๐ Lecture 23 โ DIRECTIONS FOR RESEARCH IN LANGUAGE LEARNING
๐ Overview: This lecture explores key directions for research in language learning, beginning with the scope of applied linguistics and its research characteristics. It then examines the critical distinction between implicit and explicit learning and awareness, the roles of input, output, and frequency in language acquisition, and concludes with current trends and research challenges in the Pakistani context. Understanding these foundations is essential for designing and evaluating rigorous research in language education.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four main topics: first, research within applied linguistics including definitions and characteristics; second, explicit and implicit learning and awareness including the noticing hypothesis; third, input, output, and frequency in language acquisition; and fourth, current trends and research in the Pakistani context including statistics and challenges for ESL teachers.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-081: Research Within Applied Linguistics
Research within Applied Linguistics requires understanding what the field deals with. Davies and Elder (2007) emphasized that it deals with social problems that involve language. Major issues requiring inquiry include teaching language effectively, training translators and interpreters, diagnosing speech pathologies, evaluating bilingual programmes, setting valid language tests, discussing language used in texts, deciding on literacy levels, and comparing acquisition of different languages.
Grabe (2002, p. 10) defines applied linguistics as a โpractice-driven discipline that addresses language-based problems in real-world contexts.โ Schmitt and Celce-Murcia (2002) define it as using what we know about language, how it is learned, and how it is used, to achieve some purpose or solve some problem in the real world. Applied linguistics covers eighteen topic areas including language and its acquisition, language and culture, language and cognition, language and the brain, language and media, language and assessment, language and interaction, language and ideology, language and listening, language and instruction, language and reading, language and policy, language and writing, language and speaking, language and society, language and research methodology, language and technology, and language and translation/interpretation. The dominant area has been second/foreign language acquisition and teaching.
Grant (2010) explains that research in applied linguistics is a process of arriving at answers to questions situated in current understanding, employing a methodologically rigorous way. Alami (2015) proposed five main characteristics of research within applied linguistics: empirical, logical, reductive, planned, and imaginative. McDonough and McDonough (2005) sum up research in four features: interest, originality, specificity, and dissemination of both research questions and findings. Nunan (2005, p. 226-227) contribution rests on the concept of enquiry: product and process.
๐ Definition โ Applied Linguistics: A practice-driven discipline that addresses language-based problems in real-world contexts (Grabe, 2002). ๐ Characteristics of Research (Alami, 2015): Empirical, logical, reductive, planned, imaginative โ Research must be based on observation, follow reasoning, simplify complex issues, be systematically planned, and involve creative thinking. ๐ Example: A researcher investigating why students in a bilingual programme struggle with academic writing is engaging in applied linguistics research โ it addresses a real-world language problem.
Topic-082: Explicit and Implicit Learning and Awareness
Rod Ellis (2009) proposed the distinction between implicit/explicit learning and implicit/explicit knowledge, asserting that though they are related terms, they need to be analyzed separately: the former relates to the processes of learning and the latter to the products of learning.
Schmidt believes that it is not necessary that implicit instruction results in implicit learning; therefore, learning needs to be distinguished from instruction. Learners have minds of their own and may follow their own inclinations irrespective of the nature of the instruction they receive (Allwright, 1984).
Dornyeiโs (2009) distinction: Explicit learning refers to the learnerโs conscious and deliberate attempt to master some material or solve a problem, while implicit learning involves acquiring skills and knowledge without conscious awareness, automatically and with no conscious attempt to learn them. Awareness, according to Tomlin and Villa (1994, p. 193), is โa particular state of mind in which an individual has undergone a specific subjective experience of some cognitive content or external stimulus.โ
Allport (1988) believes that cognitive changes and reporting of experience or metalinguistic description of rules are the factors responsible for creating awareness. In connection to awareness, Schmidt (1990) proposed the noticing hypothesis: โthe necessary and sufficient condition for the conversion of input into intake.โ
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding the implicit/explicit distinction helps researchers determine whether learners acquire language unconsciously or through deliberate study โ crucial for designing effective teaching methods.
๐ Definition โ Explicit learning: Learner's conscious and deliberate attempt to master material or solve a problem (Dornyei, 2009). ๐ Definition โ Implicit learning: Acquiring skills and knowledge without conscious awareness, automatically (Dornyei, 2009). ๐ Definition โ Noticing hypothesis: The necessary and sufficient condition for converting input into intake (Schmidt, 1990).
