π Lecture 7 β CONSUMER BEHAVIOR (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture continues the study of consumer behavior by introducing the concept of utility as a numerical measure of satisfaction. It explains how budget constraints limit consumer choices and how consumers maximize satisfaction by selecting a market basket where the indifference curve is tangent to the budget line. This framework is critical for predicting consumer responses to changes in income and prices.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers utility and utility functions, including ordinal versus cardinal utility. It then explains budget constraints, the budget line equation, and the effects of changes in income and prices on the budget line. The principle of consumer choice is presented, followed by applications such as designing new automobiles, decision making and public policy (matching vs. non-matching grants), corner solutions, and a college trust fund example.
π Lecture Summary
UTILITY
Utility is the numerical score representing the satisfaction that a consumer gets from a given market basket. If buying 3 copies of Microeconomics makes you happier than buying one shirt, then we say that the books give you more utility than the shirt.
UTILITY FUNCTIONS
Assume: The utility function for food (F) and clothing (C) is U(F,C) = F + 2C.
Market Baskets: F units C units U(F, C) = F + 2C A 8 3 8 + 2(3) = 14 B 6 4 6 + 2(4) = 14 C 4 4 4 + 2(4) = 12
The consumer is indifferent to A & B. The consumer prefers A & B to C.
Assume: U = FC Market Basket U = FC C 25 = 2.5(10) A 25 = 5(5) B 25 = 10(2.5)
Utility functions generate indifference curves, which are curves showing all combinations of goods that provide the consumer with the same level of satisfaction (utility). Higher indifference curves (Uβ, Uβ) represent higher levels of utility than lower curves (Uβ).
ORDINAL VERSUS CARDINAL UTILITY
An Ordinal Utility Function places market baskets in the order of most preferred to least preferred, but it does not indicate how much one market basket is preferred to another. A Cardinal Utility Function is a utility function describing the extent to which one market basket is preferred to another.
ORDINAL VERSUS CARDINAL RANKINGS
The actual unit of measurement for utility is not important. Therefore, an ordinal ranking is sufficient to explain how most individual decisions are made.
BUDGET CONSTRAINTS
Preferences do not explain all of consumer behavior. Budget constraints also limit an individualβs ability to consume in light of the prices they must pay for various goods and services.
THE BUDGET LINE
The budget line indicates all combinations of two commodities for which total money spent equals total income. Let F equal the amount of food purchased, and C is the amount of clothing. Price of food = P_f and price of clothing = P_c. Then P_f F is the amount of money spent on food, and P_c C is the amount of money spent on clothing. The budget line then can be written:
π Formula: P_f F + P_c C = I β The total expenditure on food (price Γ quantity) plus total expenditure on clothing (price Γ quantity) must equal total income (I).
π Budget Line Intercepts: The vertical intercept (I/P_C) illustrates the maximum amount of C that can be purchased with income I. The horizontal intercept (I/P_F) illustrates the maximum amount of F that can be purchased with income I.
Slope of the Budget Line: The slope of the line measures the relative cost of food and clothing. The slope is the negative of the ratio of the prices of the two goods. The slope indicates the rate at which the two goods can be substituted without changing the amount of money spent.
π Formula: Slope = ΞC / ΞF = - (P_f / P_c)
THE EFFECTS OF CHANGES IN INCOME AND PRICES
An increase in income causes the budget line to shift outward, parallel to the original line (holding prices constant). A decrease in income causes the budget line to shift inward, parallel to the original line (holding prices constant).
If the price of one good increases, the budget line shifts inward, pivoting from the other goodβs intercept. If the price of one good decreases, the budget line shifts outward, pivoting from the other goodβs intercept.
If the two goods increase in price, but the ratio of the two prices is unchanged, the slope will not change. However, the budget line will shift inward to a point parallel to the original budget line.
CONSUMER CHOICE
Consumers choose a combination of goods that will maximize the satisfaction they can achieve, given the limited budget available to them. The maximizing market basket must satisfy two conditions:
- It must be located on the budget line.
- Must give the consumer the most preferred combination of goods and services.
Recall, the slope of an indifference curve is: MRS = - ΞC / ΞF. Further, the slope of the budget line is: Slope = - P_f / P_c. Therefore, it can be said that satisfaction is maximized where:
π Formula: MRS = P_f / P_c β Satisfaction is maximized when the marginal rate of substitution (of F and C) is equal to the ratio of the prices (of F and C).
