📝 Lecture Summary
Three Types of Investment Spending
Investment is the most volatile component of GDP, and much of the decline during recessions comes from drops in investment spending. The lecture explains that standard macroeconomic models like IS-LM use a simple investment function I = I(r) stating that investment decreases when the real interest rate increases. This lecture examines the deeper theory behind this relationship by building models of each type of investment to explain fluctuations in the economy.
The three key questions addressed are: why investment is negatively related to the interest rate, what causes the investment function to shift, and why investment rises during booms and falls during recessions.
Business Fixed Investment
Business fixed investment is the largest component of investment spending, accounting for about three-quarters of total investment. The term "business" means these investment goods are bought by firms for future production, and "fixed" means the capital will stay in place for a while, as opposed to inventory investment. This includes everything from fax machines to factories and computers to company cars.
The standard model is called the neoclassical model of investment, which examines the benefits and costs of owning capital goods. Three variables shift investment: the marginal product of capital, the interest rate, and tax rules.
The model imagines two kinds of firms: production firms that produce goods and services using rented capital, and rental firms that make all the investments in the economy. In reality, most firms perform both functions.
The Rental Price of Capital
A typical production firm decides how much capital to rent by comparing the cost and benefit of each unit of capital. The firm rents capital at a rental rate R and sells output at price P. The real cost of a unit of capital is R/P, and the real benefit is the marginal product of capital (MPK) —the extra output produced with one more unit of capital. MPK falls as the amount of capital rises.
To maximize profit, the firm rents capital until MPK falls to: MPK = R/P
Thus, MPK determines the downward-sloping demand curve for capital. At any point in time, the amount of capital in the economy is fixed, so the supply curve is fixed. The real rental price of capital adjusts to equilibrate demand and fixed supply.
🔑 Definition — Real Rental Price of Capital (R/P): The cost of renting one unit of capital, adjusted for the price level, determined by the equilibrium between the demand for capital (MPK) and the fixed supply of capital.
The Cobb-Douglas production function serves as a good approximation of how the actual economy turns capital and labor into goods and services:
📐 Formula: Y = AK^α L^(1-α)
Where Y = output, K = capital, L = labor, A = technology parameter, α = capital's share of output (between 0 and 1)
📐 Formula — MPK for Cobb-Douglas: MPK = αA (L/K)^(1-α)
Since the real rental price (R/P) equals MPK in equilibrium: R/P = αA (L/K)^(1-α)
This expression shows three key relationships:
- The lower the stock of capital, the higher the real rental price of capital
- The greater the amount of labor employed, the higher the real rental price of capital
- The better the technology, the higher the real rental price of capital
Events that reduce the capital stock, raise employment, or improve technology raise the equilibrium real rental price of capital.
The Cost of Capital
Rental firms buy capital goods and rent them out. The benefit of owning capital is the real rental price (R/P) for each unit owned and rented out. For each period, the rental firm bears three costs:
- Interest cost: Purchase price of capital (PK) times the interest rate (i) = iPK
- Cost of capital loss or gain: The change in the price of capital = -ΔPK (negative sign means a capital gain reduces cost)
- Depreciation cost: The fraction of value lost per period (δ) times PK = δPK
📐 Formula — Total Cost of Capital: Total cost = iPK - ΔPK + δPK
Or: = PK(i - ΔPK/PK + δ)
The cost of capital depends on the price of capital, the interest rate, the rate of change of capital prices, and the depreciation rate.
📌 Example: A car rental company buys cars for Rs. 1,000,000 each and rents them out.
- Interest rate (i) = 10% per year, so interest cost = iPK = Rs. 100,000 per year
- Car prices rising at 6% per year, so capital gain = ΔPK = Rs. 60,000 per year
- Cars depreciate at 20% per year, so depreciation = δPK = Rs. 200,000 per year
Total cost of capital = iPK - ΔPK + δPK = 100,000 - 60,000 + 200,000 = Rs. 240,000 per year
💡 Why this matters: The cost of capital framework shows that investment decisions depend not just on interest rates but also on capital gains, depreciation, and tax considerations. This explains why investment can fluctuate dramatically even when interest rates are stable.
⭐ Key Takeaways
Investment is the most volatile component of GDP, with business fixed investment making up about three-quarters of total investment. The neoclassical model explains investment decisions through the interaction of the rental price of capital (determined by MPK) and the cost of capital (determined by interest rates, depreciation, and capital gains/losses). The Cobb-Douglas production function shows that MPK depends on the capital stock, labor employed, and technology level. The cost of capital includes three components: interest cost, capital gains or losses, and depreciation. Understanding the difference between the rental price (benefit of owning capital) and the cost of capital is crucial for predicting how changes in interest rates, technology, or tax policy will affect investment spending.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three types of investment spending and which is the largest?
