π Lecture 19 β Curriculum Design and Instructional Materials -II
π Overview: This lecture explores the complex process of materials development in language programs, examining the advantages and disadvantages of creating institution-specific materials versus using commercial textbooks. It provides a comprehensive framework for understanding how to design, manage, evaluate, and adapt instructional materials to meet diverse learner needs.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the advantages and disadvantages of preparing materials for a program, the nature of materials development, key decisions in materials design, selecting exercise types, managing a material writing project, monitoring the use of materials, the role of materials in language classrooms, the usefulness of preplanned materials, effective teaching materials, adopting and adapting existing course books, using source books instead of course books, and evaluating a course book.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-121: Preparing Materials for a Program: Advantages and Disadvantages
When considering institutionally developed materials, both advantages and disadvantages must be carefully weighed. Advantages include Relevance, where materials reflect local content and institutional needs; Develop expertise, which helps staff understand effective material characteristics; Reputation, enhancing institutional image through customized resources; and Flexibility, allowing easy revision and adaptation compared to commercial course books.
Disadvantages include Cost, as quality materials require significant time, staff, and resources; Quality, since teacher-made materials typically lack the design standards of commercial products; and Training, because material writing is a specialized skill requiring workshops and balanced writing teams.
Topic-122: The Nature of Materials Development
Only a small proportion of good teachers are also good designers of course materials. Many underestimate the developmental processes involved in commercial materials. Effective materials development mirrors lesson planning: starting with a learning goal and creating activities that enable its achievement.
Good materials should arouse learners' interest, remind them of earlier learning, explain new content, relate ideas to previous learning, encourage practice, provide feedback, enable progress checking, and help learners improve. The goal is to create a learning route at an appropriate difficulty level that provides both motivation and useful practice.
Topic-123: Decisions in Materials Design
Before designing materials, the designer must consider scope, quality, and nature of the material. Two key decisions include choosing input resources and selecting exercise types. The designer must develop aims, develop objectives, develop a syllabus, organize the course into units, develop a structure for units, and sequence units. When writing begins, further decisions involve choosing input sources and selecting exercise types.
Topic-124: Selecting Exercise Types
Deciding on exercise types is one of the most difficult aspects of writing. The challenge is creating exercises that engage learners in skills and processes related to specific language teaching objectives. Reviewing current commercial textbooks is a good starting point.
Exercises that develop "top-down" listening include listening to conversation parts and inferring topics, looking at pictures and matching them with conversations, identifying settings, numbering key points in sequence while listening, reading information then checking if it was mentioned, guessing speaker responses from one side of a conversation, completing stories then listening to real endings, and guessing what news headlines refer to before listening to broadcasts.
Topic-125: Managing a Material Writing Project
Materials writing projects vary in scope. Team-based projects require addressing several management issues. Selecting the project team involves determining the number of participants and their roles. In large-scale projects, the team may include a Project Director for overall management, Writers for course components, a Media Specialist for audiovisual and software, an Editor for final version preparation, an Illustrator for art and illustrations, and a Designer for layout and format.
Topic-126: Monitoring the Use of Materials
Materials represent plans for teaching, not the teaching process itself. As teachers use materials, they adapt and transform them. Monitoring serves to document effective ways of using materials, provide feedback on how materials work, keep records of additions and deletions, and assist other teachers.
Monitoring takes several forms: Observation through classroom visits; Feedback sessions in group meetings; Written reports using reflection sheets; Reviews by teachers on their experiences; and Students' reviews commenting on their experience with materials.
Topic-127: Role of Materials in Language Classroom
Language materials play a vital role by offering pedagogical purpose to meet classroom needs. Key questions include how materials meet learners' needs and how a course book serves specific student groups. This raises concerns about incoherence in language programs when teachers create their own materials or select from various sources. Commercial materials give teachers freedom to choose what suits them, often making them more useful than published material.
Topic-128: Preplanned Materials β Usefulness
The concern that pre-prepared materials cannot meet individual learner needs is part of the dilemma in learner-centered programs. O'Neill (1982) questioned whether each group is so unique that materials cannot be shared, arguing this ignores common linguistic and learning needs among similar proficiency learners.
Negative aspects include that each group is unique, textbooks reduce teachers' role, cultural prejudices exist, some materials fail to present realistic language examples, and teachers may follow materials exclusively ignoring student needs. Positive aspects include being a source of information and support, providing suggestions for teachers, acting as an agent of change, offering convenient structuring of learning systems, and enabling collaboration among teachers.