At market basket A (the tangency point), the budget line and the indifference curve are tangent and no higher level of satisfaction can be attained. Point B does not maximize satisfaction because the MRS (-(-10/10) = 1 is greater than the price ratio (1/2). Market basket D cannot be attained given the current budget constraint.
DESIGNING NEW AUTOMOBILES (II)
Consider two groups of consumers, each wishing to spend $10,000 on the styling and performance of cars. Each group has different preferences. By finding the point of tangency between a groupβs indifference curve and the budget constraint auto companies can design a production and marketing plan. One group is willing to trade off a considerable amount of styling for some additional performance. Another group is willing to trade off a considerable amount of performance for some additional styling.
DECISION MAKING & PUBLIC POLICY
Choosing between a non-matching grant and a matching grant to fund police expenditures.
- Non-matching Grant: The grant provides a fixed amount of money with the requirement it be spent on police. This shifts the budget line outward (horizontally, if the condition is on police expenditure). Point B shows the new preference-maximizing basket.
- Matching Grant: The government matches any police expenditures by the city (e.g., pays $1 for every $1 spent). This effectively lowers the price of police, rotating the budget line outward. Point C shows the new preference-maximizing basket.
π‘ Why this matters: A matching grant can lead to more police expenditure than a non-matching grant of the same dollar value because it changes the relative price of police, not just the income available.
CORNER SOLUTION
A corner solution exists if a consumer buys in extremes, and buys all of one category of good and none of another. This exists where the indifference curves are tangent to the horizontal and vertical axis. MRS is not equal to P_A/P_B.
At point B, the MRS of ice cream for frozen yogurt is greater than the slope of the budget line. This suggests that if the consumer could give up more frozen yogurt for ice cream he would do so. However, there is no more frozen yogurt to give up! When a corner solution arises, the consumerβs MRS does not necessarily equal the price ratio.
π Formula (for a corner solution): MRS β₯ P_IceCream / P_FrozenYogurt β The consumer would prefer to give up frozen yogurt to get ice cream, but since they have no frozen yogurt, their MRS is at least as large as the price ratio.
A COLLEGE TRUST FUND
Suppose Jane Doeβs parents set up a trust fund for her college education. Originally, the money must be used for education. If part of the money could be used for the purchase of other goods, her consumption preferences change. The trust fund shifts the budget line outward. Point B represents the consumption choice if the trust fund must be spent on education. Point C represents the consumption choice if the trust could be spent on other goods.
β Key Takeaways
Utility is a numerical measure of satisfaction, and preference rankings (ordinal utility) are sufficient for explaining consumer decisions. The budget line, defined by P_f F + P_c C = I, shows all affordable combinations of two goods given income and prices. Consumers maximize satisfaction at the point where the budget line is tangent to the highest attainable indifference curve, meaning the MRS equals the price ratio. Changes in income shift the budget line parallel, while changes in a goodβs price rotate the budget line. Corner solutions occur when a consumer chooses to consume zero of one good, making the standard tangency condition inapplicable. These concepts are applied to policy analysis, such as comparing the effectiveness of matching versus non-matching grants.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between an ordinal and a cardinal utility function?
- What is the equation for a budget line, and what do the slope and intercepts represent?
- What two conditions must a market basket satisfy to maximize consumer satisfaction given a budget constraint?
- How does a decrease in the price of one good affect the budget line (draw and describe the pivot)?
- In a corner solution, why might the MRS not equal the price ratio? Provide a real-world example from the lecture.
π Lecture 8 β Consumer Behavior (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of revealed preferences, a method for understanding consumer preferences by observing their actual choices across different budget constraints. It demonstrates how we can infer what consumers prefer by analyzing their purchasing decisions when prices and incomes change, without needing to ask them directly.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers the theory of revealed preferences, illustrated through two-budget-line and four-budget-line scenarios, and includes a practical application involving Roberta's exercise and recreation budget choices. The core idea is that choices reveal preferences: if a consumer chooses basket A when B is affordable, A is "revealed preferred" to B.
π Lecture Summary
REVEALED PREFERENCES
If we know the choices a consumer has made, we can determine what her preferences are if we have information about a sufficient number of choices that are made when prices and incomes vary. This approach avoids direct questioning and instead uses revealed preferencesβinferring preferences from observed market behavior.
π Definition β Revealed Preferences: If a consumer chooses one market basket over another when both are affordable, the chosen basket is revealed to be preferred to the other.
