π Lecture 18 β EVALUATING THE INTERNAL CONTROL SYSTEM
π Overview: This lecture focuses on evaluating internal control systems using flowcharts and internal control questionnaires within auditing. It highlights the importance of documenting processes, operations, and controls visually for clear communication and assessment of control effectiveness.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the use of various flowchart symbols in manual systems to depict documents, operations, checks, filing, and information flow especially in purchase processes. It explains how these symbols are organized within flowcharts to represent departmental activities distinctively through vertical and horizontal lines. The lecture further elaborates on correct flowchart practices, supported by narratives, and explains the importance of these visual tools in auditing internal controls.
π Lecture Summary
Symbols used in manual systems flowcharts
This section introduces key symbols in flowcharts representing different elements such as documents, multi-part documents, pre-numbered documents, books of account, operations performed on documents, checks on documents, filing, document flow, and information flow. Each symbol helps visualize distinct parts of the control system to improve understanding and tracking of audit trails.
Flowchart of purchases
An illustrative purchase flowchart accompanies the narrative describing sequential operations β from a requisition note raised at reorder points, to authorizations, preparation of purchase orders, filing procedures, checking for overdue deliveries, receipt and acceptance of goods, to issuing shortage memos when quantities differ. The commentary clarifies that operations/checks align vertically within departments while documents move horizontally across departments, and flowcharts can continue to cover invoice and payment processing steps.
Flow Charts and Internal Control Questionnaires: Use of the major symbols in flow charts
The lecture explains the use of symbols in auditing flowcharts with emphasis on:
- The Document symbol: Representing document movement over time within and between departments via vertical and horizontal flow-lines.
- The Operation symbol: Marked by a cross, it denotes actions like preparation or totaling documents occurring within one department on vertical lines only.
- The Information flow symbol: Depicted by dotted horizontal lines showing information transferred from one document to another β never vertical β with a requirement for explanatory narratives.
- The Check symbol: Denotes verification tasks on single or multiple documents, illustrating control activities; check processes use vertical and horizontal lines appropriately.
- The Filing symbol: Represents document storage, distinguishing between permanent and temporary files, the latter marked βTβ. Filing order can be indicated by 'N' (numerical), 'A' (alphabetical), or 'D' (chronological). Temporary filing keeps the flow-line continuing, permanent filing ends it.
- The Book of account symbol: Used to indicate existing books of accounts and re-filing after posting, managed similarly to documents with vertical flow-lines showing chronological filing.
π‘ Why this matters: Understanding how to read and construct flowcharts using these symbols allows auditors to evaluate the internal control system systematically, identify control weaknesses, and ensure processes comply with audit standards.
β Key Takeaways
- Flowchart symbols are essential for representing documents, operations, checks, information flows, and filing in auditing internal control systems.
- Vertical lines in flowcharts depict timeline movement within departments, horizontal lines depict movement of documents or information across departments.
- Correct placement of symbolsβoperations only on vertical lines and information flow only on horizontal linesβmaintains clarity and prevents misinterpretation.
- Narratives accompanying symbols enhance the understanding of operations and controls depicted in the flowchart.
- Differentiating between temporary and permanent filing and depicting books of account correctly are vital for complete control documentation.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What does a vertical flow-line represent in a flowchart of an internal control system?
- How is an operation symbol represented, and where should it be positioned in the flowchart?
- What is the difference between document flow and information flow lines in a flowchart?
- How are temporary and permanent filing symbols distinguished in flowcharts, and what impact do they have on flow-lines?
- Why is it important to include narratives for operations and controls depicted on a flowchart?
π Lecture 19 β INTERNAL CONTROL QUESTIONNAIRE
π Overview: This lecture explains the concept, purpose, and construction of an Internal Control Questionnaire (ICQ) used by auditors to evaluate a client's internal control systems. It also compares ICQs with Internal Control Evaluation Checklists (ICECs) and highlights their role in deciding audit approaches.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with the auditorβs need for preliminary evaluation of the internal control system to decide on audit strategy. It defines the ICQ, discusses its features and objectives, and details how to construct one, including control objectives, business considerations, and types of questions used. An example relating to the purchasing cycle is provided. Finally, the lecture critiques ICQs and introduces the ICEC as an alternative internal control evaluation tool.
