π Lecture 28 β Examples of Myhill Nerode theorem, Quotient of a language, examples, Pseudo theorem: Quotient of a language is regular, prefixes of a language, example
π Overview: This lecture continues the application of the Myhill Nerode theorem by demonstrating how languages partition Ξ£* into distinct classes, proving regularity. It then introduces the concept of the quotient of two languages and examines a pseudo theorem claiming the quotient of regular languages is regular, providing a counterexample. Finally, the lecture defines and illustrates the prefixes of a language in another language.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers detailed examples of the Myhill Nerode theorem for the EVEN-EVEN language and a language ending in ab or ba, illustrating how partitions of Ξ£* lead to Finite Automata. It then defines the quotient of a language into another, introduces and disproves a pseudo theorem about the regularity of the quotient, and concludes with the definition and example of prefixes of a language in another language.
π Lecture Summary
Example
Consider the language L which is EVEN-EVEN, defined over Ξ£ = {a,b}. It can be observed that L partitions Ξ£* into the following four classes: C1 = set of all strings with even number of aβs and odd number of bβs. C2 = set of all strings with odd number of aβs and odd number of bβs. C3 = set of all strings with odd number of aβs and even number of bβs. C4 = set of all strings with even number of aβs and even number of bβs.
Since there are finite many classes generated by L, so L is regular and hence following is an FA, built with the help of C1, C2, C3 and C4, accepting L.
[An FA diagram is provided in the original text with states c1, c2, c3, c4 and transitions labeled a and b.]
Example
Consider the language L = {w β {a,b}: length(w) β₯ 2, w ends in either ab or ba}. It can be observed that L partitions Ξ£ into the following seven classes: C1 = set containing only null string. C2 = set containing only letter a. C3 = set containing only letter b. C4 = set of strings ending in aa. C5 = set of strings ending in ab. C6 = set of strings ending in ba. C7 = set of strings ending in bb.
Since there are finite many classes generated by L, so L is regular and hence the FA shown aside, is built with the help of C1, C2, C3, C4, C5, C6 and C7, accepting L.
Following is an FA equivalent to the above FA:
[An FA diagram is provided in the original text with states 1-, 2+, 3, 4+, 5+ and transitions labeled a and b.]
Note: It can be noted, from the above two FAs accepting the same language, that if the language L, partitions Ξ£* into n distinct classes, then L may partition Ξ£* into finite many distinct classes other than n.
Quotient of a language into another
Remark: The theorem has been proved to show under what conditions a language is regular. It has also been proved that the product of two regular languages is regular. The question arises that whether there exists a theorem showing that quotient of regular languages is regular.
There is a problem in defining the quotient of two regular languages. There is an approach in defining the quotient of regular languages i.e. the language Q is said to be quotient of two regular languages P and R, denoted by Q=R/P if PQ=R. It is to be noted that this definition does not determine a unique language e.g. for P=Q=R expressed by a* then PQ=R and so Q=R/P i.e. a*=a* / a*. But for Q={Ξ}, P=R expressed by a*, PQ=R is still true which shows that Q={Ξ}=R/P expressed by a* / a*.
Similarly, for the same P and R, Q may be taken as {Ξ},{a},{aaaa},{aaaaaaaa}, ... Thus there exist infinite many choices for defining the quotient language in this case of one-letter alphabet.
Pseudo theorem
Statement: For three languages P,Q and R, while PQ=R the language Q must be regular if both P and R are regular. (Note: It is to be noted that since this theorem is not true, so the theorem is called pseudo theorem.)
Disproof: The theorem can be disproved by contradiction i.e. supposing that Q is regular.
Let P=a*, Q be the product of {aβΏbβΏ:n=0,1,2,...} and b* then PQ=a*{aβΏbβΏ}b*=ab=R which shows that R is regular. To disproof this theorem, it is sufficient to prove that Q is not regular. By definition, the words in Q are of the form aΛ£bΚΈ where x β€ y. Let Q be regular and hence there exists an FA that accepts Q. Suppose the number of states in this machine be N. Now the word aα΄Ίbα΄Ί is also in Q and must be accepted by this FA.
Since the number of states in this machine is N, there must be a circuit in this machine to run the substring aα΄Ί. Thus while accepting the word aα΄Ίbα΄Ί, the machine looping the circuit once again, can accept the word a^(more than N)bα΄Ί, which is not in Q. Hence it is impossible to find any FA that accepts exactly the language Q. Thus Q is not regular and hence the theorem is disproved.
π Definition β Pseudo Theorem: A statement that is claimed to be a theorem but is actually false; in this context, the false claim that for three languages P, Q, and R, if PQ=R and P and R are regular, then Q must be regular. π Logic of Disproof: Let P=a*, Q={aβΏbβΏ}b*, and R=ab. Since PQ=a*{aβΏbβΏ}b*=ab=R, R is regular. However, Q contains words of the form aΛ£bΚΈ with x β€ y, which is known to be non-regular (pumping lemma). Therefore, the theorem is false. π‘ Why this matters: This pseudo theorem demonstrates a critical pitfall in automata theory: the quotient of two regular languages is not necessarily regular, contradicting a plausible but incorrect assumption.
Prefixes of a language in another language
If two languages R and Q are given, then the language the prefixes of Q in R denoted by Pref(Q in R) is the set of strings of letters that, when concatenated to the front of some word in Q to produce some word in R i.e. Pref(Q in R) = the set of all strings p such that there exists words q in Q and w in R such that pq = w.