REVEALED PREFERENCES--TWO BUDGET LINES
With two budget lines, we can observe direct comparisons. When the consumer faces budget line lβ, she chooses point A over point B (since B is also affordable on lβ). This means A is revealed preferred to B. When the budget changes to line lβ, she chooses point B over point D. This means B is revealed preferred to D.
π Example: In the two-budget-line diagram:
- With lβ, consumer selects bundle A (e.g., more clothing, less food) over bundle B.
- With lβ, consumer selects bundle B over bundle D (e.g., more food, less clothing).
- All market baskets in the blue shaded area (above and right of A) are preferred to A; B is preferred to all market baskets in the pink area (below and left of B).
REVEALED PREFERENCES--FOUR BUDGET LINES
With four budget lines, we can establish a chain of preferences. The consumerβs choices across different budgets reveal a consistent preference ordering.
π Example: In the four-budget-line diagram:
- lβ: A is chosen. All baskets in the blue area (above/right of A) are preferred to A; A is preferred to all baskets in the pink area (below/left of A).
- lβ: B is chosen (B is revealed preferred to A? NoβB was not affordable on lβ? Actually, on lβ, B is below lβ, so B was affordable but A was chosen, so A > B).
- lβ: E is chosen over A (since A is also affordable on lβ). E is revealed preferred to A.
- lβ: G is chosen over A (since A is also affordable on lβ). G is revealed preferred to A.
- Therefore, E, G, and all baskets in the blue area are preferred to A; A is preferred to all baskets in the pink area.
π‘ Why this matters: This chain of revealed preferences allows economists to map out a consumer's indifference curves without ever asking for subjective preferencesβonly observing choices.
Practical Application: Roberta's Exercise Budget
Scenario: Roberta has a recreation budget of $100 per week. Initially, the price of exercise is $4 per hour per week, and she exercises 10 hours per week at point A on budget line lβ and indifference curve Uβ.
The club considers changing the fee structure to $1 per hour plus a $30 weekly membership fee. This creates a new budget line lβ. Robertaβs new chosen combination is point B on lβ.
Because B lies to the right of A and above the original budget line lβ, we can apply revealed preference: At the new price, B is chosen when A is also affordable? Actually, on lβ, A is not affordable (A lies above lβ). However, on the original lβ, B was affordable (B lies below lβ), but Roberta chose A. Thus, A is revealed preferred to B.
π Question: Would the Clubβs profits increase?
- Revenue at A (original): 10 hrs Γ $4/hr = $40/week
- Revenue at B (new): 10 hrs Γ $1/hr + $30 fee = $40/week (if she exercises the same 10 hours)
- But if she exercises more at the lower hourly rate, revenue could increase. At B, she chooses more exercise hours (say 25 hrs) β Revenue = 25 hrs Γ $1 + $30 = $55/week β Club profits increase by $15/week.
π‘ Why this matters: Revealed preference shows that even though Roberta prefers A to B (since A was chosen over B on lβ), the club can still profit by changing the pricing structure to encourage more exercise hours.
β Key Takeaways
The revealed preference approach allows economists to deduce consumer preferences purely from observed choices across different budget constraints. If a consumer chooses basket A over B when both are affordable, A is revealed preferred to B. This principle can be extended across multiple budget lines to build a preference ordering. A critical insight is that a bundle chosen under one budget constraint may not be affordable under another, but the original preference holds. Applied to pricing decisions, revealed preference helps firms predict how consumers will respond to new fee structures and whether profits will increase or decrease.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the definition of revealed preference?
- In the two-budget-line example, if a consumer chooses A over B on lβ, and later chooses B over D on lβ, what can we conclude about preferences among A, B, and D?
- How does the four-budget-line example extend the logic of revealed preferences?
- In Roberta's exercise scenario, why is A revealed preferred to B even though B is chosen under the new price structure?
- Would the Club's profits increase under the new fee structure of $1/hr plus $30/week? Explain using the numbers.
π Lecture 9 β Marginal Utility and Consumer Choice
π Overview: This lecture introduces the concept of marginal utility and the principle of diminishing marginal utility, which are fundamental to understanding consumer choice. It explains how marginal utility relates to indifference curves and the condition for utility maximization, and applies these concepts to analyze gasoline rationing and the construction of cost-of-living indexes like the Laspeyres and Paasche indices.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture covers marginal utility and diminishing marginal utility, the relationship between total and marginal utility, the connection between marginal utility and the indifference curve leading to the equal marginal principle, an application to gasoline rationing, and two types of cost-of-living indexes: the Laspeyres price index and the Paasche index, including a comparison of their properties.
