๐ Lecture 24 โ INNATE MECHANISM
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the evidence and arguments for innate biological mechanisms in language acquisition. It examines Bickerton's Language Bioprogram Hypothesis derived from studies of pidgins and creoles, introduces parameter setting within Universal Grammar, discusses the Subset Principle and negative evidence, and concludes with objections to innate mechanisms. Understanding these concepts is crucial for grasping the nativist perspective on how children acquire language despite limited or impoverished input.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the Language Bioprogram Hypothesis through studies of pidgins and creoles, particularly in Hawaii, explaining how children develop sophisticated creoles from impoverished pidgin input. It then explores the concept of parameter setting within Universal Grammar, including the head parameter. The Subset Principle is introduced as a mechanism for parameter setting, followed by a discussion of positive versus negative evidence and Pinker's argument for innate constraints. Finally, objections to innate mechanisms are presented along with counterarguments.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-139: The Language Bioprogram Hypothesis
One version of how innate processes operate in child language has been called the language bioprogram hypothesis by Bickerton (1981, 1983, 1984, 1999). Bickerton claims that children have an innate grammar that is available biologically if language input is insufficient to acquire the language of their community. It functions like a linguistic backup system.
To understand this idea, distinctions between pidgins and creoles are necessary. A pidgin is 'an auxiliary language that arises when speakers of several mutually unintelligible languages are in close contact' (Bickerton, 1984, p. 173). It typically occurs when workers from diverse countries are brought as cheap labor. A creole occurs when the children of these immigrants acquire a pidgin as their native language. Because access to native speakers is limited, these children receive the impoverished pidgin version as their primary linguistic input.
Bickerton's studies focused on creoles in Hawaii, which developed between 1900 and 1920. He examined the speech of immigrants who moved to Hawaii and their children born in the first two decades of the 20th century. The speech of pidgin speakers was rudimentary โ there was no recognizable syntax, word orders varied often related to the speaker's native language, complex sentences were absent, and there was no consistent system of anaphora.
๐ Definition โ Pidgin: An auxiliary language that arises when speakers of several mutually unintelligible languages are in close contact, typically a simplified form of the dominant language used for basic communication.
๐ Definition โ Creole: A language that occurs when children acquire a pidgin as their native language, developing it into a more sophisticated, rule-governed system.
Topic-140: The Language Bioprogram
Despite impoverished linguistic input, the children of immigrants developed a creole that was relatively sophisticated. It included consistent word order, the use of complex sentences with relative clauses, and the distinction between definite and indefinite articles. Unlike pidgins, the creoles resembled structural rules of other languages.
From these observations, Bickerton concludes that children have an innate grammar that, in the absence of proper environmental input, serves as the child's language system. He calls this system the language bio program. Bickerton responded to alternative interpretations: (1) that sophistication came from access to English โ but contact was limited and Hawaiian creole differed from English; (2) that features came from parents' native languages โ but Hawaiian creole was strikingly similar to creoles created by children in very different parts of the world.
The hypothesis has been further supported by studies of language development in congenitally deaf children by Goldin-Meadow and colleagues. Task specificity refers to the notion that cognitive processes associated with language use are not general-purpose problem-solving processes but are instead restricted to language. Bickerton goes further: the language bio program is not only specific to language but is itself highly specific โ a prepackaged, ready-to-go linguistic system.
๐ Definition โ Language Bio Program: An innate grammatical system that serves as the child's language system when environmental input is insufficient, functioning as a biological backup for language acquisition.
๐ Definition โ Task Specificity: The notion that cognitive processes associated with language use are not general-purpose problem-solving processes but are instead restricted to language.
๐ก Why this matters: The language bioprogram hypothesis provides strong evidence for nativist theories of language acquisition, suggesting that children come biologically prepared with specific linguistic knowledge that emerges when input is inadequate.
Topic-141: Parameter Setting
Parameters is a framework within generative linguistics in which the syntax of a natural language is described in accordance with general principles (abstract rules or grammars) and specific parameters (markers, switches) that for particular languages are either turned on or off. For example, the position of heads in phrases is determined by a parameter.
Bickerton's language bio program may be thought of as a specific instance of a general innate mechanism called parameter setting. The notion of parameters plays a key role in the concept of universal grammar (Chomsky, 1981). In this view, grammar can be defined in terms of a set of parameters corresponding to each subsystem of the language, with each parameter having a finite number of possible settings. Various combinations of parameter settings yield all languages of the world.
