๐ Lecture 23 โ DOING A RESEARCH LITERATURE REVIEW: ABSTRACTING PRIMARY LITERATURE
๐ Overview: This lecture teaches researchers how to systematically catalog and store information from primary research studies in preparation for writing a literature review. It provides a structured procedure for creating a database of studies and details the ten essential elements to extract from each study, ensuring a comprehensive and organized review process.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the systematic procedure for cataloging and storing information for each study, including the use of database software, accurate recording of author details and publication information, and the ten key elements to extract from primary studies. It emphasizes the importance of organization and consistency in data entry to streamline the literature review process.
๐ Lecture Summary
[ABSTRACTING PRIMARY LITERATURE]
In preparation for constructing your review of the research literature, you need to formulate a systematic procedure for cataloging and storing your information for each study. The lecture recommends using information storage software systems like Microsoftยฎ Access 2000 (1999) to create a database of studies that allows you to sort and aggregate various studies at the click of the mouse based on any criteria you choose.
When setting up your database of studies, you should enter the following information systematically. First, record very accurately the last names and all initials for every author of each study. If there is only one author, it is useful to identify his or her gender as well because you might want to use personal pronouns when summarizing their study rather than speaking formally as "the researcher." Next, record the exact title of the article using the style (e.g., APA or MLA) that you plan to use for your literature review. This saves time when preparing the table of references because you will not have to retype them. Following this, record the year published, the exact title of the journal (in italics), the volume number (in italics), the issue number, and the page numbers from the beginning to the very last page.
The lecture identifies ten essential elements to look for when summarizing the main body of each study. The first eight elements are commonly found in published literature reviews:
- The focus of the study: What area and/or issue is being studied?
- The research question(s) being asked.
- The hypothesis(es) being tested (if any).
- The size of the sample and important characteristics such as age and gender. Note how the sample was chosen or assigned, whether randomly or by some other procedure.
- The variables in the study such as observational, independent, dependent, and moderating variables.
- The procedures followed, including any materials, test instruments, or observational techniques.
- The overall findings of the study.
- The conclusion(s) that the researcher draws from the findings.
๐ Definition โ Systematic procedure: A structured and consistent method for cataloging and storing information from each research study in preparation for a literature review.
๐ Formula: Database entry = [Author names + initials + gender] + [Article title in proper style] + [Year + Journal title + Volume + Issue + Page numbers] + [10 study elements]
๐ Example: For a study by Smith (2020) published in the Journal of Educational Research, Volume 45, Issue 2, pages 123-145, you would record: "Smith, J. (male)" for author, "The Effects of Online Learning on Student Performance" (in APA style), and then extract: focus (online learning effects), research question (Does online learning improve performance?), hypothesis (Online learning positively affects grades), sample (200 students, ages 18-22, randomly assigned), variables (independent: learning modality; dependent: test scores), procedures (online vs. in-person instruction for one semester), findings (online students scored 10% higher), and conclusions (online learning is effective).
Additionally, you will want to add two more elements: 9. Any other observations you have made that pertain to your interests. 10. Any concerns you have with the study that you want to point out in your review.
๐ก Why this matters: This systematic approach ensures that you extract all relevant information consistently from every study, making your literature review comprehensive and allowing you to compare studies effectively. The database structure also enables quick retrieval and organization of studies by any criteria you choose.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember is that a systematic database is essential for an effective literature review. Always record author information accurately, including gender for single authors, and format article titles and journal details according to your chosen citation style. Extract all ten essential elements from each study: focus, research questions, hypotheses, sample characteristics, variables, procedures, findings, conclusions, personal observations, and concerns. This structured approach allows you to sort and aggregate studies with ease, saving time and ensuring completeness in your review.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the first four pieces of information you should record in your database for each study?
- When do you need to identify the author's gender, and why is this useful?
- What are the eight common elements found in published literature reviews that you should extract from each study?
- How does recording the article title in your chosen citation style save time later?
- What are the two additional elements beyond the standard eight that you should add to your database?
