๐ Lecture Summary
IMPORTANCE OF ELASTICITY IN OUR TODAY'S LIFE
The concept of elasticity has significant practical applications. Firms use advertising to change prices based on the elasticity of demand for their products. Most firms set prices by examining their product's demand elasticity. Governments collect revenues by imposing taxes, typically choosing products with either inelastic demand or inelastic supply for taxation. If the government wants to put the tax burden on consumers, it selects products with low price elasticity of demand. If the government wants to penalize producers, it chooses products with low price elasticity of supply.
ELASTICITY
Elasticity is a term widely used in economics to denote the "responsiveness of one variable to changes in another." In proper words, it is the relative response of one variable to changes in another variable. The phrase "relative response" is best interpreted as the percentage change.
TYPES OF ELASTICITY
There are four major types of elasticity: Price Elasticity of Demand, Price Elasticity of Supply, Income Elasticity of Demand, and Cross-Price Elasticity of Demand.
Price Elasticity of Demand
Price elasticity of demand is the percentage change in quantity demanded with respect to the percentage change in price.
๐ Definition โ Price Elasticity of Demand (Pะd): The responsiveness of quantity demanded to changes in price, measured as the ratio of percentage change in quantity demanded to percentage change in price.
๐ Formula: Pะd = Percentage change in Quantity Demanded / Percentage change in Price where ะ = Epsilon, the universal notation for elasticity.
๐ Example: If a 20% increase in the price of a product causes a 10% fall in the quantity demanded, the price elasticity of demand will be: Pะd = -10% / 20% = -0.5
Price Elasticity of Supply
Price elasticity of supply is the percentage change in quantity supplied with respect to the percentage change in price.
๐ Definition โ Price Elasticity of Supply (Pะs): The responsiveness of quantity supplied to changes in price, measured as the ratio of percentage change in quantity supplied to percentage change in price.
๐ Formula: Pะs = Percentage change in Quantity Supplied / Percentage change in Price
๐ Example: If a 15% rise in the price of a product causes a 15% rise in the quantity supplied, the price elasticity of supply will be: Pะs = 15% / 15% = 1
Income Elasticity of Demand
Income elasticity of demand is the percentage change in quantity demanded with respect to the percentage change in income of the consumer.
๐ Definition โ Income Elasticity of Demand (Yะd): The responsiveness of quantity demanded to changes in consumer income, measured as the ratio of percentage change in quantity demanded to percentage change in income.
๐ Formula: Yะd = Percentage change in Quantity Demanded / Percentage change in Income
๐ Example: If a 2% rise in consumer incomes causes an 8% rise in product demand, then the income elasticity of demand for the product will be: Yะd = 8% / 2% = 4
Cross-Price Elasticity of Demand
Cross-price elasticity of demand is the percentage change in quantity demanded of a specific good, with respect to the percentage change in the price of another related good.
๐ Definition โ Cross-Price Elasticity of Demand (Pbะda): The responsiveness of demand for one good to changes in the price of another related good, measured as the ratio of percentage change in demand for good A to percentage change in price of good B.
๐ Formula: Pbะda = Percentage change in Demand for good a / Percentage change in Price of good b
๐ Example 1 (Substitutes): If the demand for butter rose by 2% when the price of margarine rose by 8%, then the cross-price elasticity of demand of butter with respect to the price of margarine will be: Pbะda = 2% / 8% = 0.25
๐ Example 2 (Complements): If the price of bread (a complement) rose by 4%, leading to a 3% fall in the demand for butter, the cross-price elasticity of demand for butter with respect to bread would be: Pbะda = -3% / 4% = -0.75
WHY WE USE PERCENTAGE CHANGE RATHER THAN ABSOLUTE CHANGE IN ELASTICITY?
- Unit comparison problem: By using percentage changes and proportions, we can avoid the problem of comparing two different quantitative variables โ quantity demanded is measured in units while price is measured in rupees. Calculating percentages avoids the problem of unit conversion.
- Unit size problem: It helps avoid the problem of what size of units to be changed. A jump from Rs. 2 to Rs. 4 could be described as a 100% increase or as an increase of Rs. 2, but using percentages gives the same answer regardless.
- Defining big or small changes: By looking at Rs. 2 or Rs. 4, we cannot say whether it is a big change or a small change. But if we translate it into percentages, it becomes 100%, which is clearly a big change.
ELASTIC AND INELASTIC DEMAND
Slope and elasticity of demand have an inverse relationship. When slope is high, elasticity of demand is low, and vice versa.
When the slope of a demand curve is infinity, elasticity is zero (perfectly inelastic demand). When the slope of a demand curve is zero, elasticity is infinite (perfectly elastic demand).
Unit elasticity means that a 1% change in price will result in an exact 1% change in quantity demanded, so elasticity equals one. A unit elastic demand curve plots as a rectangular hyperbola. A straight line demand curve cannot have unit elasticity because the value of elasticity changes along the straight line demand curve.
