π Lecture 14.39 β Presumptive Income Taxation of Permanent Establishment (PE)
π Overview: This lecture covers the presumptive tax regime, where tax is charged on gross receipts instead of net taxable income under normal tax rules. It then focuses on the taxation of Permanent Establishments (PEs) of non-resident persons in Pakistan, detailing how their business income is computed, allowable deductions, and restrictions on head office payments. This matters because it clarifies special tax rules for foreign entities operating in Pakistan.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining presumptive income and explaining tax on dividends, tax on certain payments to non-residents (royalties and fees for technical services), and tax on shipping and air transport income of non-resident persons. It then transitions to the detailed taxation of a Permanent Establishment in Pakistan under Section 105, including principles for profit computation, allowable deductions, the prohibition of certain internal payments, and limitations on head office expenditure.
π Lecture Summary
Presumptive Income:
Under normal tax regime, income tax is chargeable on taxable income but under some exceptional circumstances, the income tax shall be charged on gross receipts. This is also called as presumptive tax regime. Under following situations the tax will be charged on gross receipts basis.
Tax on dividends:
a. Subject to this Ordinance, a tax shall be imposed, at the rate specified in Division III of Part I of the First Schedule, on every person who receives a dividend from a company. b. The tax imposed on a person who receives a dividend shall be computed by applying the relevant rate of tax to the gross amount of the dividend. c. This section shall not apply to a dividend that is exempt from tax under this Ordinance.
π Definition β Presumptive Tax Regime: A tax system where tax is charged on gross receipts rather than net taxable income. π Formula: Tax = (Relevant Rate) Γ (Gross Amount of Dividend) π Example: If a person receives a dividend of Rs. 100,000 and the relevant rate is 15%, the tax is 15% Γ Rs. 100,000 = Rs. 15,000.
6. Tax on Certain Payments to Non-Residents:
(1) Subject to this Ordinance, a tax shall be imposed, at the rate specified in Division IV of Part I of the First Schedule, on every non-resident person who receives any Pakistan-source royalty or fee for technical services. (2) The tax imposed on a non-resident person shall be computed by applying the relevant rate of tax to the gross amount of the royalty or fee for technical services. (3) This section shall not apply to: (a) any royalty where the property or right is effectively connected with a permanent establishment in Pakistan of the non-resident person; (b) any fee for technical services where the services are rendered through a permanent establishment in Pakistan; or (c) any royalty or fee for technical services that is exempt from tax. (4) Any such payment received by a non-resident to whom this section does not apply by virtue of (a) or (b) shall be treated as income from business attributable to the permanent establishment in Pakistan.
π Definition β Royalty: Payment for the use of property or rights. π Definition β Fee for Technical Services: Payment for services rendered. π Formula: Tax = (Relevant Rate) Γ (Gross Amount of Royalty or Fee) π‘ Why this matters: If a non-resident has a PE in Pakistan, these payments are not taxed at gross but are treated as business income of the PE, subject to net income computation.
7. Tax on Shipping and Air Transport Income of a Non-Resident Person
(1) Subject to this Ordinance, a tax shall be imposed, at the rate specified in Division V of Part I of the First Schedule, on every non-resident person carrying on the business of operating ships or aircraft as the owner or charterer in respect of: (a) the gross amount received for the carriage of passengers, livestock, mail or goods embarked in Pakistan; and (b) the gross amount received or receivable in Pakistan for the carriage of passengers, livestock, mail or goods embarked outside Pakistan. (2) The tax imposed shall be computed by applying the relevant rate of tax to the gross amount referred to in subsection (1). (3) This section shall not apply to any amounts exempt from tax under this Ordinance.
π Formula: Tax = (Relevant Rate) Γ (Gross Amount from Shipping/Air Transport Operations) π Example: A foreign airline receives Rs. 50 million for tickets sold in Pakistan for international travel. If the rate is 5%, tax = 5% Γ Rs. 50 million = Rs. 2.5 million.
Taxation of PE
105. Taxation of a Permanent Establishment in Pakistan of a Non-Resident Person. (1) The following principles shall apply in determining the income of a permanent establishment in Pakistan of a non-resident person chargeable to tax under the head βIncome from Businessβ: (a) The profit of the permanent establishment shall be computed on the basis that it is a distinct and separate person engaged in the same or similar activities under the same or similar conditions and dealing wholly independently with the non-resident person of which it is a permanent establishment; (b) there shall be allowed as deductions any expenses incurred for the purposes of the business activities of the permanent establishment including executive and administrative expenses so incurred, whether in Pakistan or elsewhere; (c) no deduction shall be allowed for amounts paid or payable by the permanent establishment to its head office or to another permanent establishment (other than towards reimbursement of actual expenses incurred to third parties) by way of:
- royalties, fees for the use of any tangible or intangible asset;
- compensation for any services including management services; or
- profit on debt on moneys lent to the permanent establishment, except in connection with a banking business; and (d) no account shall be taken in the determination of the income of a permanent establishment of amounts charged by the permanent establishment to the head office or to another permanent establishment (other than towards reimbursement of actual expenses incurred to third parties) by way of:
- royalties, fees for the use of any tangible or intangible asset;
- compensation for any services including management services; or
- profit on debt on moneys lent by the permanent establishment, except in connection with a banking business.
