π Lecture 1 β Introduction to the Course
π Overview: This lecture introduces the course "Teaching of Reading and Writing Skills" (ENG 515), targeting teachers of English as a second or foreign language. It establishes a practical, balanced approach to teaching literacy, centered on a framework of four essential strands. The lecture also defines the fundamental concepts of receptive and productive skills and explores the complex nature of reading itself.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an overview of the course's main focus and features, emphasizing a practical and balanced approach for L2/EFL teachers. It then differentiates between receptive skills (listening, reading) and productive skills (speaking, writing), noting their interconnectedness. A key section introduces the "Four Strands" of language teaching: meaning-focused input, meaning-focused output, language-focused learning, and fluency development. Finally, the lecture defines reading as a complex, interactive process involving decoding and comprehension.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-001: Introduction to the Course
The course is designed for teachers of English as a Second Language (L2) or English as a Foreign Language (EFL). It has a practical emphasis, providing usable techniques for the classroom. The course adopts a balanced approach to teaching reading and writing, structured around a framework of four strands: meaning-focused input, meaning-focused output, language-focused learning, and fluency development. A key principle is that these four strands should receive equal amounts of time in a well-designed course.
π‘ Why this matters: This framework ensures that learners are not just passively receiving information but are also actively using language, studying its features, and developing automaticity.
Topic-002: Receptive & Productive Skills
The lecture distinguishes between two main skill categories. Receptive skills are listening and reading. These are often called passive skills because the learner's role is to receive and understand language input. An example is understanding new vocabulary items before being expected to use them. In contrast, productive skills are speaking and writing, which are known as active skills.
The relationship between these four skills is complex, with one set naturally supporting another. There is a reciprocal relation among them. The lecturer notes that reading has the greatest impact on the development of the other skills, and the connection between reading and writing is particularly strong.
π Definition β Receptive Skills: Skills (listening and reading) used to receive and understand language, often called passive skills. π Definition β Productive Skills: Skills (speaking and writing) used to actively produce language, often called active skills.
Topic-003: Four Strands of Language Teaching
This section details the four principles that should be balanced in a course.
- Meaning-focused input: Learners read for authentic purposes like searching for information, learning, integrating ideas, or critiquing texts. The material must be appropriate to the learner's level.
- Meaning-focused output: Reading is not taught in isolation. The course should involve listening, speaking, and writing activities related to reading (Simock, 1993).
- Language-focused learning: This strand explicitly develops the skills and knowledge needed for effective reading. It includes training in reading strategies (e.g., skimming, scanning) and making learners familiar with text structures.
- Fluency development: This helps learners develop fluency in reading by using familiar material, practicing speed reading in word recognition, and ensuring high motivation through access to interesting texts.
Topic-004: What is Reading?
Recent research (Anderson, 2008; Birch, 2007; Grabe, 2009) highlights the complexities of reading. It is defined as a conscious and unconscious thinking process where the reader reconstructs the meaning of a text. This is done by comparing the text with prior knowledge. There is no single, simple definition. According to Nation (2005, p. 41), reading involves two key components: decoding (recognizing language) and comprehension (constructing meaning). It is ultimately an interactive process that depends on a reader's experience and prior knowledge.
π Definition β Decoding: The process of recognizing and understanding the language elements (words, grammar) in a text. π Definition β Comprehension: The process of constructing meaning from a text by integrating it with prior knowledge.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical idea for a student to remember is the framework of four strands (meaning-focused input, meaning-focused output, language-focused learning, and fluency development) as the foundation for a balanced and effective reading and writing course. You must also understand the distinction between receptive skills (reading and listening) and productive skills (speaking and writing) and their reciprocal relationship, with reading having the greatest impact. Finally, reading itself is not a single skill but a complex, interactive process of decoding and comprehension, requiring both recognition skills and the ability to construct meaning using prior knowledge.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four strands that make up the balanced approach for this course, and what principle governs their distribution of time?
- Explain the difference between receptive and productive skills, and name the two skills in each category.
- According to the lecture, which of the four language skills has the greatest impact on the development of the others?
- What are the two key components that make up the process of reading, according to Nation (2005)?
- Why is it important for teachers to provide "meaning-focused output" activities (like speaking and writing) in a reading course?
