π Lecture 36 β CHOOSING A DOCUMENTING STYLE - APA
π Overview: This lecture introduces the APA (American Psychological Association) documentation style, which is the standard for research writing in the social sciences. It explains how to choose an appropriate style, avoid plagiarism, integrate sources effectively, and format a research paper according to APA guidelines.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the details needed for citation, how APA supports a thesis through organizing ideas and using evidence, the process of citing sources to avoid plagiarism, integrating sources using quotations and signal phrases, documenting sources through in-text citations and reference lists, and the manuscript format with a sample APA paper. It also includes self-assessment questions for evaluating source use and an overview of three major citation styles (APA, Harvard, MLA).
π Lecture Summary
CHOOSING A DOCUMENTING STYLE - APA
The lecture begins by listing the details that are needed for citation: an author's, editor's, or organization's full name; the title of the article, book, or chapter; the name of the book, journal, or periodical; the version or edition; the name of the publisher; the year of publication; the place of publication (for books only); volume and issue numbers (for journals only); and page numbers (for articles and chapters only).
π Definition β APA: American Psychological Association style, the standard documentation style for research writing in the social sciences.
APA: supporting a thesis
Choosing a documentation style involves selecting a style appropriate for your discipline. APA supports a thesis by helping you form a working thesis and support it with well-organized evidence. This includes organizing your ideas and using sources to inform and support your argument. An example from Hacker & Sommers (2011, p. 445) is provided:
- Research Question: Is medication the right treatment for the escalating problem of childhood obesity?
- Working Thesis (WT): Treating cases of childhood obesity with medication alone is too narrow an approach for this growing problem.
- Organize your ideas: APA recommends using headings, following a standard model of Method, Results, and Discussion sections.
The process also involves providing background information or context, explaining terms or concepts, supporting your claims by backing up assertions with facts and examples from research, lending authority to your argument by providing expert opinion, constructing your argument in your own words while citing others' judgments, and anticipating and countering alternative interpretations by not ignoring sources contrary to your position.
APA: citing sources β avoiding plagiarism
To avoid plagiarism, you must choose an appropriate documentation style for your discipline. This involves citing quotations and borrowed ideas, enclosing borrowed language in quotation marks, and putting summaries and paraphrases in your own words. It is recommended to use software like EndNote or built-in tools in MS Word. Your research paper is a collaboration with your sources. Three acts constitute plagiarism: (1) failing to cite quotations and borrowed ideas, (2) failing to enclose borrowed language in quotation marks, and (3) failing to put summaries and paraphrases in your own words. Sources are cited for two reasons: (a) to tell your readers about the sources of information and (b) to give credit to the authors from whom you take it.
APA: integrating sources
Integrating sources requires using quotations appropriately and using signal phrases to integrate sources. While quotations, summaries, paraphrases, and facts help develop your argument, they cannot speak for you, so you must integrate them.
Use quotations appropriately when:
- Language is especially vivid or expressive
- Exact wording is needed for technical accuracy
- It is important to let debaters of an issue explain their positions in their own words
- The words of an authority lend weight to an argument
- The language of a source is the topic of your discussion
- You also must limit your use of quotations
APA: documenting sources
Documenting sources involves using APA in-text citations and an APA list of references. This can be done manually or using software like EndNote or tools built into MS Word. Various kinds of documenting techniques are required.
Ask yourself:
To ensure proper source integration, ask these questions:
- Which sources inform, support, or extend your argument?
- Have you varied the functions of sources β to provide background, explain concepts, lend authority, and anticipate counterarguments?
- Do your signal phrases indicate these functions?
- Do you explain how your sources support your argument?
- Do you connect and analyze sources in your own voice?
- Is your own argument easy to identify and to understand, with or without your sources?
The lecture contrasts the three types of in-text references:
- APA: e.g., (Bailey, 1990, p.34)
- Harvard: e.g., (Bailey, 1990: 34)
- MLA: e.g., (Bailey 34)
APA: manuscript format and sample paper
The APA documentation style requires specific formatting for your paper, including a specific manuscript format. A sample APA paper is provided, which demonstrates requirements for font, title, page number, and running head, as well as margins, capitalization, headings, and an end list of references. π‘ Why this matters: Correct manuscript formatting is essential for professional submission and meeting academic publication standards.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture is critical for understanding that APA style is more than just citation formatting; it is a comprehensive system for supporting a thesis through organized evidence. Key takeaways include the necessity of citing all borrowed ideas to avoid plagiarism, mastering the integration of sources using signal phrases and proper quotation use, and knowing the essential elements of an APA in-text citation and reference list. The lecture also highlights that a successful paper must balance source material with the student's own argument, and that three major citation styles (APA, Harvard, MLA) differ in their in-text reference format.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three acts that constitute plagiarism according to the APA guidelines discussed in this lecture?