According to Chomsky (1981), children are born with knowledge of the parameters and their possible settings. The task of acquiring a language is reduced to identifying which parameter settings apply to one's native language. One parameter is called the head parameter (Cook, 1988). Each phrase has one most essential element called the head โ the noun in noun phrases and the verb in verb phrases. The head parameter specifies the position of the head within the phrase.
๐ Definition โ Parameters: A framework within generative linguistics where syntax is described according to general principles and specific parameters (markers/switches) that are turned on or off for particular languages.
๐ Definition โ Head Parameter: A parameter that specifies the position of the head (the most essential element in a phrase) within the phrase.
๐ Formula: Universal Grammar = Principles + Parameters โ All possible languages
Topic-142: The Subset Principle
Another way to think about how parameter settings may be made is through what Berwick and Weinberg (1984) call the subset principle. First, think about languages as subsets of one another. Consider word order: English is a very strict word-order language; Russian allows a small set of admissible orders; the aborigine language Warlpiri allows almost total scrambling of word order within a clause.
The idea of a subset is that Russian could be considered a subset of Warlpiri with somewhat more restricted word order. In the same way, with respect to word order, English may be considered a subset of Russian.
๐ Definition โ Subset Principle: A principle for parameter setting where languages are viewed as subsets of one another, with more restrictive languages being subsets of less restrictive ones.
๐ Example: For word order โ Warlpiri (most flexible) โ Russian (moderately flexible) โ English (most restrictive). English is a subset of Russian, which is a subset of Warlpiri.
Topic-143: The Issues of Negative Evidence
One important feature of how the subset principle was formulated deals with the distinction between positive evidence and negative evidence. At the grammatical level, positive evidence is evidence that a particular utterance is grammatical in the language the child is learning; negative evidence is evidence that a particular utterance is ungrammatical.
Children receive positive evidence when exposed to an utterance that is not corrected or otherwise indicated as inappropriate. Children receive negative evidence when someone indicates that a particular utterance is ungrammatical or inappropriate.
Pinker (1990) argues that it would be very difficult to acquire a language from positive evidence alone. Gold found that when he wrote a program in which the computer received only positive evidence, it failed to acquire the language adequately. This was because positive evidence is consistent with a great number of different grammars โ without knowing what is ungrammatical, it is impossible to rule out competing grammars.
Pinker (1990) claims that parents do not provide sufficient negative evidence to enable a child to learn a language. He argues that although negative evidence is sometimes present, it is not systematically and consistently available to all children, yet all normal children acquire language. Therefore, innate linguistic mechanisms, such as the subset principle, are needed to constrain the child's search processes.
Pinker's argument: A: Positive evidence alone is consistent with too many competing grammars. B: Negative evidence, which could constrain the problem space, is not generally available. C: Therefore, some constraints must be innate.
๐ Definition โ Positive Evidence: Evidence that a particular utterance is grammatical in the language the child is learning.
๐ Definition โ Negative Evidence: Evidence that a particular utterance is ungrammatical or inappropriate.
๐ Example: If a child says "I goed to school" and the parent does not correct it, this counts as positive evidence. If the parent says "No, you say 'I went to school,'" that provides negative evidence.
๐ก Why this matters: The poverty of negative evidence argument is foundational for nativist claims โ since children don't receive enough correction to eliminate wrong grammatical rules, innate constraints must guide their learning.
Topic-144: Objections to Innate Mechanisms
Studies of pidgins and creoles suggest the presence of an innate backup grammar, the language bio program. Studies of parameters attempt to specify what linguistic information must be innately present. Studies of negative evidence suggest such evidence is not pervasive enough. All converge on the conclusion that some innate linguistic mechanisms โ in conjunction with environmental and cognitive factors โ must be present for successful language acquisition.
This conclusion has been challenged by Elman, Bates, Johnson, Karmiloff-Smith, Parisi, and Plunkett (1996), who raise objections to innate language mechanisms. They argue that phenomena like Nicaraguan Sign Language do not require a preformationist scenario (a situation where grammar emerges because it was innately specified). They suggest: "If children develop a robust drive to solve this problem, and are born with processing tools to solve it, then the rest may simply follow because it is the natural solution."
