📘 Lecture 18 — Universal Grammar
📖 Overview: This lecture explores the structure of adverb phrases, how meaning and phrase structure interact through structural ambiguity, and the methods of immediate constituent (IC) analysis. It then introduces phrase structure rules and their limitations, critiques the behaviorist view of language acquisition, and presents evidence for innate language capacity, ultimately leading to Chomsky's theory of transformational grammar and the distinction between deep and surface structure.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the adverb phrase and its syntactic functions as an adverbial and modifier, then examines structural ambiguity through “minimal noun phrases” and phrase structure tests. It explains tree structure diagrams for sentences, followed by a detailed look at Immediate Constituent (IC) analysis, its methods of display, and its flaws (including endocentric vs. exocentric constructions). The lecture then introduces phrase structure rules (PS rules) and their disadvantages, contrasts the behavioristic view (Skinner’s operant conditioning) with arguments for innate language capacity (biological evidence, preordained programs), and concludes with an overview of transformational grammar (TG) and the deep/surface structure distinction.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 103: Structure of Adverb Phrase
An adverb is a word used to modify verbs, adjectives, other adverbs, clauses, or phrases (except determiners modifying nouns). Adverbs provide context by describing how, where, when, in what manner, and to what extent something occurs. While many end in -ly (e.g., quickly), others do not (e.g., fast, well).
🔑 Definition — Adverb: A word that changes, modifies, or qualifies an adjective, verb, clause, another adverb, or any other type of word or phrase (except determiners that directly modify nouns).
- When? She always arrives early.
- How? He drives carefully.
- Where? They go everywhere together.
- In what manner? She eats slowly.
- To what extent? It is terribly hot.
An adverb phrase (AdvP) contrasts with an adjective phrase (AP) because it cannot be contained within a noun phrase:
- ✅ (5) The [AP quite quick] swimmer
- ❌ (6) *The [AdvP quite quickly] swimmer
Unlike APs, AdvPs can roam freely within a sentence without major effect on meaning.
- Quite quickly I saw the swimmer.
- I quite quickly saw the swimmer.
- I saw quite quickly the swimmer.
- ❌ I saw the quite quickly swimmer. (cannot roam into NP)
- I saw the swimmer quite quickly.
💡 Why this matters: The mobility of AdvPs helps us identify their syntactic function and differentiate them from adjective phrases.
Two Syntactic Functions of Adverbs
(1) Adverbial: An adverb functioning as an adverbial can be an adjunct (integrated into the clause), a disjunct (expressing an evaluation, not integrated), or a conjunct (connective function).
🔑 Definition — Adjunct: An adverb integrated with the structure of the clause to some extent.
- They are waiting outside.
- He spoke about it briefly.
🔑 Definition — Disjunct: An adverb not integrated within the clause, semantically expressing an evaluation of what is said.
- Frankly, I am tired.
- Fortunately, no one complained.
- They are probably at home.
🔑 Definition — Conjunct: An adverb with a connective function, indicating the connection between what is said and what was said before.
- If you open all the windows, then I am leaving.
- I have not looked into his qualification. He seems very intelligent, though.
(2) Modifier: Adverbs can modify other parts of speech:
- Modifier of an adjective: That was a very funny film.
- Modifier of an adverb: I have seen so very many letters like that one.
- Modifier of a prepositional phrase: The nail went right through the wall. / His parents are dead against the trip.
- Modifier of a noun phrase (premodifying pronoun/determiner): Nearly everybody came. / Over two hundred survivors. / I paid more than ten pounds for it.
- Intensifiers (e.g., quite, rather), predeterminers (e.g., such), and exclamatory words (e.g., what): It was rather a mess. / I never heard such wickedness. / He was quite some player. / What a fool he is!
Topic 104: Minimal Noun Phrase
A single sequence of words can yield two different sentence structures, each with a different meaning. This is called structural ambiguity.
🔑 Definition — Structural Ambiguity: A situation where one sequence of words can be organized into two different phrase structures, delivering two different meanings.
🔑 Definition — Phrase: A ‘box’ or group of words that functions as a unit in a sentence.
Example: I was reading the letter to John.
Two interpretations (alternative groupings):
- I was reading [the letter to John] (the letter is addressed to John)
- I was reading [the letter] [to John] (I was reading the letter aloud for John)
Replacement Test by ‘it’: If a sequence of words can be replaced by it without significantly changing the meaning, it is a phrase.
