π Lecture 7 β Common Stock Valuation (Dividend Models)
π Overview: This lecture explains how to value common stock, a form of corporate ownership that differs significantly from bonds. It covers the fundamental Dividend Discount Model and two key growth models used to estimate a stock's intrinsic value based on expected future dividends. Understanding these models is essential for making informed investment decisions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by distinguishing common stock from bonds and loans, highlighting key features like no promised cash flow for dividends, no maturity date, and challenges in observing rates of return. It then introduces the Dividend Discount Model for stock valuation, explaining that today's price equals the present value of all future dividends. Finally, it covers two dividend growth models: the No Growth Model (perpetuity) and the Constant Growth Model (Gordon Growth Model), including their formulas, assumptions, and practical examples.
π Lecture Summary
Common Stock (Introduction)
A company can raise capital by selling shares to the general public in the primary market. These shares are significantly different from bonds. Key features of a stock or share include no promised cash flow for dividends, no date of maturity (investment is forever), and problems in observing the rate of return.
Common stock (or common shares) is the most usual form of stock in a corporation. Another type is preferred stock. Treasury stock is common stock that has been re-purchased by the corporation. Common stock typically has voting rights. In a liquidation, common stockholders are near the last in priority. Dividends must be paid to preferred shares before common stockholders.
Common Stock Valuation
The following models are used to value common stock.
Dividend Discount Model
It is not easy to predict future stock prices. The Dividend Discount Model states that today's price is equal to the present value of all future dividends.
π After one year: Pβ = (Divβ + Pβ) / (1 + r)
- Meaning: Today's price is the sum of the dividend received in one year and the future stock price, discounted back to today.
π After two years: Pβ = Divβ/(1+r) + (Divβ + Pβ)/(1+r)Β²
π After three years: Pβ = Divβ/(1+r) + Divβ/(1+r)Β² + (Divβ + Pβ)/(1+r)Β³
When the time horizon is infinitely far, the final price has no present value today. This means the present value of a stock depends only on future dividends.
No Growth Model
This model assumes no growth by the company. The company pays out all earnings as dividends every year, meaning nothing is reinvested in the business. Investors may forecast that future dividends will not increase. Dividends remain at the same level forever β this is a perpetuity.
π Definition β Perpetuity: A constant stream of identical cash flows that continues forever.
π Formula: PV = DIV / r
- Where: PV = Present value (stock price), DIV = Constant dividend per period, r = Required rate of return
When the company pays out everything as dividends, earnings and dividends are equal. The formula becomes: PV = EPS / r
Constant Growth Model (Gordon Growth Model)
This model assumes dividends will grow at a constant growth rate (e.g., 5% per year).
For example, if the dividend is Rs. 2 per share with a 5% constant growth rate:
- Divβ = 2
- Divβ = 2 Γ 1.05 = 2.10
- Divβ = 2 Γ (1.05)Β² = 2.205
Fitting these into the formula:
- Pβ = 2/1.12 + 2.10/(1.12)Β² + 2.205/(1.12)Β³ + ...
- Pβ = 1.79 + 1.67 + 1.57 + ...
Although the number of terms is infinite, each term gets proportionately smaller as long as the growth rate (g) is less than the discount rate (r). The far distant dividends will be close to zero, so the sum of all terms is finite.
π Gordon Growth Model Formula: Pβ = Dβ / (r β g)
- Where: Pβ = Current stock price, Dβ = Expected dividend next year, r = Required rate of return, g = Constant growth rate of dividends
Alternatively: Pβ = Dβ Γ (1+g) / (r β g)
- Where: Dβ = Most recent dividend paid
π Example 1 (from lecture):
- Dβ = Rs. 2, g = 5%, r = 12%
- Pβ = 2 Γ 1.05 / (0.12 β 0.05) = 2.10 / 0.07 = Rs. 30.00
π‘ Why this matters: The Gordon model is valid only as long as g < r.