Following are the examples in this regard:
Example: Let Q = {aa,abaaabb,bbaaaaa,bbbbbbbbbb} and R = {b,bbbb,bbbaaa,bbbaaaaa}. It can be observed that aa and bbaaaaa occur at the ending parts of some words of R, hence these words help in defining the language pref(Q in R). Thus pref(Q in R) = {b,bbba,bbbaaa}.
Note: The language of prefixes may be consisting of word L, while there is also a possibility that this language may not contain any string (even not the null string).
π Definition β Pref(Q in R) (prefixes of Q in R): The set of all strings p such that there exist words q in Q and w in R where pq = w. In other words, p is a string that, when appended to the front of some word from Q, produces a word from R. π Example: Given Q={aa, abaaabb, bbaaaaa, bbbbbbbbbb} and R={b, bbbb, bbbaaa, bbbaaaaa}, we find:
- b (from R) can be formed by p=b and q=Ξ (null string) if Ξ were in Q, but more directly, p=bbba and q=-aa? Actually, the example states: "aa and bbaaaaa occur at the ending parts of some words of R". For word "bbbaaa" in R, we see p=bbba and q=aa producing bbbaaa. For word "bbbaaaaa", we see p=bbba and q=aaaa? No, the example states pref(Q in R) = {b, bbba, bbbaaa}. So p=b may come from p=b and q=bbbb (if bbbbb were in Qβwait, the example needs careful parsing). The core idea is: pref(Q in R) = the strings that are prefixes of R that, when followed by a word from Q, give R. The answer is {b, bbba, bbbaaa}.
β Key Takeaways
The Myhill Nerode theorem provides a powerful method to prove regularity by showing a language partitions Ξ£* into a finite number of equivalence classes, which directly corresponds to the number of states in a minimal FA. The quotient of two languages, defined as Q=R/P when PQ=R, is problematic because it does not yield a unique language, and a natural-sounding theorem claiming the quotient of regular languages is regular is actually a pseudo theorem, as demonstrated by a counterexample using the non-regular language {aβΏbβΏ}. The concept of prefixes of a language in another language, Pref(Q in R), isolates the set of strings that can serve as a prefix to a word in Q to form a word in R, which is a useful linguistic operation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- For the EVEN-EVEN language, how many equivalence classes does the Myhill Nerode theorem produce over Ξ£={a,b}, and what characterizes each class?
- In the example of the language ending in ab or ba, why does the partition of Ξ£* into 7 classes prove the language is regular, and how does the number of classes relate to the FA states?
- Why is the definition of quotient Q=R/P not unique, and what does this ambiguity imply for the pseudo theorem about regularity?
- Describe the exact counterexample used to disprove the pseudo theorem: what are P, Q, and R, and how does the pumping lemma for regular languages show Q is not regular?
- Given languages Q and R, how is Pref(Q in R) defined, and what does the set {b, bbba, bbbaaa} from the example tell us about the relationship between Q and R?
π Lecture 29 β Theory of Automata
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of prefixes of a language relative to another language, proving that pref(Q in R) is regular when R is regular. It then introduces decidability, decision procedures, and methods for determining whether two regular languages are equivalent or whether a given FA accepts any words.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an example of prefixes of a language (pref(Q in R)), followed by a theorem proving that pref(Q in R) is regular if R is regular, with a proof and example. It then covers decidability, effectively solvable problems, and decision procedures. The lecture concludes with two methods for determining whether two languages are regular and equivalent, including examples and a method to test whether an FA accepts any words.
π Lecture Summary
Example of prefixes of a language
Let Q and R be expressed by ab*a and (ba)* respectively, i.e. Q = {aa, aba, abba, ...} and R = {Ξ, ba, baba, bababa, ...}. aba is the only word in Q which can make a word in R, because the words in R don't contain the double letter. Thus pref(Q in R) = {b, bab, babab, ...}, which can be expressed by b(ab)* or *(ba)b.
π‘ Why this matters: The language R cannot be factorized with the help of language Pref(Q in R) i.e. Pref(Q in R)Q is not equal to R in general. However, the following theorem shows that the language pref(Q in R) is regular if R is regular, no matter whether the language Q is regular or not.
Theorem: pref(Q in R) is regular
Statement: If R is regular language and Q is any language (regular/nonregular), then Pref(Q in R) is regular.
Proof: Since R is regular, there exists an FA that accepts this language. Choose a state, say, s of this FA and see whether this state can trace out a path ending up in a final state while running words from Q. If this state traces out a path ending up in a final state for any of the words of Q, mark this state with certain colour. Repeat this process for remaining states of the machine. If at least one state of this machine is marked then it can be shown that the language Pref(Q in R) is non-empty. Now build a new FA with some marked states by considering the initial state that of original FA and final states which are marked. The machine, thus obtained accepts exactly the language Pref(Q in R). Thus Pref(Q in R) being accepted by an FA is regular.
Remark: There is a problem in deciding whether a state of FA should be marked or not when the language Q is infinite. This proof just gives non-constructive method to prove that Pref(Q in R) is regular.
Example of the theorem
Consider the languages Q = {aba, abb} and R = {w β {a,b}* : length(w) β₯ 2, w ends in either ab or ba}, where R may be accepted by the following FA:
[FA diagram with states 1β (initial), 2, 3, 4+, 5+ connected by edges labeled a and b]
It can be observed that the string aba from Q makes the words of R and hence the states 1, 2, 3, 4 and 5 can easily be marked. Thus from the given FA, making the states 1, 2 and 3 to be final as well, the resulting FA will accept the language pref(Q in R). Moreover it can be observed that pref(Q in R) can be expressed by (a+b)*, which is the RE corresponding to the resulting FA as well.
