π Lecture 23 β SUFFICIENT APPROPRIATE AUDIT EVIDENCE
π Overview: This lecture explains the nature and reliability of audit evidence, focusing on the concepts of sufficiency (quantity) and appropriateness (quality) of evidence auditors must gather to form an audit opinion. It also covers audit assertions, procedures for obtaining evidence, and controls within the sales system.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing types and reliability of audit evidence, then covers audit assertions related to transactions, account balances, and disclosures. It details various audit procedures such as inspection, inquiry, and confirmation. Finally, it addresses testing the sales system through control objectives and control procedures relevant to sales and debtors.
π Lecture Summary
Nature of Audit Evidence
Audit evidence can be visual, oral, or documentary in nature. The reliability of evidence depends on its source and form: evidence from independent external sources is more reliable than from the entity itself; evidence obtained directly by the auditor is more reliable than indirect; written evidence and original documents hold more weight than oral or copied evidence.
π‘ Why this matters: Evaluating reliability helps auditors decide which evidence supports audit conclusions.
Reliability of Audit Evidence - Generalizations
Key reliability generalizations include that evidence from independent sources, effective internal controls, direct auditor observation, written form, and original documents is more reliable. Auditors must also consider the consistency of evidence, its cost, and sufficiencyβno need to test all items, but evidence must be persuasive.
Other factors relating to Audit Evidence
Audit information should be complete and accurate; auditors test systems producing information for reliability. They evaluate evidence consistency and cost-effectiveness and rely on samples for conclusions. Persuasiveness rather than volume guides reliability judgment.
Assertions in obtaining Audit Evidence
Audit assertions categorize management's representations:
(a) For transactions/events: Occurrence, Completeness, Accuracy, Cutoff, Classification.
(b) For account balances: Existence, Rights and obligations, Completeness, Valuation and allocation.
(c) For presentation and disclosure: Occurrence and rights, Completeness, Classification and understandability, Accuracy and valuation.
π Definition β Assertions: Representations by management about financial statements used to evaluate audit evidence.
Audit procedures for obtaining audit evidence
Audit procedures help understand the entity and assess risks:
- Inspection of records/documents (paper/electronic), providing reliability based on source and control effectiveness.
- Inspection of tangible assets to confirm existence.
- Inquiry involves seeking information from knowledgeable people, oral or written.
- Confirmations are third-party verifications (debtors, banks).
- Recalculation checks mathematical accuracy.
- Re-performance independently executes original procedures or controls.
- Analytical procedures analyze financial/non-financial relationships and fluctuations.
These methods vary in reliability and purpose.
SUFFICIENT APPROPRIATE AUDIT EVIDENCE
Recap: Audit evidence includes documents, entries, management answers, third-party info, computations, and observations.
- Sufficiency refers to the quantity of evidence.
- Appropriateness refers to relevance and reliability of the evidence.
Auditors ask: Do I have enough evidence? Is it reliable enough to draw conclusions?
Assertions related to transactions, account balances, and disclosures are reiterated here to emphasize evidence evaluation.
Audit procedures for obtaining Audit Evidence (repeated emphasis)
The same audit procedures as above are listed again, reinforcing the types of evidence collection methods auditors utilize to substantiate their findings.
TESTING THE SALES SYSTEM
Control objectives for the sales cycle include:
a) Authorized and controlled customer orders for prompt execution.
b) Control of shipments and work completion to ensure invoicing and revenue recording.
c) Control of goods returns and customer claims to assess liabilities.
d) Accuracy and authorization of invoices and credit notes.
e) Accurate entry of only authorized transactions into records.
f) Procedures to ensure payment collection and identification of doubtful debts.
Control procedures focus on key sales cycle stages: orders, dispatch, invoicing, and credit notes to safeguard revenue and receivables.
π‘ Why this matters: Effective sales controls prevent revenue misstatements and fraud, contributing to audit reliability.
β Key Takeaways
- Audit evidence reliability depends on source, nature, and method of gathering; external and direct evidence is preferred.
- Sufficiency (quantity) and appropriateness (quality) are critical in evaluating audit evidence.
- Audit assertions guide the auditor in what aspects of transactions, balances, and disclosures to test.
- Multiple audit proceduresβinspection, inquiry, confirmation, recalculation, re-performance, analytical reviewβare used to obtain evidence.
