π Lecture 23 β Writing: Effective Sentences: Unity, Coherence, And Emphasis
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the three core elements that make sentences effective: unity, coherence, and emphasis. It provides detailed explanations of how to achieve each element and how violations of these principles can weaken writing, making it essential for clear and persuasive academic and professional communication.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by defining the three elements of effective sentences: unity, coherence, and emphasis. It then delves deeply into unity, explaining the five ways it can be violated: combining unrelated ideas, putting too many details in a single sentence, failure to complete an idea, faulty subordination, and faulty parallelism. The second major element, coherence, is discussed with four pitfalls: ambiguous pronoun reference, split constructions, mixed constructions, and aimless shifting. Finally, the lecture covers emphasis, focusing on position, order of climax, and repetition.
π Lecture Summary
Effective Sentences
The lecture introduces the three essential ingredients for effective sentences: unity, coherence, and emphasis. Unity means every part of a sentence must contribute to one main unifying thought. Coherence means the various parts of a sentence must follow one another in an order that makes their relationship clear. Emphasis means the most important parts of a sentence must be placed so that attention is directed toward them rather than toward less important parts.
I. Unity
A good sentence must express one main idea. Although a sentence may contain more than one fact, all the facts must relate to the main idea. For example, the sentence "The models were all dressed in the latest fashions and many of them are unemployed" lacks unity because the two ideasβclothing and unemploymentβare unrelated and should be in separate sentences. Unity is violated in five specific ways:
(i) Combining unrelated ideas: e.g., "The students at the college use a great deal of abusive language and they are from all parts of the country."
(ii) Putting too many ideas / details in a single sentence: This distracts the reader from the main thought. e.g., "Reading his daily newspaper that morning, standing at the crowded bus stop, the morning sun just lighting up the tops of the high buildings and making the sleepy-eyed people shade their eyes, made a great impression on me."
(iii) Failure to complete an idea or grammatical construction: These sentences leave gaps in thought. e.g., "This is such a heavy chair," or "I was so pleased about the letter." These can be improved by adding a clause: "This is such a heavy chair that it is not easy to carry."
(iv) Subordination: When you place the principal or main thought in a subordinate position, the unity of the sentence is destroyed. π Definition β Subordination: Placing a less important idea in a dependent clause while the main idea is in the independent clause. π Principle: Subordinate the less important ideas to the main idea to give emphasis to the main thought. π Example:
- Faulty: The fielder in the slips dropped the third catch, when the match was definitely lost. (Main idea is in the subordinate clause)
- Improved: When the fielder in the slips dropped the third catch, the match was definitely lost.
(v) Parallelism: If two ideas are co-ordinate (of equal rank), they must be given equal rank in the sentence. Nouns must be parallel to nouns, verbs to verbs, subordinate clauses to subordinate clauses, and gerunds to gerunds. π Definition β Parallelism: The use of grammatically equal structures to express equal or parallel ideas. π Example of faulty parallelism: "Seemaβs job is reading books and to write book reviews." (gerund vs. infinitive) π Example of improvement: "Seemaβs job is reading books and writing book reviews." π‘ Why this matters: Faulty parallelism is worse than no parallelism at all. Correlatives (either...or, not only...but also) should be used only with parallel elements. e.g., "He not only likes tennis but also golf" should be "He likes not only tennis but also golf."
II. Coherence
A sentence has coherence when the various parts follow one another in an order which makes their relationship clear. Correct handling of unity, parallelism, and subordination contributes to coherence. Four pitfalls must be avoided:
1. Reference of Pronouns: Pronoun references must be clear and unambiguous. π Example of ambiguous reference: "Ahmed saw Basit and Zahid yesterday and he said that he had the money." (Who is "he"?) π Example of antecedent agreement error: "The Guard Company is now using coal in their furnaces instead of fuel oil." (Company is singular, should be "its") π‘ Why this matters: Don't treat an antecedent first as singular and then as plural.
2. Split Constructions: Avoid splitting infinitives or other grammatical units. π Example: "The batsman started to viciously hit the stumps." (Split infinitive) π Example of poor construction: "This is the book to which I was referring to." (Repetition of preposition)
3. Mixed Constructions and Mixed Figures of Speech: Avoid mixing different figures of speech or grammatical structures. π Example: "My castles in air came tumbling down into a bottomless heap." (Mixing a castle and a heap)
4. Aimless Shifting: Avoid needless shifting from one point of view to another, which destroys coherence. This can be due to: (a) Shift from active to passive: "He ran to the station and the train was taken by him." (b) Shift from singular to plural: "If one tries hard, they can accomplish much." (c) Shift from past tense to present: "The only words that we were able to distinguish are βhorseβ and βcartβ."