π Lecture Summary
Preliminary Evaluation of the System
After understanding and documenting the clientβs system, the auditor must preliminarily evaluate it to choose whether to rely on internal controls and adopt a systems audit approach or to conduct extensive substantive testing with a verification approach. This evaluation informs the audit strategy.
Internal Control Questionnaire
An ICQ is a formal, standardized document listing the clientβs existing internal controls and highlighting weaknesses.
π Definition β Internal Control Questionnaire: A formal and usually standardized document comprising (1) a list of internal controls in existence and (2) highlights any weaknesses.
Its features include use in audits of large companies, reliance on internal controls, and design of audit approach.
Objectives include ascertaining the clientβs accounting and control systems, evaluating these controls, identifying strong controls for reliance, and spotting weak controls requiring further substantive testing and reporting in the Management Letter.
Construction of an ICQ
(I) When designing an ICQ, include an introduction listing:
- Control objectives each subsystem should achieve
- Business considerations specific to the enterprise to focus audit staff attention
(II) The ICQ questions should assess achievement of control objectives and cover: - Instructions to staff
- Authorization procedures
- Documents and procedures initiating transactions
- Recording and sequence of procedures
- Custody procedures
- Independence of personnel involved (segregation of duties)
(III) Questions should be framed for Yes/No answers, with No generally indicating a control weakness.
(IV) Basic information to include: - Document name (ICQ)
- System covered (e.g., purchasing cycle)
- Client and accounting period
- Preparers and reviewers
- Columns for Yes/No answers, comments, significance of weaknesses, audit program references, and Management Letter references
Example of ICQ (Purchasing Cycle)
The lecture provides an ICQ example focusing on purchasing with:
(a) Control objectives to ensure proper authority for orders, necessity of goods/services, inspection of goods received, approval of invoices, and accuracy of trade payables.
(b) Business considerations including nature of purchases, centralization of ordering, purchasing policy, and supplier selection to influence audit focus.
(c) The questionnaire includes Yes/No questions covering initiation and authorization (e.g., use of standard purchase orders, authorization limits, independent authorization) and custody (e.g., inspection of goods, recording by independent persons).
Criticism on ICQs
While ICQs offer a systematic approach to auditing large organizations, drawbacks occur as they can become too complex and detailed for practical evaluation. They risk promoting a formalistic focus on controls themselves rather than on the underlying frauds or irregularities the controls aim to prevent.
Internal Control Evaluation Checklists (ICEC)
To address ICQ limitations, many audit firms use ICECs, which focus on determining if desirable controls are present by asking key questions to spot specific fraud or error risks. ICECs are typically used after system information is collected (e.g., via flowcharts) and include supplementary questions prompted by initial answers.
π‘ Why this matters: ICECs are shorter, less complex, and encourage auditor judgment, while maintaining similar construction principles as ICQs.
An ICEC example regarding purchases, payables, and payments is given, featuring questions on purchasing authority, segregation of duties, receipt controls, invoice checks, cut-off errors, and invoice allocation controls.
β Key Takeaways
- The Internal Control Questionnaire is a vital formal tool for auditing large companies by listing controls and weaknesses to guide audit approach.
- An auditor uses the ICQ to decide whether to rely on internal controls or perform substantive testing.
- ICQ construction requires stating control objectives, business considerations, and designing Yes/No questions that reflect control achievements and weaknesses.
- ICQs may become overly complex and risk focusing too rigidly on controls rather than fraud detection.
- Internal Control Evaluation Checklists (ICECs) offer a more streamlined and judgment-based alternative for evaluating internal controls effectively after system documentation is complete.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the primary purpose of an Internal Control Questionnaire (ICQ) in auditing?
- List the main objectives an ICQ aims to achieve during an audit.
- Why are ICQ questions typically framed for Yes/No answers, and what does a βNoβ usually indicate?
- How do business considerations influence the design of an ICQ?
- What are the key differences between an ICQ and an Internal Control Evaluation Checklist (ICEC)?
π Lecture 20 β AUDIT TESTS
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the nature and application of audit tests, emphasizing the necessity of gathering sufficient and appropriate audit evidence through various audit procedures. Understanding how internal controls influence the selection and design of audit tests is crucial for auditors to reach valid conclusions about financial assertions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
This lecture discusses types of audit evidence, including test of controls, test of details, and analytical procedures. It covers how auditors tailor procedures based on their understanding of the entity's internal control environment and the selection of appropriate audit approaches. In addition, it explains the concepts of nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures, and concludes with detailed insights into conduct and evaluation of tests of control.