- According to the neoclassical model, what condition determines how much capital a production firm will rent?
- What are the three variables that shift business fixed investment according to the neoclassical model?
- What are the three components of the cost of capital faced by a rental firm?
- Using the Cobb-Douglas production function, explain how a decrease in the capital stock affects the real rental price of capital.
📘 Lecture 41 — Investment Theories (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture continues the study of investment theories, focusing on the neoclassical model of investment. It explains how firms determine the cost of capital, make investment decisions based on profitability, and how taxes influence these decisions. Understanding this model is crucial for analyzing how interest rates and fiscal policy affect aggregate demand and long-run economic growth.
🗂️ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the concept of the cost of capital and its formula, the determinants of net investment based on comparing the marginal product of capital to the cost of capital, and the derivation of the neoclassical investment function. It also explains the long-run steady state condition where the marginal product of capital equals the cost of capital, and discusses the effects of corporate taxes, including the corporate income tax and the investment tax credit, with a real-world example from Sweden.
📝 Lecture Summary
THE COST OF CAPITAL
The lecture begins by defining the total cost of capital, which is the cost a firm incurs from owning and using a unit of capital. This cost includes the opportunity cost of the funds tied up in the capital, any change in the price of the capital good, and the cost of depreciation. The formula for the total cost of capital is: Total cost of capital = iPk - ΔPk + δPk, which simplifies to Pk (i - ΔPk/Pk + δ). This shows the cost depends on the price of capital (Pk), the nominal interest rate (i), the rate of change of capital prices, and the depreciation rate (δ).
Assuming capital goods prices rise with the general price level, the rate of change of capital prices (ΔPk/Pk) equals the overall inflation rate (π). Since the real interest rate (r) is defined as i - π, the cost of capital simplifies to: Cost of Capital = Pk (r + δ). To express this relative to other goods in the economy, the real cost of capital is defined as the cost measured in terms of the economy’s output. The formula for this is: 🔑 Definition — Real Cost of Capital: (PK / P) (r + δ), where P is the overall price level. This represents the cost of buying and renting out a unit of capital in terms of the economy's output.
THE DETERMINANTS OF INVESTMENT
This section explains how a rental firm decides whether to increase or decrease its capital stock. For each unit of capital, the firm earns a real revenue of R/P and bears a real cost of (PK / P) (r + δ). The real profit per unit of capital is therefore: 📐 Formula: Profit rate = Revenue - Cost = R/P - (PK / P) (r + δ). Because the real rental price (R/P) equals the marginal product of capital (MPK) in equilibrium, this can be rewritten as: 📐 Formula: Profit rate = MPK - (PK / P) (r + δ).
The change in the capital stock, called net investment (ΔK), depends on this profit incentive:
- If the MPK exceeds the cost of capital, firms will add to their capital stock (positive net investment).
- If the MPK falls short of the cost of capital, firms will let their capital stock shrink (negative net investment). Thus, net investment is a function of the gap between MPK and the cost of capital: 📐 Formula: ΔK = In [MPK - (PK / P) (r + δ)], where In() is the function showing how much net investment responds to the incentive to invest. 📌 Example: If a firm’s MPK is 15% and its real cost of capital is 10%, then the profit rate is +5%. This incentive would lead the firm to increase its capital stock. Conversely, if the MPK is 5% and the cost of capital is 10%, the profit rate is -5%, leading the firm to shrink its capital stock.
THE INVESTMENT FUNCTION
The neoclassical model of investment derives the total investment function (I). Total spending on business fixed investment is the sum of net investment and the replacement of depreciated capital (δK). The investment function is: 📐 Formula: I = In [MPK - (PK / P) (r + δ)] + δK
This model shows why investment depends negatively on the real interest rate (r).
- A decrease in the real interest rate lowers the cost of capital, raising the profit from owning capital and increasing the incentive to invest.
- An increase in the real interest rate raises the cost of capital, leading firms to reduce their investment. This relationship creates the downward-sloping investment function, where I falls as r rises. An outward shift in the investment function can be caused by an increase in the MPK, for instance, due to a technological innovation. 💡 Why this matters: This model links monetary policy (which affects real interest rates) directly to investment spending, a key component of aggregate demand.