III. Emphasis
Emphasis directs attention to the most important parts of a sentence. This can be achieved through three methods:
(a) Position: Place important words or ideas at the beginning or end of a sentence, as these are the most emphatic positions. π Example (weak): "You shall be called a liar, in all probability." (The important idea is buried in the middle) π Example (improved): "In all probability, you shall be called a liar."
(b) Order of Climax: Arrange ideas in ascending order of importance. π Example (poor): "During his long stay with the club he served as president, secretary, treasurer and vice president." (Should be: secretary, treasurer, vice president, and president)
(c) Repetition: Repeat key words or phrases for emphasis. π Example: "The dog was his only friend, his only companion, his only confidant, and his only heir."
β Key Takeaways
The most critical things a student MUST remember from this lecture for the exam are the three essential elements of effective sentences: unity, coherence, and emphasis. Unity requires that every part of a sentence contribute to one main idea, which is violated by unrelated ideas, too many details, incomplete constructions, faulty subordination, and faulty parallelism. Coherence demands a clear, logical order of ideas, which is destroyed by ambiguous pronoun references, split constructions, mixed figures of speech, and needless shifts in voice, number, or tense. Emphasis is achieved by placing important ideas at the beginning or end of a sentence, using an order of climax, or employing repetition for effect. Students must be able to identify and correct violations of all three principles in sample sentences.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three elements that make sentences effective?
- List the five ways in which the unity of a sentence can be violated.
- What is faulty parallelism, and why is it considered worse than no parallelism at all?
- Identify the four pitfalls that destroy coherence in a sentence.
- Name the three methods for achieving emphasis in a sentence.
π Lecture 24 β Writing: Identifying Sentence Errors
π Overview: This lecture focuses on four common sentence errors writers must avoid to produce clear, grammatically correct writing. It provides detailed explanations, examples, and practice exercises for identifying and correcting sentence fragments, run-on sentences, and misplaced and dangling modifiers, with particular emphasis on four types of fragments.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers four major sentence errors: sentence fragments (including dependent-word fragments, -ing and to fragments, added-detail fragments, and missing-subject fragments), run-on sentences (fused sentences and comma splices), and misplaced and dangling modifiers. Each type is explained with examples and correction methods, followed by practice exercises and a lesson review.
π Lecture Summary
Sentence Errors to be Avoided:
Having considered general elements for effectiveness in sentences, we now take up four common errors in sentence construction that should be avoided by all who write in English: sentence fragments, run-on sentences (fused sentences and comma splice), and misplaced and dangling modifiers.
Sentence Fragments
A sentence fragment is less than a sentence because it lacks a subject or a verb, or because it does not express a complete thought. The basic requirement is that a group of words must contain a subject and a verb and express one complete thought. For example, "My neighbour being a typical businessman who prides himself on his efficiency" is a fragment. Professional writers may use fragments, but their fragments convey complete thoughts immediately.
I. Dependent Word Fragments
Some fragments contain a subject and a verb but do not express a complete thought. They begin with dependent words such as since, when, after, because, until, while. For example: "Since Ami was tired" is a fragment, but "Since Ami was tired, she took a nap" is complete. The dependent word group needs an independent clause to complete the thought.
π Definition β Dependent Word Fragment: A group of words that has a subject and verb but begins with a dependent word and does not express a complete thought on its own.
π Example: "After the new department store opened." (fragment) β "After the new department store opened, several small shops went out of business." (complete sentence)
Practice 1 identifies fragments in sentences like "After the new department store opened. Several small shops went out of business" β the first part is a fragment.
Practice 2 shows how to complete dependent-word fragments: "When I rang the doorbell, the lights of the house went out." "Since I had forgotten my house keys, I had to break the door." "Schools were closed yesterday because of the political rally."
II. -Ing and To Fragments
When a word ending in -ing appears at the beginning of a group of words, a fragment may result. For example: "Hoping to buy things cheaply." is a fragment because it lacks both a subject and a verb. Similarly, a to fragment occurs when to + verb begins a word group, e.g., "The ladies jogged through the park. To lose weight."