Decidability
Effectively solvable problem: A problem is said to be effectively solvable if there exists an algorithm that provides the solution in finite number of steps e.g. finding solution for quadratic equation is effectively solvable problem, because the quadratic formula provides an algorithm that determines the solution in a finite number of arithmetic operations, (four multiplications, two subtractions, one square root and one division).
π Definition β Decision procedure: If an effectively solvable problem has answer in yes or no, then this solution is called decision procedure.
π Definition β Decidable problem: A problem that has decision procedure is called decidable problem e.g. the following problems:
- The two regular expressions define the same language
- The two FAs are equivalent
Determining whether the two languages are equivalent or not
If Lβ and Lβ are two regular languages, then they can be expressed by FAs. As shown earlier, LβαΆ, LβαΆ, Lβ βͺ Lβ, Lβ β© Lβ are regular languages and the methods have already been developed to build their corresponding FAs. It can be observed that (Lβ β© LβαΆ) βͺ (LβαΆ β© Lβ) is regular language that accepts the words which are in Lβ but not in Lβ or else in Lβ but not in Lβ. The corresponding FA cannot accept any word which is in both Lβ and Lβ i.e. if Lβ and Lβ are equivalent, then this FA accepts not even null string.
Method 1 for testing equivalence
For FA corresponding to (Lβ β© LβαΆ) βͺ (LβαΆ β© Lβ), the regular expression can be determined that defines the language accepted by this FA. From that regular expression one can determine whether this regular expression defines any word or not. Following are the steps to be followed:
- Remove all *s from the regular expression
- Separate the right part of + and the plus itself
The regular expression thus obtained if contains at least one word then the language is not empty otherwise the language is empty.
Example: For (a+Ξ)(ab+ba)(a+Ξ)** to be the regular expression of (Lβ β© LβαΆ) βͺ (LβαΆ β© Lβ), it is required to find whether this language accepts any string or not?
After removing all *s the RE will be (a+Ξ)(ab+ba)(a+Ξ). After separating the right part from + and the + itself the RE will be aaba. As this language contains at least aaba as its word, so this language is not empty.
Remark: Sometimes, while determining regular expression for a given FA, it is impossible to write its regular expression e.g. FAβ, FAβ, FAβ [diagrams shown].
Method 2 for testing whether FA accepts any words
To examine whether a certain FA accepts any words, it is required to seek the paths from initial to final state. But in large FA with thousands of states and millions of directed edges, without an effective procedure it is impossible to find a path from initial to final state. Following are the steps of this procedure:
- Mark the initial state
- For every marked state, follow each edge that leads out of it and mark the concatenating states and delete these edges
- Repeat step 2 until no new state is marked
- If any of the final states are marked then the FA accepts some word, otherwise not
Example: Suppose it is required to test the FA [diagram with states 1β, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6+, edges labeled a and b], whether it accepts any string or not? Applying method 2:
[Step-by-step application of method 2 shown on the FA diagram]
This FA accepts no string as after applying method 2, the final state (6+) is not marked.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical points to remember are: (1) Pref(Q in R) is regular whenever R is regular, regardless of whether Q is regular or not β this is proven by marking states in the FA for R that can trace paths to final states using words from Q. (2) A decidable problem has a decision procedure (yes/no answer) that can be completed in finite steps. (3) To determine if two regular languages Lβ and Lβ are equivalent, construct an FA for (Lβ β© LβαΆ) βͺ (LβαΆ β© Lβ) and test whether it accepts any words β if it accepts no words (not even null), the languages are equivalent. (4) Method 1 for testing emptiness involves removing *s and + from the regular expression and checking if any word remains. (5) Method 2 for testing whether an FA accepts any words involves marking the initial state, following edges to mark new states while deleting used edges, and checking if any final state gets marked β if not, the FA accepts no words.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the language Pref(Q in R)? Give an example where Q = {aba, abb} and R = words ending in ab or ba with length β₯ 2.
- State and prove the theorem that Pref(Q in R) is regular when R is regular.
- What is the difference between an effectively solvable problem and a decidable problem? Give one example of each.
- Describe Method 1 for determining whether two regular languages Lβ and Lβ are equivalent. What does the regular expression (a+Ξ)(ab+ba)(a*+Ξ)* become after removing *s and +?
- Describe Method 2 for testing whether an FA accepts any words. Explain why the final state must be marked for the FA to accept any string.
π Lecture 30 β Deciding Equivalence of Languages, Acceptance, and Finiteness
π Overview: This lecture covers procedures for deciding whether two regular languages are equivalent, whether a finite automaton accepts any string, and whether a language is finite or infinite. These are fundamental decision problems in automata theory with practical applications in compiler design and verification.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers deciding whether two languages are equivalent using a complement-intersection method with detailed examples, determining whether an FA accepts any string using three different methods including marking states and testing words of length less than N, and deciding finiteness of a regular language using the pumping lemma theorem relating to word lengths between N and 2N.
π Lecture Summary
Example (Equivalence of Languages)
Consider two languages Lβ and Lβ expressed by the regular expressions rβ = a* and rβ = Ξ + aa* respectively. To determine whether Lβ and Lβ are equivalent, we construct FAs for the languages and then find the FA corresponding to (Lβ β© LβαΆ) βͺ (LβαΆ β© Lβ). If this FA accepts any word, then Lβ and Lβ are not equivalent; otherwise they are equivalent.