- Sales system control objectives and procedures ensure valid, complete, and accurate revenue recognition and receivables accounting.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What distinguishes sufficient audit evidence from appropriate audit evidence?
- Name three generalizations about the reliability of audit evidence.
- List the five assertions related to classes of transactions and events.
- What is the purpose of re-performance as an audit procedure?
- Identify two control objectives important in testing the sales system.
π Lecture 24 β TESTING THE SALES SYSTEM
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the controls and audit procedures related to the sales system within an organization. It emphasizes how to verify the accuracy, completeness, and authorization of sales transactions, which is crucial in preventing errors and fraud in revenue recognition.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers the detailed control procedures for various stages in the sales cycle, including orders, dispatch, invoicing and credit notes, returns, receivables (debtors), and bad debts. It then explains the kinds of tests of control auditors should perform to ensure these procedures are followed correctly and effectively.
π Lecture Summary
4. Returns Inwards; 5. Receivables; 6. Bad Debts
These sections are listed as elements of the sales system audit scope, focusing on returns, amounts owed by customers, and uncollectible debts.
(a) Orders
The sales order process needs strong controls:
- Existing customers receive a credit limit, and the order is reviewed if this limit is exceeded.
- New customersβ orders must be referred to credit control.
- All orders are recorded on pre-numbered sales order documents to check completeness.
- Orders need authorization before dispatch.
- Sales order documents generate dispatch notes, and no goods may be dispatched without one.
π Definition β Credit limit: The maximum amount of credit allocated to a customer to control credit risk. π Example: Before dispatching goods worth $10,000 to an existing customer, check if $10,000 plus current outstanding exceeds their $15,000 credit limit; if yes, refer to credit control for approval.
(b) Dispatch
- Dispatch notes should be pre-numbered, registered, and matched with invoices and orders.
- Authorization is required before goods leave the company.
- Regular checks confirm all dispatches have corresponding invoices.
π‘ Why this matters: Controls in dispatch prevent unauthorized or unrecorded shipments which could result in lost revenue or stock discrepancies.
(c) Invoicing and Credit Notes
- Invoices require authorization by a responsible official and must match the order and dispatch note.
- Invoices and credit notes must be recorded in daybooks, sales ledger, and the control account with maintained batch totals.
- Pricing, costs, and calculations must be independently verified.
- Invoices and credit notes are serially pre-numbered with sequence checks.
- Credit notes need independent authorization distinct from dispatch or ledger staff.
- Copies of cancelled invoices are retained, related dispatch notes canceled, and cancellations signed by an official.
- Invoices distinguish between sales types and VAT/sales tax rates, with periodic independent coding checks.
π Definition β Credit note: A document issued to reduce the amount payable by a customer usually due to returns or pricing corrections. π Example: A $500 returned item is authorized by an independent official who issues a credit note deducting $500 from the customerβs balance.
(d) Returns
- Returned goods are checked for damage before acceptance.
- Accepted returns lead to creation of appropriate credit notes.
(e) Receivables/Debtors
- A receivables ledger control account is regularly prepared and matched against individual balances by an independent official.
- Personnel handling receivables are independent from dispatch and cash receipt functions.
- Customers receive regular statements.
- Procedures exist for following up overdue debts via aged balances or repeated statements.
- Letters are sent for overdue collections with policies for legal action where needed.
(f) Bad Debts
- Writing off bad debts requires written authority.
- Adjustments are made in both the sales ledger and control account.
- Actions like court procedures or bad debt write-offs require authorization from an official independent of cash receipts.
Tests of Control
Auditors design tests to check application of controls:
- Perform sequence tests on invoices, credit notes, dispatch notes, and orders for omissions or duplicates.
- Verify evidence of authorization for order acceptance, dispatch, invoicing, pricing, discounts, and bad debt write-offs.
- Check signatures and application of controls.
- Review arithmetic accuracy of invoices and credit notes via grid stamps showing multiple signatures.
- Verify matching of dispatch and goods returned notes with invoices and credit notes.
- Ensure reconciliations of control accounts have been done and reviewed.
- Sampling is used for all tests.
β Key Takeaways
The sales system must maintain strict controls from order entry to cash collection to prevent fraud and errors. Pre-numbered documents, independent authorizations, and regular reconciliations are essential elements. Auditors validate these controls through tests for completeness, authorization, accuracy, and proper matching of documents. Good control over bad debt write-offs and receivables follow-up is critical in safeguarding the companyβs revenues. The overall system ensures the accurate recording and reporting of sales transactions.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What is the purpose of assigning a credit limit to existing customers before accepting orders?