๐ก Why this matters: The relationship between slope and elasticity is crucial โ steep demand curves indicate inelastic demand (consumers don't respond much to price changes), while flat demand curves indicate elastic demand (consumers are very responsive to price changes).
TOTAL REVENUE AND ELASTICITY
Total Revenue (TR) = Price ร Quantity (P ร Q)
Elastic demand means when price of any product increases, its demand decreases more than the increase in price. As price increases, total revenue decreases in the case of elastic demand.
Inelastic demand means if price of that product increases, there is very small effect on its quantity demanded. As price increases, total revenue also increases in the case of inelastic demand.
๐ Example: Flour is a basic necessity of life for all people. Its demand is inelastic. When the price of flour increases, its quantity demanded does not decrease much because people have to use flour in all situations whether its price is high or low.
EXAMPLE OF 2 FIRMS
Firm 1: (Inelastic Demand Curve)
For an inelastic demand curve, the firm increases its prices but quantity demanded does not change as much. The increase in price is greater while the decrease in quantity is smaller. So the firm will earn more revenues by increasing prices. TR increases as price increases.
๐ Example: At price 10, quantity demanded is 100. At price 6, quantity demanded is 90. ะ = (90-100)/100 รท (10-6)/6 = -0.10/0.67 = -0.15 Since |ะ| = 0.15 < 1 (ignoring minus sign), the demand curve is inelastic.
Firm 2: (Elastic Demand Curve)
For an elastic demand curve, the firm does not increase its prices because as prices increase, quantity demanded decreases much more. The decrease in quantity demanded is greater than the increase in prices. So the firm will earn less revenue. TR decreases as price increases.
๐ Example: At price 7, quantity demanded is 40. At price 6, quantity demanded is 100. ะ = (40-100)/100 รท (7-6)/6 = -0.60/0.167 = -3.6 Since |ะ| = 3.6 > 1 (ignoring minus sign), the demand curve is elastic.
ELASTICITY BETWEEN TWO POINTS
Elasticity can also be calculated between two points on a demand curve.
๐ Example: From point K to point L on an elastic demand curve: Price changes from 8 to 6, quantity changes from 8 to 16. ะKL = (16-8)/8 รท (6-8)/8 = 1.0/(-0.25) = -4 Since |ะ| = 4 > 1, it is elastic.
Arc Elasticity
Arc elasticity measures the "average" elasticity between two points on the demand curve.
๐ Definition โ Arc Elasticity: The average elasticity calculated between two points, using the average of the two prices and the average of the two quantities.
๐ Formula: Arc Elasticity = (Change in Quantity / Change in Price) ร (Average Price / Average Quantity)
To measure arc elasticity, we take average values for Q and P respectively.
Point Elasticity
Point elasticity is used when the change in price is very small, i.e., the two points between which elasticity is being measured essentially collapse on each other. Differential calculus is used to calculate the instantaneous rate of change of quantity with respect to changes in price (dQ/dP) and then this is multiplied by P/Q, where P and Q are the price and quantity at the point of interest.
๐ Definition โ Point Elasticity: The elasticity at a single point on the demand curve, calculated using calculus when price changes are infinitesimally small.
๐ Formula: ะ = (ฮQ/ฮP) ร (P/Q) or ะ = (dQ/dP) ร (P/Q) where d = infinitely small change in price.
If elasticity = zero, then the demand curve will be vertical. If elasticity = infinity, then the demand curve will be horizontal.
POINT ELASTICITY FOR QUADRATIC DEMAND FUNCTION
The quadratic demand function is: Qd = 60 - 15P + Pยฒ
๐ Example: To find point elasticity:
- Take different values of price (e.g., 0 to 3) and calculate quantity demanded:
| P | 60 | -15P | Pยฒ | Qd = 60 - 15P + Pยฒ |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | 60 | 0 | 0 | 60 |
| 1 | 60 | -15 | 1 | 46 |
| 2 | 60 | -30 | 4 | 34 |
| 3 | 60 | -45 | 9 | 24 |
-
Plot prices on vertical axis and quantity on horizontal axis โ the resulting curve is downward sloping.
-
To find point elasticity, differentiate the demand function with respect to price: dQ/dP = -15 + 2P
-
If P = 3: dQ/dP = -15 + 2(3) = -15 + 6 = -9 Qd = 60 - 15(3) + (3)ยฒ = 60 - 45 + 9 = 24
-
Using the formula ะ = (dQ/dP)(P/Q): ะ = -9 ร (3/24) = -9 ร 0.125 = -1.125
Since the absolute value (ignoring minus sign) is 1.125 > 1, it is point elastic.
