π Lecture 23 β Planning Long Reports
π Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive framework for planning and organizing long reports in business and technical contexts. It covers the essential steps from defining questions to conducting research, and explains how to structure both informational and analytical reports effectively for professional communication.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the steps in planning a report including defining outline and purpose, outlining the issue, preparing a work plan, conducting research, and analyzing data. It explores defining questions through developing a statement of purpose and organizing reports. The lecture distinguishes between informational reports (organized by importance, sequence, chronology, spatial, geography, or category) and analytical reports. It also explains writing outlines using alphanumeric and decimal systems, and discusses collecting primary data through documents, observations, surveys, and interviews.
π Lecture Summary
Steps of Planning a Report
When you gather facts, you need to arrange them in a suitable format. Before putting a single word on the page, follow a series of steps that form the foundations of any report: define the outline and purpose, outline the issue for investigation, prepare a work plan, conduct research, and analyze and interpret data to draw conclusions and develop recommendations.
Defining the Questions
The person who authorizes the report defines the questions that guide the investigation. These include: What needs to be determined? Why is this issue important? Who is involved in the situation? Where is the trouble actually located? How did the situation originate? These questions are major questions that your audience has about the subject, and your objective is to answer all those questions in an order that makes sense.
a. Developing the Statement of Purpose
A purpose statement is a declarative sentence which summarizes the specific topic and goals of a document. It is typically included in the introduction to give the reader an accurate and concrete understanding of what the document will cover and what he/she can gain from reading it.
π Definition β Purpose Statement: A declarative sentence summarizing the specific topic and goals of a document, typically included in the introduction to give the reader an accurate understanding.
An effective statement of purpose should be:
- Specific and precise - not general, broad or obscure
- Concise - one or two sentences
- Clear - not vague, ambiguous or confusing
- Goal-oriented - stated in terms of desired outcomes
π Example β For an informational report: "Purpose: To summarize the extent of substance abuse among plant employees." For an analytical report: "Purpose: To analyze the effects of employee substance abuse on productivity and product quality, and recommend ways to counteract these effects."
π‘ Why this matters: A well-crafted purpose statement sets clear expectations for both the writer and the reader, ensuring the report stays focused on its intended goals.
b. Outlining and Organizing of Report
Informational Reports These reports offer data, facts, feedback, and other types of information, without analysis of the situation or recommendations. The purpose of informational reports is to explain, and clarity is the main objective. In these types of reports, reporting of facts may be organized by sub-topics in various ways:
- In order of Importance: For example, if reviewing five product lines, organize the study in increasing order of the amount of revenue they generate.
- Sequentially: If studying a process, present information step by step (1, 2, 3).
- Chronology: When investigating a chain of events, organize the study according to the event that happens first.
- Spatially: If studying a physical object, study it left to right, top to bottom, inside to outside.
- Geography: If location is important, factor the study geographically.
- Categorically: If reviewing several distinct aspects of a subject, look at one category at a time (e.g., sales, profit, or investment).
Analytical Reports These reports offer both information and analysis, and they can also purpose recommendations. For example, an analytical report on "Why are we having trouble in hiring secretaries?" will look into aspects such as salaries being too low, what is paid to secretaries, how important pay is in influencing job choices, poor location, and decreased trend of opting for the secretarial profession.
The Rules of Division
You can divide the topic into at least two parts. Choose a significant and useful basis or guiding principle for the division. When dividing a whole into its parts, restrict yourself to one basis at a time.
Developing Structural Clues
Four tools are particularly essential for giving readers an overall structure of your document and for keeping them on track when they read: the opening, headings and lists, smooth transitions, and the ending.
a. The Opening: A good opening accomplishes at least three things: introduces the subject of your report, indicates why the subject is important, and gives the readers a preview of main ideas and the order in which they will be covered.
b. Headings and lists: To help the reader find their way around a report quickly, a report is always divided into clear sections with headings (e.g., Facts, Discussion, Findings, Costs, Limitations, Advantages, Conclusions). Usually a numbering system is used too. The important thing is to be clear and consistent.
c. Smooth transitions: Phrases such as "to continue the analysis", "on the other hand", and "additional concept" are structural clues. Additional Details include: moreover, furthermore, in addition, besides. Causal Relationship phrases include: therefore, because, accordingly, thus, hence.