Following are the FAs corresponding to LβαΆ and LβαΆ:
- FAβαΆ: starts at sβ-, goes to sβ+ on a, sβ on b
- FAβαΆ: starts at sβ-, goes to sβ on a, sβ on b
FAs corresponding to (FAβαΆ β© FAβ)αΆ and (FAβαΆ β© FAβ)αΆ are then constructed:
- (FAβαΆ β© FAβ)αΆ: states (qβ,rβ), (qβ,rβ)-, (qβ,rβ) with transitions on a and b
- (FAβαΆ β© FAβ)αΆ: states (pβ,sβ), (pβ,sβ)-, (pβ,sβ) with transitions on a and b
Both FAs have no final state, so they accept nothing. This implies their union will also not accept any string. Hence the FA corresponding to (Lβ β© LβαΆ) βͺ (LβαΆ β© Lβ) accepts nothing. Thus both languages are equivalent.
Example (Deciding if FA Accepts Any String)
Another example shows an FA for which we decide whether it accepts any string using method 2 (marking states). The process involves marking the start state, then iteratively marking states reachable from marked states via input strings. Since no final state of the FA is marked, the given FA accepts no word.
π Definition β Effective Procedure: A method that is guaranteed to produce a correct answer in finite time for any input of a given class.
Method 3
If the FA has N states, then test the words of length less than N. If no word is accepted by this FA, then it will accept no word.
π Formula: Test all strings of length < N states β If none accepted, language is empty.
π‘ Why this matters: This provides a guaranteed finite procedure to check emptiness of a regular language.
Example (Method 3)
To determine whether the following FA accepts certain word, using method 3, all strings of length less than 4 (i.e. less than the number of states of the FA) are sufficient to be tested.
The strings to test: Ξ, a, b, aa, ab, ba, bb, aaa, aab, aba, abb, baa, bab, bba, bbb
It can be observed that the strings aa, baa, aaa are accepted by this FA, hence the language accepted by this FA is not empty.
Example (Empty Language via Method 3)
Consider another FA. To determine whether this FA accepts some word, all strings of length less than 4 are to be tested.
It can be observed that none of the strings Ξ, a, b, aa, ab, ba, bb, aaa, aab, aba, abb, baa, bab, bba, bbb is accepted by this FA. Thus the given FA cannot accept any word.
Observation (Infinite Language)
To find whether a regular expression defines an infinite language or not, the following possibilities are required to be checked. If a regular expression contains * then it may define an infinite language, with the exception Ξ* as Ξ* = Ξ. For example: (Ξ + aΞ*)(Ξ* + Ξ)* defines a finite language, while (Ξ* + aΞ*)(Ξ + Ξ)* defines an infinite language.
Theorem
Let F be an FA having N states.
- If F accepts a word w such that N β€ length(w) < 2N, then F accepts infinite language.
- If F accepts an infinite language, then there are some words w such that N β€ length(w) < 2N.
The first part can be proved using the pumping lemma version II.
π Formula: Number of strings to test = m^N + m^(N+1) + m^(N+2) + ... + m^(2N-1), where m = alphabet size
π Example: For machine of 3 states and alphabet of 2 letters, 2Β³ + 2β΄ + 2β΅ = 56 strings are to be tested.
β Key Takeaways
The most critical concepts to remember are: two languages are equivalent if their symmetric difference accepts no words, which can be checked using complement-intersection construction. To determine if an FA accepts any string, you can use the marking method or test all strings of length less than the number of states β if none are accepted, the language is empty. The finiteness of a regular language can be decided by testing all words of length between N and 2N-1 (inclusive) β if any such word is accepted, the language is infinite. A regular expression containing * may define an infinite language, but with exceptions like Ξ*. All these methods are effective procedures guaranteed to terminate in finite time.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- How do you construct an FA to test whether two regular languages Lβ and Lβ are equivalent?
- If an FA has 5 states, what is the maximum length of strings that need to be tested to decide if it accepts any word (using method 3)?
- What condition on word length determines whether a language accepted by an FA with N states is infinite?
- Give an example of a regular expression containing * that defines a finite language.
- How many strings must be tested for an FA with 4 states over an alphabet of 3 letters to decide finiteness?
π Lecture 31 β Context Free Grammar, Terminals, Non-Terminals, Productions, CFG, Context Free Language, Examples
π Overview: This lecture introduces context free grammar (CFG) as a formal method for defining programming languages, explaining the difference between syntactic and semantic rules. It defines the core components β terminals, non-terminals, and productions β and illustrates how CFGs generate context free languages through multiple examples.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the historical need for CFGs in compiler design, the distinction between semantics and syntactics, CFG terminologies (terminals, non-terminals, productions), the formal definition of CFG, and context free language (CFL) with several examples showing how different grammars can generate the same language (a* and (a+b)*).
π Lecture Summary
Context Free Grammar (CFG)
The earliest computers accepted only assembly language instructions (LOAD, STORE, ADD). A major problem was displaying mathematical formulas like S = (1/2+9)/(4+8/21+5/(3+1/2)) in one line using standard typewriter symbols, requiring parentheses such as ((1/2)+9)/(4+(8/21)+(5/(3+(1/2)))). This led to high-level languages, which are converted into assembly language by a program called a compiler. The compiler takes user programs as input and prints an equivalent assembly language program.
