๐ Lecture 35 โ Insurance and Risk
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how insurance functions as a system for transferring and pooling risk to protect against financial loss. It examines the core principles of risk transference and the law of large numbers, defines the characteristics of an insurable risk, and analyzes how credit information is used differently by insurers versus lenders to assess risk and determine premiums.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining insurance and its foundational principles of risk transference and the law of large numbers, using examples like auto and health insurance. It then outlines the seven criteria for a risk to be considered insurable. The concepts of spread of risk and reduction of risk are explained. A major section differentiates between insurance-based credit scores and standard credit scores used by financial institutions, explaining their different purposes and predictive outcomes. The lecture concludes with an analysis of the basic parts of an insurance contract, including declarations, the insuring agreement, exclusions, and conditions.
๐ Lecture Summary
Insurance and Risk
Insurance is a system to protect persons against the risks of financial loss by transferring the risks to a large group who share the financial losses. Insurance is based on two principles: risk transference and the law of large numbers.
๐ Definition โ Risk transference: The transfer of risk from the individual to a pool of the insurance companyโs policyholders. The insurance company charges a fee, the premium, for accepting the risk and 'pools' the premiums from a group of policyholders into a general fund.
๐ Definition โ Law of large numbers: The principle that the larger the pool, the more predictable the amount of losses will be in a given period. Not all members of the pool will make a claim at the same time. By studying claims over a very large population, the number of people in a specific demographic who will die or have an accident in a particular year can be fairly predicted. It does not predict an individual event, but the probability for a group.
๐ Example: A teenager commands a higher auto insurance rate because statistical history shows they have more accidents than a 40-year-old driver. Homeowners on the eastern seaboard of Florida have a higher incidence of losses than a homeowner in Idaho and should pay a higher premium.
Insured Risk
An insured risk is a risk that meets the following criteria:
- The insured loss must have a definite time and place.
- The insured event must be accidental.
- The insured must have an insurable interest in the subject of coverage.
- The insured risks must belong to a sufficiently large group of homogeneous exposure units to make losses predictable.
- The risk must not be subject to a catastrophic loss where a large number of exposure units can be damaged or destroyed in a single event.
- The coverage must be provided at a reasonable cost.
- The chance of loss must be calculable.
Spread of Risk
Spread of risk is a principle of insurance that insurers need to accept homogeneous exposure units spread over a wide geographic area, with the knowledge that only a given number of risks will result in claims or losses. This dispersion allows insurers to project expected losses, lessens the potential for catastrophic losses, and allows for the development of rates.
Reduction of Risk
Reduction of risk is a method of handling risk by the scope or volume of a firm's operations or through the purchase of insurance.
๐ Example: A large outdoor advertising firm reduces its risk of lost revenue due to damaged billboards in a way that a small billboard company cannot because of its large number of dispersed exposure units. The scale of operations makes losses relatively predictable. Insurance reduces risk for the small company by combining a number of similar companies' risks into a more predictable group.
What's the difference between an insurance score and a credit score?
The use of credit information by insurance companies is not the same as by banks. Insurers aren't as interested in credit-worthiness as in stability. While it's not a loan, insurance is like a line of credit where customers pay premiums so they will have money to repair or replace their homes or cars in the event of a loss.
What is a Credit Score?
A credit score is a system developed by the lending industry to score the borrower's credit history. The score is seen as predictive of the borrower's ability and willingness to repay the loan and gives the lender the ability to give a rapid credit decision by using automated underwriting software.
What does my credit score have to do with insurance?
Most insurance companies use credit scoring as a tool to qualify customers for the best premiums possible. It is not a pure credit score, but a barometer for estimating a customer's potential for having a claim. Financial history has an effect on the ability to properly maintain property.
What is an insurance-based credit score?
An insurance-based credit score is a number or rating generated when information from a consumer's credit history is plugged into a highly specialized insurance formula or rating model. The purpose is to predict the potential risk of loss that consumer poses to the insurance company.
How can my credit insurance score benefit me?
A credit-based insurance score allows insurers to quote the fairest, most appropriate rate for every customer. About half of existing customers receive a rate decrease based on their credit score.
Why do Insurance Companies run a credit score?