Jackendoff has responded that adults also have a 'robust drive' to acquire language, but they acquire pidgins rather than creoles. Thus, something beyond a 'robust drive' seems to be necessary โ and according to Jackendoff, that something is an innate mechanism for acquiring language.
๐ Definition โ Preformationist Scenario: A situation in which grammar emerges because it was innately specified, rather than through general learning mechanisms.
โญ Key Takeaways
The lecture presents compelling evidence for innate mechanisms in language acquisition. Bickerton's Language Bioprogram Hypothesis, derived from studies of Hawaiian creoles, demonstrates that children develop sophisticated grammatical systems from impoverished pidgin input, suggesting a biological backup grammar. Parameter setting within Universal Grammar provides a framework where children are born knowing possible linguistic parameters and simply identify which settings apply to their native language. The Subset Principle and the poverty of negative evidence argument (Pinker, 1990) further support nativist claims โ since positive evidence alone is insufficient and negative evidence is not systematically available, innate constraints must guide acquisition. While some researchers (Elman et al., 1996) object that general learning mechanisms suffice, Jackendoff counters that adults with robust drives acquire only pidgins, not creoles, indicating something specifically linguistic must be innate.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a pidgin and a creole, and how does this distinction support Bickerton's Language Bioprogram Hypothesis?
- Describe the evidence from Hawaiian creoles that led Bickerton to propose an innate language bio program.
- What is parameter setting in Universal Grammar, and how does the head parameter work?
- Explain the Subset Principle and how it relates to the problem of positive versus negative evidence.
- What are the main objections to innate language mechanisms raised by Elman and colleagues, and how does Jackendoff counter these objections?
๐ Lecture 25 โ BRIAN MECHANISM AND LANGUAGE
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the brain mechanisms underlying language by examining different types of aphasiaโlanguage disorders resulting from brain damage. It covers Broca's, Wernicke's, conduction, and other aphasias, along with Geschwind's models of language processing and experimental studies that reveal how syntactic and semantic processes are organized in the brain. Understanding these conditions provides critical insights into normal language processing and the neural basis of comprehension and production.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Broca's aphasia with its characteristic telegraphic speech and agrammatism; Wernicke's and conduction aphasia including symptoms like impaired comprehension, fluent jargon, and repetition deficits; other aphasias such as pure word deafness, alexia, and agraphia; Geschwind's models of language processing for listening, speaking, and reading; experimental studies of aphasia that clarify syntactic versus semantic processing; and implications for understanding the comprehension-production distinction in normal language.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-145: Broca's Aphasia
A person with expressive aphasia exhibits effortful speech that includes important content words but omits function words (prepositions, articles) that have grammatical rather than real-world meaning. This is called "telegraphic speech." The person's intended message may still be understood, but sentences will not be grammatically correct. In severe forms, a person may only speak using single-word utterances. Comprehension is mildly to moderately impaired due to difficulty understanding complex grammar.
Speech in expressive aphasia contains mostly content words such as nouns, verbs, and some adjectives. Function words like conjunctions, articles, and prepositions are rarely used except for "and." The omission of function words makes the person's speech agrammatic. A communication partner may describe the speech as telegraphic due to poor sentence construction and disjointed words.
๐ Definition โ Expressive Aphasia (Broca's Aphasia): A language disorder characterized by effortful, non-fluent speech with preserved content words but omitted function words, resulting in telegraphic and agrammatic speech; comprehension is mildly to moderately impaired.
๐ Example: A person with expressive aphasia might say "Smart... university... smart... good... good..." instead of forming complete grammatical sentences.
Topic-146: Wernicke's and Conduction Aphasia
Common symptoms in patients with Wernicke's aphasia include:
- Impaired comprehension: Deficits in understanding (receptive) written and spoken language because Wernicke's area is responsible for assigning meaning to heard language.
- Poor word retrieval: The ability to retrieve target words is impaired, also called Anomia.
- Fluent speech: Individuals produce connected, flowing speech, but words may not belong together or make sense.
- Production of jargon: Speech that lacks content, has typical intonation, and is structurally intact. Jargon can include neologisms (made-up words) and "word salads"โcombinations of real words that do not make sense together.
- Awareness: Individuals are often not aware of their incorrect productions, so they do not self-correct when producing jargon, paraphasias, or neologisms.
Conduction aphasics show relatively well-preserved auditory comprehension, which may even be completely functional. Spontaneous speech is fluent, grammatically and syntactically correct, with preserved intonation and articulation. Speech often contains paraphasic errors: phonemes and syllables are dropped or transposed.
