π Lecture 21 β Grammar II
π Overview: This lecture explores different approaches to grammar, moving from prescriptive rules based on Latin to descriptive methods that analyze how languages actually work. It introduces structural analysis and constituent analysis as tools for understanding sentence structure, and highlights how languages differ in their grammatical organization. Understanding these approaches is crucial for linguists to describe language accurately without imposing artificial rules.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers five main topics: The Prescriptive Approach, which imposes Latin-based rules on English; The Descriptive Approach, which describes language as it is actually used by native speakers; Structural Analysis, which uses test-frames to identify grammatical categories; Constituent Analysis, which shows how words combine into larger units; and Labeled and Bracketed Sentences, which provide a formal way to represent sentence structure. The lecture concludes with a brief comparison of Gaelic and English sentence structures.
π Lecture Summary
Topic- 117: The Prescriptive Approach
The prescriptive approach views grammar as a set of rules for the "proper" use of a language. This approach was taken by influential eighteenth-century English grammarians who claimed that English sentence structure should follow Latin rules. These rules are still found today and include prohibitions against splitting infinitives, ending sentences with prepositions, and beginning sentences with "and." For example, "To boldly go" is considered incorrect because in Latin, the infinitive ire ("to go") is one word and cannot be split, and audacter ("boldly") is another word. Similarly, after comparatives, the pronoun should be in the nominative case, so "Mary runs faster than me" is deemed incorrect while "Mary runs faster than I" is considered correct. The prescriptive approach imposes Latin grammatical norms onto English, despite English having different structures.
π Definition β Prescriptive Approach: A view of grammar as a set of rules for the "proper" use of a language, often based on Latin grammatical conventions.
π Example: "Who did you go with?" is considered incorrect under prescriptive rules; "With whom did you go?" is considered correct because it does not end with a preposition.
Topic- 118: The Descriptive Approach
The descriptive approach emerged when linguists realized that Latin-based grammatical descriptions were not suitable for all languages, particularly the native languages of North America. In the twentieth century, linguists adopted a different method: they took samples of the language they were interested in and attempted to describe its regular structures. A descriptive grammarian would say that a sentence is "grammatical" if a native speaker of the language would produce that sentence in speaking. This approach rejects the imposition of prescriptive or normative Latin rules onto English and instead describes language as it is naturally used.
π Definition β Descriptive Approach: A method of grammar analysis that describes the regular structures of a language based on how native speakers actually use it.
π‘ Why this matters: The descriptive approach allows linguists to study and document languages on their own terms, without forcing them into the grammatical categories of Latin.
Topic- 119: Structural Analysis
Structural analysis is one type of descriptive approach that investigates the distribution of forms in a language. The method uses "test-frames" β sentences with empty slots. All forms that fit in the same test-frame belong to the same grammatical category. For example, in the test-frame "The _________ drinks water," words like boy, girl, or horse fit, but pronouns like he, she, it do not (The it makes a lot of noise is ungrammatical). Pronouns fit in a different test-frame: "_________ drinks water" (without "The"). This analysis reveals that pronouns are used in place of noun phrases, not just nouns, which is more accurate than the older Latin-influenced description.
π Definition β Structural Analysis: A descriptive approach that investigates the distribution of forms in a language using test-frames to identify grammatical categories.
π Test-Frame: "The _________ drinks water" β only nouns (boy, girl, horse) fit; pronouns do not.
π Example: In the test-frame "_________ drinks water," pronouns like he, she, it fit, showing they are a different grammatical category from nouns.
Topic- 120: Constituent Analysis
Constituent analysis is a descriptive approach designed to show how small constituents (or components) in sentences combine to form larger constituents. The basic step is determining how words group together to form phrases. For example, in the sentence "An old man brought a shotgun to the wedding," the words group into phrase-like constituents such as "an old man," "a shotgun," and "the wedding." Incorrect groupings like "(An old) (man brought)" show that words do not always combine arbitrarily with adjacent words.
π Definition β Constituent Analysis: A descriptive approach that shows how small constituents in sentences combine to form larger constituents.
π Example: In "An old man brought a shotgun to the wedding," the correct constituents are:
- an old man
- a shotgun
- the wedding
Topic- 121: Labeled and Bracketed Sentences
An alternative way to show constituents in sentence structure is using labeled brackets. This method marks constituents at different levels using abbreviated grammatical terms: Art (= article), V (= verb), N (= noun), VP (= verb phrase), NP (= noun phrase), S (= sentence). At the word level, constituents are shown as [the] or [dog]. At the phrase level, they appear as [the dog] or [loved the girl]. At the sentence level, the entire structure is shown as [The dog loved the girl]. Constituent analysis helps us understand each constituent at different levels.