The lecture then describes the adjustment of the capital stock over time towards a steady state. If the MPK is above the cost of capital, the capital stock rises, causing the MPK to fall. If the MPK is below the cost of capital, the capital stock falls, causing the MPK to rise. This process continues until the MPK equals the cost of capital, at which point the capital stock reaches a steady state: 📐 Formula: MPK = (PK / P) (r + δ)
TAXES AND INVESTMENT
Tax laws influence firms' incentives to accumulate capital. Two important provisions of corporate taxes are discussed:
- Corporate Income Tax: This is a tax on corporate profits. Its effect on investment depends on how profit is defined for tax purposes. If the tax law defined profit as
R/P - (PK / P)(r + δ), the tax would not distort investment decisions. However, tax laws often differ, for example, by using depreciation at historical cost instead of current economic value, which can affect the cost of capital and distort investment incentives. - Investment Tax Credit: This is a tax provision that encourages capital accumulation. It reduces a firm’s taxes by a certain amount for each monetary unit spent on capital goods. This effectively reduces the purchase price of capital (Pk), thereby lowering the cost of capital and raising investment. 🔑 Definition — Investment Tax Credit: A tax provision that reduces a firm's taxes proportionate to its spending on new capital goods, effectively lowering the purchase price of capital and stimulating investment.
SWEDISH INVESTMENT FUNDS SYSTEM
This section provides a historical example of how tax incentives were used to control aggregate demand. From the mid-1950s to the mid-1970s, the government of Sweden implemented a system called the Investment Fund system.
- During an economic slowdown, authorities offered a temporary investment subsidy to encourage investment and boost aggregate demand.
- During an economic recovery, the subsidy was revoked.
- Eventually, the subsidy became a permanent feature of Swedish tax policy.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The neoclassical model of investment explains that a firm's investment decision hinges on the profitability of capital, which is the difference between the marginal product of capital (MPK) and the real cost of capital (Pk/P times r+δ). The cost of capital is a function of the price of capital, the real interest rate, and the depreciation rate. The investment function is downward-sloping with respect to the real interest rate because a lower interest rate reduces the cost of capital, making investment more profitable. In the long run, the capital stock adjusts until the MPK equals the real cost of capital. Government policies like the investment tax credit and the corporate income tax can influence investment by altering the cost of capital.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three components of the total cost of capital in the formula
iPk - ΔPk + δPk? - What is the formula for the real cost of capital?
- Under what condition will a firm decide to increase its capital stock (positive net investment)?
- In the neoclassical investment function, why does a decrease in the real interest rate (r) lead to an increase in investment?
- What is the steady-state condition for the capital stock in the long run?
📘 Lecture 42 — Investment Theories (Continued)
The Stock Market and Tobin’s q
📖 Overview: This lecture explores advanced investment theories, focusing on Tobin’s q as a key ratio linking stock market valuations to firms’ investment decisions. It also examines how stock markets serve as economic indicators, the role of financing constraints in limiting investment, and a simple model of residential investment. Understanding these concepts is crucial for analyzing real-world investment behavior and macroeconomic fluctuations.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers Tobin’s q theory and its relationship to the neo-classical model, the stock market as an economic indicator with explanations using the AD-AS model and additional reasons for stock price movements, financing constraints that limit firms’ ability to raise funds for investment, and a two-part model of residential investment focusing on housing stock market and flow of new housing construction.
📝 Lecture Summary
THE STOCK MARKET AND TOBIN’S q
The term stock refers to the shares in the ownership of corporations. Stock market is the market in which these shares are traded. The Nobel-Prize-winning economist James Tobin proposed that firms base their investment decisions on the following ratio, now called Tobin’s q:
🔑 Definition — Tobin’s q: ( q = \frac{\text{Market Value of Installed Capital}}{\text{Replacement Cost of Installed Capital}} )
The numerator is the value of the economy’s capital as determined by the stock market. The denominator is the price of capital as if it were purchased today.
Tobin conveyed that net investment should depend on whether q is greater or less than 1:
- If q > 1, then firms can raise the value of their stock by increasing capital.
- If q < 1, the stock market values capital at less than its replacement cost and thus, firms will not replace their capital stock as it wears out.
Tobin’s q and the neo-classical model are closely related, since Tobin’s q measures the expected future profitability as well as the current profitability. If the MPK exceeds the cost of capital, firms are earning profits on their installed capital, making rental firms desirable to own, raising market value of stocks of such firms, implying a high value of q.
💡 Why this matters: Tobin’s q provides a simple, market-based measure to guide firms’ investment decisions—when stock markets value capital highly, it signals profitable investment opportunities.
📌 Example: If a company’s installed capital has a replacement cost of $10 million and its shares are valued at $12 million in the stock market, Tobin’s q = 12/10 = 1.2 > 1, indicating the firm should invest in new capital. Conversely, if the market value falls to $8 million, q = 0.8 < 1, suggesting the firm should not replace capital as it wears out.
