π Lecture 8 β Locating Primary Research
π Overview: This lecture introduces students to the methods and tools for locating primary research in academic databases. It distinguishes primary research from position papers, explains the importance of refereed and blind-reviewed sources, and provides practical strategies for using databases like ERIC, JSTOR, and Google Scholar to find credible research studies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers exploring databases for primary research, examples of popular databases like ERIC and JSTOR, the distinction between position papers and primary research, how to use tables of references and bibliographies to locate studies, and the key differences between primary and secondary sources including refereed and blind review processes.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-034: (LPR) Locating Primary Research: Exploring Databases
Experts prepare sources to find research. Preliminary sources that experts prepare are found in bound copies in libraries. Furthermore, databases like educational index, MLA/APA, ERIC/RIE, CIJE/LLBA/EI, and SSI (Social Science Index) are also available to find research.
Databases organize topics by a set of keywords and have a focus of studies. They are all available on CDs/Databases, Academic Search Premier, PsychInfo, Sociological Abstracts, JSTOR (1800s), and www.eric.ed.gov.
π‘ Why this matters: Knowing which databases to search and how they are organized by keywords is essential for efficient and effective literature searching in academic research.
Topic-035: LPR II: Examples
Use the following options for locating primary research: β’ ERIC β’ www.eric.ed.gov β’ JSTOR β’ Google Scholar
These are key digital repositories and search engines that provide access to millions of academic articles, conference papers, and research reports.
Topic-036: LPR: Position Papers vs Primary Research
A position paper is a written report outlining someone's attitude or intentions regarding a particular matter. It is similar to a literature review. Writers argue their positions on various issues. Primary research is not included. It is used for proposing answers to research questions. It helps in generating hypothesis.
Key warnings about position papers: β’ Avoid the trap of circular reasoning β’ Generating hypothesis is okay β’ Supporting and justifying is NOT β’ Position papers cannot be a substitute for a literature review. They contain: β’ Witnessing of your own eyes β’ Focused summaries
π Definition β Position Paper: A written report outlining someone's attitude or intentions regarding a particular matter, similar to a literature review, that does not include primary research.
π Example: A student writes a paper arguing that online learning is more effective than traditional learning, using only summaries of other researchers' opinions and existing literature, without conducting any original experiments or surveys. This is a position paper.
Topic-037: LPR: Tables of References and Bibliographies
To locate primary research, one should follow the following studies: β’ Profitable places to find research studies β’ Benchmark studies β’ Studies with sparking interest of the area β’ Particular issues β’ Directional change regarding the area β’ Use Seminal studies β’ Use Tactics: β’ Identify the frequency of citation β’ Important in the history of the area β’ Area of investigation β’ Go to Google Scholar
π‘ Why this matters: Using tables of references and bibliographies from known studies is a powerful "snowball" method to find additional primary research in your area of interest.
Topic-038: LPR: Difference Between Primary & Secondary Sources
Primary vs secondary sources β’ Primary research is the only way to find answers β’ Not all primary research is equally important β’ TWO criteria: β’ Refereed (pass a matter to (a higher body) for a decision) β’ Blind review (This means that the reviewers of the paper won't get to know the identity of the author(s), and the author(s) won't get to know the identity of the reviewer.)
Distinguishing primary research from position papers Primary research and position papers are different in the following aspects: β’ From title β’ Terms and techniques β’ Must be known to active researchers
π Definition β Refereed: A process where a research paper is passed to a higher body (experts) for a decision on publication. π Definition β Blind Review: A review process where the reviewers of the paper do not know the identity of the author(s), and the author(s) do not know the identity of the reviewer.
β Key Takeaways
Students must remember that primary research is the only way to find definitive answers in research, and it must be distinguished from position papers which lack original data. The most credible primary research comes from refereed and blind-reviewed sources found in databases like ERIC, JSTOR, and Google Scholar. Using bibliographies and seminal studies is a key tactic for locating additional research. Knowing the difference between primary and secondary sources, and being able to identify position papers by their title and lack of original research techniques, is critical for academic rigor.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two criteria that determine if primary research is equally important?
- Name at least three databases mentioned for locating primary research.
- What is a position paper, and why can it not substitute for a literature review?
- Explain the difference between a refereed review and a blind review.
