๐ Lecture 7 โ Needs Analysis -I
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces needs analysis as a critical component of curriculum design, examining what learners need to learn and what they want to learn. It explores the purposes, definitions, users, and target populations involved in needs analysis, emphasizing that needs analysis ensures courses contain relevant and useful content.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the introduction to needs analysis, including its emergence in the 1960s as part of the systems approach to curriculum development. It examines the various purposes of needs analysis in language teaching, explores the complex nature of needs as constructed concepts rather than objective realities, identifies the multiple users who benefit from needs analysis results, and discusses the target population and sampling considerations in conducting effective needs analysis.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-032: Introduction to Needs Analysis
The aim of this lecture is to critically examine what needs to be learned and what the learners want to learn. Needs analysis is directed mainly at the goals and content of a course. It examines what the learners know already and what they need to know. Needs analysis makes sure that the course will contain relevant and useful things to learn. Good needs analysis involves asking the right questions and finding the answers in the most effective way.
One of the basic assumptions of curriculum development is that a sound educational program should be based on an analysis of learners' needs. Procedures used to collect information about learners' needs are known as needs analysis. Needs analysis, as a distinct and necessary phase in planning educational programs, emerged in the 1960s as a part of the systems approach to curriculum development. It was a part of the prevalent philosophy of educational accountability. This lesson examines approaches to needs analysis and considers the purposes of needs analysis, the nature of needs, whom needs analysis is intended for, who the target population is, who collects information, what procedures can be used, and how the information collected can be used.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding that needs analysis emerged from the systems approach and educational accountability helps us recognize why curriculum must be evidence-based and responsive to learner requirements.
Topic-033: The Purposes of Needs Analysis
Needs analysis in language teaching may be used for a number of different purposes, for example:
- To find out what language skills a learner needs in order to perform a particular role, such as sales manager, tour guide, or university student.
- To help determine if an existing course adequately addresses the needs of potential students.
- To determine which students from a group are most in need of training in particular language skills.
- To identify a change of direction that people in a reference group feel important.
- To identify a gap between what students are able to do and what they need to be able to do.
- To collect information about a particular problem learners are experiencing.
Topic-034: What are Needs?
The term 'needs' is not as straightforward as it might appear, and hence the term is sometimes used to refer to wants, desires, demands, expectation, motivations, lacks, constraints, and requirements. Needs are often described in terms of a linguistic deficiency, that is, as describing the difference between what a learner can presently do in a language and what he or she should be able to do. This suggests that needs have objective reality. Porcher (1977, as in Brindley, 1984) offers a different perspective: "Need is not a thing that exists and might be encountered ready-made on the street. It is a thing that is constructed, the center of conceptual networks and the product of a number of epistemological choices (which are not innocent themselves, of course)."
What is identified as a need is dependent on judgment and reflects the interests and values of those making such a judgment. Teachers, learners, employers, parents, and other stakeholders may thus all have different views as to what needs are. For example, in considering the needs of immigrants, representatives of the majority population may see the immigrants' needs as achieving cultural and linguistic assimilation as quickly as possible and hence may want a needs analysis to identify the language skills immigrants require surviving, and ultimately assimilating into the dominant culture.
๐ก Why this matters: Recognizing that needs are constructed rather than objectively existing helps us understand why different stakeholders may have conflicting views about what should be taught.
Topic-035: The Users of Needs Analysis
A needs analysis may be conducted for a variety of different users. For example, in conducting a needs analysis to help revise the secondary school English curriculum in a country, the end users include:
- Curriculum officers in the ministry of education who may wish to use the information to evaluate the adequacy of existing syllabus, curriculum, and materials.
- Teachers who will teach from the new curriculum.
- Learners who will be taught from the curriculum.
- Writers who are preparing new textbooks.
- Testing personnel who are involved in developing end-of-school assessments.
- Staff of tertiary institutions who are interested in knowing what the expected level of the existing students will be and what problems they face.