๐ Definition โ Conduction Aphasia: A language disorder characterized by fluent, grammatically correct speech with paraphasic errors and a hallmark deficit in repetition; patients can paraphrase but cannot repeat words or sentences verbatim.
๐ Example: A conduction aphasic might say "snowall" for "snowball," "vellitision" for "television," or "ninety-twenty percent" for "ninety-five percent."
The hallmark deficit is in repetition. Patients show a marked inability to repeat words or sentences when prompted. After hearing a sentence, they can paraphrase it accurately but cannot repeat it, possibly because "motor speech error processing is disrupted by inaccurate forward predictions, or because detected errors are not translated into corrective commands due to damage to the auditory-motor interface."
Topic-147: Other Aphasias
Pure word deafness is a rare form of aphasia where individuals cannot comprehend language in the auditory modality but can comprehend visual language and produce language in either modality. Anatomically, there is damage to the auditory nerve, which sends messages to auditory centers in the left hemisphere, plus loss of portions of the corpus callosum (the thick band of fibers connecting the two hemispheres) that send messages from the right hemisphere auditory region to Wernicke's area in the left. The result is that neither the left nor right auditory center can transmit information to language regions, so patients can hear words but cannot comprehend them.
Alexia is the dissociation (disconnection) of visual regions from language areas. In its most severe form, it prevents even recognition of individual letters or matching of script and print. Damage to the angular gyrus leads to both alexia and agraphia (the inability to write). The angular gyrus serves as an association area connecting one brain region with another, particularly important for associating visual stimuli with linguistic symbols, influencing both reading and writing. Alexia sometimes occurs without agraphia when damage to the left visual cortex is coupled with injury to the portion of the corpus callosum connecting an intact right visual area with language areas on the left.
๐ Definition โ Pure Word Deafness: A rare aphasia where auditory language comprehension is absent despite intact hearing, visual language comprehension, and language production.
๐ Definition โ Alexia: A language disorder involving loss of the ability to read due to disconnection between visual regions and language areas; may occur with or without agraphia.
๐ก Why this matters: These rare aphasias reveal the specific neural pathways required for different language modalitiesโauditory, visual, and writtenโand show how damage to connecting fibers (like the corpus callosum and angular gyrus) can produce selective deficits.
Topic-148: Geschwind's Models of Language Processing
Geschwind proposed models for three language processes:
1. Listening and understanding spoken words: Sounds of words travel through auditory pathways to the primary auditory cortex (Heschl's gyrus) , then continue to Wernicke's area, where the meaning of words is extracted.
2. Speaking: Meanings of words are sent from Wernicke's area via the arcuate fasciculus to Broca's area, where morphemes are assembled. Broca's area holds a representation for articulating words. Instructions for speech are sent from Broca's area to the facial area of the motor cortex, then to facial motor neurons in the brainstem, which relay movement orders to facial muscles.
3. Reading: Information about written text is sent from visual areas to the angular gyrus and from there to Wernicke's area (for silent reading) or together with Broca's area (for reading out loud).
๐ Definition โ Arcuate Fasciculus: A bundle of nerve fibers connecting Wernicke's area to Broca's area, carrying information about word meanings for speech production.
Topic-149: Experimental Studies of Aphasia
Psycholinguistic research has clarified the role of syntactic and semantic processes in various aphasias. The traditional view held that Broca's (agrammatic) aphasia is a production deficit and Wernicke's a comprehension deficit, assuming that underlying language representation is intact in Broca's patients but they have difficulty translating formulated linguistic messages into words.
Broca's aphasics were thought to conceptualize sentences normally but have difficulty translating them into productive speech. However, data regarding their comprehension abilities challenged this assumption. Many comprehension tests were extremely global and did not clarify the respective roles of syntactic and semantic processes. Moreover, it is possible to disguise comprehension deficits more easily than production deficits.
This was demonstrated in a study by Caramazza and Zurif (1976), who examined comprehension in Broca's, Wernicke's, and conduction aphasics. Patients heard a sentence and had to choose which of two pictures corresponded to the sentence.
๐ Example: Caramazza and Zurif (1976) study designโaphasic patients heard a sentence and selected the matching picture from two options, testing whether comprehension deficits were masked by global test methods.