- What tactics should a researcher use to locate primary research from tables of references and bibliographies?
Here is the summary for Lecture 9, formatted exactly as requested.
π Lecture 9 β Exploring Primary Research in ELT
π Overview: This lecture provides a practical guide for students on how to locate and access research articles in the field of English Language Teaching (ELT). It outlines various sources for obtaining these articles, identifies key professional organizations and their associated journals, and provides specific examples of relevant journals at both international and national levels. This foundational knowledge is crucial for conducting a literature review and engaging with ongoing scholarly conversations in ELT research.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers three main topics: first, the various sources from which ELT research articles can be obtained, including libraries and digital databases; second, a list of major professional organizations and journals related to Applied Linguistics and ELT research; and third, a more detailed exploration of specific international and Pakistani journals, along with a pointer to the course textbook's appendix for further resources.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-039: Obtaining ELT Related Research Articles
Research articles can be obtained from a variety of sources. The most traditional source is a university library, which may also offer interlibrary loans to access materials not held in their own collection. For a fee, dedicated databases can be used to search for articles. In the Pakistani context, the HEC digital library is a key resource. Globally, JSTOR and Google Scholar are invaluable, as are TESOL specific resources.
Topic-040: Journals Related to ELT Research
The field of Applied Linguistics (ELT) has a wealth of research journals. Many of these are associated with major professional organizations. Key journals and organizations to consult include:
- TESOL (Teachers of English to Speakers of Other Languages)
- AAAL (American Association for Applied Linguistics)
- IATEFL (International Association of Teachers of English as a Foreign Language)
- AERA (American Educational Research Association)
- ESP Journal (English for Specific Purposes)
Topic-041: Exploring ELT Research Journals
This topic provides a categorized list of specific journals to explore. It recommends looking into journals from major organizations like TESOL, AAAL, IATEFL, and AERA, as well as specific journals like the ESP journal. It also highlights the importance of consulting Pakistani journals for local research. Finally, students are directed to Appendix C of your course book for a more comprehensive, specific list of journals.
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember the primary channels for obtaining ELT research, including physical libraries, digital databases like the HEC library and Google Scholar, and specific society resources. The major professional organizationsβTESOL, AAAL, IATEFL, and AERAβare the cornerstones of the field and their journals are essential reading. A student should be able to name these key journals and understand the importance of consulting both international publications and local Pakistani journals for a well-rounded perspective. Finally, always check the course textbook's appendix for a curated list of resources.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Name three different sources from which you can obtain ELT-related research articles.
- What is the significance of the HEC digital library for a Pakistani student?
- List the four major professional organizations mentioned in the lecture that are associated with ELT research journals.
- Besides international journals, what other category of journals is specifically recommended for exploration in this lecture?
- Where in your course book can you find a more specific list of journals to consult?
π Lecture 10 β Understanding Where Data Come From?
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of sampling in research methodology, explaining where data originates and how researchers select participants or objects for study. It covers key terminology, two major sampling paradigms, and the ethical considerations involved in sampling human participants, forming the foundation for designing rigorous research studies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers sampling terminology including population and sample definitions with examples. It then presents two sampling paradigms: the information-rich paradigm used in qualitative research and the representative sampling paradigm used for generalization. Finally, it addresses ethics in sampling of human participants, including protection of rights and informed consent procedures.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-042: Sampling Terminology
Population is the entire mass of observations (the universe). All members of a group or objects are generalized as population. It is impossible to access all the population. Sample is the data drawn to test hypothesis. A sample can be a subject, informant, or participant, or one or more cases like case or inanimate objects (corpora or newspapers).
Examples of samples include Su (2001) using 122 Chinese/English native speakers, and Borg (1998) using one teacher. The sample is where data come from β it is the data source to answer research questions. A sample contains the characteristics of a specific group, and various attributes and features are studied through the sample.
π Definition β Population: The entire mass of observations or all members of a group that is the focus of study. π Definition β Sample: Data drawn from a population to test a hypothesis; the actual data source to answer research questions.
Topic-043: Sampling Paradigms
There are two sampling paradigms, depending upon the nature and purpose of the study:
- Information rich paradigm
- Representative sampling paradigm
The information rich paradigm aims to uncover information and requires in-depth analysis. It is mainly used in qualitative research and focuses on views and feelings with a holistic small sample size. It is less generalizable.