π Lecture Summary
MARGINAL UTILITY
Marginal utility measures the additional satisfaction obtained from consuming one additional unit of a good.
π Definition β Marginal Utility: the additional satisfaction obtained from consuming one additional unit of a good.
π Example: The marginal utility derived from increasing from 0 to 1 units of food might be 9, increasing from 1 to 2 might be 7, increasing from 2 to 3 might be 5. Observation: Marginal utility is diminishing.
DIMINISHING MARGINAL UTILITY
The principle of diminishing marginal utility states that as more and more of a good is consumed, consuming additional amounts will yield smaller and smaller additions to utility.
RELATIONSHIP OF TOTAL AND MARGINAL UTILITY
The fact that total utility increases at a decreasing rate is shown by the negative slope of the marginal utility curve. Total utility of consuming a certain amount is equal to the sum of the marginal utilities up to that point.
Diminishing Marginal Utility: An Example
| Quantity of good consumed | Total utility | Marginal utility |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | |
| 1 | 4 | 4 |
| 2 | 7 | 3 |
| 3 | 9 | 2 |
| 4 | 10 | 1 |
| 5 | 10 | 0 |
MARGINAL UTILITY AND THE INDIFFERENCE CURVE
If consumption moves along an indifference curve, the additional utility derived from an increase in the consumption of one good, food (F), must balance the loss of utility from the decrease in the consumption in the other good, clothing (C).
Formally: 0 = MU<sub>F</sub> (ΞF) + MU<sub>C</sub> (ΞC)
Rearranging:
- (ΞC/ΞF) = MU<sub>F</sub> / MU<sub>C</sub>
Because:
- (ΞC/ΞF) = MRS of F for C
Therefore: MRS = MU<sub>F</sub>/MU<sub>C</sub>
When consumers maximize satisfaction: MRS = P<sub>F</sub>/P<sub>C</sub>
Since the MRS is also equal to the ratio of the marginal utilities, it follows that: MU<sub>F</sub>/MU<sub>C</sub> = P<sub>F</sub>/P<sub>C</sub>
This gives the equation for utility maximization: MU<sub>F</sub>/P<sub>F</sub> = MU<sub>C</sub>/P<sub>C</sub>
Total utility is maximized when the budget is allocated so that the marginal utility per dollar of expenditure is the same for each good. This is referred to as the equal marginal principle.
GASOLINE RATIONING
In 1974 and again in 1979, the government imposed price controls on gasoline, resulting in shortages and gasoline being rationed. Non-price rationing is an alternative to market rationing. Under one form, everyone has an equal chance to purchase a rationed good. Gasoline was rationed by long lines at the gas pumps. Rationing hurts some by limiting the amount of gasoline they can buy. With a limit of 2,000 gallons, the consumer moves to a lower indifference curve (lower level of utility).
COST-OF-LIVING INDEXES
The CPI is calculated each year as the ratio of the cost of a typical bundle of consumer goods and services today in comparison to the cost during a base period.
Example Two sisters, Raheela and Sarah, have identical preferences. Sarah began college in 1987 with a $500 discretionary budget. In 1997, Raheela started college and her parents promised her a budget that was equivalent in purchasing power.
| Sarah (1987) | Raheela (1997) | |
|---|---|---|
| Price of books | $20/book | $100/book |
| Number of books | 15 | 6 |
| Price of food | $2.00/lb | $2.20/lb |
| Pounds of food | 100 | 300 |
| Expenditure | $500 | $1,260 |
Sarahβs Expenditure: $500 = 100 lbs of food x $2.00/lb + 15 books x $20/book Raheelaβs Expenditure for Equal Utility: $1,260 = 300 lbs of food x $2.20/lb + 6 books x $100/book
The ideal cost-of-living adjustment for Raheela is $760. The ideal cost-of-living index is $1,260/$500 = 2.52 or 252. This implies a 152% increase in the cost of living.
The ideal cost of living index represents the cost of attaining a given level of utility at current (1997) prices relative to the cost of attaining the same utility at base (1987) prices.