The use of credit history helps provide a consistent tool to look at every risk. It does not discriminate against any specific group of customers.
Is an insurance credit score different from the credit score a bank or financial institution uses?
Yes. An insurance credit score differs from the credit score used by banks and financial institutions. Though both rely on the same source of information, the scores and the models that generate them are designed to predict different outcomes. A bank or financial institution uses credit information to predict the amount of your loan, your ability to repay the loan, and the risk of default. An insurer uses it to predict the likelihood of you filing a claim.
Analysis of Insurance Contracts
Basic Parts of an Insurance Contract
Declarations are statements that provide information about the particular property or activity to be insured. Usually the first page of the policy, in property insurance it contains the name of the insured, location of property, period of protection, amount of insurance, premium, and deductible information. Insurance contracts contain a page of definitions (e.g., the insured is referred to as "you").
The insuring agreement summarizes the major promises of the insurer. The two basic forms in property insurance are:
- Named perils policy: Only those perils specifically named in the policy are covered.
- "All-risks" policy: All losses are covered except those specifically excluded. This is also called an open-perils policy or special coverage policy. Insurers have deleted the word "all" from policies. "All-risks" coverage has fewer gaps, and the burden of proof is placed on the insurer to deny a claim.
Insurance contracts contain three major types of exclusions:
- Excluded perils, e.g., flood, intentional act
- Excluded losses, e.g., a professional liability loss is excluded in the homeowners policy
- Excluded property, e.g., pets are not covered as personal property in the homeowners policy
Exclusions are necessary because:
- Some perils are not commercially insurable (e.g., catastrophic losses due to war)
- Extraordinary hazards are present (e.g., using the automobile for a taxi)
- Coverage is provided by other contracts (e.g., use of auto excluded on homeowners policy)
- Moral hazard is present or it would be difficult to measure the amount of loss (e.g., coverage of money limited to $200 in homeowners policy)
- Coverage not needed by typical insureds (e.g., homeowners policy does not cover aircraft)
Conditions are provisions in the policy that qualify or place limitations on the insurerโs promise to perform. If policy conditions are not met, the insurer can refuse to pay the claim. Insurance policies contain a variety of miscellaneous provisions, e.g., cancellation, subrogation, grace period, misstatement of age.
โญ Key Takeaways
Insurance operates on risk transference to a large pool and the law of large numbers to make losses predictable for the group. For a risk to be insurable, it must meet criteria including being accidental, having a calculable chance of loss, and belonging to a homogeneous group where a catastrophic loss is unlikely. An insurance-based credit score is distinct from a bank credit score; insurers use it to predict loss potential and stability, not creditworthiness or repayment ability. An insurance contract's core parts are declarations, the insuring agreement (which defines coverage as named-perils or all-risks), exclusions, and conditions; exclusions are necessary for dealing with uninsurable perils, extraordinary hazards, and controlling moral hazard.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two fundamental principles upon which all insurance is based?
- List four of the seven criteria a risk must meet to be considered an insurable risk.
- What is the primary difference in the purpose of a credit score for a bank versus an insurance company?
- In property insurance, what is the difference between a "named perils" policy and an "all-risks" policy?
- Name three types of exclusions found in insurance contracts and explain a reason why exclusions are necessary.
๐ Lecture 36 โ Definition of the โInsuredโ
๐ Overview: This lecture covers key insurance contract provisions including the definition of the insured, endorsements and riders, deductibles, coinsurance, and other-insurance provisions. It also introduces social insurance programs and the liability risk, including the law of negligence. Understanding these concepts is critical for risk management and insurance analysis.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the definition of who is insured under an insurance contract, including named insured and unnamed parties. It then explains endorsements and riders that modify original contracts, followed by various types of deductibles used in property/liability and health insurance. Coinsurance clauses in both property and health insurance are detailed. Other-insurance provisions that prevent profiting from insurance are covered, along with social insurance characteristics. The lecture concludes with the basis of legal liability, elements of negligence, and legal defenses.
๐ Lecture Summary
Definition of the โInsuredโ
An insurance contract must specify the persons or persons from whom the protection is provided. Some policies insure only one person, e.g., most life insurance policies. The named insured is the person or persons named in the declarations section of the policy. A policy may cover other parties even though they are not specifically named; for example, the homeowners policy covers resident relatives under age 24 who are full-time students away from home.