With small-scale needs analysis such as that carried out by a single teacher on his or her class, the audience might consist of the teacher, other teachers, and the program coordinator. In cases of large-scale needs analysis, there will be multiple audiences for the results of a needs analysis. Determining the likely audiences is an important first step in planning a needs analysis in order to ensure that the information they need is obtained and that the needs analysis will have the impact it is designed to have.
๐ก Why this matters: Identifying users early ensures the needs analysis collects relevant information and achieves its intended impact.
Topic-036: The Target Population
The target population in a needs analysis refers to the people about whom information will be collected. Typically, in language programs there will be language learners or potential language learners, but others are also often involved depending on whether they can provide information useful in meeting the purposes of the needs analysis. For example, in conducting a needs analysis to determine the focus of an English program in public secondary schools in an EFL context, the target population might include:
- policymakers
- ministry of education officials
- teachers
- students
- academics
- employers
- vocational training specialists
- parents
- influential individuals and pressure groups
- academic specialists
- community agencies
In determining the target population, an important issue is that of sampling. In some cases, the population is small enough for every learner to be included in the sample. In other cases, this approach is not feasible and so decisions must be made about the size of the sample to be included in a needs analysis. Sampling involves asking a portion of the potential population instead of the total population and seeks to create a sample that is representative of the total population. Elley (1984) points out that a number of factors influence the approach to sampling, such as the homogeneity of the population in terms of the kinds of skills, attitudes, or knowledge being sought or the need to study subgroups within the sample - for example, based on sex, language group, or other factors. Where the target population is large, specialized advice is often needed to determine what approach to sampling best suits the purpose of the study and the sources of information available.
๐ก Why this matters: Proper sampling ensures that needs analysis findings are valid and applicable to the entire target population, not just those surveyed.
โญ Key Takeaways
Needs analysis is a distinct and necessary phase in curriculum planning that emerged in the 1960s as part of the systems approach to curriculum development and educational accountability. Needs are not straightforward objective realities but are constructed concepts dependent on the judgment and values of various stakeholders including teachers, learners, employers, and parents. The purposes of needs analysis include identifying required language skills, evaluating existing courses, determining training priorities, and identifying gaps between current abilities and required competencies. Multiple users benefit from needs analysis including curriculum officers, teachers, learners, textbook writers, testing personnel, and tertiary institution staff, making audience identification a crucial first step. Target populations can include a wide range of stakeholders beyond just learners, and when populations are large, appropriate sampling techniques must be used to ensure the sample is representative of the total population.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- When did needs analysis emerge as a distinct phase in curriculum development, and what philosophical movement was it part of?
- According to Porcher (1977), are needs objective realities or constructed concepts? Explain with reference to the lecture.
- List at least four different purposes for which needs analysis in language teaching may be used.
- Who are the potential users of a large-scale needs analysis conducted to revise a secondary school English curriculum?
- What is sampling, and what factors influence the approach to sampling in needs analysis according to Elley (1984)?
๐ Lecture 8 โ Needs Analysis -II
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of needs analysis in curriculum design, focusing on the practical aspects of administering, conducting, and designing needs analyses. It covers procedures like task analysis and case studies, how to make use of collected information, and how to evaluate the reliability, validity, and practicality of a needs analysis, concluding with an example and discussion of key issues.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers who administers a needs analysis and how to collect and analyze results. It explores various procedures for conducting needs analysis, including a triangular approach using multiple information sources. It details task analysis and case studies for future occupational or educational settings, outlines the steps for designing a needs analysis, explains how to make use of the obtained information in ranked lists, and discusses how to evaluate needs analysis based on reliability, validity, and practicality. It concludes with a real-world example from Auckland University and a discussion of key issues like common core vs. specialized language, narrow vs. wide focus, and critical needs analysis.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-037: Administering the Needs Analysis
Planning a needs analysis includes deciding who will administer it, collect data, and analyze results. The scope can vary greatly, from a survey of a whole school population to a study of a group of thirty learners. Sometimes a specific team is assembled for the task; at other times, only two or three interested teachers are involved. In some programs, informal needs analysis is a part of a teacher's regular responsibilities.
