π Lecture 21 β Salary and its Computation
π Overview: This lecture introduces the first head of income under the Income Tax Ordinanceβ"Income from Salary." It defines key concepts such as employer, employee, and employment, outlines significant rules for taxing salary income, and explains the special treatment of salary paid to members of an Association of Persons (AOP). Understanding this lecture is foundational for computing taxable salary correctly.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the five heads of income (starting with Salary), definitions of employee and employer under sections 2(20) and 2(21), the scope of employment under section 2(22), significant points about salary taxation (including multiple sources, tax-free salary, and voluntary payments), and the special rule under section 93(6) that treats salary from an AOP as business income.
π Lecture Summary
Heads of Income
The lecture begins by listing the five heads of income under the Income Tax Ordinance. We start with the first head: Salary, also called Income from Salary. The other heads are: Income from Property, Income from Business, Capital Gains, and Income from Other Sources.
Employer and Employee Relationship between Payer and Payee
Salary represents the amount received by an employee from an employment.
π Definition β Employee (Sec 2(20)): means any individual engaged in employment.
π Definition β Employer (Sec 2(21)): means any person who engages and remunerates an employee.
Employment (Sec. 2(22))
Employment includes:
- A directorship or any other office involved in the management of a company;
- A position entitling the holder to fixed or ascertainable remuneration; or
- Holding or acting in any public office.
Significant Points
Several important rules govern salary taxation:
- Salary from more than one source during a tax year is taxable income.
- Salary may be from a former employer, present employer, or prospective employer.
- No deductions are allowed under the head βIncome from Salaryβ.
- In case of Tax Free Salary by the employer, the amount of tax paid by the employer shall be added back to the employeeβs salary. This is known as Tax on Tax.
- Voluntary Payments are taxable.
- The tax year of a salaried person shall be a Normal Tax Year.
- Tax on salary income for Tax Year 2009 (1st July 2008 to 30th July 2009) shall be computed according to amendments made by the Finance Act, 2008.
- Salary paid to members of an Association of Persons (AOP) is not treated as Salary but as an appropriation of profit and is charged under the head βIncome from Business.β
Treatment of Salary by members of AOP
Any salary drawn by a member of an AOP [as defined in section 80] is an appropriation of profits and is chargeable to tax as "Income from Business", being the share of a member in the total income of the AOP, in view of provision contained in section 93(6).
Taxation of members of an associations of persons (Section 93(6))
Sec 93(6): The share of a member in the total income of an association of persons shall be determined according to the memberβs interest in the association and shall include any profit on debt, brokerage, commission, salary, or other remuneration received or due from the association.
Salary (Sec 12(1))
Any salary received by an employee in a tax year, other than salary that is exempt from tax under this Ordinance, shall be chargeable to tax in that year under the head βSalary.β
π‘ Why this matters: The distinction between salary (employee-employer relationship) and business income (AOP member's share) is critical because different rules, deductions, and tax rates apply to each head. Misclassifying income can lead to incorrect tax calculations.
β Key Takeaways
Salary is the first head of income, defined strictly by an employer-employee relationship, with no deductions allowed. Employment covers directorships, positions with fixed remuneration, and public offices. Tax-free salary requires grossing up the employer-paid tax (tax on tax). Voluntary payments are taxable, and the salaried person uses a normal tax year. Critically, salary paid to an AOP member is reclassified as business income under Section 93(6), not salary. All salary received in a tax year (except exempt amounts) is taxable under Section 12(1).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the legal definition of an "employee" under Section 2(20)?
- List the three inclusions under the definition of "employment" in Section 2(22).
- If an employer pays tax on behalf of an employee as a "tax-free salary," how is this treated for tax purposes?
- According to Section 93(6), how is salary received by a member from an AOP classified for tax purposes?
- Under Section 12(1), what is the general rule regarding the taxation of salary received in a tax year?
π Lecture 6.22 β Salary and Its Computation (Contd...)