- I was reading [the letter to John] → I was reading it ✅
- I was reading [the letter] [to John] → I was reading it [to John] ✅ (The NP the letter is a phrase)
- I was reading [the letter to John] → I was reading (cannot replace the whole verb phrase with it alone)
Movement Test: A phrase can often be moved as a unit.
- I was reading [the letter to John] → [The letter to John] was being read.
- I was reading [the letter] [to John] → [The letter] was being read [to John].
The word it is a pronoun, but more accurately a pro-noun-phrase because it substitutes for a full noun phrase.
💡 Why this matters: These tests reveal the hidden syntactic structure of sentences and explain how ambiguity arises.
Topic 105: Tree Structure for a Sentence
A sentence represents an eventuality — an action, event, or state of affairs.
🔑 Definition — Eventuality: An action, event, or state of affairs; something that happens or something that is.
The sentence separates the type of eventuality (usually represented by the verb) from the abstract or concrete things involved (represented by noun phrases), and the circumstances (often expressed by adverb phrases).
Example: (1) The man in the hat casually gave a slimy fish to Toby.
- Eventuality type: an action of giving (verb: gave)
- Things involved: the man in the hat (giver), a slimy fish (thing given), Toby (recipient)
- Circumstances: casually (adverb phrase)
A tree diagram clearly identifies each component (S → NP VP; VP → V NP PP; NP → DET N ADJ, etc.), showing the hierarchical and linear structure of the sentence.
Topic 106: IC Analysis
The structuralists (American, 1950s) needed to establish grammatical units beyond the morpheme. Their approach was to divide the sentence into immediate constituents (ICs).
🔑 Definition — Immediate Constituent (IC) Analysis: A method of dividing a sentence into two parts (binary), then cutting those parts into two, continuing until the smallest indivisible unit (the morpheme) is reached.
Example: The young man followed a girl.
- First cut: The young man + followed a girl
- Second cut: followed + a girl ; a + girl ; The + young man ; young + man
- Final morphemes: follow + ed
Notation: The || young ||| man | follow ||| ed || a ||| girl. Or: ((The (((young) (man))) ((followed) ((a) (girl))).
Topic 107: Method of Display
The best method of display is a tree diagram where branching shows the division.
Where to make the first cut? The answer lies in expansion.
🔑 Definition — Expansion: A sequence of elements is an expansion of another if it can be substituted for it (the basic procedure in structuralist analysis).
Example: The young man with a paper and followed the girl with blue dress.
- The young man with a paper is an expansion of John: John followed the girl with blue dress.
- followed the girl with blue dress is an expansion of arrived: The young man with a paper arrived.
- Therefore, the first ICs are [The young man with a paper] and [followed the girl with blue dress].
Types of Expansions
- Endocentric Construction: Contains a head — a word for which the whole construction can be substituted. Example: Children (head) can be expanded to American children, three American children, three American children with a dog, those three American children with a dog.
🔑 Definition — Endocentric Construction: A construction that contains an element (the head) for which it can be substituted.
- Exocentric Construction: Cannot be substituted for any of its elements and has no head. Example: with a paper is not an expansion of with, a, or paper.
🔑 Definition — Exocentric Construction: A construction that cannot be substituted for any of its elements and thus has no head.
💡 Why this matters: Endocentricity allows us to talk of noun phrases (with nouns as heads) and verb phrases (with verbs as heads).
Topic 108: Flaws in the ICs
IC analysis has several major flaws:
- Does not identify constituent types: It does not indicate what kind of elements the parts are (e.g., noun phrase, verb phrase) except by implication.
- Does not show headedness: It fails to show that noun phrases are built on nouns, verb phrases on verbs, etc.
- Not generative: It does not tell us how to form new sentences not already attested.
- Ambiguity & Conjunction Problems: Binary cuts are difficult for conjunctions (e.g., men and women — cannot justify a cut between men and and).
- Structural Ambiguities: For The Egyptian cotton shirt, two analyses are possible: (a) [Egyptian cotton] shirt (shirt made of Egyptian cotton) vs. (b) Egyptian [cotton shirt] (a cotton shirt made in Egypt).
- Ambiguity of Scope: The old men and the women can mean either [the old men] and [the women] or [the old men] and [the old women]. These yield different tree structures.