๐ Lecture 24 โ Writing a Research Literature Review / Writing a Review of Research
๐ Overview: This lecture provides a structured outline for writing a research literature review, adapted from Cooperโs (1998) work on synthesizing research. It details the four main sectionsโIntroduction, Method, Results, and Discussionโand explains how to prepare a comprehensive and organized review. The goal is to equip students with a systematic framework for conducting and reporting their own literature reviews in a scholarly manner.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture presents a detailed outline for writing a review of research, starting with an Introduction that defines the research question and its importance. It then moves to a Method section explaining how studies were located and selected, followed by a Results section for summarizing individual studies. The lecture concludes with a Discussion section for synthesizing findings and offering applications, and ends with criteria for students to prepare their own review of research literature.
๐ Lecture Summary
I. Introduction
The introduction to a research literature review should clearly state the research question that the review addresses, and explain the importance of the topic. It should provide historical background covering theory, methodological issues, and previous reviews. Finally, the introduction must state the goal of your review, explaining how it will add to existing theory and information.
๐ Definition โ Research Question: The central question that guides the literature review, determining which studies are relevant and how they are synthesized. ๐ Example: A review's research question might be "What is the relationship between working memory capacity and second language acquisition?"
II. Method Section
The method section provides details regarding the makeup of the review. This includes specifying what years are covered in the search, what preliminary sources were used to locate studies, and what keywords guided the search. It must also describe the criteria for deciding which studies to review, including constraints that limited selection and the rationale for those constraints. The section concludes with a statement of what studies were excluded and why.
๐ Definition โ Keywords: Specific terms used to search databases and other sources for relevant studies on the review topic. ๐ Example: For a review on language anxiety, keywords might include "second language anxiety," "foreign language classroom anxiety," and "oral performance."
III. Results Section
The results section provides a summary of the studies reviewed. It begins with an overview of what studies will be discussed and their relation to one another and the review as a whole. At least one paragraph should be dedicated to each study, summarizing the main point, the question(s)/hypothesis, the samples used and how they were chosen, the procedure(s) used, the general findings (results), the authorโs interpretations/applications, and any concerns to alert the reader.
๐ Definition โ Results Section: The part of the review where individual studies are summarized and described, organized to show their relation to the overall review. ๐ Example: A paragraph summarizing a study might state: "Smith (2020) hypothesized that explicit grammar instruction improves writing accuracy. The sample of 50 ESL students was randomly assigned to experimental and control groups. Results showed a significant improvement in the experimental group's grammar scores."
IV. Discussion Section
The discussion section synthesizes the major results of the review. It should compare and contrast results between studies, provide possible reasons for any differences, and relate results to any theoretical issues mentioned in the introduction. This section also involves comparing the review's findings with past reviews, explaining any differences, and offering applications of the findings toward future research. Constructing tables to summarize findings is recommended for providing a visual aid.
๐ Definition โ Discussion Section: The final section of the review that synthesizes findings, interprets them in the context of theory and past research, and suggests future directions. ๐ Example: "While three studies found a strong positive correlation between motivation and proficiency, two studies found a weaker link. This discrepancy may be due to differences in how proficiency was measured or the learners' first language backgrounds."
Preparing Your Own Review of Research Literature
This section provides criteria for students to produce their own review of research in an area of interest. The criteria mirror the main outline: Introduction (research question, importance, historical perspective, main aim), Method section (details of search, years covered, sources, keywords, criteria for inclusion/exclusion), Results section (organized summary of studies including main point, questions/hypothesis, sample, procedures, findings, interpretations), and Discussion section (summary of major results, comparison of results, comparison with past reviews, application to future research).
๐ก Why this matters: This structure ensures that a literature review is systematic, transparent, and replicable, allowing other researchers to understand and build upon the work.