π Lecture 2 β Teaching Reading in Another Language
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts and principles for teaching reading in a second language (L2). It explores numerous factors affecting L2 reading acquisition, including Krashen's input theory, the role of extensive reading, and the critical distinction between meaning-focused input, meaning-focused output, language-focused learning, and fluency development. This lecture establishes the foundational framework for effective L2 reading instruction.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers ten topics organized into two main parts: an introduction to learning to read in another language (Topics 005-006) and the four key principles for teaching reading (Topics 007-010). The principles include meaning-focused input, meaning-focused output, language-focused learning, and fluency development. Each principle is explained with theoretical underpinnings (Krashen, Swain) and practical teaching applications.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-005: Introduction to Learning to Read in another Language (I)
This topic introduces numerous factors essential for teaching L2 reading. Key points include Krashen (1985)'s idea that we learn to read by reading β implying extensive reading is crucial for development. Reading material needs to be much more controlled in terms of vocabulary and structure. Pre-teaching of vocabulary is important, and teachers must find effective methods of promoting L2 vocabulary. Recent research focuses on reading fluency. Teachers need to focus on the most useful words and use a combination of direct instruction, extensive reading, and multiple exposures to words. Teaching reading strategies is vital, and reading is more than translating β it requires connecting prior and existing knowledge.
π Definition β Krashen's Input Theory: Learning to read occurs through extensive exposure to comprehensible reading material (reading by reading).
Topic-006: Introduction to Learning to Read in another Language (II)
This topic introduces the cognitive dimension of L2 reading. L2 students need to think in English rather than translating from their first language. Reading instruction needs to focus on training students how to think about texts β this involves metacognitive awareness. Cognitive psychologists emphasize conscious awareness of what students are doing while reading. This means teaching students to monitor their own comprehension and use strategies intentionally.
π Definition β Thinking in English: Processing text directly in the second language without mental translation from the first language.
Topic-007: Principles for Teaching Reading: Meaning-Focused Input
Meaning-focused input involves learning L2 through reading with the main focus on understanding and gaining knowledge. Most of what learners read should be familiar in terms of content and vocabulary. Learners are interested in the input β motivation is crucial. The quality of reading matters more than quantity alone. This principle is based on Krashen's (1985) input theory, which states that meaningful comprehensible input is the primary source of L2 learning.
π Definition β Meaning-focused input: Learning a second language through reading where the primary goal is understanding content, not analyzing language forms. π Formula: Input β Comprehension β Acquisition: When learners understand messages in the target language, acquisition occurs naturally.
π‘ Why this matters: This principle argues that reading for meaning, not for language analysis, is the primary engine of L2 reading development.
Topic-008: Principles for Teaching Reading: Meaning-Focused Output
Meaning-focused output involves learning through speaking and writing β using L2 productively. Reading should be related to other skills; a course should involve listening, speaking and writing activities related to reading. Learners read, write and talk about things that are largely familiar. The main goal is to convey the message to someone else, and a small proportion of language they need is not familiar, requiring communication strategies. This principle emphasizes a mixture of input and output and is based on Swain's (1985) output hypothesis, which states that making learners produce L2 makes them consciously notice gaps in their knowledge.
π Definition β Swain's Output Hypothesis: Producing language (speaking/writing) helps learners notice what they cannot say, pushing them to improve their L2. π Example: After reading a text about climate change, students write a summary and then discuss it in pairs. When they cannot express an idea, they notice the gap and seek the correct vocabulary.
Topic-009: Principles for Teaching Reading: Language-Focused Learning
Language-focused learning involves helping learners develop skills needed for reading. An L2 reading course should focus on sub-skills including awareness of language features through phonemic awareness activities, phonics, spelling practice, vocabulary learning and grammar study. This principle involves integrating intensive reading and training in reading activities. Key strategies include previewing, setting purpose, predicting, posing questions, connecting to background knowledge, paying attention to text structure, guessing words from context, and critiquing and reflecting.
π Definition β Language-focused learning: Deliberate, direct instruction in the sub-skills and strategies needed for effective reading comprehension.
Topic-010: Principles for Teaching Reading: Fluency Development
Fluency development involves helping and pushing learners to develop fluency in reading. This requires reading familiar material and speed reading practice in word recognition and understanding. Key activities include speed reading, repeated reading, paired reading, scanning and skimming. The role of motivation is crucial β students need interesting texts. Learners should read a lot and extensive reading can be monitored and encouraged. Learners should process L2 features in deep and thoughtful ways to raise consciousness for later learning. This topic concludes with the four strands approach to a reading course: meaning-focused input, meaning-focused output, language-focused learning, and fluency development.
