π Lecture 1 β What is Morphology?
π Overview: This lecture introduces the field of morphology, the branch of linguistics concerned with the internal structure of words and how they are formed. It establishes foundational concepts such as the morpheme, types of words, and the key distinction between inflection and derivation, setting the stage for understanding how languages build and organize their vocabularies.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an introduction to morphology and its central questions, defining the morpheme and related terms like morph, stem, root, and affix. It then explores morphology in action through novel words and abstract morphological facts across languages. The discussion moves to different types of words (phonological, grammatical, lexemes), empirical tests for wordhood, and the crucial distinction between inflection and derivation. Finally, it introduces two major approaches to morphology (Item-and-Arrangement and Item-and-Process) and the concept of the lexicon.
π Lecture Summary
Topic 01: Introduction
Morphology is the study of form or forms. In linguistics, it refers to "the mental system involved in word formation" or "the branch of linguistics that deals with words, their internal structure, and how they are formed." According to Fabregas & Scalise, morphology studies the grammatical properties of words and how words relate to each other in a language. The chief task of morphology is to understand relationships between words like deep and deepen or dog and dogs, where pieces like -en (forms a verb meaning 'cause to become x') and -s (makes a plural) are identified. The central question in morphology is: how are words related to each other?
Topic 02: Morpheme
A morpheme is 'the smallest linguistic piece with a grammatical function.' It can be a word like hand or a meaningful piece of a word like the -ed in looked. Another definition is 'a pairing between sound and meaning,' though some morphemes have no concrete form or no conventional meaning. The term morph refers specifically to the phonological realization of a morpheme. For example, the past tense morpheme -ed has various morphs: [t] as in jumped, [d] as in repelled, and [ed] as in rooted. A stem is a base unit to which another morphological piece is attached (e.g., disagree is the stem of disagreement). A root is like a stem but refers only to morphologically simple units (e.g., agree is both the stem and root of disagree). Affixes are pieces like re- and -ation. Besides prefixes and suffixes, there are infixes (inserted inside a root, like -um- in Tagalog s-um-ulat 'one who wrote') and circumfixes (attached around a stem, like ke-...-an in Indonesian ke-besar-an 'bigness').
Topic 03: Morphology in Action
Morphology is active in everyday life through novel words and word play, as in the Toni Braxton lyric "Unbreak my heart, uncry these tears." Humans have a capacity for generating and understanding new words, often building them from pre-existing pieces (e.g., hobbitish from hobbit + -ish). While entirely new words like J. R. R. Tolkien's hobbit are rare, novel words formed from existing parts are common.
Topic 04: Abstract Morphological Facts
Languages display abstract morphological rules. For example, English requires a plural morpheme on nouns after numbers greater than one ("two melons a day"), while languages like Indonesian or Japanese do not use a plural suffix in such contexts. English has irregular past tense forms (say β said, not say + -ed). Ancient Greek and Manam distinguish singular, dual, and plural (and even trial in Manam), showing that number distinctions are not universal.
Topic 05: Background & Beliefs
Foundational beliefs in morphology include: 1) languages (small-l) differ from one another; 2) individual languages are different from Language (capital-L, the universal human capacity); 3) morphology is a distinct component of grammars. Methodological beliefs include skeptical realism and a motto of "anything goes" β a no-holds-barred, not strictly theory-based approach to linguistics.
Topic 06: Intro to Morphological Analysis
Two basic approaches are Analysis (breaking words down) and Synthesis (building words up). Four principles guide morphological analysis:
- Principle 1: Forms with the same meaning and sound shape in all their occurrences are instances of the same morpheme.
- Principle 2: Forms with the same meaning but different sound shapes may be instances of the same morpheme if their distributions do not overlap (i.e., they are allomorphs).
- Principle 3: Not all morphemes are segmental (they can be processes like stress change).
- Principle 4: A morpheme may have zero as one of its allomorphs provided it has a non-zero allomorph (e.g., sheep has a zero plural allomorph alongside the non-zero plural -s).
Topic 07: What is a Word?