โญ Key Takeaways
The primary framework for writing a research literature review follows the standard IMRD (Introduction, Method, Results, Discussion) structure used in primary research. Every review must begin with a clear research question and a justification for its importance. The Method section is critical for transparency, detailing how studies were located and selected, including the years covered, keywords used, and criteria for inclusion and exclusion. The Results section requires a thorough summary of each study, covering its main point, hypothesis, sample, procedures, findings, and interpretations. Finally, the Discussion section must synthesize findings, compare results across studies, and relate them to broader theory and past reviews to suggest directions for future research.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four main sections of a research literature review, as outlined in this lecture?
- What specific information should be included in the Method section of a review?
- What seven elements must be summarized for each individual study in the Results section?
- What is the purpose of the Discussion section, and what key comparisons does it require?
- How should a table be used in a literature review, and what is its primary function?
๐ Lecture 25 โ Qualitative research and qualitative data analysis
๐ Overview: This lecture positions qualitative and quantitative research as ends of a continuum rather than opposing camps, challenging the traditional epistemological polarization. It defines qualitative research through its common features, clarifies common misunderstandings (including the role of numbers and theory in qualitative work), and introduces four major strategies commonly used in applied linguistics. Understanding this continuum is essential for consumers of research who need to evaluate studies that fall anywhere between purely qualitative and purely quantitative approaches.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture examines the qualitativeโquantitative continuum as a productive framing, disputes the epistemological polarization between the two approaches, and clarifies that many studies occupy a middle ground. It addresses common misconceptions โ that qualitative research uses no numbers and that quantitative research is atheoretical โ using grounded theory as an illustrative example. The lecture then defines qualitative research through eight common features extracted from Miles and Huberman, and introduces four major strategies: case studies, ethnography, conversational analysis, and protocol analysis, with detailed focus on case studies and the ethnographyโconversational analysis continuum.
๐ Lecture Summary
The QualitativeโQuantitative Continuum
The qualitativeโquantitative distinction has been heavily debated over the past 20 years, often portrayed as "two distinct armed camps." However, many studies are neither purely qualitative nor purely quantitative. Larsen-Freeman and Long (1991) described them as two ends of a continuum with different data-collecting procedures and different degrees of subjectivity in interpreting data. The problem arises because epistemological issues about the nature of reality have been wedded to these methodologies, polarizing researchers into camps. The lecture agrees with Miles and Huberman (1994), who argued that the quantitativeโqualitative argument is "essentially unproductive" and should not be tied to epistemological preferences. Therefore, philosophical issues of positivism and postpositivism are not considered important for the consumer of research at this stage.
The two ends of the continuum originate in different disciplines. Quantitative research comes mainly from psychology, emphasizing statistics to generalize from samples to populations. Qualitative research originates with anthropologists and sociologists who rely on verbal description rather than numbers. Quantitative research uses numbers to represent data; qualitative research uses verbal descriptions. Quantitative research frequently uses sample strategies for generalizing to larger populations, whereas qualitative research works to uncover information from information-rich samples.
๐ Definition โ Qualitative-Quantitative Continuum: The view that qualitative and quantitative research are not opposing categories but two ends of a spectrum, with most studies falling somewhere between them, differing in data-collection procedures and degree of subjectivity in interpretation.
Misunderstandings about Qualitative Research
Some mistakenly think qualitative research does not use any numbers or statistics, but this is not necessarily so. Many qualitative studies involve numbers in the form of frequencies of occurrence of certain phenomena and are analyzed by statistical methods such as chi-square. Books have been written describing statistical procedures for qualitative research.
Another misunderstanding is that qualitative research is atheoretical, whereas quantitative research is not. Although most qualitative studies do not begin with theoretical hypotheses, developing theory (or a theoretical hypothesis) is often their goal. An approach called grounded theory, arising from anthropology, has become part of the qualitative research repertoire in applied linguistics. The express goal of grounded theory is to develop a theoretical hypothesis from descriptive data as the data accumulate "from the ground up."
๐ Formula: Grounded Theory Process โ Data are collected inductively; a theoretical hypothesis emerges from the data as it accumulates, rather than being deduced from a predetermined hypothesis.
