π Lecture 20 β WRITING DISCUSSION OF YOUR RESEARCH
π Overview: This lecture focuses on how to write the discussion and conclusion sections of a research paper. It explains the main goals, key ingredients, and effective writing approaches, emphasizing how to interpret findings, relate them to previous studies, and defend their significance.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the main goals and writing approaches for the discussion section, the essential ingredients for writing effective discussion and conclusion sections, how to summarize key points by checking logical consistency, and the difference between discussion and conclusion with strategies for making the discussion very effective.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-092: Discussion: main goals and writing approaches
The format of the discussion and conclusion sections varies across different journals and disciplines. This is often the most read part of a research study because it interprets findings and suggests practical applications. The writer must check for valid interpretation of the results. A good discussion should provide an overview of the study, an overview of the findings, and the relation of the findings with previous studies.
Topic-093: Discussion: what is important?
The key ingredients for the discussion and conclusion include: an overview of the study; an overview of the findings; the relation of findings to previous studies; attention to limitations; possible applications of the research; and future possibilities for research.
Topic-094: Discussion and conclusion: summarizing your key points
When summarizing key points, you must ask several critical questions. Do the findings logically answer the research questions or support the research hypothesis? Does the nature of the study remain consistent from beginning to end? Are the findings generalized to the correct population or situations? Are the conclusions consistent with the type of research design used? Are the findings and conclusions related to theory or previous research? Are any limitations of the study made clear? Is there consistency between the findings and the applications?
Topic-095: Discussion and conclusion: defending your answers and their significance
It is crucial to understand the difference between a discussion and a conclusion before drafting your manuscript. The discussion is the hardest part; you must think. After presenting results, you answer the research questionsβwhat do they mean? The discussion should interpret results, compare with previous research, discuss limitations, address unexpected results, and explain how they add value. The conclusion should restate your hypothesis, state important findings, highlight limitations, explain overall significance, and state future directions.
To make your discussion very effective, you should put the most important findings front and center, contextualize the meaning, most effectively demonstrate your ability, and highlight the importance of your study. Do not be apologeticβrepress your doubts and convey confidence.
β Key Takeaways
The discussion section interprets results and relates them to previous studies, while the conclusion summarizes the overall significance and future directions. Both sections require an overview of the study, findings, limitations, applications, and future possibilities. A writer must check for logical consistency between findings, research questions, design, and theory. The most important findings should be presented first, and the writer must convey confidence without being apologetic. Understanding the difference between discussion and conclusion is essential for drafting an effective manuscript.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five essential ingredients for an effective discussion and conclusion?
- What is the primary difference between the functions of a discussion section and a conclusion section?
- What key questions should you ask to ensure your findings logically answer your research questions?
- What strategy should a writer use to make their discussion more effective regarding their findings and confidence?
- Why is it important to highlight limitations in both the discussion and conclusion sections?
π Lecture 21 β Writing Your Conclusion
π Overview: This lecture focuses on how researchers structure their Discussion/Conclusion sections in academic papers. It outlines the essential components that should appear in this final section and provides a critical framework for evaluating whether these conclusions are logically sound and appropriately applied. Understanding this material is crucial for both writing effective research papers and critically evaluating published studies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture first explains the varying formats researchers use for their concluding sections and details the six essential components that should be included: overview of the study, overview of findings, relation of findings, attention to limitations, possible applications, and future possibilities. It then presents seven critical questions that consumers of research should ask when evaluating Discussion/Conclusion sections, including concerns about logical reasoning, design consistency, generalization, causation, theoretical grounding, limitations, and practical significance.
π Lecture Summary
Writing Your Conclusion
Researchers vary in the format they use to wrap up their studies. Some only have a Discussion section, whereas others have both Discussion and Conclusion sections. You might also see additional subheadings, such as Summary and/or Implications. Some attach their Discussion section to their Results section, labeled something like "Results and Discussion" followed by a final Conclusion. Regardless of the format, they usually include the following components:
Overview of the study: The purpose of the study is restated, the questions under investigation are summarized, and any propounded hypotheses are reiterated.
Overview of the findings: The researcher should show how the findings address the research question and/or support or fail to support any hypothesis being proposed.
Relation of findings: The researcher should relate the findings of his or her study to previous research findings and theoretical thinking.
Attention to limitations: The researcher should evaluate his or her own study and point out any weaknesses and/or limitations regarding the study.
Possible applications: The researcher should suggest in his or her conclusions how the results can be applied to practical situations.
Future possibilities: The researcher should suggest topics for future research.
π‘ Why this matters: These six components form a checklist for both writing and evaluating the concluding section of any research paper. Missing any component weakens the study's contribution.
Questions Every Consumer Should Ask
When evaluating the Discussion/Conclusion section of a study, there is a set of seven questions that the consumer should address:
1. Do the findings logically answer the research questions or support the research hypothesis? The consumer must be wary because many researchers have biases and would love to find answers to their questions or support their hypothesis from the results. Because this final section gives researchers the right to conjecture about what the findings mean, it is easy to unintentionally suggest things that the results do not support.