- According to the lecture, what is the standard model of headings recommended by APA for organizing a research paper?
- When is it appropriate to use a direct quotation rather than a paraphrase or summary in your research paper?
- What are the two main reasons for citing sources in academic writing as mentioned in the lecture?
- What are the three major documentation styles mentioned, and how does an in-text citation differ in format among them?
π Lecture 37 β Studying Literature: The Pre-Critical Response
π Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational step in literary researchβthe pre-critical response. It explains how to move from an amateur, emotional reaction to a more analytical engagement with literature by examining its basic components. Understanding this initial personal appreciation is crucial before applying any formal critical theory.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture outlines the objectives of literary research, defines the major components of a literary work (setting, plot, characters, structure, style, atmosphere, theme, conflict, tone), and then provides detailed guidance on how to comment on each component at a pre-critical level. It covers setting and plot, characters and structure, style and atmosphere, and finally theme.
π Lecture Summary
Literary research: the objectives involved
Literary research aims at understanding basic theoretical concepts and contemporary approaches to literature, along with their major differences. It also seeks to clarify the aims of literary criticism, key terminology, and forms, enabling a student to read with understanding and judicious appreciation. This foundation is essential for moving from an amateur response to an analytical one.
Major components of a literary work:
A literary work is composed of several key components: setting, plot, characters, structure, style, atmosphere, theme, conflict, and tone. These elements form the basic ingredients that a reader responds to initially.
π Definition β Setting: The time frame or place in which the work takes place. π Definition β Plot: The general background of the storyline that presents the sequence of events in which the characters, possibly in conflict, are involved. π Definition β Characters: The individuals that the writing is typically based upon within a storyline. π Definition β Atmosphere: The mood or feeling conveyed by the authorβs choice of language. π Definition β Theme: The underlying meaning of the writing, which is clearly stated and can be applied to the readerβs life.
Commenting on setting and plot
The pre-critical response to setting involves identifying the time (day or historical period) and place (general or specific). This understanding contributes strongly to the mood (atmosphere) through which the action occurs. For plot, one observes the happenings in the work, which refer to an action organized around a conflict. This conflict builds through complication, climax, and resolution. Time-honored plot ingredients include the escape, the chase, the capture, and the release.
Commenting on characters and structure
The pre-critical response examines characterizationβthe development of personality. Characters can be round (developed and believable), flat (stereotypes), dynamic (changing), or static (unchanging). Structure refers to the readerβs unconscious sense of plot structure, specifically the relatedness of actions and the gradual buildup in suspense from a situation full of potential to a climax and a resolution.
Commenting on style and atmosphere
The pre-critical response to style involves examining the distinctive handling of language, including word choice, arrangement, tone, mood, imagery, sound effects, and other devices. Atmosphere, or mood, is the overall emotional era prevailing in the work. It is a common ingredient created through several factors, including the authorβs language choices.
Commenting on theme
The pre-critical response to theme involves identifying the major idea and main conceptβthe underlying meaning. This meaning can be directly stated or implied. The theme is the often rich and varied underlying idea of the action. It is a complex aspect of literature requiring very intentional thinking, and examples include slavery, hypocrisy, violence, and destruction.
π‘ Why this matters: Identifying the theme is a sophisticated step that moves beyond simple plot summary into the realm of interpretation, which is the core of literary analysis.
β Key Takeaways
The pre-critical response is the essential first step in literary research, serving as a bridge from amateur appreciation to analytical criticism. Students must be able to identify and comment on the basic components of a literary workβsetting, plot, characters, structure, style, atmosphere, and themeβas they appear in the text without applying formal theory. Understanding that plot is organized around a conflict (complication, climax, resolution) and that characters can be classified as round, flat, dynamic, or static is vital. Finally, the lecture stresses that theme is a complex, underlying idea that requires intentional thought.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary purpose of the "pre-critical response" in literary research?
- Name the three stages through which a plot conflict typically builds.
- How does a "round" character differ from a "flat" character?