โญ Key Takeaways
The four types of elasticityโprice elasticity of demand, price elasticity of supply, income elasticity of demand, and cross-price elasticity of demandโeach measure responsiveness using percentage changes, which allows comparison across different units and scales. Elasticity values determine whether demand is elastic (|ะ| > 1), inelastic (|ะ| < 1), or unit elastic (|ะ| = 1), and this classification directly impacts total revenue: for elastic demand, raising prices decreases total revenue, while for inelastic demand, raising prices increases total revenue. The inverse relationship between slope and elasticity is criticalโsteep demand curves indicate inelastic demand while flat curves indicate elastic demand. Elasticity can be calculated between two points using arc elasticity (with average values) or at a single point using calculus-based point elasticity. Cross-price elasticity is positive for substitute goods and negative for complementary goods, providing essential information for understanding market relationships.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the formula for price elasticity of demand, and why are percentage changes used instead of absolute changes?
-
If a 10% increase in price leads to a 5% decrease in quantity demanded, what is the price elasticity of demand, and is demand elastic or inelastic?
-
Explain the relationship between total revenue and price changes for both elastic and inelastic demand curves.
-
What is the difference between arc elasticity and point elasticity, and when would you use each method?
-
How do you interpret a cross-price elasticity of demand value of +2.5 versus a value of -1.8?
๐ Lecture 7 โ Elasticities (Continued)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the study of elasticity, specifically examining how price elasticity of demand affects total revenue when prices change. It also introduces the determinants of price elasticity of demand, the effects of advertising on demand, and the concept of price elasticity of supply along with its determinants.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the relationship between price elasticity of demand and total revenue for inelastic, elastic, and unit elastic demand, including a table illustrating unitary elasticity. It then discusses determinants of price elasticity of demand such as substitutes, income proportion, and time period. The effects of advertising on the demand curve are examined, followed by an introduction to price elasticity of supply and its determinants, including the role of costs and time.
๐ Lecture Summary
Inelastic Demand 0< ะ < 1
When demand is inelastic (price elasticity between 0 and 1), the percentage change in quantity demanded is less than the percentage change in price. If price rises, quantity decreases but by a smaller proportion, so total revenue (TR = P ร Q) increases. If price falls, quantity increases but by a smaller proportion, so total revenue decreases.
๐ Definition โ Inelastic Demand: Demand for which the price elasticity coefficient is between 0 and 1, meaning the percentage change in quantity demanded is less than the percentage change in price.
๐ Example: If a 10% price increase leads to only a 5% decrease in quantity demanded (ะ = 0.5), total revenue will increase because the price rise outweighs the quantity loss.
Elastic Demand ะ > 1
When demand is elastic (price elasticity greater than 1), the percentage change in quantity demanded is greater than the percentage change in price. If price rises, quantity decreases by a larger proportion, so total revenue decreases. If price falls, quantity increases by a larger proportion, so total revenue increases.
๐ Definition โ Elastic Demand: Demand for which the price elasticity coefficient is greater than 1, meaning the percentage change in quantity demanded is greater than the percentage change in price.
๐ Example: If a 10% price increase leads to a 20% decrease in quantity demanded (ะ = 2), total revenue will fall because the quantity loss outweighs the price gain.
Unit Elastic Demand ะ = 1
When demand is unit elastic (price elasticity exactly equal to 1), the percentage change in quantity demanded equals the percentage change in price. If price rises or falls, the proportional change in quantity exactly offsets the price change, so total revenue remains unchanged.
๐ Definition โ Unit Elastic Demand: Demand for which the price elasticity coefficient equals 1, meaning the percentage change in quantity demanded is exactly equal to the percentage change in price.
Table of Unitary Elasticity
| P | Q | TR |
|---|---|---|
| 2.5 | 400 | 1,000 |
| 5 | 200 | 1,000 |
| 10 | 100 | 1,000 |
| 20 | 50 | 1,000 |
| 40 | 25 | 1,000 |
The curve of unitary elastic demand will be a hyperbola.
๐ Example: In the table above, as price increases from 2.5 to 40 and quantity decreases from 400 to 25, total revenue stays constant at 1,000 because the elasticity is exactly 1.
Determinants of Price Elasticity of Demand
There are three main determinants of price elasticity of demand. First, the number of close substitutes within the market: the more (and closer) substitutes available, the more elastic demand will be in response to a change in price, as the substitution effect will be quite strong. Second, the percentage of income spent on a good: the smaller the proportion of income spent on a good, the more inelastic demand tends to be. Third, the time period under consideration: demand tends to be more elastic in the long run rather than in the short run.
๐ Definition โ Determinants of Price Elasticity: Factors that influence how responsive quantity demanded is to price changes, including availability of substitutes, income proportion, and time horizon.
๐ Example: After the two world oil price shocks of the 1970s, the "response" to higher oil prices was modest in the immediate period after price increases, but as time passed, people found ways to consume less petroleum. This included measures to get better mileage from their cars, higher spending on insulation in homes, and car pooling for commuters. The demand for oil became more elastic in the long-run.