๐ Example: Spielmann and Radnofsky's (2001) qualitative study on tension/anxiety in the language learning classroom. They stated: ". . . our goal was to develop a grounded theoryโone that is inductively based on the data rather than deductively derived from a predetermined hypothesisโ on the role of tension in the process of instructed L2 acquisition."
Defining Qualitative Research
Miles and Huberman (1994, pp. 5โ8) defined common features across different manifestations of qualitative research. Data are gathered:
- in natural settings
- through concentrated contact over time
- holistically โ "systematic, encompassing, integrated"
- from deep inside the situation with preconceived notions held in check
- by the researcher who is the "main 'measurement device' "
- to analyze for patterns, comparisons, and contrasts
- with interpretations constrained by theoretical interests and/or "internal consistency"
- consisting mainly of verbal data
In other words, any study done in a real-life setting, involving intensive holistic data collection through observation at a close personal level without the influence of prior theory, and containing mostly verbal analysis, could be classified as a qualitative study.
๐ Definition โ Holistic data collection: Data gathering that is systematic, encompassing, and integrated, viewing the phenomenon as a whole rather than in isolated parts.
Qualitative Research Strategies in Applied Linguistics
There are differing opinions on what constitutes qualitative research. Gall et al. (1996) listed case studies and 16 research traditions, including ethnography, protocol analysis, and discourse analysis. Wolcott illustrated over 20 strategies in a tree diagram. Tesch organized 27 strategies into a flowchart under four categories. Nunan (1992) included ethnography, case studies, introspective methods, and interaction analysis. Johnson (1992) limited her book to case studies and ethnography. The TESOL Web site lists only three strategies: case studies, conversational analysis, and ethnography. The lecture uses these three plus protocol analysis (mentioned by Gall et al., 1996) as the four strategies commonly used in applied linguistics.
Case Studies
Case studies are frequently found in applied linguistics research. Gall et al. (1996) defined a case study as "the in-depth study of instances of a phenomenon in its natural context and from the perspective of the participants involved in the phenomenon." A case study sheds light on a phenomenon, which is the processes, events, persons, or things of interest to the researcher. Examples of phenomena are programs, curricula, roles, and events. Once the phenomenon is clarified, the researcher selects a case โ a particular instance of the phenomenon โ for intensive study.
๐ Definition โ Case: A particular instance of a phenomenon selected for intensive study in a case study.
๐ Definition โ Phenomenon (in case study context): The processes, events, persons, or things of interest to the researcher, such as programs, curricula, roles, and events.
๐ Example: Lam and Lawrence (2002) did a case study focusing on "changes in teacher and student roles in a computer-based project" as the phenomenon in a single Spanish foreign language classroom. They used observations, focus groups, questionnaires, and interviews to collect mainly verbal data. Being a case study involving only one intact class, the researchers recognized their findings were not generalizable to larger populations, but believed they were valid to transfer important implications for teaching and for stimulating future research.
Ethnography and Conversational Analysis
These two approaches are listed on the TESOL Web site and are described as two ends of a continuum under the qualitative research banner. On the ethnography end, data are gathered from multiple sources (notes from observations, interviews, transcriptions of video and audio recordings), resulting in large quantities of information. The verbal data are examined carefully for any reoccurring themes, coded, reduced into groups of related information, and organized into patterns perceived by the researcher. Interpretations and conclusions are warranted with thick descriptions of the data in the form of quotations from audiotapes, excerpts from interviews, and various documents for the purpose of triangulation.
๐ Definition โ Triangulation: Using multiple data sources (quotations, excerpts, documents) to warrant interpretations and conclusions, thereby increasing the validity of findings.