π Definition β -Ing Fragment: A word group beginning with an -ing word that lacks a subject and verb and does not express a complete thought. π Definition β To Fragment: A word group beginning with to + verb that lacks a subject and verb and does not express a complete thought.
π Correction Methods:
- Connect the fragment to the sentence it explains, e.g., "Hoping to buy things cheaply, poor people often go to the Sunday bazaar."
- Create a complete sentence by adding a subject and verb, e.g., "Poor people often go to the Sunday bazaar. They hope to buy things cheaply."
π Example: "Police officers stood all over the road. Directing traffic around the accident." β "Police officers stood all over the road, directing traffic around the accident." OR "The ladies jogged through the park. To lose weight." β "The ladies jogged through the park. They wanted to lose weight."
III. Added-Detail Fragment
Another common fragment begins with words like like, including, such as, for example, for instance, except, without, especially, and also. These words introduce an additional point or example to what has already been stated. For example: "Everyone enjoyed the feast. Except the fish." "We had to read several novels. Including 'The Ice Age'." Each fragment lacks both a subject and a verb.
π Definition β Added-Detail Fragment: A word group beginning with an added-detail word (such as like, including, such as, for example) that lacks a subject and verb.
π Correction Methods: A. Add the fragment to the sentence it explains, e.g., "Everyone enjoyed the feast except the fish." B. Create a new sentence by adding a subject and verb, e.g., "Everyone enjoyed the feast. They did not enjoy the fish."
π Example: "The policeman searched the room for clues. Such as old photographs, old letters and old receipts." β "The policeman searched the room for clues such as old photographs, old letters and old receipts." OR "The policeman searched the room for clues. Examples included old photographs, old letters and old receipts."
IV. Missing-Subject Fragment
Some word groups are fragments because, while they do have a verb, they lack a subject. For example: "The poor woman paid all her utility bills. But then had little money left over for food." The second word group (had little money left over for food) is a fragment because it omits the subject of the verb had. Similarly: "The nurse held a smiling baby. Then posed for the photographers."
π Definition β Missing-Subject Fragment: A word group that has a verb but lacks a subject, making it incomplete.
π Correction Methods: (a) Connect the fragment to the sentence that comes before it, adding a joining word if needed: "The poor woman paid all her utility bills but had little money left for her food." (b) Create a new sentence by adding a subject (usually a pronoun that stands for the subject of the previous sentence): "The poor woman paid all her utility bills. But she had little money left for her food."
π Example: "The sleeping dog opened one eye to look at the postman. And then went back to sleep." β "The sleeping dog opened one eye to look at the postman and then went back to sleep." OR "The sleeping dog opened one eye to look at the postman. Then it went back to sleep."
Lesson Review
Fill in the blanks:
- To be a sentence, a group of words must contain a subject and a verb and it must express a complete thought.
- Words such as because, until and while are known as dependent words because word groups that begin with them depend on another statement to complete the thought.
- Fragments that begin with words such as like, especially, and for example are known as added-detail fragments.
- One way to correct an added-detail fragment is to create a new sentence by adding a subject and verb to the fragment.
- One way to correct a missing-subject fragment is to add a subject to the fragment.
TEST: Sentence Fragments
Correcting fragments in a passage: The word groups beginning with when and which are dependent-word fragments, so each needs to be added to the sentence that comes before or after it: "When people are scared, the hair on their bodies really can 'stand on end'. Each hair is attached to a tiny muscle which can pull the hair straight up. The muscles react together in response to a great fright."
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concept is that a sentence must have a subject and a verb and express a complete thought. The four types of fragmentsβdependent-word, -ing/to, added-detail, and missing-subjectβeach have specific correction methods: either connect the fragment to the sentence it explains, or create a new sentence by adding a subject and verb. Dependent-word fragments begin with words like because, when, since and need an independent clause to complete the thought. For the exam, remember that any word group starting with -ing, to, or added-detail words (like such as, including, except) is likely a fragment that needs to be attached or rewritten. The two universal correction methods apply to all fragment types: connection (adding to the previous sentence) or creation (adding subject + verb).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three requirements for a group of words to be a complete sentence?
- How do you correct an -ing fragment like "Running quickly through the hall"?