Defining a "word" is challenging. Syntactically, a word is a minimal unit that can stand alone (like Tomorrow), unlike affixes (My is not a valid stand-alone answer). Phonologically, words are the domain of stress assignment. The term grammatical word (or morphosyntactic word) refers to different forms of a single word that occur depending on syntactic context (e.g., coughs is a grammatical word form of the lexeme cough).
Topic 08: Types of Words
Linguists distinguish:
- Phonological word: A string of sounds that behaves as a unit for stress/ accent. Items like the and for are not phonological words; they are clitics (phonologically dependent on adjacent words). Proclitics precede their host (e.g., 's in Mary's here), and enclitics follow it.
- Content words (nouns, verbs, adjectives, most adverbs) vs. Function words (pronouns, auxiliary verbs, determiners, prepositions): Function words carry grammatical meaning.
- Lexeme: A theoretical construct corresponding to one sense of the word "word." For example, dog1 (canine) and dog2 (U-shaped device) are separate lexemes.
Topic 09: Empirical Tests for Wordhood
Several tests identify words:
- Fixed order of elements: Morphemes within a word have a fixed order (unbreakable, not breakableun), unlike sentences where word order can change.
- Non-separability and integrity: Words cannot be broken up by inserting other material (a white shirt is a phrase, but a shirt is a word; you cannot say a white doghouse by inserting white into the word doghouse). Syntactic processes cannot apply to parts of words (Which school did you see bus? is ungrammatical, showing school bus is one word).
- Stress: Stress patterns can distinguish compounds from phrases (e.g., hot dog as a compound has a single stress pattern).
Topic 10: Inflection vs. Derivation
Inflection forms grammatical variants of a single lexeme (e.g., is, are, being from be; select, selects, selected, selecting). It is dictated by sentence structure and does not change lexical meaning or category. Derivation creates a new lexeme from an existing one (e.g., bookshop from book + shop; un+ do* from do; sadly from sad). Derivation typically changes meaning or lexical category, while compounding (a special type of derivation) creates one lexeme from two or more.
Topic 11: Two Approaches to Morphology
Hockett identified two approaches:
- Item-and-Arrangement (I&A) : Sees morphology as a set of elements (items) and the patterns in which they are arranged. Books results from concatenating book and -s.
- Item-and-Process (I&P) : Sees complex words as resulting from operations (processes) on simpler words. Books results from the function "make plural" applied to book. I&A and I&P are mathematically almost equivalent. However, non-affixal phenomena (like vowel change in sing, sang, sung) are more naturally represented in I&P than in strict I&A-based frameworks.
Topic 12: The Lexicon
The lexicon is the mental dictionary. Two views: 1) a list of morphemes (indivisible units); 2) a list of irregular or arbitrary forms (Bloomfield). Evidence suggests complex forms like representative and even inflected forms like says (which has an irregular pronunciation [sΞ΅z]) are stored. The lexicon contains more than words: affixes, compounds, fixed phrases (with respect to), names, and proverbs. The most accurate conception is that the lexicon is a list of forms you know β your linguistic memory β including irregular and unpredictable elements.
β Key Takeaways
A morpheme is the smallest meaningful linguistic unit, and its phonological realizations are called morphs. The fundamental distinction is between inflection (grammatical forms of the same lexeme) and derivation (creating new lexemes), which has implications for meaning and category change. Words can be identified through tests like non-separability and stress, and they are categorized as phonological words, grammatical words, or lexemes. Two major approaches, Item-and-Arrangement and Item-and-Process, offer complementary ways of analyzing complex words, and the lexicon is best understood as a speaker's mental store of irregular and unpredictable forms, not just a list of simple morphemes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a morpheme and a morph? Give an example for each from the English past tense.
- Explain the distinction between inflection and derivation using the words walks and walker as examples.
- What three empirical tests can be used to determine whether a sequence like school bus is a single word or a phrase?
- According to the lecture, what is the most accurate conception of the lexicon, and why must it include complex forms like says or representative?
- How do Item-and-Arrangement and Item-and-Process approaches differ in their analysis of the word unthinkable?