π Lecture Summary
Audit evidence through Audit Procedures
The auditor must generate sufficient appropriate audit evidence to form conclusions. Audit evidence is obtained through three main procedures:
- Test of control (compliance test)
- Test of details (substantive test)
- Analytical procedures (substantive test)
π‘ Why this matters: The quality and nature of audit evidence affect the reliability of the auditorβs opinion.
Audit Procedures based on the understanding of Internal Control
The auditorβs understanding of the control environment drives the selection of audit procedures. A strong control environment allows some audit tests at interim dates and reduces substantive testing, while a weak control environment requires more extensive procedures at period end.
π‘ Why this matters: Tailoring audit procedures improves audit efficiency and effectiveness.
Appropriate Audit Approach
Auditors select audit approaches based on internal control assessments:
- Apply tests of control only for specific assertions.
- Use substantive procedures only if no effective controls exist.
- Use a combined approach applying both tests of controls and substantive procedures for the same assertion.
Even with good controls, substantive procedures are always performed on material classes of transactions and disclosures.
π‘ Why this matters: Choosing the right approach balances audit risk and resource use.
Considering the Nature, Timing and Extent of Audit Procedures
- Nature: Refers to the purpose (test of controls or substantive) and type, such as inspection, observation, inquiry, confirmation, recalculation, re-performance, or analytical procedures. Procedures differ by assertion risk.
- Timing: When the procedures are performedβinterim or period end. Higher risk requires procedures closer to period end or unpredictably timed tests. Timing also depends on control environment and nature of risk.
- Extent: The sample size or quantity of evidence gathered, decided by auditor judgment and increasing with assessed risk and materiality. Use of computer-assisted audit techniques (CAATs) can increase testing extent.
π‘ Why this matters: Correctly setting nature, timing, and extent determines audit effectiveness against risks.
Test of Control
Tests of control are required when internal controls are effective or substantive tests alone are insufficient. They assess:
- Design β whether controls are properly designed to tackle risks (examined via internal control questionnaires (ICQs) and internal control evaluation checklists (ICECs)).
- Implementation β whether controls have been put into operation (examined via walk-through tests with small samples).
- Operating effectiveness β whether controls operated effectively during the period (examined through compliance tests using judgmental samples).
π‘ Why this matters: Confirming control effectiveness helps reduce direct substantive testing and enhances audit efficiency.
β Key Takeaways
- Audit evidence must be sufficient and appropriate, obtained through tests of controls, tests of details, and analytical procedures.
- Understanding the internal control environment guides the auditorβs choice of procedures, timing, and extent, improving audit quality and efficiency.
- Audit approaches vary: tests of controls only, substantive procedures only, or a combination, always including substantive procedures for material items.
- Timing of audit procedures is critical; tests close to period end provide better assurance for high-risk assertions.
- Tests of control focus on design, implementation, and operating effectiveness, ensuring controls legitimately reduce audit risk.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three main types of audit procedures for obtaining audit evidence?
- How does the strength of the internal control environment affect the auditorβs testing strategy?
- Describe the differences between nature, timing, and extent of audit procedures.
- What are the three aspects tested in tests of control?
- Why might an auditor choose a combined approach of both tests of controls and substantive procedures?
π Lecture 21 β SUBSTANTIVE PROCEDURES
π Overview: This lecture explains substantive procedures in auditing, focusing on detecting material misstatements at the assertion level. It highlights the nature, timing, extent, and types of substantive procedures and their relationship with tests of controls, underlining their importance for gathering sufficient appropriate audit evidence.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the nature and types of tests of controls, their timing and extent, followed by a detailed explanation of substantive procedures including their planning, nature (tests of details and analytical procedures), timing, and extent. It also discusses the auditorβs responsibility in assessing risk, designing substantive procedures accordingly, and evaluating presentation and disclosures in financial statements.
π Lecture Summary
Nature of Tests of Controls
Tests of controls check the design, implementation, and effectiveness of internal controls. Methods include inquiry and observation (e.g., observing controls over mail opening for cash receipts), re-performance (like bank reconciliations), inspection of documentation, and applying CAATs (Computer-Assisted Audit Techniques). These tests verify if controls function properly to prevent or detect errors.