π Definition β Biases: Personal preferences or preconceptions that may influence a researcher's interpretation of their findings without conscious intent.
2. Does the nature of the study remain consistent from beginning to end? Some studies begin as exploratory studies but end up as confirmatory ones. In such cases, the introduction section has research questions with no specific hypothesis stated, but in the Discussion section, the researcher claims "our hypothesis is confirmed." Another variation is that researchers generate a hypothesis in the Discussion sectionβwhich is their rightβbut then suggest their results support it. This is circular reasoning: we cannot use the same data to support a hypothesis from which it has been formulated. A new study must be conducted to test this hypothesis.
π Definition β Circular reasoning: A logical fallacy where the conclusion of an argument is used as a premise to support itself; in research, this occurs when the same data is used both to generate and confirm a hypothesis.
3. Are the findings generalized to the correct population or situations? Most studies cannot be generalized to a broadly defined population because most samples are not randomly selected, nor are they typically large enough to adequately represent a target population. Results of such studies are suggestive at most and need to be followed up with replications. If the same findings are repeated using different samples from the target population, we can have more assurance we are on the right track. A well-written Discussion section will warn readers of this problem.
π Definition β Replications: Repeating a study with different samples from the same target population to verify whether the original findings hold true.
4. Are the conclusions consistent with the type of research design used? The main concern is whether causation is being inferred from research designs that are not geared to demonstrate this effect. Non-experimental designs such as descriptive or correlational ones cannot be used to directly show causation. Yet, especially in the latter case, some researchers have slipped into concluding that their findings indicate that one variable influences another. When researchers apply their findings, they are often tempted to recommend manipulating one variable to cause changes in anotherβa logical error unless the research design warrants this application.
π Definition β Logical error: An error in reasoning where conclusions are drawn that are not supported by the research design, such as inferring causation from correlational data.
5. Are the findings and conclusions related to theory or previous research? A well-written Discussion/Conclusion section should attempt to tie the findings and interpretations to any current theoretical thinking or previous research. This might be done by showing how the findings support what has gone before or by providing evidence to refute some theory or challenge previous research.
6. Are any limitations of the study made clear? There are very few, if any, perfect studies in the literature. Regardless of how good a study is, a conscientious researcher will mention what the limitations are to caution the reader from being overly confident about the results.
7. Is there consistency between the findings and the applications? Small correlations, such as r = 0.30, are often interpreted as important findings because they are statistically significant, or a difference of 5 points between a treatment and a control group is given importance for the same reason. Yet the consumer needs to consider whether these findings are large enough to justify the cost in time, human resources, and finance. The consumer needs to be on alert when a researcher advocates costly changes based solely on statistical significance.
π Formula: Statistical significance β Practical significance β A finding can be statistically significant but too small in magnitude to justify the cost of implementation.
π Example: A researcher finds a correlation of r = 0.30 between a new teaching method and student achievement, and this is statistically significant. However, implementing this method costs $50,000 per school. Despite statistical significance, the practical benefit may be too small to warrant such expense.
β Key Takeaways
The Discussion/Conclusion section must include six essential components: overview of the study, overview of findings, relation to previous research, limitations, applications, and future possibilities. When evaluating this section, consumers must ask seven critical questions to avoid being misled by biased interpretations, circular reasoning, or overgeneralization. A crucial distinction exists between statistical significance and practical significanceβnot all statistically significant results justify costly implementation. The research design must match the conclusions drawn; non-experimental designs cannot support causal claims. Finally, well-written conclusions will acknowledge limitations and connect findings to existing theory or research, rather than claiming support for hypotheses generated from the same data.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six essential components that should appear in a Discussion/Conclusion section?
- What is circular reasoning in the context of research conclusions, and why is it problematic?
- Why can't correlational studies be used to draw causal conclusions?
- Explain the difference between statistical significance and practical significance using the example from the lecture.
- How can a consumer determine whether a study's findings are appropriately generalized to a target population?
π Lecture 22 β Constructing a Research Literature Review
π Overview: This lecture explains why conducting a literature review is essential before undertaking any research study. It demonstrates how an integrated review can reveal patterns, resolve conflicting findings, and guide researchers toward feasible methodologies. The lecture also provides practical strategies for searching databases, narrowing keywords, and accessing primary research articles.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining the central purpose of a literature review: integrating multiple studies to reveal answers, identify conflicting results, and assess external validity. It then discusses how reviews help researchers understand common methodologies and feasibility constraints. The second half focuses on the practical search process: using preliminary sources like ERIC, selecting effective keywords, setting time limits, and obtaining full articles through libraries or electronic databases.
π Lecture Summary
WHY DO A REVIEW OF RESEARCH?