π Example 2 (from lecture):
- Dividend paid (Dβ) = Rs. 2.30
- Growth rate (g) = 5%
- Required return (r) = 13%
- What is the value after five years (Pβ )?
- Step 1: Calculate Dβ = 2.30 Γ (1.05)β΅ = 2.935
- Step 2: Pβ = 2.935 Γ 1.05 / (0.13 β 0.05) = 3.082 / 0.08 = Rs. 38.53
π Example 3 (from lecture):
- Next dividend (Dβ) = Rs. 4 per share
- Required return (r) = 16%
- Dividend growth (g) = 6% per year
- Calculate value today (Pβ) and in four years (Pβ).
Solution:
-
Pβ = Dβ / (r β g) = 4 / (0.16 β 0.06) = 4 / 0.10 = Rs. 40.00
-
Step 1: Calculate Dβ = 4 Γ (1.06)Β³ = 4.764
-
Step 2: Pβ = 4.764 Γ 1.06 / (0.16 β 0.06) = 5.050 / 0.10 = Rs. 50.50
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: common stock has no promised dividends, no maturity date, and is valued based on future dividends. The Dividend Discount Model states that a stock's price equals the present value of all future dividends. The No Growth Model (PV = DIV/r) values a stock as a perpetuity when all earnings are paid as dividends. The Constant Growth Model or Gordon Growth Model (Pβ = Dβ/(r-g)) values stocks when dividends grow at a constant rate, but requires that the growth rate be less than the required return (g < r). Finally, you must be able to calculate a stock's price at any future point in time using the growth model formula.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are three key differences between common stock and bonds?
- What is the fundamental formula for the Dividend Discount Model with an infinite time horizon?
- What is the formula for the No Growth Model, and what assumption does it make about dividends?
- State the Gordon Growth Model formula, and list its key assumption regarding the relationship between "g" and "r".
- If a company just paid a dividend of Rs. 5, with a growth rate of 4% and a required return of 14%, what is the stock's value today?
π Lecture 8 β Capital Budgeting
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of capital budgeting, the process used by firms to evaluate long-term investment projects. It covers fundamental analysis as a stock valuation method, the capital budgeting process, classification of investment projects, and the critical distinction between relevant and non-relevant costs for decision-making.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers fundamental analysis including its three-step process and criticisms, then moves to capital budgeting definition and process. It explains various forms of capital investment projects, the systematic approach to capital budgeting, and classification of projects by size, benefit type, dependence, cash flow type, and statistical dependence. Finally, it covers relevant costs, the three-step approach to identifying them, and non-relevant costs including sunk costs.
π Lecture Summary
Fundamental Analysis
Fundamental Analysis is a security or stock valuation method that uses financial and economic analysis to evaluate businesses or to predict the movement of security prices such as stock prices or bond prices. The fundamental information analyzed can include a company's financial reports, and non-financial information such as estimates of the growth of demand for competing products, industry comparisons, analysis of the effects of new regulations or demographic changes, and economy-wide changes. It is commonly contrasted with technical analysis which analyzes security price movements without reference to factors outside the market itself.
A potential (or current) investor uses fundamental analysis to examine a company's financial results, its operations and the market(s) in which the company is competing to understand the stability and growth potential of that company. Company factors to consider might include dividends paid, the way a company manages its cash, the amount of debt a company has, and the growth of a company's revenues, expenses and earnings. A fundamental analyst may enter long or short positions based on the result of fundamental analysis.
Three step process: In large organizations fundamental analysis is usually performed in three steps:
- Analysis of the macroeconomic situation, usually including both international and national economic indicators, such as GDP growth rates, inflation, interest rates, exchange rates, productivity, and energy prices.
- Industry analysis of total sales, price levels, the effects of competing products, foreign competition, and entry or exit from the industry.
- Individual firm analysis of unit sales, prices, new products, earnings, and the possibilities of new debt or equity issues.
Often the procedure stresses the effects of the overall economic situation on industry and firm analysis and is known as top down analysis. If instead the procedure stresses firm analysis and uses it to build its industry analysis, which it uses to build its macroeconomic analysis, it is known as bottom up analysis.