Topic-038: Procedures for Conducting Needs Analysis
A variety of procedures can be used, and the kind of information obtained often depends on the procedure selected. Because any single source of information is likely to be incomplete or partial, a triangular approach is recommended, meaning information from two or more different sources should be sought. For example, when analyzing the writing problems of foreign students in American universities, information could be obtained from samples of student writing, test data, teacher reports, expert opinions, student interviews, textbook analysis, and surveys.
Topic-039: Task Analysis and Case Studies
This refers to analyzing the kinds of tasks learners will have to perform in English in a future occupational or educational setting and assessing the linguistic characteristics and demands of those tasks. For instance, a hotel employee might need to greet guests, inquire about accommodation needs, inform them of availability, help them choose, and handle check-in procedures. The emphasis of target situation analysis is on the nature and effect of target language communications in specific situations. Expert analysis of communication establishes standards against which current performance can be gauged.
Topic-040: Designing the Needs Analysis
Designing a needs analysis involves choosing options that will give a comprehensive view of learners' needs and represent the interests of different stakeholders. Decisions must be made on practical procedures for collecting, organizing, analyzing, and reporting information to avoid an information overload. The procedures for needs analysis include a literature survey, analysis of survey questionnaires, interviews with teachers, identification of participating departments, development and piloting of questionnaires, selecting subjects, developing a schedule, and administering the questionnaires.
Topic-041: Making Use of the Information Obtained
The results of a needs analysis generally consist of information from several sources summarized in the form of ranked lists. These lists might include situations where English is frequently used, situations where difficulties are encountered, comments on learners' performance, frequencies of different transactions, perceived difficulties with language use, frequencies of errors, suggestions and opinions about learners' problems, and frequencies of linguistic items in different texts or situations.
Topic-042: Evaluating Needs Analysis
Needs analysis can be evaluated by considering its reliability, validity, and practicality. Reliable needs analysis uses well-thought-out, standardized tools applied systematically, such as using a checklist or recording and applying standardized analysis procedures. Valid needs analysis involves looking at what is relevant and important, requiring careful consideration of the type of need being investigated. The worst decision would be to let practicality dominate by investigating what is easiest.
Topic-043: Example in Need Analysis
An example is taken from Richards' book (2001) involving NNES (non-native English speaking students) at Auckland University, New Zealand, in 1997. The purpose was to understand whether the current courses met the needs of the growing NNES population. The university gained insights from previous surveys and designed two new questionnaires addressing the issues and problems faced by the students. The survey gathered demographic information and information about different language skills. Suggestions from this survey focused on developing reading habits among NNES and proposed changes to the syllabus.
Topic-044: Issues in Needs Analysis
There are several key issues in needs analysis that are the focus of continuing debate: common core and specialised language, narrow focus โ wide focus, and critical needs analysis. Needs analysis ensures that a course will be relevant and satisfying to the learners. To neglect the needs of the learners is to run the risk of producing a course that does not meet basic requirements.
โญ Key Takeaways
For the exam, you must remember that a triangular approach (using multiple information sources) is crucial for a complete needs analysis, as any single source is likely to be partial. Task analysis focuses on identifying the specific linguistic demands of target situations, like a hotel employee's tasks. The design of a needs analysis must balance comprehensiveness with practical constraints to avoid information overload. The results are typically presented as ranked lists, and the entire process can be evaluated by its reliability, validity, and practicality. Finally, be aware of the key debates in the field, including the balance between common core and specialized language, the scope of the focus, and the concept of critical needs analysis.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is a "triangular approach" in the context of procedures for conducting needs analysis, and why is it recommended?
- Describe the focus of "target situation analysis" (Task Analysis) and give one example of a task a hotel employee might need to perform in English.
- What are the three main criteria for evaluating a needs analysis, and what does a "valid" needs analysis involve?
- According to the example from Auckland University, what was the main purpose of the needs analysis, and what key suggestion resulted from the survey?
- List the three continuing issues in needs analysis that were highlighted in the lecture.