π Lecture 5 β Words & its Forms: Inflections
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental distinction between word forms and lexemes, explaining how inflections create grammatically conditioned variants of words. It covers regular and irregular inflection across nouns, pronouns, determiners, verbs, and adjectives, establishing the foundational concepts needed to understand English morphology.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers words and grammar, distinguishing between lexemes and word forms. It then explores regular and irregular inflection, examining the forms of nouns, pronouns and determiners, verbs, and adjectives. Each section details the specific inflectional patterns and irregularities within English morphology.
π Lecture Summary
Topic: 25: Words and grammar
Some complex words have predictable meanings and need not be listed as separate lexical itemsβthey are merely grammatically conditioned variants of a more basic word. For example, performs, performed, and perform are all inflectional variants of the same abstract word, called a lexeme. A lexeme is the abstract kind of word of which word forms are inflectional variants. Being abstract, a lexeme cannot be uttered or pronouncedβonly its word forms can be. We refer to lexemes by their bare, unaffixed forms. The same word form can belong to two different lexemes (e.g., rows meaning "lines of seats" vs. "propels a boat"), and one lexeme may be represented by multiple word forms. What links a word form with a lexeme in a given context is the grammatical word that the word form expresses there.
π Definition β Lexeme: An abstract word of which individual word forms (e.g., performs, performed, perform) are inflectional variants; it is not something that can be uttered directly. π Definition β Word form: The actual, pronounceable variant of a lexeme that appears in a sentence. π Example: In "This pianist performs every week" and "This pianist performed last week," performs and performed are word forms of the lexeme perform.
Topic: 26: Regular and irregular inflection
Words like performs and pianists do not need dictionary listing because they are grammatically conditioned variants of one lexeme. Two independent reasons explain this: first, any countable noun (like pianist or cat) will predictably have a plural form meaning 'more than one X'; second, unless otherwise specified, the plural is formed by adding the suffix -s (or its allomorphs). This is the regular method of forming plurals. However, some nouns form plurals irregularly: child > children, tooth > teeth, man > men. Dictionaries must list these irregular plurals (e.g., tooth noun (plural teeth)). The different plural suffixes (-s, -en, -ae, -i) and vowel changes (like in men, teeth) can all be considered allomorphs of a single 'plural' morpheme. The key question is how much phonological divergence is acceptable for something to count as one morpheme. To avoid confusion, it is often better to use terms like 'root,' 'suffix,' and 'prefix' rather than 'morpheme.'
π Definition β Regular inflection: A predictable pattern of forming inflected words (e.g., adding -s for plurals) that applies to most words in a class. π Definition β Irregular inflection: An unpredictable pattern of forming inflected words (e.g., vowel change in tooth/teeth) that must be listed in dictionaries. π Example: Pianist β pianists (regular, predictable); Child β children (irregular, must be listed in a dictionary).
Topic: 27: Forms of nouns
Most countable nouns in English have two word forms: a singular and a plural. For any noun lexeme, there are two grammatical wordsβ'singular of X' and 'plural of X'βcontrasting in number. The regular plural suffix is -s. Irregular plural suffixes include -i, -ae, -a (from Latin/Greek), -(r)en (in oxen, children), and Hebrew -im (in cherubim). Some nouns express plurality with a vowel change (e.g., teeth, men)βa different allomorph of the root. Others, called zero-plural nouns, show no change at all (e.g., sheep, fish, deer, trout). Whether these are singular or plural is determined by syntactic context. A few nouns, like scissors and pants, exist only in a plural form (pluralia tantum), creating problems for contexts requiring a singular form (e.g., we cannot say a scissorsβinstead, we use the periphrastic form pair of scissors).
π Definition β Number: The grammatical distinction between singular and plural forms of a noun. π Definition β Zero-plural: A noun whose singular and plural forms are identical (e.g., sheep, deer). π Example: The noun cat has two forms: singular cat and plural cats. The noun deer is zero-plural: "A deer was visible" (singular) vs. "Two deer were visible" (plural).