- What kind of words begin an added-detail fragment, and give two examples?
- What is the difference between connecting a missing-subject fragment and creating a new sentence for it?
- Why is "When the postman arrived" a fragment even though it has a subject and verb?
π Lecture 25 β WRITING: REVISING SENTENCE ERRORS
π Overview: This lecture continues the exploration of sentence errors by examining the two most common types beyond fragments: run-on sentences (including fused sentences and comma splices) and dangling modifiers. Understanding how to identify and correct these errors is essential for producing clear, professional writing.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main categories of sentence errors: run-on sentences (fused sentences and comma splices) with methods for correction, and misplaced/dangling modifiers. It provides definitions, examples, practice exercises, and correction strategies for each error type, emphasizing the importance of proper punctuation and modifier placement for clarity.
π Lecture Summary
RUN-ON SENTENCES
A run-on sentence is a sentence made up of two complete thoughts that have no clear break between them. There are two kinds of run-on sentences: fused sentences and comma splice sentences.
π Definition β Run-on sentence: A sentence composed of two complete thoughts incorrectly joined without proper punctuation or connecting words.
FUSED SENTENCES
Two or more sentences that run together with no marks of punctuation between them are said to be fused. The two complete statements are simply stuck together into one sentence. A good way to prevent fused sentences is to read aloud what you have written and look for words like I, you, he, she, it, we, they, there, this, that, now, then and next, which often signal the beginning of a complete thought.
π Example:
- He left early he said he had a toothache. (fused)
- Our club raised money for the Red Crescent an organization like this is a wonderful thing. (fused)
CORRECTING FUSED SENTENCES
There are three ways to correct a fused sentence:
Method 1: Divide the fused sentence into two separate sentences. π Example: The lake is calm today. It looks like a blue mirror.
Method 2: Put a comma and an appropriate joining word (such as and, but, or so) between the two complete thoughts. π Example: Computer skills are useful in college, and they will help you in getting a job as well.
π‘ Why this matters: The comma always goes before the joining word β not after it.
Method 3: Use subordination by making one complete thought dependent on the other. Begin the subordinate thought with words like because, when, if, before, since, until, unless, while, as, though, and after. π Example: Because Youhanna has a pulled muscle, he won't do any batting in this tournament.
π‘ Why this matters: Put a comma at the end of a dependent word-group that begins a sentence.
COMMA SPLICE SENTENCES
A comma splice occurs when two complete thoughts are joined together with only a comma between them. The same three methods for correcting fused sentences apply.
Method 1: Divide into two sentences. π Example: Saad is always nervous about tests. His grades are usually the best in the class.
Method 2: Connect with a joining word after the comma. π Example: Saad is always nervous about tests, but his grades are usually the best in the class.
Method 3: Use subordination. π Example: Saad is always nervous about tests although his grades are usually the best in the class.
MODIFIERS AND MISPLACED MODIFIERS
A modifier is one or more words that describe another word or group of words.
π Example: The woman with gold-rimmed spectacles is my boss. (modifier: with gold-rimmed spectacles modifies woman)
A misplaced modifier is a modifier that is incorrectly separated from the word or words it describes. When modifiers are misplaced, the reader may misunderstand the sentence.
π Example: My brother bought a used car from a local dealer with a leaking pipe.
- Corrected: My brother bought a used car (with a leaking pipe) from a local dealer.
Pay special attention to single-word modifiers such as only, almost, and nearly. For their meaning to be correctly understood, they should be placed directly in front of the word they describe.
π Example: I only asked my boss for one day's leave. (ambiguous)
- Corrected: I asked my boss for only one day's leave. (clear meaning)
DANGLING MODIFIERS
A dangling modifier is a modifier that does not clearly relate to the word it is intended to modify, often because the subject of the modifier is missing from the sentence.
π Example: Staring dreamily into space, the instructor's loud voice startled me. (Who was staring? The instructor's voice cannot stare.)
- Corrected: Staring dreamily into space, I was startled by the instructor's loud voice. OR As I was staring dreamily into space, the instructor's loud voice startled me.
π Example: When pulling out of the driveway, the pillar blocks my view.
- Corrected: When pulling out of the driveway, I find my view blocked by the pillar. OR Whenever I pull out of the driveway, the pillar blocks my view.