The representative sampling paradigm serves as a replica of a larger group. It aims to be generalizable and uses large samples such as questionnaires.
π Definition β Information rich paradigm: A sampling approach that prioritizes depth of information from small samples, common in qualitative research, and less focused on generalization. π Definition β Representative sampling paradigm: A sampling approach that aims to replicate a larger population through large samples, enabling generalization of findings.
π‘ Why this matters: Choosing between these paradigms determines whether your study can generalize findings or instead provides deep, contextual understanding β a fundamental decision in research design.
Topic-044: The Information-Rich Paradigm
Qualitative sampling involves:
- Maximizing information
- Small sample size ranging from 1 to large
- Emphasis on the quality of information
- NOT generalizing
The example given is Borg (1998) who took one teacher as a sample.
Two guidelines are provided:
- Very good example of small sample: Borg (1998) took one teacher
- Examples of large samples: Guardado (2002) studied six families, specifically Spanish children in Canada
π Example: Borg (1998) used a sample of one teacher to conduct in-depth qualitative research. Guardado (2002) used a larger qualitative sample of six families of Spanish children in Canada, still within the information-rich paradigm.
Topic-045: Representative Sampling Paradigm
The sample serves as a true representative of the population. The goal of sampling is to generalize the findings, as access to the whole population is impossible.
For example, "EFL learners of English as students of English medium universities" β in this case, it is impossible to take the whole population to study larger populations. The rule is: the more sample size, the better it would be. The sample should highlight the important features, and the attributes of the population must be found in the selected samples.
π Rule: The larger the sample size, the better the representativeness β Larger samples more accurately reflect population attributes.
π Example: Studying "EFL learners of English as students of English medium universities" requires selecting a sample that represents the attributes of this entire population.
Topic-046: Ethics in Sampling of Human Participants
Several ethical issues relate to human participants. Protection of the rights and privacy of human beings is a matter of serious concern in research. The US Commission in 1974 and the Belmont Report 1979 devised ethics for taking humans as samples. Some organizations work for the regulation of human participants' protection.
Researchers should know the rights and exemptions before sampling. These issues can be avoided through:
- Reading and discussing ethical guidelines
- Taking informed consent with study staff
- Answering any questions from participants
- Ensuring voluntary participation
- Collecting all sorts of information
- Providing information about the study's procedures, risks, and benefits
There can be exemptions in some cases, such as educational/public behaviour or public benefit/service.
π Definition β Informed consent: The process of obtaining voluntary agreement from participants after they have been fully informed about study procedures, risks, and benefits. π Definition β Belmont Report (1979): A foundational document that established ethical principles for research involving human participants.
β Key Takeaways
Sampling is the fundamental process of selecting data sources from a larger population because accessing the entire population is impossible. The two main paradigms β information-rich for qualitative depth and representative for generalization β determine sample size, research approach, and the nature of findings. In qualitative research, small samples maximize information quality without aiming for generalization, as demonstrated by Borg (1998) studying one teacher. In quantitative research, larger samples better represent population attributes for generalization. Ethical sampling of human participants requires informed consent, voluntary participation, and protection of rights as established by the Belmont Report (1979), with some exemptions for educational or public behaviour.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a population and a sample in research?
- Name the two sampling paradigms and explain when each is appropriate.
- Why is the information-rich paradigm less concerned with generalization than the representative sampling paradigm?
- What is the "rule of thumb" for sample size in the representative sampling paradigm?
- What are the key ethical requirements when sampling human participants, according to the Belmont Report?
π Lecture 11 β Research Planning and Sampling
π Overview: This lecture introduces the crucial steps in research planning and the fundamental concept of sampling in social studies research. It explains why sampling is an indispensable technique, details the two main categories of sampling techniques (probability and non-probability), and outlines the components of sampling designs and the characteristics of a good sample.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing research planning and sampling as a crucial step in social studies research, covering components like devising objectives and selecting strategies. It then defines sampling as a portion of a larger population, explains its importance for research feasibility and accuracy, and details two major categories of sampling techniques: probability sampling (including simple random, stratified, systematic, cluster, and multi-stage) and non-probability sampling (including convenience, purposive, quota, and referral/snowball). Finally, it covers the elements of a sampling design (sampling method and estimator) and lists the key characteristics of a good sample.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-047: Research Planning and Sampling
Research planning and sampling are crucial steps in social studies research. The sampling procedure consists of making choices while answering research questions. Researchers must select mandatory design components. Firstly, to select a population, secondly, go for true sampling and then choose suitable techniques and procedures. Design components are based on class of enquiry and the model to be utilized.
