๐ Lecture 19 โ PHONATION
๐ Overview: This lecture explores the process of phonation, which describes the forms of vibration of the vocal folds (voicing) within the larynx. It explains how different states of the glottis create distinct voice qualities such as voiced, voiceless, creaky, and breathy sounds, and emphasizes how voicing distinguishes consonants and changes word meanings.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture introduces phonation as the technical term for voicing and laryngeal activity, explaining the role of the larynx and vocal folds. It details the states of the glottis that produce different voicing features, describes four main phonation types (voiceless, voiced, creaky, and breathy), and examines how voicing functions as a distinctive feature for consonants, particularly obstruents.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-095: Introduction to Phonation
The position of the larynx (sound box) and the vocal folds inside it are crucial for describing speech sounds. Phonation is the technical term for the forms of vibration of the vocal folds, more commonly known as voicing. The glottis (the space between the vocal folds) can assume various shapes, such as voiced, voiceless, murmuring, and creaky positions. The most common positions describe consonants as either voiceless (vocal folds apart, e.g., /p/, /t/) or voiced (folds nearly together and vibrating, e.g., /b/, /g/). These glottal states are important for describing sounds in specific languages and pathological voices.
๐ Definition โ Phonation: The technical term for describing the forms of vibration of the vocal folds (or vocal cords); the process is more commonly known as voicing. ๐ Definition โ Glottis: The space between the vocal folds.
Topic-096: Phonation Explanation
Phonation is a general term in phonetics for any vocal activity in the larynx. The main phonatory activities are the various kinds of vocal-fold vibration (voicing or phonation). The study of phonation types accounts for laryngeal possibilities like voiced, voiceless, breathy, and creaky voice. Some phoneticians include modifications from variations in length, thickness, and tension of the vocal folds, seen in different speech registers. During phonation, air passes between the vocal folds, and modification to the air passage creates variation in intensity, frequency, and quality of the sound, playing an important role in voicing and murmuring.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding phonation explains how the larynx physically modifies air to produce different voice qualities and sound variations.
Topic-097: States of the Glottis
The space between the vocal folds (glottis) can assume a number of positions, modifying speech sounds. The contact of vocal folds and the shape of vibration produce phonation or voicing. Based on the nature of vibration, the states of the glottis are determined, causing differences in pitch, loudness, and voice quality. A narrow opening between the vocal folds produces friction noise, found in whispering and the glottal fricative /h/. A more widely open glottis is found in most voiceless consonants. Four possible states of the glottis are listed in Table 6.6 of the course book.
Topic-098: Phonation Types
There are four main possible glottis/larynx settings or types of phonation:
- Voiceless โ Folds are open apart, air passes freely through the glottis (e.g., /t/, /p/).
- Voiced โ Folds are tight together and vibrate during air passage through the glottis (e.g., /b/, /d/).
- Creaky voice โ Slight opening in the front, arytenoid cartilages are tight together, so vocal folds vibrate only at the anterior end (small opening at the top).
- Breathy or murmuring sound โ Vocal folds are apart but still vibrating; a breathy voice is like a whisper except with voice.
๐ Definition โ Creaky voice: A phonation type where there is a slight opening in the front and the arytenoid cartilages are tight together, allowing vocal folds to vibrate only at the anterior end. ๐ Definition โ Breathy voice: A phonation type where vocal folds are apart but still vibrating, producing a sound like a whisper except with voice.
Topic-099: Voicing and Consonants
Voicing is an important feature of speech sounds used for description and distinction. Sonorants (vowels, nasals, and approximants) are usually voiced, though voicing may be weak or absent in particular contexts. Obstruents (fricatives and plosives) may be voiced or voiceless and are the most frequently found sounds with both voicing and voicelessness. Voiced and voiceless distinctions can make a phonemic distinction in languages like English, changing the meaning of a word. A glottal stop is only an allophonic variation, used in RP before /p, t, k/, and in some dialects these can be replaced by a glottal stop. The symbol for a glottal stop is [ส].