Topic-083: Input, Output, and Frequency
Corder emphasized that language input needs to be differentiated from intake. According to him, input deals with utilization of existing rules, whereas intake is a part of input and results from the comprehension of intake. Two factors โ โAvailabilityโ and โAccessibilityโ โ determine the input.
For comprehensible output, the input has been observed to be comprehensible too. Language users use correct forms of utterances for successful transmission of intended meaning; โsometimes, under some conditions, output facilitates second language learning in ways that are different from those of inputโ (Swain and Lapkin, 1995, p. 371). For the development of frequency, processing is the key factor that has the ability to match the outcome with the intended meaning.
๐ก Why this matters: The input-intake distinction explains why learners may hear language (input) but not actually learn it โ only what is processed and comprehended becomes intake. Output pushes learners to produce correct forms, which is different from simply receiving input.
๐ Definition โ Input: Language available to the learner that utilizes existing rules. ๐ Definition โ Intake: A part of input that results from comprehension. ๐ Example: A student hears the teacher say "She runs every day" (input). If the student understands this structure and internalizes it, that becomes intake. If the student then produces "He runs every day" correctly, that is output facilitating learning.
Topic-084: Current Trends and Research in Pakistani Context
The statistics regarding English language research show:
- English language is a global language and more than 1.5 billion people (native and non-native combined) speak English.
- Extensively spreading in important fields including international commerce, education, and communication.
- Plays an important role as a channel of communication (Kannan, 2009).
- Asia is not an exception to this global trend which is concerned with studentsโ personal, linguistic, social, and cultural development (Le, 2004, p. 167).
Current trends and issues in English language education in Asia survey that SLA faces great challenges with regard to L2 learning difficulties, unrealistic teaching material, and teaching strategies. Challenges of ESL teachers include teaching English as a second language in different situations, assessing second language learners with different abilities, and facilitating the procedure of second language acquisition.
โญ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that applied linguistics research is practice-driven and addresses real-world language problems, with empirical, logical, reductive, planned, and imaginative characteristics. The critical distinction between explicit and implicit learning must be understood separately from explicit and implicit knowledge, with Schmidt's noticing hypothesis stating that awareness is necessary for converting input to intake. Input differs from intake โ input is available language while intake is what is comprehended and internalized โ and output facilitates learning in ways different from input. Finally, English language education in Asia, including Pakistan, faces challenges such as unrealistic teaching material and assessing learners with diverse abilities, highlighting the need for context-sensitive research.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are Alami's (2015) five main characteristics of research within applied linguistics?
- According to Dornyei (2009), what is the difference between explicit learning and implicit learning?
- What is Schmidt's (1990) noticing hypothesis and why is it important for language learning?
- According to Corder, what is the difference between input and intake in language acquisition?
- What are three major challenges faced by ESL teachers in the Asian context according to current trends?
๐ Lecture 24 โ Automaticity, Restructuring and Noticing
๐ Overview: This lecture examines key cognitive theories in Second Language Acquisition, focusing on how learners process and internalize language. It introduces McLaughlin's distinction between controlled and automatic processing, along with restructuring as a mechanism for cognitive change, and Schmidt's Noticing Hypothesis, which argues that conscious attention to linguistic features is necessary for input to become intake. These frameworks help explain why some language knowledge becomes effortless while other knowledge requires deliberate mental effort.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers two main topics: McLaughlin's theory of Automaticity and Restructuring, which describes how cognitive processing shifts from controlled to automatic and how learners reorganize their mental representations of language, and Schmidt's Noticing Hypothesis, which argues that conscious attention to linguistic features at the level of noticing is necessary for converting input into intake, while high-level awareness (understanding) is not required.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-085: Mclaughlinโs Automaticity and Restructuring
McLaughlin (1990) introduced the distinction between controlled processing and automatic processing. He argued that SLA lacks an adequate theory to explain mental states that can be determined as 'conscious' or 'unconscious.' Rather than discarding the idea of unconsciousness in SLA, he proposed that the distinction should be between controlled and automatic processing instead of the conscious/unconscious dichotomy.
Controlled processing requires attention, and attention has a limited capacity. Automatic processing does not require attention and takes up little or no processing capacity. McLaughlin uses the twin concepts of Automaticity and Restructuring to describe the cognitive processes involved in SLA.