Criticisms:
- Some economists such as Burton Malkiel suggest that neither fundamental analysis nor technical analysis is useful in outperforming the markets.
Capital Budgeting
Capital Budgeting is the planning process used to determine a firm's long term investments such as new machinery, replacement machinery, new plants, new products, and research and development projects. Capital budgeting process is carried out for projects involving heavy initial upfront cost.
These projects can take any of the following forms:
- New project
- Expansion project
- Modernization / Replacement
- Research & development
- Exploration
- Other / social responsibility β Pollution control etc.
Capital Budgeting Process:
- Investment Opportunity (ies) is/are identified.
- Different alternatives are considered.
- Every alternative is evaluated
- The best option(s) are undertaken
Many formal methods are used in capital budgeting, including discounted cash flow techniques such as net present value, internal rate of return, Modified Internal Rate of Return and equivalent annuity method, using the incremental cash flows from each potential investment, or project. Techniques based on accounting earnings and accounting rules are sometimes used - though economists consider this to be improper - such as the accounting rate of return, and "return on investment." Simplified and hybrid methods are used as well, such as payback period and discounted payback period.
Capital Budgeting versus Current Expenditures
A capital investment project can be distinguished from current expenditures by two features: a) Such projects are relatively large b) A significant period of time (more than one year) elapses between the investment outlay and the receipt of the benefits.
As a result, most medium-sized and large organizations have developed special procedures and methods for dealing with these decisions. A systematic approach to capital budgeting implies: a) The formulation of long-term goals b) The creative search for and identification of new investment opportunities c) Classification of projects and recognition of economically and/or statistically dependent proposals d) The estimation and forecasting of current and future cash flows e) A suitable administrative framework capable of transferring the required information to the decision level f) The controlling of expenditures and careful monitoring of crucial aspects of project execution g) A set of decision rules which can differentiate acceptable from unacceptable alternatives is required. The last point (g) is crucial and this is the subject of later sections of the chapter.
The Classification of Investment Projects
a) By project size: Small projects may be approved by departmental managers. More careful analysis and Board of Directors' approval is needed for large projects of, say, half a million dollars or more.
b) By type of benefit to the firm:
- An increase in cash flow
- A decrease in risk
- An indirect benefit (showers for workers, etc).
c) By degree of dependence:
- Mutually exclusive projects (can execute project A or B, but not both)
- Complementary projects: taking project A increases the cash flow of project B.
- Substitute projects: taking project A decreases the cash flow of project B.
d) By degree of statistical dependence:
- Positive dependence
- Negative dependence
- Statistical independence.
e) By type of cash flow:
- Conventional cash flow: only one change in the cash flow sign e.g. -/++++ or +/ ---, etc
- Non-conventional cash flows: more than one change in the cash flow sign, e.g. +/-/+++ or -/+/-/++++, etc.
Relevant Costs
These are costs that are relevant with respect to a particular decision. A relevant cost for a particular decision is one that changes if an alternative course of action is taken. Relevant costs are also called differential costs.
Making correct decisions is one of the most important tasks of a successful manager. Every decision involves a choice between at least two alternatives. The decision process may be complicated by volumes of data, irrelevant data, incomplete information, an unlimited array of alternatives, etc. The role of the managerial accountant in this process is often that of a gatherer and summarizer of relevant information rather than the ultimate decision maker.
The costs and benefits of the alternatives need to be compared and contrasted before making a decision. The decision should be based only on RELEVANT information. Relevant information includes the predicted future costs and revenues that differ among the alternatives. Any cost or benefit that does not differ between alternatives is irrelevant and can be ignored in a decision. All future revenues and/or costs that do not differ between the alternatives are irrelevant. Sunk costs (costs already irrevocably incurred) are always irrelevant since they will be the same for any alternative.
π‘ Why this matters: Correctly identifying relevant costs prevents managers from making poor decisions based on irrelevant historical data.