π Definition β Permanent Establishment (PE): A fixed place of business through which a non-resident person carries on business in Pakistan. π Definition β Arm's Length Principle: The PE's profits are computed as if it were a separate and independent entity dealing at arm's length with its head office. π‘ Why this matters: The PE is treated as a separate taxpayer for income computation, but internal payments (like royalties or interest) between the PE and its head office are generally not deductible/recognized to prevent profit shifting.
(2) No deduction shall be allowed in computing the income of a permanent establishment for a tax year for head office expenditure in excess of the amount as bears to the turnover of the permanent establishment in Pakistan the same proportion as the non-residentβs total head office expenditure bears to its worldwide turnover.
π Formula: Allowable Head Office Deduction = (Turnover of PE in Pakistan / Worldwide Turnover) Γ Total Head Office Expenditure π Example: If a PE has turnover of Rs. 10 million, the worldwide turnover is Rs. 100 million, and total head office expenditure is Rs. 20 million, then the allowable deduction = (10/100) Γ 20 million = Rs. 2 million. Any excess is not deductible.
(3) In this section, βhead office expenditureβ means any executive or general administration expenditure incurred by the non-resident person outside Pakistan for the purposes of the business of the Pakistan permanent establishment, including: (a) any rent, local rates and taxes excluding any foreign income tax, current repairs, or insurance outside Pakistan; (b) any salary paid to an employee employed by the head office outside Pakistan; (c) any traveling expenditures of such employee; and (d) any other expenditures which may be prescribed
(4) No deduction shall be allowed in computing the income of a permanent establishment for: (a) any profit paid or payable by the non-resident person on debt to finance the operations of the permanent establishment; or (b) any insurance premium paid or payable by the non-resident person in respect of such debt.
β Key Takeaways
The key takeaways from this lecture are: (1) Presumptive tax is charged on gross receipts for dividends, certain payments to non-residents, and shipping/air transport income. (2) A Permanent Establishment (PE) is taxed under the head "Income from Business" on its net income, computed as if it were a separate and independent entity. (3) Internal payments between a PE and its head office (like royalties, management fees, or interest) are generally not deductible to prevent tax avoidance, except for reimbursement of actual third-party expenses. (4) Head office expenditure allocated to the PE is deductible only up to a proportion calculated using the PE's turnover relative to worldwide turnover. (5) Interest on debt financing the PE's operations and related insurance premiums are not deductible by the PE.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the general rule for taxing dividends under the presumptive tax regime?
- When does a non-resident's royalty or fee for technical services NOT fall under the presumptive tax on gross receipts?
- What gross amounts are subject to tax for a non-resident carrying on shipping or air transport business in Pakistan?
- According to Section 105, what is the fundamental principle for computing the profit of a Permanent Establishment?
- Why are payments like royalties and management fees from a PE to its head office generally not allowed as deductions?
π Lecture 46 β Tax Returns & Assessment of Income Universal Self Assessment Scheme
π Overview: This lecture covers the mandatory requirements for filing tax returns in Pakistan under the Income Tax Ordinance. It details who must file, who is exempt, the rules for wealth statements, revised returns, and extensions, which are fundamental for understanding taxpayer compliance obligations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining a tax return as a prescribed document for submitting taxable income, designed by CBR under Income Tax Rules 2002. It then lists persons required to file returns, including all companies and individuals meeting certain conditions like prior tax liability or property ownership. Returns on notice by the Commissioner are explained for special circumstances, followed by persons not required to file returns, such as salaried employees with employer certificates. Wealth statement filing under Section 116 is detailed, along with rules for discontinuance of business, revised returns, and extensions for filing.
π Lecture Summary
TAX RETURN
A tax return is the prescribed document for submission of taxable income by a taxpayer. Specimens of return to be submitted by different taxpayers are designed by CBR under the Income Tax Rules, 2002.
π Definition β Tax Return: A prescribed form where a taxpayer declares their taxable income and relevant particulars for a tax year.
Persons Required to File Returns
a) Every Company: Every person (other than company) whose taxable income exceeds the initial threshold as provided under the ordinance. However, companies must submit a return and pay minimum tax even in case of loss @ 0.50% of annual turnover.
b) Every Person:
- Charged to tax for any two preceding years
- Claims loss that is carried forward
- Owns immovable property, with a land area of 250 Sq. yards or more in municipal limits, cantonment and CDA
A return of income shall be: (a) Prescribed form along with required documents. (b) Fully state all relevant particulars or information as specified in the form of return, including a declaration of the records kept by the taxpayer; and (c) Shall be signed by the person, being an individual, or the personβs representative where section 172 applies.