๐ Definition โ Automaticity: Occurs when an associative connection between a certain kind of input and some output pattern develops, allowing for effortless, routine responses. ๐ Example: Typical greeting exchanges illustrate automaticity โ Speaker 1: "Hi." Speaker 2: "Morning. How are you?" Speaker 1: "Fine, and you?" Speaker 2: "Fine." (Jordan, 2004). These exchanges happen without conscious effort.
McLaughlin (1987, pp. 134-135) introduced three information processes: automatic processing, controlled processing, and restructuring. He presented the process starting from attention and ending at intention:
๐ Formula: Attention โ Rehearsal โ Retrieval โ Intention ๐ก Why this matters: This sequence shows how initially effortful, attention-demanding language processing can become automatic through practice, freeing cognitive resources for higher-level language tasks.
Topic-086: Schimdtโs Noticing Hypothesis
Schmidt proposed the concept of 'Noticing'; he believed that 'noticing is the necessary and sufficient condition for converting input into intake' (Schmidt, 1990, p. 130). The concept emerged in response to Krashen's claim that subconscious processes can guarantee successful L2 acquisition. Schmidt argued that noticing is important for L2 learning.
๐ Definition โ Noticing: 'Conscious registration of the concurrence of some event' (Schmidt, 1995, p. 29) โ a low level of awareness where learners consciously pay attention to specific linguistic features in the input.
๐ Definition โ Understanding: 'Recognition of a general principle, rule, or pattern' (Schmidt, 1995, p. 29) โ a high level of awareness that is not required for learning to occur.
From Schmidt's perspective, for learning to occur, attention and a low level of awareness (i.e., noticing) are necessary, but high-level awareness (i.e., understanding) is not required (Ahn, 2014).
The following are the features of the Noticing Hypothesis:
- Noticing as focal awareness โ attention is directed toward specific linguistic features
- Noticing refers to a private experience โ it is internal and subjective
- Consciousness as knowledge โ awareness that learners have about their own learning
To overcome the ambiguities between conscious and unconscious learning, Schmidt explained that unconscious learning deals with unawareness of having learned something. Conscious learning establishes awareness at the level of noticing, whereas unconscious learning results in picking up speech without noticing. He calls this process 'subliminal' learning.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical points from this lecture are: McLaughlin replaced the conscious/unconscious dichotomy with the controlled/automatic processing distinction, where controlled processing requires limited-capacity attention while automatic processing does not. McLaughlin's cognitive sequenceโAttention โ Rehearsal โ Retrieval โ Intentionโexplains how learners move from effortful to automatic language use. Schmidt's Noticing Hypothesis directly challenges Krashen by asserting that conscious noticing of input is necessary and sufficient for converting input into intake, while full understanding of rules is optional. The key distinction in Schmidt's framework is between noticing (low-level awareness required for learning) and understanding (high-level awareness not required). Finally, Schmidt differentiates conscious learning (with noticing) from subliminal learning (picking up speech without noticing), which he considers true unconscious learning.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between controlled processing and automatic processing according to McLaughlin?
- According to McLaughlin, what is the sequence from attention to intention in language processing?
- What is the main claim of Schmidt's Noticing Hypothesis regarding input and intake?
- According to Schmidt, what is the difference between noticing and understanding, and which is necessary for L2 learning?
- How does Schmidt define 'subliminal' learning, and how does it differ from conscious learning?
๐ Lecture 25 โ INTERACTION HYPOTHESIS, PROCESSABILITY THEORY, AND TOWELL AND HAWKINS MODEL OF SLA
๐ Overview: This lecture explores three major theoretical frameworks in Second Language Acquisition (SLA). It begins with Longโs Interaction Hypothesis, which emphasizes the role of conversational interaction and input modification. It then introduces Pienemannโs Processability Theory, which explains the staged grammatical development of learners, and concludes with Towell and Hawkins' model, which addresses the dual nature of learning an L2 system and its use, focusing on knowledge types and key SLA questions.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Longโs Interaction Hypothesis, detailing its core components (comprehensible input and interactional modifications), empirical support, and identified limitations. It then explains Pienemannโs Processability Theory, its core characteristic of processing constraints, and the factors it considers for L2 development. Finally, it discusses Towell and Hawkinsโ model, introducing declarative and procedural knowledge, the concept of multiplicity of knowledge sources, and five main questions addressing L2 acquisition (transfer, staged development, systematicity, variability, and incompleteness).