Topic-150: Implications for Understanding Normal Language Processing
A major distinction in studying normal language processing is between comprehending language and producing it. If this distinction is biologically based, we would expect to see some aphasic cases where comprehension is impaired but production is spared, and vice versa. Initial descriptions of Broca's and Wernicke's aphasias support this comprehensionโproduction distinction, which appears beyond dispute despite more subtle differences between the two cases.
Another intriguing aspect is the sparing of comprehension of axial commands in individuals with Wernicke's aphasia. Although Wernicke's aphasics show many problems in language comprehension, they respond correctly to commands involving midline or axial structures, such as "stand up," "turn around," "take a bow," and "look up" (Geschwind, 1965). For example, patients accurately perform when asked to "stand like a boxer" or "take two steps backward, turn around, and sit down again." What is especially striking is that axial commands sometimes involve specific nouns or verbs that these patients ordinarily fail to comprehend.
๐ก Why this matters: The sparing of axial command comprehension in Wernicke's aphasia suggests that different neural systems may support comprehension of body-centered commands versus other language, revealing how language processing is not a single, unified system.
โญ Key Takeaways
This lecture reveals that different types of aphasia correspond to damage in specific brain regions, each producing distinct language deficits: Broca's aphasia involves effortful, telegraphic, agrammatic speech with relatively preserved content words; Wernicke's aphasia features fluent but meaningless jargon with impaired comprehension; conduction aphasia shows paraphasic errors with a hallmark repetition deficit. Geschwind's models map these onto neural pathwaysโauditory input to Wernicke's area for comprehension, transmission via the arcuate fasciculus to Broca's area for production, and visual input through the angular gyrus for reading. Experimental studies demonstrate that comprehension deficits in aphasia can be subtle and require careful testing to distinguish syntactic from semantic processing. These findings support a biologically based distinction between language comprehension and production, while the sparing of axial command comprehension in Wernicke's aphasia suggests specialized neural systems for body-centered language.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is telegraphic speech and which type of aphasia is it characteristic of?
- What are the five key symptoms of Wernicke's aphasia described in the lecture?
- What is the hallmark deficit of conduction aphasia, and how does it differ from the ability to paraphrase?
- According to Geschwind's model, what are the neural pathways for reading aloud versus silent reading?
- What is the significance of spared axial command comprehension in Wernicke's aphasia for understanding normal language processing?
๐ Lecture 26 โ LATERALIZATION OF LANGUAGE PROCESSES
๐ Overview: This lecture investigates how language functions are distributed across the brain's two hemispheres, focusing on the concept of lateralization. It examines evidence from split-brain patients, normal brains, and studies of brain damage to show that while the left hemisphere is typically dominant for language, the right hemisphere contributes to pragmatic understanding, and that lateralization develops early and is even observed in other species.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers six main topics: split-brain research and the role of the corpus callosum; lateralization in normal brains using visual field and dichotic listening tasks; the contributions of the right hemisphere to pragmatic aspects of language; aphasia in children and evidence from hemispherectomy studies; behavioral and psychological studies on the development of lateralization from infancy; and the development of lateralization in other species, including Japanese macaques and songbirds.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-151: Split-Brain Research
Research on aphasia consistently finds that language deficits are associated with damage to the left hemisphere more often than the right. Studies of animals show that communication between the hemispheres is disrupted by severing the corpus callosum. In these studies, when one hemisphere is taught a specific task, little or no learning is found in the other hemisphere, indicating little or no transfer of information. The goal is to determine what skills are lateralized to one side of the brain or the other.
๐ Definition โ Lateralization: The specialization of cognitive functions (like language) in one hemisphere of the brain, typically the left.
Topic-152: Lateralization in Normal Brains
Techniques for studying the intact brain have increased dramatically. The visual field task used with split-brain patients is also used with normal individuals. Another technique is a dichotic listening task, which involves the simultaneous presentation of different stimuli to the two ears. Initially developed to study attention, it was first used by Kimura (1961) to examine ear and hemisphere differences. Kimura found that recall of verbally presented materials (like digits) was superior in the right ear, and recognition of nonverbal stimuli (like melodies) was better in the left ear.
๐ Definition โ Dichotic Listening Task: A technique where different auditory stimuli are presented simultaneously to each ear to study hemispheric specialization for processing those stimuli. ๐ Key Finding: Right ear advantage for verbal stimuli โ left hemisphere specialization. Left ear advantage for nonverbal stimuli (e.g., melodies) โ right hemisphere specialization.
