π Lesson 22 β Task-Based Language Teaching
π Overview: This lecture introduces Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT), an approach that uses tasks as the core unit for planning and instruction. It explains the theoretical background, key assumptions, and practical applications of TBLT, highlighting how tasks promote meaningful communication and language acquisition.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the background of Task-Based Language Teaching, including its origins in Communicative Language Teaching and SLA research, the theory of language and learning behind TBLT, its objectives and syllabus design, the roles of learners, teachers, and materials, and the procedural framework for implementing tasks in the classroom. It also discusses different task types and classification systems.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-106: Background of Task-Based Language Teaching
Task-Based Language Teaching (TBLT) refers to an approach based on the use of tasks as the core unit of planning and instruction in language teaching. It is presented as a logical development of Communicative Language Teaching (CLT) because it draws on principles from the 1980s, such as: activities involving real communication are essential for learning; activities using language for meaningful tasks promote learning; and language meaningful to the learner supports learning. Tasks are proposed as useful vehicles for applying these principles. Two early applications were the Malaysian Communicational Syllabus (1975) and the Bangalore Project, both short-lived. Interest in tasks emerged when SLA researchers turned to tasks as research tools in the mid-1980s, focusing on strategies and cognitive processes learners use. This suggested a reassessment of formal grammar instruction, arguing that engaging learners in task work provides a better context for activating learning processes than form-focused activities. Language learning depends on tasks requiring learners to negotiate meaning and engage in naturalistic communication.
The key assumptions of TBLT, summarized by Feez (1998, p. 17), are: focus is on process rather than product; basic elements are purposeful activities and tasks emphasizing communication and meaning; learners learn by interacting communicatively while engaged in tasks; tasks can be real-world or pedagogical; and tasks are sequenced according to difficulty. Difficulty depends on factors including learner experience, task complexity, language required, and support available. TBLT has gained attention in applied linguistics, though there have been few large-scale practical applications.
TBLT proposes "task" as a central unit. A task is an activity or goal carried out using language, such as solving a puzzle, giving directions, or writing a letter. Tasks have meaning as their primary focus, and success is evaluated by outcome achievement. Nunan (1989, p. 10) defines a communicative task as a piece of classroom work involving learners in comprehending, manipulating, producing, or interacting in the target language with attention focused on meaning rather than form.
The use of tasks in curriculum planning has a history in vocational training from the 1950s. Task analysis initially focused on solo psychomotor tasks with little communication, then turned to team tasks requiring communication. Four major categories of team performance function were recognized: orientation functions (generating and distributing information), organizational functions (coordinating actions), adaptation functions (adapting performance to each other), and motivational functions (defining objectives and energizing the group). In general education, Doyle (1983, p. 161) defined academic tasks as having four dimensions: products students produce, operations required, cognitive operations and resources, and the accountability system.
π Definition β Task: An activity or goal carried out using language, with meaning as the primary focus, evaluated by achievement of an outcome, and resembling real-life language use.
Topic-107: Theory of Language and Learning behind Task-Based Language Teaching
TBLT is primarily motivated by a theory of learning rather than a theory of language. Several assumptions about language underlie TBLT:
Language is Primarily a Means of Making Meaning: In common with CLT, TBLT emphasizes the central role of meaning. Skehan (1998, p. 98) notes that in task-based instruction (TBI), "meaning is primary" and it is not "concerned with language display."
Multiple Models of Language Inform TBI: TBLT draws on structural, functional, and interactional models of language. Structural criteria are used for determining linguistic complexity of tasks. Functional classifications of task types include "task goals" (educational and social) by Berwick, and classifications by Foster and Skehan (functional, personal, narrative, decision-making). Interactional dimensions focus on interactional activity and communicative goal (Pica 1994).
Lexical Units Are Central: Vocabulary plays a more central role than traditionally assumed, including lexical phrases, sentence stems, prefabricated routines, and collocations. Skehan argues that native language speech processing is frequently lexical in nature, based on whole phrase units larger than the word. Fluency concerns the capacity to produce language in real time without undue hesitation, relying on more lexicalized modes of communication.
"Conversation" is the Central Focus: Speaking and communicating with others using available linguistic resources is considered the basis for second language acquisition in TBI, so most tasks involve conversation.