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-087: Longโs Interaction Hypothesis
Longโs (1981) Interaction Hypothesis refers to the participation in conversation with a native speaker. The process may include modification of interaction and plays an important role in second language acquisition. Long (1981) defines, 'Input refers to the linguistic forms used; whereas, interaction means the functions served by those forms, such as expansion, repetition, and clarification' (p. 259). Ellis (1991) explains the states, IH propagates, as follows: 1. Comprehensible input and 2. Modifications to the interactional structure.
Longโs Interaction Hypothesis was analyzed by a number of researchers, leading among them were Pica and Ellis. Pica (1987) empirically investigated the hypothesis and Ellis (1991) summarized it as:
- Comprehensible input is necessary for second language acquisition.
- Modifications to the interactional structure of conversations help to make input comprehensible to a second language learner.
- Tasks and a situation where there is a need for the participants to exchange information.
The limitations of Interaction Hypothesis were identified by Ellis as following:
- Interaction facilitates comprehension (not causes it): when learners have opportunity to signal their non-understanding and try to ask for clarification.
- There are individual differences with regard to the amount of their participation.
- Comprehension does not depend on negotiation; learners may benefit from the dialogic interaction by other learners.
- Modified input facilitates acquisition of word meanings.
- The most important factor to acquisition of word meanings is range (different contexts).
๐ Definition โ Interaction Hypothesis: The hypothesis that participation in conversation with a native speaker, including modification of interaction, plays an important role in SLA.
๐ก Why this matters: This hypothesis shifted focus from just providing input to the quality of interactional modifications needed to make that input comprehensible.
Topic-088: Processability Theory
โProcessability Theoryโ was proposed by Manfred Pienemann, and it refers to the grammatical development of learnersโ interlanguage. The theory has been explained as 'cognitively founded (hence applicable to any language), formal and explicit (hence empirically testable), and extended, having not only formulated and tested hypotheses about morphology, syntax and discourse-pragmatics, but having also paved the way for further developments at the interface between grammar and the lexicon and other important modules in SLA.'
The core characteristic of processability theory is that in the process of second language acquisition, learners can produce and comprehend those L2 forms which their L1 process can manage. It refers to two formal models, describing and interfacing: (a) language generation, and (b) linguistic knowledge. Pienemann (2012) considered the following factors in their explanation of the processability theory:
- Second language development progresses according to universal stages.
- Variability of interlanguage is limited and regular.
- Transfer from the first language is limited by the ability to process a certain structure.
- Differences in tasks are limited by the language processing hierarchy.
- Acquisition of both the first and the second language is limited by the language processing hierarchy.
- Bilingual language development can be universally compared for different languages using the language processing hierarchy described in the PT.
๐ Definition โ Processability Theory: A theory of SLA that posits learners can only produce and comprehend L2 forms that their current L1 processing mechanisms can manage, leading to universal, sequential stages of development.
๐ Formula: Language Processing Hierarchy โ L1 processing constraints determine the order and possibility of acquiring L2 grammatical structures.
๐ก Why this matters: This theory explains why L2 development follows predictable stages and why L1 transfer is not unlimited but constrained by processing abilities.
Topic-089: Towell and Hawkinsโ Model of SLA
Towell and Hawkins were the first ones to propose the concepts of โDeclarative Knowledgeโ and โProcedural Knowledge.โ They believe that SLA research has to deal both with the learnerโs attempts to learn the system and the learnerโs attempts to learn to use the system. โMultiplicity of knowledge sources,โ was the term used by Towell and Hawkins which according to them is the result of learnerโs exposure to SLA after 7 years of age.
Towell and Hawkins (1994) proposed five main questions addressing English as a second or foreign language:
- Transfer: of grammatical properties from L1 mental grammar into the mental grammar that learners construct for L2.
- Staged Development: L2 learners go through a series of โtransitional stagesโ towards the target language.
- Systematicity: in the growth of L2 knowledge across learners.
- Variability: in learnersโ intuitions about, and production of, the L2 at various stages of L2 development.