To identify which costs are relevant in a particular situation, take this three step approach:
- Eliminate sunk costs and committed costs
- Eliminate costs and benefits that do not differ between alternatives
- Compare the remaining costs and benefits that do differ between alternatives to make the proper decision.
- Take care of opportunity cost.
π Definition β Relevant Costs: costs that change if an alternative course of action is taken; also called differential costs. π Definition β Sunk Costs: costs already irrevocably incurred; always irrelevant for decision-making. π Definition β Opportunity Cost: the benefit foregone by choosing one alternative over another; must be considered in decision-making.
β Key Takeaways
Capital budgeting is the planning process for evaluating long-term investments with heavy upfront costs, distinguished from current expenditures by their large size and multi-year time horizon. Fundamental analysis uses a three-step top-down or bottom-up approach analyzing macroeconomic, industry, and firm-level factors. Investment projects must be classified by size, benefit type, degree of dependence (mutually exclusive, complementary, substitute), statistical dependence, and cash flow type (conventional vs. non-conventional). Relevant costs are future costs that differ between alternatives, while sunk costs are always irrelevant. The critical decision rule is to eliminate sunk costs and non-differential items, then compare only the remaining costs and benefits.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three steps in the fundamental analysis process, and what is the difference between top-down and bottom-up analysis?
- Define capital budgeting and list at least four types of investment projects it covers.
- What are the key features that distinguish a capital investment project from a current expenditure?
- Explain the difference between mutually exclusive projects, complementary projects, and substitute projects.
- What is the three-step approach to identifying relevant costs, and why are sunk costs always irrelevant?
π Lecture 9 β Methods of Project Evaluations
π Overview: This lecture introduces the Net Present Value (NPV) method as a primary tool for evaluating whether a project will increase the value of a firm. It also covers the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC), used as the discount rate in NPV calculations, and the concept of opportunity cost, which underpins financial decision-making.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the Net Present Value (NPV) method of project evaluation, including its calculation, decision rule, and a worked example involving an office building investment. It then explains the Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) formula, its components (cost of equity and cost of debt), and its use as the firm's overall required return and discount rate. Finally, the concept of opportunity cost is defined and illustrated with examples from investing, education, and business.
π Lecture Summary
Methods of Project evaluations: NPV
The Net Present Value (NPV) method has two aspects: the initial investment (upfront cost, incurred now) and the future benefits (cash flows). The initial investment is simple to measure, but future benefits involve the time value of money, making their measurement more complex. NPV measures the net benefit by which a firm's value would increase if a project is undertaken.
To calculate NPV, the present value (PV) of future cash flows is computed using a discount rate. If the PV of future cash flows is greater than the initial investment, the NPV is positive, meaning the project is financially viable and worth undertaking. If the PV is less than the initial investment, the NPV is negative, and the project should be rejected.
π‘ Why this matters: A positive NPV directly adds to a firm's shareholder value, making it a critical tool for capital budgeting decisions.
π Definition β Net Present Value (NPV): The difference between the present value of future cash flows and the required initial investment.
π Formula: NPV = PV β required investment or NPV = Co + C1 / (1 + r)
Where:
Co= cash flow at time 0 (initial investment, typically a cash outflow)C1= cash flow at time 1r= discount rate (required minimum rate of return)
π Example: An office building costs Rs. 1,900,000 to build. Its present value is estimated to be Rs. 2,000,000.
NPV = 2,000,000 β 1,900,000 = Rs. 100,000
Since the NPV is positive, the project makes a net contribution to value and should be accepted.
Decision Rule:
- If NPV is positive (+): accept the project
- If NPV is negative (-): reject the project
Weighted Average Cost of Capital
Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC) is a calculation of a firm's cost of capital where each category of capital (common stock, preferred stock, bonds, and other long-term debt) is proportionately weighted. A companyβs assets are financed by either debt or equity, and WACC is the average cost of these sources, each weighted by its proportion in the firm's capital structure.