๐ก Why this matters: The ethnographyโconversational analysis continuum shows that even within qualitative research, there is a range of approaches โ from broad, multi-source data gathering (ethnography) to more focused analysis of language use (conversational analysis). Consumers of research must understand where a study falls on this continuum to evaluate its methods and claims appropriately.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that qualitative and quantitative research exist on a continuum, not as opposing camps, and epistemological preferences should not dictate methodological choices. Qualitative research is defined by eight common features including natural settings, holistic data collection, the researcher as the main measurement device, and primarily verbal data โ but it can and does involve numbers and statistical analysis. Grounded theory exemplifies how qualitative research can develop theory inductively from data rather than testing predetermined hypotheses. For applied linguistics, the four key strategies are case studies (in-depth study of a specific phenomenon in context), ethnography (broad, multi-source data gathering with thick description), conversational analysis, and protocol analysis. Understanding that case study findings may not be generalizable but can transfer important implications is essential for evaluating qualitative research outcomes.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two origins of qualitative and quantitative research, and what disciplines do they come from?
- List four of Miles and Huberman's eight common features of qualitative research.
- What is grounded theory, and how does it differ from hypothesis-testing approaches?
- According to the lecture, why is it a misunderstanding to say qualitative research is atheoretical?
- What are the four qualitative research strategies discussed in the lecture, and which three appear on the TESOL Web site?
๐ Lecture 26 โ Qualitative Data Analysis
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces Qualitative Data Analysis (QDA), the processes and procedures for interpreting qualitative data to achieve understanding of people and situations. It explores key dimensions of qualitative methods, contrasts qualitative with quantitative analysis, outlines step-by-step analysis procedures, and examines specific analytical approaches including content, narrative, discourse, and framework analysis.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the definition and philosophy of qualitative data analysis, the three dimensions of qualitative methods (understanding context, people, and interaction), key terminology (theory, themes, characteristic, coding, coding sorts, indexing), differences between qualitative and quantitative data analysis, the five-step process of qualitative data analysis, and detailed explanations of content analysis, narrative analysis, discourse analysis, framework analysis, and analytic induction.
๐ Lecture Summary
What is qualitative research?
Qualitative Data Analysis (QDA) is the range of processes and procedures whereby we move from the qualitative data that have been collected into some form of explanation, understanding or interpretation of the people and situations we are investigating. QDA is usually based on an interpretative philosophy.
Dimensions of qualitative methods
- Understanding context: How economic, political, social, cultural, environmental and organizational factors influence health.
- Understanding people: How people make sense of their experiences of health and disease.
- Understanding interaction: How the various actors involved in different public health activities interact with each other.
Terms used in qualitative data analysis:
- Theory: A set of interrelated concepts, definitions and propositions that presents a systematic view of events or situations by specifying relations among variables.
- Themes: Idea categories that emerge from grouping of lower-level data points.
- Characteristic: A single item or event in a text, similar to an individual response to a variable or indicator in a quantitative research. It is the smallest unit of analysis.
- Coding: The process of attaching labels to lines of text so that the researcher can group and compare similar or related pieces of information.
- Coding sorts: Compilation of similarly coded blocks of text from different sources into a single file or report.
- Indexing: Process that generates a word list comprising all the substantive words and their location within the texts entered into a program.
Qualitative vs quantitative data analysis
The difference between qualitative and quantitative data analysis lies in the data, instruments, procedures and analyses.
Qualitative: Content โ attitudes โ individual or shared ideas โ experiences; uses verbal data and observation. Quantitative: Numerical data โ statistics โ questionnaire.
Steps in qualitative data analysis
The process of qualitative data analysis involves five main steps:
Step 1: Organize the data
- Transcribe the data (can use HyperTRANSCRIBE software)
- Translate the data (can use language translation software like SYSTRAN)
- Data cleaning
- Label the data โ Structuring โ Familiarizing
Step 2: Identify a Framework
- Read, Read, Read...