π‘ A return of income can also be filed electronically (e-Filing of return).
Returns on Notice by Commissioner
The Commissioner may, by notice in writing, require a person to furnish a return by a specified date for a period of less than 12 months in these cases:
-
The person has died
-
The person has become bankrupt or gone into liquidation
-
The person is about to leave Pakistan permanently
-
If the Commissioner believes a person failed to file a required return, he may require them to file. The person must file within 30 days from the date of service of notice.
-
In case of omission, a revised return can be filed within 5 years of the date the original return was furnished.
Person Not Required to File Tax Return
Section 115 grants immunity to salaried persons: a salary certificate from the employer is sufficient in lieu of a return.
Other Exceptions (Sec-115):
- Widow
- Orphan below age of 25 years
- Disabled person
- In case of ownership of immovable property, a non-resident person
Further Exceptions: All persons subject to final tax regime/PTR under sections 5, 6, 7, 113A, 148, 153, 154, 156, 156A, 233 or 235(5) shall furnish to CIT a statement showing such particulars relating to the personβs income.
Filing of Wealth Statement (Sec. 116)
The Commissioner may require any person to furnish a wealth statement in prescribed form giving particulars of: (a) The personβs total assets and liabilities as on specified date(s) (b) The total assets and liabilities of the personβs spouse, minor children and other dependents (c) Any assets transferred by the person to any other person and the consideration (d) The total expenditures incurred by the person and their spouse, minor children, and other dependents
- Every resident taxpayer filing a return whose last declared or assessed income is five hundred thousand rupees or more shall furnish a wealth statement along with the return.
- A revised wealth statement can be furnished at any time before an assessment is made for the tax year.
Sec. 117βDiscontinuance of Business
Return to be filed within 15 days of discontinuance.
- Where NTN is not already registered, the taxpayer shall apply on prescribed form for NTN at the time of furnishing return of income.
Provision of Revised Tax Return
A person may furnish a Revised Return within five years of the date when the original return was furnished.
Extension in Time for Furnishing Returns
If the Commissioner is satisfied that the applicant is unable to furnish returns by the due date, he can grant extension for 15 days from the due date. Under exceptional circumstances, a longer extension can be granted for:
- Absence from Pakistan
- Sickness or other misadventure
- Any other reasonable cause
β Key Takeaways
All companies must file returns and pay minimum tax of 0.50% of turnover even if they have a loss. Salaried persons with employer certificates are generally exempt from filing returns under Section 115. Taxpayers with declared income of PKR 500,000 or more must also submit a wealth statement with their return. Revised returns can be filed up to five years after the original return, and the Commissioner can grant extensions for filing in cases of absence, sickness, or other reasonable cause. Returns on notice must be filed within 30 days for special circumstances like death, bankruptcy, or permanent departure from Pakistan.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the minimum tax rate for a company that has incurred a loss for the tax year?
- A salaried individual earning PKR 600,000 per year β are they required to file a tax return? Why or why not?
- A taxpayer discovers an omission in their filed return after 3 years. Can they file a revised return?
- What is the filing deadline for a return of income when the Commissioner issues a notice of discontinuance of business?
- Under what conditions must a taxpayer furnish a wealth statement along with their return of income?
π Lecture 15.41 β TAX RETURNS & ASSESSMENT OF INCOME UNIVERSAL SELF ASSESSMENT SCHEME
π Overview: This lecture explains the three main ways tax assessments are framed under the normal tax regime in Pakistan, focusing on the Universal Self Assessment Scheme (USAS). It details the processes for normal assessment, best judgment assessment, and provisional assessment, along with amendments and revisions. Understanding these mechanisms is critical for tax professionals to know how taxpayer claims are verified and finalized.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition and types of assessments under the normal tax regime, including Normal Assessment under USAS (Sec. 120), Best Judgment Assessment (Sec. 121), and Provisional Assessment (Sec. 123). It details the amendment of assessments (Sec. 122), revisions by the Commissioner (Sec. 122A) and Regional Commissioner (Sec. 122B), and special provisions for assessments. The salient features of the Universal Self Assessment Scheme are explained in depth, covering its scope, requirements for a complete return, short documents notice, and the criteria for selection for audit (Sec. 177).
π Lecture Summary
Assessments
An assessment is the process whereby claims of taxpayers are verified by tax authorities and taxable income and the tax thereon is determined according to the ordinance.
Ways of Framing Assessment under Normal Tax Regime
There are three main ways: 1) Normal Assessment/USAS, 2) Provisional Assessment, and 3) Best Judgment Assessment.