Topic-129: Effective Teaching Materials
Materials reflect writers' views of language and learning. For materials to be a helpful scaffold, underlying principles must be explicit and open for discussion. Effective materials reflect that language is functional and must be contextualized; language development requires purposeful engagement; language should be realistic and authentic; materials should include an audiovisual component; second language learners need to handle written and spoken genres; materials should foster learner autonomy; materials must be flexible for individual differences; and learning needs to engage learners both affectively and cognitively.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these principles helps teachers evaluate whether materials truly support language acquisition rather than just covering content.
Topic-130: Adopting and Adapting an Existing Course Book
Once chosen, teachers may make substantial changes to a course book for reasons including responding to the environment, accounting for needs, or putting principles into practice. Reasons include missing activities, time constraints, unsuitable content, mismatched learner knowledge, missing language items or skills, and non-application of desired principles.
Teachers can adapt by adding or omitting content, changing sequencing, changing format, changing presentation (e.g., using a 4/3/2 fluency activity where speakers talk for four, then three, then two minutes on the same subject with different listeners), adding or omitting monitoring, and adding or omitting assessment. Adding extensive reading may reflect principles of comprehensible input, fluency, and time on task.
Topic-131: Using Source Books Instead of Course Books
Using source books instead of course books allows teachers to assemble courses from various resources. Reasons include that a single course book does not meet diverse needs; drawing from multiple sources keeps lessons close to learner needs; learners have a stronger say in topics and materials; teachers use more professional skills; circumstances make textbook selection difficult; and current course books may not reflect latest applied linguistics knowledge.
The biggest challenge is providing systematic coverage and creating a unified course rather than unrelated bits. Courses are often organized around themes. More trained and experienced teachers tend to reject single textbooks. Using computers and the internet impacts teaching through self-access centers, classroom computer-mediated activities, internet as information source, and corpora like the British National Corpus. Constraints include lack of money, no electricity, and teacher unfamiliarity. Salaberry (2001) suggests four questions about pedagogical effectiveness: Does better technology result in better teaching? Which features help? How can new technologies be used? Do they result in efficient resource use?
Topic-132: Evaluating a Course Book
Systematic course book evaluation should be based on curriculum design processes: Does the book suit the environment? Meet learner needs? Apply sensible teaching principles? Match course goals? Suit proficiency level with sensible selection and sequencing? Use effective techniques? Include tests and progress monitoring?
Teachers must decide essential features early: appropriate vocabulary and grammar level, focus on course goals, acceptable price, availability, suitable size and number of lessons, and no offensive content. The aim is to create a short list of absolutely essential features to eliminate unsuitable books quickly.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that materials development involves weighing advantages like relevance and flexibility against disadvantages like cost and quality, and that effective materials mirror good teaching by creating learning routes with motivation and practice. The process requires careful decisions about input sources, exercise types, and team management, with monitoring of materials use through observation, feedback, and reviews. Preplanned materials have both strengths and limitations, and effective materials must be functional, contextualized, realistic, authentic, flexible, and engaging. Teachers can adapt course books by adding, omitting, resequencing, or changing format and presentation, and systematic evaluation based on curriculum design principles is essential before adopting any course book.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are three advantages and three disadvantages of developing institution-specific materials for a language program?
- List at least eight things that good teaching materials should do according to the lecture.
- What are the key roles in a large-scale material writing project team, and what is each person responsible for?
- What five forms of monitoring the use of materials are discussed in the lecture?
- What are the four essential questions Salaberry (2001) suggests teachers consider about technology use in language teaching?
π Lecture 20 β Evaluating the Evaluation Forms / Approaches to Language Curriculum Design
π Overview: This lecture covers two main areas: how to critically evaluate course book evaluation forms using test-like criteria (reliability, validity, practicality), and introduces key models of curriculum design including the Language Curriculum Design diagram, Gravesβ model, and Murdochβs model. It also discusses the practical process of doing curriculum design, contrasting the "waterfall" model with real-world constraints.
ποΈ Topics Covered
Topic 133 focuses on evaluating evaluation forms by comparing Tucker (1968) and Sheldon (1988) and applying test evaluation criteria (reliability, validity, practicality). Topic 134 introduces models of curriculum including the Language Curriculum Design diagram, Gravesβ Model (2000), and Murdochβs Model (2010), comparing their components. Topic 135 discusses the process of doing curriculum design, contrasting the theoretical "waterfall" model with the practical reality of starting at any point under constraints.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-133: Evaluating the Evaluation Forms
A comparison of the evaluation forms designed by Tucker (1968) and Sheldon (1988) shows how current theories of second-language learning influence course book evaluation. An evaluation form that seemed adequate twenty or forty years ago now seems inappropriate. When examining the adequacy of an evaluation form, we can use the same criteria as we use for evaluating a test.