Endorsements and Riders
In property and liability insurance, an endorsement is a written provision that adds to, deletes from, or modifies the provisions in the original contract. For example, an earthquake endorsement to a homeowners policy. In life and health insurance, a rider is a provision that amends or changes the original policy, such as a waiver-of-premium rider on a life insurance policy.
Deductibles
A deductible is a provision by which a specified amount is subtracted from the total loss payment that otherwise would be payable. The purpose of a deductible is to: eliminate small claims that are expensive to handle and process; reduce premiums paid by the insured; and reduce moral and morale hazard. Under the large loss principle, insurance should pay for high severity losses; small losses can be budgeted out of the personโs income.
With a straight deductible, the insured must pay a certain amount before the insurer makes a loss payment, e.g., an auto insurance deductible. An aggregate deductible means that all losses that occur during a specified time period are accumulated to satisfy the deductible amount.
๐ Definition โ Deductible: A provision by which a specified amount is subtracted from the total loss payment that otherwise would be payable.
Deductibles in Health Insurance
A calendar-year deductible is a type of aggregate deductible that is found in basic medical expense and major medical insurance contracts. A corridor deductible is a deductible that can be used to integrate a basic medical expense plan with a supplemental major medical expense plan. An elimination (waiting) period is a stated period of time at the beginning of a loss during which no insurance benefits are paid.
Coinsurance
A coinsurance clause in a property insurance contract encourages the insured to insure the property to a stated percentage of its insurable value. If the coinsurance requirement is not met at the time of the loss, the insured must share in the loss as a coinsurer.
๐ Formula: Coinsurance Formula: Amount of insurance carried / Amount of insurance required ร Loss = Amount of recovery
The purpose of coinsurance is to achieve equity in rating. A property owner wishing to insure for a total loss would pay an inequitable premium if other property owners only insure for partial losses. If the coinsurance requirement is met, the insured receives a rate discount, and the policy-owner who is underinsured is penalized through application of the coinsurance formula.
๐ Example: If a property has insurable value of $100,000 and an 80% coinsurance clause, the required amount of insurance is $80,000. If the insured carries only $60,000 of insurance and suffers a $20,000 loss, the recovery would be: ($60,000/$80,000) ร $20,000 = $15,000.
Coinsurance in Health Insurance
Health insurance policies frequently contain a percentage participation clause. The clause requires the insured to pay a certain percentage of covered medical expenses in excess of the deductible. The purpose is to reduce premiums and prevent over-utilization of policy benefits.
Other-insurance Provisions
The purpose of other-insurance provisions is to prevent profiting from insurance and violation of the principle of indemnity. Under a pro rata liability provision, each insurerโs share of the loss is based on the proportion that its insurance bears to the total amount of insurance on the property. Under contribution by equal shares, each insurer shares equally in the loss until the share paid by each insurer equals the lowest limit of liability under any policy, or until the full amount of the loss is paid.
Under a primary and excess insurance provision, the primary insurer pays first, and the excess insurer pays only after the policy limits under the primary policy are exhausted. The coordination of benefits provision in group health insurance is designed to prevent over-insurance and the duplication of benefits if one person is covered under more than one group health insurance plan, e.g., two employed spouses are insured as dependents under each otherโs group health insurance plan.
Social Insurance
Social insurance programs are necessary for several reasons: to help solve complex social problems; to provide coverage for perils that are difficult to insure privately; and to provide a base of economic security to the population.
Basic Characteristics of Social Insurance
Social insurance programs have certain characteristics that distinguish them from other government insurance programs: most programs are compulsory, which makes it easier to provide a floor of income to the population and reduces adverse selection. Programs are designed to provide a floor of income and pay benefits based largely on social adequacy rather than individual equity, with benefits heavily weighted in favor of certain groups such as low-income persons, large families, and retirees.
Benefits are loosely related to the workersโ earnings. Programs, benefits, and benefit formulas are prescribed by law. A formal means test is not required, which involves disclosing income and assets. Full funding of benefits is unnecessary; for example, it is not necessary to fully fund Social Security because workers will always enter the program and support it. Programs are designed to be financially self-supporting, almost completely financed from the earmarked contributions of covered employees.