1. Normal Assessment/Universal Self assessment Scheme (Sec. 120)
This applies when a taxpayer furnishes a complete return. In this case, the commissioner is deemed to have made an assessment of taxable income and tax equal to the amounts specified in the return. The return itself is taken as the assessment order.
A return is considered complete if it is in accordance with Sec. 114(2). If a return is incomplete, the Commissioner (CIT) issues a notice to rectify omissions or deficiencies by a due date. Errors pertaining to taxable income and tax payable are not rectifiable under this section. If the taxpayer does not reply by the due date, the incomplete return is treated as invalid. If the taxpayer complies with the notice, the return is treated as complete. No notice under Sec. 120(3) can be issued after the expiration of one year, at which point the return and assessment attain finality.
Best Judgment Assessment Sec. 121
This assessment is made when a person: (a) Fails to furnish a return u/s 114(3) or 114(4) (b) Fails to furnish return u/s 143 or 144 (for non-resident Air Carriers or Shipping Companies) (d) Fails to furnish return u/s 116 (Wealth Statement on notice by CIT or where income is Rs. 500,000 and above) (e) Fails to furnish documents u/s 174
The Assessment Order by the Commissioner must state: Taxable Income, Tax Due, Amount of Tax Paid, Tax Payable, and the Time, place & manner of appealing the assessment order.
Amendment of Assessments (Sec 122)
Amendments are made when the commissioner is satisfied, on the basis of definite information, that:
- Any income chargeable to tax has escaped assessment; or
- Total income has been under-assessed, or assessed at too low a rate, or has been the subject of excessive relief or refund; or
- Any amount under a head of income has been misclassified.
Revision by the Commissioner Sec 122A
The commissioner shall not revise an order if an appeal lies to the Commissioner (Appeals) or the Appellate Tribunal and the time for appeal has not expired, or the order is pending in appeal.
Revision by the Regional Commissioner Sec 122B
Revision can be made by the RCIT (Regional Commissioner of Income Tax) on his own or on an application by the taxpayer, relating to the issuance of an exemption or lower rate certificate regarding collection or deduction of tax at source.
2. Provisional Assessment (Sec. 123)
Under Sec. 123(1), where concealed assets are impounded by any department or agency of the federal or provincial government, the commissioner may issue a provisional assessment order for the last completed tax year, taking into account the concealed asset. A concealed asset is any property or asset acquired from income subject to tax, in the opinion of the CIT.
Assessment giving effect to an order Sec. 124
This concerns assessments that give effect to an order from the CIT (A), ITAT, High Court, or Supreme Court.
Sec. 124-A modification of an Order by Commissioner The CIT must follow a decision on a question of law by the High Court or ITAT, even if an appeal has been filed. On reversal, the CIT shall modify the order.
Special Provisions with respect to Assessment Sec. 125
For disputed properties, assessment must be made within one year from the date of the court's decision.
Sec. 126 Evidence of Assessment
Production of an assessment order or a certified copy is conclusive evidence. An assessment order may not be deemed void or voidable for want of form, nor affected by any mistake, defect, or omission, if it is in substance and effect in conformity with the ordinance.
3. Self Assessment Scheme β‘οΈ Universal Self Assessment Scheme
1) Scope of the scheme: Section 120 (1) (2)
- Where a taxpayer has furnished a complete return of income (other than a revised return under Sec. 114(6)) for a tax year ending on or after July 1, 2002: (a) The commissioner is deemed to have made an assessment of taxable income and tax due, equal to the amounts specified in the return. (b) The return is taken, for all purposes of the Ordinance, to be an assessment order issued to the taxpayer on the day the return was furnished.
- A return of income is considered complete if it is in accordance with Sec. 114(2), meaning it is in the prescribed form, fully states all relevant particulars, and is duly signed.
2) Requirements of a Return (Rule 34)
- A return of income under Sec. 114 must be in the specified form for companies (Part-i), non-salaried individuals and AOPs (Part-ii), or salaried individuals (Part-iii A).
- The return must be verified in the manner specified in the form.
- It must be accompanied by all applicable documents, statements, certificates, and annexes.
3) Short Documents Notice: Section 120 (3) (4) (5) (6)
- If a return is not complete, the Commissioner issues a notice to the taxpayer informing them of deficiencies (other than incorrect tax payable or short payment of tax). This notice directs the taxpayer to provide the required information by a specified date.
- If the taxpayer fails to comply by the due date, the return is treated as an invalid return as if it had not been furnished.
- If the taxpayer fully complies by the due date, the return is treated as complete from the day it was originally furnished, and the provisions of sub-section (1) apply.
- No notice under sub-section (3) can be issued after the end of the financial year in which the return was furnished.
4) Selection for Audit Section 177
- The Central Board of Revenue (CBR) may lay down criteria for selecting a person for audit. The Commissioner must select persons for audit in accordance with these criteria, which the CBR keeps confidential.
- In addition, the Commissioner may select a person for audit having regard to:
- The personβs history of compliance or non-compliance.