- What is the difference between "style" and "atmosphere" in a literary work?
- According to the lecture, what makes "theme" the most complex aspect of literature to comment on?
π Lecture 38 β Introduction to Textual Scholarship, Genre and Source Studies
π Overview: This lecture introduces three fundamental questions for studying literature as art: whether we have an accurate version of the text (textual scholarship), what type of work we are dealing with (genre studies), and how earlier writings influenced the work (source studies). It explains the methods of textual criticism, the importance of genre analysis, and the genetic approach to understanding literary origins.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three core areas: textual scholarship, which investigates the accuracy and authenticity of texts; genre studies, which classify literature by form, content, and style; and source studies, which trace the influence of earlier works on a given text. Examples include Hamlet, To His Coy Mistress, and Great Expectations. It also discusses key critics and works such as Aristotle's Poetics, Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism, and James Thorpe's Principles of Textual Criticism.
π Lecture Summary
Three Fundamental Questions for Literature as Art
The lecture begins by framing the study of literature through three essential questions about any artistic work.
π Definition β Textual Scholarship: The discipline (also called textual criticism) that investigates texts by examining primary sources to understand how texts have come to be as they are. Some scholars focus on the author's intention, others see texts as collaborative products, and some study how a text was transmitted.
π Definition β Genre Studies: The study of types or kinds of art, literature, or music characterized by specific form, content, and style. Literature has four main genres: poetry, drama, fiction, and non-fiction.
π Definition β Source Studies: The genetic approach that investigates how earlier writings and other works of art influenced the creation of a text.
Studying Through Textual Scholarship
This section explains what textual scholars do and why their work matters for literary interpretation.
Textual scholars aim to determine if we have an accurate version of what we are studying, asking about works like Sophocles' plays, the story of Troy, local romances, Macbeth, or Heer Ranjah. The scholar James Thorpe wrote Principles of Textual Criticism, which emphasizes the search for the authentic text β the text which the author intended. The main problem with older works is that they may be corrupted through omissions and errors introduced during transmission.
Textual scholars study the genesis and development of a piece of literature. For instance, Ezra Pound helped shape T.S. Eliot's The Waste Land into a modern classic. Similarly, Dickens' Great Expectations* raises the question: which version is the real one? Scholars must be skilled in linguistics, literary criticism, and bibliography to produce an aesthetic (as well as scientific) text that serves as an indispensable tool for further meaningful analysis. Textual criticism is therefore a combination of artist and scientist.
π Example: Hamlet: Shakespeare's Hamlet had its greatness discovered by editors over 400 years and across four versions. Words with changed meanings create richness of interpretation. In Act 1, Scene ii, the line "O that this too too solid flesh would melt" raises a textual problem: is the word "solid" a corruption of "sallied" or "sullied"? This illustrates how 17th-century meaning matters. Key works cited: James Thorpe's Principles of Textual Criticism and DC Greetham's Textual Scholarship: An Introduction.
Studying Through Genre Studies
Genre means a type of art, literature, or music characterized by specific form, content, and style. The four main literary genres are poetry, drama, fiction, and non-fiction.
Genre criticism asks: What are we dealing with? It is the fountainhead of criticism, beginning in the POETICS by Aristotle, who introduced basic notions such as catharsis, tragic hero, formative elements of drama, unity of plot, and mimesis. Critics have long followed this tradition, becoming Aristotelian or Neo-Aristotelian, with a significant revival in the 20th century at the University of Chicago.
Traditional Athenian citizens knew what they were going to see in a play by Sophocles because of genre conventions. Homer's Iliad and Odyssey established the conventions of epic, which were later parodied in mock-epic by Pope. Works can be pure types, mixed, innovative, or unique compositions that create a new kind β as in the example The Age of Earthquake.
π Definition β Genre Criticism: A traditional way of approaching a piece of literature by classifying it according to its type or kind.
Significant development in genre theory occurred in the 20th century through Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism, which introduced Greek terminology to make new distinctions. Words can be acted, spoken, sung/channted, or written. Two more recent works are ED Hirsch's Validity in Interpretation (focusing on the individuality of a given work) and Robert Scholes' Structuralism in Literature (focusing on archetypal and rhetorical aspects).
π Example: To His Coy Mistress: This poem is classified as a lyric, characterized by emotion, imagination, and subjectivity. Its proposition is graceful, sophisticated, and philosophical β but what makes it impassioned? Genre analysis helps answer this.