- Identify a Framework โ Explanatory (Guided by the research question) or Exploratory (Guided by the data)
- Framework will structure, label and define data
- Framework = Coding plan
Step 3: Sort data into Framework
- Code the data
- Modify the Framework
- Data entry if using computer packages
Step 4: Use Framework in descriptive analysis
- Descriptive analysis โ Range of responses in categories
- Identify recurrent themes
- Stop here if exploratory research
Step 5: Second order analysis
- Identify recurrent themes
- Notice patterns in the data
- Identify respondent clusters
- Search for causality
- Identify related themes
- Build sequence of events
- Search data to answer research questions
- Develop hypothesis and test
Content analysis
Content analysis is the procedure for the categorization of verbal or behavioural data for the purpose of classification, summarization and tabulation. The content can be analyzed on two levels:
- Descriptive: What is the data?
- Interpretative: What was meant by the data?
Narrative analysis
Narratives are transcribed experiences. Every interview/observation has a narrative aspect โ the researcher has to sort-out and reflect upon them, enhance them, and present them in a revised shape to the reader. The core activity in narrative analysis is to reformulate stories presented by people in different contexts and based on their different experiences.
Discourse analysis
Discourse analysis is a method of analyzing naturally occurring talk (spoken interaction) and all types of written texts. It focuses on ordinary people's method of producing and making sense of everyday social life: How language is used in everyday situations? Sometimes people express themselves in a simple and straightforward way; sometimes people express themselves vaguely and indirectly. The analyst must refer to the context when interpreting the message, as the same phenomenon can be described in a number of different ways depending on context.
Framework analysis
Framework analysis follows these steps:
- Familiarization: Transcribing & reading the data
- Identifying a thematic framework: Initial coding framework developed both from a priori issues and from emergent issues
- Coding: Using numerical or textual codes to identify specific pieces of data that correspond to different themes
- Charting: Charts created using headings from thematic framework (can be thematic or by case)
- Mapping and interpretation: Searching for patterns, associations, concepts and explanations in the data
Analytic induction
Analytic induction starts with an examination of a single case from a 'pre-defined' population in order to formulate a general statement about a population, a concept or a hypothesis. The analyst then examines another case to see whether it fits the statement. If it does, a further case is selected. If it doesn't fit, there are two options: either the statement is changed to fit both cases, or the definition of the population is changed so that the case is no longer a member of the newly defined population. Then another case is selected and the process continues. In such a way, one should be able to arrive at a statement that fits all cases of a population-as-defined. This method is only for a limited set of analytic problems: those that can be solved with some general overall statement.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the distinction between modifying the statement versus redefining the population is crucial in analytic induction, as it determines whether the theory or the sampling frame is being adjusted.
โญ Key Takeaways
Qualitative Data Analysis is an interpretative process involving moving from raw data (interviews, observations) to explanation and understanding through systematic procedures. The five-step analysis processโorganizing data, identifying a framework, sorting data, descriptive analysis, and second-order analysisโprovides a structured pathway from raw data to theoretical insights. The four major analytical approaches serve different purposes: content analysis categorizes verbal/behavioural data; narrative analysis reformulates stories; discourse analysis examines language use in context; and framework analysis provides a structured thematic approach. A critical distinction exists between exploratory analysis (stopping at descriptive analysis) and explanatory analysis (proceeding to second-order analysis to test hypotheses and search for causality).
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three dimensions of qualitative methods discussed in this lecture, and what does each focus on?
- What is the difference between a "characteristic" and a "theme" in qualitative data analysis?
- What are the five steps of the qualitative data analysis process, and what happens in each step?
- How does framework analysis differ from content analysis in its approach to data?
- In analytic induction, what two options does a researcher have when a new case does not fit the initial statement?
๐ Lecture 27 โ QDA: USING SOFTWARE FOR ANALYSIS
๐ Overview: This lecture examines the role of computer software in qualitative data analysis (QDA), highlighting advantages over traditional manual methods. It provides a comprehensive guide to selecting appropriate software, outlines basic operational steps, and lists common QDA software packages, emphasizing how technology can ease the labor-intensive process of qualitative research.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing the advantages of using computer software for qualitative analysis compared to traditional manual methods. It then describes the labor-intensive nature of traditional qualitative data analysis. The core content covers how using computer software streamlines the workflow, the specific advantages of software in qualitative studies, key steps for choosing appropriate software, and basic operational steps for using such programs. The lecture concludes with a list of common software packages and their access links.