Despite being illuminating for some types of ambiguity, IC analysis is ultimately unsatisfactory because it lacks grammatical labeling and generative power.
Lesson 19: Sentence Presenting
Topic 109: Phrase Structure Rules
What is needed is a generative model that:
- Identifies constituents in grammatical terms
- Changes emphasis from mere description to the specification of possible sentences
🔑 Definition — Labelled Bracketing: A method of bracketing a sentence where each constituent is given a grammatical identification (e.g., DET, N, NP, VP, S).
Example: The man followed a girl.
- Symbol set: DET (determiner), N (noun), V (verb), NP (noun phrase), VP (verb phrase), S (sentence)
- Labelled bracketing:
[S [NP [DET The] N. man]] [VP [V followed] [NP [DET a] N. girl]]]]
Tree Diagram Concepts:
- Nodes: Points joined by the lines
- Terminal Nodes: Nodes on the bottom line
- Dominate: One node is higher in the tree than another
- Immediately Dominates: Joined by a single line
- Dominance: A larger constituent may consist of one or more smaller kinds.
- Precedence: Linear order (e.g., the first NP precedes the VP, the determiner precedes the noun)
Phrase Structure Rules (PS Rules):
(1) S → NP - VP
(2) VP → V - NP
(3) NP → DET - N
(4) V → followed
(5) DET → the, a
(6) N → man, girl
These rules can generate more than one sentence:
- A girl followed the man.
- The girl followed a man.
- A man followed a man.
PS rules differ from traditional grammar in that they are generative, not merely descriptive.
Topic 110: Disadvantages of Phrase Structure Grammar
A phrase structure grammar is essentially a taxonomic model — a grammar of lists and inventories. It is strong in giving structural descriptions but deficient in generative capacity. It fails to account for all the intentions of native speakers.
Processes that pose problems to PS grammar:
- Ambiguities
- Synonymies
- Permutations
- Discontinuous constituents (e.g., particles)
- Remote relationships (e.g., those of cases)
- Concord phenomena
- Co-ordination
Specific failures:
- Passive sentences: The police diverted the traffic. vs. The traffic was diverted by the police. PS rules show by the police and by a country road as identical prepositional phrases, ignoring semantic and case relations.
- Deep meaning: PS grammar cannot capture crucial notions or prevent false, ungrammatical structures.
- Superficially identical structures:
- John is eager to please. (John pleases someone)
- John is easy to please. (Someone pleases John)
- PS rules treat these as identical.
PS grammar lacks the precision, simplicity, elegance, power, insight, and competence of transformational generative (TG) grammar.
Topic 111: Automatic Grammatizator
Every normal human can talk, yet no one has simulated the full language ability of a human. This raises the nature-nurture controversy: is language due to nature (innate) or nurture (learning)?
Noam Chomsky (1959) wrote a devastating review of B.F. Skinner’s Verbal Behavior, which claimed language is a set of habits built up through operant conditioning (training by voluntary responses). Skinner believed language could be explained by identifying “controlling variables” in the external world.
Chomsky made two major criticisms:
- Irrelevance of rat behavior: The behavior of rats in boxes is irrelevant to human language.
- Fundamental misunderstanding: Skinner fundamentally misunderstood the nature of language.
Topic 113: Behavioristic View: The Irrelevance of Rats
Chomsky argued that the simple sequence of events in rat experiments cannot be applied to human language without becoming hopelessly vague.
Example: What controls “Oh what a beautiful picture”? Skinner would say the beauty of the picture “controls” it. But the person might say “It clashes with the wallpaper” or “It’s hideous.” This makes “control” meaningless — you only know what controlled it after hearing the utterance. This is unlike the predictable rat behavior with a fixed response to a stimulus (e.g., a flashing light).
Reinforcement Problem:
- Rats were repeatedly rewarded with food pellets.
- Children do not receive food pellets for correct utterances. Skinner stretched “reinforcement” to include approval, self-reinforcement, and imagined rewards, making the notion “woolly” and incomparable to rat experiments.
Evidence from Roger Brown’s Studies: Parents tend to approve true statements rather than grammatically correct ones.
- A child saying “Teddy sock on” (ungrammatical but true) → approval.
- A child saying “Look, Teddy is wearing a sock” (grammatical but false) → disapproval. If reinforcement worked as Skinner suggested, children would grow up telling the truth but speaking ungrammatically — the opposite happens.