๐ Lecture 9 โ Twenty Principles -I
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the Twenty Principles framework for language curriculum design, dividing them into three groups: content and sequencing, format and presentation, and monitoring and assessment. The principles are based on research and theory, designed to guide teachers in creating effective courses by focusing on what yields the best return for learning effort.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the introduction to Twenty Principles and their three groups, then delves into the first eight principles of content and sequencing: Frequency (Principle 1), Strategies and autonomy (Principle 2), Spaced retrieval (Principle 3), Language System (Principle 4), Keep moving forward (Principle 5), Teach-ability (Principle 6), Learning Burden (Principle 7), and Interference (Principle 8). Each principle includes its rationale, supporting research, and practical applications for curriculum design.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-045: Introduction to Twenty Principles-I
This lesson critically analyzes how learning can be encouraged within the framework of language curriculum design. Its purpose is to provide a sensible basis to guide teachers and help them design courses based on certain principles. These principles must be based on research and theory, and must be general enough to allow variety and flexibility in their application to suit a wide range of conditions in which language is taught. The principles have been divided into three groups, which represent the three major divisions of the central circle in the curriculum design diagram.
Topic-046: Introduction to Twenty Principles-II
The first group of principles deals with content and sequencing, concerning what goes into a language course and the order of language items. The aim is to ensure learners gain something useful, avoiding courses with interesting activities but poor return for time invested. Poor return can occur because lessons contain nothing new, new items have little value in ordinary language use, or they set up interference conditions causing a step backward in learning.
The second group of principles deals with format and presentation, concerning what happens in the classroom and during learning, relating to kinds of activities used and how learners process material. Teachers have their greatest influence on the course in this aspect.
The third group of principles deals with monitoring and assessment and to some degree evaluation. In each group, principles have been ranked in order of importance, with the first being most important.
Topic-047: First Group of Twenty Principles: Content and Sequencing (Principles 1-2)
Principle 1: Frequency A language course should provide the best possible coverage of language in use through the inclusion of items that occur frequently, so learners get the best return for their learning effort.
๐ Definition โ Frequency Principle: Language courses should prioritize items that occur most frequently in language use.
Research on vocabulary frequency shows that knowing 10 items provides coverage of 25% of written text, 100 items 50%, 1,000 items 70%, and 2,000 items over 80%.
General rules about frequency, coverage, and types of items:
- A small number of high-frequency items will cover a large proportion of text
- After the few most frequent items, a very large number of low-frequency items must be known to cover the remainder
- High-frequency items are typically simple in form (but not necessarily in meaning)
๐ก Why this matters: Application to material selection: courses should give most attention to high-frequency items. Low-frequency items should be dealt with only after high-frequency items are sufficiently learned. It may be more efficient to teach learners strategies for learning and coping with low-frequency items rather than presenting the items themselves.
Principle 2: Strategies and autonomy A language course should train learners how to learn a language so they can become effective and independent language learners.
๐ Definition โ Strategies and Autonomy Principle: Courses should develop learners' ability to learn independently.
Research on good language learners (Wong Fillmore, 1983; Naiman, 1996) and effective strategies includes:
- Learning strategies: deep processing of language and content, vocabulary learning cards, word part strategies, mnemonic strategies (e.g., keyword), predicting, notetaking strategies
- Gaining input: peer interaction strategies, strategies for controlling the teacher
- Coping strategies: inferring vocabulary from context, coping with complex sentences
Topic-048: First Group of Twenty Principles: Content and Sequencing (Principles 3-4)
Principle 3: Spaced retrieval Learners should have increasingly spaced, repeated opportunity to give attention to wanted items in a variety of contexts.
๐ Definition โ Spaced Retrieval Principle: Repetition of items should be increasingly spaced over time and occur in varied contexts.
Evidence comes from studies of repetition effects on learning (Kachroo, 1962; Saragi et al., 1978) and the levels of processing theory (Craik and Tulving, 1975).