π Example: Hamlet: Classified as a revenge tragedy (drama), it involves serious action following Seneca's concept of tragedy with typical ingredients: hesitation, intrigue, real or pretended insanity, philosophic soliloquies, murders, and dead bodies.
Did Earlier Writings Help This Work Come Into Being?
This section introduces the genetic approach and new historicism as ways to understand a work's growth and development.
These approaches ask more background questions about the art of allusion. For example, what earlier works influenced To His Coy Mistress? What was the basic source for GB Shaw's Saint Joan β a play about a 16th-century event? Scholars engage in multiple levels of literary dissection to provide information about the genesis of a text.
Characteristics of Fiction and Non-Fiction
Fiction has three categories: realistic, non-realistic, and semi-fiction. Fiction work is not real. Authors can use complex figurative language to touch readers' imaginations. Unlike poetry, fiction is more structured, follows proper grammatical pattern, and correct mechanics. A fictional work may incorporate fantastical and imaginary ideas from everyday life. It comprises important elements such as plot, exposition, foreshadowing, rising action, climax, falling action, and resolution. Popular literary fiction includes James Joyce's A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man, Charles Dickens' A Tale of Two Cities, Jane Austen's Pride and Prejudice, and Harper Lee's To Kill a Mockingbird.
Non-fiction is a vast category with sub-genres; it can be creative like a personal essay, or factual like a scientific paper. It may use figurative language, but not like poetry or fiction. Sometimes non-fiction tells a story (e.g., an autobiography) or conveys information. Other examples include biographies, diaries, memoirs, journals, fantasies, mysteries, and romances. A popular example is Michael Pollan's The Omnivore's Dilemma: A Natural History of Four Meals, an account of American eating habits.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the distinctions between fiction and non-fiction helps researchers choose appropriate methodologies and recognize the different standards of evidence, interpretation, and truth-claims associated with each genre.
β Key Takeaways
Textual scholarship is essential because older texts may be corrupted through transmission errors, and establishing an authentic text (the author's intended version) is the foundation for all further interpretation. Genre studies, originating with Aristotle's Poetics and revived by critics like Northrop Frye, help us classify a work and understand its conventions, expectations, and innovations β whether it is a lyric, revenge tragedy, epic, or mock-epic. Source studies investigate the genetic development of a work, tracing how earlier writings and allusions influenced its creation, as seen in examples like Hamlet, To His Coy Mistress, and Saint Joan. Students must remember the three fundamental questions: Do we have an accurate version? What type of work is it? What influenced it? Finally, the characteristics of fiction and non-fiction differ in structure, purpose, and use of figurative language β fiction includes plot elements like climax and resolution, while non-fiction ranges from creative essays to factual reports.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three fundamental questions for studying literature as art, and what academic approaches address each?
- According to James Thorpe's Principles of Textual Criticism, what is an "authentic text," and why do older works often pose problems for establishing it?
- How does the example of Hamlet's "solid/sallied/sullied" line illustrate the work of textual scholarship?
- What were Aristotle's key concepts introduced in Poetics that form the foundation of genre criticism?
- What are the three categories of fiction, and list at least three of the seven important elements that comprise a fictional work.
π Lecture 39 β Research Methods in Literature β III
π Overview: This lecture explores two major approaches to literary criticism: the historical-biographical approach (HBM) and the moral-philosophical approach. It explains how understanding an authorβs life, times, and context can illuminate a literary work, and how moral and philosophical analysis reveals the values and ethical teachings embedded in literature. These methods help readers move beyond surface interpretation to deeper cultural and ethical understanding.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the introduction to the historical-biographical approach, its importance and practice, including old and new historicism, critical questions for analysis, advantages and disadvantages of HBM, then transitions to the moral-philosophical approach, its history with figures like Plato, Horace, Matthew Arnold, and Neo-Humanist critics, and ends with the advantages and disadvantages of moral criticism.
π Lecture Summary
Introduction to historical biographical approach
Biographical criticism is a form of literary criticism that analyzes a writerβs biography to show the relationship between the authorβs life and their works of literature. It is often associated with historical-biographical criticism, a method that sees a literary work chiefly, if not exclusively, as a reflection of its authorβs life and times.
π Definition β Historical-Biographical Criticism: a critical method that views a literary work primarily as a reflection of its authorβs life and historical context. π Example: Understanding Chaucerβs Canterbury Tales requires knowledge of 14th century Englandβs social structures, religious practices, and class tensions.