Like spoken languages, high-level computer languages have grammar. The grammatical rules that involve word meaning are called Semantics, while rules that do not involve meaning are called Syntactics. For example, in English "Buildings sing" is invalid due to semantics, but in computer language one number is as good as another (e.g., X = B + 10 or X = B + 999).
π‘ Why this matters: In general, computer language grammar rules are all syntactic and not semantic. A law of grammar is in reality a suggestion for possible substitutions.
CFG terminologies
Terminals: The symbols that canβt be replaced by anything are called terminals.
Non-Terminals: The symbols that must be replaced by other things are called non-terminals.
Productions: The grammatical rules are often called productions.
CFG
CFG is a collection of the following:
- An alphabet Ξ£ of letters called terminals from which the strings are formed, that will be the words of the language.
- A set of symbols called non-terminals, one of which is S, stands for "start here".
- A finite set of productions of the form: non-terminal β finite string of terminals and/or non-terminals.
π Definition β Terminals: designated by small letters; Non-terminals: designated by capital letters.
π Note: There is at least one production that has the non-terminal S as its left side.
Context Free Language (CFL)
The language generated by CFG is called Context Free Language (CFL).
Example β a using S β aS, S β Ξ* Ξ£ = {a} Productions: S β aS, S β Ξ
Applying production (1) six times and then production (2) once, the word aaaaaa is generated as: S β aS β aaS β aaaS β aaaaS β aaaaaS β aaaaaaS β aaaaaaΞ = aaaaaa
It can be observed that production (2) generates Ξ, a can be generated applying production (1) once then production (2), aa by applying production (1) twice then production (2), and so on. This shows the grammar defines the language expressed by a*.
Example β a using S β SS, S β a, S β Ξ* Ξ£ = {a} Productions: S β SS, S β a, S β Ξ
This grammar also defines the language expressed by a*.
π Definition β Ξ (lambda): Ξ is not considered to be terminal. It has a special status. If for a certain non-terminal N, there may be a production N β Ξ, this simply means that N can be deleted when it comes in the working string.
Example β (a+b) using X, Y approach* Ξ£ = {a,b} Productions: S β X, S β Y, X β Ξ, Y β aY, Y β bY, Y β a, Y β b
All words of this language are of either X-type or Y-type. i.e., while generating a word the first production used is S β X or S β Y. The words of X-type give only Ξ, while the words of Y-type are words of finite strings of aβs or bβs or both i.e. (a+b)βΊ. Thus the language defined is expressed by (a+b)*.
Example β (a+b) using direct productions* Ξ£ = {a,b} Productions: S β aS, S β bS, S β a, S β b, S β Ξ
This grammar also defines the language expressed by (a+b)*.
Example β (a+b)aa(a+b) Ξ£ = {a,b} Productions: S β XaaX, X β aX, X β bX, X β Ξ
This grammar defines the language expressed by (a+b)aa(a+b).
β Key Takeaways
CFG consists of terminals (symbols that cannot be replaced), non-terminals (symbols that must be replaced, with S as the start), and productions (rules of the form non-terminal β string of terminals/non-terminals). The language generated by a CFG is called a Context Free Language (CFL). Ξ has a special status as a non-terminal that can be deleted from the working string, and different CFG productions can generate the same language (e.g., multiple grammars for a* and (a+b)*). Remember that terminals are designated by small letters and non-terminals by capital letters, and at least one production must have S on the left side.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three essential components of a Context Free Grammar?
- How is Ξ different from a terminal symbol in CFG?
- Show two different CFGs that both generate the language a*.
- What is the distinction between semantics and syntactics in computer language grammar?
- What language does the CFG with productions S β XaaX, X β aX, X β bX, X β Ξ generate?
π Lecture 32 β Examples of CFL, EVEN-EVEN, EQUAL, Language of strings containing bbb, PALINDROME, {a^n b^n}, Language of strings beginning and ending in different letters, Parsing tree, example
π Overview: This lecture provides multiple detailed examples of Context-Free Grammars (CFGs) for various important languages, including EVEN-EVEN, EQUAL, strings containing bbb, PALINDROME, {a^n b^n}, and strings beginning and ending in different letters. It also introduces the concept of the parse tree (or derivation tree) as a visual representation of how a word is generated by a grammar, which is critical for understanding syntax analysis.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture presents and analyzes six distinct CFG examples: the EVEN-EVEN language, the EQUAL language, the language of strings containing bbb, PALINDROME, the language {a^n b^n}, and the language of strings beginning and ending in different letters. The final topic introduces the construction and purpose of a parsing tree (syntax/derivation tree) using the word "baab".
π Lecture Summary
Examples of CFL, EVEN-EVEN, EQUAL, Language of strings containing bbb, PALINDROME, {a^n b^n}, Language of strings beginning and ending in different letters, Parsing tree, example
Example
Ξ£ = {a,b} productions: S β SS S β XS S β Ξ S β YSY X β aa X β bb Y β ab Y β ba This grammar generates the EVEN-EVEN language.
Example
Ξ£ = {a,b} productions: S β aB S β bA A β a A β aS A β bAA B β b B β bS B β aBB This grammar generates the language EQUAL (the language of strings, with number of aβs equal to number of bβs).
Note
It is to be noted that if the same non-terminal has more than one production, it can be written in a single line e.g. S β aS, S β bS, S β Ξ can be written as S β aS|bS|Ξ. It may also be noted that the productions S β SS|Ξ always defines the language which is closed w.r.t. concatenation i.e. the language expressed by RE of type r*. It may also be noted that the production S β SS defines the language expressed by r^+.