π Definition β Fluency development: Practice with familiar, easy material at a faster pace to build automatic word recognition and comprehension speed. π Example: A student reads the same passage three times, timing each reading. The first reading takes 2 minutes, the second 1 minute 30 seconds, the third 1 minute 15 seconds β showing improved speed with maintained comprehension.
β Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that teaching reading in another language requires balancing four strands: meaning-focused input (reading for understanding), meaning-focused output (using language productively), language-focused learning (direct instruction in sub-skills and strategies), and fluency development (speed and automaticity). Krashen's input theory and Swain's output hypothesis provide the theoretical foundation, while practical techniques include pre-teaching vocabulary, extensive reading, speed reading, and strategy training. The critical shift is from translation-based reading to thinking in English, and from passive reading to active, strategic comprehension. For exam success, remember that L2 reading instruction is NOT just about translation β it requires controlled materials, multiple exposures, varied activities, and conscious strategy use across all four strands.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- According to Krashen's input theory, what is the primary mechanism through which students learn to read in another language?
- What is the difference between meaning-focused input and meaning-focused output in reading instruction?
- List five specific reading strategies mentioned in the lecture under language-focused learning.
- Why does Swain (1985) argue that learners must produce language (output) in addition to receiving input?
- What are the four strands that a complete L2 reading course should include, according to this lecture?
π Lecture 3 β Teaching How to Recognize and Spell Words I
π Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational principles of teaching word recognition and spelling to beginning readers. It covers prerequisites for formal reading instruction, with particular emphasis on phonemic awareness, spoken language development, and phonics knowledge as essential building blocks for fluent reading and comprehension.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an introduction to teaching word recognition and spelling, emphasizing the significance of recognizing known words and deciphering unfamiliar ones. It then outlines prerequisites for formal reading instruction, including phonemic awareness, spoken language experience, and the alphabetic principle. Specific attention is given to developing phoneme awareness through sound identification, blending, and segmentation activities, as well as using the language experience approach to connect learners' oral language to written text. Finally, it addresses phonics and decoding skills, explaining how sound-symbol knowledge enables accurate and fluent word recognition.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-011: Teaching How to Recognize & Spell Words: Introduction
This section establishes the importance of teaching word recognition β the skill of recognizing written forms, connecting them with spoken forms and their meanings. It highlights the significance of both recognizing known words and deciphering unfamiliar words. The lecture acknowledges debates in L1 (first language) reading instruction over the role and nature of systematic teaching of word recognition. The position taken in this course advocates for a balance of four strands in reading instruction. The significance of formal word recognition instruction is stressed, guided by principles that give priority to rules and items that occur most frequently, simply, and regularly.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that word recognition instruction should prioritize high-frequency and regular patterns helps teachers focus limited instructional time on the most useful skills for beginning readers.
π Definition β Word Recognition: The skill of recognizing written forms of words, connecting them with their spoken forms and their meanings.
Topic-012: Prerequisites for Formal Reading Instruction
This section outlines the essential components of effective reading instruction that must be in place before formal teaching begins. Phonemic awareness is identified as a critical prerequisite. The lecture emphasizes the need for explicit instruction in sound identification and matching sounds to sound symbols. Fluent word recognition depends on phonic knowledge β the ability to decode a word, name it, and attach meaning. Beginning readers need to apply their decoding skills to achieve fluent and automatic reading. Adequate fluency is crucial for comprehension. Vocabulary β knowledge of word meanings β is critical to comprehension, and text comprehension depends on a large working vocabulary. This is enhanced when teachers ensure that readers understand what they are reading. The section also highlights the role of effective instruction, written expressions, and motivation in reading development.
π‘ Why this matters: Each prerequisite builds on the previous one; without phonemic awareness, phonics instruction will fail, and without fluent word recognition, comprehension will suffer.
Topic-013: Prerequisites for Formal Reading Instruction: Phonemic Awareness
This section provides detailed guidance on developing phonemic awareness β the understanding that words and syllables are comprised of a sequence of elementary speech sounds. The focus of activities should be on the sounds of words, not on letters or spelling. Teachers should use strategies that make phonemes prominent, such as asking learners to produce each sound in isolation until they understand its nature. Instruction should begin with simple words, for example, listening for the initial /s/ in sat, sit, sad. Teachers should teach how to blend phonemes into words, with examples like /m/-ilk, /s/-at. Learners should identify separate phonemes within words, for example, "What is the first sound of soup?" Learners should break up words into component sounds, like /m/-/oo/-/s/ for "moose". The lecture recommends making phonemic awareness a top priority with plentiful, frequent, brief, and funny activities.