WACC shows how much interest a company must pay for every dollar it finances. It is often used internally by company directors to determine the economic feasibility of expansionary opportunities and mergers. WACC is the appropriate discount rate to use for cash flows with risk similar to that of the overall firm.
π Definition β Weighted Average Cost of Capital (WACC): The overall required return on a firm as a whole, representing the average cost of its capital from all sources.
π Formula: WACC = (E / V) * Re + (D / V) * Rd * (1 β Tc)
Where:
Re= cost of equityRd= cost of debtE= market value of the firm's equityD= market value of the firm's debtV= E + DE/V= percentage of financing that is equityD/V= percentage of financing that is debtTc= corporate tax rate
Opportunity Cost
Opportunity cost is the cost of an alternative that must be forgone in order to pursue a certain action. It represents the benefits you could have received by taking an alternative action. It is the difference in return between a chosen investment and one that is necessarily passed up.
π Example 1 (Investing): You invest in a stock with a 2% return over the year. You gave up the opportunity of a risk-free government bond yielding 6%. Your opportunity cost is 4% (6% - 2%).
π Example 2 (Education): The opportunity cost of going to college is the money you would have earned if you worked instead. You lose four years of salary, but you hope to earn more during your career to offset this loss.
π Example 3 (Business): If a gardener decides to grow carrots, the opportunity cost is the alternative crop that might have been grown instead (e.g., potatoes, tomatoes).
β Key Takeaways
The NPV method is the definitive tool for project evaluation, as a positive NPV directly increases firm value. The discount rate used in NPV calculations is typically the firm's WACC, which represents the blended cost of all financing sources. A crucial rule is to accept projects with a positive NPV and reject those with a negative NPV. WACC is calculated as a weighted average of the cost of equity and the after-tax cost of debt. Finally, opportunity cost is a fundamental concept reminding us that the true cost of any decision is the value of the next best alternative forgone, which is the basis for the required rate of return.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the NPV decision rule, and what does it imply for firm value?
- Write the formula for NPV and identify each variable.
- What does WACC represent, and why is it used as the discount rate in project evaluation?
- List all the components required to calculate WACC and their roles in the formula.
- Define opportunity cost and provide a business example that illustrates the concept.
π Lecture 10 β Methods of Project Evaluations
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) method for project evaluation, including its calculation and comparison with the Net Present Value (NPV) method. It explores the conflicts that arise between NPV and IRR when evaluating mutually exclusive projects and explains which method should be preferred for optimal decision-making.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) method, its calculation for annuities, and a detailed comparison of NPV versus IRR for both independent and dependent (mutually exclusive) projects. It examines specific scenarios where conflicts arise, including differences in the scale of investment, the timing of cash flows, and projects with different horizons, ultimately demonstrating the superiority of the NPV criterion.
π Lecture Summary
Methods of Project evaluations: Internal Rate of Return β IRR
The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is the discount rate at which the Net Present Value (NPV) for a project equals zero. This rate means that the present value of the cash inflows for the project would equal the present value of its outflows. The IRR is the break-even discount rate and is found by trial and error.
The formula is:
NPV = C0 + C1/(1+r) + C2/(1+r)^2 + ... = 0
Where r is the IRR.
IRR of an annuity:
For a project with a uniform annual receipt, the IRR is found by:
Io / C = Q(n, r)
Where Q(n, r) is the discount factor, Io is the initial outlay, and C is the uniform annual receipt.
π Example:
What is the IRR of an equal annual income of $20 per annum which accrues for 7 years and costs $120?
Io / C = 120 / 20 = 6
The discount factor is 6. Looking at the present value factor for an annuity for 7 years, the rate that gives a factor of 6 is approximately 9%. Therefore, the IRR is 9%.
Net present value vs. Internal rate of return
Independent vs. dependent projects NPV and IRR methods are closely related because both are time-adjusted measures of profitability and their mathematical formulas are almost identical.
a) NPV vs. IRR: Independent projects An independent project is one where selecting one project does not preclude the choosing of the other. With conventional cash flows (-|+|+), no conflict in decision arises; in this case, both NPV and IRR lead to the same accept/reject decisions. If NPV is positive, the project is acceptable, and the IRR (R) must be greater than the cost of capital (k). If NPV = 0, then R = k.
b) NPV vs. IRR: Dependent projects NPV clashes with IRR where mutually exclusive projects exist. In mutually exclusive projects, selecting one project prevents the selection of the other.