- Why must all sales orders be recorded on pre-numbered documents?
- What controls exist to ensure goods are only dispatched with a proper dispatch note?
- How is authorization for credit notes kept independent from dispatch and sales ledger functions?
- What types of tests do auditors perform to check the application of sales system controls?
π Lecture 25 β TESTING THE PURCHASES SYSTEM
π Overview: This lecture explains the objectives, control procedures, and tests of control related to the sales system, which includes credit sales and managing debtors. Understanding these controls is crucial for ensuring accurate revenue recording and safeguarding against errors and fraud in sales transactions.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture details the control objectives for the sales cycle, emphasizing authorization, recording, and control of orders, dispatches, invoicing, returns, receivables, and bad debts. It then explains specific control procedures at each sales stage and concludes with methods to test whether these controls are effectively applied.
π Lecture Summary
Control Objectives
The sales systemβs control objectives aim to ensure customersβ orders are authorized and recorded correctly for timely execution. Goods shipped and work completed must be controlled to guarantee all sales are invoiced and revenue is recorded. Returns and claims are managed to determine liabilities accurately. Invoices and credits require authorization and accuracy checks before entry in records. Only authorized transactions should be recorded, with procedures in place to ensure collection of sales invoices and identification of doubtful debts for provision or write-offs.
π Definition β Control Objectives: Goals designed to ensure accurate, authorized, and controlled processing of sales and debtors in a business.
Control Procedures over Sales and Debtors
The sales cycle involves multiple control points due to its high risk and importance:
(a) Orders: Existing customers have credit limits reviewed before order acceptance; new customers require credit control referral. Orders should be recorded on pre-numbered documents to check completeness. Authorization is mandatory before dispatch, and dispatch notes are produced from the sales order.
(c) Dispatch: Dispatch notes are pre-numbered and registered to match sales invoices and orders. Authorization is needed before dispatch, with regular checks to ensure all dispatches are invoiced.
(d) Invoicing and Credit Notes: Sales invoices require authorization and matching with orders and dispatch notes. They must be entered into daybooks, sales ledgers, and control accounts, with batch totals maintained. Price and calculation checks are done by a different person than the preparer. Invoices and credit notes are pre-numbered with sequence checks, and canceled documents are retained with proper authorization and signatures. Different sales types and VAT rates should be clearly distinguished, with periodic independent checks on coding.
(e) Returns: Returned goods are inspected for damage before acceptance and documented. Credit notes are prepared accordingly.
(f) Receivables/Debtors: The receivables control account is regularly reconciled with individual balances by an independent official. Ledger personnel are segregated from dispatch and cash receipt functions. Customer statements and aged lists track overdue debts, with formal collection procedures including legal action when needed.
(g) Bad Debts: Writing off bad debts needs written authorization and appropriate ledger adjustments. Court actions or write-offs require approval from officials independent of cash functions.
π‘ Why this matters: These procedures prevent unauthorized sales, revenue leaks, and fraudulent activity, maintaining accurate financial records and credit risk management.
Tests of Control
Audit tests verify that controls are applied and objectives met:
(a) Sequence checks on invoices, credit notes, dispatch notes, and orders to detect omissions or duplications.
(b) Examine authorization evidence for order acceptance (credit checks), dispatch, invoicing, pricing, discounts, and bad debt write-offs. Confirm the presence of signatures and actual control application.
(c) Verify arithmetic accuracy checks on invoices (including VAT/sales tax) and credit notes, often indicated by multi-signature βgrid stampsβ on documents. Testing includes recalculations to confirm control effectiveness.
(d) Match dispatch notes and goods returned notes with respective invoices and credit notes to ensure consistency.
(e) Review reconciliations of control accounts for completeness and correctness.
Tests are done on samples to provide audit evidence efficiently.
β Key Takeaways
- Sales transactions require stringent controls over authorization, completeness, and accuracy at every stage: orders, dispatch, invoicing, returns, receivables, and bad debts.
- Pre-numbered documents and segregation of duties are critical to preventing errors and fraud.
- Authorized and independent checks on pricing, calculations, and cancellations help maintain data integrity.
- Regular reconciliations and follow-up on overdue debts safeguard financial health.