Example
Ξ£ = {a,b} productions: S β YXY Y β aY|bY|Ξ X β bbb It can be observed that, using prod.2, Y generates Ξ. Y generates a. Y generates b. Y also generates all the combinations of a and b. Thus Y generates the strings generated by (a+b)*. It may also be observed that the above CFG generates the language expressed by (a+b)*bbb(a+b)*. Following are four words generated by the given CFG
S β YXY β aYbbbΞ β abYbbb β abΞbbb = abbbb
S β YXY β bYbbbaY β bΞbbbabY β bbbbabbY β bbbbabbaY β bbbbabbaΞ = bbbbabba
S β YXY β ΞbbbaY β bbbabY β bbbabaY β bbbabaΞ = bbbaba
S β YXY β bYbbbaY β bΞbbbaΞ = bbbba
Example
Consider the following CFG S β SS|XaXaX|Ξ X β bX|Ξ It can be observed that, using prod.2, X generates Ξ. X generates any number of bβs. Thus X generates the strings generated by b*. It may also be observed that the above CFG generates the language expressed by (b*ab*ab*)*.
Example
Consider the following CFG Ξ£ = {a,b} productions: S β aSa|bSb|a|b|Ξ The above CFG generates the language PALINDROME. It may be noted that the CFG S β aSa|bSb|a|b generates the language NON-NULLPALINDROME.
Example
Consider the following CFG Ξ£ = {a,b} productions: S β aSb|ab|Ξ It can be observed that the CFG generates the language {a^n b^n : n = 0,1,2,3, ...}. It may also be noted that the language {a^n b^n : n=1,2,3, ...} can be generated by the CFG, S β aSb|ab
Example
Consider the following CFG S β aXb|bXa X β aX|bX|Ξ The above CFG generates the language of strings, defined over Ξ£={a,b}, beginning and ending in different letters.
Trees
As in English language any sentence can be expressed by parse tree, so any word generated by the given CFG can also be expressed by the parse tree, e.g. consider the following CFG S β AA A β AAA|bA|Ab|a Obviously, baab can be generated by the above CFG. To express the word baab as a parse tree, start with S. Replace S by the string AA, of nonterminals, drawing the downward lines from S to each character of this string as follows
S
|
A A
Now let the left A be replaced by bA and the right one by Ab then the tree will be
S
/ \
A A
| |
b A A b
Replacing both Aβs by a, the above tree will be
S
/ \
A A
/ \ / \
b A A b
| |
a a
Thus the word baab is generated. The above tree to generate the word baab is called Syntax tree or Generation tree or Derivation tree as well.
π Definition β Parse Tree (also Syntax tree, Generation tree, or Derivation tree): A tree structure used to represent the derivation of a string (a word) from a Context-Free Grammar. The root is the start symbol (S), internal nodes are non-terminals, and leaves are terminals (the symbols in the final string).
β Key Takeaways
- Context-Free Grammars are a powerful tool for defining languages, and a single grammar can often be constructed for languages with specific constraints like EVEN-EVEN, EQUAL, PALINDROME, and {a^n b^n}.
- The production S β SS|Ξ is a key construct that defines a language closed under concatenation, which is fundamental to generating languages expressed by r*.
- A non-terminal (like Y or X in examples) that generates (a+b)* or b* is often used as a "filler" to add any number of symbols on either side of a specific pattern (e.g., bbb).
- A parse tree (or derivation tree) provides a visual, hierarchical representation of the derivation of a word, showing how the start symbol is replaced by non-terminals and finally terminals.
- The same CFG can generate different languages; the inclusion or exclusion of a production like Ξ critically changes the set of strings generated (e.g., {a^n b^n} with or without n=0).
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the role of a non-terminal in a context-free grammar?
- Write a CFG that generates the language {a^n b^n : n >= 0}.
- What is the primary difference between a derivation and a parse tree?
- How does the production S β SS influence the language generated by a grammar?
- Considering the CFG for PALINDROME (S β aSa|bSb|a|b|Ξ), what modification is needed to generate only NON-NULLPALINDROME?
π Lecture 33 β Reading Material
π Overview: This lecture explores the concept of ambiguity in Context-Free Grammars (CFGs), demonstrating how ambiguous grammars can generate the same word through different derivation trees. It introduces Polish Notation (prefix notation) as an alternative representation for arithmetic expressions and shows how certain CFGs can be redesigned to eliminate ambiguity.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with an example of an ambiguous CFG for arithmetic expressions, showing two different derivation trees for the expression 3+4*5. It then demonstrates how ambiguity can be removed by modifying the grammar. Polish Notation (prefix notation) is introduced as an operator prefix notation for arithmetic expressions, with examples of evaluating prefix expressions. The lecture concludes with a formal definition of ambiguous CFGs and additional examples.
π Lecture Summary
Example
Consider the following CFG: S β S+S | SS | number where S and number are non-terminals and the operators behave like terminals. The above CFG creates ambiguity as the expression 3+45 has two possibilities: (3+4)5=35 and 3+(45)=23, which can be expressed by the following production trees:
Tree (i):
S
/|\
S + S
/| |\
3 S * S 5
| |
4 5
This evaluates to 3 + (4*5) = 3 + 20 = 23
Tree (ii):
S
/|\
S * S
/| |\
3 + 4 5
This evaluates to (3+4)5 = 75 = 35
The expressions can be calculated starting from bottom to the top, replacing each nonterminal by the result of calculation.