π Definition β Tests of Controls: Procedures performed to test the design and operating effectiveness of internal controls.
Timing of Tests of Controls
Tests may be done at a specific time or over the entire audit period. Testing at one time shows if controls worked then; testing over the entire period confirms ongoing effectiveness. If controls change, re-testing is essential before reliance; unchanged controls should be tested at least every third audit.
Extent of Tests of Controls
The extent depends on factors like control frequency, audit period length of reliance, relevance and reliability of evidence, planned reliance on controls, and expected deviation rate. The auditor designs tests to ensure evidence supports control effectiveness throughout the period.
Substantive Procedures
Substantive procedures detect material misstatements at the assertion level (e.g., occurrence, completeness, valuation). They include tests of details of transactions, balances, disclosures, and substantive analytical procedures. These procedures respond to the assessed risk of misstatement, regardless of control testing results.
π Definition β Substantive Procedures: Audit procedures designed to detect material misstatements at assertion level.
Substantive procedures also verify financial statement closing processes such as agreeing statements to records and examining journal entries or adjustments.
Nature of Substantive Procedures
- Substantive analytical procedures are suitable for large, predictable transaction volumes (e.g., payroll, sales).
- Tests of details are better for assertions like existence and valuation on account balances. When designing analytical procedures, the auditor considers:
- Suitability of using them given specific assertions,
- Data reliability (internal vs. external sources, controls over data preparation),
- Precision of expectations to identify material misstatements,
- Acceptable difference thresholds.
π‘ Why this matters: Using the right substantive procedure increases audit efficiency and effectiveness based on the nature of transactions and risk.
Timing of Substantive Procedures
Performed at interim dates or year-end. If done interim, additional tests or tests of controls should cover the remainder of the period to ensure reliable conclusions. Factors influencing timing include control environment, risk assessment, availability of information, and nature of account or transaction. Fraud risk may require year-end testing.
If misstatements are found at interim, risk assessments and audit plans must be updated for the remaining period.
Extent of Performance of Substantive Procedures
Higher risk from weak controls necessitates more extensive substantive testing. Tests of details may use sampling or selective testing methods depending on risk and audit judgment.
Adequacy of Presentation and Disclosure
Auditors must evaluate whether the financial statementsβ overall presentation and disclosures comply with the applicable financial reporting framework, ensuring material accuracy and transparency.
Test of Control Procedures Summary
Tests of controls include evaluating:
- Design β whether controls are properly designed to address risks.
- Implementation β if controls have been put into operation.
- Operating effectiveness β if controls functioned during the period.
Testing design uses ICQs and ICEC; implementation is assessed via walkthroughs; operating effectiveness is judged through compliance testing on samples.
Types of Substantive Procedures
- Tests of detail: examples include reviewing land registry, debtor circulars, and building rent agreements.
- Analytical procedures: comparing payroll to turnover ratios, production costs per unit, or month-over-month production cost changes.
β Key Takeaways
- Substantive procedures are essential for detecting material misstatements at the assertion level regardless of control tests.
- Tests of controls evaluate control design, implementation, and effectiveness; substantive procedures include tests of details and analytical procedures.
- Timing and extent of substantive procedures depend on assessed risk, control environment, and audit objectives.
- Analytical procedures are best for large, predictable data; tests of details are required for sensitive assertions like existence and valuation.
- Auditors must ensure financial statements, including disclosures, comply with the applicable framework through substantive testing.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the main objectives of tests of controls in an audit?
- Explain when and why substantive procedures must be performed at interim versus year-end.
- What factors influence the extent of tests of controls?
- Distinguish between substantive analytical procedures and tests of details with examples.
- Why must auditors review financial statement presentation and disclosures as part of substantive procedures?
π Lecture 22 β AUDIT EVIDENCE
π Overview: This lecture covers the fundamental concept of audit evidence, including its nature, sources, sufficiency, appropriateness, and the timing and extent of substantive audit procedures. Understanding audit evidence is crucial because auditors rely on it to form opinions about the fairness and accuracy of financial statements.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by explaining the concept of audit evidence and the information it comprises, including accounting records and other sources. It discusses the sufficiency and appropriateness of evidence and factors affecting these qualities. Next, it covers the timing and extent of substantive procedures, emphasizing why year-end testing is most reliable. Assertions about transactions, account balances, and disclosures are described, followed by an overview of audit procedures like inspection, inquiry, and confirmation used to obtain audit evidence. Finally, the importance of evaluating presentation and disclosure adequacy is highlighted.