π Definition β Labeled and Bracketed Sentences: A diagramming method that marks off constituents in sentence structure using labeled brackets and abbreviated grammatical terms.
π Example: The sentence "The dog loved the girl" can be bracketed and labeled as: S[NP[Art[The] N[dog]] VP[V[loved] NP[Art[the] N[girl]]]]
Topic- 122: A Gaelic Sentence
Gaelic sentence structure is organized with the pattern V NP NP, which differs from English structure NP V NP. This difference helps explain why a Spanish learner of English might produce phrases like "*the book good" instead of "the good book," as Spanish follows a different word order pattern. Different languages have different structures, and understanding these differences is essential for analyzing and learning languages.
π Definition β Gaelic Sentence Structure: V NP NP (verb, then noun phrase, then noun phrase), as opposed to English NP V NP.
π Example: English: "The boy loves the girl" (NP V NP); Gaelic equivalent would follow V NP NP order.
β Key Takeaways
The prescriptive approach imposes Latin-based rules on English, such as not splitting infinitives or ending sentences with prepositions, while the descriptive approach describes language as it is actually used by native speakers. Structural analysis uses test-frames to discover grammatical categories by examining which forms fill specific slots in sentences. Constituent analysis and labeled brackets show how words combine into phrases and sentences at different levels, using abbreviations like NP, VP, and S. Languages like Gaelic and English have fundamentally different sentence structures (V NP NP vs. NP V NP), which explains why learners may produce non-native patterns. The most critical understanding is that grammar should be described based on how a language actually works, not forced into Latin molds.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the main difference between the prescriptive approach and the descriptive approach to grammar?
- Why is "To boldly go" considered incorrect under prescriptive rules, and why does this rule not apply naturally to English?
- How do test-frames work in structural analysis, and what do they reveal about pronouns?
- What are constituents, and how does constituent analysis help in understanding sentence structure?
- How does Gaelic sentence structure differ from English sentence structure, and what implication does this have for language learning?
π Lecture 22 β SYNTAX I
π Overview: This lecture introduces the fundamental concepts of syntax, focusing on generative grammar as proposed by Noam Chomsky. It explains how a finite set of rules can generate an infinite number of well-formed sentences, and explores key properties such as recursion and the distinction between well-formed and ill-formed structures. Understanding these principles is crucial for analyzing the underlying rule system of language.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the introduction to syntax and its goals, including the concept of a generative grammar that produces well-formed structures. It details the properties of generative grammar, elaborates on well-formed syntactic structures, discusses the finite number of rules, and explains the crucial property of recursion in generating complex sentences.
π Lecture Summary
Topic- 123: Introduction
The word 'syntax' comes from Greek and means 'a putting together' or arrangement. It involves producing an accurate description of the sequence or ordering of elements in the linear structure of a sentence. Modern analysis focuses on the underlying rule system used to produce or 'generate' sentences. A prepositional phrase in English consists of a preposition followed by a noun phrase, which itself consists of an article and a noun. For example, 'near London' is correct as London is a proper noun, but 'with dog' is incorrect; the correct form is 'with a dog'.
π Definition β Syntax: The study of the rules governing the way words are combined to form phrases and sentences in a language. π Example: 'near London' (correct) vs. 'with dog' (incorrect) β 'with a dog' (correct).
Another goal of syntactic analysis is to have a small and finite (i.e., limited) set of rules capable of producing a large and potentially infinite (i.e., unlimited) number of well-formed structures. This small and finite set of rules is sometimes described as a 'generative grammar' because it can 'generate' or produce sentence structures, not just describe them. π‘ Why this matters: This grammar should also reveal how some superficially different sentences are closely related (e.g., active and passive) and how some superficially similar sentences are in fact different (e.g., ambiguous structures).
Topic- 124: Generative Grammar
Generative grammar is a linguistic theory that regards grammar as a system of rules that generates exactly those combinations of words that form grammatical sentences in a given language. The generative school has focused on the study of syntax but has also addressed other aspects like morphology and phonology. Early versions of Noam Chomsky's theory were called transformational grammar. Generativists argue that many properties of a generative grammar arise from a universal grammar that is innate to the human brain, rather than being learned from the environment. Chomsky opposed structuralism by rejecting the idea that each language is completely different from others.
π Definition β Generative Grammar: A system of rules that can generate an infinite number of grammatical sentences in a language. π Definition β Transformational Grammar: An early version of Chomsky's theory that included rules for transforming one sentence structure into another (e.g., active to passive).