d. The ending: Cite your sources to persuade the reader about your information-gathering reliability. These may include interviews, articles, company records, surveys, your own observation, and so on. Proofread your document carefully before sending it to the reader.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts to remember from this lecture are the five foundational steps for planning any report: defining outline and purpose, outlining the issue, preparing a work plan, conducting research, and analyzing data. The statement of purpose must be specific, concise, clear, and goal-oriented, serving as the guiding framework for the entire document. Informational reports are organized without analysis using methods like importance, sequence, chronology, space, geography, or category, while analytical reports include both information and recommendations. Structural tools including openings, headings, transitions, and proper endings are essential for reader comprehension. Finally, the rules of division require dividing topics into at least two parts using a single, consistent basis of organization.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the five steps in planning a report as outlined in the lecture?
- What are the four characteristics of an effective statement of purpose?
- How do informational reports differ from analytical reports in terms of content and organization?
- What are the six methods for organizing informational reports mentioned in the lecture?
- What are the four essential tools for giving readers an overall structure of your document and keeping them on track?
π Lecture 24 β Writing Long Reports
π Overview: This lecture provides a comprehensive guide to producing and composing formal long reports. It details the three major divisions of a formal reportβPrefatory Parts, Body, and Supplementary Partsβand explains the function and content of each component, from the title page to the index. Understanding this structure is crucial for creating professional, well-organized reports in academic and business settings.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the overall process of report production, then details the composition of a formal report by breaking it down into its three major divisions: Prefatory Parts (Title fly, Title page, Letter of authorization, Letter of transmittal, Table of contents, Preface), the Body of the Report (Introduction, Text, Terminal Section including Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations), and Supplementary Parts (Appendix, Bibliography, Glossary, Index). Each component's specific purpose and content requirements are explained.
π Lecture Summary
Report Production
Planning formal reports and proposals, conducting the necessary research, organizing the ideas, developing visual aids, and drafting the text are demanding and time-consuming tasks. After careful editing and rewriting, you still need to produce a polished version.
Composing a formal Report
A professional report conveys the impression that the subject is important. A formal report has many formalities, embellishments, and requirements, which must be completed. A formal report may be divided into three major divisions:
- Prefatory parts
- Body of report
- Supplementary parts
1. Prefatory parts
The Prefatory Parts of a formal report include the title fly, title page, letter of authorization, letter of transmittal, table of contents, and preface.
a. Title fly
The title fly is a plane sheet with only the title of the report on it. π Definition β Title fly: a plain sheet of paper that contains only the title of the report.
b. Title page
The title page includes four blocks of information:
- The title of the report
- The name, title and address of the person that authorized the report
- The name, title and address of the person that prepared the report
- The date on which the report was submitted
π Definition β Title page: the page in a report that includes the report title, the authorizer's details, the preparer's details, and the submission date.
2. Body of report
The Body of the Report consists of the introduction, text, and terminal section.
a. Introduction
A report's introduction summarizes the contents by describing the purpose of the report and giving an overview of the main ideas expressed within it. The introduction to a report serves a number of important functions:
- Authorization
- Problem/purpose
- Scope
- Background
- Sources and methods
- Definitions
- Limitations
- Report organization
π Definition β Introduction (in a report): a section that summarizes the report's contents by describing its purpose and providing an overview of its main ideas.
b. Text
The text contains the actual details of the report. It is the main and crucial part of the body. This part consists of major sections or chapters that analyze and interpret the material gathered as a result of your investigation. The content, organization, language, style, and visual aid should be trimmed to the type of the reader. π Definition β Text (in a report): the main section of the body that contains the detailed analysis and interpretation of the investigation's findings.
c. Terminal Section
The Terminal Section of the body of the report may comprise one or all of the following elements:
- Summary
- Conclusions
- Recommendations
Summary
This section summarizes the findings of the investigation.
Conclusions
It interprets facts explained. It does not give the writer's personal opinion. The opinion should be unbiased and should not be based on personal likes and dislikes.
Recommendations
This section suggests a plan of action based on findings and conclusions.
π Definition β Terminal Section: the final part of the report's body that may include a summary of findings, unbiased conclusions, and recommendations for action.
3. Supplementary Parts
The Supplementary Parts of a formal report include the appendix, bibliography, glossary, and index.
a. Appendix
The appendix (or appendices) contains supplementary material that is too detailed or lengthy to include in the main body of the report.