Three key criteria are used to judge an evaluation form:
π Definition β Reliability: Would different people using the same form on the same course book reach similar conclusions?
π Definition β Validity: Does the form cover the important features of a course book? Is the choice of features to examine in agreement with our current knowledge of curriculum design and second language learning?
π Definition β Practicality: Is it easy to understand? Is it easy to use? Can it be used to evaluate a course book in a reasonably short time? Are the results of the evaluation understandable and usable?
π‘ Why this matters: These criteria ensure that course book evaluation is objective, relevant to modern teaching theory, and efficient for classroom use.
Topic-134: Models of Curriculum
This lesson is based on a model of curriculum design which is represented by the curriculum design diagram. This diagram is intended to be easy to remember so that teachers can use it whenever they face curriculum design issues. One way to answer how adequate the model is is to compare it with other models to see where they overlap and where they don't.
Monitoring and assessment and evaluation in the Language Curriculum Design model are included in one part of the Graves Model (2000) i.e. designing an assessment plan. In her book, Graves distinguishes evaluation from assessment, but deals with both in the same chapter. Clearly, there is a great deal of similarity between the two models. When looking at other models of curriculum design, it is worth doing such a comparison to see where the similarities and differences lie.
Principles, monitoring and assessment, and evaluation are not included in Murdoch's Model (2010). These are possible weaknesses of his model. However, in his discussion of his model, it is clear that he intends that principles should be considered when dealing with several of the parts of his model. There are numerous other models of curriculum design and it is interesting to compare them to see where their strengths and weaknesses lie.
π Example (Model Comparison): The Language Curriculum Design model includes monitoring and assessment/evaluation together. Gravesβ model places them under "designing an assessment plan" but treats evaluation and assessment separately. Murdochβs model omits principles, monitoring, assessment, and evaluation as separate components, which may be a weakness.
Topic-135: Doing Curriculum Design
This book has taken the approach that curriculum design is best viewed as a process like writing where the curriculum design could begin at any of several places β needs analysis, materials writing, selection of principles, goals, etc. Some models of curriculum design see it occurring as a series of steps in a fixed order.
Tessmer and Wedman (1990) describe this fixed-order view as a "waterfall" model, where one stage of curriculum design (for example environment analysis) is done thoroughly and then the next stage of needs analysis is done thoroughly and so on. It is in the same way as the flow of water fills one container in a stepped-down series and then flows over to fill the next. If this does happen, it is probably rare. Most curriculum design occurs under constraints that make it almost impossible for a waterfall model to occur.
π Example: In many English courses the teacher does not know who the learners will be until the first day, making it impossible to start with a thorough needs or environment analysis in a fixed sequence.
β Key Takeaways
To effectively evaluate curriculum materials, you must assess evaluation forms using reliability, validity, and practicality, similar to test evaluation. The Language Curriculum Design diagram serves as a memorable framework for teachers, and comparing it with models like Gravesβ (which separates evaluation from assessment) and Murdochβs (which omits principles and assessment) reveals strengths and weaknesses. Curriculum design is a non-linear, iterative process: unlike the rigid "waterfall" model, it realistically begins at any point (e.g., materials, goals, needs) due to real-world constraints like unknown learners until the first day of class.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What three criteria are used to judge the adequacy of an evaluation form, and what does each criterion measure?
- How does the Language Curriculum Design model treat monitoring and assessment/evaluation compared to Gravesβ Model (2000)?
- What are the possible weaknesses of Murdochβs Model (2010) of curriculum design?
- Describe the "waterfall" model of curriculum design as explained by Tessmer and Wedman (1990), and why is it considered rare in practice?
- Give a real-world example of a constraint that makes the waterfall model impossible to follow when designing a curriculum.
π Lecture 21 β Curriculum Design-ENG519
π Overview: This lecture explores the practical starting points and processes involved in curriculum design for language courses. It examines three distinct approaches to developing a curriculumβthe waterfall model, focused opportunistic approach, and layers of necessity approachβand provides guidance on selecting the most appropriate path based on available time, resources, and constraints.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers starting points for curriculum design including creating materials from scratch, drawing from existing material banks, and using curriculum statements. It then examines three processes for curriculum design: the waterfall model, the focused opportunistic approach, and the layers of necessity approach. Finally, it discusses how to decide on an approach based on practical constraints and the advantage of following systematic curriculum design.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-136: Starting Points
Curriculum designers and teachers can start from nothing and gather and write the material. This most often happens because of copyright issues with courses that are likely to be published, or where there is no existing course. The curriculum designer or teacher is thus responsible for all parts of the curriculum design process.