π Overview: This lecture completes the detailed analysis of the definition of "Salary" under Section 12(2) of the Income Tax Ordinance, then dives deeply into Section 13 β the valuation of perquisites provided by employers. It explains how to compute the taxable value of motor vehicles, domestic assistants, utilities, loans at concessional rates, forgiven debts, property transfers, and housing. The lecture also covers Section 14 on Employee Share Schemes, detailing when and how share options and restricted shares become taxable.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture revisits the comprehensive definition of Salary under Section 12(2), covering pay, perquisites, allowances, termination payments, provident funds, pensions, and share schemes. It then systematically examines Section 13, subsections (1) through (14), explaining how to compute the taxable value of motor vehicles, housekeepers and domestic assistants, utilities, loans with below-benchmark profit rates, waived or paid obligations, property transfers, housing, and other unlisted perquisites. Finally, it covers Section 14 on Employee Share Schemes, including the tax treatment of rights/options and restricted shares.
π Lecture Summary
Salary as defined in Section 12(2)
Salary means any amount received by an employee from any employment, whether of a revenue or capital nature. It includes pay, wages, leave pay, payment in lieu of leave, overtime, bonus, commission, fees, gratuity, or work condition supplements (e.g., for unpleasant or dangerous working conditions). It also includes any perquisite, whether convertible to money or not.
The definition further includes allowances such as cost of living, subsistence, rent, utilities, education, entertainment, or travel allowance β but excludes any allowance that is "solely expended in the performance of the employee's duties." Salary also covers consideration for agreeing to enter employment or to accept changes in conditions, payments on termination of employment (including golden handshake payments), amounts from provident or other funds (beyond the employee's own non-deductible contributions), consideration for agreeing to a restrictive covenant, any pension or annuity, and amounts chargeable as salary under Section 14 (Employee Share Schemes).
Sec. 13 Value of Perquisites
Sub Sec (1) β For computing income under "Salary," the value of any perquisite provided by an employer to an employee in that year is determined according to this section.
Sub Sec (2) β This section does NOT apply to any amount referred to in clause (c) or (d) of sub-section 12 (i.e., termination payments and provident fund payments).
Sub Sec (3) β Motor Vehicle: Where a motor vehicle is provided by an employer to an employee wholly or partly for private use, the amount chargeable to tax includes an amount computed as may be prescribed (i.e., as per rules β typically a fixed percentage of the vehicle's cost or lease value).
Sub Sec (5) β Domestic Assistants (Housekeeper, Driver, Gardener, etc.): Where an employer provides the services of a housekeeper, driver, gardener, or other domestic assistant, the taxable amount is the total salary paid to such assistant for services rendered to the employee, reduced by any payment made by the employee to the employer for such services.
Sub Sec (6) β Utilities: Where an employer provides utilities (electricity, gas, water, telephone), the taxable amount is the fair market value of the utilities provided, reduced by any payment made by the employee for those utilities.
Sub Sec (7) & (8) β Loans at Concessional Rates: Where an employer makes a loan (on or after July 1, 2002) and either charges no profit or charges profit at a rate less than the benchmark rate, the taxable amount is:
- (a) the profit on loan computed at the benchmark rate if no profit is payable, OR
- (b) the difference between the actual profit paid and the profit computed at the benchmark rate.
π Definition β Benchmark Rate: For the tax year commencing July 1, 2002, it was 5% per annum. For each successive year, it is 1% above the rate for the immediately preceding tax year, but not exceeding any rate specified by the Federal Government. For tax year 2009, the benchmark rate is 11%.
π Formula:
- If no profit is charged: Taxable amount = Principal Γ Benchmark Rate
- If profit < Benchmark Rate: Taxable amount = (Principal Γ Benchmark Rate) β Actual Profit Paid
π‘ Why this matters: Subsections (8) provides a special rule: If the employee uses the loan (wholly or partly) to acquire an income-producing asset, the employee is treated as having paid profit equal to the benchmark rate on that portion of the loan. This prevents double counting β the assetβs income is already taxed, so the loan benefit is considered "paid" and not added to salary.