The components and steps involved in research planning include:
- Devise research objectives and sampling
- Research strategy + tools and techniques
- Analyzing data
- Reporting the results
- Selecting qualitative & quantitative procedures
- Selecting a valid and reliable research design
Topic-048: Meaning and Definition of Sampling
Sampling is an indispensable technique in research. It refers to a portion of a larger population. Research is impossible without sampling, as selecting a total population is impossible to be selected due to limitations of time, energy, and money. A research design is based on sampling, which is both economical and accurate. Sampling is fundamental to all statistical methods. A sample should contain maximum information about the population, and the generalizability of research data is drawn from it.
Topic-049: Sampling Techniques
There are a lot of sampling techniques which are grouped into two categories:
Probability Sampling This sampling technique uses randomization to make sure that every element of the population gets an equal chance to be part of the selected sample. It is alternatively known as random sampling. Types include:
- Simple Random Sampling
- Stratified sampling
- Systematic sampling
- Cluster Sampling
- Multi stage Sampling
Non-Probability Sampling This technique does not rely on randomization. It is more reliant on the researcherβs ability to select elements for a sample. The outcome of sampling might be biased and makes it difficult for all elements of the population to be part of the sample equally. This type of sampling is also known as non-random sampling. Types include:
- Convenience Sampling
- Purposive Sampling
- Quota Sampling
- Referral / Snowball Sampling
π‘ Why this matters: The choice between probability and non-probability sampling determines the objectivity of the sample and the ability to generalize findings to the larger population.
Topic-050: Sampling Designs
A sample design is made up of two elements.
Sampling method refers to the rules and procedures by which some elements of the population are included in the sample. Some common sampling methods are simple random sampling, stratified sampling, and cluster sampling.
Estimator: The estimation process for calculating sample statistics is called the estimator. Different sampling methods may use different estimators. For example, the formula for computing a mean score with a simple random sample is different from the formula for computing a mean score with a stratified sample. Similarly, the formula for the standard error may vary from one sampling method to the next.
The "best" sample design depends on survey objectives and on survey resources. For example, a researcher might select the most economical design that provides a desired level of precision. Or, if the budget is limited, a researcher might choose the design that provides the greatest precision without going over budget.
π Definition β Sample Design: A sample design is made up of two elements: the sampling method (rules for selecting elements) and the estimator (process for calculating sample statistics). π Formula: Estimator β The formula for calculating a mean or standard error varies depending on the sampling method used (e.g., simple random vs. stratified).
Topic-051: Characteristics of Good Sampling
A sample should be a true representative of the population.
Characteristics of a good sample:
- Free from bias
- Objective
- Maintains accuracy
- Comprehensive in nature
- Economical
- Approachable
- Appropriate sample size
- Makes work more feasible
- Practicability
- Having maximum possible features and attributes of the population
- Free from errors
β Key Takeaways
Research planning and sampling are foundational to valid social studies research. Sampling is an indispensable technique because it is impossible to study an entire population due to limitations of time, energy, and money; a good sample must be a true representative of the population, free from bias, objective, accurate, and economical. The two main categories of sampling techniques are probability sampling (using randomization for equal chance of selection) and non-probability sampling (reliant on researcherβs judgment, which may introduce bias). A sample design consists of two elements: the sampling method (rules for selection) and the estimator (formula for calculating statistics), and the best design balances precision with available resources.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main categories of sampling techniques, and what is the primary difference between them?
- List the four types of non-probability sampling mentioned in the lecture.
- What are the two elements that make up a sample design?
- Why is sampling considered an indispensable technique in research?
- State five key characteristics that define a good sample.