LASPEYRES PRICE INDEX
Price indexes, like the CPI, use a fixed consumption bundle in the base period called a Laspeyres price index. The Laspeyres index tells us the amount of money at current year prices that an individual requires to purchase the bundle of goods and services that was chosen in the base year divided by the cost of purchasing the same bundle at base year prices.
Calculating Raheelaβs Laspeyres Cost of Living Index Setting the quantities of goods in 1997 equal to what were bought by her sister, but setting their prices at their 1997 levels result in an expenditure of $1,720 (100 x 2.20 + 15 x $100). Her cost of living adjustment would now be $1,220. The Laspeyres index is: $1,720/$500 = 344. This overstates the true cost-of-living increase.
The Laspeyres index assumes that consumers do not alter their consumption patterns as prices change. By increasing purchases of those items that have become relatively cheaper, and decreasing purchases of the relatively more expensive items, consumers can achieve the same level of utility without having to consume the same bundle of goods.
THE PAASCHE INDEX
The Paasche Index calculates the amount of money at current-year prices that an individual requires to purchase a current bundle of goods and services divided by the cost of purchasing the same bundle in the base year.
COMPARING THE TWO INDEXES
Suppose there are two goods: Food (F) and Clothing (C) Let:
- P<sub>Ft</sub> & P<sub>Ct</sub> be current year prices
- P<sub>Fb</sub> & P<sub>Cb</sub> be base year prices
- F<sub>t</sub> & C<sub>t</sub> be current year quantities
- F<sub>b</sub> & C<sub>b</sub> be base year quantities
Both indexes involve ratios that involve todayβs current year prices. However, the Laspeyres index relies on base year consumption, F<sub>b</sub> and C<sub>b</sub>, whereas the Paasche index relies on todayβs current consumption, F<sub>t</sub> and C<sub>t</sub>.
Then: LI = (P<sub>Ft</sub> F<sub>b</sub> + P<sub>Ct</sub> C<sub>b</sub>) / (P<sub>Fb</sub> F<sub>b</sub> + P<sub>Cb</sub> C<sub>b</sub>) PI = (P<sub>Ft</sub> F<sub>t</sub> + P<sub>Ct</sub> C<sub>t</sub>) / (P<sub>Fb</sub> F<sub>t</sub> + P<sub>Cb</sub> C<sub>t</sub>)
Example using Sarah (1990) and Raheela (1997) Cost of base-year bundle at current prices: $1,720 (100 lbs x $2.20/lb + 15 books x $100/book) Cost of same bundle at base year prices: $500 (100 lbs x $2.00/lb + 15 books x $20/book) The Laspeyres index is: LI = $1,720/$500 = 344
Cost of buying current year bundle at current year prices: $1,260 (300 lbs x $2.20/lb + 6 books x $100/book) Cost of the same bundle at base year prices: $720 (300 lbs x $2/lb + 6 books x $20/book) The Paasche index is: PI = $1,260/$720 = 175
The Paasche index will understate the cost of living because it assumes that the individual will buy the current year bundle in the base year.
β Key Takeaways
The central concept of this lecture is the principle of diminishing marginal utility, which explains why consumers value additional units of a good less and is the foundation for the downward-sloping demand curve. The key condition for consumer utility maximization is the equal marginal principle, which states that a consumer maximizes satisfaction when the marginal utility per dollar spent is equal across all goods (MU<sub>F</sub>/P<sub>F</sub> = MU<sub>C</sub>/P<sub>C</sub>). This condition can be derived from the indifference curve analysis where the MRS equals the price ratio. The lecture applies these concepts to show how non-price rationing, like gasoline rationing, can lower utility. Finally, it explains that the Laspeyres price index, which uses a fixed base-year consumption bundle, tends to overstate the true cost-of-living increase, while the Paasche index, which uses the current-year bundle, tends to understate it.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the formula that defines the condition for utility maximization for a consumer choosing between two goods, food (F) and clothing (C)?
- Why does the Laspeyres price index tend to overstate the true increase in the cost of living?
- Explain the principle of diminishing marginal utility using the example of consuming units of food provided in the lecture.
- How is the marginal rate of substitution (MRS) of food for clothing related to the marginal utilities of food and clothing?
- In the example of gasoline rationing, why does the consumer end up on a lower indifference curve?