π Definition β Phonemic Awareness: Understanding that words and syllables are comprised of a sequence of elementary speech sounds.
π Example:
- Blending: Teacher says /m/-ilk, learner says "milk"
- Isolation: Teacher asks "What is the first sound of soup?", learner answers /s/
- Segmentation: Teacher says "moose", learner breaks it into /m/-/oo/-/s/
Topic-014: Prerequisites for Formal Reading Instruction: Spoken Language & Reading
This section introduces the language experience approach to connecting spoken language with reading. Learners should bring a lot of experience and knowledge to reading, as this helps them focus on small amounts of new information. The method involves: each learner draws a picture illustrating something; the learner takes the picture to the teacher who asks what it is about; the teacher writes the description exactly as the learner said it, using the same words even if it is non-standard English; this becomes the learner's text of the day, which they read back to the teacher; the learner then takes the description away to practice reading to classmates, friends, and family. These pictures and texts are gathered to form a personal reading book. The key principle is that most knowledge needed to read and comprehend text is already within the reader's experience.
π‘ Why this matters: By using the learner's own words and experiences, the language experience approach ensures that decoding is supported by meaning, reducing cognitive load for beginning readers.
Topic-015: Phonics and the Alphabetic Principle
This section explains phonics and decoding in relation to the alphabetic principle. Apart from phoneme awareness and letter knowledge, sound-symbol knowledge is vital for reading. Accurate and fluent word recognition depends on phonics knowledge. When good readers see an unknown word, they decode it, name it, and attach meaning. Instruction must go beyond knowing the names of letters to developing a sense about the purpose of letters. Teachers should engage learners in activities to recognize letters visually, help them form letters, teach how to attend to sounds or phonology of language, and develop students' awareness of sounds of individual words. A progression is recommended: starting with playing games with words, syllables, and rhymes, then moving on to phonemic awareness.
π Definition β Phonics: Sound-symbol knowledge that enables accurate and fluent word recognition, allowing readers to decode unknown words, name them, and attach meaning.
π Formula: Unknown word β Decode it β Name it β Attach meaning
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: word recognition instruction should be systematic and prioritize frequently occurring, simple, and regular patterns. Phonemic awareness is a non-negotiable prerequisite for formal reading instruction, requiring explicit, frequent, and enjoyable activities focused on sound isolation, blending, and segmentation. The language experience approach effectively bridges spoken language and reading by using learners' own words and experiences as text. Phonics knowledge (sound-symbol correspondence) is vital for decoding unfamiliar words, and instruction must progress from word and rhyme games to explicit phonemic awareness. Finally, all these components β phonemic awareness, spoken language experience, and phonics β work together to build fluent word recognition, which is essential for reading comprehension.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the "balance of four strands" position taken in this course regarding word recognition instruction?
- Name three specific activities teachers can use to develop phonemic awareness in beginning readers.
- How does the language experience approach ensure that a learner's text is meaningful and comprehensible?
- What is the difference between phonemic awareness and phonics knowledge?
- According to the lecture, what should instruction progress from before moving to explicit phonemic awareness activities?
π Lecture 4 β TEACHING HOW TO RECOGNIZE AND SPELL WORDS II
π Overview: This lecture explores the role of phonics in reading programs, the distinction between system and item learning in spelling, and the influence of first language on second language reading. It provides practical strategies for teaching spelling and designing focused spelling programs, emphasizing both incidental and deliberate learning approaches.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers six main topics: the role of phonics in reading programs, spelling as productive phonics, system vs. item learning, first language effects on second language reading, learning to spell and its significance for teaching reading (across two parts), and designing a focused spelling program for reading. Key concepts include phonics instruction methods, incidental vs. deliberate learning, spelling-sound correspondences, contrastive analysis, and strategies for spelling mastery.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-016: The Role of Phonics in a Reading Program
Word recognition is helped by familiarity with what is being read. Learners can recognize words as complete units and decode phonically. Phonics involves spelling-sound relationships and has significance for both learning to read and learning to spell. There are several ways phonics can fit into instruction: helping use phonics to read specially chosen isolated words, introducing phonics with known words, reading interesting texts, using phonics in one-to-one reading instruction, teaching the most frequent, simple, regular spelling-sound correspondences, teaching students to sound out all sounds in a word, concentrating on first letters of a word, using regularized English as an intermediary step, and allowing invented spellings that follow rulesβwhere the rule is more important than the items.