β Key Takeaways
The formal report is structured into three primary divisions: Prefatory Parts (including the title fly and title page), the Body (introduction, text, and terminal section with summary, conclusions, and recommendations), and Supplementary Parts (appendix, bibliography, glossary, index). The title page is a critical prefatory element that clearly identifies the report, its authorizer, its preparer, and the submission date. The introduction serves multiple key functions like defining the problem, scope, and methodology, while the text is the core analytical section. The terminal section provides a summary, unbiased conclusions, and actionable recommendations based on the findings.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three major divisions of a formal report?
- What four blocks of information must be included on a title page?
- What is the primary difference between the function of the text section and the conclusions section in the body of a report?
- List at least five of the key functions that a report's introduction serves.
- What is a title fly, and how does it differ from a title page?
π Lecture 25 β General Reports
π Overview: This lecture covers the fundamental structure and purpose of general reports in business and technical contexts. It explains how report length varies by situation, how readers use information, and the essential six-part superstructure that answers readers' key questions, making reports effective and reader-centered.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers report-writing situations that vary in length from two paragraphs to two hundred pages, how readers want to use information to solve organizational, social, or personal problems, the six key questions readers ask most often, and the general superstructure for reports containing introduction, method, facts, discussion, conclusions, and recommendations.
π Lecture Summary
Report-writing situations
Report-writing situations vary widely. You might produce a one-hundred-page report on a seventh-month project to test a special method of venting high-speed engines for space vehicles, a twelve-page report based on library research to determine which long-distance telephone company provides the most reliable service, a two-paragraph report based upon a manufacturing engineer's visit to a new plant that is about to be put into service, or a two-hundred-page report to the general public concerning the environmental impact of mining certain portions of public land in Baluchistan. The length of a report varies according to the situation and the project, with no definite criteria β it can be from only two paragraphs to two hundred pages.
How readers want to use the information you provide
Your readers may want to use your information to solve: an organizational problem, where typical goals are to increase efficiency and profit; a social problem, where typical goals are to improve the general health and welfare of groups of people; or a personal problem, where typical goals are to satisfy individual preferences and values.
The questions that readers ask most often
Readers typically ask: What will we gain from your report? Are your facts reliable? What do you know that is useful to us? How do you interpret those facts from our point of view? How are those facts significant to us? What do you think we should do?
General superstructure of reports
The general superstructure of reports contains six elements, one for each of the six basic questions: introduction, method of obtaining facts, facts, discussion, conclusions, and recommendations.
a. Introduction
In the introduction, you answer your readers' question, "What will we gain by reading your report?" In longer reports, your explanation of the relevance of your report to your readers may take many pages, telling things such as: what is the problem that your report will help to solve; what activities you performed towards solving that problem; and how your audience can apply your information in their own efforts towards solving the problem.
b. Method of obtaining facts
The method section also suggests to your readers how they can gain additional information on the same subject. For example, if you obtained your information through reading, you direct your readers to those sources; if you obtained your information through an experiment, survey, or other special technique, your account of your method may help others design similar projects.
c. Facts
Your facts are the individual pieces of information that underlie and support your conclusions and recommendations. If your report is based upon interviews, your facts are the things that people told you. If your report is based upon laboratory, field, or library research, your facts are the verifiable pieces of information that you gathered.
d. Discussion
Taken alone, facts mean nothing. Therefore, an essential element of every report you prepare will be a discussion in which you interpret your facts in a way that is significant to your readers. It is important to remember that your readers count on you not only to select facts that are relevant to them, but also to discuss those facts in a way that is meaningful to them.
π‘ Why this matters: Without discussion, facts remain raw data; discussion connects facts to the reader's needs and context.
e. Conclusions
Like interpretations, conclusions are general statements based on your facts. However, conclusions don't simply focus on interpreting the facts but also on answering the readers' question: "How are those facts significant to us?"
f. Recommendations
The lecture mentions recommendations as the final element of the superstructure but does not provide detailed explanation or example in this excerpt.
β Key Takeaways
Report length is flexible, ranging from two paragraphs to two hundred pages depending on the situation. Readers use report information to solve organizational, social, or personal problems, and they consistently ask six key questions about gain, reliability, utility, interpretation, significance, and action. The universal report superstructure contains exactly six elements β introduction, method, facts, discussion, conclusions, and recommendations β each answering one of those reader questions. Facts alone are meaningless without discussion that interprets them for the reader's context. Conclusions answer how facts are significant to readers, not just what facts mean.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the six elements of the general report superstructure, and which reader question does each answer?