- The amount of tax payable.
- The class of business conducted.
- Any other matter material for determination of correct income.
- After selection, the Commissioner conducts an audit of the person's income tax affairs, including examination of accounts, records, expenditure, assets, and liabilities.
- After the audit, the Commissioner may, after obtaining the taxpayerβs explanation, amend the assessment under Sec. 122.
- Being audited in one year does not preclude being audited again in subsequent years if there are reasonable grounds.
- The CBR may appoint a firm of Chartered Accountants to conduct an audit, with the scope determined on a case-to-case basis.
Section 120 (1A) Notwithstanding the provisions of sub-section (1) of Section 120, the Commissioner may select a person for an Audit of his income tax affairs under Section 177.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is that under the Universal Self Assessment Scheme (USAS), a taxpayerβs complete return is automatically treated as the assessment order, making self-declaration the primary assessment method. Students must differentiate between the three types of assessment: Normal (USAS, based on a filed return), Best Judgment (for failure to file or comply), and Provisional (for concealed assets). The process for amending an assessment (Sec. 122) requires "definite information," and the time limits for issuing a "Short Documents Notice" (end of financial year) and for the assessment attaining finality (one year) are crucial. Finally, audit selection under Sec. 177 can be based on confidential CBR criteria or on commissioner discretion, and an audit does not prevent future audits.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Under the Universal Self Assessment Scheme (Sec. 120), when is a return of income considered an "assessment order"?
- What are the three ways of framing an assessment under the normal tax regime?
- What is the difference between an "Amendment of Assessment" (Sec. 122) and a "Revision" (Sec. 122A/122B)?
- According to Sec. 120, after how long does a return and assessment attain finality?
- List three factors a Commissioner may consider, in addition to CBR criteria, when selecting a person for an audit under Sec. 177.
π Lecture 48 β Advance Tax Collection & Recovery of Tax Penalties & Prosecution
π Overview: This lecture covers the legal mechanisms for tax collection and recovery in Pakistan, including due dates for payment, recovery methods through property attachment and arrest, and procedures involving third parties and liquidators. It also details the specific penalties for various tax offenses and the prosecution framework for non-compliance, providing a comprehensive view of the enforcement powers of tax authorities.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the collection and recovery of tax, specifying due dates under Section 137 and recovery methods under Sections 138 and 138A, including property attachment and arrest. It then covers special recovery rules for private companies and AOPs, recovery from persons holding money for the taxpayer, and the obligations of liquidators. The second half details a comprehensive list of penalties for failures like not filing returns or maintaining records, followed by the prosecution framework for offenses such as false statements and obstruction, concluding with an explanation of advance tax computation.
π Lecture Summary
Collection and recovery of tax β Due date for payment of taxes (Sec. 137)
Tax shall be due on the due date for furnishing the return for that tax year, or within thirty days of service of notice in case of an assessment order passed by the commissioner.
Recovery of tax out of Property and through arrest of Tax-Payer (Sec. 138)
The commissioner may recover tax by:
- Attachment and sale of any movable or immovable property of the tax payer
- Appointment of receiver for the management of movable or immovable property of the taxpayer
- Arrest of taxpayer and his detention in prison not exceeding six months
Recovery of Tax by District Officer (Revenue) (Sec. 138A)
On a Certificate from Commissioner, the specified property of taxpayer and amount of tax due can be recovered by a District Officer (Revenue).
Collection of tax in the case of private companies and Association of Persons
If tax due cannot be recovered from the company, it can be recovered from every person who was at any time in that tax year:
- A director of the company, other than employed director
- Share holder owning at least ten percent of paid up capital of the company β these persons shall be jointly and severally responsible.
In case of AOP, if tax due from a member in respect of the memberβs share of income cannot be recovered from the member, the association shall be liable for the tax due by the member.
Recovery of Tax from persons holding money due on behalf of a taxpayer (Sec. 140)
For recovering any tax due by a taxpayer, the commissioner may, by notice in writing, require any person:
- Owing or who may owe money to the taxpayer
- Holding or who may hold money for or on account of the taxpayer
- Holding or who may hold money on account of some other person for payment to the taxpayer
- Having authority of some other person to pay money to the taxpayer
Liquidators (Sec. 141)
The following are referred to as liquidator:
- A liquidator of a company
- A receiver appointed by a Court or appointed out of court
- A trustee for a bankrupt
- A mortgagee in possession
π Definition β liquidator: A person appointed to manage the winding-up of a company or the administration of assets, including court-appointed receivers, trustees for bankrupts, and mortgagees in possession.
Liquidators shall, within fourteen days of being appointed or taking possession of an asset in Pakistan, give written notice to the commissioner. The commissioner shall within three months provide information regarding tax payable by the person whose assets are in possession. A liquidator shall not part with any asset until notified by the commissioner.