Topic-017: Spelling: Productive Phonics I
π Definition β Receptive skill: Being familiar with spelling-sound correspondences, seen as the reading aspect of phonics. π Definition β Productive skill: Spelling, which is part of the skill of writing.
From an applied linguistics perspective, there are rewarding research insights. The role of incidental learning in vocabulary and grammar items (Krashen, 1989) is significant. There are arguments in favor of incidental learning, with deliberate learning playing a secondary, indirect role. L1 research supports both approaches. Deliberate analytic learning can speed up learning and can help with learning difficulties. Vocabulary learning and the role of deliberate learning are important. Learning spelling can be supported by both incidental and deliberate methods.
Topic-018: Spelling: Productive Phonics: System & Item Learning
π Definition β System learning: Some words can be dealt with by rules (e.g., regular spelling patterns). π Definition β Item learning: Other words have to be learned as unique items (e.g., yacht).
The unpredictability of English spelling system is a major obstacle to learning to spell. Phonological awareness affects spelling and has long-term effects. Spelling affects word recognition. Poor spellers have problems in writingβthey use avoidance strategies. Phonological awareness affects reading. Complex items need to be learned through a series of stages. Letting students invent spellings can have positive effects. The writing system of L1 can have both positive and negative effects.
Topic-019: First Language Effects on Second Language Reading
The Contrastive Analysis Hypothesis states that L2 learning can be strongly affected by L1 knowledge. If there are similarities between languages, L2 will be easier. There are positive and negative effects on pronunciation, vocabulary, grammar, and discourse.
There is a correlation between L1 and L2 reading ability. L2 students transfer prior linguistic and cognitive skills. Reading in both L1 and L2 involves the reader, text, and interaction. L1 reading shares basic elements with reading in L2. Reading in both contexts requires knowledge of content, form, and linguistic schema. Successful L1 and L2 readers consciously or unconsciously engage in specific behaviors to comprehend text.
Topic-020: Learning to Spell and its Significance for Teaching Reading (I)
English spelling is difficult, with both rules and irregularities. Poor spelling leads to avoidance of writing tasks. Spelling is dealt with across four strands.
Spelling & Input: Continual receptive exposure serves as a useful basis for later production. Spelling & Output: Accept invented spellings as a way to more accurate spelling. Activities include copying, read and write from memory, dictation, and free writing. These are important for writing. There should be giving deliberate attention to spelling, with an appropriate balance of each of the four strands.
Topic-021: Learning to Spell and its Significance for Teaching Reading (II)
Spelling & Learning: There are numerous techniques for teaching spelling, including deliberate memorization:
- Cover & retrieve: (e.g., yacht β y, occurrence β o)
- Using analogies: Think of known words sharing similar spelling features (e.g., apply β learners think of known words reply, supply, etc.)
- Pronouncing word in the way it is spelled: Yacht can be deliberately mispronounced
- Visualizing
- Tests
- Noticing patterns: day, play, say, may, stay
Studying rules: Study of complicated rulesβfree and checked vowels. Strategy training includes: memorize new item, find spelling of needed word, and learn how to pronounce new word when reading.
Topic-022: Designing a Focused Spelling Program for Reading
Spelling issues have positive and negative effects on learning. Features of a good intensive learning program include:
- Keep learners motivated
- Praise success, give quick feedback
- Do mastery testing
- Measure progress
Make learning fun: Use attractive materials and have amusing competitions. Encourage thoughtful processing: Use rich associations, rules, visualization, and deliberate learning. Plan for repetition & revision: Give regular practice. Train learners in strategies and get them to reflect on learning.
β Key Takeaways
Learning to spell involves both system learning (rules) and item learning (unique words), and the unpredictability of English spelling is a major challenge. Phonics serves as the bridge between reading (receptive) and spelling (productive), and both incidental and deliberate learning are necessary, with deliberate analytic learning accelerating progress. First language knowledge strongly affects second language reading through the contrastive analysis hypothesis, with positive and negative transfer across linguistic domains. A focused spelling program must incorporate motivation, mastery testing, repetition, strategy training, and fun activities while encouraging thoughtful processing through visualization, rules, and analogies. Allowing invented spellings and accepting deliberate mispronunciation can be effective transitional strategies toward accurate spelling.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between system learning and item learning in spelling, and give an example of each?