- Tests of control by auditors confirm that these procedures are operating effectively, ensuring reliable sales and receivables reporting.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the main control objectives in the sales cycle, and why are they important?
- Describe key control procedures related to dispatch and invoicing in the sales process.
- Why must sales invoices and credit notes be pre-numbered and checked for sequence?
- How should bad debts be authorized and recorded according to the controls?
- What audit tests can be performed to verify that sales system controls are working effectively?
π Lecture 26 β TESTING THE PURCHASES SYSTEM (CONTINUED)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on auditing the purchases system, focusing on the control objectives and control procedures over purchases and payables. It highlights the importance of ensuring purchases are properly authorized, recorded, and inspected to maintain accuracy and validity in accounting records.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture reviews key control objectives related to procurement, emphasizing authorized ordering, necessity, and quality inspection. It then details control procedures encompassing purchase order authorization, receipt of goods verification, invoice processing, and purchase ledger maintenance. Finally, it introduces the concept of tests of control to verify these procedures are applied effectively.
π Lecture Summary
Control Objectives
The control objectives in the purchases system ensure proper authorization and necessity of purchases, verification of received goodsβ quality and quantity, and accurate recording of valid transactions related to payables. This includes ensuring that all purchased goods and services are ordered per procedure and from approved suppliers, inspected upon receipt, and that invoices are thoroughly checked and approved before entering into accounts.
π Definition β Control Objectives: Goals to ensure purchases are authorized, necessary, inspected, and valid transactions are recorded correctly.
π‘ Why this matters: These objectives prevent unauthorized or unnecessary purchases and ensure financial records' integrity.
Control Procedures over Purchases and Payables
Control procedures are categorized by stages:
(a) Orders β Purchases must be authorized using requisition notes and official orders documenting supplier details, quantities, and prices. Major purchases require higher-level authorization. Pre-set reorder levels enhance control.
(b) Receipt of Goods β Designated goods-inwards areas handle receipt, with inspections validating quantity, quality, and description. Goods Received Notes (GRNs) must be signed by a responsible official, cross-checked with orders, and monitored for completeness.
(c) Invoicing and Returns β Invoices receive approval stamps and unique serials, matched against GRNs and orders before payment approval. Independent officials approve invoices, and VAT is recorded separately. Coding and batch controls ensure proper ledger allocation, and records of returned goods are checked against supplier credit notes.
(d) Purchase Ledger and Suppliers β A payables ledger control account is maintained and reconciled independently. Purchase ledger records are managed by staff separate from goods receipt, invoice authorization, and payments. Supplier statements are verified against ledger balances.
π Definition β Goods Received Note (GRN): A document raised for all goods accepted, verifying quantity, quality, and description.
π Example: A purchase order authorized for 100 units of inventory at $10 each should have a GRN signed by a responsible official upon receipt, checked against the order and invoice before payment approval.
Tests of Control
Tests of control are designed based on transaction cycle documents to verify that control procedures function properly and meet control objectives. For the purchases cycle, auditors list documents involved and develop specific tests to ensure controls over ordering, receiving, invoicing, and recording are applied consistently. This methodology can be adapted to other transaction cycles as well.
π‘ Why this matters: Testing controls helps auditors validate the effectiveness of purchase procedures and ensures prevention or detection of errors or fraud.
β Key Takeaways
- Control objectives ensure only necessary, authorized purchases from approved suppliers are made and received goods are inspected for quality and quantity.
- Purchase orders, goods receipt, invoice processing, and ledger maintenance must follow strict control procedures involving authorization, documentation, verification, and segregation of duties.
- Goods Received Notes (GRNs) play a critical role in confirming the receipt of goods matching the orders placed.
- Proper coding, invoice approvals by independent officials, and batch controls are essential for accurate recording in the nominal and purchase ledgers.
- Tests of control based on transaction documents are vital tools for auditors to verify that purchases system controls are operational and effective.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the primary control objectives in the purchases system?
- Why must purchase orders and requisition notes be authorized, and by whom?
- How does the Goods Received Note (GRN) contribute to controlling purchases?
- Describe the procedures involved in invoice processing within the purchases cycle.
- What is the purpose of tests of control in auditing the purchases system?