Topic-153: Contributions of the Right Hemisphere
The right hemisphere has its own talents in the linguistic realm, particularly for pragmatic aspects of language. Normal individuals use the skills of both hemispheres. Kaplan, Brownell, Jacobs, and Gardner (1990) examined individuals with right-hemisphere brain damage and their ability to interpret conversational remarks. Subjects heard vignettes and interpreted an utterance that was either literally true or literally false (e.g., "you sure are a good golfer" said to someone playing poorly). Interpretation depends on the relationship between characters (friendly vs. hostile). Individuals with right-hemisphere damage were as adept at interpreting literally true sentences but were poorer at identifying the pragmatic intent of literally false utterances, having difficulty integrating performance information with relationship information. ๐ก Why this matters: This shows that language comprehension is not solely a left-hemisphere function; the right hemisphere is crucial for understanding non-literal language, sarcasm, and social context.
Topic-154: Aphasia in Children and Hemispherectomy Studies
Lenneberg based his hypothesis on studies of children recovering from brain damage. Basser (1962) found that if brain damage occurs prior to the onset of speech, speech is often delayed but normal in pattern. Damage to the right hemisphere in the first two years of life produces as much disruption as damage to the left. However, if damage occurs after the onset of speech (between 2 and 10 years), left-hemisphere damage causes language disturbances nearly twice as often as right-hemisphere damage. A hemispherectomy (surgical removal of a hemisphere) reveals that removal of the right hemisphere in adults leads to little or no language impairment, while removal of the left leads to significant language problems.
๐ Definition โ Hemispherectomy: A surgical procedure involving the removal of one cerebral hemisphere, used to treat severe conditions like tumors, and providing insights into hemispheric specialization. ๐ Example: In children who sustain brain damage between 2 and 10 years of age, injury to the left side resulted in language disturbances nearly twice as often as injury to the right side.
Topic-155: Behavioral and Psychological Studies
Dichotic listening studies with normally developing children provide a clear picture of lateralization development. Kimura (1963) reported that children as young as 4 to 6 years can produce adult-like right-ear advantages on dichotic tasks. Subsequent studies have found this advantage in children as young as 2 years. Studies of very young infants using the high-amplitude sucking procedure found that the right ear was better at responding to changes in speech, while the left ear was better with changes in musical stimuli.
๐ Definition โ High-Amplitude Sucking Procedure: A method used to study infant perception where a change in sucking rate indicates a response to a new stimulus. ๐ Example: Bertoncini et al. (1989) habituated infants to a sound (sucking rate decreased). When a different sound was substituted, the right ear was better at detecting changes in speech, and the left ear for musical stimuli.
Topic-156: Development of Lateralization & Lateralization in Other Species
It was once thought laterality was exclusively human, but there are now documented cases in other species. Petersen et al. (1978) studied Japanese macaque monkeys and found that all five showed better performance when species-specific vocalizations were presented to the right ear. Only one of five monkeys from other species showed this advantage, suggesting human lateralization is part of a larger pattern. Research on birdsong by Nottebohm (1970) identified three developmental sequences:
- Type 1 (e.g., chickens, ring doves): Develops normal song even if isolated and deafened at birth.
- Type 2 (e.g., song sparrows): Develops normal song if isolated but not if deafened.
- Type 3 (e.g., chaffinches, white-crowned sparrows): Isolation or deafening produces an abnormal song. This third type shows analogs to human speech: a "subsong" period (like babbling), regional dialects, age-dependent effects of deafening, and the left half of the brain is more involved in song. Severing the left hypoglossus nerve (connecting the syrinx to the left brain) seriously disrupts the song, while severing the right side leaves the song intact.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical takeaway is that language is predominantly, but not exclusively, a left-hemisphere function. This is supported by aphasia studies, split-brain research, and dichotic listening experiments which show a right-ear/left-hemisphere advantage for verbal material. However, the right hemisphere is crucial for processing pragmatic aspects of language, such as interpreting sarcasm and integrating context. Lateralization is established very early in life, evident even in infants, and is not unique to humans, as similar patterns of lateralization for species-specific communication are seen in other animals like macaques and songbirds. Finally, evidence from hemispherectomy and childhood aphasia shows that the brain has significant plasticity early in life, allowing for greater recovery from left-hemisphere damage compared to in adulthood.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the corpus callosum, and what happens when it is severed in split-brain research?