- According to the contrastive analysis hypothesis, how does L1 knowledge affect L2 reading?
- What are the six specific techniques for deliberate memorization of spelling listed in the lecture?
- What are the four key features of a good intensive spelling program to keep learners motivated?
- Why is allowing invented spellings considered beneficial for learning to spell?
π Lecture 5 β Teaching Intensive EFL/ESL Reading I
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of intensive reading as distinct from extensive reading, focusing on detailed analysis of texts for specific learning aims. It explores the key focuses of intensive reading exercises, the features of a good intensive reading exercise, and critically evaluates the usefulness of comprehension questions as a training tool. This matters because understanding how to design effective intensive reading activities is fundamental for developing learners' language knowledge and comprehension skills.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining intensive EFL/ESL reading and contrasting it with extensive reading, listing various classroom activities like skimming, scanning, and gap-filling. It then outlines the multiple aspects that intensive reading focuses on, including comprehension, phonics, vocabulary, grammar, cohesion, and information structure. The features of a good intensive reading exercise are detailed, emphasizing generalizable items and strategies, directing attention to the text, and providing useful feedback. Finally, the lecture presents a two-part critical analysis of comprehension questions, weighing their usefulness as a training technique against the skills, time, and effort required to construct them effectively.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-023: Introduction to Intensive EFL/ESL Reading
Significance: Intensive reading involves reading in detail with specific aims and tasks, unlike extensive reading, which focuses on enjoyment and general reading skills. In the classroom, intensive reading activities include skimming a text for specific information to answer questions, as well as various other ways such as true or false statements, filling gaps in a summary, scanning a text to match headings to paragraphs, and scanning jumbled paragraphs to put them in order. Intensive reading is a means of increasing knowledge of language features and improving comprehension skill. One approach is the classic GTM (Grammar Translation Method), used to determine what language features will get attention.
Topic-024: Focuses in Intensive Reading
Aspects: Intensive reading focuses on several key aspects. These include comprehension, which is understanding a particular text. It also involves regular and irregular sound-spelling relations, taught through teaching phonics, spelling rules, and reading aloud. Attention is given to vocabulary (useful words and underlying meaning), grammar, and cohesion. Finally, it focuses on information structure, which involves understanding certain kinds of information (e.g., in newspaper reports: what happened, how, effects) and genre features, which explain how a text achieves its communicative purpose via vocabulary, grammatical features, and cohesive features.
Topic-025: Features of a Good Intensive Reading Exercise
What a Good Intensive Reading Exercise Does: A good reading exercise focuses on items and strategies that can be applied to any text. It requires reading the text, providing useful feedback, and is easy to make.
It directs learnersβ attention to features of text that can be found in any text. This includes strategies for dealing with any text, and it allows learners to gain knowledge of the language and ways of dealing with language rather than focusing on the message.
It directs learnersβ attention to the reading text. This requires learners to read it or part of it to do the exercise, to understand parts of the text in relation to its wider context, and to use information from outside the text.
It provides useful information about learnersβ performance. If learners are not successful on some parts, the exercise should help indicate what they can do different and provide useful feedback.
Topic-026: Are Comprehension Questions Good For Reading Exercise? (I)
Usefulness: Comprehension questions are one of the effective techniques to train in reading. They can take many forms, including yes/no questions, true/false statements, multiple choice items, and blank-filling exercises. A simple question can help check vocabulary, sentence structure, inference, and supposition. These questions should be local rather than general, focusing on the message of a particular text, the interpretation of modal verbs, and developing language knowledge.
Topic-027: Are Comprehension Questions Good For Reading Exercise? (II)
Usefulness (Continued): Comprehension questions direct learnersβ attention to the reading text. They should be pre-tested to make sure they cannot be answered without reading the text. They must make learners consider more than one sentence to answer a question. Classroom discussion of errors is valuable; the causes of errors need to be clearly identified to help learners develop interest in finding the right answer and help them avoid a similar error through feedback. However, it is difficult to make comprehension questions because it takes skills, time, and effort. Despite this, they remain useful ways of practicing reading and motivating learners to read.