- Incompleteness: most L2 learners do not achieve native-like competence. This phenomenon is referred as fossilization by Selinker (1972) and as incompleteness by Schacter (1990). (Towell and Hawkins, 1994, p. 15).
๐ Definition โ Declarative Knowledge: Knowledge of the L2 system (knowing what the rules are). ๐ Definition โ Procedural Knowledge: Knowledge of how to use the L2 system in real-time communication (knowing how to apply the rules). ๐ Definition โ Multiplicity of Knowledge Sources: The idea that after the age of 7, L2 learners rely on a combination of knowledge sources (e.g., L1, instruction, input) rather than a single, dedicated language faculty.
๐ก Why this matters: This model highlights that SLA is not just about learning grammar rules (declarative knowledge) but also about developing the automatic ability to use them fluently (procedural knowledge), and it identifies the key puzzles (like fossilization and variability) that any theory of SLA must address.
โญ Key Takeaways
The three frameworks offer complementary perspectives on SLA. Longโs Interaction Hypothesis underscores that comprehensible input is necessary but often requires interactional modifications (like clarification requests) to be effective, though it notes that interaction only facilitates comprehension and is limited by individual differences. Pienemannโs Processability Theory provides a cognitively-based explanation for the universal, sequential stages of grammatical development, arguing that learners can only process L2 structures their L1 processing system can handle, thus constraining both development and L1 transfer. Towell and Hawkinsโ model expands the scope by distinguishing between declarative knowledge (knowing the rules) and procedural knowledge (using them), and by framing SLA as a process involving multiple knowledge sources, leading to specific phenomena like staged development, variability, systematicity, and incompleteness (fossilization) .
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- According to Longโs Interaction Hypothesis, what is the essential role of interactional modifications in SLA, and what are the limitations of this hypothesis identified by Ellis?
- What is the core characteristic of Pienemannโs Processability Theory, and how does it explain the universal stages of L2 grammatical development?
- In Towell and Hawkinsโ model, what is the distinction between decl declarative and procedural knowledge, and why is this distinction important for understanding SLA?
- Explain the concept of โmultiplicity of knowledge sourcesโ as proposed by Towell and Hawkins. What is its significance for learners after the age of 7?
- Compare and contrast the five main questions about SLA (transfer, staged development, systematicity, variability, and incompleteness) as outlined by Towell and Hawkins.
๐ Lecture 26 โ Comparing Six Theories-I
๐ Overview: This lecture compares six major language learning theoriesโBehaviorism, Generativism, Cognitivism, Constructivism, Monitor-Model, and Socio-cultural theoryโbased on factors including learning influences, memory role, transfer occurrence, learning types, and teaching paradigms. It emphasizes how language learning perspectives differ according to their focus on behavior, innateness, mental processes, experiences, interaction, and the role of society.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture first introduces the six theories and the factors for comparison, then discusses the role of memory (encoding, storing, retrieving information) and transfer occurrence (applying knowledge from one language to another). It examines how memory function and language transfer vary across Behaviorism, Generativism, Cognitivism, Constructivism, Monitor-Model, and Socio-cultural theories, noting that generativist and cognitivist theories share similar views on memory, while generativism shows some language transfer perspective.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-090: Theories Perspectives
The six key theoriesโBehaviorism, Generativism, Cognitivism, Constructivism, Monitor-Model, and Socio-cultural theoryโhave been compared based on factors that influence learning, role of memory, transfer occurrence, types of learning, and teaching paradigms. Language learning perspectives vary according to the uniqueness of their domains and research covering: behavior, innateness, mental processes, experiences, interaction, and role of society. ๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these foundational differences helps educators select appropriate teaching strategies for different learning contexts.
Topic-091: Role of Memory and Transfer Occurrence
Memory is the process by which we encode, store, and retrieve information. Long-term memory is our brainโs system for storing, managing, and retrieving information. Working memory is the short-term memory wherein the information is kept in mind for a short time before either dismissing it or transferring it to long-term memory. Transfer occurrence refers to the application of knowledge from one language to another.