- How does the discussion section differ from the conclusions section in a report?
- What three types of problems might readers want to solve using information from your report?
- According to the lecture, what determines whether a report should be two paragraphs or two hundred pages?
- Why is it important to include the method of obtaining facts in a report?
π Lecture 26 β Empirical Research Report
π Overview: This lecture defines the empirical research report and explains its purpose in both practical decision-making and human knowledge extension. It outlines the seven key questions readers ask about such reports and provides a detailed superstructure for organizing them, including sections on introduction, objectives, methods, results, discussion, conclusions, and recommendations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining an empirical research report as a research that reports results of a study using data derived from actual observation or experimentation. It then discusses the two main purposes of such research: supporting practical decisions and extending human knowledge. The lecture presents the seven questions readers most commonly ask about empirical research, followed by a detailed superstructure with seven elements: introduction, objectives of research, methods, results, discussion, conclusions, and recommendations. Within the introduction section, it covers announcing the topic and explaining the importance of research through relevance to organization goals and literature reviews.
π Lecture Summary
Defining Empirical Research Report
An empirical research is a research that reports the results of a study and uses data derived from actual observation or experimentation. Such research is used to answer a question or test a hypothesis. You will be able to use the superstructure for empirical research reports most successfully, if you understand the purpose of research discussed in them. When you are writing about empirical research, you will be writing to people who will make decisions based on the results of your reports.
π Definition β Empirical Research Report: A research report that reports the results of a study using data derived from actual observation or experimentation, used to answer a question or test a hypothesis.
π Example: Ayeshaβs experiment will be used by engineers who design engines for employees. The results of Anamβs survey will be used by a state agency in charge of outdoor recreation as it decides what sort of facilities it must provide to meet the needs of older citizens.
A smaller amount of empirical research has a different purpose: to extend general human knowledge. The researchers set out to learn how fish remember, what the molten core of earth is like, etc. The research is carried out for the sake of humanity and is published in science journals. In some situations, these two aims of research overlap. Some organizations sponsor basic research, usually in the hope that what is learned can later be turned into practical use. Likewise, some practical research turns up results that are of interest to those who desire to learn more about the world in general.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding the purpose of your researchβwhether practical or knowledge-extendingβdetermines how you present your findings and to whom.
The Questions Readers Ask Most
Whether it aims to support practical decisions, extend human knowledge, or achieve some combination of the two purposes, almost all empirical research is customarily reported in the same superstructure. That's because readers of all types have the same seven general questions about it.
The seven questions are:
- Why is the research important to us? β Readers concerned with solving specific practical problems want to know what problems your research will help address. Readers concerned with extending human knowledge want to know how your research contributes to what humans should know.
- What were you trying to find out? β A key part of an empirical research project is the careful formulation of the research questions that the project will try to answer. Readers want to know what those questions are so they can determine whether they are significant.
- Was your research method sound? β Your method has to be appropriate to your research and intellectually sound. If it is not, your readers will not rely on your results, conclusions, and recommendations.
- What results did your research produce? β Naturally, your readers will want to find out what results you obtained.
- How do you interpret those results? β Your readers will want to interpret those results in ways that are meaningful to them.
- What is the significance of those results? β What answers do those results imply for your research questions, and how do your results relate to the problems?
- What do you think we should do? β Readers concerned with practical problems want to know what you advise them to do. Readers concerned with extending human knowledge want to know what you think your results imply for future research.
Superstructure for Empirical Research Reports
To answer the readers' typical questions about empirical research reports, writers use a superstructure that has the following elements: a. Introduction b. Objectives of research c. Methods d. Results e. Discussion f. Conclusions g. Recommendation
a. Introduction
In the introduction to an empirical report, you should seek to answer the readers' question: "Why is the research important to us?" Typically, writers answer this question in two steps:
- They announce the topic of their research
- Explain the importance of the topic to their readers
Announcing the topic: You can often announce the topic of your research simply by writing the topic as the key phrase in the opening sentence of your report.
π Example: "For the past eighteen months, the Satellite Products Laboratory has been developing a system that will permit companies with large, nationwide fleets of trucks to communicate directly with their drivers at any time through a satellite link." π Example: "Social Psychologists know very little about the way real friendships develop in their natural settings."
Explaining the importance of research: To explain the importance of research to your readers, you can use either or both of the following methods:
- State the relevance of your research to your organization's goals.