Theory of Learning: TBLT shares assumptions with CLT but adds learning principles: Tasks provide both input and output processing necessary for language acquisition. While Krashen argued comprehensible input is sufficient, Swain (1985) showed that productive output is also critical. Tasks provide opportunities for both input and output, including "negotiation of meaning" β which focuses learners' attention on parts of utterances requiring modification. Plough and Gass (1993, p. 36) view negotiation as "the trigger for acquisition." Tasks are believed to foster negotiation, modification, rephrasing, and experimentation.
Task Activity and Achievement are Motivational: Tasks improve motivation because they use authentic language, have well-defined dimensions and closure, are varied, include physical activity, involve collaboration, call on past experience, and tolerate various communication styles.
Learning Difficulty can be Negotiated: Specific tasks can be designed to facilitate use and learning of particular aspects of language. Skehan suggests a trade-off between cognitive processing and focus on form β more difficult tasks reduce attention to formal features, potentially developing fluency at the expense of accuracy. Tasks can be designed along a cline of difficulty and used to "channel" learners toward particular aspects of language, such as discourse, accuracy, complexity, or fluency.
π Definition β Negotiation of meaning: The process by which learners modify their pronunciation, grammar, or lexicon to make utterances comprehensible, viewed as a trigger for acquisition.
Topic-108: Objectives, Syllabus and Learning Activities in Task-Based Language Teaching
Objectives: Goals in TBLT are ideally determined by specific learner needs. Long and Crookes (1993) state that task selection should be based on careful analysis of learners' real-world needs. The English Language Syllabus in Schools Malaysian (1975) provides an example: a broad goal of giving Malaysian secondary school leavers the ability to communicate accurately in common English activities, leading to twenty-four objectives forming a framework for related activities.
The Syllabus: A conventional syllabus specifies content like language structures, functions, topics, macro-skills, competencies, text types, and vocabulary. A TBLT syllabus specifies tasks. Nunan (1989) suggests two types: Real-world Tasks (practice or rehearse tasks important in real life) and Pedagogical Tasks (based on SLA theory, not necessarily reflecting real-world tasks). The Bangalore Project used both types, with examples including diagrams and formations, drawing, clock faces, monthly calendars, maps, school timetables, programs, train timetables, age/year of birth, and money calculations. Norris, Brown, Hudson, and Yoshioka (1998) provide real-world task themes like "Planning a vacation" (deciding where to go, booking flights, choosing hotels) and "Application to a university" (applying, corresponding, inquiring about support, registering).
Task sequencing is based on difficulty, but difficulty is complex to determine. Honeyfield (1993, p. 129) offers considerations: procedures, input text, output required, language items, skills, world knowledge, strategies, help given, roles, time, motivation, confidence, and learning styles.
Different definitions of task exist. Breen (1987, p. 26) gives a broad description: a task is a structured plan for providing opportunities for refinement of knowledge and capabilities in a new language. Prabhu (1987, p. 17) defines a task as "an activity which requires learners to arrive at an outcome from given information through some process of thought." Crookes (1986) defines a task as "a piece of work or an activity, usually with a specified objective."
Several task classifications exist. Willis (1996) proposes six types: listing, ordering and sorting, comparing, problem solving, sharing personal experiences, and creative tasks. Pica, Kanagy, and Falodun (1993) classify by interaction type: Jigsaw tasks (combining different pieces of information), Information-gap tasks (complementary sets of information negotiated), Problem-solving tasks (arriving at a solution with single resolution), Decision-making tasks (choosing one outcome through negotiation), and Opinion exchange tasks (discussion without needing agreement).
Other characteristics include: one-way or two-way exchange, convergent or divergent goals, collaborative or competitive, single or multiple outcomes, concrete or abstract language, simple or complex processing, simple or complex language, and reality-based or not.
Topic-109: Role of Learners, Teachers and Materials in Task-Based Language Teaching
Learner Roles: Primary roles include: Group Participant β many tasks are done in pairs or small groups, requiring adaptation for students used to whole-class work. Monitor β learners must "attend" to both the message and form in task work. Techniques to support reflection are proposed by Bell and Burnaby (1984). Risk-Taker and Innovator β tasks require creating and interpreting messages with limited resources, practicing restating, paraphrasing, using paralinguistic signals, guessing, asking for clarification, and consulting others.