- Describe a dichotic listening task and the typical "right-ear advantage" finding. What does this indicate about language lateralization?
- According to Kaplan et al. (1990), what specific linguistic difficulty do individuals with right-hemisphere damage experience?
- What do hemispherectomy studies in adults reveal about the role of each hemisphere in language?
- What evidence from Nottebohm's research on chaffinches suggests that lateralization for communication is not exclusive to humans?
๐ Lecture 27 โ Evolution of Language
๐ Overview: This lecture explores how human language may have evolved, contrasting theories of gradual development from primate communication (continuity) versus sudden emergence (discontinuity). It examines evidence from nonhuman primate communication, attempts to teach language to apes, and the evolutionary sequence of anatomical and social changes that enabled spoken language.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the fundamental debate between continuity and discontinuity theories of language evolution, examines communication systems in present-day primates, reviews attempts to teach language to nonhuman primates (chimpanzees and bonobos), analyzes the continuity debate in light of Darwinian theory, and explores possible evolutionary sequences involving gesture and speech, brain size, and social behavior.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-157: Evolution of Language
Continuity theories are built on the idea that language exhibits so much complexity that one cannot imagine it simply appearing from nothing in its final form; therefore it must have evolved from earlier pre-linguistic systems among our primate ancestors. Discontinuity theories take the opposite approachโthat language, as a unique trait which cannot be compared to anything found among non-humans, must have appeared fairly suddenly during the course of human evolution.
Some theories see language mostly as an innate facultyโlargely genetically encoded. Other theories regard language as a mainly cultural systemโlearned through social interaction.
๐ก Why this matters: This foundational debate shapes how researchers approach the study of language origins and whether we should expect to find precursors of language in other species.
Topic-158: Communication in Present Day Primates
Noam Chomsky, a prominent proponent of discontinuity theory, argues that a single chance mutation occurred in one individual in the order of 100,000 years ago, installing the language faculty (a component of the mid-brain) in "perfect" or "near-perfect" form. A majority of linguistic scholars as of 2018 hold continuity-based theories, but they vary in how they envision language development.
Among those who see language as mostly innate, someโnotably Steven Pinkerโavoid speculating about specific precursors in nonhuman primates, stressing simply that the language faculty must have evolved in the usual gradual way. Others in this intellectual campโnotably Ib Ulbรฆkโhold that language evolved not from primate communication but from primate cognition, which is significantly more complex.
Topic-159: Teaching Language to Nonhuman Primates
Attempts to teach language (or a language-like system of communication) to other primates may be divided into three groups.
In the first group, attempts were made to teach speech to chimpanzees (Hayes & Hayes, 1952; Kellogg & Kellogg, 1933). The vocal apparatus of chimpanzees is not suited to produce speech sounds; consequently, these studies proved very little. In the Hayes's study, the chimpanzee was able to learn only two words in two years of training.
A second group involved programs in which the communication system was not clearly defined in linguistic terms. Premack (1971) used tokens with symbols on them to teach a chimpanzee named Sarah some logical concepts. Although Sarah was able to demonstrate a number of aspects of complex cognition, the results are of uncertain importance to the issue of whether apes can acquire a language because it has not been demonstrated that these symbols have the power or flexibility of human language.
Topic-160: The Continuity Debate
The communication skills of nonhuman primates, studied either in the wild or in the laboratory, fall well short of the full range of human language. In the wild, nonhuman primates display signals that have meaning, but the signals fail to achieve some of the defining characteristics of language. The signals tend to be iconic rather than arbitrary. Moreover, the system of communication is very limited.
In human language, we have a duality of patterning that permits us to construct an infinite set of messages from a small set of meaningless elements. In contrast, the alarm calls of vervet monkeys are global signals that do not consist of elements that can be combined and recombined in different ways. The linguistic skills of chimpanzees and bonobos taught ASL or other language-like systems are more impressive at the level of semantics. However, these laboratory animals do not seem to easily grasp the nuances of syntax, something that all normal children attain without specific instruction in their first few years of life.
Thus, we are compelled to conclude that human language is qualitatively different than the communication systems of nonhuman primates and, by extension, the common species from which humans, chimpanzees, and bonobos evolved. But this observation creates a dilemma: Darwinian Theory is based on the concept of continuity, the notion that evolutionary changes are quantitative rather than qualitative. As Darwin (1871) commented: "There can be no doubt that the difference between the mind of the lowest man and that of the highest animal is immense....Nevertheless, the difference, great as it is, certainly is one of degree and not of kind" (pp. 127โ128).