Few course books provide adequate repetition checking, which is too difficult for individual teachers without computer access. The simplest way to check is to test frequently whether wanted items are learned. Another possibility is to choose a small group of very useful but likely neglected items (not more than 20) and keep a note of their repetition.
Principle 4: Language System The language focus of a course needs to be on generalizable features of the language system.
๐ Definition โ Language System Principle: Attention should focus on regular, generalizable language features that enable creative use.
This does not mean all attention is directed to formal features. Where attention is directed, features should be predominantly regular features. A good command enables learners to make "creative" use of the languageโto say, write, and understand things they have not met before.
To check application: ask "Will today's work help learners deal with tomorrow's task?" If yes, the principle is being applied. Teachers should examine the learning goal of a lesson and evaluate it in terms of learners' future language uses, ensuring the widest possible use of language features.
Topic-049: First Group of Twenty Principles: Content and Sequencing (Principles 5-6)
Principle 5: Keep moving forward A language course should progressively cover useful language items, skills, and strategies.
๐ Definition โ Progressive Coverage Principle: Courses should have explicit language teaching goals with systematic opportunity for achievement.
Applied differently by various methodsโAural-oral courses and others assign particular structures, functions, or vocabulary to particular lessons (e.g., Cambridge English Course lists items in detailed table of contents).
To check application: have lists of useful items to check the course against. The most effective way is to ensure each learning task has a goal fitting the course plan. Before using a new task, teachers should decide its learning goal, which can include language items, content material (ideas), skill elements (including fluency development with previously met items), and discourse features (text structure, dialogue maintenance strategies).
๐ก Why this matters: If activities lack obvious learning goals or don't fit overall goals, adapt or replace the task. Having regular goal-directed tests can positively affect teaching and learning.
Principle 6: Teach-ability The teaching of language items should take account of the most favorable sequencing of these items and when learners are most ready to learn them.
๐ Definition โ Teach-ability Principle: Sequencing should consider learners' developmental readiness for language items.
Research by Pienemann et al. (1988) and others examines the sequence of second language acquisition and its effects on teaching.
Psychological complexity of a structure depends on the amount of rearranging needed when expressing a message in language. For example, the message "John arrives when?" requires two rearrangements to produce "When will John arrive?"โmaking it more complex than "Will John come?" which requires only one rearrangement. Learning the rearrangement for "Will John come?" is a prerequisite to learning "When will John come?"
๐ Example: The sentence "When will John arrive?" involves two rearrangements from the message order "John arrives when?" making it more psychologically complex than "Will John come?" which involves one rearrangement from "John will come."
Based on this analysis, Pienemann and Johnston (1987) created a sequenced list of structures matching the natural second language acquisition order.
Topic-050: First Group of Twenty Principles: Content and Sequencing (Principles 7-8)
Principle 7: Learning Burden The course should help learners make the most effective use of previous knowledge.
๐ Definition โ Learning Burden Principle: Courses should leverage learners' existing knowledge, particularly from their first language.
Previous knowledge from the first language has been debatedโsome argue it has major effect (Lado, 1957; Ringbom, 1987), others argue second language learning occurs without other language influence.
The effect varies by circumstances: where language is learned as a foreign language with little contact outside class, first language effect is more noticeable. Where classroom is one of many sources (e.g., English learning in New Zealand, Australia, Britain, US), first language influence is less noticeable.
Evidence shows first language aspects can help learning at all levelsโpronunciation, grammar, vocabulary, discourseโas well as with aspects of language skill and content knowledge.
Principle 8: Interference Items in a language course should be sequenced so that items learned together have a positive effect on each other, and interference effects are avoided.
๐ Definition โ Interference Principle: Items with strong meaning relationships should not be taught together to avoid negative interference.
Research shows items with loose indirect connections (indirect free associates) are learned more effectively when learned together. Items with strong meaning relationships (opposites, near synonyms, free associates) interfere with each other, making learning more difficult (Higa, 1963; Nation, 2000).
Despite this evidence, many courses still present opposites and near synonyms together, reflecting associations in the curriculum designer's mind rather than what helps learning.