- Review the previously published literature on the subject.
Relevance to Organization Goals: In reports written to readers in an organization (whether it's your own or a client's), you can explain the relevance of your research by relating it to some organizational goal or problem. Sometimes the importance of research will be so obvious to your readers that merely naming your topic will be sufficient. At other times, you will need to discuss at length the relevance of your research to the organization. In the first paragraph of the satellite report, for instance, the writers mention the potential market for the satellite communication system they are developing.
Literature Reviews: A second way to establish the importance of your research is to review the existing knowledge on your subject. Writers usually do this by reviewing the previously published literature. Generally, you can arrange a literature review in two parts: First, present the main pieces of knowledge communicated in the literature. Then, identify some significant gap in this knowledgeβthe very gap your own research will fill. In this way, you establish the special contribution that your research will make.
π Example: "A great deal of research in social psychology has focused on variables influencing an individual's attraction to another at an initial encounter, usually in laboratory settings (Bergscheid and Walster, 1978; Bryne, 1971; Huston and Levinger, 1978), yet very little data exists on the processes by which individuals in the real world move beyond initial attraction to develop a friendship; even less data is known about the way developing friendships are maintained and how they evolve over time (Huston and Burgess, 1979; Levinger, 1980)."
The writer continues this discussion of previous research for three paragraphs. Each follows the same pattern: it identifies an area of research, tells what is known about that area, and identifies gaps in the knowledge that will be filled by the research that the writer has conducted. These paragraphs serve an important additional function: they introduce the established facts and theories that are relevant to the writer's work and necessary to the understanding of the report.
Writers almost always include literature reviews in the reports they write for professional journals. In contrast, they often omit reviews when writing to readers inside an organization. That's because such reviews are often unnecessary when addressing organizational readers. Organizational readers judge the importance of a report in terms of its relevance to the organization's goals and problems, not in terms of its relation to the general pool of human knowledge. For example, the typical readers of the truck-and-satellite communication report were interested in the report because they wanted to learn how well their company's system would work. To them, a general survey of the literature on satellite communication would have seemed irrelevantβand perhaps even annoying. A second reason that writers often omit literature reviews when addressing readers in organizations is that such reviews rarely help such readers understand the reports. That's because the research projects undertaken within organizations usually focus so sharply on a particular, local question that published literature on the subject is beside the point. For example, a review of previously published literature on satellite communications would not have helped readers understand the truck-and-satellite report.
Sometimes, of course, literature reviews do appear in reports written to organizational readers. Often, they say something like this: "In a published article, one of our competitors claims to have saved large amounts of money by trying a new technique. The purpose of the research described in this report is to determine whether or not we could enjoy similar results." Of course, the final standard for judging whether you should include a literature review in your report is your understanding of your purpose and readers. In some way or another, however, the introduction to all your empirical research reports should answer your readers' question, "Why is this research important to us?"
b. Objectives of the Research
Every empirical research project has carefully constructed objectives. These objectives define the focus of your project, influence the choice of research method, and shape the way you interpret your results. Thus, readers of empirical research reports want and need to know what the objectives are.
π Example from the satellite report: "In particular, we wanted to test whether we could achieve accurate data transmissions and good-quality voice transmissions in the variety of terrains typically encountered in long-haul trucking. We wanted also to see what factors might affect the quality of transmissions."
When reporting on research that involves the use of statistics, you can usually state your objectives by stating the hypotheses you tested. Where appropriate, you can explain these hypotheses in terms of existing theory, again citing previous publications on the subject.
π Example from the friendship study: "The goal of the study was to identify characteristics of behavioral and attitudinal changes that occurred within interpersonal relationships as they progressed from initial acquaintance to close friendship. With regard to relationship benefits and costs, it was predicted that both benefits and costs would increase as the friendship developed. The ratings of both the costs and benefits would be positively correlated with the ratings of friendship intensity. In addition, the types of benefits listed by the subjects were expected to change as the friendships developed."
c. Method
When reading the reports of your empirical research, people will look for precise details concerning your method. Those details serve three purposes:
- They let the readers assess the soundness of your research design and its appropriateness for the problems you are investigating.
- The details enable your readers to determine the limitations that your method might place upon the conclusions you draw.
- The description of your method provides information that will help your readers repeat your experiment, if they wish to verify your results or conduct similar research of their own.
The kind of information you provide about your method depends upon the nature of your research.