๐ Definition โ Obstruents: A class of speech sounds (fricatives and plosives) that can be voiced or voiceless. ๐ Definition โ Glottal stop: An allophonic variation in RP occurring before /p, t, k/, represented by the symbol [ส].
โญ Key Takeaways
Phonation is the technical term for voicing, describing the vibration of vocal folds in the larynx. The glottis can assume different states, producing four main phonation types: voiceless, voiced, creaky, and breathy. These states affect pitch, loudness, and voice quality, and are crucial for describing consonants. Voicing is a phonemic distinction in English, especially for obstruents (fricatives and plosives), where it can change word meaning. The glottal stop [ส] is an allophonic variation in RP, often before /p, t, k/.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the technical term for the process of vocal fold vibration, and what is its more common name?
- Name the four main states of the glottis or types of phonation described in the lecture.
- Which class of speech sounds (obstruents or sonorants) most frequently shows both voiced and voiceless forms?
- What is the symbol for a glottal stop, and in what context does it appear in RP English?
- How does a voiceless sound differ from a voiced sound in terms of the position and activity of the vocal folds?
๐ Lecture 20 โ Voice Onset Time (VOT)
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces Voice Onset Time (VOT), a key acoustic measure in phonetics that captures the timing of vocal-fold vibration relative to the release of a plosive (stop) consonant. VOT is crucial for distinguishing voicing and aspiration patterns across languages, and it provides a scientific basis for comparing stop sounds in different linguistic systems.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining Voice Onset Time (VOT) and explaining how it relates to voiced, voiceless, and voiceless aspirated plosives. It then discusses the importance of VOT in experimental phonology, language comparison, and bilingual perception, including examples from English and Navajo. Finally, it describes the three types of VOT: zero (unaspirated voiceless), positive (aspirated), and negative (voiced), with a figure illustrating the VOT continuum.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-100: Voice Onset Time (VOT)
All human languages distinguish between voiced and voiceless consonants, with plosives (stops) being the most common consonants to use this distinction. However, the timing of voicing relative to articulation is critical. In the case of aspiration, the beginning of full voicing is delayed after the release of a (usually voiceless) plosive. This delay (or lag) is measured scientifically as voice onset time (VOT). The onset of voicing may also precede the release, called a lead, resulting in fully or partially voiced plosives. Both cases are represented on the VOT scale: positive values (lag) and negative values (lead), with a third possibility of zero VOT.
๐ Definition โ Voice Onset Time (VOT): The point in time at which vocal-fold vibration starts in relation to the release of a closure during the production of plosive sounds. ๐ Formula: VOT = time of voicing onset โ time of plosive release โ Positive values = voicing after release (lag); negative values = voicing before release (lead); zero = voicing at release. ๐ Example: In English, the /p/ in โpinโ has a positive VOT (approximately 50โ60 ms), while the /b/ in โbinโ may have a negative or zero VOT.
Topic-101: VOT Explanation
To understand VOT, three types of plosive sounds must be explained: voiced, voiceless unaspirated, and voiceless aspirated. During the production of a fully voiced plosive (e.g., /b/ or /g/), the vocal folds vibrate throughout. In a voiceless unaspirated plosive (e.g., /p/ or /t/), there is a delay (lag) before voicing starts. In a voiceless aspirated plosive (e.g., /pสฐ/ or /tสฐ/), the delay is much longer, depending on the amount of aspiration. This delay is called VOT, and it varies from language to language.
Topic-102: Importance of VOT
VOT is an important feature in experimental phonology used to analyze the nature of different languages and their stop sounds. Languages vary in VOT, and the delay (lag or VOT) is key for comparing languages. It also provides insight into perception of VOT by bilingual learners. Language-specific VOT values are important for language experts, and VOT values can reveal phonemic contrast in sound production by learners. VOT is calculated using a specific methodology, and contrastive features must be considered.
๐ก Why this matters: VOT is not just a theoretical measureโit directly affects how speakers of different languages perceive and produce stop consonants, which is critical for language learning and cross-linguistic studies.