๐ก Why this matters: Social insurance protects the population from risks that are difficult for private insurers to cover, ensuring basic economic security.
The Liability Risk โ Basis of Legal Liability
A legal wrong is a violation of a personโs legal rights, or a failure to perform a legal duty owed to a certain person or to society as a whole. Legal wrongs include: crime, breach of contract, and tort. A tort is a legal wrong for which the court allows a remedy in the form of money damages. The person who is injured (plaintiff) by the action of another (tortfeasor) can sue for damages.
Torts fall into three categories: intentional, e.g., fraud, assault; strict liability, where liability is imposed regardless of negligence or fault; and negligence.
๐ Definition โ Tort: A legal wrong for which the court allows a remedy in the form of money damages.
Law of Negligence
Negligence is the failure to exercise the standard of care required by law to protect others from an unreasonable risk of harm. The standard of care is not the same for each wrongful act; it is based on the care required of a reasonably prudent person.
Elements of Negligence: Existence of a legal duty to use reasonable care; failure to perform that duty; damage or injury to the claimant; and proximate cause relationship between the negligent act and the infliction of damages, requiring an unbroken chain of events.
The law allows for the following types of damages: Compensatory damages compensate the victim for losses actually incurred, including special damages (e.g., medical expenses) and general damages (e.g., pain and suffering). Punitive damages are designed to punish people and organizations so that others are deterred from committing the same wrongful act.
The ability to collect damages for negligence depends on state law. Under a contributory negligence law, the injured person cannot collect damages if his or her care falls below the standard of care required for his or her protection. Under strict application of common law, the injured cannot collect damages if his or her conduct contributed in any way to the injury.
Under a comparative negligence law, the financial burden of the injury is shared by both parties according to their respective degrees of fault. Under the pure rule, you can collect damages even if you are negligent, but your reward is reduced in proportion to your fault. Under the 49 percent rule, you can collect damages only if your negligence is less than the negligence of the other party. Under the 50 percent rule, you can recover reduced damages only if your negligence is not greater than the negligence of the other party.
Some legal defenses can defeat a claim for damages: The last clear chance rule states that a plaintiff who is endangered by his or her own negligence can still recover damages from the defendant if the defendant has a last clear chance to avoid the accident but fails to do so. Under the assumption of risk doctrine, a person who understands and recognizes the danger inherent in a particular activity cannot recover damages in the event of an injury.
๐ Definition โ Negligence: The failure to exercise the standard of care required by law to protect others from an unreasonable risk of harm.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that an insurance policy can cover named insureds and unnamed parties. Deductibles eliminate small claims and reduce premiums, with straight, aggregate, calendar-year, corridor, and elimination period types. Coinsurance in property insurance uses a formula to encourage full insurance, while in health insurance it involves percentage participation. Other-insurance provisions prevent profiting from insurance using pro rata liability, equal shares, primary and excess, and coordination of benefits approaches. Social insurance is compulsory, provides a floor of income based on social adequacy, and is financially self-supporting. The liability risk involves torts (intentional, strict liability, and negligence), with negligence requiring four elements: duty, breach, damages, and proximate cause. Contributory negligence bars recovery, while comparative negligence shares damages based on fault.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the purpose of a deductible in an insurance policy, and how does a straight deductible differ from an aggregate deductible?
- Under the coinsurance formula in property insurance, if a property with a $200,000 insurable value has a 90% coinsurance requirement, the insured carries $150,000 of insurance, and suffers a $50,000 loss, what is the amount of recovery?
- What are the four elements of negligence that must be proven for a plaintiff to recover damages?
- How does contributory negligence differ from comparative negligence in determining liability for damages?
- What are the basic characteristics of social insurance programs that distinguish them from private insurance?