๐ Lecture Summary
Advantages and concerns
Using computer software for research has several advantages. The most prominent advantage is that it eases the burden by automating manual tasks like cutting and pasting. The writer can perform a comparatively more powerful analysis, create and insert codes in text files, and can index, hyperlink, and retrieve data. This leads to various shortcuts for a quick and effective study, saving the researcher from impeding the process or distancing from the text.
๐ก Why this matters: These advantages transform QDA from a tedious manual chore into a more efficient, organized, and analytically rich process.
Traditional qualitative data analysis: a labor-intensive process
Traditionally, qualitative data analysis used to be labor intensive. Researchers would record source material with a word processor, make multiple photocopies of the text, painstakingly read through and assign codes to the material, cut the pages up into coded passages, and manually sort the coded text to analyze the patterns they found. Hence, it was a much more difficult process without the existence of computers.
Using computer software
After the arrival of computer software, the workflow became easier. Researchers gained capability for data storage and facilities for automated searching and display. They were able to insert text, picture, audio, and video source files directly, assign codes manually (autocode) to any section, use the report feature easily, select a subset of cases and codes to work with, and find data to use and sort in reports.
Use of computer software in qualitative studies
By using computer software in qualitative studies, one can have the following advantages:
- Transcribing data
- Writing/editing the data
- Easy storage of data
- Coding data (keywords or tags)
- Search and retrieval of data
- Data linking of related text
- Writing/editing memos about the data
- Display of selected reduced data
- Graphic mapping
- Preparing reports
Choosing software for qualitative studies
Keep in mind the following things while choosing the computer software for your study:
- Type and amount of data
- Theoretical approaches to analysis
- Time to learn vs time to analyze
- Level of analysis (simple or detailed)
- Desired โclosenessโ to the data
- Any desired quantification of results
- Individual or working as a team
- Peer software support available
- Any cost constraints
Basic steps involved:
- Install the program (note the requirements)
- Learn the operation using the help menu
- Prepare a source document (in text format)
- Open a project/study unit/Hermeneutic unit
- Import text, audio, video, picture source files
- Read the imported text documents
- Select the segment of the text
- Insert codes, categories, memos, quotations, etc.
- Search, sort, manage categories, manage quotations, etc.
- Mapping of concepts, layering, linking, etc.
- Producing reports, matrices, exporting data, print
Common software for qualitative data analysis โ links to access
- Atlas ti 6.0 (www.atlasti.com)
- HyperRESEARCH 2.8 (www.researchware.com)
- Max QDA (www.maxqda.com)
- The Ethnograph 6.0 (https://ethnograph.software.informer.com/6.0/)
- QSR N6 (www.qsrinternational.com)
- QSR Nvivo (www.qsrinternational.com)
- Weft QDA (www.pressure.to/qda)
- Open code 3.4 (https://opencode.software.informer.com/3.6/)
โญ Key Takeaways
For an exam, you must remember that computer software revolutionizes qualitative data analysis by replacing the traditional labor-intensive process of manual cutting and pasting. The key advantages include data storage, automated searching, easy coding, data linking, and graphic mapping. When choosing software, factors like the type and amount of data, theoretical approach, time constraints, and cost are critical. The basic workflow involves installing the program, preparing source documents, importing data, inserting codes, and producing reports. Finally, be familiar with common software names like Atlas.ti, NVivo, and MaxQDA.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the most prominent advantage of using computer software for QDA?
- Describe the traditional, pre-software method of qualitative data analysis.
- List two key capabilities that computer software provides to researchers that manual methods do not.
- What three factors should a researcher consider when choosing QDA software, as mentioned in the lecture?
- What is the first basic step involved in using computer software for analysis after selecting it?