π Lecture 10 β Individual and Market Demand
π Overview: This lecture examines how individual demand curves are derived from consumer choice theory, focusing on the effects of price changes and income changes on consumer behavior. It introduces the price-consumption curve, income-consumption curve, and Engel curves as tools for understanding demand, while also classifying goods as normal, inferior, substitutes, or complements.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers individual demand derived from price changes using indifference curves and budget lines, tracing the price-consumption curve and deriving the demand curve with its two important properties. It then examines income changes and the income-consumption curve, distinguishing between normal and inferior goods. Engel curves are introduced to show the relationship between income and quantity demanded, and the lecture concludes with classifying goods as substitutes, complements, or independent based on cross-price effects.
π Lecture Summary
INDIVIDUAL DEMAND
Individual demand shows the relationship between the price of a good and the quantity a consumer will buy, derived from utility-maximizing behavior.
PRICE CHANGES
Using indifference curves, the impact of a change in the price of food can be illustrated. Assume income I = $20, price of clothing Pc = $2, and price of food PF varies at $2, $1, and $0.50. As the price of food falls, the budget line rotates outward, and the consumer reaches higher indifference curves at different tangency points (A, B, D). The price-consumption curve traces out the utility-maximizing market baskets for various prices of food.
π Price-Consumption Curve: A curve tracing the utility-maximizing combinations of two goods as the price of one changes.
π Example: With I=$20, Pc=$2, when PF=$2, consumer chooses point A (4 food, 6 clothing). When PF=$1, consumer chooses point B (12 food, 6 clothing). When PF=$0.50, consumer chooses point D (20 food, 4 clothing). These points form the price-consumption curve.
Effect of a Price Change β Demand Curve
The individual demand curve relates the quantity of a good that a consumer will buy to the price of that good. Plotting price against quantity from the price-consumption curve gives points E ($2.00, 4 food), G ($1.00, 12 food), and H ($0.50, 20 food).
π‘ Why this matters: The demand curve is derived directly from utility-maximizing behavior, not assumed arbitrarily.
TWO IMPORTANT PROPERTIES OF DEMAND CURVES
- The level of utility that can be attained changes as we move along the curve (utility increases as price falls).
- At every point on the demand curve, the consumer is maximizing utility by satisfying the condition that the MRS of food for clothing equals the ratio of the prices of food and clothing.
π Formula: MRS = PF/PC
π Example: At point E: PF/PC = $2/$2 = 1 = MRS. At point G: PF/PC = $1/$2 = 0.5 = MRS. At point H: PF/PC = $0.50/$2 = 0.25 = MRS. As price falls, both PF/PC and MRS also fall.
INCOME CHANGES
Using indifference curves, the impact of a change in income can be illustrated. Assume PF = $1, Pc = $2, and income varies at $10, $20, and $30. As income increases, the budget line shifts rightward, and the consumer reaches higher indifference curves. The income-consumption curve traces out the utility-maximizing combinations of food and clothing associated with every income level.
π Income-Consumption Curve: A curve tracing the utility-maximizing combinations of two goods as a consumer's income changes (with prices fixed).
An increase in income shifts the budget line to the right, increasing consumption along the income-consumption curve. Simultaneously, the increase in income shifts the demand curve to the right (from D1 to D2 to D3).
NORMAL GOOD VERSUS INFERIOR GOOD
When the income-consumption curve has a positive slope, the quantity demanded increases with income. The income elasticity of demand is positive. The good is a normal good.
When the income-consumption curve has a negative slope, the quantity demanded decreases with income. The income elasticity of demand is negative. The good is an inferior good.
π Normal Good: A good for which quantity demanded increases as income increases (positive income elasticity).
π Inferior Good: A good for which quantity demanded decreases as income increases (negative income elasticity).
π Example: In the tea and coffee example, both tea and coffee behave as normal goods between points A and B on the income-consumption curve. However, tea becomes an inferior good when the income-consumption curve bends backward between points B and C, meaning at higher incomes, consumers buy less tea and more coffee.
ENGEL CURVES
Engel curves relate the quantity of good consumed to income. If the good is a normal good, the Engel curve is upward sloping. If the good is an inferior good, the Engel curve is downward sloping (backward bending).
π Engel Curve: A curve showing the relationship between a consumer's income and the quantity of a good consumed.
π Example: From US consumer expenditure data (1997 $), as income increases from less than $10,000 to $70,000 and above, expenditures on food rise from $656 to $8,279 (normal good), while expenditures on rented residences fall from $1,957 to $1,266 (inferior good).
π‘ Why this matters: Engel curves help economists predict how consumption patterns change with economic growth or recession.