๐ Lecture 37 โ Personal Auto Policy Basics
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the 2005 Personal Auto Policy (PAP), a standardized insurance contract drafted by the ISO and widely used in the USA and European countries. It explains the core coverages of the PAPโliability, medical payments, uninsured motorists, and damage to your autoโalong with key definitions, eligible vehicles, exclusions, and the duties of the insured after a loss.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the structure and eligibility of the PAP, followed by detailed explanations of its four major coverage parts: Liability Coverage, Medical Payments, Uninsured Motorists Coverage, and Coverage for Damage to Your Auto. It also addresses duties after an accident, general provisions including cancellation and non-renewal, and the insuring of motorcycles and other vehicles via endorsement.
๐ Lecture Summary
Personal Auto Policy Basics
The 2005 Personal Auto Policy (PAP) is a standardized form drafted by the ISO (Insurance Services Office), replacing the 1998 version and widely used in the USA and European Countries. Eligible vehicles include a four-wheeled motor vehicle owned or leased by the insured for at least six consecutive months, and a pick-up or van with a gross vehicle weight rating (GVWR) of 10,000 pounds or less, which cannot be used for deliveries (with some exceptions). Autos covered by the policy are: any auto shown in the declarations; a newly acquired auto; coverage depends on whether it is an additional or replacement vehicle and if the declarations indicate at least one auto for collision coverage; a trailer owned by the named insured; and a temporary substitute vehicle, which is a non-owned auto or trailer used temporarily because of mechanical breakdown, repair, servicing, loss, or destruction of a covered vehicle.
Liability Coverage
Liability coverage is the most important part of the PAP. It protects a covered person against a suit or claim arising out of the ownership or operation of a covered vehicle. The coverage is usually written in split limits, where the amounts of insurance for bodily injury liability and property damage liability are stated separately. The insurer agrees to provide defense and pay all legal defense costs for claims covered by the policy, and these defense costs are covered in addition to the policy limits.
๐ Definition โ Split Limits: A method of stating liability coverage limits where separate maximum amounts are specified for bodily injury per person, bodily injury per accident, and property damage per accident.
Liability coverage applies to: the named insured and any resident family member; any person using the named insuredโs covered auto; any person or organization legally responsible for any insuredโs use of a covered auto; and any person or organization legally responsible for the named insuredโs or family membersโ use of any auto or trailer (other than a covered auto or one owned by the person or organization). In addition to policy limits and legal defense, certain supplementary payments can be paid, including: the cost of a bail bond, premiums on appeals bonds, interest accruing after a judgment, loss of earnings, and other reasonable expenses.
Key exclusions to liability coverage include: intentional injury or damage; property owned or transported; property rented, used, or in the insuredโs care; bodily injury to an employee; use as a public livery or conveyance; vehicles used in the auto business; vehicles with fewer than four wheels; and a vehicle furnished for the insuredโs regular use. If an accident occurs in another state with higher financial responsibility law liability limits than shown in the declarations, the PAP automatically provides the higher limits. If more than one liability policy covers a loss, the insurer pays its pro rata share for an owned vehicle, and the coverage is excess over any other insurance for a non-owned vehicle.
Medical Payments
Medical payments coverage covers all reasonable medical and funeral expenses incurred by an insured in an accident. Coverage is not based on fault. Two groups are eligible: (1) the named insured and family members, while occupying any motor vehicle or as pedestrians when struck by a motor vehicle; and (2) other persons occupying a covered auto (but not in a non-owned vehicle). It covers medical services rendered within three years from the date of the accident.
Exclusions include injuries sustained: while occupying a vehicle with fewer than four wheels; while operating the vehicle as a public livery or conveyance; when the vehicle is used as a residence; when the vehicle is used without a reasonable belief of permission; or when the vehicle is competing in a race. If more than one auto policy covers a loss, the insurer pays its pro rata share for an owned vehicle, and the coverage is excess over any other insurance for a non-owned vehicle.
Uninsured Motorists Coverage
The uninsured motorists coverage pays for bodily injury caused by an uninsured motorist, by a hit-and-run driver, or by a negligent driver whose insurance company is insolvent. In some states, property damage is also covered. The uninsured motorist must be legally liable. The coverage applies to the named insured and family members, any other person occupying a covered auto, and any person legally entitled to recover damages (e.g., a surviving spouse).