Different languages choose different points along the VOT continuum when forming oppositions among stop consonants. These possibilities are shown on a scale from most aspirated (largest positive VOT) to most voiced (largest negative VOT). For example, the Navajo aspirated stops have a very large VOT value, exceptional at 150 ms, while the normal VOT for English stressed initial /p/ is between 50 and 60 ms.
Topic-103. Types of VOT
There are three possible types of VOT based on the nature of stop sounds:
- Simple unaspirated voiceless stops: VOT is at or near zero โ voicing of the following vowel begins at or near the release of the stop.
- Aspirated stops followed by a vowel: VOT is greater than zero, called positive VOT. The length of VOT corresponds to aspiration: longer VOT = stronger aspiration (e.g., Navajo at 150 ms, compared to English at 50โ60 ms).
- Voiced stops: VOT is noticeably less than zero, called negative VOT โ the vocal cords begin vibrating before the stop is released.
โญ Key Takeaways
Voice Onset Time (VOT) is a fundamental acoustic measure that captures the timing of vocal-fold vibration relative to plosive release, allowing for a precise distinction among voiced, voiceless unaspirated, and voiceless aspirated stops. VOT values can be positive (lag), negative (lead), or near zero, and these values vary systematically across languages (e.g., Navajo aspirated stops have a large positive VOT of 150 ms, while English /p/ has about 50โ60 ms). VOT is crucial for experimental phonology, language comparison, and bilingual speech perception, as it reveals phonemic contrasts and helps explain how different language systems organize stop consonant oppositions. The three VOT typesโzero (unaspirated), positive (aspirated), and negative (voiced)โcover the full range of possibilities found in human languages.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What does Voice Onset Time (VOT) measure, and how is it calculated?
- What are the three types of VOT, and what does each indicate about the nature of a stop sound?
- How does the VOT of English stressed initial /p/ compare to that of Navajo aspirated stops?
- Why is VOT important for studying bilingual learners?
- What does a negative VOT value indicate about the production of a plosive?
๐ Lecture 21 โ Consonantal Gestures - I
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of consonantal gestures, treating speech sounds not as static points of articulation but as dynamic articulatory movements with inherent timing. It explains how experts describe and categorize unfamiliar sounds from various languages by focusing on articulatory targets and different types of gestures, including stops, nasals, and fricatives.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the definition of consonantal gestures and how sounds are treated as abstract movement patterns rather than exact locations. It then explores articulatory targets, explaining that traditional place names denote targets rather than fixed points. Several types of articulatory gestures are detailed, including bilabial, labiodental, dental, alveolar, retroflex, palato-alveolar/palatal, velar, pharyngeal, and epiglottal gestures. Finally, it provides a detailed examination of stops, nasals, and fricatives as gestural categories, with examples from English and other languages.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-104: Consonantal Gestures
In phonetics and phonology, speech sounds (segments) using basic units of contrast are defined as gestures โ they are treated as the abstract characterizations of articulatory events with an intrinsic time dimension. Thus sounds are the underlying units represented by classes of functionally equivalent movement patterns. The purpose is to enhance the ability of experts to describe unfamiliar sounds of various languages, clarifying variation between varieties of a language and among different languages and language families. So involving the place and manners of articulation, sounds are treated as gestures rather than exact locations and manners.
Topic-105: Articulatory Targets
A number of possible places of articulation used in world languages have been defined so far. The traditional terms for places of articulation are not just names for particular locations; they should be thought of as names for articulatory targets. Many non-English sounds involve using gestures where the target or place of articulation is different from any similar sound found in English. For others, it is the type of gesture or the manner of articulation that is different. Experts illustrate these different types of targets by considering how each place of articulation is used in English and other languages for making stops, nasals, and fricatives.