๐ก Why this matters: The easiest solution is to let naturally occurring spoken or written texts determine item order. If course books present closely related items together, teachers can help learners master the most useful one first before the pair is metโfor example, teaching "hot" before the book introduces both "hot" and "cold." The more secure the learning of the first item, the less chance of interference when the second item appears.
โญ Key Takeaways
The Twenty Principles framework is organized into three groups (content/sequencing, format/presentation, and monitoring/assessment) with principles ranked by importance. The most critical content principles include Frequency (prioritizing high-frequency items for best return), Strategies and Autonomy (training learners to become independent), and Spaced Retrieval (providing increasingly spaced repetition in varied contexts). Teachers must also ensure the Language System principle (focusing on generalizable features), progressive coverage, teach-ability based on developmental readiness, leveraging previous knowledge through Learning Burden, and avoiding Interference by not teaching strongly related items together. All principles must be grounded in research and allow flexibility for diverse teaching conditions.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
-
According to vocabulary frequency data, what percentage of written text is covered by knowing 100 items? 1,000 items? 2,000 items?
-
What is the difference between the Content and Sequencing group of principles and the Format and Presentation group?
-
How does the Spaced Retrieval principle (Principle 3) differ from simply providing repetition, and what research supports it?
-
According to the Teach-ability principle, why is "When will John arrive?" more psychologically complex than "Will John come?"
-
What is the recommended solution for dealing with course books that present closely related items together (like "hot" and "cold") to avoid interference?
๐ Lecture 10 โ TWENTY PRINCIPLES -II
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of the second group of twenty principles for curriculum design, focusing on format and presentation (principles 1-10) and introducing the third group on monitoring and assessment (principles 1-2). It covers essential aspects of motivation, course structure, input, fluency, output, deliberate learning, time management, and feedback, providing practical guidance for effective language teaching.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers ten principles from the second group (Format and Presentation): Motivation, Four Strands, Comprehensible Input, Fluency, Output, Deliberate Learning, Time on Task, Depth of Processing, Integrative Motivation, and Learning Style. It then introduces the first two principles from the third group (Monitoring and Assessment): Ongoing Needs and Environment Analysis, and Feedback. Finally, it discusses the wider uses of the list of principles for course design, evaluation, and professional development.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-051: Second Group of Twenty Principles: Format and Presentation (Principle 1-2)
Principle 1: Motivation
This principle stresses the importance of learners' attitude to what they are studying. Motivation is a very important determinant of the amount of time, involvement and effect that learners give to learning. The best motivation is โintrinsicโ, springing from within the learner, rather than โextrinsicโ, coming from some outside integrative or instrumental reward. Intrinsic motivation can develop as a result of extrinsic motivation.
To attract and involve learners who are not interested, teachers can: make the subject matter relevant and interesting; give learners some control and decision-making; set tasks with clear outcomes and high possibility of success; set many short achievement tests; show learners how to keep records of their progress (e.g., speed reading graphs, dictation scores); help learners become autonomous learners by explaining rationales; reward efforts through publication, praise, and attention; use tasks with built-in challenges like competition, time pressure, and puzzles; and encourage learners to set achievable individual goals.
๐ Definition โ Intrinsic motivation: motivation that comes from within the learner rather than from external rewards.
Principle 2: Four Strands
This principle is concerned with the relative amount of time given to the four main strands of a language course: meaning-focused input, language-focused learning, meaning-focused output, and fluency development. The rough rule of thumb is that on average equal time should be given to each of these four strands in the total language experience of the learner. Time in class and out of class can be considered if the learner is gaining appropriate language activity during these times.
๐ Formula โ Four Strands Balance: Meaning-focused input (25%) + Language-focused learning (25%) + Meaning-focused output (25%) + Fluency development (25%) = Total language course time (100%)
Topic-052: Second Group of Twenty Principles: Format and Presentation (Principle 3)
Principle 3: Comprehensible input
This principle states that there should be substantial quantities of interesting comprehensible receptive activity in both listening and reading. In the Elley and Mangubhai (1981) experiment, Fijian learners who replaced part of drill-based English lessons with self-directed reading of interesting children's books made 15 months' progress on proficiency measures in just 8 months. The reading replaced about one-third of the usual course. The theoretical justification rests on the idea that learners need to build up understanding of the language system before being called on to produce language.