β Key Takeaways
- Run-on sentences (fused and comma splice) must be corrected using one of three methods: splitting into separate sentences, adding a comma with a joining word, or using subordination with words like because, when, or since.
- Misplaced modifiers cause confusion by describing the wrong word β always place modifiers as close as possible to the word they modify, especially single-word modifiers like only, almost, and nearly.
- Dangling modifiers occur when the subject of the modifier is missing β correct by either adding the missing subject or rewriting the sentence to include a clear subject.
- Reading your writing aloud helps catch sentence errors that may be missed when reading silently.
- All good writers avoid fragments, run-ons, comma splices, and dangling modifiers β mastering these corrections is essential for clear, professional writing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two types of run-on sentences, and how do they differ?
- List the three methods for correcting a fused sentence, and provide an example of each.
- What is a misplaced modifier, and why is it problematic? Give an example.
- How do you correct a dangling modifier? Provide two different correction strategies for the same sentence.
- Why is the placement of single-word modifiers like only and almost important? Show the difference in meaning when only is misplaced versus correctly placed.
π Lecture 26 β Subject Verb Agreement
π Overview: This lecture covers the rules of subject-verb agreement in English, focusing on situations that commonly cause errors. It explains how to ensure that subjects and verbs match in number (singular or plural) in various sentence structures, including those with prepositional phrases, inverted word order, indefinite pronouns, and compound subjects.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a revision of present tense verb forms, then examines four problematic situations for subject-verb agreement: when a prepositional phrase separates the subject and verb, when the verb comes before the subject, when the subject is an indefinite pronoun, and when the subject is compound (joined by and, or, nor, etc.). It also covers special cases with pronouns like both, few, all, and some.
π Lecture Summary
Revision of Present Tense
Present tense verbs have two forms: singular and plural. For singular subjects (except I and you), an -s is added to the verb. For I, you, and all plural subjects, no -s is added.
π Definition β Subject-verb agreement: In a correctly written sentence, the subject and verb match in number; a singular subject takes a singular verb, and a plural subject takes a plural verb.
π Pattern: Singular subjects (he/she/it) β verb + s; Plural subjects (they/we/you) and I β verb (no s)
π Example: "My mother works at two jobs" (singular subject, verb with s). "My friends played cards" (past tenseβno change for number).
π Definition β Prepositional phrase: A group of words that begins with a preposition (such as in, on, for, from, of, to) and ends with a noun or pronoun.
π Example: "Most shops on Mall Road are having sales this week." The subject is shops (not Mall Road), so the verb is plural are having.
π Rule: The subject of a sentence is never part of a prepositional phrase.
π Example: "One of my best friends now lives in Dubai." Subject is One (singular), verb is lives (singular). Of my best friends is a prepositional phrase.
Verb Coming Before the Subject
In some sentences, the verb comes before the subject, such as in questions or sentences beginning with There is/are or Here is/are. Even then, the verb must agree with the subject.
π Rule: To find the subject when the verb comes first, find the verb and ask "who?" or "what?"
π Example: "What was the result of the cricket match?" Verb = was; ask "what was?" β answer result (singular subject).
π Example: "There are many unemployed teachers in the district." Verb = are; ask "what are there?" β teachers (plural subject).
π Example: "Here is the computer disk of the lesson." Verb = is; subject = disk (singular).
Indefinite Pronoun Subject
Indefinite pronouns are pronouns that do not refer to a specific person or thing. The pronouns each, anyone, anybody, anything, either, everyone, everybody, everything, neither, someone, somebody, something, one, no one, nobody, nothing are always singular and take singular verbs.
π Example: "One of those correspondence courses is still open." Subject = One (singular), verb = is.
π Example: "Neither of my parents is alive." Subject = Neither (singular), verb = is.
π Example: "Somebody was opening my letters." Subject = Somebody (singular), verb = was.
π Example: "Nearly everyone in my class owns a computer." Subject = Everyone (singular), verb = owns.
Compound Subjects
Compound subjects are two or more subjects joined by conjunctions.
π Rule 1: Subjects joined by and usually require a plural verb.
π Example: "Petrol and car repairs are my biggest expenses every month."
π Rule 2: Subjects joined by or, nor, either...or, neither...nor, not only...but also β the verb agrees with the closer subject.
π Example: "Either grapes or mango ice cream is the specialty..." (closer subject ice cream is singular β verb is).