๐ Definition โ Duality of patterning: The property of human language that permits constructing an infinite set of messages from a small set of meaningless elements.
Topic-161: Gesture and Speech as Possible Evolutionary Sequences
Spoken language developed quite recently in our evolutionary history. When we produce sounds, air is expelled from the lungs and sent through the structures of the vocal tract. We can change the shape of the vocal tract by altering the position of our lips, jaw, tongue, and larynx. The shape and flexibility of our vocal tract are required for the range of sounds found in contemporary languages.
A crucial evolutionary development is the enlargement of the pharyngeal area that lies above the larynx and just below the mouth. In newborn humans and adult chimpanzees, the larynx exits directly into the mouth, whereas in adult humans, it exits into the pharynx. This anatomical difference greatly influences the number of sounds that can be produced. For example, newborns and chimpanzees are physically incapable of producing the vowels [a], [i], and [u], sounds that are found in a wide variety of languages.
Evolution is said to be miserly. The human mouth, throat, and larynx were "designed" for swallowing and breathing, not for speech. In evolutionary terms, speech may be an example of exaptation (Gould, 1980; Gould & Vrba, 1982): It utilizes preexisting physical structures for new functions. In this context, the enlargement of the pharyngeal area has a highly significant consequence. Because in adult humans the passageways are shared among speech, eating, and breathing, the potential for choking on food is much greater than for infants or chimpanzees, which have a smaller pharyngeal area (Lieberman, 1991). This is one indication that language is so vital that we have evolved a speech apparatus that increases our capacity to choke in order to use productive speech.
๐ Definition โ Exaptation: The evolutionary process by which preexisting physical structures are utilized for new functions, such as the vocal tract being used for speech after originally evolving for swallowing and breathing.
Topic-162: Brain Size and Social Behaviour as Possible Evolutionary Sequences
The finding that brain size increased prior to vocal tract changes helps pin down the sequence of evolutionary events but also raises an issue: Why did brain size increase? What selective pressures led to this development?
As Dunbar (1993, 1998) has pointed out, brain size has costs as well as benefits. It is, for one thing, harder to escape from predators when carrying around such a large brain. Dunbar (1998) asserts that "in the absence of any selection pressure, larger brains will not evolve" (p. 93).
Dunbar (1998) suggests that brain size may have increased in relation to group size. As our evolutionary ancestors began to congregate in larger groups, the mechanisms of group cohesion and regulation began to change. That is, we need a mechanism to hold the larger social group together. With smaller groups, grooming served this essential function, and grooming is a pervasive feature of several nonhuman primates, including chimpanzees. With larger groups, some form of communication may have evolved to play this role. Dunbar claims that language evolved to meet this need by enabling one member of the species to communicate with many members of the group simultaneously.
The social cognition hypothesis is that language evolved as a bonding device. Larger group sizes led to larger brains, including brains more capable of inferring the intentions of others, and larger brains ultimately led to language (Dunbar, 1998). If this view is correct, then social pressure is the driving force behind the evolution of language.
๐ Definition โ Social cognition hypothesis: The theory that language evolved as a bonding device because larger group sizes led to larger brains capable of inferring others' intentions, with social pressure as the driving force behind language evolution.
๐ก Why this matters: This hypothesis provides an evolutionary rationale for why language might have been selected for, linking social complexity, brain expansion, and communication.
โญ Key Takeaways
The critical distinction between continuity and discontinuity theories frames the entire debate on language evolution, with most current scholars favoring continuity-based approaches that see language developing gradually from pre-linguistic systems. Evidence from nonhuman primate communicationโboth in the wild and in laboratory language-teaching experimentsโreveals that while some semantic abilities exist, the syntactic complexity and duality of patterning that characterize human language remain uniquely human, creating a dilemma for Darwinian continuity. Anatomically, speech appears to be an exaptation of structures originally evolved for breathing and swallowing, with the enlarged pharyngeal area in adult humans enabling vowel production but increasing choking risk. The social cognition hypothesis offers a compelling explanation for why language evolved, suggesting that increasing group size created selective pressure for larger brains and ultimately for language as a bonding mechanism that allowed one individual to communicate with many others simultaneously.