π Lecture Summary
Concept of Audit Evidence
Audit evidence encompasses all information the auditor uses to draw conclusions for the audit opinion. This includes information in accounting records such as journal entries, ledgers, invoices, and contracts, whether in paper or electronic form, as well as other information like minutes, confirmations, and reports. The auditor primarily obtains evidence from the entity's accounting records but supplements this when necessary from external or other sources.
π Definition β Audit Evidence: All information used by the auditor to arrive at conclusions on which the audit opinion is based, including accounting records and other information obtained during the audit.
Sufficient Appropriate Audit Evidence
Sufficiency measures the quantity of evidence, while appropriateness measures its quality, focusing on relevance and reliability for detecting misstatements. The amount of evidence needed depends on the risk of material misstatement and the evidence's quality, which are interrelated. More quantity does not compensate for low quality. Evidence usually covers specific assertions and cannot substitute for evidence about other assertions.
π Example: If the risk of misstatement in inventory is high, more and higher-quality evidence about inventory existence and valuation is required.
Sources of Obtaining Audit Evidence
Evidence sources are classified into internal (accounting system, management, employees, related documents) and external (third parties like banks, suppliers, legal advisors). Using both provides a comprehensive evidence base.
Timing of Substantive Procedures
Substantive procedures are ideally performed at year-end, as they provide the most reliable evidence. When done at an interim date, auditors must extend those procedures or combine them with tests of controls to cover remaining periods. Factors influencing timing include the control environment, information availability, risk assessment, nature of transactions, and auditorβs ability to perform procedures after interim testing.
π‘ Why this matters: Choosing the correct timing ensures auditors reduce the risk of undetected misstatements and provides a solid basis for audit conclusions.
Extent of Performance of Substantive Procedures
The extent depends on the assessed risk of material misstatement, especially due to internal control weaknesses. Auditors select detailed items either by audit sampling or other selective testing methods to gather sufficient evidence.
Adequacy of Presentation and Disclosure
Auditors must verify whether the financial statements' presentation and disclosures comply with the applicable financial reporting framework. This evaluation is part of audit evidence regarding completeness, classification, accuracy, and rights and obligations related to disclosure.
Assertions in Obtaining Audit Evidence
Assertions are grouped as follows:
(a) Assertions about classes of transactions and events β Occurrence, Completeness, Accuracy, Cutoff, Classification.
(b) Assertions about account balances at period-end β Existence, Rights and obligations, Completeness, Valuation and allocation.
(c) Assertions about presentation and disclosure β Occurrence and rights, Completeness, Classification and understandability, Accuracy and valuation.
Understanding these assertions guides auditors in designing audit procedures targeting specific risks of misstatement.
Audit Procedures for Obtaining Audit Evidence
The auditor applies several procedures, including:
(i) Inspection of Records or Documents β Examining internal or external records and documents in any form to gather evidence, with reliability varying based on source and control effectiveness.
(ii) Inspection of Tangible Assets β Physical examination to confirm existence but limited for other assertions.
(iii) Inquiry β Collecting information from knowledgeable persons inside or outside the entity, either orally or in writing, which might lead to new or corroborative evidence.
(iv) Confirmations β A specialized inquiry obtaining direct third-party representations regarding specific information (e.g., from debtors, creditors, bankers).
β Key Takeaways
- Audit evidence includes all information used by the auditor to support audit conclusions, primarily from accounting records but also from other sources.
- The quantity (sufficiency) and quality (appropriateness) of evidence depend on the assessed risk and the evidenceβs reliability; more evidence is required when risk is higher.
- Year-end substantive procedures are more reliable; interim testing requires extending procedures or combining with control tests to cover subsequent periods.
- Assertions about transactions, balances, and disclosures form the basis for designing audit procedures and gathering targeted evidence.
- Common audit procedures to obtain evidence include inspection, inquiry, and confirmation, each providing varying degrees of reliability depending on the context.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the difference between sufficiency and appropriateness of audit evidence?
- Why are year-end substantive procedures generally more reliable than interim testing?
- List and describe three groups of audit assertions relevant to obtaining audit evidence.
- What types of sources can auditors use to obtain audit evidence?
- Explain the difference between inquiry and confirmation as audit procedures.