π Lecture 20 β Later Language Acquisitions
π Overview: This lecture examines language development beyond the early years, focusing on how children acquire more complex grammatical structures, metalinguistic awareness, and discourse skills during the preschool and early school years. It also explores the crucial transition from oral language to the demands of written language in formal schooling, highlighting the relationship between reading and language development.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers later grammatical acquisitions including grammatical morphemes and complex sentence constructions, cross-linguistic differences in later grammar acquisition, the emergence of metalinguistic awareness and discourse processes in children, the adaptation to language in school settings, and the relationship between reading skills and overall language development during formal education.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-115: Later Grammar
Children make impressive strides in their acquisition of grammar in their first 2 to 3 years, developing the ability to form simple, functional utterances such as Daddy chair that express meaning relatively directly. Later grammatical acquisitions are built on these earlier accomplishments. The lecture examines two such acquisitions: grammatical morphemes and more complex sentence constructions.
Topic-116: Cross-linguistic Differences in Later Grammar
Children acquire grammatical morphemes gradually throughout the preschool years, using them productively and sometimes producing errors such as over-regularizations. Complex syntactic constructions such as negatives, questions, and relative clauses are also developed during the preschool years. The ease of acquisition appears to be related to the formal and conceptual complexity of the construction, along with certain processing limitations in the child.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding cross-linguistic differences helps researchers distinguish between universal aspects of language development and features that are specific to particular languages.
Topic-117: Metalinguistic and Discourse
While a good deal of our linguistic knowledge is tacit, explicit awareness of linguistic units and processes is essential for writing, reading, and other aspects of language. The emergence of linguistic awareness takes place after the child's basic grammatical system is organized, in the late preschool and early school years.
π Definition β Metalinguistic awareness: The explicit awareness of linguistic units and processes, as opposed to tacit linguistic knowledge.
Topic-118: Discourse Processes in Children
Children as young as 2 or 3 years old are able to tell stories and participate in conversations, albeit in limited ways. During the subsequent preschool years, they become more flexible and skilled conversationalists and storytellers. They use a greater variety of cohesive devices, learn new genres, adapt their speech to different listeners, and formulate and justify requests of others. By the time children enter school, they have an impressive repertoire of communication skills.
Topic-119: Language in School
The language skills that children bring to the school setting are important because language is the predominant means of instruction in a wide variety of subject matters. However, the language of the school is different from the language of home and of the playground, and children must adapt to these differences as they enter formal schooling. The main focus in school is on oral communication in the classroom, and then the lecture discusses the relationships between reading and language development.
π‘ Why this matters: The mismatch between home language and school language can create challenges for children, particularly those from different linguistic backgrounds.
Topic-120: Reading and Language Development
There is another major difference between language in school and language before school: schooled language is increasingly written language, and the demands of written language pose a considerable challenge for most children entering formal schooling. The beginning reader is already a fluent language user. Many of the comprehension skills that have been acquired to deal with oral language are also applicable to reading.
These general comprehension skills include:
- The ability to extract the meaning of a sentence
- Interpret that sentence in a given communicative context
- Draw inferences from individual statements
- Monitor one's own comprehension
In addition, learning to read involves mastering other skills specific to written language:
- Using eye movements to scan sentences in a text
- Extracting the visual features of letters and words
- Reading from left to right on a page (in most languages)
- Relating printed language to spoken language in some way
It is likely that some of these skills may be acquired rather easily, but others may take substantial time and effort. Reading involves a variety of skills that are well coordinated only in the mature reader. The early reader is consumed with the task of identifying even familiar words in a new and unfamiliar mode, and thus is less able to attend to the overall meaning of a text and to apply those comprehension strategies acquired in the acquisition of oral language. As children master reading-specific skills, they are increasingly able to bring their substantial repertoire of linguistic skills to bear on the task of reading.
π Definition β General comprehension skills: Skills acquired through oral language that are also applicable to reading, including extracting meaning, interpreting sentences in context, drawing inferences, and monitoring comprehension.
β Key Takeaways
Later grammatical acquisitions build on early accomplishments and include the gradual acquisition of grammatical morphemes and complex syntactic constructions like negatives, questions, and relative clauses. Metalinguistic awareness emerges after the basic grammatical system is organized, typically in late preschool and early school years, and is essential for literacy. Children develop sophisticated discourse skills during preschool, including using cohesive devices, adapting speech to listeners, and telling stories. The language of school differs significantly from home language, and children must adapt to these differences. Reading involves both general comprehension skills shared with oral language and reading-specific skills (eye movements, letter recognition, left-to-right scanning), with early readers struggling to balance word identification with overall comprehension until they master these specific skills.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main types of later grammatical acquisitions discussed in this lecture?