Studies on historical and biographical approaches
The focus is on the life, times, and environment of the author and/or the literary characters. Nearly all literature is open to this approach. It examines how these external factors affect the literary work. Literature is seen as the reflection of an authorβs life and times, including the political, economic, and sociological context. To truly understand the works, one must study these contextual elements.
The Importance of the Historical Perspective
Historical novels often make important comments on the human condition in a particular era. Understanding the human condition and social pressures helps understand the work. Examples include Chaucerβs 14th century England, Miltonβs On the Late Massacre in Piedmont, On His Blindness, and On His Deceased Wife.
π‘ Why this matters: Without historical perspective, a reader might miss the political rebellion in Miltonβs sonnets or the social satire in Chaucer β the texts are inseparable from their time.
Historical biographical method: practice I
The concept of historical perspective involves a traditional view that there are βfactsβ we can know with some degree of certainty. As readers, we need to gather them and relate them to literary works, exploring the possible ways in which the meaning of the text has changed over time.
Historical criticism: goals
Historical criticism strives to understand a literary text as a product of the social, cultural, and intellectual context in which it was created. It examines how the text was initially received by readers as well as how its reception has changed over time. It also examines how the authorβs own experiences may be reflected in the text.
Historical criticism: two ways to approach
- Old Historicism: looks at the time in which a piece was written to determine how it was interpreted by its contemporaries.
- New Historicism: demonstrates how a literary work reflects ideas and attitudes of the time in which it was written.
Why examine the time period in which a piece was written?
Every work is written in a specific time. Time periods change how people think and their views of the world. Specific social values influence how a piece is written, along with intellectual beliefs. For example, Shakespeare wrote during a tumultuous time when some in power believed the theater to be an evil influence β did he write βall the worldβs a stageβ to comment on these attacks? Kurt Vonnegut wrote Slaughterhouse Five during the Viet Nam war era β while the book is about World War II, how much of it is a commentary on the Viet Nam War?
π‘ Why this matters: This question reveals that authors often use historical settings to critique their own contemporary events, making the historical context doubly important.
Historical biographical method: practice II
Demonstrating how a work reflects its time involves commenting on power struggles, examining other texts such as diaries, records, and institutions to understand better. Language influences how we interpret text (the diction of a piece). Critics compare and contrast βthe language of contemporaneous documents and literary works,β revealing βhidden assumptions, biases, and cultural attitudes that relate to the two kinds of texts,β and demonstrate how the literary work shares the cultural assumptions.
Checklist for critical questions
- When was the work written? Published? Received? Why?
- What does it reveal about the standards, tastes, and values?
- What social attitudes and cultural practices were prevalent?
- The kinds of power relations?
- How do the power relations reflected in the literary work manifest the cultural practices and social institutions?
- What other historical documents, cultural artifacts, or social institutions relate?
- How might close reading of such nonliterary βtextβ illuminate the literary work?
- How is the past reflected?
- What are the differences from the ideas and values?
Advantages and disadvantages of HBM
- Advantages: works well for some works which are obviously political or biographical in nature; places allusions in their proper classical, political, or biblical background.
- Disadvantages: "the intentional fallacy" β the mistaken belief that an author's intended meaning is the only valid interpretation; tends to reduce art to the level of biography and make it relative (to the times) rather than universal. π Example: Studying the life and times of Marvell to understand the context of the poem.
Introduction to moral philosophical approach
A moral philosophical approach usually describes or evaluates a work in terms of the ideas and values it contains. This often means examining a workβs ideas and values β both those expressed directly by the narrator or character and those implied by the overall design and content β in relation to a particular ethical, philosophical, or religious system (rationalism, existentialism, Christianity, etc.). The philosophical approach in literature becomes much more than a novelty; it becomes something human, concerned with love and wisdom as well as hatred and innocence. This approach does not just think of literature as an art; it recognizes that literature can influence the lives of others in a significant way. Critics believe that the major purpose of literature is to teach morality. Plato and Horace both emphasized on morality. Matthew Arnold discussed morality in the genre of poetry.
π Definition β Moral Philosophical Approach: a critical method that evaluates literature based on the ideas, values, and ethical teachings it contains, often in relation to a specific philosophical or religious system.
What is being taught?