π Lecture 12 β Avoiding Errors in Sampling
π Overview: This lecture addresses the critical issue of sampling errors in research and how to avoid them. It emphasizes that a sample is not always a perfect representation of the population and discusses two main types of errors: random and systematic. The lecture also explores the importance of sample size, and deeply examines internal and external validity as key concepts for ensuring the credibility and generalizability of research findings.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the fundamental errors that can occur in sampling, including random and systematic errors. It details the importance of sample size as a crucial factor in avoiding these errors. The concept of internal validity is explored, focusing on how well an experiment avoids confounding variables and ensures that observed effects are due to the independent variable. Finally, external validity is discussed, which concerns the generalizability of research findings to other settings and populations.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-052: Avoiding Errors in Sampling
A sample is not necessarily always a true representative of the population. There can be errors that occur in sampling, which are classified into two primary types: random error and systematic error.
Errors in research can also be categorized in four ways: random-constant and sampling-measurement. These errors can be avoided through a solid sampling design, using a large sample, and making multiple contacts with the sample.
π Definition β Random Error: An error that occurs due to chance and is unpredictable, often leading to less precision in estimates. π Definition β Systematic Error: An error that is not due to chance and consistently affects measurements in a particular direction, leading to bias. π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the difference between random and systematic errors is vital because each requires a different strategy to minimize. Random error is reduced by increasing sample size, while systematic error requires careful research design and instrument calibration.
Topic-053: Avoiding Errors: Size of Sample
The sample size is a crucial problem in avoiding sampling errors. By carefully choosing the sample size, a researcher can avoid many sampling errors. The required sample size depends upon the total number of subjects/participants present and the desired precision of the research. Before selecting the sample size, we estimate the population parameter, but there is no single rule for this. The researcher should try to reach as large a sample as possible.
For example, ( n = 30 ) in each group of the population is a common guideline. The larger the sample, the smaller the standard error would be. A sample should ideally cover 10 to 20% of the population. In descriptive research, larger size samples are typically taken. In pure experimental studies, different groups of equal sizes are preferred as sample units.
π Concept: Standard Error β The standard deviation of a sampling distribution; it decreases as the sample size increases. π Example: A researcher wants to study the average height of students in a university with 10,000 students. To minimize error, they should aim for a sample size of 10-20% (1,000 to 2,000 students). Using a sample of only 30 students would lead to a large standard error and less reliable results.
Topic-054: Internal Validity
Internal validity refers to how well an experiment is done, especially whether it avoids confounding (more than one possible independent variable acting at the same time). The less chance for confounding in a study, the higher its internal validity.
Therefore, internal validity refers to how well a piece of research allows you to choose among alternate explanations of something. A research study with high internal validity lets you choose one explanation over another with a lot of confidence, because it avoids many possible confounds. There are two types of validity. Validity determines how sound your research design is. Internal validity is critically important. It is concerned with the effects observed in the dependent variables being only due to independent variables. It also defines the causal relationship between independent variables and dependent variables.
Extraneous variables affect internal validity because if they are not controlled, the study has lower internal validity. It is very difficult or impossible to replicate extraneous variables, and the reliability of findings cannot be checked.
π Definition β Internal Validity: The extent to which a study's results can be attributed to the manipulation of the independent variable, not to other confounding factors. π Definition β Confounding: A situation where the effects of two or more variables are mixed, making it impossible to determine which variable caused the observed effect.
Credibility of sampling in Qualitative research methods faces several challenges:
- Hard to avoid selection biasness
- Maturation is required
- Sample size matters
- Careful instrumentation
- Confounding
- Testing method
- History
- Attrition (loss of participants over time)
π Example: A study tests a new teaching method. If the group using the new method also has a better teacher (an extraneous variable), it is impossible to know if improved test scores are due to the method or the teacher. This is a threat to internal validity.
Topic-055: External Validity
External validity refers to how well data and theories from one setting apply to another. This question is usually asked about laboratory research: Does it apply in the everyday "real" world outside the lab?
External validity determines the degree of generalizability. Can the findings of the study be generalized to the whole population? External and internal validity are not limited to each other. It depends upon the transferability to a situation.
Threats to external validity include:
- Participant characteristics should be studied keenly. Is the sample a true representative? Does the sample have all the characteristics of the population?
- Factors relating to the setting of the study. Does it relate to the real world?
- The timing of the study. Is it realistic?