THE STOCK MARKET AS AN ECONOMIC INDICATOR
Although the volatility of the stock market can give false signals about the future of the economy, one should not ignore the link between the two. Changes in the stock market often reflect changes in GDP. Whenever the stock market experiences a substantial decline, we should be ready for an upcoming recession.
Why do stock prices and economic activity tend to fluctuate together?
Tobin’s q and AD-AS Model: Suppose there occurs a fall in stock prices. Since replacement cost of capital is stable, this will result in a fall in Tobin’s q, reflecting investors’ pessimism about the current or future profitability of capital.
Some Additional Reasons:
- A fall in stock prices makes people poorer, depressing their spending, resulting in reduced aggregate demand.
- A fall in stock prices reflects bad news about technological progress and economic growth, resulting in slow expansion of the natural rate of output.
💡 Why this matters: Stock market movements are not just noise—they contain real information about future economic activity, making them useful early warning indicators for recessions.
FINANCING CONSTRAINTS
When a firm wants to invest in new capital, e.g., by building a new factory, it raises the funds in financial markets by:
- Obtaining loans from banks
- Selling bonds to the public
- Selling shares in future profits on the stock market
The neo-classical model assumes that if a firm is willing to pay the cost of capital, financial markets will make the funds available. But sometimes firms face financing constraints, limiting the amount of funds they can raise from financial markets. So the amount a firm can spend on new capital goods is limited to the amount it is currently earning.
🔑 Definition — Financing constraints: Limitations on the amount of funds a firm can raise from financial markets, forcing it to rely on current earnings for capital spending.
For example, a recession reduces employment, rental price of capital, and profits. If the firm expects the recession to be short-lived, it will continue investing for long-term profitability, thus having a small effect on Tobin’s q. So the firm that can raise funds in financial markets will face a small effect of recession on investment. While in the case of firms facing constraints, the fall in current profits restricts the spending on new capital goods and may prevent such firms from making profitable investment.
💡 Why this matters: Financing constraints explain why some firms—especially smaller ones—cannot take advantage of profitable investment opportunities during economic downturns, potentially deepening recessions.
RESIDENTIAL INVESTMENT
We will now consider the determinants of residential investment by looking at a simple model of the housing market. Residential investment includes the purchase of new housing both by people who plan to live in it themselves and by landlords who plan to rent it to others. To keep things simple, we shall assume that all housing is owner-occupied.
There are two parts to the model:
- The market for the existing stock of houses determines the equilibrium housing price
- The housing price determines the flow of residential investment
The relative price of housing (P_H/P) adjusts to equilibrate supply and demand for the existing stock of housing capital. Construction firms buy materials and hire labor to build the houses and then sell them at market price. Their costs depend on the overall price level P while their revenue depends on the price of houses P_H. The higher the P_H, the greater the incentive to build houses.
Graphical Model:
- Market for Housing: A demand curve (D) and a vertical supply curve (S) for stock of housing capital (K_H) determine the relative price of housing (P_H/P)
- Supply of New Housing: The relative price (P_H/P) determines the flow of residential investment (I_H) through an upward-sloping supply curve
This model of residential investment is much similar to the q theory of business fixed investment, which states that business fixed investment depends on the market price of installed capital relative to its replacement cost, which in turn depends on expected profits from owning installed capital. The residential investment depends on the relative price of housing, which in turn depends on demand for housing, depending on the imputed rent that individuals expect to receive from their housing.
🔑 Definition — Imputed rent: The implicit rental income that homeowners expect to receive from living in their own houses, which influences housing demand and thus the relative price of housing.
📌 Example: If the demand for housing increases (e.g., due to lower interest rates or population growth), the demand curve shifts right in the housing market, raising the equilibrium relative price P_H/P. This higher relative price then shifts along the supply curve for new housing, increasing the flow of residential investment I_H—more new houses are built.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The most critical concept from this lecture is Tobin’s q, which provides a direct link between stock market valuations and real investment decisions—firms invest when q > 1 and disinvest when q < 1. Stock market movements serve as leading indicators of economic activity because they affect spending through wealth effects and signal changes in future profitability and technological progress. Financing constraints are a crucial real-world modification to the neo-classical model, showing that firms limited in their ability to raise external funds may be forced to cut investment during recessions even when profitable opportunities exist. The residential investment model parallels Tobin’s q theory, with the relative price of housing (P_H/P) playing the same role as q—determining the flow of new construction based on the market valuation of existing housing stock. Finally, understanding that both business fixed investment and residential investment depend on market valuations relative to replacement costs provides a unified framework for analyzing all forms of investment.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- If Tobin’s q equals 0.8 for a firm, should it increase or decrease its capital stock? Explain why.
- How does a fall in stock prices affect aggregate demand according to the lecture?