Example
S β (S+S) | (S*S) | number where S and number are nonterminals, while (, *, +, ) and the numbers are terminals.
Here it can be observed that: S β (S+S) β (S+(SS)) β (3+(45)) = 23 S β (S*S) β ((S+S)*S) β ((3+4)*5) = 35
Polish Notation (o-o-o)
There is another notation for arithmetic expressions for the CFG, SβS+S|S*S|number. Consider the following derivation trees:
Tree (i):
S
/|\
3 + S
/|\
4 * 5
Tree (ii):
S
/|\
S * 5
/|\
3 + 4
The arithmetic expressions shown by the trees (i) and (ii) can be calculated from the following trees, respectively:
Tree (i):
+
/ \
3 *
/ \
4 5
Tree (ii):
*
/ \
+ 5
/ \
3 4
Here most of the S's are eliminated. The branches are connected directly with the operators. Moreover, the operators + and * are no longer terminals as these are to be replaced by numbers (results).
To write the arithmetic expression, it is required to traverse from the left side of S and going onward around the tree. The arithmetic expressions will be as under:
(i) + 3 * 4 5 (ii) * + 3 4 5
The above notation is called operator prefix notation.
To evaluate the strings of characters, the first substring (from the left) of the form operator-operand-operand (o-o-o) is found and is replaced by its calculation e.g.
+3*4 5 = +3 20 = 23 *+3 4 5 = * 7 5 = 35
It may be noted that 4*5+3 is an infix arithmetic expression, while an arithmetic expression in (o-o-o) form is a prefix arithmetic expression.
π Definition β Infix arithmetic expression: An expression where operators are placed between operands (e.g., 45+3). π Definition β Prefix arithmetic expression (Polish Notation): An expression where operators precede their operands (e.g., +345). π Example: The prefix expression *+3 4 5 is evaluated by first finding the o-o-o substring "+3 4", evaluating it to 7, then evaluating "*7 5" to 35.
Example
To calculate the arithmetic expression of the following tree:
*
/ \
+ 6
/ \
* 5
/ \
+ +
/ \ / \
1 2 3 4
It can be written as: ++1 2+3 4 5 6
The above arithmetic expression in (o-o-o) form can be calculated as: ++1 2+3 4 5 6 = *+*3+3 4 5 6 = *+*3 7 5 6 = *+21 5 6 = *26 6 = 156
Note The previous prefix arithmetic expression can be converted into the following infix arithmetic expression as: ++1 2+3 4 5 6 = ++1 2 (3+4) 5 6 = +(1+2) (3+4) 5 6 = (((1+2)(3+4)) + 5) 6 = (((1+2)*(3+4)) + 5)*6
π‘ Why this matters: Polish Notation eliminates the need for parentheses and precedence rules in evaluation, as the order of operations is unambiguous from the prefix structure.
Ambiguous CFG
π Definition β Ambiguous CFG: The CFG is said to be ambiguous if there exists at least one word of its language that can be generated by different production trees.
Example: Consider the following CFG: S β aS | Sa | a
The word aaa can be generated by the following three different trees:
Tree 1:
S
/|\
a S
/|\
a S
|
a
Tree 2:
S
/|\
S a
/|\
S a
|
a
Tree 3:
S
/|\
S a
/|\
a S
|
a
Thus the above CFG is ambiguous, while the CFG, SβaS|a is not ambiguous as neither the word aaa nor any other word can be derived from more than one production trees. The derivation tree for aaa is as follows:
S
/|\
a S
/|\
a S
|
a
β Key Takeaways
Ambiguous CFGs allow a single word to be generated by multiple distinct derivation trees, which can lead to multiple interpretations β as seen with the arithmetic expression 3+4*5 having two possible evaluations (23 vs 35). Polish Notation (prefix o-o-o notation) provides an unambiguous way to represent arithmetic expressions by placing operators before their operands, eliminating the need for parentheses. A CFG can be made unambiguous by restructuring its production rules, such as adding parentheses to force a specific evaluation order. The evaluation of a prefix expression involves repeatedly finding and replacing the leftmost operator-operand-operand substring with its calculated result until a single number remains. Not all CFGs are ambiguous; for example, SβaS|a is unambiguous because every word has exactly one derivation tree.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is an ambiguous CFG, and how does it relate to derivation trees?
- Why is the CFG S β S+S | SS | number considered ambiguous for the expression 3+45?
- How does Polish Notation (prefix notation) represent arithmetic expressions differently from infix notation?
- Describe the step-by-step evaluation of the prefix expression ++1 2+3 4 5 6.
- Give an example of an unambiguous CFG and explain why it is not ambiguous.
π Lecture 34 β Theory of Automata
π Overview: This lecture explores the concepts of ambiguous and unambiguous grammars, introduces the total language tree as a visualization tool, and establishes the connection between regular grammars and finite automata. It provides methods for converting between regular grammars and transition graphs, which is essential for understanding language generation and recognition.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers examples of ambiguous and unambiguous grammars (including PALINDROME), the total language tree with finite and infinite tree examples, the definition and properties of regular grammar, the conversion from FA to CFG, the concepts of semiword and word, a theorem on regular grammar, and the method to build a TG for regular grammar.
π Lecture Summary
Example of Ambiguous Grammar
Consider the following CFG: S β aS | bS | aaS | ο. It can be observed that the word aaa can be derived from more than one production tree. Thus, the above CFG is ambiguous. This ambiguity can be removed by removing the production S β aaS.