The liquidator:
- Shall set aside, out of proceeds of sale, the amount notified by the commissioner (or lesser amount agreed)
- Shall be liable to the extent of the amount set aside for the tax
- May pay any debt that has priority over the tax
Additional sections mentioned include: Recovery of tax due by non-resident member of an Association of Persons (Sec. 142), Non-resident ship owner or charterer (Sec. 143), Non-resident aircraft owner or charterer (Sec. 144).
Assessment of Person about to Leave Pakistan (Sec. 145)
A person must notify the CIT about the probable date of departure not less than fifteen days from said date if they have to leave the country with no intention to return to Pakistan. The CIT shall give notice to furnish a return of taxable income, which shall be charged to tax.
Penalty for failure to furnish a return or statement Sec. 182
A person is liable for a penalty equal to one-tenth of one percent of the tax payable for each day of default, subject to a minimum penalty of Rupees five hundred and a maximum penalty of twenty-five percent of tax payable in respect of that tax year.
π Formula: Penalty = (0.1% Γ Tax Payable Γ Days of Default), with minimum Rs. 500 and maximum 25% of tax payable.
Penalty for non-payment of tax Sec 183
A person is liable for penalty equal to:
- (a) In case of first default, five percent of the amount of tax in default
- (b) In case of second default, an additional penalty of twenty-five percent of the amount of tax in default
- (c) In case of third default, an additional penalty of twenty-five percent of the amount of tax in default
- (d) In case of fourth and subsequent default, an additional penalty of up to fifty percent of the amount of tax in default
The total penalty in respect of the amount of tax in default shall not exceed one hundred percent of such amount of tax.
π Example: If a taxpayer has a tax default of Rs. 10,000 and this is a first default, the penalty would be 5% of Rs. 10,000 = Rs. 500. If it is a second default, the additional penalty would be 25% of Rs. 10,000 = Rs. 2,500 (total penalty now Rs. 3,000). If it is a third default, another 25% = Rs. 2,500 (total Rs. 5,500). If a fourth default occurs, the commissioner can impose up to 50% = Rs. 5,000, but total cannot exceed 100% of Rs. 10,000 = Rs. 10,000.
π‘ Why this matters: The escalating penalty structure creates a strong deterrent against repeated non-payment, with the total potential penalty reaching 100% of the tax in default.
Penalty for failure to maintain records Sec. 185
- (a) In case of first failure: two thousand rupees
- (b) In case of second failure: five thousand rupees
- (c) In case of third and subsequent failure: ten thousand rupees
Penalty for non-compliance with notice: Sec 186
- (a) In case of first failure: two thousand rupees
- (b) In case of second failure: five thousand rupees
- (c) In case of third and subsequent failure: ten thousand rupees
Penalty for making false or misleading statements Sec 187
- Where the statement or omission is made knowingly or recklessly: two hundred percent of the tax shortfall
- In any other case: twenty-five percent of tax shortfall
Penalty for failure to give notice Sec 188
- For failure to give notice of business discontinuation: penalty not exceeding the amount of tax payable for the tax year
- For failure to give notice of appointment as liquidator: penalty not exceeding ten thousand rupees
Penalty for obstruction Sec 189
The commissioner may impose a penalty not exceeding ten thousand rupees.
Imposition of penalty Sec 190
No penalty may be imposed on any person unless the person is given a reasonable opportunity of being heard.
Offences & Prosecutions
- Prosecution for non-compliance with certain statutory obligations (Sec. 191): Failure to comply with notices, non-payment of advance tax (Sec. 147), or non-collection/deduction of tax. Punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year, or both.
- Prosecution for false statement in verification (Sec. 192): Punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years, or both.
- Prosecution for failure to maintain records (Sec. 193): If deliberate, a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both; in any other case, a fine shall be imposed.
- Prosecution for improper use of National Tax Number card (Sec. 194): Punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both.
- Prosecution for making false or misleading statements (Sec. 195): If made knowingly or recklessly, a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding two years, or both; in any other case, with a fine.
- Prosecution for obstructing an income tax authority (Sec. 196): Punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding one year, or both.
- Prosecution for disposal of property to prevent attachment (Sec. 197): Punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years, or both.
- Prosecution for unauthorized disclosure of information by a public servant (Sec. 198): Punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding six months, or both.
- Prosecution for abetment (Sec. 199): Punishable on conviction with a fine or imprisonment for a term not exceeding three years, or both.
- Offences by companies and associations of persons (Sec. 200): In case of a company, every person who at the time of the offence was: Principal Officer, Director, General Manager, Company secretary, or any similar officer, or acting or purporting to act in that capacity, shall be guilty of the offence.
- Power to compound offences (Sec. 202): The CIT may compound with the taxpayer/person and order them to pay the amount for which the offence may be compounded.