Chomsky used these arguments to show the irrelevance of Skinner’s experiments, though Chomsky’s own ideas may also be outdated.
Topic 114: Is Language Restricted to Humans?
Animals can “talk” in two senses:
- “To utter words” (e.g., talking parrots)
- “To use language in a meaningful way”
Psycholinguists ask: Are humans the only species that possesses language? Are we biologically “articulate mammals”?
Two theories:
- Continuity theory: Human language evolved gradually from primitive animal communication.
- Discontinuity theory: Human language is something quite different from animal heritage.
Charles Hockett’s Design Features: Vocal-auditory channel, arbitrariness, semanticity, cultural transmission, spontaneous usage, turn-taking, duality, displacement, structure-dependence, creativity, and ability to read intentions.
Birdsong: Birds combine notes in indefinite ways but only deal with two aspects: courting a mate and marking territory. They show no creativity.
Crucial Feature: Intention-reading (or mind-reading). Humans are the best at this skill. Some limited awareness exists among apes (e.g., Washoe and Nim in sign language experiments).
Chomsky’s Claim: Language is specific to humans because only humans possess a language acquisition device (LAD) — the universal grammar. Higher apes lack the capacity for the computational structure of human language.
Lesson 20: Constituency Tests
Topic 115: Biological Evidence for Innate Language Capacity
If an animal is innately programmed, there are likely to be biological clues. Humans have several physical differences from other animals that are partial adaptations for language:
- Teeth: Unusual in form (even in height, unbroken barrier)
- Larynx (voice box): Simpler structure than other primates, allowing air to move freely through the nose and mouth
- Brain: Heavier, with more surface folding of the cortex (grey matter). The brains of chimps and humans have superficial similarities.
- Lateralization: Speech centers in the left hemisphere are linked to right-handedness. Most humans are right-handed, and most people’s speech is controlled by the left hemisphere.
Human vocal organs, lungs, and brains are “preset” to cope with speech intricacies, just as monkeys are preset to climb trees.
Topic 116: A Preordained Language Programme
Language emerges at about the same time in children worldwide (between 18th–28th month), suggesting a biological clock sets it in motion.
Characteristics of Biologically Triggered Behaviour (Lenneberg):
- The behaviour emerges before it is necessary.
- Its appearance is not the result of a conscious decision.
- Its emergence is not triggered by external events (though the environment must be sufficiently rich).
- Direct teaching and intensive practice have relatively little effect.
- There is a regular sequence of ‘milestones’ correlated with age.
- There may be a ‘critical period’ for acquisition.
- Language proficiency varies much less than other skills (e.g., knitting, violin).
Child’s Likely Progress Chart:
- Birth: Crying
- 6 weeks: Cooing
- 6 months: Babbling
- 8 months: Intonation patterns
- 1 year: One-word utterances
- 18 months: Two-word utterances
- 2 years: Word inflection
- 2 1/4 years: Questions, negatives
- 5 years: Rare or complex constructions
- 10 years: Mature speech
Children do not manufacture new brain cells after birth. From birth to around 2 years, many more cells interconnect, and brain weight increases from ~300g to ~1000g.
Topic 117: Conceivable Innate Grammatical Information
It is easy to show humans are innately predisposed to acquire language; the hard part is finding out exactly what is innate.
Historical Experiment: Egyptian king Psammetichus theorized language was innate. He isolated children to see what language they would speak. (Not taken seriously today; found children had no speech.)
Chomsky’s View: Children must be endowed with a “rich internal structure” for language acquisition. This contrasts with the “blank sheet” view.
Chomsky’s Assumptions (Aspects of the Theory of Syntax, 1965): Children are endowed with an innate hypothesis-making device guided by language universals — a “blueprint” for language. This includes:
- Semantic rules
- Syntactic rules
- Phonological rules
Children automatically know:
- Language involves two levels of syntax (deep and surface) linked by transformations.
- There are innately inbuilt constraints on the form sentences can take.
Reason: The “primary linguistic data” children are exposed to is likely to be “deficient in various respects.”
Michael Tomasello’s Alternative (Usage-Based Approach): “How children learn language is not a logical problem but an empirical problem.” Language capacity is a conspiracy of cognitive, social-cognitive, information-processing, and learning skills.
Topic 118: Transformational Grammar
Transformational Grammar (TG) or Transformational-Generative Grammar (TGG): A system of rules that generate exactly those combinations of words that form grammatical sentences, involving defined operations called transformations to produce new sentences from existing ones. Largely developed by Noam Chomsky.