Topic: 28: Forms of pronouns and determiners
Morphology is mainly concerned with open classes (nouns, adjectives, verbs, adverbs) whose membership can grow. Determiners are a closed class, but some display a singularβplural contrast: this/these and that/those. This shows that number contrasts can affect grammar within noun phrases and between subjects and verbs. Personal pronouns exhibit case inflection: he/him, she/her, we/usβwhere he and him contrast in case (nominative vs. accusative), not number. This is a suppletive relationship (phonologically unrelated forms). Possessive forms like his, our, my may be analyzed as a third case (the genitive or possessive) or as determiners. These words cannot combine with other determiners (e.g., the my hat is ungrammatical).
π Definition β Case: An inflectional category (e.g., nominative, accusative, genitive) that marks the grammatical function of a noun or pronoun in a sentence. π Definition β Suppletion: The use of phonologically unrelated forms to express grammatical contrasts within a paradigm (e.g., good/better, go/went). π Example: "He loves her" vs. "She loves him." He and she are nominative forms; him and her are accusative forms. The lexeme we has forms we (nominative) and us (accusative).
Topic: 29: Forms of Verbs
An English verb lexeme has at most five distinct forms, illustrated by give:
- Third person singular present tense: gives (e.g., Mary gives a lecture.)
- Past tense: gave (e.g., Mary gave a lecture.)
- Progressive participle: giving (e.g., Mary is giving a lecture.)
- Perfect or passive participle: given (e.g., Mary has given a lecture. The lecture is always given by Mary.)
- Basic form: give (e.g., Mary may give a lecture.)
The present/past contrast is tense. The third person singular also marks person and number. Most verbs have only four forms because the past tense and perfect participle are identical (e.g., performed). This is called syncretism. Irregular verbs (about 150) do not use the -ed suffix. The verb be is highly irregular, distinguishing eight forms, while modals like must have only one.
π Definition β Syncretism: When two distinct grammatical words are expressed by the same word form (e.g., past tense and perfect participle in performed). π Formula: Verb lexeme forms = basic form, -s form (3sg present), -ing form (progressive participle), past tense form, perfect/passive participle form. π Example: The verb perform has four forms: perform (basic), performs (3sg present), performing (progressive participle), performed (past tense AND perfect/passive participle).
Topic: 30: Forms of adjectives
Many English adjectives exhibit three forms for comparison: positive (green), comparative (greener), and superlative (greenest). This is expressed by the regular suffixes -er and -est, except for suppletive forms like better and best. This belongs to inflectional morphology because in certain grammatical contexts, the comparative or superlative form is required (e.g., This field is greener than that oneβgreen would be ungrammatical). However, not all adjectives can take these suffixes. Longer adjectives require periphrastic forms using more or most (e.g., more fertile, most fertile). Broadly, -er/-est appear on one-syllable adjectives and some two-syllable adjectives ending in a vowel (e.g., tidy, yellow); longer adjectives require periphrasis.
π Definition β Comparative: The form of an adjective used to compare two entities, typically marked by the suffix -er. π Definition β Periphrastic forms: Multi-word phrases used to express grammatical categories that could otherwise be expressed by inflectional suffixes (e.g., more interesting instead of interestinger). π Example: Positive: "Grass is green." Comparative: "The grass is greener now." Superlative: "The grass is greenest in early summer." For fertile, we use periphrasis: "more fertile," "most fertile."
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is the distinction between lexemes (abstract word units) and their word forms (actual utterances). Inflectional morphology creates grammatically conditioned variants of lexemesβthese are predictable and systematic, not arbitrary. Students must memorize the five possible verb forms and recognize that syncretism (where past tense and perfect participle are identical) is the norm for regular verbs. For nouns, the key is understanding the difference between regular -s plurals, irregular plurals (vowel change, -en, etc.), and zero-plural nouns. Adjective inflection involves a three-way contrast (positive/comparative/superlative) that requires periphrasis for longer words. Finally, the lecture establishes that pronouns are unique: they show case inflection via suppletion, unlike other word classes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a lexeme and a word form? Provide an example using the verb run.
- List three types of irregular noun plurals in English and give an example of each.
- What is syncretism in verb morphology? Which two grammatical words are syncretized for regular English verbs?