β Key Takeaways
Intensive reading is a detailed, task-oriented approach aimed at building language knowledge and comprehension skills, contrasting with the fluency-focused nature of extensive reading. Effective intensive reading exercises must direct learners' attention to generalizable features of any text, require careful reading of the text in its context, and provide specific, actionable feedback on performance. The multiple focuses of intensive reading include comprehension, phonics, vocabulary, grammar, cohesion, information structure, and genre features. Comprehension questions are a powerful training tool for reading but must be carefully designed to be local, not answerable without reading, and to require linking multiple sentences, while the effort and skill needed to create them is a significant challenge.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary difference between intensive reading and extensive reading?
- List four different forms that comprehension questions can take in an intensive reading exercise.
- According to the lecture, what are the three main things a good intensive reading exercise must do?
- What does it mean for a comprehension question to be "local" rather than "general"?
- Why is it difficult to make good comprehension questions, even though they are a useful practice for reading?
π Lecture 6 β Teaching Intensive EFL/ESL Reading II
π Overview: This lecture focuses on comprehension in intensive reading, specifically how to design and use different types of comprehension questions to test and deepen understanding. It covers question formats, the cognitive focus of comprehension questions (from literal to critical), standardized reading procedures like Reciprocal Teaching and CORI, and vocabulary instruction strategies for reading texts.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main topics: types of comprehension questions (pronominal, yes/no, true/false, multiple-choice, sentence completion), the focus of comprehension questions across multiple cognitive levels (literal, inferential, main idea, critical response), the value of analyzing question focus, standardized reading procedures (Reciprocal Teaching and CORI), and principles and options for teaching vocabulary in intensive reading.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-028: Comprehension of the Text (I)
Comprehension questions are a significant means for helping learners comprehend a text. The typical activity involves reading a text and then answering questions about it. Several types of questions can be used. Pronominal questions use question words like who, what, when, how, and why. These are used to test reading and writing ability and often require one-word answers or copying answers directly from the text. Some questions use commands like "Explain" or "Describe." Yes/no questions require short answers (yes or no) and thus do not require a high level of writing skill; they often use auxiliary verbs like does, do, etc. True/false sentences require learners to state if a statement is true or false according to the passage, simply by copying "true" or "false." A key drawback of true/false questions is that there is a 50% chance of guessing correctly.
π Definition β Pronominal Questions: Questions beginning with who, what, when, how, why, etc., used to test reading and writing ability. π Example: "What is the capital of France?" requires a one-word answer.
π Definition β Yes/No Questions: Questions requiring a short "yes" or "no" answer, involving low-level writing skill. π Example: "Does the sun rise in the east?" requires a short answer.
π Definition β True/False Sentences: Statements that learners must judge as true or false according to the passage, with a 50% chance of guessing correctly.
Topic-029: Comprehension of the Text (II)
Further question types are discussed. Multiple-choice sentences present four choices, giving learners a 25% chance of guessing correctly. These questions are complicated to make. Sentence completion questions require learners to fill in empty spaces to demonstrate understanding of the text. These questions come after the passage. There are four types of sentence completion: (1) exact copies of sentences from the passage where the missing word can be simply found; (2) sentences not exactly the same, requiring learners to find missing words; (3) missing words that are not in the passage, requiring inference.
π Definition β Multiple-Choice Questions: Questions with four answer options (25% chance of correct guess), complicated to make. π Formula: Question stem + Option A + Option B + Option C + Option D β Learner selects one correct answer.
π Definition β Sentence Completion: A question format where learners fill in empty spaces to show understanding, with four subtypes ranging from direct copy to inference.
Topic-030: The Focus of Comprehension Questions (I)
Comprehension questions can focus on different cognitive levels, as outlined by schemes from Tollefson (1989) and Day & Park (2005). Literal comprehension asks about what the text explicitly says; answers can be found by quoting parts of the text. Drawing inferences requires taking messages not explicitly stated but that can be justified by reference to the text. Other focuses include working out the main idea, understanding the organization of the text, determining the writerβs attitude to the topic, and working out cause and effect. Finally, questions can focus on using the text for other purposes beyond understanding, such as applying ideas to solve problems, applying ideas to personal experience, comparing ideas outside the text, and imagining extensions.
π Definition β Literal Comprehension: Understanding what a text explicitly says, answerable by quoting parts of the text. π Example: If the text says "The cat sat on the mat," a literal question is "Where did the cat sit?"