Key Development Timeline:
- 1957: Syntactic Structures (first published work)
- 1965: Aspects of the Theory of Syntax (introduced Deep Structure; “Standard Theory”)
- 1970s: Extended Standard Theory (EST)
- 1980s: Lectures on Government and Binding
- Later: Minimalist Program (Deep Structure and Surface Structure no longer featured; only LF — Logical Form and PF — Phonetic Form remain)
Topic 119: The Founder and the Theory
Avram Noam Chomsky (b. Dec 7, 1928) is an American linguist, philosopher, cognitive scientist, and social critic. He is called “the father of modern linguistics” and is a founder of cognitive science.
- Born to middle-class Jewish immigrants in Philadelphia
- Studied linguistics, mathematics, and philosophy at University of Pennsylvania (age 16)
- Harvard Society of Fellows (1951–1955) — developed transformational grammar
- Doctorate in 1955; began teaching at MIT in 1957
- Published Syntactic Structures (1957), which remodeled the scientific study of language
- Created/co-created: Universal Grammar Theory, Generative Grammar Theory, Chomsky Hierarchy
- Played a pivotal role in the decline of behaviorism
- One of the most cited scholars in history
Topic 120: Deep and Surface Structure
The structuralist approach was corpus-bound and broke down because it could not account for ambiguities or inter-relatedness of sentences. An adequate grammar must be productive, complex, and arbitrary.
Key Distinction in TG Grammar:
- Deep Structure: The underlying syntactic structure that determines meaning. It is the kernel sentence (simple, assertive, active).
- Surface Structure: The final syntactic form of a sentence after applying transformations. It may be active/passive, affirmative/negative, declarative/interrogative.
🔑 Definition — Kernel Sentence: A simple, assertive, active sentence that serves as the deep structure from which other sentences are derived.
Examples of Kernel Sentences:
- John is playing football.
- I wrote a letter.
- You spoke the truth.
Non-Kernel Sentences (derived by transformations):
- Is John playing football? (Interrogative)
- John is not playing football. (Negative)
- A letter was written by me. (Passive)
- Who wrote the letter? (Question form)
- Why did you speak the truth? (Question form)
- You spoke the truth when you were forced. (Complex)
- You did not speak the truth. (Negative)
- You spoke the truth but told a new story. (Compound)
Transformational analysis shows inter-relatedness and resolves ambiguities:
*Example: Structural Ambiguity Flying planes can be dangerous. *
- Deep Structure 1: Some people fly planes. This can be dangerous. (deep: someone flies planes)
- Deep Structure 2: Planes fly. They can be dangerous. (deep: planes fly)
*Example: I expected John to hit a six. * vs. I asked John to hit a six.
- Deep: I expected (something). John hits a six.
- Deep: I asked John (something). He hits a six.
*Example: John is eager to please. * vs. John is easy to please.
- Deep: John is eager (for something). He pleases (someone).
- Deep: It is easy. Someone please John.
A kernel sentence (deep structure) has a string of transformation rules applied to it to generate the surface structure.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The lecture establishes that adverb phrases are mobile modifiers that cannot appear within noun phrases, and that meaning depends on invisible phrase structure organization revealed by replacement and movement tests. Structural ambiguity arises when one word string can be grouped into different phrases. Immediate Constituent (IC) analysis provides binary segmentation but is flawed because it lacks grammatical labeling and generative power — it cannot explain how new sentences are formed or resolve deep ambiguities. This leads to Phrase Structure Rules, which are stronger descriptively but still fail to capture relationships between passive/active, question/declarative, or semantically identical but structurally distinct sentences (e.g., John is eager/easy to please). The lecture then contrasts Skinner’s behaviorist view (language as operant conditioning) with Chomsky’s evidence for innate capacity: biological adaptations (brain lateralization, vocal tract), a regular developmental sequence (6 weeks to 10 years), and the failure of simple reinforcement to explain grammatical truth. Finally, Transformational Grammar resolves PS grammar’s deficiencies by positing Deep Structure (kernel sentences) and Surface Structure, with transformations linking them to account for synonymy (active/passive) and structural ambiguity.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the key syntactic difference between an adjective phrase (AP) and an adverb phrase (AdvP) in terms of noun phrase insertion? Give an example of a violation.