- When must a speaker use periphrastic forms (more/most) instead of the comparative/superlative suffixes -er/-est for adjectives?
- Which word class in English uses case inflection? Give an example of a nominative/accusative pair.
π Lecture 12 β Morphological Productivity and the Mental Lexicon
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of morphological productivity, which describes how certain word-formation patterns are more likely to generate acceptable new words than others. It explores how productivity relates to language structure, the constraints that limit it, and how it is tested experimentally. The lecture also connects these ideas to the mental lexicon, psycholinguistics, and the ongoing debate about how complex words are stored and processed in the human mind.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the definition of morphological productivity and the concept of potential words, using examples of English plurals and negative prefixes like non-, un-, and in- to illustrate the relationship between productivity and semantic transparency. It then discusses degrees of productivity and the various phonological, morphological, syntactic, and semantic constraints that limit it. The summary of experimental methods for testing productivity, particularly the study of the suffixes -ness and -ity, is followed by an introduction to the mental lexicon, psycholinguistics, and neurolinguistics. Later sections cover the relationship between morphology and syntax, including the difference between morphological and syntactic inflection, structural constraints on inflection, and grammatical-function-changing phenomena like passive, causative, and applicative constructions. The final part addresses the acquisition of morphology, sources of experimental and naturalistic evidence, models of morphological knowledge (including dual-system and analogy-based models), and the processing of complex words via direct and indirect routes.
π Lecture Summary
Topic: 67: What is Morphological Productivity?
Morphological productivity refers to the probability that a potential word formed by a given morphological pattern will be accepted as a valid word in a language. For example, English has several plural forms (cats, oxen, deer, mice), but when encountering a novel word like argaz (a Hebrew crate) or smick (a cracker), a speaker is most likely to add the suffix /-z/ (e.g., argazes, smicks). Only a word like ceratopus might be pluralized as ceratopi on the Latin pattern. This illustrates that while a potential word could exist, it may or may not be accepted. Studying productivity involves investigating why some patterns (like -ness) are more productive than others (like -th). A key debate is whether productivity is part of linguistic competence (Chomsky's term for a speaker's internal knowledge of language). Some argue it is not, as productivity is probabilistic rather than an "all or none" structural rule.
π Definition β Potential word: A word that could exist in a language (it is formed by a rule or pattern) but is not yet an actual, established word. π Example: Mugglehood βthe state of being a non-wizardβ is a potential word created from Muggle and -hood, which was not in common use but could become an actual word over time.
Topic: 68: Productivity and Structure β Negative Prefixes in English
Productivity can reveal information about language structure. A more productive derivational process tends to have a compositional meaning that is transparently predictable from its parts. In contrast, a less productive process is more likely to result in non-compositional, idiosyncratic meanings. This is illustrated by the English negative prefixes non-, un-, and in-. Zimmer (1964) found non- to be the most productive and semantically transparent. For instance, non-Christian simply means βnot Christianβ, while unchristian can mean βnot behaving in a Christian mannerβ or βbarbaricβ. Similarly, non-human means βnot humanβ, but inhuman means βlacking human qualities like pityβ. Non- is a logical or contrary negator (represented as Β¬ Christian), whereas un- and in- are contradictory negators, meaning βopposite of Xβ. This pattern extends to other affixes: the more productive -ness has more transparent semantics than the less productive -ity, as seen in the pair collectiveness vs. collectivity.
π Definition β Compositional meaning: A meaning that is predictable from the meanings of the individual parts of a word or phrase. π Example: Collectiveness (from -ness) has a transparent meaning ('the quality of being collective'), while collectivity (from -ity) also has an additional, less transparent meaning ('the people considered as a body').
Topic: 69: Degrees of Productivity
Morphological processes are not simply productive or unproductive; they exist on a scale of productivity. Many constraints limit productivity:
- Phonological constraints: The Modern Hebrew pet-name suffix -le attaches only to bases ending in a vowel. The English suffix -al attaches only to verbs stressed on the final syllable (e.g., arrival, denial). The suffix -ish attaches mostly to monosyllabic adjectives (e.g., greenish).