π Lecture 27 β TESTING THE PAYROLL SYSTEM
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the essential procedures and control objectives for testing the payroll system within an auditing framework. Understanding how to verify the accuracy and authorization of payroll transactions is critical to ensuring financial statements reflect true liabilities and expenses.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins with a review of the control objectives related to payroll, emphasizing authorized payments, accurate calculations, and proper recording of liabilities. It also covers the necessary tests auditors perform to verify these controls, such as ensuring payments are made only to authorized employees, at correct rates, and in line with actual work performed. Furthermore, it highlights the importance of verifying payroll deductions and tax obligations.
π Lecture Summary
CONTROL OBJECTIVES
This section outlines the control objectives that an effective wages and salaries system must meet. These include ensuring payments are made strictly to authorized employees and at authorized rates of pay. It requires that payments correspond to documented work performed (like time worked, output, or sales commissions). The system should also calculate payroll and deductions β including tax and social security β accurately, ensuring payments go to the correct employees. Lastly, liabilities towards tax authorities must be properly recorded.
π‘ Why this matters: Meeting these control objectives prevents fraud, errors in payroll, and misstatements in financial records, which are critical in maintaining financial integrity.
π Definition β Control objectives: Goals set to ensure that payroll processing is authorized, accurate, and compliant with applicable regulations.
π Formula: Not applicable here (focus is on controls, not numerical calculation).
π Example: An auditor tests if payroll payments are authorized by cross-checking employee records against payroll registers to confirm only current, authorized employees are paid.
β Key Takeaways
- Payroll payments must be made only to client-authorized employees, ensuring no fictitious or terminated employees receive pay.
- Payment amounts must align with approved rates and actual work records (time or output), preventing overpayment.
- Payroll deductions for tax and social security should be calculated accurately to comply with laws and avoid penalties.
- Proper authorization and documentation prevent errors and fraud in payroll processing.
- Recording liabilities accurately ensures financial statements reflect true obligations to tax authorities.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key control objectives in testing a payroll system?
- Why is it important to ensure payments are made only to authorized employees?
- How should payroll deductions be handled according to the control objectives?
- What evidence might an auditor review to confirm payroll payments correspond to actual work performed?
- How do accurate recording of payroll-related liabilities benefit financial reporting?
π Lecture 28 β TESTING THE CASH SYSTEM
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the control objectives, procedures, and tests of control related to wages and salaries in the payroll system. Understanding these is critical for auditors to ensure accurate and authorized payment processes, compliance with regulations, and safeguarding of assets.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by outlining the control objectives for payroll systems, then describes control procedures including documentation, arithmetical checks, control accounts, and access limitations. Finally, it provides a detailed program of tests of controls auditors can use to validate payroll accuracy and authorization.
π Lecture Summary
Control Objectives
The payroll system must ensure: (a) wages are paid only to authorized employees, (b) payment is at authorized rates, (c) payments reflect work performed (time, output, commissions), (d) accurate calculation of payroll and deductions, (e) payments go to correct employees, and (f) liabilities to tax authorities are properly recorded.
π Definition β Control Objectives (Payroll System): Goals to ensure wages and salaries are paid correctly, authorized, and properly recorded.
Control Procedures - Wages and Salaries
(a) Approval and control of documents:
- Employment or dismissal must be authorized in writing.
- Pay rate changes need approval from an official outside wages.
- Overtime requires prior authorization.
- Payroll should be reviewed and signed by an independent official.
- Cheques require two signatures and agreement with payroll.
- Time worked tracked via clock cards supervised carefully.
- Piece work payments must be for inspected, approved quality work.
- Personnel records must be kept independently with employee details and signatures.
- A wages supervisor may handle some authorizations.
(b) Arithmetical accuracy:
- Payroll prepared from source documents (clock/job cards) and tested against rates of pay.
- Payroll deductions (tax, social security, pensions) should be accurately calculated.
(c) Control accounts:
- Maintain accounts for deductions that track payments to authorities and unions.
- Conduct analytical checks against budgets, past payments, and personnel records.
- Management review and control are essential.
(d) Access to assets and records:
- Payments ideally by cheque or bank transfer.
- Cash payments require: employees must sign for wages, no wage-taking by others, late payments authorized and recorded, wage packets can be checked by employees before opening, and the wages department should be independent from receipts/payments.
- Duties should be rotated; the person preparing payroll should not prepare pay packets.
- Conduct surprise audits during pay-out.
- Unclaimed wages are recorded separately and re-banked if unclaimed after a defined period; reasons investigated promptly.