Sub Sec (9) β Waived Obligations: Where an employer waives an employee's obligation to pay or repay an amount owing to the employer, that amount is included under the head Salary.
Sub Sec (10) β Third-Party Obligations Paid by Employer: Where an employer pays an employee's obligation to another person (e.g., pays off the employee's bank loan directly), that amount is included in salary income.
Sub Sec (11) β Property Transfers or Services Provided: Where property is transferred or services are provided by an employer to an employee, the taxable amount is the fair market value at the time of transfer/provision, reduced by any payment made by the employee for the property or services.
Sub Sec (12) β Accommodation or Housing: Where accommodation or housing is provided, the taxable amount is computed as may be prescribed (typically based on rent or a percentage of salary).
Sub Sec (13) β Other Perquisites (Catch-All): For any perquisite not covered by subsections (3) through (12), the taxable amount is the fair market value at the time it is provided, reduced by any payment made by the employee, unless rules provide otherwise.
Sub Sec (14) β Definitions:
- Benchmark rate: as explained above (5% for 2002, then +1% each year; 11% for 2009)
- Services: includes the provision of any facility
- Utilities: includes electricity, gas, water, and telephone
Employee Share Schemes β Sec 14
Rights or Options: The value of a right or option to acquire shares under an employee share scheme is not chargeable to tax at the time of grant.
Restricted Shares: Where shares issued are subject to a restriction on transfer:
- (a) No amount is chargeable to tax until the earlier of:
- (i) the time the employee has a free right to transfer the shares; or
- (ii) the time the employee disposes of the shares.
- (b) The chargeable amount is the fair market value of the shares at the time the employee has a free right to transfer, reduced by any amount given as consideration for the grant of the right or option.
Disposal of Rights/Options: Where an employee disposes of a right or option to acquire shares, the chargeable amount is the gain on disposal, computed as:
π Formula: A β B
- A = Consideration received from the disposal of the right or option
- B = Employee's cost in respect of the right or option
π Example: If an employee receives a right to buy shares (cost = Rs. 0) and later sells that right for Rs. 10,000, then A = 10,000, B = 0, and taxable salary = Rs. 10,000.
β Key Takeaways
The definition of Salary under Section 12(2) is extremely broad, covering not only direct pay but also perquisites, allowances, termination payments, non-repaid provident fund amounts, restrictive covenant payments, pensions, annuities, and employee share scheme gains. Section 13 provides specific valuation rules for common perquisites: motor vehicles are valued "as prescribed"; domestic assistants at their salary cost; utilities at fair market value; concessional loans at the difference between benchmark rate profit and actual profit paid; waived or employer-paid debts at their full amount; transferred property at fair market value; and housing "as prescribed." The benchmark rate started at 5% in 2002 and increases by 1% each year, reaching 11% for 2009. Under Section 14, share options are not taxable at grant; restricted shares are taxed when the restriction lifts or the shares are sold; and gains from selling rights/options are taxed as salary income. The catch-all provision in subsection (13) ensures any unlisted perquisite is taxed at its fair market value.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- An employer provides an employee with a car entirely for private use. Under which subsection of Section 13 is this valued, and how is the taxable amount determined?
- An employer provides free electricity (fair market value: Rs. 50,000) and the employee pays Rs. 10,000 towards it. What amount is chargeable to tax under Section 13(6)?
- An employer grants an employee a loan of Rs. 1,000,000 at a profit rate of 3% per annum. The benchmark rate is 11%. What is the taxable amount under Section 13(7)?
- Under Section 14, when is the taxable event triggered for shares that are subject to a restriction on transfer?
- An employer waives an employee's obligation to repay a Rs. 200,000 loan made directly by the employer. Under which subsection is this included in salary, and what amount is taxable?