๐ Definition โ Memory: the process by which we encode, store, and retrieve information ๐ Definition โ Long-term memory: our brainโs system for storing, managing, and retrieving information ๐ Definition โ Working memory: the short-term memory where information is kept briefly before being dismissed or transferred to long-term memory ๐ Definition โ Transfer occurrence: application of knowledge from one language to another
It has been observed that the role of memory and language transfer appear to vary across Behaviorism, Generativism, Cognitivism, Constructivism, Monitor-Model, and Socio-cultural theories. It has also been noted that the generativist and cognitivist theories share views on the role of memory; whereas, the language transfer perspective is observed in generativism to some extent. ๐ก Why this matters: Recognizing which theories emphasize memory and transfer helps predict how learners might apply prior linguistic knowledge when acquiring a new language.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that six major language learning theoriesโBehaviorism, Generativism, Cognitivism, Constructivism, Monitor-Model, and Socio-culturalโare compared using five factors: influences on learning, role of memory, transfer occurrence, types of learning, and teaching paradigms. Memory involves encoding, storing, and retrieving information, with long-term memory for permanent storage and working memory for temporary holding. Transfer occurrence refers to applying knowledge from one language to another, a concept observed most prominently in generativism. Notably, generativist and cognitivist theories share similar perspectives on the role of memory. These comparisons are essential for understanding how different theoretical frameworks approach language acquisition.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six key theories compared in this lecture?
- What are the five factors used to compare these theories?
- Define the three types of memory discussed (memory, long-term memory, working memory).
- What is transfer occurrence in the context of language learning?
- Which two theories share the same view on the role of memory?
๐ Lecture 27 โ COMPARING SIX THEORIES-II
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the comparison of six major language learning theories by examining different types of learning and their specific domains. It then explores how these theories are applied in classroom settings, addressing how different theoretical foundations shape teaching methodologies and influence instructional practices.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main topics: Types of Learning, which explores distinctions such as declarative vs. procedural knowledge, formal vs. informal learning, and the specific domains of learning including acquisition, retention, memory, and practice; and Classroom Application, which discusses how behaviorist, interactionist, comprehensible input, readiness-based, and selective instruction methods apply theory to teaching practice.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-092: Types of Learning
Learning is defined as an act of acquiring or modifying new knowledge, and as a process whereby new knowledge is built based on previous knowledge. Two primary categories are Declarative Knowledge (knowing that something is true) and Procedural Knowledge (knowing how to do something).
Other more general types of learning include: Formal learning (structured, intentional), Technology-based learning (using digital tools), Monolingual/mono-cultural context learning (single language and culture), Multilingual/multicultural context learning (multiple languages and cultures), Practical/functional learning (applied skills), and Personalized learning (tailored to individual needs).
These types are best explained in terms of their specific learning domains:
- Learning is acquisition or 'getting.'
- Learning is retention of information or skill.
- Retention implies storage systems, memory, and cognitive organization.
- Learning involves active, conscious focus on and acting upon events outside or inside the organism.
- Learning is relatively permanent but subject to forgetting.
- Learning involves some form of practice, perhaps reinforced practice.
- Learning is a change in behavior (Brown, 2006).
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these domains helps distinguish between surface-level memorization and deep learning, guiding both theory and instruction.
๐ Definition โ Declarative Knowledge: Knowledge about facts and things, i.e., "knowing that." Example: knowing the capital of France. ๐ Formula: Declarative Knowledge = Knowledge of facts and events โ "knowing what" ๐ Example: A student knows that the past tense of "walk" is "walked."
๐ Definition โ Procedural Knowledge: Knowledge about how to perform tasks, i.e., "knowing how." Example: knowing how to ride a bicycle. ๐ Formula: Procedural Knowledge = Knowledge of skills and processes โ "knowing how" ๐ Example: A student can correctly form the past tense of "walk" during spontaneous speech without conscious thought.
๐ Definition โ Formal Learning: Structured, intentional learning that typically takes place in educational institutions with a curriculum. ๐ Formula: Formal Learning = Structured + Intentional + Curriculum-based โ Organized education ๐ Example: A university course on second language acquisition with scheduled classes, readings, and assessments.
๐ Definition โ Technology-based learning: Learning that utilizes digital tools, software, or online platforms for instruction. ๐ Formula: Technology-based learning = Digital tools + Instruction โ Enhanced learning access ๐ Example: Using language learning apps like Duolingo or attending virtual classrooms.
๐ Definition โ Retention: The ability to store and recall information or skills over time. ๐ Formula: Retention = Storage systems + Memory + Cognitive organization โ Long-term preservation of knowledge ๐ Example: A learner remembers vocabulary words from a lesson taught three weeks ago.