- What is over-regularization, and why does it occur during grammatical morpheme acquisition?
- When does metalinguistic awareness typically emerge in child development?
- List three discourse skills that children develop during the preschool years.
- Why are early readers less able to attend to overall text meaning compared to mature readers?
π Lecture 21 β BILINGUALISM AND SECOND LANGUAGE ACQUISITIONS
π Overview: This lecture explores the contexts and cognitive consequences of bilingualism, distinguishing between simultaneous and sequential bilingual acquisition. It examines how children acquire two languages, the nature of second language acquisition, and the cognitive benefits of bilingualism including enhanced metalinguistic awareness, cognitive control, and problem-solving abilities, while also addressing historical misconceptions about bilingualism's effects.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers contexts of childhood bilingualism including simultaneous and sequential bilingualism, bilingual first-language acquisition through case studies, second language acquisition from ages 5-9, metalinguistic awareness as a consequence of bilingualism, cognitive control and the Simon task findings, and problem-solving and creativity research that debunks earlier claims of bilingual cognitive impairment.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-121: Contexts of Childhood & Bilingualism
Bilingualism varies tremendously across situations. Some individuals become bilingual because they live in bilingual regions; some because their home language differs from their school or business language; some because colonization imposed another language; others because they studied a language in school or grew up in bilingual homes.
A key distinction is drawn between simultaneous bilingualism and sequential bilingualism. When children acquire two languages at the same time, their bilingualism is referred to as simultaneous bilingualism. Sequential bilingualism (also called second-language acquisition) occurs when an individual acquires a second language after already acquiring a native language. Most commonly, children learn two languages simultaneously when born into a bilingual community.
Topic-122: Bilingual First-Language Acquisitions
Popular ideas about bilingual language development are curiously mixed. Some believe young children can effortlessly acquire two or more languages simultaneously, while some parents and educators fear that bilingual exposure may slow children's language development and cause them to mix or confuse languages.
Several questions arise: Do bilingual children learn each language similarly to how monolingual children acquire their language? Can bilingual children learn two languages at the same rate as monolingual children learn one? Is language mixing or interference between languages inevitable?
Much knowledge about bilingual language acquisition comes from early case studies based on diaries kept by parents. Several concerns arise regarding case studies: it is impossible to know precisely what circumstances caused a particular developmental outcome; parents may have difficulty being fully objective; outstanding utterances may be preserved better than errors. Nonetheless, case studies have provided detailed data that inspired subsequent studies.
Topic-123: Second Language Acquisitions
Many children learn a second language after attaining considerable proficiency in their native language. The first language is referred to as L1 and the second language as L2. As Gass and Selinker (2001) point out, boundaries of child second-language acquisition are somewhat arbitrary.
At one end, the term excludes children acquiring two or more languages simultaneously. At the other end, child second-language acquisition generally excludes individuals acquiring L2 beyond about 12 years. The reason is the commonly held belief that there is a critical period for L2 acquisition and that acquiring a second language after puberty is much more difficult. Generally, child second-language acquisition extends from about 5 to 9 years β after the primary language is essentially acquired but before any possible effects related to a critical period.
π Definition β Critical period: A biologically determined period during which language acquisition occurs most easily, after which learning a language becomes much more difficult.
Topic-124: Metalinguistic Awareness
If children learn two languages, they learn two ways of referring to objects in their environment. A bilingual child who has learned that the cat and el gato refer to the same animal may better understand that language is arbitrary β the principle that there is no necessary relation between a word and its referent.
Leopold stated that "the most striking effect of bilingualism was a noticeable looseness of the link between the phonetic word and its meaning." This phenomenon may be broader than word meaning β bilingual children may be generally more attentive to language than monolingual children.
As Vygotsky (1934/1986) suggested, a bilingual child would "see [one's] language as one particular system among many, to view its phenomena under more general categories, and this leads to an awareness of [one's] linguistic operations."
π Definition β Metalinguistic awareness: The ability to think about and reflect on language as a system, understanding that words are arbitrary symbols for concepts.
π‘ Why this matters: Metalinguistic awareness gives bilingual children an advantage in understanding the abstract nature of language, which may benefit their overall cognitive and linguistic development.