π‘ Why this matters: These controls help prevent fraud, errors, unauthorized payments, and ensure proper tax and social security compliance.
Tests of Controls - Wages and Salaries
Auditors can test controls by:
(a) Sampling time sheets or clock cards for official approval, especially overtime.
(b) Testing authority for casual labor payments, especially in cash.
(c) Observing wage distribution procedures: signing, handling unclaimed wages.
(d) Testing authorization for payroll amendments via personnel files.
(e) Testing control over payroll amendments.
(f) Examining evidence of payroll calculation checks (e.g., signature by financial controller).
(g) Checking for approving signatures on payroll.
(h) Looking for independent checks such as internal audit.
(i) Inspecting payroll reconciliations.
(j) Examining explanations for payroll expense variances.
(k) Testing authority for payroll deductions.
(l) Testing controls on unclaimed wages management.
β Key Takeaways
- Payroll systems require strict authorization controls on employment, pay rates, and overtime.
- Maintaining accurate and independent personnel records supports payroll accuracy.
- Payroll calculations and deductions must be carefully verified for arithmetic accuracy.
- Access to cash and payroll records must be carefully controlled and subjected to periodic independent review.
- Auditors must perform thorough tests of control to validate authorization, accuracy, reconciliation, and handling of unclaimed wages as part of payroll audits.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the main control objectives in a payroll system?
- Why should pay rate changes be authorized by someone outside the wages department?
- What procedures ensure the accuracy of payroll deductions?
- How should unclaimed wages be handled according to control procedures?
- Name three tests an auditor can perform to verify payroll controls.
π Lecture 29 β TESTING THE CASH SYSTEM (CONTINUED)
π Overview: This lecture continues the discussion on auditing the cash system, emphasizing the critical importance of controls over cash due to its susceptibility to disappearance. It outlines specific control objectives and detailed procedures for different aspects of cash handling, including receipts by post, cash collections by salesmen, and cash sales to ensure accuracy and safeguard the asset.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture starts with the central control objectives for the cash system, focusing on receipt, payment, and recording accuracy. It then details control procedures for cash receipts received by post, cash collected by sales staff, and cash sales in the business. Each section lists practical steps to prevent theft, errors, and misstatements in cash handling.
π Lecture Summary
Control Objectives
The control of cash is paramount as it is the asset most vulnerable to theft or loss. The central objectives are:
a) All monies owed to the company are received and accounted for.
b) No unauthorized payments are made.
c) All receipts and payments are recorded promptly and accurately.
Because there is not a single overarching "cash system" but multiple cash-related systems, controls must be tailored accordingly. The lecture stresses that businesses should prefer cash transactions via cheques or bank transfers, as these are easier to control than physical cash.
Control Procedures
The lecture outlines several control procedures targeting various stages of cash receipt and payment:
(a) Cash receipts by post
(b) Cash collected by salesmen and representatives
(c) Cash sales
(d) Banking of receipts
(e) Cheque payments
(f) Bank reconciliations
(g) Petty cash
Controls over Cash Receipts by Post
This section specifies rigorous steps to prevent theft or misplacement of cash received by mail:
- A locked mailbox and restricted key access prevent interception.
- Post-opening should be supervised by at least one responsible official, ideally two where mail volume is high.
- All cheques and postal orders must be restrictively crossed as 'Account payee only, not negotiable'.
- Immediate recording of received cheques, postal orders, and cash is essential, via a rough cash book or remittance advice copies, ensuring control over amounts to be banked and recorded.
- Sales ledger and cashier personnel must be restricted from accessing receipts before recording.
- Receipts should be secured in a locked safe and banked promptly.
- Post should be date-stamped to prevent "teeming and lading" (misstating the receipt date to cover theft).
π‘ Why this matters: These controls reduce risks of cash theft between receipt and banking and enhance audit trail reliability.
Controls over Cash Collected by Salesmen and Representatives
Key procedures govern cash collections made out in the field:
- The authority for cash collection should be clearly defined.
- Salesmen must remit cash and report sales regularly.
- Delinquencies in returns are followed up promptly by responsible officials.
- Collections are to be recorded upon receipt, such as through rough cash books or receipt copies.
- Collection cash should reconcile with banking amounts, and banking should be prompt.
- Periodic independent checks of salesmen's receipt books against cash entries occur.