Topic-106: Types of Articulatory Gestures
Based on the definition of gesture as a possibility of articulation of various speech sounds in contrast with English ones, the possible types are given here:
-
Bilabial gesture โ very common in English (e.g., stops and nasal: p, b, m). In some languages (such as Ewe of West Africa), bilabial fricatives contrast with labiodental fricatives. The symbols for the voiceless and voiced bilabial fricatives are [ษธ, ฮฒ]. These sounds are pronounced by bringing the two lips nearly together so there is only a slit between them.
-
Labiodental fricatives โ many languages including English have the labiodental fricatives [f, v]. Probably no language has labiodental stops or nasals except as allophones of the corresponding bilabial sounds. In English, a labiodental nasal, [ษฑ], may occur when /m/ occurs before /f/, as in emphasis or symphony.
-
Dental sounds are present in British and American English, e.g. dental fricatives [ฮธ, รฐ], but there are no dental stops, nasals, or laterals except allophonically realized before [ฮธ, รฐ] as in eighth, tenth, wealth. Many speakers of French, Italian, and languages like Urdu, Pashto, and Sindhi typically have dental stops such as [tฬช, dฬช].
-
Alveolar are very common targets โ stops, nasals, and fricatives all occur in English and many other languages at alveolar as a target of articulatory gestures (e.g., t, d, n, l, r).
-
Retroflex is very common in many Pakistani languages, made by curling the tip of the tongue up and back so the tongue tip moves during sounds such as [ษณ, ล, ษฒ, ส, ษฝ]. These are also a feature of Indian English.
-
Palato-alveolar and palatal are also possible articulatory gestures. Similarly, velar sounds found in Urdu and other Pakistani languages include [x, ษฃ] which are velar fricatives. The gestures for pharyngeal (such as Arabic pharyngeal fricative [ส]) and epiglottal sounds (such as epiglottal fricative [สข]) involve pulling the root of the tongue or the epiglottis back toward the back wall of the pharynx. These sounds are found in Arabic and other Semitic languages.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these diverse gestural targets is crucial for accurately describing and transcribing sounds from languages beyond English.
Topic-107: Stops
Typical stop sounds are found in English and other languages, but there are interesting types found elsewhere. The following table shows how rich stop sounds are in various languages:
| Description | Symbol | Language |
|---|---|---|
| Voiced | b | English and other languages |
| Voiceless unaspirated | p | -do- |
| Aspirated | pสฐ | Sindhi and many other Pakistani languages |
| Murmured (breathy) | bสฑ | Sindhi |
| Implosive | ษ | Sindhi |
| Laryngealized (creaky) | bฬฐ | Hausa |
| Ejective | kสผ | Hausa |
| Nasal release | dn | Russian |
| Prenasalized | nd | Swahili |
| Lateral release | tษฌ | Navajo |
| Ejective lateral release | tษฌสผ | Navajo |
| Affricate | ts | German |
| Ejective affricate | tsสผ | Navajo |
๐ Definition โ Stop: A speech sound produced by completely blocking the airflow in the vocal tract, which can vary in voicing, aspiration, and release type across languages.
Topic-108: Nasals
Nasal manners of articulation are commonly found in world languages. Like stops, nasals can occur voiced or voiceless (for example, in Burmese, Ukrainian, and French), though in English and most other languages nasals are voiced. Voiceless nasals are comparatively rare. They are symbolized by adding the voiceless diacritic [ ฬฅ ] under the symbol for the voiced sound. There are no special symbols for voiceless nasals; it is written as /mฬฅ/ โ a combination of the letter for the voiced bilabial nasal and a diacritic indicating voicelessness.
Topic-109: Fricatives
Fricative as an articulatory gesture may be divided into voiced or voiceless sounds, but we can also subdivide fricatives according to other aspects of the gestures that produce them. Some authorities divide fricatives into sounds like [s], where the tongue is grooved so the airstream comes through a narrow channel, and those like [ฮธ], where the tongue is flat and forms a wide slit. A slightly better way is to separate them on a purely auditory basis. Say the English voiceless fricatives [f, ฮธ, s, ส]. The two with the loudest high pitches are [s, ส]; they differ from [f, ฮธ] in this way. The same difference occurs between [z, ส] and [v, รฐ]. The fricatives [s, z, ส, ส] are called sibilant sounds. They have more acoustic energy โ greater loudness โ at a higher pitch than other fricative sounds.