Topic-125: Cognitive Control
Another cognitive consequence of bilingualism may be cognitive control β the ability to selectively attend to some stimuli and ignore others. A report by Bialystok, Craik, Klein, and Viswanathan (2004) suggests that bilingualism may help to offset age-related losses in cognitive or executive control.
The study used the Simon task (Lu & Proctor, 1995), based on stimulusβresponse compatibility. Investigators presented colored stimuli to the left or right side of a computer screen. Each of two colors was associated with a response key on one side of the keyboard. On congruent trials, the stimulus and key were on the same side; on incongruent trials, they were on opposite sides.
Individuals are faster to respond to congruent trials than incongruent trials. The difference in reaction time β the Simon effect β is greater for older adults than younger adults. The ability to selectively attend to relevant stimuli declines with age.
Bialystok et al. found that bilingualism was associated with smaller Simon effects in both middle-aged and older adults. The bilingual advantage was greater for older adults. The authors suggest that using two languages encourages development of cognitive control mechanisms, such as when one must suppress a word in one language in favor of another.
π Definition β Simon effect: The difference in reaction time between congruent and incongruent trials in a stimulus-response compatibility task, reflecting the cognitive effort required to ignore irrelevant spatial information.
π Example: In Bialystok et al.'s study, a colored stimulus (e.g., red) appears on the left side of a screen. The red response key is on the left side β this is a congruent trial. If the red stimulus appears on the right side while the red key is on the left, this is an incongruent trial requiring more cognitive control to ignore the spatial location.
Topic-126: Problem Solving and Creativity
It was once commonly accepted that bilingualism led to cognitive impairment. The prominent linguist Otto Jesperson stated that "the brain effort required to master the two languages instead of one certainly diminishes the child's power of learning other things."
Many early psychologists concluded that bilingualism had a detrimental effect on children's intellectual development and academic performance. However, as Hakuta pointed out, many of these studies had serious methodological flaws.
The studies failed to control for group differences in socioeconomic status between monolingual and bilingual samples. The apparent problems associated with bilingualism may have instead been due to low socioeconomic status β the bilingual children usually came from poor backgrounds. Additionally, these studies did not always ensure that the bilinguals were truly fluent in both languages. Some early investigators "assessed" bilingualism through family names, leaving considerable doubt about whether the "bilingual" children were really bilingual.
β Key Takeaways
Students must understand the fundamental distinction between simultaneous and sequential bilingualism, and that child second-language acquisition typically occurs between ages 5-9, before the critical period. Bilingual first-language acquisition research relies heavily on case studies despite their methodological limitations, particularly regarding objectivity and causal inference. The lecture presents strong evidence that bilingualism enhances metalinguistic awareness and cognitive control, as demonstrated by Bialystok et al.'s Simon task research showing bilinguals have smaller Simon effects and better preserved executive control in aging. Crucially, students should remember that early claims of bilingual cognitive impairment were based on flawed research that failed to control for socioeconomic status and did not verify actual bilingual fluency, making those conclusions invalid.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the key difference between simultaneous bilingualism and sequential bilingualism?
-
What are the three main methodological concerns with using case studies (parent diaries) to study bilingual language acquisition?
-
Why does child second-language acquisition generally exclude individuals beyond about 12 years of age?
-
According to Bialystok et al. (2004), what cognitive advantage did bilingual adults show on the Simon task, and why was the advantage greater for older adults?
-
What were the two major methodological flaws in early studies that claimed bilingualism caused cognitive impairment in children?
π Lecture 22 β The Linguistic Environment
π Overview: This lecture explores the environmental, cognitive, and innate factors that serve as necessary and sufficient conditions for language acquisition. It examines evidence from feral and isolated children, evaluates the critical period hypothesis, and analyzes the characteristics and potential effects of "motherese" or adult speech directed at children.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by introducing the concept of necessary and sufficient conditions for language acquisition, identifying three classes of variables: environmental, cognitive, and innate factors. It then examines evidence from feral and isolated children, focusing on the case of Victor, the Wild Boy of Aveyron. The critical period hypothesis is introduced and evaluated through empirical studies, particularly Johnson and Newport's landmark study on second language learners. Finally, the characteristics of motherese (adult-to-child speech) are described, along with a critical discussion of whether this speech form actually assists language development.
π Lecture Summary
Topic-127: Introduction of Process of Language Acquisition
One way to think about the factors that play a role in language acquisition is to identify necessary and sufficient conditions. A necessary condition is one that must be present for language to occur normally. A sufficient condition is one that, if present, ensures language will develop normally. Most complex behaviors have multiple causes rather than a single sufficient condition.