- Morphological constraints: A process may require a base to have a certain structure. The suffix -ish often attaches only to unsuffixed bases.
- Syntactic constraints: The base must belong to a specific lexical category. The English prefix re- attaches only to verbs.
- Semantic constraints: Barker (1998) found that the English suffix -ee (advisee, employee) is constrained by three factors: (1) the referent of the -ee noun must be sentient; (2) the referent is typically characterized by a lack of volitional control; and (3) the -ee noun and its stem must be episodically linked (e.g., a lessee must have a specific leasing event). The less productive rule often serves a linguistic purpose, creating words that sound more technical or stand out.
π Definition β Episodic link: A relationship where a specific event (e.g., a leasing) must qualify an individual (e.g., a lessee) for the derived noun to be used correctly.
Topic: 70: Testing Productivity
Researchers use various tools to test productivity, including dictionaries, corpora, and advanced techniques like PET scans. Aronoff and Schvaneveldt (1978) conducted an experiment to verify if productivity is part of linguistic competence. They tested the suffixes -ness (native English) and -ity (Latin-Romance) because -ness is more productive. Subjects were presented with three sets of words: (i) actual words (listed in the dictionary), (ii) possible words (where the stem existed but not the suffixed form), and (iii) non-words (where neither stem nor suffix existed). Over 141 subjects judged words from randomized lists. The results showed that speakers preferred actual words in -ity (balanced for frequency), showed no preference for non-words, and preferred -ness words for potential words. This demonstrates that speakers can distinguish between a more productive and a less productive rule.
π‘ Why this matters: This experiment shows that productivity is not just an abstract linguistic notion; it reflects a psychological reality in the minds of speakers.
Topic: 71: The Mental Lexicon
Psycholinguistics and neurolinguistics (or cognitive neuroscience) study the mental lexiconβthe dictionary of words stored in a language user's brain. A key distinction is between the lexicon itself (storage) and how it is used in word recognition (associating a speech/writing signal with a lexical entry) and word production (selecting the right words to speak). Most early research focused on written word recognition, but spoken word recognition is now seen as more fundamental. Most psycholinguists assume there is a single mental lexicon accessed by both recognition and production, but it is studied indirectly through these processes.
π Definition β Psycholinguistics: The study of the psychological and neurobiological factors that enable humans to acquire, use, and understand language.
Topic: 72: Psycholinguistics and Neurolinguistics
A key challenge is understanding how morphological information is represented in the brain. For example, in Kujamaat JΓ³ola, vowel harmony requires all vowels in a word to be either tense or lax. Morphemes that only have tense vowels likely have one stored form, but morphemes that alternate might be stored as two allomorphs or processed by a mental rule that changes lax vowels to tense. Psycholinguists devise experiments to determine which is the case. A broad consensus has emerged that morphological structure is present in the mental lexicon, regardless of whether individual words are stored as whole units or decomposed. This leads to the debate between single-route and dual-route models of lexical access. A related finding is the frequency effect: more frequent words are recognized faster. For example, clean is recognized faster than glean because it is about thirty times more common.
π Example: An English speaker will recognize the common word clean more quickly than the less common word glean.
Topic: 73: Morphology and Syntax
Morphosyntax studies the interaction between morphology and syntax. According to the traditional view, morphology builds word forms (by combining roots and affixes), and syntax takes these fully inflected words as input to build phrases and sentences. This suggests a strict division of labor where morphology operates below the word level and syntax above it, with syntax taking over after morphology is complete.
Topic: 74: Morphological vs. Syntactic Inflection
There is a key difference between how morphologists and syntacticians define inflection.
- For a morphologist, inflection requires the existence of multiple forms of a lexeme. If a lexeme has only one form, there is no morphological inflection. For example, Chinese and Vietnamese have no morphological inflection because lexemes are invariant.
- For a syntactician, inflection can be abstract, even if not overtly realized. A syntactician may say a verb in Chinese abstractly agrees with its subject, even though the verb form never changes.