The basic concept sets forth the rules to recognize grammatical sentences in a language. These rules differentiate correct structures from improper sequences of words or ungrammatical sentences. The sentence is represented as a tree having branches denoting subordinate and superordinate elements, rather than just a sequence of words. Generative grammar attempts to formalize the implicit rules that a person uses while speaking their native language.
Topic- 125: Properties of Generative Grammar
Noam Chomsky has argued that many properties of a generative grammar arise from an 'innate' universal grammar common to all languages. The grammar must generate all the well-formed syntactic structures (sentences) of the language and fail to generate any ill-formed structures. It will have a finite (limited) number of rules but will be capable of generating an infinite number of well-formed structures, capturing the productivity of language. The rules of this grammar also need the crucial property of recursion. The grammar must capture the fact that a sentence can have another sentence inside it. Grammar should also reveal the basis of two phenomena:
- How some superficially distinct sentences are closely related? Charlie broke the window. The window was broken by Charlie.
- How some superficially similar sentences are in fact distinct? The king is easy to please. The king is eager to please.
π Definition β Productivity: The ability of a finite set of rules to generate an infinite number of new and unique sentences. π Definition β Recursion: The property of a rule that allows it to be applied repeatedly, embedding one structure inside another of the same type.
Topic- 126: Well-Formed Syntactic Structures
Well-formedness is the quality of a clause, word, or other linguistic element that conforms to the grammar of the language of which it is a part. Well-formed words or phrases are grammatical, meaning they obey all relevant rules of grammar. A form that violates some grammar rule is ill-formed and does not constitute part of the language. A word may be phonologically well-formed; a word, phrase, clause, or utterance may be grammatically well-formed; a semantically well-formed utterance is one that is meaningful. Grammatical well-formedness and semantic well-formedness do not always coincide. For example, 'colorless green ideas sleep furiously' is grammatically correct but semantically incorrect. Sometimes, native speakers do not agree whether a particular structure is well-formed, which is a problem for generative linguistics.
π Definition β Well-formed: Grammatically correct, obeying all relevant rules of grammar. π Definition β Ill-formed: Violating a grammar rule and not part of the language. π Example: Colorless green ideas sleep furiously (Grammatically well-formed, semantically ill-formed).
Topic- 127: Finite Number of Rules
'A small set of rules operating on a large but finite set of words generates an infinite number of sentences.' However, some argue that language may not be organized in discrete sentences, and the distinction between words and rules may be an artifact of dictionary making. Furthermore, it is not guaranteed that the number of possible sentences is truly infinite rather than just unimaginably large. As a matter of practical fact, the set of expressions actually produced by humans (or machines) is finite. Therefore, what matters is that any language allows a set of expressions that is sufficiently large for any purpose a human language can be used for.
Topic- 128: Recursion
The crucial property of recursion allows rules to be applied more than once in generating a structure. Recursive rules have the capacity to be applied repeatedly. For example, 'The gun was on the table' has one prepositional phrase. We can add 'near the window' and 'in the bedroom' to get 'The gun was on the table near the window in the bedroom'. Sentences are also put inside other sentences: 'Mary helped George' can become 'Cathy knew that Mary helped George', and further, 'John believed that Cathy knew that Mary helped George'. Principally, there is no end to recursion.
π Definition β Recursion: The property of a grammar rule that can be applied repeatedly, creating structures of potentially unlimited length and complexity. π Example: The gun was on the table near the window in the bedroom. (Repeated prepositional phrases) π Example: John believed that Cathy knew that Mary helped George. (Embedded sentences)
π‘ Why this matters: Grammar must capture that a sentence can contain another sentence inside it, and a phrase can be repeated as often as required. Recursion is an essential feature of grammar and a theory of cognitive structure.
β Key Takeaways
Syntax is the study of the rules for arranging words into sentences, and a generative grammar is a finite system of rules that can produce an infinite number of well-formed sentences. This grammar must have the property of recursion to allow for embedding, and it must distinguish between well-formed (grammatical) and ill-formed (ungrammatical) structures. Importantly, grammatical well-formedness does not always guarantee semantic sensibility, as shown by sentences like "colorless green ideas sleep furiously." Finally, the grammar should also explain how superficially different sentences (like active and passive) can be related, while superficially similar sentences (like "easy to please" vs. "eager to please") can have different underlying structures.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the literal meaning of the word 'syntax', and what is its primary goal in modern linguistics?
- What is a generative grammar, and what is its relationship to transformational grammar?
- List and explain at least three key properties that a generative grammar must have.
- Explain the difference between grammatical well-formedness and semantic well-formedness, providing an example.
- What is recursion in syntax, and why is it considered a crucial property for generating sentences?