π Definition β External Validity: The extent to which the results of a study can be generalized to or across other populations, settings, and times. π‘ Why this matters: A study with high internal validity but low external validity may produce accurate findings that are only applicable to a very specific, artificial situation, limiting its real-world usefulness.
π Example: A psychological experiment on memory is conducted with university students in a quiet, controlled lab (high internal validity). However, the results may not apply to elderly people or to real-world environments with distractions (low external validity).
β Key Takeaways
A student must remember that a sample can be unrepresentative due to random or systematic errors, which can be mitigated by a large and well-designed sample. The concept of validity is split into two critical types: internal validity, which concerns the accuracy of causal claims within a study and is threatened by confounding extraneous variables; and external validity, which concerns the generalizability of findings to other populations, settings, and times. It is essential to understand that a study can have high internal validity but low external validity, and vice versa. Finally, factors like participant characteristics, study setting, and timing are major threats to external validity that must be carefully considered.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main types of errors that can occur in sampling?
- Why is sample size a crucial factor in avoiding sampling errors, and what is a general guideline for its selection?
- Define internal validity and explain how extraneous variables threaten it.
- Define external validity and list at least three key threats to it.
- Can a study have high internal validity but low external validity? Provide a brief example to explain your answer.
π Lecture 13 β Classifying Research Designs
π Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational framework for classifying research designs in academic studies. It explains that research design is the overall blueprint of a study and presents three key continua β basic-applied, qualitative-quantitative, and exploratory-confirmatory β that help researchers systematically categorize and select the most appropriate design for their research questions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the concept of research design as an overall plan, the three continua for classifying research designs (basic-applied, qualitative-quantitative, and exploratory-confirmatory), detailed explanations of basic versus applied research with a comparison chart, the qualitative-quantitative continuum including their data collection methods and characteristics, and the exploratory-confirmatory continuum defining their purposes. The step-wise study framework from problems to research designs is also presented.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-058: Classifying Research Designs
Research design is the blue print of your study, and there can be more than one possibility in selecting research design for the study. The step wise study framework is given below: Problems (Variables) β Research Questions β Population β Sample β Research Designs
You have to choose a specific type of research design that can be selected from the following categories: β’ Basic-Applied β’ Qualitative β Quantitative β’ Exploratory β Confirmatory
Characteristics of a Research Design β’ Research design must be the plan that can guide the strongest plan for your research. β’ Research design should be the most efficient structure to provide data for your study. β’ Research designs must be the most useful plan to answer research questions. β’ A poor research design is a house full of problems. β’ Mapping strategy through critical planning can help for a systematic research process.
Topic-059: CRD: Three Continua
The three continua for classifying research designs are: β’ Basic β Applied β’ Qualitative β Quantitative β’ Exploratory β Confirmatory
These continua represent different dimensions along which research can be positioned. They provide a systematic framework for categorizing any given study.
Topic-060: CRD: Three Continua
Classifying research designs: the basic-applied continuum
Basic Research β otherwise called pure or fundamental research β is one that focuses on advancing scientific knowledge for the complete understanding of a topic or certain natural phenomenon, primarily in natural sciences. In a nutshell, when knowledge is acquired for the sake of knowledge it is called basic research.
Basic Research is completely theoretical, focusing on basic principles and testing theories. It tends to understand the basic law. Basic Research deals with generalization and formulation of theory about human behaviour. It is aligned towards collecting information that has universal applicability. Therefore, basic research helps in adding new knowledge to the already existing knowledge.
Characteristics of Basic Research: o Highly theoretical o Hypothetical o No immediate value o Broader studies
Applied Research can be defined as research that encompasses real life application of the natural science. It is directed towards providing a solution to specific practical problems and develop innovative technology. In finer terms, it is the research that can be applied to real-life situations. It studies a particular set of circumstances, so as to relate the results to its corresponding circumstances.
Applied research includes research that focuses on certain conclusions experiencing a business problem. Moreover, research that is aligned towards ascertaining social, economic or political trends are also termed as applied research.