Topic-093: Classroom Application
Theories application in classroom aims to address the issues of learners' needs and adopt appropriate learning procedures to cater those needs. The application of SLA theories in classroom provides teachers with better understanding of learners' needs and an insight on their teaching practices.
Teaching methodologies are evolved over the period of time, and these are practiced as per specific requirements. The broader aspect of theoretical application has been preferred to address the wide range of teaching issues as there is no single, straightforward solution to learning. Furthermore, the relationship between teaching and learning determines the relevancy of a particular theory.
The following factors address classroom teaching and research associated with one another:
-
Methods based on the behaviorist theory of language learning lay emphasis on accuracy and form and do not allow errors.
-
Methods based on the interactionist theory give learners the opportunity for conversation where they receive meaningful input from teachers and students.
-
Methods based on the 'comprehensible input' theory, most closely associated with Stephen Krashen, do not put emphasis on interaction, but on providing input through listening and/or reading.
-
Methods based on teaching what the learner is ready to learn.
-
Methods that not only 'recognize the role for instruction, but also assume that not everything has to be taught' (Lightbown & Spada, 1993, p. 97).
๐ก Why this matters: The choice of teaching method directly reflects which theoretical perspective a teacher adopts, affecting how errors are treated, how interaction is structured, and what role instruction plays.
๐ Definition โ Behaviorist theory: A theory of language learning that emphasizes stimulus-response, repetition, and habit formation, with a focus on accuracy and form. ๐ Formula: Behaviorist Theory = Stimulus + Response + Reinforcement โ Habit formation ๐ Example: A teacher drills students on correct pronunciation and immediately corrects every error during a repetition exercise.
๐ Definition โ Interactionist theory: A theory that emphasizes the role of social interaction and meaningful conversation in language acquisition. ๐ Formula: Interactionist Theory = Conversation + Meaningful Input + Negotiation of Meaning โ Language acquisition ๐ Example: Students work in pairs to complete a task, asking each other for clarification when they do not understand a phrase.
๐ Definition โ Comprehensible input theory: Stephen Krashen's hypothesis that language acquisition occurs when learners understand messages that are slightly beyond their current level of competence (i+1). ๐ Formula: Comprehensible Input Theory = i (current level) + 1 (new input) โ Acquisition through understanding ๐ Example: A teacher provides a listening passage with familiar vocabulary and one or two new words supported by context, visuals, or gestures.
โญ Key Takeaways
This lecture establishes that learning can be categorized into declarative and procedural knowledge, and into domains involving acquisition, retention, memory, practice, and behavioral change. These distinctions guide how different SLA theories are applied in the classroom. The five classroom applications show that behaviorist methods prioritize accuracy and error avoidance, interactionist methods emphasize conversation and meaningful input, comprehensible input methods focus on listening and reading without requiring interaction, readiness-based methods teach what the learner is prepared for, and selective instruction methods recognize that not everything needs explicit teaching. There is no single perfect method; the relationship between teaching and learning determines the relevance of any particular theory.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between declarative knowledge and procedural knowledge? Provide one example of each.
- List three specific learning domains discussed in relation to types of learning.
- According to the behaviorist theory-based method, how should errors be treated in the classroom?
- How does Stephen Krashen's comprehensible input theory differ from the interactionist theory in terms of the role of conversation?
- What does Lightbown and Spada mean by methods that "recognize the role for instruction, but also assume that not everything has to be taught"?
๐ Lecture 28 โ Learning Factors-I
๐ Overview: This lecture introduces the key internal and external factors that influence second language acquisition (SLA). It examines how age impacts learning success through the Critical Period Hypothesis and explores motivation as a psychological construct with behavioristic, cognitive, and constructivist views, along with its phases and types.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
This lecture covers three main topics: language learning factors (categorized into internal and external factors), the Age factor including the Critical Period Hypothesis and research findings on younger versus older learners, and Motivation defined through three theoretical views (behavioristic, cognitive, constructivist), Dornyeiโs three-phase model, and the distinction between integrative and instrumental motivation.
๐ Lecture Summary
Topic-094: Language Learning Factors
Language learning factors contribute significantly in the understanding of processes involved in SLA. The study of SLA covers broadly from pure linguistic units of a language to cognitive and social/interactionist models. The key factors include comprehensive analysis of factors responsible for particular processes in a specific model, nature of stages learners go through, the pace at which learning takes place, and the outcomes.