Teacher Roles: Additional roles include: Selector and Sequencer of Tasks β selecting, adapting, and creating tasks and forming instructional sequences according to learner needs and skill level. Preparing Learners for Tasks β pre-task preparation or cuing including topic introduction, clarifying instructions, helping with useful words and phrases, and providing partial demonstration. Consciousness-Raising β employing "Focus on Form" techniques including attention-focusing pre-task activities, text exploration, guided exposure, and use of highlighted material, without doing a grammar lesson before tasks.
Role of Instructional Materials: Materials play an important role as TBLT depends on a sufficient supply of appropriate tasks. Pedagogic Materials include teacher resource books (e.g., Willis 1996), textbooks (e.g., Think Twice), multimedia (e.g., Challenges), and task cards. Realia includes authentic materials from popular media. For newspapers: examine sections and suggest new ones, prepare job-wanted ads, plan weekend entertainment. For television: take notes on weather reports and prepare maps, identify "hype" words in infomercials, list characters from soap operas. For internet: conduct comparative shopping analysis, search for hotels using different search engines, initiate chats in chat rooms.
Topic-110: Procedure in Task-Based Language Teaching
Richards (1985) provides an example from an intensive conversation course for Japanese college students in the United States. Needs analysis identified target tasks: basic social survival transactions, face-to-face conversations, telephone conversations, interviews, and service encounters. The format for each role-play task was:
Pre-Task Activities: 1) Preliminary activity introducing topic, situation, and "script" (brainstorming, ranking, problem-solving) to establish schemata. 2) Reading a dialogue on a related topic to model the transaction and provide language examples.
Task Activity: 3) Learners perform a role play in pairs with cues.
Post-Task Activities: 4) Learners listen to recordings of native speakers performing the same task and compare differences.
Willis (1996, pp. 56-57) recommends a similar sequence:
Pre-task: Introduction to topic and task β understanding theme and objectives, brainstorming, using pictures or personal experience, doing a pre-task (e.g., odd-word-out games), highlighting useful words but not pre-teaching structures, giving preparation time, hearing a recording of a parallel task, or reading part of a text.
The Task Cycle: 1) Task β done in pairs or groups, using whatever language learners have; teacher monitors encouragingly, helps formulate but does not correct errors; emphasis on spontaneous, exploratory talk. 2) Planning β students draft and rehearse for reporting; teacher advises on language, suggests phrases, helps polish; emphasis on clarity, organization, accuracy. 3) Report β teacher asks some pairs to report to whole class for comparison; teacher chairs, comments on content, rephrases but gives no overt public correction.
Post-task listening: Students listen to recordings of fluent speakers doing the same task and compare.
Analysis: Teacher sets language-focused tasks based on texts or transcripts, e.g., find words related to title, find verbs in simple past, classify questions. Students continue in pairs; teacher reviews in plenary.
Practice: Teacher conducts practice activities based on language analysis, including choral repetition, memory challenge games, sentence completion, matching past-tense verbs, and dictionary reference.
Conclusion: Tasks have long been part of language teaching, but TBLT offers a different rationale and criteria. It is characterized by dependence on tasks as the primary source of input and absence of a systematic grammatical syllabus. Many aspects β task types, sequencing, evaluation β remain unproven. The basic assumption that TBLT provides a more effective basis for teaching than other approaches remains ideological rather than factual.
β Key Takeaways
TBLT is a communicative approach using tasks as the core unit for instruction, emphasizing meaning, real communication, and learner interaction. Tasks provide both input and output opportunities, fostering negotiation of meaning and naturalistic language use. The syllabus specifies tasks rather than grammatical content, with sequencing based on difficulty. The procedure follows a pre-task, task cycle, and post-task sequence including planning, reporting, analysis, and practice. Despite its theoretical appeal, TBLT lacks large-scale evidence for its effectiveness compared to other approaches.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key principles from Communicative Language Teaching that TBLT draws upon?
- List the five key assumptions of task-based instruction as summarized by Feez (1998).
- What are the four major categories of team performance functions recognized from vocational training?
- Explain the difference between real-world tasks and pedagogical tasks as defined by Nunan (1989).
- Describe the three main stages of the TBLT procedure as recommended by Willis (1996).