Requirements for this approach are that learners have access to large quantities of interesting reading or listening material at a suitable level, and that such material is not used as an excuse for heavy follow-up exercises. Teachers can build up class sets by: seeking funding from English-speaking embassies; having each learner buy one text and exchanging them; building a reading box from newspapers, learner writings, or teacher writings; or placing a book in a glass case and turning one page daily.
Topic-053: Second Group of Twenty Principles: Format and Presentation (Principle 4)
Principle 4: Fluency
Fluency is a part of the skill goal of language learning. Fluency activities do not aim to teach new language items but aim to give the learner ready access to what is already known. The importance of fluency is highlighted in first-language research on vocabulary learning and reading comprehensionโknowing meanings of new words is not sufficient; learners must also be able to retrieve these meanings quickly. Fluency is often contrasted with accuracy and is seen as a way of making consciously studied material become available for less conscious use.
Fluency activities depend on several conditions: first, the user is encouraged to process a large quantity of language; second, demands are limited to a smaller set than in uncontrolled activities; third, the learner is helped to reach a high level of performance. An example technique involves learners working in pairs: the speaker talks for four minutes on a topic, then repeats to a new partner in three minutes, then two minutes.
๐ก Why this matters: Fluency activities bridge the gap between conscious knowledge and automatic, effortless language use in real communication.
Topic-054: Second Group of Twenty Principles: Format and Presentation (Principle 5-6)
Principle 5: Output
While input is very important and should precede output, there are strong arguments for ensuring learners produce language. Swain (1985) argues that the language knowledge needed to comprehend language is not the same as that needed to produce languageโlearners must move "from a purely semantic analysis of the language to a syntactic analysis of it." For example, understanding English articles and prepositions requires minimal knowledge, but producing them requires detailed decisions.
Speaking and writing require retrieval of form and development of productive skills. Courses aiming at all four skills should ensure about 25% of total learning time is given to language production activities. It is also worthwhile checking that neither writing nor speaking is neglected, and that learners produce language in both formal and informal settings, for transactional and interactional purposes, and in a variety of social roles.
Principle 6: Deliberate Learning
Language-focused learning occurs when learners' attention is on language items because they want to learn some part of the language system. It can be directed towards the sound system, spelling, vocabulary, grammar, and discourse patterns. Research shows that language-focused learning can speed up learning, help overcome barriers, and have a positive effect on meaning-focused learning. Examples include dictation, repetition drills, memorizing dialogues, analyzing cohesive devices, learning to guess from context, sentence completion, and learning vocabulary on cards.
Most courses need to reduce the amount of language-focused learning rather than increase itโit should take up about 25% of course time. Language-focused learning is a support, not a substitute, for learning through meaning-focused activities.
Topic-055: Second Group of Twenty Principles: Format and Presentation (Principle 7-8)
Principle 7: Time on Task
This principle is based on the research finding that one of the best indicators of how much will be learned is how long learners spend on appropriate learning activities. The more time learners spend on language learning, the more they learn. Research on teacher use of the foreign language shows: teachers have inaccurate ideas of how much they use the foreign language; learners are not worried to have all lessons in the foreign language; and with training, teachers can devote all class time to the foreign language without using the first language.
Principle 8: Depth of Processing
The "levels of processing" hypothesis (Craik and Lockhart, 1972) proposes that the single most important factor in learning is the quality of mental activity at the moment of learning. Items repeated without thoughtful attention will not be learned as quickly or retained as long as those related to past experience, resulting in meaning-directed effort, or those thoughtfully analyzed. This principle can be expressed as: "the quantity of learning depends on the quality of mental activity at the moment of learning."