๐ Definition โ Sibilant: A type of fricative sound (e.g., [s, z, ส, ส]) characterized by greater acoustic energy and higher pitch loudness due to a grooved tongue channeling the airstream.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical point is that speech sounds are best understood as articulatory gestures โ dynamic movements with intrinsic timing โ rather than static points or manners. The traditional terms for places of articulation should be thought of as articulatory targets, which may vary across languages. Students must recognize that languages differ greatly in their stop inventories (e.g., aspirated, implosive, ejective, murmured stops in Sindhi, Hausa, and Navajo) and that nasals can be voiceless in some languages despite being predominantly voiced in English. Finally, fricatives can be subdivided auditorily into sibilants ([s, z, ส, ส]) which have more acoustic energy and higher pitch, and non-sibilants ([f, ฮธ, v, รฐ]).
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What does it mean to treat speech sounds as "gestures" rather than as exact articulatory locations?
- Give an example of a non-English bilabial fricative, and name a language that uses it.
- List three types of stop sounds found in Sindhi that are not found in English.
- How are voiceless nasals symbolized in phonetic transcription? Provide an example.
- What auditory feature distinguishes sibilant fricatives like [s, z, ส, ส] from non-sibilant fricatives like [f, ฮธ]?
๐ Lecture 22 โ Consonantal Gestures-II
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of articulatory gestures for English consonants, focusing on trills, taps, flaps, and laterals. It also provides a comprehensive summary of how different consonant sounds are classified based on shared articulatory features, emphasizing the gestural approach in phonology.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers trills, taps, and flaps as approximant sounds found in world languages, including their varying articulatory gestures and lengths. It then discusses laterals as a distinct articulatory gesture, with special attention to the English lateral /l/. Finally, it summarizes the articulatory gestures for consonants, explaining how sounds are categorized into classes based on shared features and gestures, including primary and secondary articulation.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-110: Trills, Taps and Flaps
In approximants, trills, taps, and flaps are commonly found with different articulatory gestures in the world languages. These languages vary not only in the nature of the sounds (such as making it a usual /r/ approximant or unusual rhotic approximate [ษน] found in American English) but also in the length of the sound (some making it a short trill, others a long one). The following table covers various types of these approximant sounds found in the world languages:
๐ Definition โ Trill: An articulatory gesture where one articulator (e.g., the tongue tip or uvula) is set into vibration by the airstream, producing a rapid series of taps.
๐ Definition โ Tap: A single, quick contact between an articulator (e.g., the tongue tip) and the roof of the mouth, with the movement being a single ballistic gesture.
๐ Definition โ Flap: A sound similar to a tap, but the articulator (e.g., the tongue tip) strikes the roof of the mouth in a downward (retroflex) motion.
| Type | IPA Symbol | Language Example |
|---|---|---|
| Voiced alveolar trill | r | Spanish |
| Voiced alveolar tap | ษพ | Spanish |
| Voiced retroflex flap | ษฝ | Hausa |
| Voiced alveolar approximant | ษน | English |
| Voiced alveolar fricative trill | ษป | Czech |
| Voiced uvular trill | ส | French |
| Voiced uvular fricative or approximant | ส | Parisian French |
| Voiced bilabial trill | ส | Kele |
| Voiced labiodental flap | * | Margi |
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these different approximant gestures is crucial for accurately producing and transcribing sounds from languages other than English, particularly for field linguists and phoneticians.