147. Advance tax paid by the taxpayer
Every taxpayer whose income was charged to tax for the latest tax year, other than certain incomes (capital gains, income under sections 5, 6, 7, 15, income subject to deduction at source under section 149, and income from which tax has been collected/deducted with no tax credit allowed), shall be liable to pay advance tax.
This section does not apply to an individual or AOP where the latest assessed taxable income (excluding specified income) is less than one hundred and fifty thousand rupees.
For a company, the amount of advance tax due for a quarter shall be computed by the formula:
(A/4) β B
Where:
- A is the tax assessed to the taxpayer for the latest tax year or latest assessment year under the repealed ordinance
- B is the tax paid in the quarter for which a tax credit is allowed under section 168 (other than tax deducted under section 149 or 155)
β Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that tax authorities have extensive powers for recovery, including property attachment, arrest for up to six months, and holding company directors and major shareholders jointly liable. Penalties are structured to escalate with repeated offenses, ranging from fixed amounts (Rs. 2,000-10,000 for record-keeping failures) to percentage-based penalties that can reach 200% of tax shortfall for fraudulent statements. The prosecution framework provides for imprisonment terms from six months to three years for various offenses, with the most severe penalties for false verification, disposal of property to prevent attachment, and abetment. Advance tax for companies is computed as one-quarter of the prior year's assessed tax, less tax credits already paid, with a Rs. 150,000 threshold exempting small individuals and AOPs.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three methods available to the commissioner for recovering tax under Section 138, and what is the maximum duration of imprisonment for arrest?
- Under Section 141, what is the timeline for a liquidator to notify the commissioner of their appointment, and how long does the commissioner have to respond with the tax amount?
- Calculate the penalty for a taxpayer who has a first default of non-payment of Rs. 50,000 in tax under Section 183. What would be the penalty if this is a fourth default?
- What is the maximum imprisonment term for prosecution under Section 192 (false statement in verification), and how does this compare to the penalty for obstructing an income tax authority under Section 196?
- Using the formula in Section 147, calculate the advance tax due for a company's first quarter if its latest assessed tax (A) is Rs. 400,000 and the tax paid in the quarter eligible for credit (B) is Rs. 30,000.
π Lecture 17.42 β Appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) (Sec.127)
π Overview: This lecture covers the complete appeals and references framework under the Federal Tax law in Pakistan. It explains the hierarchical process from filing an appeal with the Commissioner (Appeals) to the Appellate Tribunal, High Court references, and the role of the Alternate Dispute Resolution committee and the Federal Tax Ombudsman.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture details the procedure for filing an appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) under Section 127, including prescribed fees and timelines. It then covers the procedure for appeal under Section 128, decisions by the Commissioner under Section 129, and the structure and qualification requirements for the Appellate Tribunal under Section 130. The lecture also explains appeals to the Appellate Tribunal under Section 131, references to the High Court under Section 133 on a question of law, burden of proof in appeals under Section 136, the Alternate Dispute Resolution mechanism, and a comprehensive overview of the Federal Tax Ombudsman including its establishment, objectives, jurisdiction, and procedures.
π Lecture Summary
Lesson 17.42 β Appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) (Sec.127)
An appeal to the Commissioner (Appeals) is the first level of formal appellate remedy. The appeal is allowed only provided that the amount of tax due under section 137 has been paid. The appeal must be filed: i) in the prescribed form, ii) with proper verification, iii) stating the grounds of appeal, iv) accompanied by the prescribed fee, and v) within 30 days of the date of service of the order against which the appeal is filed.
π Definition β Prescribed Fee for Appeal: In case of an appeal against an assessment order/notice, the fee is the lesser of Rs. 1,000 or 10% of the tax assessed. In any other case, companies pay Rs. 1,000 and others pay Rs. 200.
Procedure in appeal (Sec.128)
The Commissioner (Appeals) (CIT) shall give notice of hearing to both the appellant and the commissioner. If satisfied, the CIT may allow an appellant to file any new ground of appeal. However, the CIT (Appeal) shall not admit any documentary material or evidence which was not produced before the original commissioner, unless the CIT is satisfied that the appellant was prevented by sufficient cause from producing such material earlier.
Decision in Appeal (Sec.129)
The Commissioner of appeal may confirm, modify, or annul the assessment order. The order must be passed within three months of the date of filing the appeal. π‘ Why this matters: If the order is not passed within this period, the relief sought by the appellant in the appeal is treated as having been automatically given.
Appointment of the Appellate Tribunal (Sec. 130)
The Appellate Tribunal consists of a Chairperson, judicial members, and accountant members appointed by the Federal Government. A judicial member must have exercised the powers of a District Judge and be qualified to be a Judge of a High Court, or be or have been an advocate of a High Court qualified to be a Judge of a High Court. An accountant member must be an officer of an income tax group equivalent in rank to that of a Regional Commissioner.