SUBSTITUTES AND COMPLEMENTS
Two goods are considered substitutes if an increase (decrease) in the price of one leads to an increase (decrease) in the quantity demanded of the other. Example: movie tickets and video rentals. If the price-consumption curve is downward-sloping, the two goods are considered substitutes.
Two goods are considered complements if an increase (decrease) in the price of one leads to a decrease (increase) in the quantity demanded of the other. Example: gasoline and motor oil. If the price-consumption curve is upward-sloping, the two goods are considered complements.
Two goods are independent when a change in the price of one good has no effect on the quantity demanded of the other.
π Substitutes: Two goods for which an increase in the price of one leads to an increase in the quantity demanded of the other.
π Complements: Two goods for which an increase in the price of one leads to a decrease in the quantity demanded of the other.
β Key Takeaways
The individual demand curve is derived from price changes along the price-consumption curve, with the key property that at every point the MRS equals the price ratio. Income changes shift the demand curve and are traced by the income-consumption curve, which distinguishes normal goods (positive slope) from inferior goods (negative slope). Engel curves graphically represent the relationship between income and quantity consumed, sloping upward for normal goods and backward-bending for inferior goods. Finally, the slope of the price-consumption curve determines whether goods are substitutes (downward-sloping) or complements (upward-sloping). Understanding these derivations is essential for predicting consumer responses to price and income changes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the price-consumption curve and how is it used to derive the individual demand curve?
- State the two important properties of demand curves discussed in this lecture.
- What is the difference between a normal good and an inferior good in terms of the income-consumption curve and income elasticity?
- How do Engel curves differ for normal goods versus inferior goods?
- How can the slope of the price-consumption curve indicate whether two goods are substitutes or complements?
π Lecture 11 β Individual and Market Demand (Continued)
π Overview: This lecture examines how changes in price affect consumer behavior through substitution and income effects, distinguishing between normal and inferior goods. It then extends the analysis to market demand curves, discussing how individual demands aggregate, and concludes with a detailed exploration of price elasticity of demand, including point and arc elasticity calculations.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers income and substitution effects for normal and inferior goods, including the special case of Giffen goods. It then examines a practical application involving gasoline taxes with rebates before shifting to market demand curves and their determination. Finally, it addresses elasticity of demand, including point elasticity, its problems with large price changes, and arc elasticity as a solution.
π Lecture Summary
INCOME & SUBSTITUTION EFFECTS
A fall in the price of a good has two effects: substitution effect and income effect. Consumers will tend to buy more of the good that has become relatively cheaper, and less of the good that is now relatively more expensive. Consumers also experience an increase in real purchasing power when the price of one good falls.
SUBSTITUTION EFFECT
The substitution effect is the change in an item's consumption associated with a change in the price of the item, with the level of utility held constant. When the price of an item declines, the substitution effect always leads to an increase in the quantity of the item demanded.
π Definition β Substitution Effect: The change in consumption of a good resulting from a change in its relative price, holding utility (real income) constant.
INCOME EFFECT
The income effect is the change in an item's consumption brought about by the increase in purchasing power, with the price of the item held constant. When a person's income increases, the quantity demanded for the product may increase or decrease. Even with inferior goods, the income effect is rarely large enough to outweigh the substitution effect.
π Definition β Income Effect: The change in consumption of a good resulting from a change in real purchasing power (real income), holding relative prices constant.
INCOME & SUBSTITUTION EFFECTS: NORMAL GOOD
When the price of food falls for a normal good, consumption increases by FβFβ as the consumer moves from point A to B. The substitution effect, FβE (from point A to D), changes the relative prices but keeps real income (satisfaction) constant. The income effect, EFβ (from D to B), keeps relative prices constant but increases purchasing power.
π Example β Normal Good: Total Effect = FβFβ = FβE (Substitution Effect) + EFβ (Income Effect). The substitution effect moves from A to D along Uβ, and the income effect moves from D to B from Uβ to Uβ.
π‘ Why this matters: For normal goods, both substitution and income effects work in the same direction (increasing quantity demanded when price falls), reinforcing the downward-sloping demand curve.
INCOME & SUBSTITUTION EFFECTS: INFERIOR GOOD
Since food is an inferior good, the income effect is negative. However, the substitution effect is larger than the income effect, so the overall effect is still an increase in quantity demanded when price falls.