- Using the sentence “I was reading the letter to John,” explain how the replacement test (by it) and the movement test reveal two different phrase structures and thus structural ambiguity.
- What are the three major limitations of Immediate Constituent (
📘 Lecture 21 — Constituents I: Words Order
📖 Overview: This lecture introduces the foundational concepts of syntax within traditional grammar, focusing on how sentences are structured from constituents. It explores the classification of words into grammatical categories (lexical and functional), the properties of each category, and the basic grammatical functions and clause types. Understanding this framework is essential for analyzing sentence structure and lays the groundwork for more advanced syntactic study.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining syntax as the study of sentence structure and introduces the key concept of constituents. It then delves into grammatical categories, subdividing words into lexical/substantive categories (nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs, prepositions) and functional categories (determiners, quantifiers, pronouns, auxiliaries, complementisers). Finally, it covers grammatical functions like subjects, predicates, complements, and adjuncts, and concludes with a discussion of different clause types based on finiteness, mood, and force.
📝 Lecture Summary
Topic 121: Introduction
Grammar is traditionally divided into morphology and syntax. Morphology studies word formation (e.g., antidisestablishment-arianism), while syntax studies how words are structured into phrases and sentences. Traditional grammar uses a taxonomy (classificatory list) to describe syntactic structures. A central assumption is that sentences are built from constituents (syntactic units), each belonging to a specific grammatical category and serving a specific grammatical function. For example, in the sentence Students protested, "Students" is a plural noun functioning as the subject, and "protested" is a past tense verb functioning as the predicate. The overall sentence is a finite declarative clause, stating a fact.
💡 Why this matters: The idea of constituents is the foundation of all syntactic analysis; we must be able to identify these building blocks before we can understand how they combine.
Topic 122: Grammatical Categories
In traditional grammar, words are assigned to grammatical categories (parts of speech) based on their:
- Semantic properties (meaning)
- Morphological properties (different forms)
- Syntactic properties (word-order positions)
Words are divided into two types:
- Content words: Have substantive lexical content (e.g., car, tall, increase). They often have antonyms.
- Function words (functors): Serve to mark grammatical properties and have little or no descriptive content (e.g., they, me). They have no obvious antonyms.
Corresponding to these are two kinds of grammatical categories: lexical/substantive categories (for content words) and functional categories (for function words).
Topic 123: Lexical/substantive categories
The main lexical categories are Noun (N), Verb (V), Adjective (A), Adverb (ADV), and Preposition (P).
🔑 Definition — Noun (N): A word that denotes an entity (e.g., bottle, water, John).
- Count nouns (e.g., chair) have singular and plural forms.
- Mass nouns (e.g., furniture) are uncountable.
- Common nouns (e.g., boy) can be modified by a determiner (the boy), whereas proper nouns (e.g., Andrew) generally cannot (the Andrew).
- Syntactic property: Only a noun can complete the sentence They have no... (e.g., car).
🔑 Definition — Verb (V): A word that denotes an action or event (e.g., eat, sing, resign).
- Syntactic property: Only a verb (in its infinitive form) can complete They/It can... (e.g., stay).
- Morphological property: Regular verbs have four forms: bare (cry), present tense (cries), past/participle (cried), and progressive participle (crying).
🔑 Definition — Adjective (A): A word that denotes a state or attribute (e.g., ill, happy, big).
- Syntactic property: Can complete They may be... (e.g., tired).
- Can be modified by a degree word like very (e.g., very happy).
- Morphological property: Many have comparative (-er) and superlative (-est) forms (e.g., big, bigger, biggest).
🔑 Definition — Adverb (ADV): A word that denotes the manner of an action (e.g., well in She sings well).
- Morphological property: Often formed by adding -ly to an adjective (e.g., sad → sadly).
- Syntactic property: Only an adverb can end a sentence like She behaved... (e.g., badly).
🔑 Definition — Preposition (P): A word that marks location (e.g., in, on, under).
- Syntactic property: Can be modified by right or straight (e.g., right down the stairs).
- Morphological property: Invariable/uninflected (e.g., no past tense offed).
Topic 124: Functional category
Functional categories include items like determiners, quantifiers, pronouns, and auxiliaries.
🔑 Definition — Determiner (D): Includes the definite article the and demonstratives (this/that/these/those).
- Semantic property: They determine specific semantic properties of the noun expression, often marking it as a definite referring expression (e.g., the car refers to a specific, known car).