๐ Lecture 28 โ What is Action Research?
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces Action Research, a process where practitioners (primarily teachers) systematically examine their own educational practices to solve practical problems. It covers the definition, meaning, purpose, and the structured steps involved in conducting an action research project, culminating in guidelines for developing a successful project.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture begins by defining Action Research as practitioners' research focused on studying and solving their own practical problems. It then explores the meaning of Action Research as an organized investigative activity aimed at change. The core content details the sequential steps in action research, from problem selection to drawing conclusions. A comprehensive framework for an action research project is presented, including identification of the problem, formulation of action hypotheses, and evaluation. Finally, suggestions for implementing an action research project are provided, emphasizing direct connection to real problems, objective evaluation, and economical design.
๐ Lecture Summary
What is Action Research?
Action Research is defined as a process where participants, typically teachers, systematically and carefully examine their own educational practice using research techniques. It is fundamentally practitioners' (teachers') research, a process by which practitioners attempt to study their own problems. The goal is to guide, correct, and evaluate their decisions and actions. It involves studying a problem with input from those who have a stake in it ("part-owners") to make decisions for improving their current practices, for example, bringing about a constructive change in a school. The origin of this approach lies in human organization theory, and it is both task and relationship centered, with the primary capacity to solve problems and take decisions.
๐ Definition โ Action Research: "A process in which participants examine their own educational practice systematically and carefully, using the techniques of research." (Watts, 1985, p.118)
Definition and meaning of action research
Action Research is defined as an organized investigative activity undertaken to bring about change. It focuses on studying the practical problems of education to find practical solutions to current problems. A key principle is that the practitioner can only study his own problems. The aim is to improve and modify current practices. This research can address both individual and group problems. It is mainly an applied research and is considered a kind of personal research.
๐ก Why this matters: This emphasizes that Action Research is not theoretical or detached; it is directly applied by the teacher in their own classroom to fix real, immediate issues.
Steps in action research
The process follows an organized investigative activity to bring about change. The steps are based on the general scientific method of research:
- Selection of problem
- Formulation of Hypotheses
- Design of research (determining sampling and methodology)
- Collection of data (administration of tool and scoring)
- Analysis of data (using statistics)
- Formulation of conclusions
A framework of action research project
The framework and paradigm for an Action Research project include two main phases: planning and implementation.
Phase 1: Planning the Project
- Identification of problem
- Defining and delimiting the problem
- Analysing causes of the problem
- Formulating the action hypotheses
- Design for testing the action hypothesis
Phase 2: Implementation Components
- Conclusions of action research project
- Working topic
- Objectives
- System of the project work
- Evaluation of the project
- Estimation of expenditure
- (Sampling) institution, students/teachers
- Facilities involved
- Now start your research study
Suggestions for an action research project
Several suggestions are provided for planning and executing a successful Action Research project:
- Determine the nature of the project: Decide if it is developmental or experimental.
- Ensure the project is directly associated with the problem.
- It must address a real problem.
- Plan well regarding schoolwork so it integrates smoothly.
- There must be a direct connection with qualitative improvement in the performance of the students.
- Evaluate objectively by using reliable and valid tools.
- The action hypotheses should be formulated by considering the causes of the problem.
- The work should be done under the approach of the teacher or worker.
- The design of the Action Research project should be economical from money, time and energy.
- The problem should be selected objectively and studied scientifically.
- The causes of the problem should be isolated objectively on the basis of some evidence.
โญ Key Takeaways
You must remember that Action Research is a practitioner-led, applied research method focused on solving the teacher's own practical problems in an educational setting to bring about qualitative improvement. The process follows a systematic sequence of steps similar to general research: problem selection, hypothesis formulation, research design, data collection, analysis, and conclusions. A successful project requires a clear framework including problem identification, cause analysis, hypothesis formulation, testing, and objective evaluation. Finally, the project must be economical, directly connected to the problem, and focused on improving student performance.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to the lecture, who is the primary practitioner who conducts Action Research?
- What is the main purpose of Action Research?
- List at least four of the six steps involved in the action research process.
- What should the action hypotheses in an Action Research project be based on?
- What are three key attributes a well-designed Action Research project should be?