๐ก Why this matters: Understanding these determinants helps businesses and policymakers predict consumer reactions to price changes and plan accordingly.
Effects of Advertising on Demand Curve
Advertising aims to change the slope of the demand curve by making it more inelastic, which is done by generating brand loyalty. Additionally, advertising aims to shift the demand curve to the right by tempting people's want for that specific product.
Price Elasticity of Supply
The price elasticity of supply is the relative response of a change in quantity supplied to a relative change in price. More specifically, it can be defined as the percentage change in quantity supplied due to a percentage change in supply price.
| Price (P) | Inelastic Supply Curve | Unitary elastic Supply Curve | Elastic Supply Curve |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quantity Supplied (Q) |
The lecture notes show three supply curves: an inelastic supply curve (steep slope), a unitary elastic supply curve (linear through origin), and an elastic supply curve (flat slope). Calculating elasticities between two points on the same curve involves the arc elasticity method, while calculating elasticity at a certain point involves the point elasticity method.
Determinants of Price Elasticity of Supply
Two main determinants are discussed. First, costs: if costs increase, supply will be lower; lower costs lead to more supply. Second, the amount of time given for quantity to respond to a price increase or decrease; there may be an immediate time period, short term, and long term time period.
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical point is the inverse relationship between price elasticity and total revenue: for inelastic demand (0<ะ<1), price and total revenue move in the same direction; for elastic demand (ะ>1), they move in opposite directions; and for unit elastic demand (ะ=1), total revenue remains constant regardless of price changes. The three key determinants of demand elasticity are the number of substitutes, proportion of income spent, and time horizon, with demand becoming more elastic in the long run. Advertising makes demand more inelastic through brand loyalty and shifts the demand curve rightward. Price elasticity of supply depends on cost conditions and the time period available for production adjustment. Finally, arc elasticity is used when calculating between two points, while point elasticity is used at a specific point on the curve.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- If a product has price elasticity of demand of 0.4 and the price increases by 15%, what happens to total revenue? Explain why.
- Why does the demand for oil become more elastic in the long run after a price shock?
- How does advertising affect both the slope and position of a demand curve?
- What is the difference between arc elasticity and point elasticity of supply?
- Using the unitary elasticity table, verify that total revenue remains constant at 1,000 for all price-quantity combinations.
๐ Lecture 8 โ Elasticities (Continued)
๐ Overview: This lecture extends the concept of elasticity beyond price changes to examine how demand responds to changes in income and the prices of related goods. It also explores the practical application of elasticity concepts to understand tax incidence and provides core rules to classify goods by their elasticity characteristics.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
Income elasticity of demand, its measurement and determinants; cross-price elasticity of demand and its determinants; incidence of taxation; three core rules of elasticity; and exercises applying elasticity concepts to real-world scenarios including brand vs. product elasticity, oil demand, and cigarette taxation.
๐ Lecture Summary
INCOME ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
The relative response of a change in demand to a relative change in income. More specifically, income elasticity of demand is defined as the percentage change in demand due to a percentage change in buyers' income. It quantitatively identifies the theoretical relationship between income and demand.
๐ Definition โ Income Elasticity of Demand (ะdy): The percentage change in quantity demanded divided by the percentage change in buyers' income.
๐ Formula: ะdy = (โQ / Q) รท (โY / Y) โ Measures the responsiveness of demand to changes in income.
Goods are classified as: Less income elastic (ะdy < 1) or More income elastic (ะdy > 1). If the sign of income elasticity of demand is positive, the good is normal; if sign is negative, the good is inferior.
๐ Example: Income rises from Rs. 10,000 to Rs. 12,000, quantity demanded rises from 100 to 105 units. ะdy = (5/100) รท (2000/10000) = 0.05 รท 0.20 = 0.25. The good is normal (positive sign) but demand is income inelastic (0 < |ะ| < 1).
DETERMINANTS OF INCOME ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
The determinants include: Degree of necessity of the good; the rate at which the desire for the good is satisfied as consumption increases; and the level of income of the consumer.
Short Run is a period in which not all factors can adjust fully, so adjustment to shocks can only be partial. Long Run is a period over which all factors can be changed and full adjustment to shocks can take place.
MINISTRY OF AGRICULTURE REPORT
The report provides income elasticity values for various food items. Examples include: Milk (-0.40), Eggs (-0.41), Mutton (-0.21), Bread (-0.25), Butter (-0.04), Margarine (-0.44), Sugar (-0.54), Fresh Potatoes (-0.48), Tea (-0.56), Cheese (0.19), Beef (0.08), Cakes & Biscuits (0.02), Fresh Green Vegetables (0.13), Fresh Fruit (0.48), Fresh Juices (0.94), Coffee (0.23). Elasticity for All Food is -0.01.
๐ก Why this matters: Most basic food items have negative income elasticities, making them inferior goods โ as incomes rise, demand for these staples actually falls.