A SPECIAL CASE--THE GIFFEN GOOD
The income effect may theoretically be large enough to cause the demand curve for a good to slope upward. This rarely occurs and is of little practical interest. A Giffen good is an inferior good for which the income effect outweighs the substitution effect, leading to an upward-sloping demand curve.
EFFECT OF A GASOLINE TAX WITH A REBATE
Assume:
- Price elasticity of demand (Eβ) = -0.5
- Income = $9,000
- Price of gasoline = $1
After a $0.50 excise tax plus a $450 rebate: Gasoline consumption = 900 gallons (originally 1200 gallons), other expenditures = $7,800 (originally $7,800). The consumer moves from point A to H on a new budget line, with utility level Uβ instead of Uβ.
MARKET DEMAND
MARKET DEMAND CURVES A curve that relates the quantity of a good that all consumers in a market buy to the price of that good is called market demand curve.
DETERMINING THE MARKET DEMAND CURVE
The market demand curve is obtained by summing the consumer's demand curves horizontallyβadding the quantities demanded by each individual at each price.
π Example β Market Demand Determination:
| Price ($) | Individual A | Individual B | Individual C | Market |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | 6 | 10 | 16 | 32 |
| 2 | 4 | 8 | 13 | 25 |
| 3 | 2 | 6 | 10 | 18 |
| 4 | 0 | 4 | 7 | 11 |
| 5 | 0 | 2 | 4 | 6 |
At price $3: Market demand = 2 + 6 + 10 = 18 units.
TWO IMPORTANT POINTS
The market demand will shift to the right as more consumers enter the market. Factors that influence the demands of many consumers will also affect the market demand.
ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
Price elasticity of demand measures the percentage change in the quantity demanded resulting from a 1-percent change in price.
π Formula: Eβ = (ΞQ/Q) / (ΞP/P) = (ΞQ/ΞP) Γ (P/Q)
Price Elasticity and Consumer Expenditure:
| Demand | If Price Increases, Expenditures: | If Price Decreases, Expenditures: |
|---|---|---|
| Inelastic (Eβ < 1) | Increase | Decrease |
| Unit Elastic (Eβ = 1) | Are unchanged | Are unchanged |
| Elastic (Eβ > 1) | Decrease | Increase |
POINT ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
For large price changes (e.g., 20%), the value of elasticity will depend upon where the price and quantity lie on the demand curve. Point elasticity measures elasticity at a point on the demand curve.
π Formula: Eβ = (P/Q)(1/slope)
PROBLEMS USING POINT ELASTICITY
We may need to calculate price elasticity over a portion of the demand curve rather than at a single point. The price and quantity used as the base will alter the price elasticity of demand.
π Example β Point Elasticity Problems: Assume price increases from $8 to $10, quantity demanded falls from 6 to 4.
- Percent change in price: $2/$8 = 25% or $2/$10 = 20%
- Percent change in quantity: -2/6 = -33.33% or -2/4 = -50%
- Elasticity equals: -33.33/0.25 = -1.33 or -0.50/0.20 = -2.54
Which one is correct? Neither is fully accurate for a rangeβarc elasticity solves this.
ARC ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
Arc elasticity calculates elasticity over a range of prices using average price and average quantity.
π Formula: Eβ = (ΞQ/ΞP)(PΜ/QΜ), where PΜ = average price and QΜ = average quantity
π Example β Arc Elasticity of Demand: Pβ = $8, Pβ = $10, Qβ = 6, Qβ = 4 PΜ = 18/2 = $9, QΜ = 10/2 = 5 Eβ = (-2/$2)($9/5) = -1.8
β Key Takeaways
The substitution effect always increases quantity demanded when price falls, while the income effect can work in either direction. For normal goods, both effects reinforce each other; for inferior goods, the income effect is negative but typically smaller than the substitution effect, except in the rare Giffen good case. Market demand curves are constructed by horizontally summing individual demand curves at each price. Elasticity calculations require careful handling of the base price and quantityβarc elasticity using averages provides a consistent measure over a range, avoiding the ambiguity of point elasticity for large price changes.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the two effects of a price change, and how do they differ in what they hold constant?
- Why is the Giffen good case considered a theoretical curiosity rather than a practical concern?
- How do you construct a market demand curve from individual demand curves?
- What is the formula for arc elasticity of demand, and why is it preferred over point elasticity when price changes are large?
- If price increases and total expenditure rises, is demand elastic or inelastic?