Key Differences:
| Morphological Inflection | Syntactic Inflection |
|---|---|
| Realized overtly (has a visible form). | May or may not be overt (can be abstract). |
| Properties must be expressed by bound forms (e.g., affixes) or other morphophonological means. | May be realized by free forms (e.g., auxiliary verbs like will, must). |
π Example: English modals (may, could, will) are considered syntactic inflection by syntacticians but are not morphological inflection because they are separate words, not bound forms.
Topic: 75: Structural Constraints on Morphological Inflection
The realization of inflectional morphology can be constrained by syntactic context. Examples include:
- Russian: Verbs show gender agreement with their subject only in the past tense.
- Hebrew: Verbs agree in gender with their subjects only in the present tense.
- Kujamaat JΓ³ola: Subject agreement is obligatory except in past subordinate and positive imperative verb forms.
- Balanta: Verbs agree with their subjects only when no subject noun phrase is present, or the subject is focused.
- Arabic: Verbs agree with their subjects in number only when the word order is Subject-Verb (SV), not when it is Verb-Subject (VS). In VS order, a default 3rd-person singular form is used.
Topic: 76: Inflection and Universal Grammar
Universal Grammar (Chomsky) proposes that all languages are identical at some level of analysis. A key question is whether inflectional categories themselves are universal. While categories like tense, aspect, mood, voice, agreement, number, gender, and case appear frequently across languages, their realizations are highly variable. For example, the number of noun classes (genders) in languages of the Atlantic family varies from 7 (Balanta) to 25 (Gombe Fula). Despite this variation, universal principles likely govern what is inflectionally possible. For instance, nouns are regularly inflected for case, number, and gender, while verbs are inflected for tense, aspect, mood, voice, or agreement.
π Definition β Universal Grammar: A theory developed by Noam Chomsky that all human languages share a fundamental, innate structure at some abstract level of analysis.
Topic: 77: Grammatical Function Change
Grammatical function change refers to alternations in the grammatical encoding of a verbβs arguments (e.g., subject, object). Examples include:
- Passive: The subject of the verb is the patient (e.g., The law was broken). The agent can be expressed as an adjunct (e.g., by the governor).
- Antipassive: The object of a transitive verb is either omitted or expressed in an oblique case. The verb becomes intransitive.
- Causative: The subject causes an event. This can be expressed by a separate verb (make), an affix, or a verb that inherently means βcause to Xβ (kill means βcause to dieβ).
- Applicative: A morpheme is added to a verb, allowing it to take an additional object, often a beneficiary. English lacks a dedicated applicative affix but uses verb-preposition compounds (outran).
- Noun Incorporation: A noun stem is compounded with a verb stem to form a new, derived verb (e.g., babysit).
Topic: 78: Productivity in Grammatical Function Change
Grammatical-function-changing phenomena like passive and causative demonstrate the productivity of syntax, as they can be applied to a wide range of verbs. They represent a very close interaction between morphology and syntax.
Topic: 79: Morphology and Mind
This section focuses on how morphological knowledge is represented in the human mind, a key topic in the debate on the nature of linguistic rules. A central theme is the balance between storage and computation. For example, to use the word books, we can either retrieve the entire form from memory or compute it by adding -s to book. Understanding this choice helps reveal the nature of human cognition. Empirical research uses both naturalistic data (e.g., corpora, speech errors) and experimental data (e.g., lexical decision tasks). Statistical and probabilistic data are crucial for modeling morphological knowledge.
Topic: 80: The Use of Mental Lexicon
A speaker's mental lexicon differs from a dictionary in three key ways:
- Vocabulary size: A mental lexicon contains far fewer words than a dictionary. It includes a large passive vocabulary (words you understand) and a smaller active vocabulary (words you use). It is also more dynamic, containing neologisms (new words) not yet in dictionaries.
- Word relationships: Words in the mental lexicon are linked in a web of semantic (e.g., symphony for sympathy), phonological, and morphological similarities.
- Frequency information: The mental lexicon stores frequency information for each word. High-frequency words have higher activation levels and are recognized faster. This leads to the cumulative frequency effect and the base frequency effect, where the frequency of a root word (e.g., book) contributes to the activation of its inflected forms (e.g., books).