CROSS-PRICE ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
Cross-price elasticity of demand is the percentage change in quantity demanded of a specific good, with respect to the percentage change in the price of another related good.
๐ Definition โ Cross-price Elasticity of Demand (Pbะda): The percentage change in quantity demanded of good A divided by the percentage change in the price of good B.
๐ Formula: Pbะda = (โQa / Qa) รท (โPb / Pb) โ Measures how demand for one good responds to price changes in another good.
If the sign is positive, goods are substitutes; if negative, goods are complements.
๐ Example: Demand for good A rises from 100 to 140 when price of good B rises from 10 to 12. Pbะda = (40/100) รท (2/10) = 0.40 รท 0.20 = 2. Goods are substitutes (positive sign). Demand is cross-price elastic (|ะ| > 1).
DETERMINANTS OF CROSS PRICE ELASTICITY OF DEMAND
The longer the time period, the more will be the elasticity. Taste and preferences can change over time.
INCIDENCE OF TAXATION
A tax results in a vertical shift of the supply curve as it increases the cost of producing the taxed product. The incidence of taxation relates to how much of the tax's burden is being borne by consumers and producers. The more inelastic the demand, the more of the tax's burden will fall on consumers. The more inelastic the supply, the more of the tax's burden will fall on producers.
Terms of trade means the 'real' terms at which a nation sells its exports and buys its imports. OPEC is the Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries.
THREE CORE RULES OF ELASTICITY
RULE # 1 โ Price Elasticity: If |ะ| < 1, demand is inelastic; if |ะ| = 1, demand is unit elastic; if |ะ| > 1, demand is elastic.
RULE # 2 โ Income Elasticity: If ะdy > 0, the good is a normal good; if ะdy < 0, the good is an inferior good.
RULE # 3 โ Cross Elasticity: If ะ > 0, goods are substitutes; if ะ < 0, goods are complements.
EXERCISES
Brand vs. Product Elasticity: Price elasticity of demand for a particular brand (e.g., Shell) is greater than for the product in general (e.g., petrol) because people can switch to alternative brands if the price of one brand rises. This difference results from the substitution effect.
Food Elasticity: The income effect for food will be relatively large (making demand relatively elastic), while the substitution effect will be relatively small (making demand relatively inelastic).
Oil Demand Paradox: Demand for oil might be relatively elastic over the longer term, yet people consume more oil despite rising prices because of a rightward shift in the demand curve due to rising incomes, changing tastes, decline in substitute transport, and longer travel distances.
Inelastic Demand and Price: So long as demand remains inelastic with respect to price, consumer expenditure will go on rising as price rises. However, if price is raised high enough, demand always becomes elastic.
Totally Inelastic Demand: No goods have totally inelastic demand at all prices (people have finite incomes). Over very small price ranges, goods with no close substitutes (oil, scarce water) may be totally inelastic.
Rectangular Hyperbola: A demand curve with elasticity of -1 throughout its length is a rectangular hyperbola (Qd = 1000/P). At P=ยฃ1, Q=1000; at P=10p, Q=10,000; if free, Q would be infinite.
Arc Elasticity Calculation: Using the midpoint formula [(โQ/mid Q) รท (โP/mid P)] on a straight-line demand curve: Between P=6 and P=4: (10/25) รท (-2/5) = -1 (unit elastic). Between P=4 and P=2: (10/35) รท (-2/3) = -0.43 (inelastic). As you move down a straight-line demand curve, elasticity decreases.
Point Elasticity: Given Qd = 60 - 15P + Pยฒ, with dQ/dP = -15 + 2P. At P=5: (-5) ร (5/10) = -2.5. At P=2: (-11) ร (2/34) = -0.65. At P=0: (-15) ร (0/60) = 0.
Supply Elasticity: For supply schedule P: 2,4,6,8,10 and Q: 0,10,20,30,40, with dQ/dP=5. Arc elasticity between P=2 and P=4: (10/5)รท(2/3)=3. Between P=8 and P=10: (10/35)รท(2/9)=1.29. Point elasticity at P=6: 5ร(6/20)=1.5. Elasticity of supply decreases as P and Q increase when supply curve crosses vertical axis.
Cross Elasticity: Two brands of tea have higher cross elasticity of demand than tea and coffee because they are closer substitutes.
Tax Incidence Over Time: As supply becomes more elastic over time, output falls and incidence shifts from producer to consumer. As demand becomes more elastic, incidence shifts from consumer to producer.
Cigarette Taxation Dilemma: To raise maximum revenue may require modest tax increases. To obtain large reduction in smoking may require very large tax increases. If tax is so high as to stop smoking, there would be no tax revenue at all.
Food Supply Curve: The supply curve for food is often drawn as a vertical straight line because the supply of food is virtually fixed in the short run after a crop is harvested.
Inferior Good Implication: Since income elasticity of demand for potatoes is negative, potato producers expect to earn less as national income rises over time, so production should be reduced.