π Definition β Method: The precise details of how the research was conducted, which let readers assess soundness, determine limitations, and repeat the experiment if desired.
β Key Takeaways
An empirical research report uses data from actual observation or experimentation to answer a question or test a hypothesis. The report must answer seven key reader questions: why the research is important, what the objectives are, whether the method was sound, what results were produced, how to interpret those results, what the significance is, and what should be done. The superstructure includes introduction, objectives, methods, results, discussion, conclusions, and recommendations. The introduction must announce the topic and explain its importance, either through relevance to organizational goals or through a literature review that identifies gaps in existing knowledge. The objectives define the focus and influence the method and interpretation, while the method description must allow readers to assess soundness, determine limitations, and potentially replicate the study.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is an empirical research report and what is its primary purpose?
- What are the seven questions that readers of empirical research reports most commonly ask?
- What two methods can writers use to explain the importance of their research in the introduction?
- Why do writers often omit literature reviews when writing to organizational readers?
- What three purposes does the method section serve for readers of empirical research reports?
π Lecture 27 β Feasibility Reports
π Overview: This lecture introduces feasibility reports, which are written to help decision-makers choose between two or more courses of action. It covers the typical writing situation, the key questions readers ask, and the seven-element superstructure that organizes the report. Understanding this structure ensures your feasibility report is persuasive, credible, and actionable.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the typical writing situation for feasibility reports, the seven questions readers ask most often, and the seven-element superstructure used to answer them. The superstructure includes the Introduction, Criteria, Method of Obtaining Facts, Overview of Alternatives, Evaluation, Conclusions, and Recommendations. Detailed examples from Fawaz and Shazi illustrate how to apply each element in practice.
π Lecture Summary
Typical Writing Situation
All feasibility reports share one essential characteristic: they are written to help decision-makers choose between two or more courses of action. Even when a report focuses on one option, the reader always considers a second courseβleaving things as they are. For example, continuing to use metal parts rather than plastic parts in sailboats. However, readers may already have decided change is necessary and will be choosing between two or more alternatives to the status quo.
The Questions Readers Ask Most Often
Decision-makers ask seven basic questions that remain consistent across situations, making it possible to use a similar superstructure for any feasibility report. These questions are: a. Why is it important for us to consider these alternatives? b. Are your criteria reasonable and appropriate? c. Are your facts reliable? d. What are the important features of the alternatives? e. How do the alternatives stack up against your criteria? f. What conclusions do you draw about the alternatives? g. What do you think we should do?
a. Why is it important for us to consider these alternatives? Decision-makers ask this to know why they have to make any choice. You may need a detailed explanation of a problem to show the importance of considering alternatives. However, if readers are familiar with the problem, simply reminding them may suffice.
b. Are your criteria reasonable and appropriate? To help readers choose, you must evaluate alternatives using specific criteria. At work, people want these criteria to reflect the needs and aims of their organization.
c. Are your facts reliable? Decision-makers need assurance that your facts are reliable before they act on them.
d. What are the important features of the alternatives? Readers need an overview highlighting the key features of each alternative to understand the detailed discussion that follows.
e. How do the alternatives stack up against your criteria? The heart of a feasibility study is your evaluation of alternatives against your criteria. Readers want to know these results.
f. What conclusions do you draw about the alternatives? Based on the detailed evaluation, you reach general conclusions about the merits of each alternative. Decision-makers need these overall judgments to form their decision.
g. What do you think we should do? Finally, you must help readers by telling them what you recommend, based on your expertise.
Superstructure for Feasibility Reports
To answer readers' questions, use a superstructure with these seven elements: a. Introduction b. Criteria c. Method of Obtaining Facts d. Overview of Alternatives e. Evaluation f. Conclusions g. Recommendations
You may combine elements depending on your situation (e.g., integrating conclusions into evaluation, or omitting a separate criteria section). However, it is better to include each element based on your purpose, audience, and situation.
a. Introduction
In the introduction, answer the question: βWhy is it important for us to consider these alternatives?β The most persuasive way is to identify the problem your feasibility study will help solve or the goal it will help achieve. Be sure to identify a problem significant from the point of view of your employer or client, such as reducing rejected parts or increasing productivity.
π Definition β Problem: The issue or challenge that your feasibility study is designed to resolve, which is significant from the stakeholder's perspective.