Coverage does not apply when: an insured is injured in or by a vehicle owned by the named insured but not insured under the policy; there is primary coverage under another policy; the vehicle is used as a public livery or conveyance (does not apply to a carpool); or when workers compensation benefits are applicable. There are several limitations when more than one uninsured motorist coverage provision applies to a loss. For example, if an insurer provides coverage on a vehicle not owned by the named insured, the insurance provided is excess over any collectible insurance provided on a primary basis.
Underinsured motorists coverage can be added to the PAP as an endorsement to provide more complete protection. In general, the maximum amount paid is the underinsured motoristโs coverage limit stated in the policy less the amount paid by the negligent driverโs insurer. Some states make it mandatory, while others make it optional.
Coverage for Damage to Your Auto
Under coverage for damage to your auto, the insurer agrees to pay for any direct and accidental loss to a covered auto or any non-owned auto. Two optional coverages are available: Collision coverage, defined as the upset of your covered auto or non-owned auto or its impact with another vehicle or object; and other-than-collision (often comprehensive) coverage. A non-owned auto is defined as a private passenger auto, pickup, van, or trailer not owned by or furnished for regular use of the named insured or family member, while in their custody or being operated by them. The coverage also applies to a temporary substitute vehicle.
๐ก Why this matters: The policy offers the broadest coverage applicable to any covered auto shown in the declarations. A collision damage waiver (CDW) may be unnecessary on a rental car if you carry collision and comprehensive coverage on your own car, though most independent agents recommend its purchase.
This part also pays for temporary transportation expenses (e.g., train, bus, taxi), subject to daily and total limits, and includes charges from a rental car company for loss of daily rental. Coverage for towing and labor costs can be added by an endorsement.
Exclusions include: use as a public livery or conveyance; damage from wear and tear, freezing, and mechanical or electrical breakdown; radioactive contamination or war; certain electronic equipment (though permanently installed equipment is covered); tapes, records, and disks; government destruction or confiscation; trailer, camper body, or motor home; and racing vehicle. For a total loss, the policy pays the actual cash value less the deductible. For a partial loss, the policy pays only the amount necessary to repair or replace the damaged property of like kind and quality, using original equipment manufacturer (OEM) or generic parts. Insurers can add a clarifying endorsement to exclude coverage for diminution in value. The insured can purchase gap insurance to cover the difference between the amount an insurer pays for a totaled car and the amount owed on a lease or loan. If more than one auto policy covers a physical damage loss, the insurer pays its pro rata share for an owned vehicle, and coverage is excess for a non-owned vehicle. The policy includes an appraisal provision for handling disputes over the amount of physical damage loss.
Duties after an Accident or Loss
After an accident, the insured is required to perform certain duties, such as: promptly notify the insurance company or agent; cooperate with the insurer in the investigation and settlement of a claim; send the insurer copies of any legal notices received in connection with an accident; and take a physical exam, if required. The police must be notified if a hit-and-run driver is involved. The insurer must be allowed to inspect your vehicle if you are seeking coverage under the next Part. The insurer can deny coverage only if failure to comply is prejudicial to the insurer.
General Provisions
The PAP provides coverage in the US, US territories, Puerto Rico, and Canada. All states restrict the insurerโs right to cancel or non-renew coverage. Termination provisions include:
- Cancellation: The named insured can cancel at any time. If a policy has been in force for more than 60 days, the insurer can cancel only if: the premium has not been paid; the driverโs license of any insured has been suspended; or the policy was obtained through material misrepresentation.
- Non-renewal: If an insurer decides to discontinue coverage, the insured must be given notice at least 20 days before the end of the policy period.
- Automatic termination: A policy is automatically terminated if the insured declines the insurerโs offer to renew.
Insuring Motorcycles and Other Vehicles
A miscellaneous-type vehicle endorsement can be added to the PAP to insure motorcycles, mopeds, motor-scooters, golf carts, motor homes, dune buggies, etc. It does not cover snowmobiles. The liability coverage does not apply to a non-owned vehicle. A passenger hazard exclusion can be elected, which excludes liability for bodily injury to any passenger on a motorcycle.