π Example: "Either mango ice cream or grapes are the specialty..." (closer subject grapes is plural β verb are).
π Rule 3: The pronouns both and a few are always plural and require plural verbs.
π Example: "Both of my aunts play the sitar." "A few of my cousins are also actors."
π Rule 4: The pronouns all and some can be singular or plural depending on the words that follow them.
π Example: "Some of the chicken is still on the table." (chicken is singular β some is singular β is)
π Example: "Some of the guests are not having chicken." (guests is plural β some is plural β are)
π‘ Why this matters: These rules prevent common errors in writing, especially with complex sentence structures.
β Key Takeaways
Subject-verb agreement is a fundamental grammatical rule that requires the subject and verb to match in number. The key problematic situations to remember are: (1) when a prepositional phrase separates the subject from the verb, always find the true subject by ignoring the prepositional phrase; (2) when the verb comes before the subject, locate the subject by asking "who" or "what" after the verb; (3) indefinite pronouns like each, everyone, nobody, and neither are always singular; and (4) with compound subjects, the verb must agree with the closer subject when joined by or/nor, but requires a plural verb when joined by and.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the subject of the sentence "One of my classmates is missing" β and why?
- In the sentence "There are several options available," what is the subject, and why is the verb plural?
- Which of the following indefinite pronouns are always singular: both, everyone, neither, few, someone?
- Should the verb in "Either the teacher or the students (is/are) responsible" be singular or plural? Explain why.
- When does the pronoun some take a singular verb, and when does it take a plural verb?
π Lecture 27 β Writing
π Overview: This lecture focuses on three critical pronoun errors that frequently appear in writing: pronoun agreement, pronoun reference, and pronoun point of view. Mastering these concepts is essential for clear, effective communication and avoiding common grammatical mistakes that confuse readers.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers three main areas of pronoun usage: Pronoun Agreement, which deals with singular and plural pronouns matching their antecedents; Pronoun Reference, which ensures pronouns clearly refer to specific nouns; and Pronoun Point of View, which maintains consistent person (first, second, or third) throughout writing. The lesson includes multiple practice exercises and test passages for each concept.
π Lecture Summary
Pronouns (Agreement, Reference Point of View)
Effective writing requires correct pronoun usage. Three common mistakes include: using a plural pronoun with a singular antecedent, creating ambiguous pronoun reference, and shifting point of view unnecessarily. For example, "Each of my students required four to five chances to pass their driving test" is incorrect because Each is singular, requiring the singular pronoun his. Similarly, "If there are stains on any hotel sheets, they should be removed at once" is ambiguousβdoes they refer to stains or sheets? Finally, "People go to the neighborhood restaurant because you get low-priced meals" incorrectly shifts from third person (People) to second person (you).
I. Pronoun Agreement
Agreement shows the relationship between nouns and pronouns and their verbs, and between nouns and their corresponding pronouns. A singular noun/pronoun uses a singular verb, a plural noun/pronoun takes a plural verb, a singular pronoun refers to a singular noun, and a plural pronoun refers to a plural noun. A pronoun must agree in number with the word it refers to (the antecedent). For example: "The students have spent many hours studying for their examinations" (their refers to students); "The book Yousaf lent me is missing its cover" (its refers to book); "If your friends don't get here soon, they'll miss the train" (they refers to friends).
The following is a list of indefinite pronouns which are always singular: Each, Either, Neither, One, Anyone, Everyone, Someone, No one, Anything, Everything, Something, Nothing, Anybody, Everybody, Somebody, Nobody. For example: "Each of the wild horses raced for its freedom"; "Neither of my sons ever feels like cleaning his room"; "No one in the class wanted to read his / her paper aloud" (or "No students in the class wanted to read their papers aloud" for plural).
π Definition β Antecedent: The word that a pronoun refers to (e.g., in "The students...their," students is the antecedent of their).
π Example: Practice 1(A) β "Neither of the babies has had (his, their) polio shot yet." The pronoun needed is his because Neither is singular. The word it refers to is Neither.
π Example: Practice 1(B) β "Each of the actresses who auditioned believes (she, they) should be chosen for the main role." The correct pronoun is she because Each is singular.
