day or less are unlikely to succeed. The most common indicators of success are reduced grievances and lawsuits, increased diversity in promotions, and increased self-awareness of biases.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main barriers to career advancement faced by women and minorities according to the SHRM survey?
- Describe the cycle of disillusionment that results from managing diversity solely through adherence to employment laws.
- What are the three criticisms of attitude awareness and change diversity training programs?
- What is cultural immersion, and how does the UPS Community Internship Program serve as an example of this approach?
- What are the characteristics of successful long-term diversity efforts, and why are one-day training programs unlikely to succeed?
📘 Lecture 43 — SPECIAL ISSUES IN TRAINING AND EMPLOYEE DEVELOPMENT (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture examines the comprehensive diversity management program at Sodexo, a leading food and facilities management company, to illustrate how diversity training integrates with broader organizational strategy. It explains why successful diversity initiatives require more than just training—they demand cultural change, top management support, and accountability systems to achieve measurable business results.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Sodexo’s diversity strategy and objectives, the distinction between equal employment opportunity (EEO) compliance training and diversity education, the structure of diversity learning programs for executives and managers, employee network groups and recognition programs, the use of diversity scorecards tied to manager bonuses, and the business outcomes including a $19 return for every $1 spent. It concludes with a table of key components of effective diversity programs and the necessity of an ongoing culture change process.
📝 Lecture Summary
Sodexo’s Diversity Effort
Sodexo integrates diversity as a core element of its business strategy to meet growth targets. The company’s diversity objectives include understanding the business case for diversity and inclusion, increasing awareness of how diversity relates to business challenges, creating a diverse work environment through management practices that drive hiring, promotion, and retention of talent, engaging in relationship management to attract diverse clients, and partnering with women and minority businesses.
Sodexo separates equal employment opportunity (EEO) and legal compliance training from diversity education. Employees take EEO and affirmative action refresher courses every three years. Top management is involved through an ongoing classroom program reinforced with community involvement, sponsorship of employee groups, and mentoring of diverse employees. Every manager takes an eight-hour introductory class called “Spirit of Diversity,” with additional three- to four-hour learning labs on topics like cross-cultural communications, sexual orientation, generations, and gender in the workplace. The learning team develops customized solutions—for example, a course on selling to a diverse client base for the sales force and a cross-cultural communications program for recruiters.
Sodexo has six employee network groups, such as the African American Leadership Forum and People Respecting Individuality, Diversity and Equality, which provide forums for professional development and idea sharing. The “Champions of Diversity” program rewards employees who advance diversity and inclusion.
Each manager has a diversity scorecard that evaluates success in recruitment, retention, promotion, and development of all employees. The scorecard includes quantitative goals and behavioral evaluations such as participating in training, mentoring, and community outreach. A portion of managers’ pay bonuses is determined by success in these areas.
Sodexo’s diversity efforts have positively impacted business results: the mentoring program increased productivity, engagement, and retention of women and people of color. There has been an estimated return on investment of $19 for every $1 spent on the program. Sodexo also won new business contracts and retained clients due to its diversity management.
🔑 Definition — Diversity Scorecard: A tool that evaluates managers’ success in recruitment, retention, promotion, and development of all employees, including quantitative goals and behavioral evaluations tied to pay bonuses.
📐 Formula: ROI = ($19 return / $1 spent) → For every dollar invested in the diversity mentoring program, the company gains $19 in business value.
📌 Example: Sodexo’s mentoring program cost $1 and generated $19 in increased productivity, engagement, and retention of women and people of color, plus new business contracts and client retention.
💡 Why this matters: This demonstrates that diversity training, when integrated with accountability, top management support, and employee networks, yields substantial financial returns beyond compliance.
Table 86 and Key Components of Effective Diversity Programs
Most effective programs to manage diversity, such as Sodexo’s, include key components shown in Table 1 (referred to as Table 86 in the text). Successful diversity programs involve more than just an effective training program—they require an ongoing process of culture change that includes:
- Top management support
- Diversity policies and practices in recruitment and hiring
- Training and development
- Administrative structures such as conducting diversity surveys and evaluating managers’ progress on diversity goals
- Improved relationships with minority customers, vendors, and suppliers
🔑 Definition — Culture Change: An ongoing process required for successful diversity programs that extends beyond training to include top management support, diversity policies, administrative structures, and improved relationships with minority stakeholders.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that effective diversity management is not a one-time training event but an ongoing culture change requiring top management commitment, separate EEO compliance from diversity education, and accountability mechanisms like diversity scorecards tied to bonuses. Sodexo’s example shows that integrating diversity into business strategy—through employee network groups, customized learning, and recognition programs—produces measurable ROI ($19 per $1 spent) and improves recruitment, retention, and client relationships. Key components include administrative structures like surveys and manager evaluations, plus partnerships with minority businesses. Finally, diversity programs must address all areas: hiring, training, promotion, retention, and community outreach to succeed.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between EEO compliance training and diversity education at Sodexo?
- Name three components of a manager’s diversity scorecard and explain how it affects compensation.
- What was the estimated return on investment for Sodexo’s diversity mentoring program?
- List the six key components of effective diversity programs mentioned in the lecture.
- How does Sodexo involve top management in its diversity efforts beyond classroom training?