Example of Unambiguous Grammar (PALINDROME)
Consider the CFG of the language PALINDROME: S β aSa | bSb | a | b | ο. It may be noted that this CFG is unambiguous as all the words of the language PALINDROME can only be generated by a unique production tree. It may be noted that if the production S β aaSaa is added to the given CFG, the CFG thus obtained will be no more unambiguous.
Total Language Tree
For a given CFG, a tree with the start symbol S as its root and whose nodes are working strings of terminals and non-terminals. The descendants of each node are all possible results of applying every production to the working string. This tree is called total language tree.
π Definition β Total Language Tree: A tree with the start symbol S as its root, where nodes are working strings, and descendants are all possible results of applying every production to the working string.
π Example: Consider the following CFG: S β aa | bX | aXX, X β ab | b. The total language tree shows S branching to "aa", "bX", and "aXX". From "bX", we get "bab" and "bb". From "aXX", we get strings like "aabab", "aabb", "abab", and "abb". Dropping repeated words, the language generated is {aa, bab, bb, aabab, aabb, abab, abb}.
π Example: Consider the CFG: S β X | b, X β aX. The total language tree shows S branching to X and b. From X, we get aX, then aaX, then aaaX... This tree is infinite. Note: The only word in this language is b.
Regular Grammar
All regular languages can be generated by CFGs. Some nonregular languages can be generated by CFGs but not all possible languages can be generated by CFG, e.g., the CFG S β aSb | ab generates the language {aβΏbβΏ : n=1,2,3,...}, which is nonregular. It is to be noted that for every FA, there exists a CFG that generates the language accepted by this FA.
π Example: Consider the language L expressed by (a+b)aa(a+b), i.e., the language of strings, defined over Ξ£={a,b}, containing aa. To construct the CFG corresponding to L, consider the FA accepting L. The CFG corresponding to the FA may be: S β bS | aA, A β aB | bS, B β aB | bB | ο. It may be noted that the number of nonterminals in the above CFG is equal to the number of states of the corresponding FA, where the nonterminal S corresponds to the initial state and each transition defines a production.
π‘ Why this matters: This establishes a direct connection between finite automata (language recognizers) and context-free grammars (language generators) for regular languages.
Semiword and Word
A semiword is a string of terminals (may be none) concatenated with exactly one nonterminal on the right, i.e., a semiword, in general, is of the following form: (terminal)(terminal)...(terminal)(nonterminal).
A word is a string of terminals. Ξ (null string) is also a word.
π Definition β Semiword: A string of terminals concatenated with exactly one nonterminal on the right. π Definition β Word: A string of terminals (including Ξ).
Theorem
If every production in a CFG is one of the following forms:
- Nonterminal β semiword
- Nonterminal β word
then the language generated by that CFG is regular.
Regular Grammar Definition
A CFG is said to be a regular grammar if it generates a regular language, i.e., a CFG is said to be a regular grammar in which each production is one of the two forms:
- Nonterminal β semiword
- Nonterminal β word
π Example: The CFG S β aaS | bbS | ο is a regular grammar. It may be observed that this CFG generates the language of strings expressed by the RE (aa+bb)*. π Example: The CFG S β aA | bB, A β aS | a, B β bS | b is a regular grammar. It may be observed that this CFG generates the language of strings expressed by RE (aa+bb)+.
Method to Build TG for Regular Grammar
For every regular grammar there exists a TG (Transition Graph) corresponding to the regular grammar. Following is the method to build a TG from the given regular grammar:
- Define the states of the required TG, equal in number to that of nonterminals of the given regular grammar.
- An additional state is also defined to be the final state.
- The initial state should correspond to the nonterminal S.
For every production of the given regular grammar, there are two possibilities for the transitions of the required TG:
- If the production is of the form nonterminal β semiword, then the transition of the required TG would start from the state corresponding to the nonterminal on the left side of the production and would end in the state corresponding to the nonterminal on the right side of the production, labeled by the string of terminals in the semiword.
- If the production is of the form nonterminal β word, then the transition of the TG would start from the state corresponding to the nonterminal on the left side of the production and would end on the final state of the TG, labeled by the word.
π Example: Consider the CFG S β aaS | bbS | ο. The TG accepting the language generated by this CFG has state S and an additional final state. From state S, there is a transition labeled "aa" back to S, a transition labeled "bb" back to S, and a transition labeled Ξ from S to the final state. The corresponding RE may be (aa+bb)*.
β Key Takeaways
In this lecture, you learned that ambiguity in a CFG occurs when a word has more than one derivation tree, and that the PALINDROME grammar is unambiguous in its standard form. The total language tree is a powerful tool for visualizing all possible derivations in a grammar, and it can be finite or infinite. You must remember that regular grammars are a restricted form of CFG where productions are limited to nonterminalβsemiword or nonterminalβword forms, and that for every FA there exists a corresponding CFG. Finally, there is a systematic method to convert any regular grammar into a transition graph by creating states for each nonterminal plus a final state, and labeling transitions according to the production rules.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What makes a context-free grammar ambiguous, and how can ambiguity be resolved in the given example S β aS | bS | aaS | ο?
- Why is the CFG S β aSa | bSb | a | b | ο considered unambiguous for the PALINDROME language?
- What is a total language tree, and how do you determine the language generated by a CFG from its total language tree?
- What are the two production forms that define a regular grammar, and what theorem guarantees that the language generated is regular?
- Describe the step-by-step method to construct a Transition Graph from a given regular grammar.