II. Pronoun Reference
Just as a pronoun must agree in number with its antecedent, it is also necessary for effective communication for a pronoun to refer clearly to the word it stands for. If the meaning of a pronoun is uncertain, the sentence will be confusing. This agreement between a noun and its pronoun is related to number, person, and gender, and is called reference. For example: "Rabia told Nafeesa that she had got an A in her term paper" β who got the A? The words she and her could refer to either Rabia or Nafeesa. "There was no question after the lecture, which was regrettable" β what was regrettable, the lecture or the lack of questions? Be careful with pronouns which and this; they must clearly refer to one thing or situation. "Both of Basit's parents are doctors, but it doesn't interest Basit" β it doesn't refer to anything in the sentence.
π‘ Why this matters: Unclear pronoun reference creates confusion for readers, forcing them to guess the intended meaning.
π Example: Correcting ambiguous reference β "Rabia told Nafeesa, 'You got an A on your term paper'" OR "Rabia told Nafeesa, 'I got an A in my term paper'" clarifies who received the grade. "Personnel and management have reached tentative agreement on personnel's contract" replaces its with a specific noun.
π Example: Practice 2 β "Mahnoor tore off the wrapping paper from the present and then threw (it, the paper) in the rubbish bin." The correct word is the paper because it could refer to either the present or the paper.
III. Pronoun Point of View
Pronouns that refer to the person who is speaking are called first person (I, me, my, mine, we, us, our). A pronoun that refers to someone being spoken to, such as you, is a second person pronoun. A pronoun that refers to another person or thing, such as he, she, it, is a third person pronoun.
When you write, your pronoun point of view must stay the same. Do not shift unnecessarily from one point of view to another. For example: "The worst thing about my not writing letters is that you never get any back" β the writer begins with the first person pronoun my but shifts to the second person pronoun you. "Though we like most of our neighbors, there are a few you can't get along with" β the writer shifts from first person (we, our) to second person (you).
These sentences can be improved by eliminating the shifts: "The worst thing about my not writing letters is that I never get any back" and "Though we like most of our neighbors, there are a few we can't get along with."
π Definition β First person: Pronouns referring to the speaker (I, me, my, we, us, our). Second person: Pronouns referring to the person being spoken to (you, your). Third person: Pronouns referring to another person or thing (he, him, his, she, her, it, they, them, their).
π Example: Practice 3 β "Whenever students are under a great deal of stress, we often go into depression" should be corrected to "Whenever students are under a great deal of stress, they often go into depression" to maintain consistent third person.
Test A, B, and C
Test A β "I won't go to Abrar ul Haq's concert tonight because there's no way you could get a ticket" should be corrected to "I won't go to Abrar ul Haq's concert tonight because there's no way I could get a ticket" to maintain first person.
Test B β "Each of the sisters is a successful artist in their own field" should be corrected to "Each of the sisters is a successful artist in her own field" because Each is singular. "Kamilia makes jewelry which one sells by herself from her home" should be "which she sells by herself from her home."
Test C β "When Aunty Mussarrat and Uncle Riaz arrived, we all jumped up... shouting their greetings" should be "shouting our greetings" because we is first person and their is an unnecessary shift to third person.
Lesson Review and Recap
Key points: Words such as each, everyone, and something are singular pronouns. Words such as I, you, and they are personal pronouns. A second person pronoun is one that refers to the person being spoken to. A pronoun cannot be singular if its antecedent is plural (False). A writer should not needlessly change from the first person to the second person (True).
β Key Takeaways
The three most critical pronoun errors to avoid in writing are agreement, reference, and point of view shifts. For agreement, remember that indefinite pronouns like each, either, neither, everyone, anybody, and nobody are always singular and require singular pronouns (his, her, its). For reference, ensure every pronoun clearly refers to a specific antecedent β if a sentence could be interpreted in multiple ways, replace the pronoun with a noun. For point of view, never shift unnecessarily between first, second, and third person within the same sentence or passage. Consistent practice with identifying and correcting these errors will significantly improve writing clarity and effectiveness.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three most common pronoun mistakes discussed in this lecture?
- Is the word "everyone" singular or plural? Give an example of correct pronoun agreement with it.
- What is wrong with the sentence "When I was stopped for speeding, he said I'd been going beyond the speed limit"?
- Why is the sentence "The restaurant down the road isn't making a profit... During an inspection last month, they found rats" problematic?
- What pronoun should replace "you" in the sentence "The worst thing about my not writing letters is that you never get any back"?