Curriculum designers and teachers can draw on a bank of existing materials from which they select the most appropriate material for the course. Such a bank could include: (1) copies of activities prepared by themselves or other teachers for other courses or for previous deliveries of the course, (2) published supplementary materials such as graded readers, grammar activity books, conversation texts, speed reading courses and so on, (3) clippings from newspapers or magazines, recordings from the radio or TV or photocopied material from texts or course books. The curriculum designer or teacher chooses the bits and puts them together to make a course, taking most responsibility for content, sequencing and goals.
Some curriculum statements and course books deliberately provide only some of the material needed for a complete course. Curriculum statements usually provide the content and sequencing, goals, and assessment parts of the course, and leave it to the teacher to decide on the materials to use to deal with format and presentation.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these starting points helps teachers recognize the range of possibilities available to them when beginning curriculum design, from total creation to selective adaptation.
Topic-137: The Process of Curriculum Design
In most approaches the main parts of the curriculum design process described in the curriculum design model will be covered, but they may be covered at various times, at various degrees of thoroughness, in various orders, and by various people. We will look at the ways of going through the process of curriculum design β the waterfall model, the focused opportunistic approach, and the layers of necessity approach.
The waterfall model represents ideal conditions for curriculum design, where there is plenty of time, access to the intended learners, a known teaching environment and plenty of resources.
Topic-138: The Process of Curriculum Design: A Focused Opportunistic Approach
In a focused opportunistic approach, the format and presentation part of the curriculum design process is typically done first. That is, material is gathered or prepared to teach the course. Then, with each re-teaching of the course, one part of the curriculum design process is done thoroughly. Thus, it might be that a proper needs analysis is not carried out until the third or fourth re-teaching of the course. Tessmer and Richey (1997) warn against this approach, mainly from the point of view of efficiency in that working thoroughly on one aspect of curriculum design may result in wasted effort because the findings may not be able to be used in the other less-elaborated parts of the curriculum design process. The attractiveness of this model is that it allows a concentrated focus with possible high-quality improvements in a course. For example, if during one presentation of a course, assessment was focused on or there was a careful needs analysis done, then the improvements could be done well.
If the time and resources available are very limited, the curriculum designer might choose the least detailed layer. This layer would involve all the following steps:
- Decide on the most severe environmental constraint on the course and how it will affect the curriculum design.
- Decide on the most urgent necessity that learners have to meet at the end of the course.
- Make a short list of items to cover.
- Decide on a simple lesson format that will make use of available material.
- Gather the material for the course.
- Decide on a simple form of assessment.
π Definition β Focused Opportunistic Approach: An approach where material is gathered or prepared first, then with each re-teaching of the course, one part of the curriculum design process is done thoroughly.
π Definition β Layers of Necessity Approach: When time and resources are very limited, the curriculum designer chooses the least detailed layer, involving only the most essential steps for course delivery.
Topic-139: Deciding on an Approach
Choosing which path to take will depend on the starting point, the time available for course preparation, the availability of needs analysis information, the availability of a usable course book, and the skill of the curriculum designer. We will assume that time is short and that only a small amount of needs analysis information is available.
Clearly, the least demanding approach is to choose an existing course book as a source of material and then apply a focused opportunistic approach to gradually improve and eventually replace it.
Whatever approach is chosen, the advantage of following a systematic approach to curriculum design involving all the parts of a model is that parts of the process are not missed out. Poor curriculum design misses important parts and does not deal with parts in a principled way.
π‘ Why this matters: The choice of approach has practical consequences for the quality and completeness of the resulting curriculum, and systematic design prevents important elements from being overlooked.
β Key Takeaways
There are three main starting points for curriculum design: creating materials from scratch (due to copyright or lack of existing courses), drawing from a bank of existing materials (teacher-created or published), and using curriculum statements that provide content and sequencing but leave materials to the teacher. Three process models exist: the waterfall model (ideal conditions with ample time and resources), the focused opportunistic approach (material first, then gradual improvement with each re-teaching), and the layers of necessity approach (minimal steps when resources are very limited). The focused opportunistic approach is attractive for allowing concentrated focus and high-quality improvements, but Tessmer and Richey warn it may result in wasted effort since findings from one component may not transfer to others. The choice of approach depends on practical factors including starting point, time, needs analysis availability, course book availability, and curriculum designer skill. Regardless of approach chosen, following a systematic model ensures all parts of the curriculum design process are addressed in a principled way.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main starting points for curriculum design discussed in this lecture?
- What is the focused opportunistic approach and what is its main advantage and disadvantage according to Tessmer and Richey?
- What steps are involved in the least detailed layer approach when time and resources are very limited?
- What factors determine which curriculum design approach should be chosen?
- What is the key advantage of following a systematic approach to curriculum design involving all parts of the model?