Three classes of variables have been proposed as necessary or sufficient for language acquisition: environmental, cognitive, and innate factors. Although each is sometimes discussed in isolation, it is likely that all three are needed for a complete account of language acquisition. A successful theory will explain the interactions among these factors.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding that language acquisition requires multiple interacting factors rather than a single cause helps explain why some children develop language normally while others struggle.
Topic-128: Feral and Isolated Children
The first question about necessary conditions has been addressed through studies of feral childrenβthose who have grown up in the wild. Lane presented a detailed analysis of Victor, the Wild Boy of Aveyron, found in the woods of France in 1797. At capture, Victor was thought to be about 12 or 13 years old, with no speech despite normal hearing. Jean-Marc-Gaspard Itard, a young physician, worked intensively with Victor for 5 years using language training and behavior modification techniques.
Victor could name objects when presented but would not request them by name. He developed a gestural communication system that interfered with spoken language trainingβLane suggests signs may have supplanted his need for spoken language. Victor also associated a name with a particular object rather than a class of objects (e.g., "book" applied only to one book). Only with considerable effort could Itard teach Victor to generalize names for classes of objects.
π Definition β Feral children: Children who have grown up in the wild, without human contact or language exposure.
Topic-129: The Critical Period Hypothesis
The critical period hypothesis proposes there is a period early in life when we are especially prepared to acquire language. Many investigators suggest neurological changes near puberty leave a learner less able to acquire language, though the nature of these changes is not well understood. Despite much discussion, few empirical studies have tested this hypothesis.
A landmark study by Johnson and Newport (1989) examined native speakers of Korean and Chinese who immigrated to the United States between ages 3 and 39. Participants who arrived earlier (before puberty) had been in the US about the same amount of time as later arrivals. A group of native speakers was included for comparison.
π Definition β Critical period hypothesis: The theory that there is a specific time window early in life during which language acquisition occurs most naturally and effectively.
Topic-130: Critical Period Effects in Second Language Learning
Evidence from second-language acquisition research has not provided unequivocal support for the critical period hypothesis. The best conclusion is that young children generally learn L2 better than older children and adults, at least in the long run. The advantage younger learners display may be due to biological changes (as the hypothesis assumes), environmental factors, cognitive changes, or a combination of factors. Much remains to be learned about how language acquisition capacity changes over the life span.
π‘ Why this matters: This finding has practical implications for when to begin foreign language instruction in educational settings.
Topic-131: Motherese
Language development deals with the ways adults speak to young children. Adult-to-child language, called motherese, differs significantly from adult-to-adult language.
π Definition β Motherese: The simplified, exaggerated speech pattern that adults use when speaking to young children.
Topic-132: Some Characteristics of Adult Speech to Children
In general, speech to children learning language is shorter, more concrete, more directive, and more intonationally exaggerated than adult-directed speech. However, speaking this way to children does not necessarily mean it assists language acquisition. Some properties of adult-to-child language are also seen when adults speak to dogs and even plants, though the effect on them is unknown.
Although such properties would appear to assist children in language development, data on this question are relatively scarce, and widely different opinions exist (DePaulo & Bonvillian, 1978; Hoff-Ginsburg & Shatz, 1982; Marshall, 1980; Snow, 1979).
π‘ Why this matters: Despite the intuitive appeal of motherese as a helpful linguistic input, the empirical evidence for its effectiveness in accelerating language acquisition remains inconclusive.
β Key Takeaways
Language acquisition requires multiple interacting factorsβenvironmental, cognitive, and innateβwith none being sufficient alone. Studies of feral children like Victor demonstrate that severe language deprivation during childhood leads to lasting deficits even with intensive training, particularly in speech production and word generalization. The critical period hypothesis suggests a biological window for optimal language learning that closes near puberty, supported by Johnson and Newport's finding that younger immigrants achieve better second-language proficiency. However, second-language research shows younger learners' advantage may stem from biological, environmental, or cognitive factors, or a combination. Motherese, characterized by shorter, more exaggerated, and directive speech, is commonly used with children but lacks conclusive evidence that it directly aids language development.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three classes of variables proposed as necessary or sufficient conditions for language acquisition?
- What two specific language problems did Victor exhibit during Itard's training, and what explanation does Lane offer for one of them?
- According to the critical period hypothesis, what neurological change is assumed to occur near puberty that affects language learning ability?
- What were the key findings of Johnson and Newport's (1989) study on second language learning and age of arrival?
- List four characteristics of motherese and explain why researchers disagree about its effectiveness in language development.