The main benefit of a literature review is to provide a mosaic of what is happening concerning a given topic. No single research study exhausts all knowledge on a topic. By integrating recent research articles, you can discover whether plausible answers to your questions exist. When weaving studies together, you may find answers for practical use or discover conflicting results between studies. On careful scrutiny, you might realize that differences in samples, procedures, or materials produced the differing results. You must then decide which study best corresponds to your particular research question. The closer the correspondence, the more applicable the findings might be.
If the same results are replicated over a variety of studies, you can have more confidence that you are on the right track. Here, external validity comes into play: regardless of sample, procedures, materials, or tests, if the same findings keep appearing, you have a workable answer. Without a well-done literature review, you cannot have this assurance.
Occasionally, you may discover little recent research on a particular question. This serves as a warning: perhaps your research question is stated so that your search accessed only a few studies, or you may need to go further back in time. Alternatively, your question may be so novel that little research is available. π‘ Why this matters: Recognizing gaps in research helps you avoid pursuing questions that cannot be answered with current methods.
π Definition β External Validity: The extent to which research findings can be generalized across different populations, settings, procedures, and measurements. π Concept: Replicated findings β greater confidence β stronger external validity. π Example: A student investigating the critical period hypothesis found insufficient research from the past 5 years. The variables used to test this hypothesis are beyond current capabilities to manipulate or measure, so strong conclusions about children's language learning abilities compared with adults cannot yet be made.
Second, doing a research review is important if you plan to do a study yourself. Such a review provides an overview of different methodologies, instruments for collecting data, and ways to analyze data commonly used in a given area. This knowledge helps you decide whether your proposed study is feasible given your time, material, and financial constraints. Many fledgling researchers could have saved themselves needless angst if they had realized the study required more time and resources than were available before launching into it.
SEARCHING FOR STUDIES
The first place to begin is searching for studies using preliminary sources. These are used to find documents that report research studies or theoretical positions. Most university libraries in the United States and Europe, as well as some public libraries, have computerized search capabilities. With the Internet available in most countries, you should be able to obtain a list of research studies pertinent to your questions from your home computer. Your search is as good as the keywords (or descriptors) you use. You might try different combinations of these words to obtain sufficient results, or use a thesaurus from the preliminary source to identify related keywords.
Your goal is to access firsthand research studies (i.e., primary studies) that relate to your questions. How many studies you include depends on the nature of your question(s). For an exhaustive literature review, you cover as many studies as possible. However, most people place limitations, such as time constraints and/or only journal articles, to confine their search to studies with certain characteristics.
π Example: Figure A.1 illustrates a search using the ERIC database on the Internet. With time limits (1990β2002) and location limits (research journals only), starting with the broad keyword ESL yielded 1,200 documents. Narrowing to ESL and writing resulted in 336 references. Narrowing further to ESL and writing strategies captured 37 articles. Adding learning strategies reduced the search to 11 articles.
π Definition β Preliminary Sources: Databases or indexes used to locate documents that report original research studies or theoretical positions (e.g., ERIC, library catalogs).
As for how far back to search, the recommendation is to begin by looking at the last 5 years of research. This usually provides enough current research to address your question(s). Start with the most recent research and work backward in time. This keeps you abreast of the most recent issues and findings, saving time by avoiding outdated issues with which people in the discipline are no longer concerned.
OBTAINING ARTICLES
Once you have identified the studies you want to include, you face the challenge of getting the actual articles. Ideally, you will be near a good library that carries the journals. If the library does not subscribe, it may have a library loan agreement with other libraries. Some journals such as Language Learning and Modern Language Journal have electronic versions to which your library might have access, allowing you to download full articles. If all else fails, you can order journal articles through databases such as ERIC, and they will mail them either through your library or to your address. Ordering the microfiche version is recommended to keep costs down and save treesβthough you will need a microfiche reader, which should be available at your library.
β Key Takeaways
A literature review integrates multiple studies into a meaningful mosaic, revealing practical answers, resolving conflicting findings through careful scrutiny of differences in samples and procedures, and strengthening confidence when results are replicated across varied contextsβthis demonstrates external validity. Literature reviews also help researchers understand common methodologies and assess feasibility before starting their own study. When searching, use preliminary sources like ERIC with well-chosen keywords, narrowing from broad to specific terms, and focusing on the most recent 5 years of research working backward. If little research exists, consider that your question may need refining or that current methods cannot adequately test the variables. Finally, access full articles through library subscriptions, electronic journals, interlibrary loans, or database ordering services like ERIC microfiche.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main reasons the lecture gives for doing a literature review?
- How should a researcher resolve conflicting results found when reviewing studies on the same topic?
- What role does external validity play in interpreting replicated findings across multiple studies?
- Describe the step-by-step process demonstrated in the ERIC database example, starting from the broad keyword "ESL" down to the final 11 articles.
- What is the recommended time frame for a literature search, and why should you start with the most recent studies?