π Example: Agritex is considering building either a one-storey (Project A) or five-storey (Project B) block of offices on a prime site.
| Initial Investment Outlay | Net Inflow at the Year End | |
|---|---|---|
| Project A | -9,500 | 11,500 |
| Project B | -15,000 | 18,000 |
Assume k = 10%.
NPVA = (11,500 / 1.10) - 9,500 = $954.55
NPVB = (18,000 / 1.10) - 15,000 = $1,363.64
IRR Calculation:
IRRA: 11,500 = 9,500 (1 + RA) β (1 + RA) = 1.21 β IRRA = 21%
IRRB: 18,000 = 15,000 (1 + RB) β (1 + RB) = 1.2 β IRRB = 20%
Decision: Both projects are acceptable. The NPV method prefers Project B (higher NPV), while the IRR method prefers Project A (higher IRR). This is a conflict.
Differences in the scale of investment
NPV and IRR may give conflicting decisions where projects differ in their scale of investment.
π Example:
| Years | 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Project A | -2,500 | 1,500 | 1,500 | 1,500 |
| Project B | -14,000 | 7,000 | 7,000 | 7,000 |
Assume k = 10%.
NPVA = (1,500 x 2.487) - 2,500 = $1,230.50
NPVB = (7,000 x 2.487) - 14,000 = $3,409.00
IRR Calculation:
IRRA: 2,500 / 1,500 = 1.67 β IRRA = 36%
IRRB: 14,000 / 7,000 = 2.0 β IRRB = 21%
Decision: Conflicting: NPV prefers B to A, while IRR prefers A to B. The NPV is superior to the IRR here. π‘ Why this matters: The conflict arises because IRR is a percentage return, ignoring the absolute dollar value of the return. The NPV method is preferred as it ensures the firm reaches an optimal scale of investment.
To resolve this, use the incremental cash flow approach, "B minus A". Choosing project B is equivalent to choosing Project A plus a hypothetical project "B minus A".
i) IRR"B Minus A" = 20%
ii) Given k of 10%, this is a profitable opportunity, therefore must be accepted.
iii) If k were greater than the IRR (20%) on the incremental CF, then reject the incremental project.
iv) At the point of intersection, NPVA = NPVB, the company is indifferent.
v) This justifies the use of NPV criterion.
Advantage of NPV: It ensures that the firm reaches an optimal scale of investment. Disadvantage of IRR: It expresses the return in a percentage form rather than in terms of absolute dollar returns (e.g., the IRR will prefer 500% of $1 to 20% return on $100).
The timing of the cash flow
The IRR may give conflicting decisions where the timing of cash flows varies between the 2 projects, even with the same initial outlay.
π Example:
| 0 | 1 | 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Project A | -100 | 20 | 125.00 |
| Project B | -100 | 100 | 31.25 |
| "A minus B" | 0 | -80 | 88.15 |
Assume k = 10%.
| NPV | IRR | |
|---|---|---|
| Project A | 17.3 | 20.0% |
| Project B | 16.7 | 25.0% |
| "A minus B" | 0.6 | 10.9% |
IRR prefers B to A even though both projects have identical initial outlays. However, the incremental cash flow from choosing A over B ("A minus B") has a positive NPV, so the decision is to accept A, based on the NPV criterion.
The horizon problem
NPV and IRR rankings are contradictory when projects have different horizons (project lives).
π Example:
| 0 | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Project A | -100 | 120 | - | - | - |
| Project B | -100 | - | - | - | 174 |
Assume k = 10%.
| NPV | IRR | |
|---|---|---|
| Project A | 9 | 20% |
| Project B | 19 | 15% |
Decision: NPV prefers Project B to Project A, while IRR prefers Project A to Project B.