โญ Key Takeaways
Income elasticity distinguishes normal goods (positive sign) from inferior goods (negative sign), with values less than one indicating necessity and values greater than one indicating luxury. Cross-price elasticity identifies substitutes (positive sign) from complements (negative sign), with the degree of elasticity determined by time period and tastes. Tax incidence depends on relative elasticities โ more inelastic side bears more tax burden. The three core rules provide a quick framework: price elasticity (inelastic < 1 < elastic), income elasticity (positive = normal, negative = inferior), and cross elasticity (positive = substitutes, negative = complements). Understanding the difference between point and arc elasticity methods is essential for accurate calculation, with arc elasticity preferred for larger price changes.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- If income rises by 10% and quantity demanded rises by 5%, what is the income elasticity of demand, and what type of good is this?
- How can you determine whether two goods are substitutes or complements using cross-price elasticity?
- Who bears more of a tax burden โ consumers or producers โ when demand is highly inelastic?
- Why does elasticity decrease as you move down a straight-line demand curve?
- What is the difference between point elasticity and arc elasticity of demand, and when should each be used?
๐ Lecture 9 โ Consumer Behavior: Consumption Side Analysis
๐ Overview: This lecture examines how consumers make rational choices under income scarcity, analyzing the trade-offs between marginal costs and benefits. It introduces two major approaches to understanding consumer behaviorโcardinal utility theory and ordinal analysisโand explains how consumers determine optimal consumption levels using the law of diminishing marginal utility and the equi-marginal principle.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by establishing scarcity and rational choice as foundations of consumer decision-making, distinguishing between ignorance and irrationality. It then compares the cardinal (marginal utility) and ordinal (indifference curve) approaches to consumer analysis. Key concepts include total and marginal utility, the law of diminishing marginal utility (with numerical example and graphical analysis), using calculus to derive marginal utility from total utility functions, consumer surplus and optimal consumption decisions, and finally the equi-marginal principle for multiple goods.
๐ Lecture Summary
Scarcity and Rational Choice
The most common form of scarcity is scarcity of incomeโconsumers have limited money resources and must decide how to spend them on different goods and services. Rational choice consists of evaluating the costs and benefits of different decisions and then choosing the decision that gives the highest benefit relative to cost. Economics stresses the importance of weighing marginal costs against marginal benefits rather than total costs and benefits when making decisions.
๐ก Why this matters: This distinction between marginal and total analysis is central to economic decision-makingโfocusing on the next unit, not the entire consumption bundle.
There is a difference between ignorance and irrationality. A person operating under uncertainty and thus at least partial ignorance can still make rational decisions by taking into account all the information she has at her disposal. Rationality is an ex-ante conceptโeconomists do not judge rational behavior on the basis of actual outcomes, rather on the basis of choices made.
Cardinal vs. Ordinal Approach
There are two approaches to analyzing consumer behavior:
- Marginal utility analysis (Cardinal approach) โ involves cardinal measurement of utility, assigning exact values or measuring utility in exact units
- Indifference curve approach (Ordinal approach) โ involves ranking possibilities or outcomes in an order of preferences without assigning exact utility values
Utility is the usefulness, benefit, or satisfaction derived from the consumption of goods and services. Total utility (TU) is the entire satisfaction one derives from consuming a good or service. Marginal utility (MU) is the additional utility derived from the consumption of one or more unit of the good.
The Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility
The law of diminishing marginal utility states that as you consume more and more of a particular good, the satisfaction or utility that you derive from each additional unit falls.
๐ Definition โ Law of Diminishing Marginal Utility: As consumption of a good increases, the marginal utility derived from each additional unit decreases.
๐ Example: Bottles of coke consumption:
| Bottles of Coke | TU | MU |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | 0 | โ |
| 1 | 7 | 7-0=7 |
| 2 | 11 | 11-7=4 |
| 3 | 13 | 2 |
| 4 | 14 | 1 |
| 5 | 14 | 0 |
| 6 | 13 | -1 |
As we consume more bottles of coke, total utility increases and marginal utility remains positive until 4 units. After that, total utility starts decreasing and marginal utility becomes negative. Total utility is maximum at unit 5 and marginal utility is zero at this point.
Total and Marginal Utility Curves: The marginal utility curve slopes downward in a MU-Q graph, showing the principle of diminishing marginal utility. The MU curve is exactly equal to the demand curve. The total utility curve starts at the origin and reaches the peak when marginal utility is zero. Marginal utility can be derived from total utilityโit is the slope of the lines joining two adjacent points on the TU curve. At point A, total utility is at maximum and marginal utility is zero.
๐ Definition โ Consumer Surplus: The difference between willingness to pay and what the consumer actually has to pay: CS = MU - P.
๐ Formula (Calculus derivation): TU = 60Q โ 4Qยฒ (quadratic utility function) MU = dTU/dQ = 60 โ 8Q For calculating MU, take different values of Q.