- If salesmen hold inventories, an independent reconciliation between inventory, sales, and cash received is required.
π‘ Why this matters: These controls safeguard against misappropriation by sales staff and ensure completeness and accuracy of recorded collections.
Controls over Cash Sales
For cash sales, the lecture specifies controls to maintain integrity:
- Cash sales should be recorded immediately at the point of sale, using a Cash Till or pre-numbered cash sale invoices or receipts.
- Registers must be maintained, and copies of cash sale books retained.
- Daily reconciliation of cash received against till rolls or invoice totals is essential, with cash banked promptly.
- This reconciliation should be performed by personnel independent from those handling cash or recording sales.
- Daily banking is compared with till rolls/invoice totals, and any discrepancies are investigated.
- A responsible official should sign cancelled cash sale invoices at cancellation, and sequential numbering should be checked regularly.
π‘ Why this matters: These controls ensure all cash sales are properly recorded and reconciled, preventing theft and errors at the cash collection point.
β Key Takeaways
- The main objective in auditing the cash system is to ensure receipt, payment, and recording of cash are accurate and secure to prevent loss.
- Different parts of the business have unique cash controls due to varying circumstances, including cash received by post, collected by salesmen, or from cash sales.
- Controls over postal receipts focus heavily on supervision, restrictive crossing of cheques, immediate recording, secure storage, and prompt banking paired with date stamping.
- Cash collected by salesmen requires clearly defined authority, timely remittance, independent reconciliations, and inventory checks if applicable.
- Controls over cash sales depend on immediate recording, pre-numbered documentation, independent reconciliations, prompt banking, and regular investigation of differences.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the three central control objectives for the cash system?
- Why are cash transactions preferably handled through cheques or bank transfers?
- List at least three control procedures for cash receipts received by post.
- What role does independent reconciliation play in the controls over cash sales?
- Explain the term "teeming and lading" and how controls help prevent it.
π Lecture 30 β TESTING OTHER SYSTEMS
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the audit procedures related to testing various financial systems beyond inventory or fixed assets, specifically the cash system. Understanding testing of cash receipts, payments, bank reconciliations, and petty cash controls is crucial for ensuring accuracy and preventing fraud in an organizationβs cash handling processes.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture covers controls over banking of receipts, detailed procedures for cheque payments, and the importance of bank reconciliations. It then outlines controls necessary for effective petty cash management before moving onto specific tests of control auditors perform to verify these systems are working as intended.
π Lecture Summary
Controls over Banking of Receipts
Receipts must be banked daily and intact, meaning no payments are made from cash receipts, which strengthens control over the cash cycle. Sales ledger personnel should not have access to cash or preparing paying-in slips. Periodic comparisons should be made between recorded receipts and banked amounts, helping to detect discrepancies early.
Controls over Cheque Payments
Unused cheques must be securely stored, and cheque preparation should exclude personnel responsible for purchase or sales ledgers. Cheques are only signed when supported by approved transactions such as invoices or payroll documentation. Controls include requiring at least two signatories for cheques, prohibiting signing blank cheques or those payable to signatories, crossing cheques to βA/c Payee only,β and canceling supporting documents as paid to prevent duplicate payments. Immediate dispatch or secure holding of cheques safeguards their integrity.
Bank Reconciliations
Bank reconciliations should be prepared regularly, ideally monthly, by someone independent of cash handling to maintain objectivity. Reconciliation must include checks of selected receipts and payments against bank statements. Independent preparation and review enhance detection of errors or fraud in reconciliations.
π‘ Why this matters: Proper bank reconciliations reveal timing differences or genuine errors, ensuring reported cash balances are reliable.
Controls over Petty Cash
The petty cash system relies on formalized cash float levels, restricted access, and secure holding. Vouchers signed by responsible officials authorize expenditures, and the imprest system ensures the petty cash float is topped up only after expenditure is verified by vouchers. Periodic, independent reconciliation of petty cash balances and cancellation of vouchers prevent misuse and improve accountability.
TESTS OF CONTROL
Cash Receipts: Auditors attend mail openings, test the banking of receipts, verify sequence checks of numbered receipts, ensure proper authorization and arithmetic review of cash received records.
Cash Payments: Inspect cheque usage for sequencing, secure custody, and absence of blank or unsigned cheques. Test that invoices marked paid to avoid double payments and verify arithmetic accuracy of cash payments records.