β Key Takeaways
The Internal Rate of Return (IRR) is the discount rate that makes a project's NPV equal to zero, serving as a break-even point. For independent projects, NPV and IRR always lead to the same accept/reject decisions. However, for mutually exclusive projects, conflicts arise due to differences in project scale, cash flow timing, or project horizon; in these cases, NPV is the superior method because it focuses on the absolute dollar value of wealth created, leading to optimal investment scale. The conflict can be resolved using the incremental cash flow approach to identify the superior project.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Define the Internal Rate of Return (IRR) and how it is mathematically determined.
- Explain why IRR and NPV can lead to conflicting decisions when evaluating mutually exclusive projects.
- Describe the "scale of investment" problem and how the incremental cash flow approach resolves it.
- A project has an IRR of 15% and a cost of capital of 12%. Is the project acceptable based on the IRR rule? Why?
- Why is the NPV criterion generally considered superior to the IRR criterion for capital budgeting decisions?
π Lecture 11 β Methods of Project Evaluations
π Overview: This lecture introduces several methods for evaluating capital investment projects. It covers the Payback Period, Discounted Payback Period, Accounting Rate of Return (ARR), and Profitability Index (PI), explaining their calculations, advantages, and disadvantages. Understanding these methods is crucial for making informed investment decisions in corporate finance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four main project evaluation methods: Payback Period (PP), Discounted Payback Period, Accounting Rate of Return (ARR), and Profitability Index (PI). For each method, it explains the calculation process, decision rules, and practical implications. It also discusses the advantages and disadvantages of each method, particularly focusing on the widespread use of the payback method in practice despite its limitations.
π Lecture Summary
ο THE PAYBACK PERIOD (PP)
The Payback Period is defined as the time it takes for the cash inflows from a capital investment project to equal the cash outflows, usually expressed in years. When deciding between competing projects, the usual decision is to accept the one with the shortest payback. Payback is often used as a "first screening method" to quickly assess how long it will take to recover the project's cost. A company might have a target payback period, rejecting projects exceeding that time.
Example 1: Years 0 1 2 3 4 5 Project A -1,000,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000 250,000
For a project with equal annual receipts: Payback Period = Initial Investment / Annual Cash Inflow = $1,000,000 / $250,000 = 4 years
Example 2: Years 0 1 2 3 4 Project B -10,000 5,000 2,500 4,000 1,000
Payback period lies between year 2 and year 3. Sum of money recovered by the end of the second year = $7,500 ($5,000 + $2,500) Sum of money to be recovered by end of 3rd year = $10,000 - $7,500 = $2,500 Payback Period = 2 years + ($2,500 / $4,000) = 2.625 years
Disadvantages of the payback method:
- It ignores the timing of cash flows within the payback period, the cash flows after the end of payback period, and therefore the total project return.
- It ignores the time value of money, meaning it does not account for the fact that $1 today is worth more than $1 in one year's time.
- It is unable to distinguish between projects with the same payback period.
- It may lead to excessive investment in short-term projects.
Advantages of the payback method:
- Payback can be important because a long payback means capital is tied up and there is high investment risk.
- The method involves a quick, simple calculation and an easily understood concept.
ο DISCOUNTED PAYBACK PERIOD
The Discounted Payback Period is the length of time required to recover the initial cash outflow from the discounted future cash inflows. This approach uses the present values of cash inflows, cumulating them until they equal the initial investment. This method addresses the payback method's flaw by accounting for the time value of money.