Deciding on the Optimal Level of Consumption
Consumer Surplus is the difference between willingness to pay and what the consumer actually has to pay: CS = MU โ P. Total consumer surplus is the area between the MU curve and the horizontal market price line. As price increases, consumer surplus shrinks, and vice versa.
The optimal point of consumption is where consumer surplus becomes zero. If marginal utility is greater than price, consumption will increase causing MU to fall until it equals price, and vice versa.
There are 3 points regarding marginal utility and price:
- Consumer will consume additional units until MU = P
- If MU > P then consumer will increase consumption, increasing consumption causes MU to fall and MU will become equal to the price
- If MU < P then consumer will decrease consumption, decreasing consumption causes MU to rise and MU will become equal to the price
The Equi-Marginal Principle
In the case of more than two goods, optimum consumption can be arrived at using the equi-marginal principle. This states that a person will derive a maximum level of total utility from consuming a particular bundle of goods when the utility derived from the last dollar spent on each good is the same:
๐ Formula: MUโ / Pโ = MUแตฆ / Pแตฆ = MUโ / Pโ = ...
โญ Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts from this lecture are: (1) Rational choice focuses on weighing marginal costs against marginal benefits rather than total costs and benefits. (2) The law of diminishing marginal utility states that as consumption of a good increases, the additional satisfaction from each extra unit decreasesโthis is why demand curves slope downward. (3) The optimal consumption point for a single good occurs where MU = P and consumer surplus is zero. (4) For multiple goods, the equi-marginal principle requires that the marginal utility per dollar spent be equal across all goods. (5) Rationality is an ex-ante concept based on decision-making processes, not actual outcomes.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
- Why is rationality considered an "ex-ante" concept rather than judged by outcomes?
- As consumption of a good increases, what happens to total utility and marginal utility, and at what point does total utility reach its maximum?
- If a consumer finds that MU > P for a good, should they increase or decrease consumption? Why?
- What does the equi-marginal principle state about the allocation of spending across different goods?
- How can marginal utility be derived mathematically from a total utility function?
๐ Lecture 10 โ Consumer Behavior: Consumption Side Analysis (Continued)
๐ Overview: This lecture continues the analysis of consumer behavior by examining the supply side and demand side views on the value of goods, using the diamond-water paradox as a central example. It then introduces the concepts of uncertainty and risk in consumption decisions, explaining how different attitudes toward risk (averse, loving, neutral) affect consumer behavior, and concludes with risk hedging strategies.
๐๏ธ Topics Covered
The lecture covers two main themes: first, the historical debate between supply-side and demand-side theories of value, illustrated through the diamond-water paradox that challenged classical economists; second, the role of uncertainty in consumer decision-making, including definitions of risk, odds ratios, consumer risk profiles (risk averse, risk loving, risk neutral), and risk hedging mechanisms such as insuranceโincluding problems like adverse selection and moral hazard.
๐ Lecture Summary
SUPPLY SIDE AND DEMAND SIDE VIEWS ON THE VALUE OF GOOD
According to the supply side view on the value of a good, the value of a good was determined by the labor content that had gone into producing that good, either directly or indirectly. Economists like Ricardo and Karl Marx focused on this supply-side perspective, arguing that any good produced has a value equal to the labor used in its production. For example, if workers work 8 hours a day to produce bicycles, then their time multiplied is the value of that bicycle.
According to the demand side view on the value of a good, the value of a good was determined by its marginal utility. Adam Smith focused on this demand-side perspective. This helped solve the diamond-water paradox, i.e., why diamonds have such a high price while water (much more essential for life) sells so cheaply.
SUPPLY SIDE AND DEMAND SIDE: DIAMOND WATER PARADOX
Economists like Ricardo and Karl Marx focused on the supply side of economics. In their opinion, any good produced has a value equal to the labor content used in its production. For example, if workers are working 8 hours a day to produce bicycles then their time multiplied is the value of that bicycle. This is labor content.
On the other hand, economists like Adam Smith focused on the demand side of economics. They faced a paradox of diamond and water. They found that water and diamonds are very different in value. Water is an extremely used thing while diamonds are not much used. The price of diamond is very high while the price of water is very low. Since water is used widely so its marginal utility is very low. And diamonds are used very rarely so its marginal utility is very high.
On the supply side, water is abundant so has low value and diamond is scarce so has very high value.
The "law" of diminishing marginal utility is said to explain the "paradox of water and diamonds". Human beings cannot even survive without water, whereas diamonds were mere ornamentation. Yet water had a very small price, and diamonds a very large price. Marginalists explained that it is the marginal usefulness of any given quantity that matters, rather than the usefulness of a class or of a totality. For most people, water was sufficiently abundant that the loss or gain of a gallon would withdraw or add only some very minor use; whereas diamonds were in much more restricted supply, so that the lost or gained use were much greater.