- What is the key difference between the neo-classical assumption about financing and the reality of financing constraints?
- In the residential investment model, what determines the equilibrium relative price of housing (P_H/P)?
- How is Tobin’s q theory similar to the model of residential investment?
📘 Lecture 43 — Investment Theories (Continued)
Inventory Investment
📖 Overview: This lecture shifts focus from fixed business investment to inventory investment — the goods businesses store. Though small in magnitude, inventory investment is highly volatile and a key driver of economic fluctuations. It explains how firms decide to hold stock, why seasonal patterns contradict production smoothing theory, and how output changes and interest rates affect inventory behavior.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture defines inventory investment and explains why it matters despite its small size. It examines four core motivations for holding inventory: production smoothing, inventories as a factor of production, stock-out avoidance, and work in process. It then challenges the production smoothing hypothesis using evidence from seasonal industries. Two models of inventory investment are presented: the Accelerator Model, linking inventory stock proportionally to output, and the role of the real interest rate as the opportunity cost of holding inventories.
📝 Lecture Summary
What Is Inventory Investment?
Inventory investment refers to the goods businesses put aside in storage. It is one of the smallest components of spending but its volatility makes it critical for studying economic booms and recessions. Firms may hold inventories for four reasons:
- Production smoothing — When sales are high, the firm sells more than it currently produces by drawing down inventory (and vice versa).
- Inventories as a factor of production — Holding inventory may allow firms to operate more efficiently.
- Stock-out avoidance — Firms don’t want to run out of goods when sales are unexpectedly high.
- Work in process — Partially completed products are still counted in inventory.
💡 Why this matters: In a recession, firms stop replenishing inventory as goods are sold, making inventory investment negative. This amplifies downturns.
Seasonal Fluctuation and Production Smoothing
Contrary to expectations, firms do not use inventories to smooth production over time. The clearest evidence comes from industries with seasonal fluctuations in demand (e.g., fan manufacturing). One would expect firms to build up inventories in low-sales seasons and draw them down in high-sales seasons. Yet in most industries, the seasonal pattern of production matches the seasonal pattern of sales, not the inverse.
🔑 Key Insight: The textbook theory of production smoothing is not supported by real-world seasonal data.
The Accelerator Model of Inventories
The accelerator model assumes firms hold a stock of inventories proportional to their level of output. When output rises, manufacturing firms need more materials and supplies, and retailers need more merchandise on shelves.
Let:
- N = economy’s stock of inventories
- Y = output
- β = parameter reflecting desired inventory-to-output ratio
Then:
📐 Formula:
- Stock of inventories:
N = βY - Inventory investment (I) is the change in stock:
I = ΔN = βΔY
📌 Example: If β = 0.2 and output increases by $100 billion, then inventory investment = 0.2 × $100 billion = $20 billion.
Prediction:
- When output rises, firms want larger inventory stock → positive inventory investment.
- When output falls, firms let inventory run down → negative inventory investment.
💡 Why this matters: Inventory investment depends on whether the economy is speeding up or slowing down — it amplifies the business cycle.
Inventories and the Real Interest Rate
Like other forms of investment, inventory investment depends on the real interest rate. When a firm holds a good in inventory and sells it tomorrow rather than today, it gives up the interest it could have earned on the proceeds in the meantime.
🔑 Definition — Opportunity Cost of Holding Inventory: The real interest rate measures the opportunity cost of holding inventories.
📌 Example: Holding $1 million of inventory for one year when the real interest rate is 5% costs the firm $50,000 in forgone interest.
Prediction:
- When the real interest rate rises, holding inventories becomes more costly → firms reduce inventory stock → inventory investment falls.
⭐ Key Takeaways
- Inventory investment is small in magnitude but highly volatile, making it critical for understanding business cycles.
- Firms hold inventories for four reasons: production smoothing, factor of production, stock-out avoidance, and work in process.
- Real-world seasonal industries contradict the production smoothing hypothesis — production patterns match sales patterns, not the inverse.
- The accelerator model states inventory investment is proportional to the change in output:
I = βΔY. - The real interest rate represents the opportunity cost of holding inventory; higher rates depress inventory investment.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- Why is inventory investment considered "negligible but significant" in macroeconomics?
- What are the four reasons firms hold inventories? Briefly explain each.
- How does the evidence from seasonal industries (e.g., fan manufacturing) challenge the production smoothing theory?
- In the accelerator model, what is the relationship between inventory investment (
I) and the change in output (ΔY)? Write the formula. - How does an increase in the real interest rate affect inventory investment? Explain the economic reasoning.