โญ Key Takeaways
The Personal Auto Policy (PAP) is a standardized insurance contract with four main coverage parts: Liability, Medical Payments, Uninsured Motorists, and Coverage for Damage to Your Auto. Liability coverage is the most critical, providing protection and legal defense for covered persons, and is written in split limits. Medical Payments coverage is not based on fault and covers expenses for named insureds, family members, and occupants. Uninsured Motorists coverage protects against hit-and-run and uninsured drivers, while Underinsured Motorists coverage can be added as an endorsement. Coverage for Damage to Your Auto includes optional Collision and comprehensive coverages, with payment based on actual cash value for total losses and repair/replacement for partial losses, minus the deductible.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main coverage parts of the Personal Auto Policy (PAP)?
- Define "split limits" as they apply to liability coverage in the PAP.
- List three specific exclusions that apply to Liability Coverage under the PAP.
- For Coverage for Damage to Your Auto, how does the policy pay for a total loss versus a partial loss?
- Under what three conditions can an insurer cancel a PAP that has been in force for more than 60 days?
๐ Lecture 38 โ Auto Insurance and Society
๐ Overview: This lecture examines societal approaches to compensating auto accident victims, focusing on the challenges of uninsured and underinsured drivers. It explores various state-level mechanisms including financial responsibility laws, compulsory insurance, unsatisfied judgment funds, and the no-fault auto insurance system, analyzing their effectiveness and limitations. The session also covers insurance for high-risk drivers and the factors influencing the cost of auto insurance.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers approaches for compensating auto accident victims, including financial responsibility laws, compulsory insurance laws, unsatisfied judgment funds, uninsured motorists coverage, and low-cost auto insurance. It discusses no-fault auto insurance in detail, including pure, modified, add-on, and choice plans, and arguments for and against no-fault laws. The lecture concludes with auto insurance for high-risk drivers through shared markets and the cost of auto insurance.
๐ Lecture Summary
Approaches for Compensating Auto Accident Victims
Many accident victims are unable to recover damages because the negligent driver may be uninsured or underinsured. States use several approaches to protect victims from irresponsible drivers. A financial responsibility law requires motorists to furnish proof of financial responsibility up to certain minimum dollar limits. Proof is required after an accident involving bodily injury or property damage over a certain amount, upon failure to pay a final judgment from an accident, or following a conviction for certain offenses like DUI. Evidence can be provided through an auto liability insurance policy, posting a bond, depositing the required amount, or showing status as a qualified self-insurer. Financial responsibility laws provide only limited protection because there is no guarantee all victims will be paid; victims may not be paid if injured by an uninsured driver, hit-and-run driver, or driver of a stolen car. State laws also require only minimum liability limits.
A compulsory insurance law requires motorists to carry at least a minimum amount of liability insurance before the vehicle can be licensed or registered. Some argue this provides greater protection because proof is required before an accident occurs, but critics note mandatory insurance does not reduce the number of uninsured drivers, and computer reporting systems to track them have not been effective. Five states have established unsatisfied judgment funds for compensating victims who have exhausted all other means of recovery. The victim must obtain a judgment against the negligent motorist and show it cannot be collected; the amount paid is limited and may be reduced by collateral sources, and the negligent driver must repay the fund. States finance benefits through insurer assessments.
Uninsured motorists coverage requires the injured personโs insurer to compensate for bodily injury caused by an uninsured motorist, a hit-and-run driver, or a negligent driver whose insurer is insolvent. Some states include property damage losses. One advantage is faster claim settlement than a tort lawsuit, but the injured person must establish the uninsured motorist is legally liable, and minimum limits are low. Low-cost auto insurance provides minimum liability insurance at reduced rates to motorists who cannot afford regular insurance, aiming to reduce uninsured drivers. A pilot program in California has not been effective, as many drivers still find insurance too expensive. Several states have enacted "no pay, no play" laws which prohibit uninsured motorists from suing negligent drivers for non-economic damages.
No-fault Auto Insurance
No-fault auto insurance is another method for compensating injured accident victims, with about half the states having such laws. After an accident involving bodily injury, each party collects from their own insurer regardless of fault. These laws were enacted because of dissatisfaction with the traditional tort liability system. No-fault plans vary: a pure no-fault plan allows accident victims to sue at all, but no states have enacted this. A modified no-fault plan gives victims a limited right to sue; in some states, an injured driver may sue if the claim exceeds a certain monetary threshold, while in others, a verbal threshold applies (e.g., death, dismemberment, disfigurement, or permanent loss). An add-on plan pays benefits without regard to fault but allows the injured person to sue the negligent driver, making it not a true no-fault plan. Under a choice no-fault plan, motorists can elect coverage under the no-fault law with lower premiums or retain the right to sue under tort liability with higher premiums.