π Example: The high-frequency word nice is recognized more quickly than the low-frequency word opaque.
Topic: 81: Acquisition of Morphology
Children acquire morphological rules in stages. Research by Berko (1958) on English past tense forms identified a three-stage U-shaped learning curve:
- Stage I: Children learn past tense forms by rote, producing correct forms for both regular (asked) and irregular (went) verbs.
- Stage II: Children discover the regular rule (add -ed) but overgeneralize it, producing incorrect forms like goed instead of went.
- Stage III: Children have acquired both the rule and the set of exceptions (irregular verbs), once again producing correct forms like asked and went.
In other domains, children discover case marking early and coin new words from a very young age, though they may violate the principle of conventionality (which gives priority to established words).
Topic: 82: Sources of Evidence
Evidence for how morphology is represented in the mind comes from:
- Experimental data: Lexical decision tasks (judging if a string of letters is a real word) are often combined with priming. In morphological priming, a morphologically related word (e.g., calculate) is presented before the target word (e.g., calculation) to see if it speeds up recognition.
- Naturalistic data: This includes speech errors (e.g., the freezes out of the steaker shows that the morphological structure of freezer is accessible) and language deficits like aphasia (e.g., Broca's aphasics may struggle with regular plurals but retain high-frequency irregular ones), which provide evidence for different processing modules.
Topic: 83: Models of Morphological Knowledge
Several models explain how morphological knowledge is organized:
- Dual System Model: Proposes two separate systems: a rule-based system for regular forms (e.g., past tense -ed) and a memory-based system for irregular forms (e.g., sing-sang). In this model, the rule for the regular past tense is always applied; irregular forms are stored and linked associatively. This explains why patterns like -ing/-ang/-ung can be extended to new verbs (e.g., bring-brang). Neurological evidence (PET scans) suggests these two systems may be processed in different parts of the brain.
- Single System Model (Bybee): All word forms (both regular and irregular) are listed in the lexicon. Regularities are captured by abstract schemas built from sets of words, rather than by strict rules.
- Analogy-based Model: New forms are created by analogy with existing words, without an abstract rule. For example, the word seascape was coined by analogy with landscape (land : sea = landscape : seascape).
Topic: 84: Morphological Processing
Complex words can be processed via two routes:
- Direct Route: The whole word is retrieved directly from the mental lexicon. This is faster for high-frequency words.
- Indirect Route: The word is parsed into its constituent morphemes (e.g., book + -s), and the meaning is computed. This is necessary for novel or low-frequency words.
The morphological race model proposes that both routes race against each other, and the fastest one determines the result. The relative frequency of the complex word compared to its base also affects which route is more efficient. For instance, dazzlement (lower frequency than dazzle) is more likely to be parsed, while government (higher frequency than govern) is more likely to be accessed directly. This model also explains why high-frequency irregular forms (like went) are maintained, as their direct-route access is faster than computing the rule (goed).
β Key Takeaways
Morphological productivity is a gradient, not a binary, property, meaning some word-formation patterns are more likely than others to create acceptable new words. This productivity is closely tied to semantic transparency; more productive processes like -ness and non- yield more predictable meanings than less productive ones like -ity and un-. Productivity is constrained by phonological, morphological, syntactic, and semantic factors, and speakers can intuitively distinguish between more and less productive rules. The mental lexicon is a dynamic, frequency-sensitive, and interconnected network where morphological structure is present, and models of its representation range from dual-system (rule vs. memory) to single-system (analogy). Finally, complex words can be processed either by direct retrieval from the lexicon or by parsing them into morphemes, with the choice depending on factors like word frequency.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a morphological contrary negator (like non-) and a contradictory negator (like un- or in-), and how does this relate to productivity?
- Name and briefly explain the four types of constraints that limit morphological productivity.
- According to the three-stage model of acquisition, what is overgeneralization, and why does it create a U-shaped learning curve?
- Describe the key difference between morphological inflection and syntactic inflection, using the English modals as an example.
- What is the "morphological race model," and what factors determine whether the direct or indirect route is faster for processing a complex word?