📘 Lecture 44 — Money & Banking
📖 Overview: This lecture moves beyond the simplified view of money supply controlled only by the central bank, introducing the critical role of the banking system and household behavior. It explains how different banking systems—100% reserve and fractional-reserve—affect the total money supply, and introduces the key concept that banks can actually create money.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by redefining money supply as currency plus demand deposits, then explores two banking models: 100% reserve banking (where all deposits are held as reserves, not affecting money supply) and fractional-reserve banking (where banks lend out a portion of deposits, thereby creating new money). The concepts of reserves, reserve-deposit ratio, and excess reserves are formally introduced.
📝 Lecture Summary
MONEY SUPPLY
Earlier, we introduced the concept of money supply in a highly simplified way, defining the quantity of money as the number of rupees held by the public, and assuming the central bank controls supply through open-market operations. This definition omits the role of the banking system. Here, we see that the money supply is determined not only by the Central Bank, but also by the behavior of households (which hold money) and banks (where money is held). The Money supply includes both currency in the hand of public and deposits at banks that households use on demand for transactions.
🔑 Definition — Money Supply (M): M = C + D, where C is Currency and D is Demand Deposits. 💡 Why this matters: This formula shows that money is not just physical cash; bank deposits are a major component of the total money available in the economy.
100% RESERVE BANKING
Imagine a world without banks, where all money is currency ($1,000). A new bank accepts deposits but does not make loans. Its only purpose is to provide a safe place for depositors. The deposits that banks have received but have not lent out are called reserves. Some reserves are held in vaults of local banks but most are held at the central bank. In a 100% reserve banking system, all deposits are held in reserve, and the banking system does not affect the supply of money.
Suppose households deposit the economy’s entire $1,000 in First bank. The bank’s balance sheet shows:
- Assets: Reserves $1,000
- Liabilities: Deposits $1,000
The bank makes no loans, so it is not earning a profit, only a small fee. The money supply before and after creation of the bank remains $1,000.
🔑 Definition — Reserves: Deposits that banks have received but have not lent out. 📐 Key Principle: 100% reserve banking → M remains constant. All deposits are held as reserves, so the banking system does not affect the money supply.
FRACTIONAL RESERVE BANKING
If banks start to use some of their deposits to make loans (e.g., to households for house finance and to firms for capital finance), they can charge interest. Banks must keep some reserve on hand so that reserves are available whenever depositors want to make withdrawals. As long as new deposits approximately equal withdrawals, a bank need not keep all its deposits in reserves.
🔑 Definition — Reserve-deposit ratio: The fraction of deposits kept in reserve. 🔑 Definition — Excess reserves: Reserves above the reserve requirement. 🔑 Definition — Fractional-reserve banking: A system under which banks keep only a fraction of their deposits in reserve. In this system, banks create money.
📌 Example: In a 100% reserve system, a $1,000 deposit stays as $1,000 in money supply. In a fractional-reserve system with a 10% reserve ratio, the bank keeps $100 as reserves and lends out $900. That $900 is then deposited in another bank, which keeps $90 and lends $810, and so on. The total money supply becomes $1,000 + $900 + $810 + ... = $10,000, showing money creation. 📐 Formula: Money multiplier ≈ 1 / reserve-deposit ratio. 💡 Why this matters: This is how the banking system expands the money supply. Each loan creates new deposits, which can be lent again, multiplying the initial deposit.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The money supply is not controlled solely by the central bank; it is also influenced by household decisions to hold cash versus deposits and by banks' decisions on how much to lend. In a 100% reserve banking system, banks merely store money and do not affect the total money supply. In contrast, a fractional-reserve banking system allows banks to create money because only a fraction of deposits needs to be held in reserve, and the rest can be lent out, which eventually becomes new deposits elsewhere. The reserve-deposit ratio is the key determinant of how much money banks can create, with a lower ratio leading to a larger money multiplier. Finally, excess reserves represent any reserves held above the required minimum.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula for the money supply, and what are its two components?
- In a 100% reserve banking system, does the creation of a bank change the money supply? Why or why not?
- Define the “reserve-deposit ratio.”
- In a fractional-reserve banking system, how do banks “create money”?
- If the reserve-deposit ratio is 20%, what is the approximate money multiplier?
📘 Lecture 45 — Money & Banking (Continued)
📖 Overview: This lecture examines how central banks control the money supply through three key policy instruments. It then transitions to theories of money demand, comparing classical, Keynesian, portfolio, and transactions approaches, and concludes with a formal model of money supply determination and the process of money creation through the banking system.
🗂️ Topics Covered
The lecture covers central bank instruments for controlling money supply (open market operations, reserve requirements, discount rate), classical and Keynesian theories of money demand, portfolio theories emphasizing money as a store of value, transactions theories including the Baumol-Tobin model of cash management, the process of money creation through fractional-reserve banking, financial intermediation, and a formal model of money supply with the money multiplier.