Topic-111: Laterals
As an important articulatory gesture, the centralโlateral opposition can be applied to all these manners of articulation, producing a lateral stop and a lateral fricative as well as a lateral approximant, which is by far the most common form of lateral sound. The only English lateral phoneme, at least in British English, is /l/ with allophones [l] as in led [lษd] and [ษซ] as in bell [bษษซ]. In most forms of American English, initial [l] has more velarization than is typically heard in British English initial [l]. In all forms of English, the air flows freely without audible friction, making this sound a voiced alveolar lateral approximant. It may be compared with the sound [ษน] in red [ษนษd], which is for many people a voiced alveolar central approximant. Laterals are usually presumed to be voiced approximants unless a specific statement to the contrary is made.
๐ Definition โ Central-lateral opposition: The distinction between sounds where air flows over the center of the tongue (central) versus sounds where air flows around the sides of the tongue (lateral).
๐ Definition โ Lateral approximant: A sound produced by placing the tongue tip on the alveolar ridge while allowing air to escape freely around one or both sides of the tongue.
๐ Example: The English /l/ has two allophones:
- Clear [l] โ in initial position, e.g., led [lษd]
- Dark [ษซ] โ in final position, e.g., bell [bษษซ]
Topic-112: Summary of the Articulatory Gestures
A number of sounds share various features of speech production in which the underlying units are represented by classes of functionally equivalent movement patterns (gestures). A particular gesture gradually increases its influence on the shape of the vocal tract, thus making many sounds similar in terms of articulatory features. Speech segments are modeled as sets of gestures that have their own intrinsic temporal structure, allowing them to overlap one way or the other. In the sections on various stop sounds in world languages, we studied 13 types of stop sounds (i.e., b, p, pสฐ, bสฑ, ษ, bฬฐ, kสผ, dn, nd, tษฌ, tษฌสผ, ts, tsสผ) and nine types of trill, tap and flap (together one category of approximants) sounds (i.e., r, ษพ, ษฝ, ษน, ษป, ส, ส, ส, *) with a range of similarities in terms of their articulatory gestures. These examples show that the articulatory gestures for consonants have a wide range of possibilities of similar sounds in world languages.
๐ Definition โ Gesture: A functionally equivalent movement pattern used in speech production, with its own intrinsic temporal structure.
Topic-113: Explaining the Summary of the Articulatory Gestures
Based on a matrix of features specifying a particular characteristic of a segment and relating that particular characteristic to other similar sounds has made possible a range of similar sounds to be classified in the same class of segments. For example, an โoral gestureโ would specify all supraglottal characteristics (such as place and manner of articulation), and a โlaryngeal gestureโ would specify characteristics of phonation. The notion is particularly used in dependency phonology, where โcategoricalโ, โarticulatoryโ and โinitiatoryโ gestures are distinguished. Gestures, in turn, are analyzed into subgestures; for example, the initiatory gesture is analyzed into the subgestures of glottal stricture, airstream direction, and airstream source.
While discussing the articulatory gestures for consonants, it may be remembered that the case of consonants is even more complicated (than vowels). But still, a wide range of sounds are put together to classify them mainly on the basis of the characteristics of their primary articulation. However, sounds may also be taken together on the basis of their secondary articulation (e.g., added lip rounding).
๐ Definition โ Dependency phonology: A phonological theory that uses gestures as fundamental units, distinguishing categorical, articulatory, and initiatory gestures.
โญ Key Takeaways
Trills, taps, and flaps are types of approximants with distinct articulatory gestures, and the IPA provides specific symbols for their transcription in world languages like Spanish, French, and Hausa. The English lateral approximant /l/ has two allophones ([l] and [ษซ]) depending on position, with American English showing more velarization in initial position. A gesture is a functionally equivalent movement pattern, and consonants can be classified by oral, laryngeal, and initiatory gestures. The 13 stop types and 9 trill/tap/flap types demonstrate the wide range of articulatory possibilities. Both primary articulation (e.g., place and manner) and secondary articulation (e.g., lip rounding) are used to group similar consonant sounds.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between a trill and a tap in terms of articulatory gesture?
- What are the two allophones of English /l/, and in which positions do they occur?
- How does American English initial [l] differ from British English initial [l]?
- What three types of gestures are distinguished in dependency phonology?
- Name three subgestures into which the initiatory gesture is analyzed.