Literature is seen as an important source of moral guidance and spiritual inspiration, in harmony with critical tradition. Matthew Arnold considered poetry a supremely important source of moral guidance and spiritual inspiration, stating: βThe best poetry has a power of forming, sustaining, and delighting us, as nothing else can.β
Moral criticism - the longest history
The importance of literature is not just its way of saying, but also what it says. Critics who concentrate on the moral dimensions of literature often judge literary works by their ethical teachings and by their effects on readers. Literature that is ethically sound and encourages virtue is praised; literature that misguides and corrupts is condemned.
Literature has a didactic purpose?
The greatest writers have considered themselves teachers as well as artists. Literatureβs power as a teacher has been debated since Plato, who saw it as capable of corrupting morals and undermining religion (moralism β utilitarianism). Aristotle and Horace saw it as capable of fostering virtue, being both delightful and instructive. Samuel Johnson emphasized the functions of literature: to teach morality and probe philosophical issues.
Moral philosophical method: practice I
In The Study of Poetry, Matthew Arnold argued that the most important thing is the moral or philosophical teaching. A great literary work must possess βhigh seriousness.β Literature (poetry) was seen as an important source of moral and spiritual inspiration that would probably replace philosophy and religion, emphasizing moral and religious significance.
Neo-Humanist: 20th century moral evaluation
Originally American, Neo-Humanism viewed literature as a criticism of life. The study of the technique of literature is a study of means; critics are concerned with the ends of literature β how it affects the reader. This approach involves evaluating works using MSM (Moral/Spiritual/Material standards) in your own context.
Moral philosophical method: practice II
Moral criticism in the 1940s saw the βDeathβ of Neo-Humanism and the birth of Christian Humanism (Religious Humanism) β defined by Webster as βa philosophy advocating the self-fulfillment of man within the framework of Christian principles.β This view holds that most human beings have personal and social needs that can only be met by religion. Key figures include T.S. Eliot, Edmund Fuller, and Hyatt Waggoner.
Moral criticism
Moral criticism has become less popular during the last few decades β perhaps due to an excess of criticism? It asserts that the larger purpose of literature is to teach morality and to probe philosophical issues. Authors intend to instruct the audience in some way. The question posed: βCan you think of some works to be evaluated?β
Moral criticism: advantages and disadvantages
- Advantages: useful for works which do present an obvious moral philosophy; useful when considering the themes of works; does not view literature merely as "art" isolated from all moral implications; recognizes that literature can affect readers and that the message of a work is important.
- Disadvantages: too judgmental? What about artistic merit? What about moral-philosophical content?
β Key Takeaways
The historical-biographical approach treats literature as a reflection of its authorβs life and times, requiring readers to gather contextual facts about the period, social values, and power relations. Two versions exist: old historicism (focusing on contemporary interpretation) and new historicism (showing how works reflect their era). While useful for political or biographical works, HBM risks the intentional fallacy and reducing art to biography. The moral-philosophical approach evaluates literature by its ethical teachings, with roots in Plato, Horace, and Arnold, and evolved through Neo-Humanism into Christian Humanism. Though less popular today, it emphasizes that literature can teach morality and affect readers, but critics must balance judgment with artistic merit.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the central claim of historical-biographical criticism about the relationship between literature and its author?
- How does new historicism differ from old historicism in its approach to literary analysis?
- What is the βintentional fallacyβ and why is it considered a disadvantage of the historical-biographical method?
- According to Matthew Arnold, what quality must a great literary work possess, and what role did he see poetry playing in society?
- What are two advantages and two disadvantages of the moral-philosophical approach to literary criticism?
π Lecture 40 β Choosing a Documenting Style - MLA and CMS
π Overview: This lecture introduces two major documentation styles used in academic writing: MLA (Modern Language Association) and CMS (Chicago Manual of Style). It explains how to cite sources, avoid plagiarism, format papers, and integrate sources properly in humanities and history courses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Modern Language Association (MLA) style for source documentation used in most humanities courses, including book citation, in-text citations, integrating quotations, and manuscript format. It also covers the Chicago Manual of Style (CMS) for source documentation used in publishing and history courses, including book citation, notes, bibliography, and manuscript format.
π Lecture Summary
Choosing a Documenting Style - MLA and CMS
The Modern Language Association (MLA) provides a method for source documentation that is used in most humanity courses. CMS stands for the Chicago Manual of Style. It is a style of formatting written works that is most widely used in publishing.