📝 Lecture Summary
HOW DOES THE CENTRAL BANK CONTROL THE MONEY SUPPLY?
Central banks use three main instruments to influence the money supply. Open market operations are the purchase and sale of government bonds by the central bank. When the central bank buys bonds from the public, the money it pays increases the monetary base and thus increases the money supply. When it sells bonds, the money received reduces the monetary base and reduces the money supply.
Reserve requirements are regulations that impose on banks a minimum reserve-deposit ratio. An increase in reserve requirements raises this ratio, thus lowering the money multiplier and the money supply.
The discount rate is the interest rate the central bank charges when it lends to banks. Banks borrow from the central bank when they have too few reserves to meet requirements. The lower the discount rate, the cheaper borrowed reserves become, and the more banks demand such loans. Hence, a reduction in the discount rate raises the monetary base and the money supply.
💡 Why this matters: Although these instruments give the central bank substantial power to influence the money supply, it cannot do so perfectly. Bank discretion—such as holding excessive reserves or there being no limit on bank borrowings from the discount window—can cause the money supply to change in ways the central bank did not anticipate.
MONEY DEMAND
CLASSICAL THEORY OF MONEY DEMAND
The Quantity Theory of Money assumes that the demand for real money balances is directly proportional to income:
🔑 Definition — Real money balances demand (classical): (M/P)ᵈ = kY, where k is a constant measuring how much people want to hold for every dollar of income.
KEYNESIAN THEORY OF MONEY DEMAND
This presents a more realistic money demand function where the demand for real money balances depends on both the interest rate (i) and income (Y):
🔑 Definition — Keynesian money demand: (M/P)ᵈ = L(i, Y), where L is the liquidity preference function.
Money serves three functions: unit of account, store of value, and medium of exchange. The first function cannot by itself generate any demand for money, because we can quote prices in any currency without holding any of it. Theories focus on the latter two functions.
PORTFOLIO THEORIES OF MONEY DEMAND
Portfolio theories emphasize the role of money as a store of value. According to these theories, people hold money as part of their portfolio of assets. The key point is that money offers a different combination of risk and return than other assets—particularly a safe nominal return—while other assets may fall in both real and nominal terms.
These theories predict that money demand should depend on the risk and return offered by money and other assets, and also on total wealth, which measures the size of the portfolio to be allocated.
🔑 Definition — Portfolio money demand function: (M/P)ᵈ = L(rₛ, r_b, πᵉ, W), where:
- rₛ = expected real return on stocks
- r_b = expected real return on bonds
- πᵉ = expected inflation rate
- W = real wealth
If rₛ or r_b rises, money demand decreases because other assets become more attractive. A rise in πᵉ also reduces money demand because money becomes less attractive. An increase in W raises money demand because higher wealth means a larger portfolio.
Money Demand Function L(i,Y): A useful simplification:
- Uses real income Y as a proxy for real wealth W
- Nominal interest rate i = r_b + πᵉ
💡 Why this matters: Whether portfolio theories are useful depends on which measure of money we use. M1 is a dominated asset—as a store of value, it exists alongside other assets that are always better. Portfolio theories cannot explain demand for dominated forms of money like M1, but are more plausible for broader measures like M2.
| Symbol | Assets Included |
|---|---|
| C | Currency |
| M1 | C + demand deposits, travelers' checks, other checkable deposits |
| M2 | M1 + small time deposits, savings deposits, money market mutual funds, money market deposit accounts |
| M3 | M2 + large time deposits, repurchase agreements, institutional money market mutual fund balances |
TRANSACTIONS THEORIES OF MONEY DEMAND
These theories emphasize the role of money as a medium of exchange. They acknowledge that money is a dominated asset but stress that people hold money to make purchases. These theories best explain why people hold narrow measures of money, assuming that money has the cost of earning a low rate of return but makes transactions more convenient.
BAUMOL-TOBIN MODEL OF CASH MANAGEMENT
This model, developed in the 1950s, analyzes the costs and benefits of holding money:
- Benefit: Convenience (fewer trips to the bank)
- Costs: Foregone interest on money that could have been deposited in a savings account
📌 Example: A person plans to spend Y dollars over the course of a year (assuming constant price levels and real spending). If they withdraw Y dollars at the beginning of the year and gradually spend it, the average money balance is Y/2. If they withdraw Y/2 at the beginning, spend it in six months, then withdraw the rest Y/2 for the next half-year, the average balance is Y/4.
Generalizing: money holdings vary between Y/N and zero, averaging Y/(2N), where N is the number of trips to the bank.