No-fault benefits are provided by an endorsement to an auto insurance policy, restricted to economic loss including medical expenses, loss of earnings, essential services expenses, funeral expenses, and survivorsโ loss benefits. In some states, insurers must also offer optional no-fault benefits above minimums. The right to sue varies across states, but all permit lawsuits for serious injuries. No-fault laws cover only bodily injury, not property damage (except in Michigan), so motorists can sue the negligent driver for property damage, with cases usually small and resolved quickly.
Arguments supporting no-fault laws include difficulty in determining fault, inequity in claim payments where serious claims may be underpaid, high transaction costs and attorney fees (less than half of tort dollars reach victims), fraudulent and inflated claims when pain and suffering awards are based on multiples of expenses, and delay in payments. Arguments against no-fault laws include that defects of the present system are exaggerated, savings are exaggerated, court delays are confined to large cities, safe drivers may be penalized through inequitable rating, no payment is provided for pain and suffering, and the tort system should be improved rather than replaced. Some states have repealed no-fault laws because low monetary thresholds increased lawsuits. A study by the Institute for Civil Justice found that no-fault plans reduce attorney fees and claim processing costs, match compensation more closely with economic loss, and pay benefits more quickly, but savings depend on plan provisions.
Auto Insurance for High Risk Drivers
High risk drivers who have difficulty obtaining insurance in the voluntary market can obtain insurance in the shared (residual) market. These include younger drivers, those with poor driving records, and those with DUI convictions. Most states have an auto insurance plan (assigned risk plan) that makes insurance available to these motorists. All auto insurers in the state are assigned a proportionate share of high-risk drivers based on their total volume of auto premiums written, and premiums are substantially higher than in the voluntary market. A few states have a joint underwriting association (JUA), where insurers participate through a common pool, each paying a pro rata share of losses and expenses. The JUA designs policies and sets rates, with underwriting losses shared proportionately. A limited number of insurers are designated as servicing insurers, but all participate in the pool.
A few states have a reinsurance facility (or pool) for high-risk drivers, requiring insurers to accept all applicants. If an applicant is high-risk, the insurer can place them in the reinsurance pool, with losses shared by all auto insurers. The Maryland Automobile Insurance Fund is a state fund providing insurance to high-risk drivers. Specialty insurers specialize in insuring motorists with poor driving records.
Cost of Auto Insurance
Auto insurance rates have increased due to rising medical and motor vehicle repair costs, soaring jury awards in liability cases, and insurance fraud. Insurers use factors including territory, age, gender, marital status, use of the auto, driver education, and number and types of cars. A multicar discount is available for owning two or more cars, along with a good student discount. The individual driving record is key, and many insurers offer a safe driver plan for clean records. An insurance score, based on an applicantโs credit record, is also used.
โญ Key Takeaways
The key distinction between financial responsibility laws (proof after an incident) and compulsory insurance laws (proof before licensing) is critical for exam understanding. No-fault insurance is a major departure from the tort system, with four plan types โ pure, modified, add-on, and choice โ each with different lawsuit restrictions. The arguments for no-fault (reducing costs, delays, fraud) and against it (penalizing safe drivers, no pain and suffering) are frequently tested. High-risk drivers access insurance through assigned risk plans, JUAs, reinsurance facilities, or state funds, all with higher premiums. Finally, remember that auto insurance premiums are based on multiple factors including territory, age, driving record, and insurance score, with specific discounts like multicar and good student discounts.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main difference between a financial responsibility law and a compulsory insurance law?
- Under a modified no-fault plan, what are two types of thresholds that allow an injured driver to sue?
- List three arguments in favor of no-fault auto insurance and three arguments against it.
- What are the four methods by which high-risk drivers can obtain auto insurance when they cannot get it in the voluntary market?
- Name at least four factors that insurers use to establish auto insurance premiums.