Bank Reconciliations: Verify evidence of monthly reconciliations, independent review with signatures, and the appropriate follow-up of old outstanding items like un-presented cheques to ensure proper cleanup.
Petty Cash: Test approval and cancellation of petty cash vouchers, arithmetic checks, and independent verification of petty cash balances are performed to confirm controls work correctly.
β Key Takeaways
- Daily and intact banking of receipts is essential to maintain effective cash controls.
- Cheque payments require multiple layers of authorization, secure cheque custody, and cancellation of supporting documents to prevent fraud.
- Regular, independent bank reconciliations are critical for accurate cash balances and to identify errors or outdated reconciling items.
- Effective petty cash control depends on restricted access, the imprest system, and independent reconciliation.
- Auditors conduct tests of control on each aspect of the cash system to ensure policies and procedures are followed and functioning correctly.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- Why must receipts be banked daily and intact according to the audit controls?
- What are the key controls auditors look for in cheque payments to prevent fraud?
- Describe the role of independence in preparing and reviewing bank reconciliations.
- What is the imprest system in petty cash management and why is it important?
- Name two specific tests auditors perform on petty cash controls during an audit.
π Lecture 31 β TESTING THE NON-CURRENT ASSETS
π Overview: This lecture focuses on the auditorβs approach to evaluating control systems related to non-current assets and inventory, emphasizing the critical role of authorized procedures and physical verification. Understanding these controls ensures accurate asset valuation and proper safeguarding, essential for reliable financial reporting.
ποΈ Topics Covered
The lecture begins by discussing the types of control systems auditors encounter, particularly those safeguarding inventory and non-current assets. It outlines control objectives and detailed control procedures over inventory, including authorization, accuracy of records, control accounts, and physical comparison of assets to records.
π Lecture Summary
Fundamentals of Auditing β Testing Other Systems
Auditors encounter various systems depending on business nature, typically systems safeguarding business assets like inventory and non-current assets. Some businesses also require systems for investments management. This section narrows focus to systems managing inventory and non-current assets to illustrate controls auditors should test.
Inventory
Inventory connects closely with sales and purchases, so some control points overlap. The lecture revisits these briefly for a holistic view of inventory control within auditing.
CONTROL OBJECTIVES
The fundamental control objectives across diverse inventory records include:
(i) Authorization and purchase procedures to ensure purchases are valid;
(ii) Control over goods inwards to verify receipt accuracy;
(iii) Maintenance of inventory records supported by physical counts to validate book records;
(iv) Control over dispatches and goods outwards for accurate inventory reduction;
(v) Identification of inventory needing provisions where net realizable value is less than cost;
(vi) Maintaining optimum inventory levels ensuring availability without excess.
Control Procedures over Inventory
(i) Approval and Control of Documents:
a) Inventory issues require properly authorized requisitions;
b) Regular reviews of damaged, obsolete, or slow-moving inventory, with write-offs authorized.
(ii) Arithmetical Accuracy:
a) All receipts/issues recorded on inventory cards linked to Goods Received Notes (GRN) or requisitions;
b) Costing departments allocate direct and overhead costs to work-in-progress accurately;
c) Standard costs are used and regularly reviewed for relevance;
d) Periodic cross-checks of actual units versus work-in-progress records validate accuracy.
(iii) Control Accounts:
a) Inventory records integrated with accounting system must undergo reconciliation and investigation of discrepancies.
(iv) Comparison of Assets to Records:
a) Periodic independent checks compare physical inventory to records, investigating material differences;
b) If perpetual records are inadequate, a full inventory count is required annually;
c) Pre-determined maximum and minimum inventory levels are regularly reviewed;
d) Re-order quantities are similarly predetermined and reviewed.
β Key Takeaways
Auditors must focus on control systems ensuring authorized transactions, reliable record-keeping, and physical verification of inventories. Regular reconciliation and physical counts maintain accuracy in reporting non-current assets and inventory values. Identifying obsolete or slow-moving inventory helps in accurate financial provisioning. Control accounts need consistent review, and inventory levels must be optimized to avoid overstocking or shortages, safeguarding the business operation and financial integrity.
π§ Quick Revision Questions
- What are the key control objectives for inventory systems in auditing?
- Why is authorization important in inventory issue procedures?
- How do standard costs help in controlling work-in-progress valuation?
- What role do control accounts play in inventory management?
- Why should physical inventory be independently checked and how often?