π Example 1 (Fawaz): Fawaz, a process engineer in a paper mill, evaluated substituting one ingredient for another. His introduction stated: βAt present, we rely on titanium dioxide... the price has been rising... Some mills are now replacing some titanium dioxide with silicate extenders... To determine whether we could enjoy similar savings... I have studied the physical properties, material handling requirements, and cost of two silicate extenders.β He also included his major conclusion: βI conclude that one of the silicate extenders... looks promising enough to be tested in a mill run.β
π Example 2 (Shazi): Shazi evaluated opening a new bank branch. She announced her topic, provided background, emphasized importance (βAl-Shami bank has approached opening new branches with great care... which is undoubtedly a major reason why it has become the most successful small, privately owned financial institutionβ), and included her conclusion: βOverall, Gulberg offers an appealing opportunity, but would present Al-Shami Bank with some challenges it has not faced before.β
π‘ Why this matters: The introduction must also preview main conclusions and major recommendations for long reports. It may combine with other elements like criteria, methods, or overview of alternatives.
b. Criteria
Criteria are the standards you apply to evaluate the alternative courses of action. For instance, Shazi used criteria like the existence of a large enough market, good possibility of attracting depositors, likelihood of profit exceeding expenses, and reasonableness of financial outlay.
Two Ways of Presenting Criteria
- Devote a separate section: Common in long reports or when criteria need extended explanation.
- Integrate into other elements: Fawaz integrated his criteria into his introduction: βI have studied the physical properties, material handling requirements, and cost of two silicate extenders.β
Importance of Presenting Criteria Early Three reasons: First, readers need to know the criteria to evaluate the validity of your conclusions. Second, the criteria tell readers about the scope of your study. Third, if readers know the criteria in advance, your decision-making will make more sense.
Sources of Your Criteria Often, the requester tells you what criteria to apply. In other situations, readers expect you to identify relevant criteria based on your technical knowledge.
Four Common Types of Criteria At work, criteria often address these questions:
- Will the course of action really do whatβs wanted?
- Can we implement it?
- Can we afford it?
- Is it desirable?
c. Methods of Obtaining Facts
When you describe your methods, you answer the question βAre your facts reliable?β by assuring readers your facts form a sound basis for decision-making. Sources include library research, calls to manufacturers, interviews, meetings with experts, surveys, and laboratory research. The amount of detail depends on your readers and situation; the goal is to say enough to show your information is trustworthy.
π Example: Shazi used technical procedures to estimate deposits for a new branch, so she needed to describe her methods. The amount of description depends on how many techniques you used; if you used several, you might mention each at the point where you discuss the results.
d. Overview of Alternatives
Before detailed evaluation, ensure readers understand what the alternatives are. Sometimes a few words suffice.
π Example (simple): If you investigate increasing starting salaries for store managers, readers will not need special explanation of that alternative.
π Example (complex): Jahangir, reporting on replacing a company-owned telephone system, needed to provide extensive background information to help readers piece together his point-by-point evaluation.
e. Evaluation
(Referenced in the superstructure but not detailed further in the lecture text. This section typically contains your point-by-point comparison of alternatives against criteria.)
f. Conclusions
(Referenced but not detailed. Conclusions explain what your results mean in terms of original research questions.)
g. Recommendations
(Referenced but not detailed. Recommendations tell readers what action you think should be taken, especially in practical problem-solving contexts.)
β Key Takeaways
The most critical thing to remember is that a feasibility report is structured specifically to answer the seven questions decision-makers ask, from βWhy consider alternatives?β to βWhat should we do?β The superstructure elementsβIntroduction, Criteria, Method, Overview, Evaluation, Conclusions, and Recommendationsβare designed to answer these questions in order. Criteria must be presented early and can come from the requester or your own expertise; they answer questions about effectiveness, feasibility, cost, and desirability. The introduction must identify a significant problem, preview the study's scope, and state the main conclusions to grab the reader's attention and establish credibility. Finally, always tailor the level of detail to your audience, ensuring your facts are trustworthy and your overview of alternatives is clear before evaluation begins.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the one essential characteristic that all feasibility reports share?
- Name the seven questions that decision-makers ask when reading a feasibility report.
- What are the three good reasons for presenting criteria early in a feasibility report?
- In the two examples (Fawaz and Shazi), what was one key element included in their introductions that went beyond simply stating the problem?
- What are the four common types of criteria that address βWill it work?β βCan we do it?β βCan we afford it?β and βIs it acceptable?β