Example: Assume a machine purchased for $5,000 yields cash inflows of $5,000, $4,000, and $4,000. The cost of capital is 10%. Year 1 PV = $5,000 / 1.10 = $4,545 Year 2 PV = $4,000 / (1.10)Β² = $3,306 Year 3 PV = $4,000 / (1.10)Β³ = $3,005
The payback period (without discounting) is exactly 1 year. However, the discounted payback period is a little over 1 year because the first year discounted cash flow of $4,545 is not enough to cover the initial investment of $5,000. Discounted Payback = 1 year + [($5,000 - $4,545) / $3,306] = 1 year + 0.14 year = 1.14 years
ο THE ACCOUNTING RATE OF RETURN - (ARR)
The Accounting Rate of Return (ARR), also called the return on capital employed (ROCE) or return on investment (ROI), estimates the accounting rate of return a project should yield. If it exceeds a target rate of return, the project will be undertaken. Note that net annual profit excludes depreciation.
Example: A project has an initial outlay of $1 million and generates net receipts of $250,000 for 10 years. Assuming straight-line depreciation of $100,000 per year:
Average annual profit = $250,000 - $100,000 = $150,000
Average investment = ($1,000,000 + $0) / 2 = $500,000
ARR (based on average investment) = ($150,000 / $500,000) Γ 100 = 30%
ARR (based on initial investment) = ($150,000 / $1,000,000) Γ 100 = 15%
Disadvantages:
- It does not take account of the timing of the profits from an investment.
- It implicitly assumes stable cash receipts over time.
- It is based on accounting profits and not cash flows; accounting profits are subject to different accounting treatments.
- It is a relative measure rather than an absolute measure and takes no account of the size of the investment.
- It takes no account of the length of the project.
- It ignores the time value of money.
The payback and ARR methods in practice: Despite limitations, the payback method is most widely used in practice for several reasons:
- It is useful for ranking projects where a firm faces liquidity constraints and requires fast repayment.
- It is appropriate in situations with risky investments in uncertain markets where future cash flows are difficult to predict.
- It is often used in conjunction with NPV or IRR as a first screening device.
- It is easily understood by all levels of management.
- It provides an important summary: how quickly will the initial investment be recouped?
ο THE PROFITABILITY INDEX β PI
The Profitability Index (PI), also known as the benefit-cost ratio, is the relationship between the present value (PV) of all future cash flows and the initial investment. It is calculated by dividing the PV of all cash flows by the initial investment. This is a variant of the NPV method.
Formula: PI = PV of Future Cash Flows / Initial Investment
Decision rule:
- PI > 1: accept the project
- PI < 1: reject the project
If NPV = 0, we have NPV = PV - Iβ = 0, so PV = Iβ. Dividing both sides by Iβ gives PI = 1. A PI of 1.2 means the project's profitability is 20%.
Example: PV of CF Iβ PI Project A 100 50 2.0 Project B 1,500 1,000 1.5
Decision: Choose option B because it maximizes the firm's profitability by $1,500 (NPV = $500 for B vs. $50 for A).
Disadvantage of PI: Like IRR, it is a percentage and therefore ignores the scale of investment.
The NPV method is preferred over the PI method because PI greater than 1 implies positive NPV. NPV clearly states whether to undertake or reject a project and returns a dollar value of the economic contribution to firm value, unlike PI which only expresses relative profitability.
β Key Takeaways
The Payback Period is a simple, widely-used first screening method that measures how quickly a project recovers its initial investment, but it ignores the time value of money and post-payback cash flows. The Discounted Payback Period improves upon this by discounting future cash flows. The Accounting Rate of Return (ARR) uses accounting profits rather than cash flows and also ignores the time value of money, making it less reliable than discounted cash flow methods. The Profitability Index (PI) is a relative measure of profitability but, like IRR, can be misleading when comparing projects of different scales. Despite their limitations, payback and ARR remain popular due to their simplicity and intuitive appeal, especially for liquidity-constrained firms.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- A project costs $50,000 and generates annual cash inflows of $12,500. What is its payback period?
- How does the Discounted Payback Period differ from the regular Payback Period, and what problem does it solve?
- If a project has an initial investment of $200,000, average annual profit of $30,000, and a 10-year life with straight-line depreciation, what is its ARR based on average investment?
- A project has a profitability index of 0.85. Should the project be accepted or rejected? Why?
- What is the main disadvantage of the Profitability Index compared to the Net Present Value method?