Book Citation in MLA
Book citation in MLA generally requires an author name, work title, publication city, publisher, year published, and an identification of the publication medium, such as print.
π Definition β Book Citation (MLA): The standard way to reference a book in MLA format, including author, title, city, publisher, year, and medium.
Book Citation in CMS
Book citation in CMS generally requires an author name, work title, publication city, publisher and publication year.
π Definition β Book Citation (CMS): The standard way to reference a book in Chicago style, including author, title, city, publisher, and year.
Modern Language Association
- To be fair and ethical, you must cite anything you borrow from
- MLA recommends a system of in-text citations
- The source is introduced by a signal phrase that names its author.
- The material being cited is followed by a page number in parentheses.
- At the end of the paper, a list of works cited (arranged alphabetically by authorsβ last names) gives complete publication information about the source.
Learn MLA carefully and apply it accordingly:
- Enclose borrowed language in quotation marks
- Put summaries and paraphrases in your own words
- Use the in-text citation tips recommended by MLA
- Give full details of the source at the end
- Avoid intentional and unintentional plagiarism
π‘ Why this matters: MLA's three-part in-text citation system (signal phrase, page number, works cited list) creates a clear and ethical way to give credit to sources while allowing readers to easily locate the original material.
MLA: documenting and integrating sources
MLA Handbook for Writers (New York: MLA, 2009)
- Use quotations appropriately
- Limit your quotations
- Use the ellipsis mark and brackets
- Set off long quotations if more than 4 lines, indent 1β
- Use signal phrases
π Definition β Ellipsis mark: Three dots (...) used to indicate that words have been omitted from a quotation. π Example: Original: "The research was conducted over three years and produced significant results." β For a short quotation: "The research...produced significant results."
π Definition β Signal phrase: A phrase that introduces a quotation, paraphrase, or summary by naming the author and providing context. π Example: According to Smith, "the results were conclusive" (23).
MLA: manuscript format and sample paper
MLA formatting:
- Times New Roman
- Size: 12
- No title page
- Margins: 1β all sides
- Pagination: Upper right corner with your last name
- Line spacing: double
- Read the detail and see the sample paper
CMS: citing sources β avoiding plagiarism
Chicago Manual of Style (University of Chicago 2009)
- Required by many history and humanities instructors
- Consult your advisor
- CMS citations consist of superscript numbers in the text
- To be fair and ethical, you must cite anything you borrow from
- Notes with corresponding numbers
- Given at the foot of the page (footnotes) or at the end of the paper (endnotes)
π Definition β Superscript numbers: Small numbers placed above the line of text that refer readers to a footnote or endnote.
CMS (Chicago) β documenting sources
- Superscript numbers in the text of the paper
- Refer readers to notes with corresponding numbers
- Given either at the foot of the page (footnotes) or at the end of the paper (endnotes)
- A bibliography is often required as well
- Appears at the end of the paper and gives publication information for all the works cited in the notes
- Ibid β in the same place
π Definition β Ibid: An abbreviation for the Latin word "ibidem," meaning "in the same place," used in footnotes and endnotes to refer to the same source cited in the immediately preceding note. π Example: 1. Smith, Research Methods, 45. 2. Ibid., 50. (This means the same work by Smith, but on page 50.)
CMS: manuscript format and sample paper
CMS (Chicago) style:
- Times New Roman
- Size: 12 (not specific)
- Full title page
- Margins: 1β all sides
- Begin the endnotes on a new page at the end of the paper
- Line spacing: relax - single but could be double
- Read the detail and see the sample paper
β Key Takeaways
The most critical differences between MLA and CMS styles are their citation methods: MLA uses parenthetical in-text citations with a works cited page, while CMS uses superscript numbers with footnotes or endnotes and often a bibliography. Both styles require Times New Roman font, 1-inch margins, and ethical citation of all borrowed material. MLA forbids a title page and uses double spacing, while CMS requires a full title page and allows more flexible spacing. Understanding signal phrases, quotation integration, and the use of ibid are essential for proper CMS citations, while MLA emphasizes limiting quotations and using ellipsis marks appropriately.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of an MLA in-text citation according to the lecture?
- How does CMS citation differ from MLA citation in terms of how sources are indicated in the text?
- What does "ibid" mean in CMS style, and when is it used?
- What is the required font and spacing for an MLA manuscript according to this lecture?
- What is the purpose of a signal phrase in MLA documentation?