Characteristics of Applied Research: o Action research o Solving problems o Very practical
Comparison Chart:
| Basis for Comparison | Basic Research | Applied Research |
|---|---|---|
| Meaning | Study aimed at expanding the existing base of scientific knowledge | Research designed to solve specific practical problems or answer certain questions |
| Nature | Theoretical | Practical |
| Utility | Universal | Limited |
| Concerned with | Developing scientific knowledge and predictions | Development of technology and technique |
| Goal | To add some knowledge to the existing one | To find out solution for the problem at hand |
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding where your research falls on the basic-applied continuum defines the purpose, scope, and expected outcomes of your study. Basic research builds foundational knowledge, while applied research solves immediate real-world problems.
Topic-061: CRD: The Qualitative - Quantitative Continuum
The qualitative - quantitative continuum is the center of focus (last 30 years). They were two schools of thoughts initially depending upon different data collection procedures. Quantitative and qualitative are two ends of a continuum having separate designs and methodologies.
Quantitative data collection
Quantitative research is a form of research that relies on the methods of natural sciences, which produces numerical data and hard facts. It aims at establishing cause and effect relationship between two variables by using mathematical, computational and statistical methods. The research is also known as empirical research as it can be accurately and precisely measured.
Characteristics of Quantitative Research: β’ Psychology β’ Statistics (generalize) β’ To larger populations β’ Large scale researches
Qualitative data collection
Qualitative research is used to gain an in-depth understanding of human behaviour, experience, attitudes, intentions, and motivations, on the basis of observation and interpretation, to find out the way people think and feel. It is a form of research in which the researcher gives more weight to the views of the participants. Case study, grounded theory, ethnography, historical and phenomenology are the types of qualitative research.
Characteristics of Qualitative Research: β’ Anthropological β Sociological research β’ Verbal description β’ Uncover information-rich β’ Natural setting β’ Concentrated contact β’ Patterns-comparisons-contrast
π‘ Why this matters: The choice between qualitative and quantitative approaches determines your entire data collection strategy β whether you seek numerical patterns from large samples or deep understanding from small, information-rich cases.
Topic-062: CRD: The Exploratory - Confirmatory Continuum
Confirmatory Research: Confirmatory research is where researchers have a pretty good idea of what's going on. That is, the researcher has a theory (or several theories), and the objective is to find out if the theory is supported by the facts. β’ Confirming something β’ Whether the study is going to find evidence β’ Supporting a hypothesis β’ To confirm
Exploratory Research: An exploratory design is conducted about a research problem when there are few or no earlier studies to refer to or rely upon to predict an outcome. The focus is on gaining insights and familiarity for later investigation or undertaken when research problems are in a preliminary stage of investigation. Exploratory designs are often used to establish an understanding of how best to proceed in studying an issue or what methodology would effectively apply to gathering information about the issue.
Characteristics of Exploratory Research: β’ Exploring a phenomenon β’ Prior to developing a Ho (null hypothesis) β’ Doesnβt test a hypothesis β’ What is happening?
π‘ Why this matters: This continuum determines whether you are testing an existing theory (confirmatory) or generating initial understanding when little is known (exploratory). The exploratory stage often precedes confirmatory testing.
β Key Takeaways
The single most important idea is that research designs are classified along three independent continua: basic-applied, qualitative-quantitative, and exploratory-confirmatory, and every study can be positioned on each continuum. Basic research builds theoretical knowledge with no immediate application, while applied research solves practical problems; quantitative research relies on numerical data and statistics for generalization, while qualitative research provides deep verbal descriptions in natural settings; confirmatory research tests existing hypotheses, while exploratory research investigates new phenomena with no prior theory. The step-wise framework β Problems β Research Questions β Population β Sample β Research Designs β must guide systematic planning, and a poor design leads to a flawed study. Understanding these classifications allows researchers to select the most appropriate and efficient design to answer their specific research questions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three continua used to classify research designs according to this lecture?
- How does basic research differ from applied research in terms of nature, utility, and goal?
- List two characteristics of quantitative research and two characteristics of qualitative research.
- What is the key difference between exploratory research and confirmatory research?
- According to the step-wise study framework presented, what must come immediately before "Research Designs" in the planning process?