π Definition β Drawing Inferences: Taking messages not explicitly stated but justified by reference to the text. π Example: If the text says "She shivered and put on a coat," an inference is "She was cold."
Topic-031: The Focus of Comprehension Questions (II)
A further focus, responding critically, involves evaluating the quality of evidence, the adequacy of content, the quality of expression, and the clarity of language. It also includes agreeing or disagreeing with the text and expressing satisfaction with the text. The value of analyzing these different focuses is that it allows teachers to check if they are providing suitable and varied cognitive demands. More demanding questions involve deeper and more thoughtful processing. Teachers are encouraged to make questions rather than statements. Other elements that can direct attention include the title, theme, and pictures accompanying the text. Predicting the passage based on these elements also directs learners' attention to features of language for future use.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding these focuses helps teachers design a balanced set of questions that move students from surface-level recall to deep, critical analysis.
Topic-032: Standardized Reading Procedures
Standardized procedures provide structured frameworks for reading instruction. Reciprocal Teaching involves a series of steps that can be used with any text: (1) predicting the content before reading it, (2) making questions on the main idea, (3) summarizing, and (4) seeking clarification. CORI (Concept-Oriented Reading Instruction) by Guthrie (2003) uses six strategies: (1) activating background knowledge, (2) questioning, (3) searching for information, (4) summarizing, (5) organizing information, and (6) structuring stories. CORI involves the use of modelling, scaffolding, and guided practice and typically involves 30 minutes per day. Elements like pictures accompanying the text and predicting the passage direct learners' attention to features of language for future use.
π Definition β Reciprocal Teaching: A standardized reading procedure involving predicting, questioning, summarizing, and seeking clarification. π Example: Before reading, students predict what a text about volcanoes will cover, then after reading, they ask questions about the main idea and summarize the key points.
π Definition β CORI (Concept-Oriented Reading Instruction): A six-strategy approach using background, questioning, searching, summarizing, organizing, and structuring stories.
π Definition β Scaffolding: Providing temporary support to learners as they develop new skills, which is gradually removed.
Topic-033: Vocabulary
Vocabulary work is an important opportunity within intensive reading. It falls under the language-focused learning strand, which involves deliberate learning using word cards and training. Key principles include: high-frequency words (such as the 2000 academic word list) deserve sustained attention, while low-frequency words are best ignored or dealt with quickly. Useful strategies include learning word parts and using a dictionary. Options for vocabulary instruction include: pre-teaching a small amount of vocabulary (covering meaning, forms, parts, collocations, and grammar), having students read the passage, asking about several aspects of the word's forms, meaning, and use, guessing the word from context, and using vocabulary-focused strategies.
π Definition β High-Frequency Words: Words that appear very often in a language, like the 2000 academic word list, which deserve sustained attention. π Example: Words like "analyze," "concept," and "structure" are high-frequency academic words.
π Definition β Low-Frequency Words: Words that appear rarely in a language, best ignored or dealt with quickly. π Definition β Guessing from Context: A strategy where learners deduce the meaning of an unknown word from the surrounding text.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical things to remember are first, that comprehension questions come in several types (pronominal, yes/no, true/false, multiple-choice, sentence completion), each with different guessing probabilities and cognitive demands. Second, comprehension questions can focus on five main cognitive levels: literal, inferential, main idea/organization/writer's attitude, cause and effect, application, and critical response β teachers must ensure a balanced focus across these levels. Third, standardized procedures like Reciprocal Teaching (predict, question, summarize, clarify) and CORI (six strategies including background, questioning, and organizing) provide structured frameworks for teaching reading. Fourth, in vocabulary instruction, high-frequency words deserve deliberate attention while low-frequency words should be handled quickly. Finally, options for vocabulary work include pre-teaching, reading, post-reading questions, guessing from context, and using word parts and dictionaries.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the four types of comprehension question formats discussed in the lecture, and what is the chance of guessing correctly for true/false and multiple-choice questions?
- Name the five main cognitive focuses of comprehension questions, from literal to critical, as described by Tollefson and Day & Park.
- What are the four steps of Reciprocal Teaching, and how do they help students engage with a text?
- According to the vocabulary principles, which type of words deserves sustained attention and how should low-frequency words be treated?
- List at least four of the six strategies in CORI (Concept-Oriented Reading Instruction).