Topic-056: Second Group of Twenty Principles: Format and Presentation (Principle 9-10)
Principle 9: Integrative Motivation
Affective factors refer to feelings and attitudes and include motivation, language anxiety, opinions about native speakers, and attitudes towards the teacher. If learners have negative attitudes or feel personally threatened, it will make progress difficult. Among motivation factors, integrative motivation and instrumental motivation have received the most attention. Dรถrnyei (2001) suggests four principal aspects of motivational teaching practice: creating basic motivational conditions, generating initial student motivation, maintaining and promoting motivation, and encouraging positive retrospective self-evaluation.
Principle 10: Learning Style
Learners approach activities in various ways depending on personality, previous learning experience, expectations, and view of the learning task. An effectively designed language course allows for individual differences by providing choices in: group size, speed and intensity, medium (aural or written), representation of information, mental process (holistic or analytic), understanding (through doing or understanding), use of first language (translation or second language), and source of control (teacher-planned or self-access). A course should provide opportunities for learners to work to their strengths AND provide opportunity and training to try other ways of learning.
Topic-057: Third Group of Twenty Principles: Monitoring and Assessment (Principles 1-2)
Principle 1: Ongoing Needs and Environment Analysis
This principle stresses the importance of doing environment analysis and needs analysis during course planning. It emphasizes how to select and grade lexical or grammatical material. Overall, this principle analyzes how well a language program caters to various needs of learners, and touches on the element of time and resources. To monitor a program, language teachers need to ensure the time and resource element.
Principle 2: Feedback
Feedback is a term from communication theory. After a message has been sent, the sender may receive information about various aspects of the messageโwhether it said what it was supposed to say, whether it was clearly received, and whether it brought about the required response. Feedback from language use can come from the sender herself, from the people who receive the message, and from an observer of the communication process.
Topic-058: Using the List of Principles
The list of twenty principles has a much wider range of uses beyond curriculum design: it can guide the design of language teaching courses and lessons; evaluate existing courses and lessons; help teachers integrate and contextualise information from journals like TESOL Quarterly, Language Learning, Applied Linguistics or RELC Journal; provide a basis for teachers to reflect on their practice and professional development through action research; and act as a reference point in teacher training courses.
โญ Key Takeaways
For exam success, remember that motivation is best when intrinsic but can develop from extrinsic rewards; a balanced course must allocate roughly equal time to the four strands of meaning-focused input, language-focused learning, meaning-focused output, and fluency development. Comprehensible input alone is insufficientโoutput is also necessary, with Swain's argument that production requires syntactic analysis beyond mere semantic understanding. Deliberate learning should support but not replace meaning-focused activities (about 25% of course time), and time on task combined with depth of processing are strong predictors of learning outcomes. Finally, the principles serve multiple practical purposes: guiding course design, evaluating existing courses, supporting professional reflection, and providing a framework for teacher training.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between intrinsic and extrinsic motivation, and how can extrinsic motivation lead to intrinsic motivation?
- What are the four strands of a language course, and what proportion of time should each receive?
- According to Swain (1985), why is input alone insufficient for language learning, and what does the shift from "semantic to syntactic analysis" mean?
- What conditions must fluency activities meet to achieve their goal of making known language readily accessible?
- What are Dรถrnyei's four principal aspects of motivational teaching practice?
๐ Lecture 11 โ PLANNING GOALS AND LEARNING OUTCOMES -I
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the crucial dimension of decision-making in curriculum planningโdetermining the goals and outcomes of a program. It explores different ideological perspectives that shape curriculum goals, including academic rationalism, social and economic efficiency, learner centeredness, and social constructionism. Understanding these ideologies helps planners make informed judgments about what learners need to develop.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lesson begins with an introduction to planning goals and learning outcomes, covering key assumptions about goals in curriculum planning. It then examines four major curriculum ideologies: academic rationalization, which stresses intrinsic value of subject matter; social and economic efficiency, emphasizing practical needs and economic productivity; learner centeredness, focusing on addressing social injustices; and social constructionism and cultural pluralism, preparing students for multiple cultures.