🔑 Definition — Quantifier (Q): Denotes expressions of quantity (e.g., some, all, every, many). The indefinite article a is also a quantifier.
🔑 Definition — Pronoun (PRN): An item that 'stands in place of' a noun expression (e.g., he/him, one).
- The word one (e.g., a blue one) is a pronominal noun (N-pronoun).
- Other pronouns can function as Q-pronouns (some) or D-pronouns (those).
- Personal pronouns (I/me/we/us/you/he/him/she/her/it/they/them) can function as D-pronouns (e.g., We republicans).
🔑 Definition — Auxiliary (verb): Marks grammatical properties like tense, aspect, voice, or mood.
- Syntactic property: Unlike main verbs, auxiliaries can be inverted with their subject in questions (e.g., It is raining → Is it raining?).
- Types include perfect/progressive auxiliaries (have/be), passive voice auxiliary (be), dummy auxiliary (do), and modal auxiliaries (can/could/may/might/will/would/shall/should).
- Auxiliaries belong to the category T (tense-marked auxiliary). The infinitive particle to (e.g., to be impeached) is also a T constituent, specifically a nonfinite, infinitival tense marker.
Topic 125: Complementisers
Complementisers (= C) are functors that introduce complement clauses.
- 🔑 That introduces a finite declarative clause.
- 🔑 If introduces a finite interrogative clause.
- 🔑 For introduces an infinitival irrealis clause (relating to a hypothetical event).
💡 Why this matters: Complementisers tell us crucial information about the clause they introduce: if it is finite or not, and what its force (statement, question, hypothetical) is.
Using these categories, we can label words in a sentence:
- [D The] [N president] [T is] [ADV clearly] [V feeling] [A angry] [C that] [N Congress] [T has] [V refused] [T to] [V negotiate] [P with] [PRN him]
Grammatical features describe differences within a category (e.g., she = [3rd person, singular, feminine, nominative]; us = [1st person, plural, accusative]).
The main grammatical functions are subject (S) and predicate (which can contain a verb and its complements). A complement is an entity directly involved in the action (e.g., a direct object). A verb with a direct object is transitive.
- Subjects and complements are arguments of the predicate.
- A predicate with one argument is one-place (e.g., resign), with two is two-place (feel + remorse), and with three is three-place (send + Mary + flowers).
- Adjuncts are optional elements that provide additional information (e.g., after dinner).
- Sentences can be complex, containing more than one clause.
Topic 126: Types of clauses
Clauses can be finite or non-finite.
- Finite clauses contain a verb that shows tense (e.g., She writes/wrote).
- Non-finite clauses contain a verb that does not show tense, like infinitives (to write), present participles (writing), and past participles (written).
- Finite clauses can have a nominative subject (he), while non-finite clauses cannot (they may have an accusative subject like him or a silent subject).
Grammatical mood is a verb feature that signals modality (the speaker's attitude).
- Indicative mood: Denotes a real event (e.g., he apologised).
- Subjunctive mood: Denotes a hypothetical or unreal event (e.g., he apologise in She demanded that he apologise).
Each clause also has a specific force:
- Declarative: Makes a statement (e.g., He went home).
- Interrogative: Asks a question (e.g., Are you feeling OK?).
- Imperative: Issues a command (e.g., You be quiet!).
- Exclamative: Expresses surprise (e.g., What a great idea that is!).
In a complex sentence, each clause has its own force (e.g., main clause declarative, complement clause interrogative). The primary goal of traditional grammar is description, not explanation.
⭐ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes the descriptive vocabulary of traditional syntax. You must be able to identify the two main word types (content and function) and assign words to their correct lexical or functional categories (N, V, A, ADV, P, D, Q, PRN, T, C) based on their semantic, morphological, and syntactic properties. Understanding the difference between subjects, predicates, complements (arguments), and adjuncts is crucial for analyzing sentence structure. Finally, you need to distinguish between finite and non-finite clauses, and between different moods and clause forces (declarative, interrogative, imperative, exclamative).
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two main types of words in traditional grammar, and what is the primary difference between them?
- List four different functional categories and give one example of a word for each.
- What is the key syntactic property of an auxiliary verb that distinguishes it from a main verb?
- Explain the difference between a complement and an adjunct, using an example sentence to illustrate each.
- What does it mean for a clause to be "finite," and what kind of subject can it have?