π Lecture 14 β Questions and Research Designs
π Overview: This lecture explains how research questions determine research design. It distinguishes between βWhat questionsβ (descriptive, exploratory) and βWhy questionsβ (causal, explanatory), showing how each type of question leads to different methodological choices in quantitative, qualitative, basic, and applied research.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the basic relationship between questions and research designs, detailed characteristics of βWhat questionsβ and examples of studies that use them, then moves to βWhy questionsβ that explore causation, with examples of causal-comparative, experimental, and quasi-experimental designs applied in language research.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-063: Questions and Research Designs
Research questions are the basic determining points for research designs. You must understand your research designs in the light of your research questions. The process involves gathering, analyzing, and concluding data.
Two generic questions are asked in the process:
- What?
- Why?
Examples of βWhat questionsβ include:
- What phenomena are important?
- What simple relationships exist between phenomena?
Examples of βWhy questionsβ include:
- Why do some people learn languages better than others?
- Why do certain variables relate with one another?
π‘ Why this matters: The type of question you ask determines whether your research will be exploratory or confirmatory, and whether you will use quantitative or qualitative methods.
Topic-064: Q&D: The WHAT Questions
Characteristics of βWhat questionsβ:
- Explain phenomenon
- Describe nature
- Description of philosophy
- State function(s)
- For example:
- What is important about it?
- What relationship exists?
- What is phonological memory?
- What is influence of bilingualism?
Key features include: information not known previously, no hypothesis to confirm, and studies mainly based on what questions are primarily exploratory. They could be both quantitative and qualitative or basic and applied.
Topic-065: Q&D: The WHAT Questions (Examples)
Example 1: What phenomena are important?
- About personal experiences of ethnic and language of pre-service teachers
- Can be studied through: Qualitative, Exploratory, Applied research designs
Example 2: What simple relationships exist between phenomena?
- The relationship among previous knowledge, topic interest and L2 reading (Carrel & Wise, 1998)
- Can be studied through: Quantitative, Exploratory, Applied research designs
Example 3: Influence of bilingualism on learning a third language (Sanz, 2000)
- Can be studied through: Quantitative, Exploratory, Basic research designs
Topic-066: Q&D: The WHY Questions
After WHAT (Phenomenon + Relation) between variables, βWhy questionsβ are asked. Why questions show causation. They involve discovering why independent variable affects dependent variable (at least one).
Used in:
- Causal studies
- Relationships and correlations
- Causal comparative studies
- Experimental and quasi experimental designs
- Exploratory β Confirmatory
- Could be both quantitative and qualitative
- Basic and applied
Topic-067: Q&D: The WHY Questions (Examples)
Why Qs and their examples:
- Why some variables influence others?
- Why simple relationships exist between phenomena?
For example: Kobayashi (2002) studied:
- Method Effects on Reading Comprehension Test Performance: Text Organization and Response Format
- Shows causation (one or more relationships)
Other terms used: impact, influence, improve, change, role of:
- Qualitative - quantitative
- Exploratory - confirmatory
- Applied - basic
Causal Qualitative Studies example: (Wesche & Paribakht, 2000) asked Why a particular enhanced reading method works better than reading only for learning vocab? β This is a qualitative-exploratory-applied study.
Causal-Comparative Designs examine effect, impact, influence.
Experimental and Quasi-Experimental Designs are used to establish causation.
β Key Takeaways
The single most critical thing to remember is that research questions drive research design: βWhat questionsβ are exploratory, describe phenomena, and do not require hypotheses, while βWhy questionsβ seek causation and require causal, comparative, experimental, or quasi-experimental designs. βWhat questionsβ can be answered by both quantitative and qualitative exploratory studies (basic or applied), whereas βWhy questionsβ explicitly test cause-effect relationships using independent and dependent variables. The examples provided (Carrel & Wise, 1998; Sanz, 2000; Kobayashi, 2002; Wesche & Paribakht, 2000) illustrate how each question type maps onto specific methodological choices.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two generic types of research questions, and what does each type aim to discover?
- What is the main methodological difference between studies based on βWhat questionsβ versus βWhy questionsβ regarding hypothesis formation?
- Name two research designs suitable for answering βWhat questionsβ and two suitable for answering βWhy questions.β
- According to the lecture, what terms (besides causation) are used to describe the effect studied in βWhy questionsβ?
- Why would a study on the influence of bilingualism on learning a third language (Sanz, 2000) be classified as exploratory and basic, rather than confirmatory and applied?