π Definition β Judicial Member Qualification: A person who has exercised the powers of a District Judge and is qualified to be a Judge of a High Court; or is or has been an advocate of a High Court and is qualified to be a Judge of a High Court.
Appeal to Appellate Tribunal (Sec. 131)
An appeal to the Appellate Tribunal must be: in the prescribed form, verified in the prescribed manner, and accompanied by the prescribed fee. The fee for an appeal in relation to an assessment order is the lesser of Rs. 2,500 or 10% of the tax assessed. In any other case, if the appellant is a company, the fee is Rs. 2,000; if not a company, Rs. 500. The appeal must be filed within 60 days of the order of the Commissioner (Appeals). The maximum period for staying recovery of tax is not beyond six months. The appellate tribunal must decide the appeal within 6 months of its filing and communicate its order to both the taxpayer and the commissioner.
Reference to the High Court (Sec. 133) on a Question of Law
A Reference to the High Court may be filed within 90 days of the communication of the order of the Appellate Tribunal. The aggrieved person or the commissioner may prefer an application in the prescribed form, along with a statement of the case, to the High Court, stating any question of law arising out of such order. A Division Bench of the High Court hears the reference. The High Court delivers a judgment, and a copy is sent to the Tribunal for giving effect. A fee of Rs. 100 is paid by a person other than the commissioner.
Burden of proof in appeals (sec. 136) on Tax Payers
The burden of proof lies on the tax payer: i) in the case of an assessment order, to the extent to which the order does not correctly reflect the taxpayer's liability for the tax year; or ii) in the case of any other decision, that the decision is erroneous.
Alternate Dispute Resolution
An aggrieved person may apply to the CBR for the appointment of a committee for the resolution of any hardship or dispute pending before an appellate authority. The CBR appoints a committee consisting of: an officer of income tax and two persons from a panel of Chartered Accountants, Cost Accountants, Advocates, or reputable taxpayers. The committee conducts an inquiry and seeks expert opinion, then makes recommendations. The CBR may pass an order based on these recommendations. This order is submitted to the authority, tribunal, or court where the matter is sub judice. If the taxpayer is not satisfied, they may continue to pursue their remedy before the relevant authority.
Federal Tax Ombudsman
The Federal Tax Ombudsman (FTO) was established by the βEstablishment of the Office of the Federal Tax Ombudsman, Ordinance, 2000β on 11/08/2000. Its objective is to diagnose, investigate, redress, and rectify any injustice done through mal-administration by functionaries administering tax laws.
π Definition β Mal-administration: Includes decisions, processes, or acts contrary to law, perverse, arbitrary, biased, or discriminatory; neglect, inattention, or delay; repeated notices or prolonged hearings; wilful errors in refunds; coercive recovery methods; and avoidance of disciplinary action.
The FTO is independent from the executive, easily accessible, impartial, and ensures quick disposal. Its jurisdiction extends to all Federal Taxes and the Revenue Division. It can be exercised on a complaint, on a reference by the President, Senate, National Assembly, on a motion of the Supreme Court or High Court, or on its own motion. It cannot investigate matters that are sub judice or relate to assessment of income, wealth, or tax liability where appeal remedies are available, or service matters of employees.
Procedure: Any aggrieved person sends an application on plain paper (anonymous complaints not entertained) within six months of having notice of the matter. After scrutiny, a notice is issued to the CBR, and most cases are disposed of within 60 days. The FTO makes a Recommendation/Finding.
Implementation: It is the duty of the Revenue Division to implement findings within 30 days. If CBR fails, it is treated as Defiance. The FTO may refer the matter to the President, and the report becomes part of the responsible employee's personal file, who is liable for contempt. The FTO has the same powers as the Supreme Court to punish for contempt.
Reference: Any person aggrieved by the FTO's finding can file a representation to the President.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember the strict 30-day timeline for appeal to the Commissioner and the 60-day timeline for appeal to the Appellate Tribunal, along with the specific fee structures which are the lesser of a fixed amount or a percentage of tax assessed. The Commissioner (Appeals) must decide within 3 months, and the Appellate Tribunal within 6 months. The High Court reference is only on a question of law, filed within 90 days. The Alternate Dispute Resolution offers a settlement mechanism pending appeal. Finally, the Federal Tax Ombudsman provides an independent, swift remedy for mal-administration, with findings that CBR must implement within 30 days, and defiance carries serious consequences including contempt powers.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the prescribed fee for filing an appeal against an assessment order to the Commissioner (Appeals)?
- Within how many days must the Commissioner (Appeals) pass an order after an appeal is filed, and what happens if this deadline is missed?
- What are the qualifications required for a judicial member of the Appellate Tribunal?
- On what basis (question of fact or question of law) can a case be referred to the High Court under Section 133, and what is the filing deadline?
- What specific recourse does a taxpayer have if the Central Board of Revenue fails to implement a finding of the Federal Tax Ombudsman?