🔑 Definition — Fixed cost effect: Any change in the fixed cost of going to the bank (F) alters the money demand function—it changes the quantity of money demanded for a given interest rate and income.
MONEY CREATION
Assume each bank maintains a reserve-deposit ratio (rr) of 20% and the initial deposit is $1000.
First Bank Balance Sheet:
| Assets | Liabilities |
|---|---|
| Reserves $200 | Deposits $1,000 |
| Loans $800 |
Second Bank Balance Sheet:
| Assets | Liabilities |
|---|---|
| Reserves $160 | Deposits $800 |
| Loans $640 |
Third Bank Balance Sheet:
| Assets | Liabilities |
|---|---|
| Reserves $128 | Deposits $640 |
| Loans $512 |
Mathematically, the amount of money the original $1000 deposit creates:
- Original Deposit = $1000
- First bank lending = (1-rr) × $1000
- Second bank lending = (1-rr)² × $1000
- Third bank lending = (1-rr)³ × $1000
- And so on...
📐 Formula: Total Money Supply = [1 + (1-rr) + (1-rr)² + (1-rr)³ + ...] × $1000 = (1/rr) × $1000
📌 Example: With rr = 0.2: Total Money Supply = (1/0.2) × $1000 = $5000
The banking system's ability to create money is the primary difference between banks and other financial institutions.
Financial intermediation is the process of transferring funds from savers to borrowers. Financial markets transfer resources from households (who wish to save) to households and firms that wish to borrow to buy investment goods for future production.
A MODEL OF MONEY SUPPLY
Three exogenous variables:
🔑 Definitions:
- Monetary base (B): The total number of dollars held by the public as currency (C) and by banks as reserves (R)
- Reserve-deposit ratio (rr): The fraction of deposits (D) that banks hold in reserves (R)
- Currency-deposit ratio (cr): The amount of currency (C) people hold as a fraction of their holdings of demand deposits (D)
Definitions of money supply and monetary base:
- M = C + D
- B = C + R
Solving for M as a function of the three exogenous variables:
- M/B = (C/D + 1) / (C/D + R/D)
Making substitutions:
- M = [(cr + 1) / (cr + rr)] × B
The money multiplier (m) = (cr + 1) / (cr + rr)
So: M = m × B
Because the monetary base has a multiplied effect on the money supply, it is sometimes called high-powered money.
📌 Example: Suppose monetary base B is $500 billion, rr = 0.1, and cr = 0.6
- Money multiplier: m = (0.6 + 1) / (0.6 + 0.1) = 1.6 / 0.7 = 2.3
- Money supply: M = 2.3 × $500 billion = $1,150 billion
How changes in exogenous variables affect money supply:
-
The money supply M is proportional to the monetary base B. An increase in the monetary base increases the money supply by the same percentage.
-
The lower the reserve-deposit ratio (rr = R/D), the more loans banks make, and the more money banks create from every dollar of reserves.
-
The lower the currency-deposit ratio (cr = C/D), the fewer dollars of the monetary base the public holds as currency, the more base dollars banks hold in reserves, and the more money banks can create. A decrease in the currency-deposit ratio raises the money multiplier and the money supply.
⭐ Key Takeaways
The three central bank instruments—open market operations, reserve requirements, and the discount rate—affect the money supply through different channels, but bank behavior introduces uncertainty into monetary control. Money demand theories range from the simple classical quantity theory (M/P proportional to income) to the Keynesian function incorporating interest rates, portfolio theories emphasizing risk-return trade-offs across assets, and transactions theories like the Baumol-Tobin model explaining optimal cash management given the trade-off between convenience and foregone interest. The fractional-reserve banking system creates money through a multiplier process where an initial deposit generates loans that become new deposits at other banks, with the total money created equal to 1/rr times the original deposit. The formal money supply model shows that the money multiplier depends on both the reserve-deposit ratio and the currency-deposit ratio, making the monetary base "high-powered" because small changes in base money are multiplied into larger changes in the money supply.
🧠 Quick Revision Questions
-
What are the three instruments the central bank uses to control the money supply, and how does each affect the monetary base or money multiplier?
-
According to portfolio theories of money demand, what four factors determine the demand for real money balances, and in what direction does each affect money demand?
-
In the Baumol-Tobin model, if a person makes N trips to the bank over the year and spends Y dollars total, what is their average money balance?
-
If the reserve-deposit ratio is 0.25 and a bank receives a new deposit of $1,000, what is the total amount of money that can ultimately be created from this deposit?
-
Given a monetary base of $800 billion, a reserve-deposit ratio of 0.15, and a currency-deposit ratio of 0.5, calculate the money multiplier and the total money supply.