Learning factors are of the following two types: Internal Factors: Age, Personality, Motivation (intrinsic), Experience, Cognition, and Native language External Factors: Culture and status, Motivation (extrinsic), Access to native speakers, Curriculum, and Instruction
Topic-095: Age
The Age factor is a matter of great interest to SLA researchers. Researchers like Ellis (2008), Larsen-Freeman (2008), and Mayberry & Lock (2003) state that younger learners are more successful in language study than aged ones. Cook (1991) claimed that children with exposure to SLA at the early stage demonstrate the ability to perform native-like which adults fail to do. Krashen et al. (1979) believe that older is faster, but the young is better.
The 'Critical Period Hypothesis' is widely referred to in the study of age factor. It is defined as 'the period during which a child can acquire language easily, rapidly, perfectly, and without instruction' (Richards & Schmidt, 2002, p. 145). This hypothesis has been opposed by Singleton (2004) who claimed that Dutch learners, who started learning English in the classroom after the age of twelve, were able to gain native-like accent. Others have diverse views: Harley & Hart (1997) cited in DeKeyser, 2007 observed that the importance of memory in young learners and of analytic abilities in older learners are key differences. Ekstrand (1978) described age effects according to which older learners outscored younger ones, which can be explained by teaching and testing techniques (Lightbown & Spada, 1993).
๐ Definition โ Critical Period Hypothesis: The period during which a child can acquire language easily, rapidly, perfectly, and without instruction (Richards & Schmidt, 2002, p. 145). ๐ก Why this matters: This hypothesis is central to debates about the optimal age for starting SLA, with implications for curriculum design and teaching strategies.
Topic-096: Motivation
Motivation has been defined as 'a psychological construct that refers to the desire and incentive that an individual has to engage in a specific activity' (Hall, 2011). Another definition by Loewen & Reinders (2011, p. 119) is that 'it provides the primary impetus to initiate L2 learning and later the driving force to sustain the long and often tedious learning process' (Dornyei, 2005, p. 65).
Three Views of Motivation
- Behavioristic: This view deals with factors like anticipation of reward, desire for positive reinforcement, and external individual forces in control.
- Cognitive: Driven by basic human needs, degree of efforts expended, and internal individual forces in control are the factors considered in cognitive view of motivation.
- Constructivist: Social context, community, social status, security of group, and internal and interactive forces in control are the factors constructivists focus on for studying motivation.
Motivation follows certain phases that determine its sustenance. Dornyeiโs model presents three phases:
- Setting goals and getting started
- Keeping the motivation intact while carrying out the tasks
- Performance reflection
Moreover, 'Integrative Motivation' (desire to integrate into the target language community) and 'Instrumental Motivation' (practical reasons like career advancement) affect language learning process.
๐ Definition โ Motivation: A psychological construct that refers to the desire and incentive that an individual has to engage in a specific activity (Hall, 2011); it provides the primary impetus to initiate L2 learning and the driving force to sustain the learning process (Dornyei, 2005). ๐ก Why this matters: Understanding motivation types and phases helps teachers design interventions that sustain learner engagement throughout the SLA process.
โญ Key Takeaways
Students must remember that language learning factors are divided into internal (age, personality, motivation, experience, cognition, native language) and external (culture, extrinsic motivation, access to native speakers, curriculum, instruction). The age factor is debated: while the Critical Period Hypothesis suggests younger learners achieve native-like ability, some research (Singleton, 2004) shows older classroom learners can also develop native-like accents, and age effects may favor older learners due to teaching techniques. Motivation has three theoretical views (behavioristic-external, cognitive-internal, constructivist-interactive), follows Dornyeiโs three phases (goal-setting, maintenance, reflection), and is categorized as integrative (social integration) or instrumental (practical goals). Krashen et al.'s claim that "older is faster, but young is better" captures a key paradox in age research.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six internal factors and five external factors in language learning?
- Name two researchers who oppose the Critical Period Hypothesis and summarize their findings.
- What is the difference between the behavioristic, cognitive, and constructivist views of motivation?
- List Dornyeiโs three phases of motivation in order.
- Define integrative motivation and instrumental motivation, and give one example of each.