That is not to say that the price of any good or service is simply a function of the marginal utility that it has for any one individual. Rather, individuals are willing to trade based upon the respective marginal utilities of the goods that they have or desire (with these marginal utilities being distinct for each potential trader), and prices thus develop constrained by these marginal utilities.
๐ก Why this matters: The diamond-water paradox resolution is fundamental to understanding why essential goods (like water) can be cheap while luxury goods (like diamonds) are expensiveโit's about marginal utility and scarcity, not overall usefulness.
UNCERTAINTY IN THE CONSUMPTION DECISION ANALYSIS
Uncertainty is the possibility that any number of things could happen in the future. In other words, the future is not known. The problem of uncertainty is integral to consumption decisions especially in the matter of purchasing durable goods. Uncertainty means assigning probabilities to the outcomes.
A consumer's response to uncertainty depends upon her attitude to risk: whether she is: a. Risk averse b. Risk-loving c. Risk neutral
RISK
Risk means to take a chance after the probabilities have been assigned. Risk is the possibility of gain or loss. Risk, the calculated probability of different events happening, is usually contrasted with uncertainty (the possibility that any number of things could happen).
For example, uncertainty is the possibility that you could win or lose $100 on the flip of a coin. You don't know which will happen; it could go either way. Risk, in contrast, is the 50 percent chance of winning $100 and the 50 percent chance of losing $100 on the flip of the coin. You know that your probability of winning or losing is 50 percent because the coin has a 50 percent chance of coming up either heads or tails.
The odds ratio (OR) is the ratio of the probability of success to the probability of failure. It can be equal to 1, less than 1, or greater than 1. If it is equal to 1 we call it fair odds, if less than 1 unfavorable odds, and if greater than 1 favorable odds.
๐ Definition โ Odds Ratio (OR): The ratio of the probability of success to the probability of failure. OR = P(success) / P(failure)
A risk neutral person is one who buys a good when OR > 1. He is indifferent when OR = 1 and will not buy when OR < 1.
A risk averse person will not buy if OR < 1. He will also not buy if OR = 1. He might also not decide to buy if OR > 1.
A risk loving person will buy if OR > 1 or = 1, but he might also buy when OR is < 1.
The degree of risk aversion increases as your income level falls, due to diminishing marginal utility of income. Risk aversion is a common feature of rational utility maximizing behavior by the average consumer.
๐ Example: If chances of winning = 50%, chances of losing = 50%. You toss a coin; if head comes, you are given Rs. 100 & if tail comes, you have to pay Rs. 100. Will you play this game or not? The answer is: if you are a risk averse person then you will not play this game because you consider the loss of Rs. 100 much more than the gain of Rs. 100. On the other hand, if you are a risk loving person then you will play this game.
The total utility curve for a risk neutral person will be a straight line, while it will be convex for a risk averse person. The greater the convexity (curvature), the more risk averse the person will be.
RISK HEDGING
Risk hedging can be used to reduce the extent to which concerns about uncertainty affect our daily lives.
๐ Example: Insurance companies operate under the principle of the law of large numbers. An insurance company collects the premium from the people. They also diversify the risk.
In the presence of asymmetric information, an insurance company has to contend with the problems of:
- Adverse selection (people who want to buy insurance are also the most risky customers; an ex-ante problem)
- Moral hazard (once a person is insured his behavior might become more rash; an ex-post problem)
๐ Definition โ Adverse Selection: A problem that occurs before a transaction (ex-ante) where those most likely to buy insurance are also the most risky customers.
๐ Definition โ Moral Hazard: A problem that occurs after a transaction (ex-post) where, once a person is insured, his behavior might become more rash or careless.
โญ Key Takeaways
The diamond-water paradox is resolved by understanding that value depends on marginal utility and scarcity, not total usefulnessโwater has low marginal utility due to abundance while diamonds have high marginal utility due to scarcity. Risk and uncertainty are distinct concepts: uncertainty is unknown probabilities, while risk involves known probabilities (odds ratios). Consumers exhibit three risk attitudes: risk averse (avoid even fair odds), risk neutral (accept favorable odds, indifferent to fair odds), and risk loving (may accept unfavorable odds). Risk aversion increases as income falls due to diminishing marginal utility of income. Risk hedging (like insurance) reduces uncertainty but faces problems of asymmetric information including adverse selection (ex-ante) and moral hazard (ex-post), which insurers must manage through the law of large numbers and risk diversification.
๐ง Quick Revision Questions
-
What is the diamond-water paradox, and how does the concept of marginal utility resolve it?
-
What is the difference between risk and uncertainty? Provide an example of each.
-
How would a risk averse person, a risk neutral person, and a risk loving person each respond to a bet with odds ratio (OR) = 1?
-
What is the odds ratio (OR), and what do the values OR > 1, OR = 1, and OR < 1 indicate?
-
Explain the difference between adverse selection and moral hazard in the context of insurance markets.